ekthesi_ippokrateio

178
ΕΛΛΗΝΙΚΗ ΔΗΜΟΚΡΑΤΙΑ ΕΛΕΓΚΤΙΚΟ ΣΥΝΕΔΡΙΟ ΕΚΘΕΣΗ ΕΛΕΓΧΟΥ ΔΗΜΟΣΙΟΝΟΜΙΚΟΣ ΕΛΕΓΧΟΣ ΚΑΙ ΕΛΕΓΧΟΣ ΣΥΜΜΟΡΦΩΣΗΣ ΤΩΝ ΔΙΑΔΙΚΑΣΙΩΝ ΠΡΟΜΗΘΕΙΩΝ ΚΑΙ ΤΗΣ ΔΙΑΧΕΙΡΙΣΗΣ ΑΠΟΘΕΜΑΤΩΝ ΤΟΥ ΓΕΝΙΚΟΥ ΝΟΣΟΚΟΜΕΙΟΥ ΑΘΗΝΩΝ «ΙΠΠΟΚΡΑΤΕΙΟ» Ομάδα Ελέγχου Αθήνα, Δεκέμβριος 2013

description

ΕΚΘΕΣΗ ΙΠΠΟΚΤΑΤΕΙΟ

Transcript of ekthesi_ippokrateio

  • ,2013

  • 2

    3

    1. 4

    2. 8

    3. 11

    3.1 11

    3.2 12

    3.3 14

    3.4 15

    3.5 16

    3.6 16

    4. 17

    4.1(internalcontrol)

    18

    4.1.1 18

    4.1.2 23

    4.1.3 24

    4.1.4 25

    4.2

    27

    4.3 28

    4.4 29

    5. 31

    5.1(internalcontrol)

    32

    5.1.1 32

    5.1.2 33

    5.1.3 34

    5.1.4 34

    5.2 35

    5.3 35

    5.4 36

    6. 38

    40

  • 3

    ..

    ...

    ...

    .....

    ...

    ......

    ..

    ./.

    ....

    ..

    ....

    ....

    ...

  • 4

    1.

    ()

    ,634/60997/12.11.2012.

    1, ,

    . 2

    , ,

    , INTOSAI3,

    .

    .

    , . ,

    , ,

    .

    (internal control)

    .,,

    (internal control)

    .

    2011,

    .

    ,

    . (internal control)

    ,,,

    .

    :

    1.3871/2010(141),.3852/2010(87).4055/2012(51).41658/722/23.10.2012(2848)28081.4055/2012,(,51)3www.issai.org

  • 5

    (internal control) ,

    ().

    4

    .

    :

    ,

    .

    ,(,,

    ) . ,

    .

    ,

    (internalcontrol).

    4INTOSAIGOV9100

  • 6

    (...):

    ,

    ,

    ,

    (

    ).

    (...)

    .

    ,

    . ,

    ,

    .

    7 .

    6.

    . .17166/23.10.2013 , ...

    .

    2013,

    ,

    .,.

    . . 11/17.10.2013 ,

    .,

    .

    , . . /873 /22.11.2013 ,

    , ,

  • 7

    ...

  • 8

    2.

    (

    ),.634/60997/12.11.2012.

    5,

    ,.

    6,,

    , INTOSAI7,

    .

    .

    ,

    2011(1.1.201131.12.2011).

    ,31.12.2011,

    2011.

    2012292013.

    ,

    .

    ,

    ,,50,5.

    2011,.,.

    2011:

    697.240,01

    29.784.171,47

    17.207.805,30

    (,,) 2.801.574,83

    50.490.791,61

    5.3871/2010,.3852/2010.4055/2012.41658/722/23.10.2012(2848//23.10.2012) 68081.4055/2012,,517www.issai.org

  • 9

    :

    ,,

    , ,

    ,

    ,

    ,

    .

    ,5.

    ,3,

    , ,

    .

    , ,

    ( 3.4 3.2).

    4. ,

    ,

    , , ,

    (4.1).,

    (4.2).

  • 10

    , ( 4.3). ,

    ,,,,

    ( 4.4). , 5

    . ,

    ...(.....).

    .

    .

    ,

    ,.

  • 11

    3.

    3.1

    .

    .

    (21,.3).

    (...).

    ...

    ,.

    ... ,

    : ) (.. ), )

    (.. ) )

    (.. ). ...

    .

    .

    .

    ..., . ,

    (....).,

    .

    3/19296/5.2.1987 (

    75//5.2.1987),,,4:)

    ))).

    ,

    .

    ,

    ,

    .

    (..) . .

    1.

  • 12

    2011

    :

    472

    149.621

    37.982

    140.385

    3,7

    8.400

    4.330.334

    83,30%

    :

    8

    405 100%

    528 72%

    95 77%

    15 56%

    116 103%

    107 107%

    68 19%

    3.2

    ..,

    .

    ........

    7 (..). ..,

    , ,

    8

  • 13

    ().

    ,

    . : ) (...) )

    (...) ...

    2.

    /

    :

    ...

    /

    1 ()

    .

    2 ...

    (,

    ,)

    ( .3580/2007 .

    3918/2011).

    (....)

    .

    3 .

    .

    .

    4 , ,

    .

    ....

    .

    45.000100.000

  • 14

    3.3

    31.12.2011,

    ,:

    2011 2010 .(%)

    48.379.616,95 49.448.864,58 2,16%

    2.124.256,10 3.931.074,54 45,96%

    50.503.873,05 53.379.939,12

    126.647.516.43 118.847.612,49

    40.402.262,97 53.091.656,52 23,90%

    40.402.262,97 53.091.656,52

    126.647.516.43 118.847.612,49

    .

    5

    .

    .

    ....

    .

    .

    15.00045.000

    ..

    45.000100.000.

    6 .

    ....

    15.000

    .

    15.000

    45.000

  • 15

    2011 2010 Var(%)

    697.240,01 925,65 99,87%

    46.795.393,52 59.801.191,77 27,79%

    s 196.583,25 299.190,14 34,29%

    2.801.574,83 2.455.920,15 12,34%

    50.490.791,61 62.557.227,71

    97.319.883,37 110.517.322,38

    3.12011

    3.4

    , , ,

    ,

    2011

    3867/2010 3918/2011,

    ,

    .

    ,

    ,,,

    , (

    3.2.).

    ,,

    .

    :

    ).

  • 16

    ),

    ,.

    ),,

    ,,

    ,

    .

    ).

    3.5

    .

    ,

    , :

    , , , ,

    ,,

    ,

    , ,

    ..146/2003

    (

    122//21.5.2003).

    3.6

    ,,

    ,

    ..146/2003,

    ,

    ,

    , .

    ,

    .

    ,

  • 17

    .

    (INTOSAI).

    ,

    ,

    .

    4.

    .

    (internalcontrol)

    ,,

    .

    :

    .

    .

    ()

    .

    9

    .

    9INTOSAIGOV9100

  • 18

    4.1(internalcontrol)

    INTOSAIGOV 9100 (. 8),

    :

    , , , .

    ,.

    (internalcontrol):

    ..

    4.1.1

    . ,

    .

    :(1)

  • 19

    ,

    /

    (2) (3) " "(.

    )(4)(5)

    .

    :

    (4.1.1

    ).

    , ,

    /,

    ,

    ,

    (4.1.1).

    () (

    4.1.1.). ,

    ,

    , (

    4.1.1.V). ,

    ,

    (4.1.1.V).

  • 20

    .,

    ,

    .

    ,

    , ,

    ,

    .:

    ) ,

    (), ,

    , ,

    ( ).

    . ,

    .,

    .

    .

    ,

    . , ,

    ,,

    .

    )

    .

    ,

    ... (.

    4.1.1V).

    )

    .

    ,

    , , ,

    . ,

  • 21

    .

    ,

    ,

    ,

    .

    ()

    .

    ,

    ,,

    (.. ,

    ..).:

    )

    ,

    ,

    ,,,

    .

    ,

    :

    ,

    .

    ,

    (.4.1.1VII).

    ) ,

    (4.1.1VII).

  • 22

    (4.1.1.VIII)

    .

    ,2009

    ,

    . 62008/ 1992/2008 (. 2657//30.12.2008) ,

    .

    ,

    , ,

    .

    ,

    , .

    (expost).

    :

    )

    .

    2008. 2013, ,

    13%14%, 6%

    .

    .

    )(12)

    ,,

    ,

    (12),.

  • 23

    ,

    10.

    11(5).

    :),)

    )

    .

    ,

    ,

    ,

    .(.4.1.1IX)

    4.1.2

    . ,

    .

    ,:

    (1)

    (2) (,,,)

    (3)

    (4)

    (5)

    (6)

    (7) ,

    10..166/2003(138/5.6.2003)2000/352962000.1142011/7/, 1, . 5 .4152/2013 ( 107) . 4046/2012, .4093/2012.4127/2013.

  • 24

    (8) (,,).

    ,

    .

    /

    ( )

    .

    (.4.1.2.).

    , .

    ,

    31.12.2012,

    .

    .

    (.. ,

    , )

    ,

    (.4.1.2.).

    4.1.3

    .

    .

    , , , .

  • 25

    .,

    ,.

    ,

    .

    ,

    /.

    . ,

    (,)

    ,,,

    .

    ,

    . ,

    ,

    ,,

    (.4.1.3.).

    4.1.4

    ,

    , ,

  • 26

    , ,

    .,

    ,

    .

    ,

    . ,

    ,

    (),

    (.4.4.).

    ,

    .,

    .,

    ..... .. ,

    ().

    .

    .. 2011 2012,

    ,

    , 12

    12 1 2, . 4, . 9 .3861/2010 ,(112)

  • 27

    .

    .

    (

    ),

    .

    (.4.1.4.).

    4.2

    520.658,99

    2011

    ,

    2011 2012,

    2011 ,

    520.658,99

    31.12.20112011.

    , ,

    (.4.1.2.).

  • 28

    ,

    .,

    ( 5

    ),547.808,67.

    , .

    , (

    4.2).

    )

    ,

    .

    )

    (.......)

    ,

    Excel.

    4.3

    ,.,

    ,

    .

    ,

    .

  • 29

    ,

    (..servers..)

    (..

    ). ,

    . ,

    .

    .

    ,

    ,.

    (.4.3).

    (back up) ,

    .

    4.4

    , ,

    , ,

    .

    , , ,

    .

    (.4.4I)

    , ,

    . ,

  • 30

    ,

    .

    ...

    (.4.4).

    .

    , (

    ),

    ....(.4.4).

    , ,

    .

    2011

    6.081.757,20(.4.4.V).

    , (..) 30%40% ,

    , ,

    (.4.4V).

    (.

    4.4VI).

    .......(.4.4.V).

    (.4.4.V).

    (.4.4.).

  • 31

    5.

    ,.

    ):

    ,

    .

    .

    ,

    (, , )

    .,

    .

    )...:

    ,

    ,

    ,

    (

    ).

    ...,

    .

    ,

    .,

    ,

    .

  • 32

    ,,,

    4.

    5.1(internalcontrol)

    5.1.1

    ,

    .

    .

    (..

    )

    .

    ,

    ,barcodes,scanners .

    ,

    .

    ,..

    (.).

    , ,

    .

    , .

    .

  • 33

    .

    management

    .

    .

    .

    ,

    ,

    ,

    .

    ,

    .

    ,

    .. .

    .

    5.1.2

    .

    :

    .

    : ) , )

    , ,

    , , ) )

    .

    .

  • 34

    ,

    ,.

    .

    5.1.3

    . , (

    ,,,.)

    , , , .

    .

    ,

    (,

    ,,.).

    5.1.4

    .

    ,

    (.,).

    ,

    .

    .

  • 35

    5.2

    .

    ,

    (,

    ),

    .

    ,,

    .

    scanners barcodes

    .

    , (.. ,

    ). ,

    ,,.

    ..,

    .

    .

    5.3

    (.).

    stickers,tags,.

    .

    (,).

  • 36

    . ,

    .

    5.4

    ... ,

    .

    ...,.

    ,

    .

    ,

    .

    ( , )

    .

    , (.

    )(.).

    ,

    .,

    .

    ,

    .,

    .

    ...

  • 37

    ,.

    .

  • 38

    6.

    (..521/30.09.2013), () (..

    520/30.09.2013)(..519/30.09.2013)

    7 .

    6.

    . .17166/23.10.2013 , ...

    .

    2013

    ..

    ,..11/17.10.2013,

    .,

    .

    , . . /873 /22.11.2013 ,

    ,

    ...

    .

    2, ..

    ,

    ,

    .

    ..

    . ,

  • 39

    .. ...

    .

    52013

  • 40

    1

    HOSPITAL BOARDHOSPITAL BOARD

    TECHNICAL SERVICETECHNICAL SERVICE

    HOSPITAL RD

    TECHNICAL SERVICE

    -

    ..

  • 41

    2

  • 42

    3

    3.1

    (.)

    2011 2010 2011 2010 48.406 49.449 83.153 56.826 2.124 3.931 1.184 181. 50.084 37.323 41.733 61.623 4.770 15.696 ./. 21.263 12.448 ./. 577 217

    126.647 118.847 126.647 118.847

    (.)

    2011 2010 46.654 49.350

    79.625 91.712

    32.971 42.362

    40.225 43.349

    19.434 20.676

    ./ 12.180 19.689

    . 368 54

    ./ 11.812 19.635

    3.385 1.848

    . 8.427 17.787

    /() 8.427 17.787

  • 43

    3.2

    :(,).

    .(

    )

    .2/2010 2.300.000,00

    .3/2010 900.000,00

    .26/2010() 43.050,00

    .3/2010() 45.000,00

    (/..) .27/2010 250.000,00

    .5/2011() 40.600,00

    & .15/2010() 45.000,00

    .7/2010() 23.800,00

    .6/2010 600.000,00

    .13/2008 220.000,00

    .8/2010 990.000,00

    .51/2010 1.118.827,50

    .20/2008 285.000,00

    .32/2010 300.000,00

    .35/2010 300.000,00

    .44/2010 200.000,00

    .21/2010 500.000,00

    8.161.277,50

    .()

    2.028.662,57

    313.237,95

    655.867,82

    1.133.056,58

    80.794,29

    305.112,57

    187.402,97

    53.719,00

    4.757.853,75

    12.919.131,25

  • 44

    4

    4.1

    4.1.1

    4.1.1I

    : ( 33/06)

    1/11/2007 31/10/2009 (

    ).30/6/2011,

    (1/11/200918/12/2009,1/2/201025/5/2010

    1/7/2011 20/9/2011) ,

    .

    2/2010,1/7/201130/9/2011,

    ..,

    33/06.

    : 29/9/2008

    2 1/10/200830/9/2010.

    31/3/2012 3/2010,

    28/3/2012.

    02/6/201030/8/2010.

    ,

    21/10/20101,5.

    4.1.1II

    8/2010 ,

    5 ,

    23(460%).

  • 45

    2

    ,3(

    50%)

    51/2010

    2011:

    1

    2011 69 1.813.020

    2012 81 2.052.474

    32 844.272 150 3.865.494 118 3.021.222

    2

    2011 71 130.731,78

    2012 87 108.490,92

    55 63.591 158 239.222,70 103 175.629,70

    3

    2011 46 43.973,05

    2012 82 73.627,80

    0 0 158 117.600,85 158 117.600,85

  • 46

    4.1.1III

    (4)

    OKIML5521,(6)3/15

    92010.(

    )5/2011,

    ,

    ,

    .

    4.1.1IV

    0304400403(CARBOSEALVALSALVAAORTICSZ25)

    8/2010,

    2011,

    2011 2/8/2011 30/12/2011,

    .

    .

    4.1.1V

    . 8 / 2010

    , , 28/6/2011

    (5).2011,

    .,

    7/11/201220/12/2012(

    ),.

    13/2008 ,

    ,

  • 47

    13.052,90 .

    .

    4.1.1VI

    ,

    ...()0541....

    5.000 ,

    ,

    .

    4.1.1VII

    :

    1. .

    (

    ) ...

    ...

    2. ,

    .

    3.,

    .

    : ) )

    .

    4.,

    . :

    , ,

    .

    5.

    /.

    :

    2011,2012

    2011,

  • 48

    ,

    .

    .

    2011,

    2011 2012,

    2011

    .,

    31.12.20112011.

  • 49

    4.1.1VIII

    ,:

    ..

    (201120112012)

    /

    1 15/9/201015.09.1010.11.10

    2008 10.500,00 12.915,00 1559/2011

    2 5/11/2010 5/11/2010

    2009 11.000,00 13.530,00 1772/2011

    3 18/11/2010 14.12.1013.12.11

    (146/03)20112010

    35.000,00 43.050,00 5565/2011

    4 14/12/201114.12.1130.06.11

    2011 12.000,00 12.760,00 4420/2012

    5 27/4/20121.5.1230.6.12

    2010 11.800,00 14.514,00 2723/2012

    80.300,00 96.769,00

    4.1.1IX

    ....

    .

    .

  • 50

    ()

    ..

    .

    2/2010 1/2/2010 8/5/200922/6/2009(2009) 10 28/4/2010 21/9/2011

    3/2010 20/3/2008 29/9/2008 12/5/2008 29/9/2008

    26/2010

    27/2010 1/2/2010

    13/7/2010()14/7/2010() 5/8/2010 8/10/2010 5/1/2011

    13/200820072008 9/4/2008

    16/10/2008(2008)

    23/10/2009 14/11/2008

    16/12/20082..

    16/10/2010

    13/2992010

    16/11/2010

    8/2010 3/2/2010 7/7/2010 2/3/2010 18/6/2010 2/7/2010 28/6/2011(all5)

    51B/2010 3/2/2010

    28/12/2010&9/2/2011

    2/3/2010 21/12/2010 21/2/2011 14/4/2011

    13/9/2011&31/10/2011

    5/2011./ 2009 16/3/2011 26/3/2011 1/6/2011 28/6/2011 28/7/2011

    15/2010./ 13/9/2010 3/3/2011 2/5/2011 7/2010./ 2010 27/5/2009 24/2/2010 1/6/2011 12/9/2011

    3/2010./ 10/6/2009() 10/6/2009 14/10/2009 3/2/2010 23/6/2010 15/9/2010

  • 51

    4.1.2

    4.1.2I

    ,,. ,

    proforma,

    .

    ,

    ,

    .

    , .

    4.1.2II

    (31.12.2012),:

    31.12.2012.

    .

    ,

    .

    .., .

    ,.

    4.1.3

    4.1.3I

    ,

    .

    2011,

  • 52

    ,.

    4.1.4

    4.1.4I

    , 19652/2892011 19513/1112007

    ,

    ,

    .

    ,,

    ( )

    .

    4.1.4II

    : 8/2010

    ,,

    .

    4.1.4III

    :

    400800140 /ACSGUIDANTHTBALANCE 126.998,73

    405000108 AVAILAJOS5MM115 151.290,00

    403300812 /PTCA2.0MMMAVERICK2MONORAIL 34.949,22

    313.237,95

  • 53

    . ,

    ,

    ..

    , 2011,

    ,

    .

    , (

    )51/2010

    .

    4.2

    2006 547.808,67

    . (.2362/95 . 496/74 44 .1)

    ,

    .

    4.3

    ( ..)

    ,,

    . ,

    ,

    .

    4.4

    4.4I()

    2012.

    ... ....

    .

    ...

    .

    ,...,

  • 54

    /

    ... . 2011

    ( 2010)

    / ...

    .

    4.4 II ...

    ... ,

    , .

    ...

    . ,

    .

    20082009...

    ,., 2010,

    2011 ...,

    .

    ... ,

    ,

    ,.

    ....

    4.4.III

    , ...

    ...

    . 67 .

    ,...

    ...

    , .... , ... 2010

  • 55

    2010, 2011.

    2011 2011,

    . .... 2011

    ...20102012.

    4.4IV

    , . ,

    2011

    6.081.757,20

    364.047,97().

    .2011()

    560.203,30 1.583.805,90 1.133.056,58 65.716,45 150.274,02 90.348,92 313.237,95 2.028.662,57 117.824,60 38.626,91

    6.081.757,20

    ...

    .()

    2011

    2012

    2013

    .13/2008 220.000,00 102.789,87 9.418,17 40.236,25

    .8/2010 990.000,00 149.476,40 40.793,00 .51/2010 1.118.827,50 83.455,50

    35/2010 300.000,00 240.317,00 21.185,52 19.483,20

    2.628.827,50 343.106,87 9.418,17 294.353,67 60.276,20

  • 56

    4.4V

    , .

    ,....

    ,.

    .

    ,

    ,(,

    , ...)

    .

    4.4VI

    , . ,

    .

    ,

    .

    . ,

    ,

    . ,

    ,,

    .

    4.4VII

    ,

    ,

    .

  • 57

    4.4VIII

    (.....,....)

    4.4IX

    2009 ( 2009)

    18/12/200925/5/2010.,

    .

  • 58

    5

    '.19296/1987()(

    81//4.4.2005),

    ().

    .2362/1995.. (247//1995), ,

    ,

    .

    .. 146/2003

    , (122//21.5.2003), , ,

    ,,

    .

    N. 2286/1995 (.

    19//19.01.1995),

    , .. 118/2007

    (...)( 150//10.07.2007), , , ,

    ,

    .

    .3329/2005 (

    81//4.4.2005),

    , ( , ,

    ),.

    .. 60/2007 2004/18/

    ,,

    2005/51/ 2005/75/

    16 2005( 64/'/16.3.2007),

    ,.

  • 59

    .3580/2007

    (134/'/18.6.2007),

    (...),,

    ,.

    .3599/2007 (

    176//01.08.2007),27,

    ..146/2003 (122), ,

    ,

    .

    '.1/3305/12112010 ( 1789 /B/12112010) 35130/739/11082010 ( 1291/B/1108

    2010) ,

    (),,:

    :200.000

    :60.000

    :20.000,0160.000

    ():20.000

    .1/1.2.2010(99/B/3.2.2010),

    ()2010.

    .3846/2010(66//11.05.2010).

    24 (),

    ,

    ,

    ,.

    .3861/2010

    ,

    (112//13.07.2010),

    .

    .3863/2010,(

    115//15.07.2010). 68 ,( ,

  • 60

    , ,

    , ),

    / ,

    , , (..

    , ..),

    .

    ,

    .

    .3867/2010,,

    (128//03.08.2010).27.1

    ,

    , , ,

    1.1.2007

    31.12.2009.27.11,12

    , ,

    /,45.000.

    .3871/2010 ( 141//17.08.2010) (

    .2362/1995),

    . 21,

    .

    .. 113/2010 ( 194 /22112010..

    209/10122010),,

    .

    . 3868/2010

    ( 129//03.08.2010), ,

    : ) . 2955/2001

    ,).3580/20109

    .3580/2007/,

    .

  • 61

    .4025/2011,,

    ... ( 228//02112011), , ,

    .

    .3918/2011 (31//02.03.2011),

    (..

    ,..).

    '. 6588/25.7.2011 ( 1650 /B/27.7.2011) ,

    ()2011.

    '. 69/15.10.2012 ( 2814 /B/17.10.2012) ,

    ()20102011.

  • 62

    6

    :

    /

    (//)

    ..

    1

    .

    .

    .

    3

    .

    ,

    .

    30/11/2013

    .

  • 63

    2013

    ,

    .

    2

    .

    .

    .

    .

    .

    3

    .

    .

    .

  • 64

    :,,

    .

    .,2014

    budget.

    2013.

    4

    ,

    ...

    .

    .(

    )

    .

    .

    .

  • 65

    .

    .

    5

    ,()

    .

    .

    (..).

    2013.

    .

    (1)

    &.

    .

    .

    6

    ,

    .

    .

    .

  • 66

    7

    barcodes,scanners.

    ,.

    barcodes.

    .01/01/2012

    LS(LaboratoryInformationSystem)barcode.

    01/01/2014

    .

    8

    ..(.

    ).

    (

    ,).

    .

    9

    ,

    ,,

    .

    ,

    .

    .

    10,

    ..

  • 67

    (

    ,

    )

    .

    .

    11

    .

    .

    ,

    .

    (.),.

    12

    :

    .:),),

    ,,,)

    ).

    .

    .

    .

    ,INTOSAIGOV9100(8).,

  • 68

    .

    13N,

    .

    ,.

    ,

    .

    .

    14

  • 69

    . .

    .,

    ,.

    .

    15

    H(,,,.)

    ,,,.

    ,.

    .

    .

    16

    .

    .

    .

    17

    (,,,.)

    .

    .

    H,

  • 70

    .

    .

    18

    .

    ,

    (.,).

    .

    .

    .

    19,

    .

    & .

    .

    .

  • 71

    20

    .

    .

    .

    21

    .,(,),.

    2012.

    2013.

    ,

    .

    .

    22

    201331/12/2013

    .

    23

    ..

    .

    2013&.

    .

  • 72

    24scannersbarcodes

    .

    .

    .

    .

    25

    ,

    (..).,,

    ,.

    .

    .

    .

    .

    26

    ..,.

    .

    .

    .

    .

  • 73

    27

    .

    ..

    .

    ().

    .

    28

    (.).

    .

    .

    .

    29

    .

    .

    FIFO.

    .

    .

    30

    .

    .

  • 74

    .

    31

    (,).

    ..

    .

    32

    .

    .

    33.

    .

    .

    34

    .

    .

    .

    .

    .

  • 75

    :

    /

    (//)

    ..

    1 , .

    .7

    .6

    2 .7

    .6

    3 , .

    .7

    .6

    4 .

    .7

    .6

    5

    ..

    .7

    .6

  • 76

    6,.

    .7

    .6

  • 77

    :(...)

    /

    (//)

    ..

    1

    . (, ) .

    . 24 . 3846/2010(66) .8/2010(777) . . , , . ,

    ( ), .

  • 78

    , . , .., ., , , , .(.1&3.....11/17.10.2013...)

    2

    (.

    )(.).

    ,.

    (

  • 79

    (..1.....11/17.10.2013...)

    ),.

    3

    .

    , , .(..2.....11/17.10.2013...)

    (.),.

    4

    .

    , , .(..7.....11/17.10.2013...)

    .

  • 80

  • 81

    & 1 .. NA

    23 / 10 / 2013

    . .: 17166

    7

    .

    ...

    : 521/30-9-2013

    ,

    ..

    : . :

    . . .:

    : & &

  • 82

    ,

    .

    .

    . 3329/2005 ( 81/)

    (

    7), 2 ( ) 3 . 5 (1,2,3,8,9 ...)

    ... .

    -

    .

    ( management)

    . (3)

    ,

    .

    ,

    , .

    , ,

    ,

    .

    , ,

    , 3 .

    ,

  • 83

    thing tank

    .

    ,

    (..),

    2010, 120

    , ( ),

    160.492.145,25 .

    ,

    80 &

    31.000.000,00 .

    ,

    13%

    ( 50%/)

    () ( 32%/),

    39% ( 72.108.378

    2009 46.957.218 2012)

    .

    (20% )

    .

    .

    .

  • 84

    .

    .

    .

    .

    .

    :

    9 2007, 2008 & 2009.

    9 9 & 9 9 & 9 9

    9 9 ,

    & (PACS)

    9

    9 online barcode

    9 &9 15%

  • 85

    9

    .

    9 () .

    2

    2012 & 2013. ,

    2012

    :

    (): 90

    653 28 2

    230

    1.683 [656 (2010) 538 (2011) 489 (2012)]

    34 17

    2011

    &

    :

    1.

    2. ,

    ,

  • 86

    3. ,

    ,

    &

    &

    , &

    . ,

    :

    9 & 9 & 9 , &

    .

    .

    . .:1. ..

    2.

    /

  • 87

    1.

    ( ,

    , ..),

    .

    2. 2.1. ,

    & .

    2.2. .

    2.3. , , & .

    3. 3.1. , , &

    : 3.2. (4-203)

    .

    3.3. , , & ( ) / .

    3.4. , , / : /

    , .

    : , &

  • 88

    .

    3.5. , .

    4. / 4.1. ( 4 203) 4.2. ( ) - 4.3. . -

  • 89

    5.

    .

    6. 6.1.

    , , & .

    6.2. , , , ( , & ) .

    7. 7.1. , ,

    , , , , stents & , :

    7.2. ( ), 48 ( 24 ) :

    (GMDN),

    ... . 7.3. .. (

    , ) .

    7.4. . 7.5. ( ,

    )

    : &

  • 90

    , . / ( ) .

    7.6. :

    - ( ). , -, . , .

    , . .

    .

    / , , .. , , .

    7.7. / , .

    7.8. . / , ( ), . . .

    7.9. , .

    7.10. FAX . 7.11.

    . 7.12. , -

    .

  • 91

    . 7.13. , -

    . , ( ). .

    7.14. , , .

    7.15. ( ,) : .

    . .

    . , .

    7.16. , - , , . .

    7.17. - .

    7.18. , / .

    8. / 8.1. ( 4 202) 8.2. 8.3.

  • 92

  • 93

  • 94

  • 95

  • 96

    8

    INTOSAIGOV9100

    (Guidelinesforinternalcontrol

    standards for the Public Sector),

    (INTOSAI)

    . 626/60996, 634/60997 635/60999/12112012

    .

    ,

    ,

    .

    (internal

    control).

    . ,

    internal control internal audit

    control audit

    .

    INTOSAI GOV 9100,

    2848/2012

    internalcontrol.

  • 97

    INTOSAI GOV 9100 , ISSAI, , INTOSAI. , : www.issai.org

  • 98

    (PSC) INTOSAI

    PSC Rigsrevisionen Landgreven 4 P.O. Box 9009 1022 K

    .: + 45 3392 8400 : + 45 3311 0415 : [email protected]

    : http://www.issai.org

    INTOSAI - RECHNUNGSHOF ( )

    DAMPFSCHIFFSTRASSE 2 A-1033

    .: ++43 (1) 711 71 : ++43 (1) 718 09 69

    : [email protected] : http://www.intosai.org

  • 99

  • 100

  • 101

    Fr. VANSTAPEL

    Regentschapsstraat 2 B-1000

    .: ++32 (2) 551 81 11 : ++32 (2) 551 86 22

    : [email protected]

  • 102

  • 103

    INTOSAI - RECHNUNGSHOF ( )

    DAMPFSCHIFFSTRASSE 2 A-1033

    .: ++43 (1) 711 71 : ++43 (1) 718 09 69

    : [email protected] http://www.intosai.org

  • 104

    ..............................................................................................................................1 ...............................................................................................................................3 1 ..........................................................................................................6

    1.1 ......................................................................................................................6 1.2 .......................12

    2 ..............................................................13

    2.1 ...............................................................................................17 2.2 .................................................................................................22 2.3 ........................................................................................28 2.4 ................................................................................36 2.5 ......................................................................................................40

    3 ...................................................................................................43 1 ...............................................................................................49 2 ...................................................................................................57

  • 1 / 105

    1992 INTOSAI , . . 17 (INCOSAI , 2001) 1992 (Committee of Sponsoring Organisations-COSO) Treadway. , . . , , , COSO13. INTOSAI. EI , , , , , , , ( ).

    13 COSO, Enterprise Risk Management Integrated Framework, www.coso.org, 2004.

  • 2 / 106

    50 (, 2002). , 51 (, 2003). 2004. , INTOSAI . , . INTOSAI . . XVIII INCOSAI 2004. Franki VANSTAPEL INTOSAI

  • 3 / 107

    2001, INCOSAI 1992 INTOSAI COSO - . COSO , , . . . COSO 1992, . , , .14 . . , . , . , , . , , . , . 1992 , .

    14 XVI INCOSAI, , , 1998.

  • 4 / 108

    , () , . , , , , , . , . . , . 15, . COSO 16 , . , INTOSAI . . . , , , . , , , , ( , , ,

    15 INTOSAI 16 . , , , , . 3 .

  • 5 / 109

    ) . , . , , . . , . . , . . , , . , , . .

  • 6 / 110

    1 1.1 , :

    , , ,

    , .

    . . , . . . , , . . . , , .

  • 7 / 111

    . . , , . . , . , . , . , (3) . . , , . , . . , . , . , . , . , . , . . . .

  • 8 / 112

    , . , . , . , . , . , . . , , . , . , . : , , , , , . , . . . . , , , .

  • 9 / 113

    . , , , , . , . , , . , , , , . , . , . , / , . , . . , , . : , , ,

    , , , . . .

  • 10 / 114

    . . . . , . . , , , . . . .

    , , , . , . , ( ), . . , , . , , , /

  • 11 / 115

    , , .

    , , , , ,

    (, , , ), . . , , . , . , , . , , , . , , . . , , .

  • 12 / 116

    1.2 17 . , , . , , . , . , , , . . , . , , , , , , , , . . . , . , . . , , , . 17 , .

  • 13 / 117

    2

    : . , . . , . , . , . . / . , . . ( -). . , , , . , .

  • 14 / 118

    , , , , . . . . , , , . , , , , . . - ( ), ( ), (, , , ) - , , . . , , , , , .

  • 15 / 119

    .. , , . , , . . , , . , .

  • 16 / 120

    , . , , , , , . , . , .

  • 17 / 121

    2.1

    ..

    , . , . : (1)

    ,

    (2) (3) (

    ) (4) (5) . ,

  • 18 / 122

    . . . , (.. ), . , , . , , , , , , , , , . , , , , . , . . , , , , . , , , , , . ( ) :

  • 19 / 123

    ,

    ,

    , , , .

    . , . , . , , . , , . , , . , , . , , , , , . , . , . . , . :

  • 20 / 124

    .

    . . . , . , , . . 3 . , , ( ) , , , . . . , , , , , . , , , . . . , , . .

  • 21 / 125

    .

  • 22 / 126

    2.2

    ..

    , . : (1) :

    ,

    (2) :

    (3) (4) :

    : , , . , ,

    .

  • 23 / 127

    , , , , . , ( ) . , . . , . , . . . , . . . , . . , . ( ). , . ,

  • 24 / 128

    . , . 18 , , . . .19 , , . , (.. ), ( ). , . , . , , . . , , , , . ,

    18 (.. , , ), . 19 . . , , , ( ). . . ( ) . , .

  • 25 / 129

    , . , ( ). . . . , . . . . , , , , , . , . . , . . , , .20 , ,

    20 , . , , .

  • 26 / 130

    . . . . , . , . , . , . , .

    , , . , . . , . , , .

  • 27 / 131

    , , , , , . , ( ) , . , , , . .

  • 28 / 132

    2.3

    , ..

    . , , , () , , , . , . : (1) (2) (, , ,

    ) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) , (8) (, , ). .

  • 29 / 133

    , . . , : (

    )

    (, )

    ( )

    , .

    : 1. . , . , , . . 2. (, , ,

    ) , , , . , . , , . , . ,

  • 30 / 134

    . , . . , , . 3. / . , , . . , . , , . 4. , .. , . , . . 5. , .. (extrait).. 6. , . , , .

  • 31 / 135

    7. , , , , , . 2.5. 8. (, , ) . , :

    ,

    . (supervisor) . , . , . 1 3 , 4 6 , 7 8 . , . , . , . , . .

  • 32 / 136

    .

  • 33 / 137

    2.3.1 . , : (1)

    , . . 1) , 2) , 3) , , 4) , 5) 6) .

    (2)

    , , , . , .

    . , . , , , . , , , . , . .

  • 34 / 138

    . , , , , , , , , . , . , , , . , ..

    , , , . . : (1)

    , , , . .

    (2) (, , ), , , . .

    (3) , .

    (4) .

    (5) , ,

  • 35 / 139

    .

    (6) , .

    , , , ( ), , , . , . : : ,

    , , :

    :

    , .

    , , , . . . . , .

  • 36 / 140

    , , , . . , . , , . , (.. 24 ), . , , . , . , , , . (Information Systems Audit and Control Association - ISACA), (Control Objectives for Information and Related Technology-COBIT) ISACA, INTOSAI. .

  • 37 / 141

    2.4

    - - .

    . . , ( ). , . , , . , , . , , , , .

  • 38 / 142

    . , . . , , , . , , . , . , , . . , . , , , . , . . , , . , , , . , , . , :

  • 39 / 143

    ( ;) ( ;) ( ;) ( ;) ( ;). , , , (.. ). . , . , . , . ( , ), . . , . , . , , . ( , ), .

  • 40 / 144

    . , , , . , . . , . , , . , , , . , . .

  • 41 / 145

    2.5

    - .

    . , . (1)

    , . , . , , , .

    (2)

    .

  • 42 / 146

    . .

    . . , . , , , . , , 2.3. , . , . , . , , . . , , , , , . , . , . , . , .

  • 43 / 147

    , . . , , . . . , . , , .. , , . . : 1) , , , 2) , 3) , , . , 1) , 2) 3) .

  • 44 / 148

    .

  • 45 / 149

    3 : :

    , , , , . .

    :

    , , . , , , .

    : . . , .

    . , . , , , , .

  • 46 / 150

    ():

    . , . .

    :

    . , , .

    :

    . .

    : (, , ..) .

    , . , . . , , , , . , . , , . , . . , .

  • 47 / 151

    , . , . , . , , , . , . , (Professional Practices Framework-PPF) (), , , . , INTOSAI. , . , , . . , , , , .

  • 48 / 152

    , ( ), , . , . , , , , . , , . , . : ,

    , ,

    , , , ,

    ,

    . , . , . , , . , , , . , , , .

  • 49 / 153

    . . , , . . . , , . , . , . . , . . .

  • 50 / 154

    1

  • 51 / 155

    , (1): , , , , (, , ). &

    . . , .

    , , . , .

    , , , .

    , , , , .

    , , , , , .

  • 52 / 156

    , (2): 15% . &

    , . ( ! )

    , . , , 15%. , 15% , 15% . , .

    .

    . , . .

    .

  • 53 / 157

    , : . . , . . &

    . .

    . , , . , . , .

    , .

    , . , .

    .

  • 54 / 158

    , , , , (1): . , , . , , , , . &

    , .

    . , . , , . , , .

    , , , .

    , ( ), . .

    .

  • 55 / 159

    , , , , (2): . . &

    , .

    , .

    : -

    .

    - .

    - , , ( ) ..

    - .

    -

    () .

    . .

  • 56 / 160

    , (1): , . . &

    .

    . , , .

    , . .

    . .

    , , .

  • 57 / 161

    , (2): . , () , , . &

    , . .

    , : -

    -

    -

    -

    -

    - .

    , .

    : -

    (.. ) (.. , , )

    -

    -

    - ( )

    -

    , . . () ( ) .

    , , , .

  • 58 / 162

    ( !)

    - .

  • 59 / 163

    2

  • 60 / 164

    . , , .

    Code of ethics and auditing standards, INTOSAI, 2001. (INTOSAI auditing standards)

    Internal Control Integrated Framework, COSO, 1992. (COSO 1992) Glossarium, Office for official publications of the European communities, P.

    Everard and D. Wolter, 1989. (glossarium) Auditing and assurance services, an integrated approach, A. A. Arens, R. J.

    Elder and M. S. Beasley, Prentice Hall international edition, ninth edition, 2003. (Arens, Elder & Beasley)

    the COSO exposure draft Enterprise Risk Management Framework, COSO, 2003. (COSO ERM)

    Handbook of international auditing, assurance, and ethics pronouncements, IFAC, 2003. (IFAC)

    Transparency International Source Book 2000, (Transparency International) XVI INCOSAI, Montevideo, Uruguay, 1998, Principal Paper Theme 1A

    (Preventing and Detecting Fraud and Corruption), February 1997, (XVI INCOSAI, Uruguay, 1998)

    Professional Practices Framework, The Institute of Internal Auditors. (IIA) C COSO Treadway (Committee of Sponsoring Organisations of the Treadway Commission - COSO), . 1992, - . COSO. A (Uncertainty) . (COSO ERM) (Collusion) , . (Arens, Elder & Beasley) (Integrity) , . , . , . (COSO 1992) (Independence)

  • 61 / 165

    . (glossarium) EI (SAI) . ( INTOSAI) . , , . (IIA) ( ). (Arens, Elder & Beasley) ( ). (Arens, Elder & Beasley) (Deficiency) , . (COSO 1992) (Risk Tolerance) . (COSO ERM) (Objectivity) (SAI) , . . () (SAI) , , , , . ( INTOSAI & IFAC) (Risk Evaluation) . (Fraud) , , , . , , , . (XVI INCOSAI, , 1998).

  • 62 / 166

    (Efficient) . . (Efficiency) , , , . ( INTOSAI) , , . (glossarium) (Effective) . (Effectiveness) . ( INTOSAI) . (glossarium) (General Controls) , . . , . , , , , . . : . (COSO ERM) (Flowcharting) , . . (glossarium)

  • 63 / 167

    (Data) . (Public Accountability) , , , , , . ( INTOSAI) (Public Sector) , ( , , , ) , ( , , ) ( , , , ). (IFAC) (Flowchart) , . (Arens, Elder & Beasley) (Procedure) . (COSO 1992) (Management process) . .. (COSO 1992) (Risk appetite) . . (COSO ERM) (Detective control) ( ). (COSO 1992) (Corruption) . (XVI INCOSAI, , 1998) . (Transparency International) (Segregation or separation of duties)

  • 64 / 168

    , , , (, , , ) . (INTOSAI) O INTOSAI () . . INTOSAI 1953 34 170 . (control) 1. , , .. - . . 2. , , .. : , . 3. , . : . (COSO 1992) , , . , . (IIA) (Application controls) , , , . , , . , . (COSO 1992) / (Computer controls) 1. , , ( ). 2. /, ( ). (COSO 1992)

  • 65 / 169

    (System software controls) . (Access control) , , . (Budgetary control) , , , . (glossarium) (Service continuity control) , . (Network) , . , , . , , , . (Management) . . (IFAC) (Control activity) . . , . (Input) .

  • 66 / 170

    (Risk assessment) , . (Audit Committee) , , . ) , ) , ) , ) ) ( ). (Audit Institution) , , , . (glossarium) (Edit checks) . , . , , . (Audit) , , . , , . (glossarium) (Stakeholders) , , , , . (COSO ERM)

  • 67 / 171

    (Inherent limitations) . , , . (COSO 1992) (Inherent risk) . (COSO ERM) (External audit) , , / . (glossarium) (Processing) , . (-) (-) (Internal auditor(s)) , , , . (Internal audit) , . , . ( INTOSAI) , .. , . () . , , , . (IFAC)

  • 68 / 172

    (Internal control) , , : , , , , , , . (Reasonable assurance) , . , , . . (COSO 1992) (Orderly) .. (Application) / , , , , . , , , , . (Ethical values) . , . (COSO 1992) (Ethical) . (Institute of Internal Auditors - ) , .

  • 69 / 173

    (Mainframe) . . (Risk) . (COSO ERM) (Risk assessment cycle) , , , . , , . (Operations) : , , . (COSO 1992) , . (Logical access) /. , , . ( ) (System software) , , . (Accountability) , .

  • 70 / 174

    . (glossarium) (Computer Information System) (Computer Information System - CIS) () , . (IFAC) (Internal Audit Unit) ( ) , , , . . (glossarium) , , . , . (IIA) (Legislature) , , . ( INTOSAI) (Economy) , . ( INTOSAI) , . (glossarium) (Economical) . , , , .

  • 71 / 175

    (Entity) . , , , - , . . (COSO 1992) (Output) , / , . (Management Override) ( ) (COSO 1992) (Monitoring) . (Management Intervention) , - . ( ) (COSO 1992) (Control Environment) , . , . (Policy) .. . (COSO 1992) (Security program) ,

  • 72 / 176

    . , , . (End user computing) - (, ) , (.., ). . , . (Preventive control) ( ) (COSO 1992) (Budget) , . . (glossarium) (Risk profile) (.. , , ) . (Compliance) . (COSO 1992) , , , , , . (IIA) (Component of Internal Control) . , , , , . (COSO 1992) ( ) (Internal Control System or Process or Architecture) . (COSO 1992)

  • 73 / 177

    (Design) 1. : , . , . 2. : , . (COSO 1992) - (Value for money) , . (Documentation) , , . , , . (Residual risk) . (Physical Access) , . ( ) (Manual Controls) , ( /). (COSO 1992)

  • 74