-, - .

:

:

,

, Sun Tzu Clausewitz

: .

: . (: 03115)

, 2016

, , . , , .

.

Clausewitz, Sun Tzu,

.

, ,

,

,

16

.. .

,

,

, . ,

.

,

.

. ,

,

.

,

Clausewitz. ,

,

.

: , , , , , , , , , , ,

, .

i

.................................................................................................I

............................................................................................................................1

:...........................................................................3

1.......................................................................................3

1.1................3

1.2..............................................................................................................7

1.3....................................................10

1.4..........................................................13

1.5(Friction)..........................................................16

2.

...............................................................................18

2.1................................................18

2.216...........................................................19

2.3(97...),..............................20

2.4SunTzu(5...)...................................................22

2.5(431404..)....................................25

2.6........................................................................................26

:,................................................28

3./.....28

3.1.

.................................................................................30

3.2

.........................................................................32

3.3.......................................................35

3.4

.......................................................................37

3.5

........................................................................39

3.6.........................................42

3.73................................................................45

4:

...........................................................47

4.1.....................................47

4.1.................................49

4.2

SunTzu...........................................................................................................52

ii

4.3

Clausewitz.....................................................................................................56

4.44..........................................................................60

....................................................................................................................62

............................................................................................................63

..........................................................................................................63

..............................................................................64

....................................................................................................66

- 1 -

/

Clausewitz On war.

, ,

. ..

, .

,

.

, .

.

Clausewitz

, .

,

.

. ,

,

.

, Sun Tzu Clausewitz,

(.. )

- 2 -

(.. ).

.

,

, .

.

.

(16 .., , Sun

Tzu ),

,

.

.

.

,

.

,

. ,

, Sun

Tzu Clausewitz.

,

,

,

. .

- 3 -

: -

1.

,

,

. ,

:

;

;

;

, ;1 -

,

,

;

1.1 .

,

(, ) 2,

Carl von Clausewitz

On War . .

:

1 . , . , . . , . , , , 2010 ( ),. 125-127.2 , : ( ) (operational art). , . , (750-192..), , , 2001,. 29. . .

- 4 -

. ,

,

, ,

, .3

. ,

,

,

,

.

Clausewitz

, Helmuth von Moltke,4

.

,

. 5

,

,

. , ,,

( )

. ,

(..

),

.

.

,

.

3 . , .., .253. 4 (1800-1891) Clausewitz , 1857 Clausewitz . . Encyclopedia Britannica,http://www.britannica.com/biography/Helmuth-von-Moltke. 5 Carl von Clausewitz, On War (Indexed Edition). : Michael Howard Peter Paret, Princeton New Jersey, Princeton University Press, 1989, . 30.

- 5 -

.6 Martin Van Creveld

:

, ,

.

, , ,

,

, ,

, .

( )

3000 ,

,

.

,

. 7 Creveld

,

.

,

.

, ,

,

, .

. ,

6 Martin van Creveld, , , . , , ,2001, .137 Martin van Creveld, .., .13-14

- 6 -

(1618-1648),

.V. Creveld

,

. 8

O Michael Howard

( Clausewitz),

, ,

, , ,

.

.

, . 9

.

, ,

.

,

,

,

. 10

, Michael

Howard

, ,

.

.

,

8 Martin van Creveld, .., .32. 9 Michael Howard, , , , 2000, .75. 10 Michael Howard, .., .75-76.

- 7 -

( )

( )

. ,

, ,

, .

. ,

11

.

, Andre

Beaufre :

,

,

. 12, .

,

Andr Beaufre .

1.2

,

.

,

11 , . , . . Carl von Clausewitz, .., .28, 69, 78, 8012 Andr Beaufre, (. ), ,, 2015, ., 14

- 8 -

.

Andr Beaufre,

1980, ,

, ,

,

.

.13

( )-

.

, Colin Gray14

(the use made of force)

(for the ends of policy). 15

Clausewitz

, (use

of the engagement) . 16

,

17 .

13 Andr Beaufre, (. ), ,, 2015, ., 14-15. 14 Reading , , . 15 Colin S. Gray, STRATEGY FOR CHAOS, Revolution in Military Affairs and the Evidence of History, London- Portland- Oregon, Frank Cass Publishers, 2002, p.3. 16 Carl von Clausewitz, .., p.177. 17 Joseph Nye (soft power), . . - - , , , .

- 9 -

,

,

, E. H. Carr

.18

,

.

. : -

-.19

20,

- ,

, ,

,

. 21

,

.

18 , Edward H. Carr, : , . ultima ratio . , , . Edward H. Carr, 1919-1939, ,. . , , , 2004 ( ), . 154 157. 19 . , , , , 2008 ( ), .44. 20 K. N. Waltz, . (.. , ). , . Kenneth N. Waltz, , . . , , , 2011, . 10-13 179-220. 21 . , .., . 226.

- 10 -

,

,

.

,

.

1.3 .

,

(grand strategy)

, , , ,

.

. 22

, .

23

,

,

,

. 24

,

.

Liddel Hart

Paul Kennedy, ,

,

22 , .., .44. 23 , . Perez Zagorin, , , . . , , ( ),2006,