contrast - Southeast Asian Linguistics Societyjseals.org/seals23/cooper2013case.pdf · Modern...

30

Transcript of contrast - Southeast Asian Linguistics Societyjseals.org/seals23/cooper2013case.pdf · Modern...

Page 1: contrast - Southeast Asian Linguistics Societyjseals.org/seals23/cooper2013case.pdf · Modern Burmese is said to have a dental fricative [θ] Acoustic studies reveal it to be a dental
Page 2: contrast - Southeast Asian Linguistics Societyjseals.org/seals23/cooper2013case.pdf · Modern Burmese is said to have a dental fricative [θ] Acoustic studies reveal it to be a dental

Modern Burmese is said to have a dental

fricative [θ]

Acoustic studies reveal it to be a dental plosive

[t]

Dental/alveolar

plosive contrast

Many other languages have this contrast

There should be a symbol for the dental stop like there is for the fricative

Page 3: contrast - Southeast Asian Linguistics Societyjseals.org/seals23/cooper2013case.pdf · Modern Burmese is said to have a dental fricative [θ] Acoustic studies reveal it to be a dental
Page 4: contrast - Southeast Asian Linguistics Societyjseals.org/seals23/cooper2013case.pdf · Modern Burmese is said to have a dental fricative [θ] Acoustic studies reveal it to be a dental

Fricative Affricate“Gives the impression

of a weak plosive”Plosive

Armstrong & Pe Maung Tin (1925)

Aung Naing Win (2000)

Bradley (2011) Burling (1967)

Chang (2009) Firth (1936)

Green (2005) Kato (1998)

Myint Soe (1999)

Okell (1994) Roop (1972)

Than Than Win (1998)

Watkins (2001) Wheatley (2003)

*Bradley (“slight

preaffrication”)

*Chang

*Watkins

*Wheatley

*Armstrong & Pe

Maung Tin

*Chang

*Than Than Win

Shiwaruangarote

(2000)

*Kato

Page 5: contrast - Southeast Asian Linguistics Societyjseals.org/seals23/cooper2013case.pdf · Modern Burmese is said to have a dental fricative [θ] Acoustic studies reveal it to be a dental
Page 6: contrast - Southeast Asian Linguistics Societyjseals.org/seals23/cooper2013case.pdf · Modern Burmese is said to have a dental fricative [θ] Acoustic studies reveal it to be a dental

Figure 1. Spectrogram of ‘this son’ ဒသား /dita/ spoken by F1

Page 7: contrast - Southeast Asian Linguistics Societyjseals.org/seals23/cooper2013case.pdf · Modern Burmese is said to have a dental fricative [θ] Acoustic studies reveal it to be a dental

Figure 2. Spectrogram of ‘this son’ ဒသား /dita/ spoken by M1

Page 8: contrast - Southeast Asian Linguistics Societyjseals.org/seals23/cooper2013case.pdf · Modern Burmese is said to have a dental fricative [θ] Acoustic studies reveal it to be a dental

Figure 3. Spectrogram from ‘this hammer’ ဒတ /d itu/ spoken by F1

Page 9: contrast - Southeast Asian Linguistics Societyjseals.org/seals23/cooper2013case.pdf · Modern Burmese is said to have a dental fricative [θ] Acoustic studies reveal it to be a dental

Figure 4. Spectrogram from ‘this hammer’ ဒတ /d itu/ spoken by M1

Page 10: contrast - Southeast Asian Linguistics Societyjseals.org/seals23/cooper2013case.pdf · Modern Burmese is said to have a dental fricative [θ] Acoustic studies reveal it to be a dental

Figure 5. Spectrogram from သတငး [dədɪ ] ‘news’ spoken by F2

Page 11: contrast - Southeast Asian Linguistics Societyjseals.org/seals23/cooper2013case.pdf · Modern Burmese is said to have a dental fricative [θ] Acoustic studies reveal it to be a dental
Page 12: contrast - Southeast Asian Linguistics Societyjseals.org/seals23/cooper2013case.pdf · Modern Burmese is said to have a dental fricative [θ] Acoustic studies reveal it to be a dental

Figure 7. Dental plosive in the wordသ [t u] ‘him’ from the recorded passage (line 6 of IPA transcription)

Page 13: contrast - Southeast Asian Linguistics Societyjseals.org/seals23/cooper2013case.pdf · Modern Burmese is said to have a dental fricative [θ] Acoustic studies reveal it to be a dental

Figure 8. Dental plosive in the wordသ [tu ] ‘him’ from the recorded passage (line 2).

Page 14: contrast - Southeast Asian Linguistics Societyjseals.org/seals23/cooper2013case.pdf · Modern Burmese is said to have a dental fricative [θ] Acoustic studies reveal it to be a dental

Figure 9. Alveolar plosive (unaspirated) in the word တက [taɪʔ] ‘push, blow’ from the recorded passage (line 4).

Page 15: contrast - Southeast Asian Linguistics Societyjseals.org/seals23/cooper2013case.pdf · Modern Burmese is said to have a dental fricative [θ] Acoustic studies reveal it to be a dental

Figure 10. Alveolar plosive (unaspirated) in the wordတတ [taʔ] ‘be able’ from the recorded passage (line 3).

Page 16: contrast - Southeast Asian Linguistics Societyjseals.org/seals23/cooper2013case.pdf · Modern Burmese is said to have a dental fricative [θ] Acoustic studies reveal it to be a dental

40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110 120 130 140

Bilabial

Dental

Alveolar

Velar

Female 2

40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110 120 130 140

Bilabial

Dental

Alveolar

Velar

Male 1

40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110 120 130 140

Bilabial

Dental

Alveolar

Velar

Female 1

40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110 120 130 140

Bilabial

Dental

Alveolar

Velar

Male 2n=30-46

n= ~20 per place of articulation

Page 17: contrast - Southeast Asian Linguistics Societyjseals.org/seals23/cooper2013case.pdf · Modern Burmese is said to have a dental fricative [θ] Acoustic studies reveal it to be a dental

0 10 20 30 40 50 60

Bilabial

Dental

Alveolar

Velar

Male 1

0 10 20 30 40 50 60

Bilabial

Dental

Alveolar

Velar

Male 2

0 10 20 30 40 50 60

Bilabial

Dental

Alveolar

Velar

Female 2

0 10 20 30 40 50 60

Bilabial

Dental

Alveolar

Velar

Female 1

Page 18: contrast - Southeast Asian Linguistics Societyjseals.org/seals23/cooper2013case.pdf · Modern Burmese is said to have a dental fricative [θ] Acoustic studies reveal it to be a dental
Page 19: contrast - Southeast Asian Linguistics Societyjseals.org/seals23/cooper2013case.pdf · Modern Burmese is said to have a dental fricative [θ] Acoustic studies reveal it to be a dental
Page 20: contrast - Southeast Asian Linguistics Societyjseals.org/seals23/cooper2013case.pdf · Modern Burmese is said to have a dental fricative [θ] Acoustic studies reveal it to be a dental
Page 21: contrast - Southeast Asian Linguistics Societyjseals.org/seals23/cooper2013case.pdf · Modern Burmese is said to have a dental fricative [θ] Acoustic studies reveal it to be a dental

Speaker M2 saying သတငး [dədɪ ] ‘news’ (on the left) and သမး [təmi] ‘daughter’

116 Hz 142 Hz

Page 22: contrast - Southeast Asian Linguistics Societyjseals.org/seals23/cooper2013case.pdf · Modern Burmese is said to have a dental fricative [θ] Acoustic studies reveal it to be a dental
Page 23: contrast - Southeast Asian Linguistics Societyjseals.org/seals23/cooper2013case.pdf · Modern Burmese is said to have a dental fricative [θ] Acoustic studies reveal it to be a dental
Page 24: contrast - Southeast Asian Linguistics Societyjseals.org/seals23/cooper2013case.pdf · Modern Burmese is said to have a dental fricative [θ] Acoustic studies reveal it to be a dental
Page 25: contrast - Southeast Asian Linguistics Societyjseals.org/seals23/cooper2013case.pdf · Modern Burmese is said to have a dental fricative [θ] Acoustic studies reveal it to be a dental
Page 26: contrast - Southeast Asian Linguistics Societyjseals.org/seals23/cooper2013case.pdf · Modern Burmese is said to have a dental fricative [θ] Acoustic studies reveal it to be a dental
Page 27: contrast - Southeast Asian Linguistics Societyjseals.org/seals23/cooper2013case.pdf · Modern Burmese is said to have a dental fricative [θ] Acoustic studies reveal it to be a dental

If it’s possible for the fricatives to have their own symbols, then why not for the plosives?

Page 28: contrast - Southeast Asian Linguistics Societyjseals.org/seals23/cooper2013case.pdf · Modern Burmese is said to have a dental fricative [θ] Acoustic studies reveal it to be a dental
Page 29: contrast - Southeast Asian Linguistics Societyjseals.org/seals23/cooper2013case.pdf · Modern Burmese is said to have a dental fricative [θ] Acoustic studies reveal it to be a dental