Ennoia and ΠΡΟΛΗΨΙΣ in the Stoic Theory of Knowledge F. H. Sandbach
Canadians Must Expand Chemical Knowledge to Develop Resources
Transcript of Canadians Must Expand Chemical Knowledge to Develop Resources
THE CHEMICAL WORLD THIS WEEK
Chatting between sessions at the CIC conference were: (left to r ight) : T. L. Davies , Polymer Corp.; S- M. Cadwell, U . S. Rubber; and R. A. Kundinger, Dominion Rubber
C&EN REPORTS: Chemica l Inst i tute o f Canada
Canadians Must Expand Chemical Knowledge to Develop Resources
Canada can profit by U. ί expanding its chemical industry
experience in
WINDSOR, O N T . - U n l e s s Canadians continue to maintain and expand their fundamental chemical knowledge they will lose out in the development of the vast natural resources of their country. This was the warning given to the 36th annual conference of the Chemical Institute of Canada, held here June 4 to 6, by R. S. Jane, Shawinigan Chemicals, retiring president of the institute.
The meetirg drew chemists and chemical engineers from all parts of Canada, and its location in the border city of Windsor attracted many visitors from the United States as well. Over 100 technical papers covered almost every branch of chemistry. All signs indicated that the Canadian chemical industry is on the threshold of a period of tremendous expansion.
As J. W. T. Spinks, University of Saskatchewan and newly elected president of the CIC put it, "We have not even reached the end of the beginning." H e told members of the institute that in order to have a first-rate chemical industry they must have first-rate chemists and chemical engineers. To obtain these, they must have a first-rate chemical institute. T h e
CIC now has over 4000 members and is the largest scientific society in Canada.
In many respects, the Canadian chemical industry is likely to parallel the development of that of the United States, but in others, Canada may be expected to leapfrog some of the difficulties encountered by the U. S. W. T. Nichols, Monsanto, president of the American Institute of Chemical Engineers, warned the Canadians that the huge size of the chemical industry in the United States is not a result of population growth, but of an en-
The Week's Events Spinks and S+eacie Honored by
Chemical Institute of Canada 2486 Production Capacity tor Acryloni-
trile W i l l Reach 190 Million Pounds in Two Years 2490
Solvay Wi l l Build Methyl Chloride Plant at Moundsvïlle, W . Va. . 2495
Good Possibilities of Commercial Production of Atomic Energy Seen by Gordon Dean . . . . 2498
General Activities Building Dedicated a t Institute of Paper Chemistry 2502
vironment of free and untrammeled competition. He said that many problems lie ahead for the Canadians and that they should profit by the experience of their neighbors south of the border.
In regard to the rapidly expanding plastics industry in Canada, Mr. Nichols stated that there is unmistakable evidence of big things to come. When the predicted big chemical operations get under way one thing will lead to another and a whole chain of events will start. It will b e all one can do to hang on.
Once a plant site is opened u p , integrar tion begins. One product leads to another, raw material problems give rise to new operations, and research starts to throw pebbles into the technological mill pond. Well-conceived and well-administered research will b e needed to induce and maintain a steep growth curve.
Engineering Education. Engineering, according to dictionary definition, is the art and science b y which the properties of matter and the sources of power in nature are made useful to man in structures, machines, and manufactured products. H o w should an engineer be educated? This was the question considered b y George G. Brown, University of Michigan dean of engineering, in his Westman Memorial Lecture. Part of an engineer's training must b e art and part science. Today the tendency is toward more science and away from the art, said Dr . Brown.
Educators are carefully scrutinizing the requirements for undergraduate engineering curricula. Every day more and more is added to the body of scientific knowledge. If w e continue to try to give the student all of the- science which is added, the curriculum will have to be lengthened, possibly up to seven years. With the d e mand for technically trained men being what it is, Dr. Brown thinks that this is both impractical and unnecessary. What should be done is to give the students a good grounding in fundamental science. With such a background, the engineer will be able to overcome the obstacles he meets by thinking out the basic principle involved in each case.
Language is becoming increasingly important to the engineer. Dr. Brown tells his engineering students that they must know three languages. First they must know English, their native tongue. Then they must know mathematics. Most general laws are expressed in mathematics, and a knowledge of the science i s essential if the engineer is to follow the advances made in his field. T h e third language needed b y the engineer is that of graphical presentation, or drawing. I t is by this means that a great many engineering ideas are described.
Engineering teachers must give their students a background of science that will
2484 C H E M I C A L A N D E N G I N E E R I N G N E W S
enable them to meet the problems they have to face 2 0 years or so after they graduate. To accomplish this end, the undergraduate should be given an insigbt into the directions along which scientists are thinking and working.
There is one important educational concept which must b e reversed for engineering students. Heretofore, the emphasis of all scholarship has been on individual achievement. However, after graduation the student runs immediately into cooperative projects in which teamwork is of the greatest importance. Therefore, teamwork must be encouraged in college. Mo one who receives a degree from a recognized engineering college ever fails b e cause of a lack of technical ability. There is always some reason involving the ability to get along with people.
At the chemical engineering department of the University of Michigan, Dr. Brown now assigns his seniors to group projects. He told of cases where the groups had solved problems which had stumped a long series of individual workers. The value of a group is especially demonstrated when there is no "expert" available to tell the students that certain things are impossible.
One thing Dr. Brown emphasized particularly was the fact that an undergraduate engineering curriculum should not be designed as the first four years of graduate work. This tendency is becoming pronounced in the large universities. The aim of the engineering curriculum should be to turn out practicing engineers. Instead of deciding how much t ime is needed to cover a certain course. It should be determined just how much time can b e allotted to the course. Then everything should be put into the course which i s absolutely necessary for the graduate engineer to know.
The stimulating system of discussion i n small groups followed in English universities has much in its favor. The close contact between student and teacher -which develops from some of these apparently leisurely meetings is o f immense value a s a means of imparting knowledge. U. S . and Canadian institutions would do wel l to follow the example of their English cousins.
Freed Radicals. T h e major problem o f chemical kinetics today is the empirical building up of t h e organic chemistry o f short lived substances. E. W . R. Steacie, president of the National Research Council of Canada, in his CIC medalist address, said that t h e transitory existence o f free radicals has long been established i n spectroscopy. There is no question that the lack of existence of free radicals under ordinary circumstances is not due t o any intrinsic lack of stability, but rather t o their high reactivity which results in their rapid disappearance by reaction with themselves or with other substances which may be present.
Rubber Chsmisf ry. The problem of the rubber chemists 4 0 years ago was one o f recognition; his problem of the future i s to understand the complex chemistry o f rubber and other polymers. S. M. Cad-
V O L U M E 3 1 , N O . 2 4 » » »
well, U . S. Rubber Co., said that 3 0 or 40 years ago the chemists were not very welcome in rubber manufacturing plants. The foremen carried their formulas in little black books hidden away in their back pockets. The first chemists in—the industry had to spend a long time overcoming the suspicion of the factory men.
Now this is all changed. Dr. Cadwell stated that today the chemical industry has to a large extent become a rubber, or rather polymer, industry. In the United States, about 3 0 % of chemical business last year was in this field. The Polymer Corp. installation at Sarnia, Ont., is the largest chemical plant in Canada.
The rubber industry owes a great deal to other branches of the chemical industry. If the petroleum chemists had not developed economical methods of producing such raw materials as butadiene, our synthetic rubber industry would be nonexistent. On the other hand, the rubber industry has made contributions to other fields. For example, the antioxidants used in so many applications today were first developed by the rubber industry.
The picture Dr. Cadwell sees is that in the future the opportunity for service presented to the rubber chemist will be second to none. The scope of rubber chemistry encompasses colloid, organic, high polymer, and many other branches of chemistry. It is concerned with everything from natural latex to the development of new synthetic polymers.
George G. Brown, dean of the college of engineering at the University of Michigan, delivered the Westman Memorial Lecture
The use of cotton in tire casings has almost completely been superseded by the employment of man-made fibers. At present the most important fiber is high-tenacity viscose rayon, said J. W. Illing-worth, Dunlop Tire and Rubber, Birmingham, England. Nylon is finding some application in tire casings, especially in air-
COMMERCIAL PRODUCTION
• FOR M A K I N G
• pharmaceuticals • insect repellents • plasticizers • emulsifiers • synthetic lubricants
v4
• H .
H O C H 2 C C H 2 O H
C 4 H 9
2-ETHYL-2-BUTYL PROPANEDIOL-1,3
<~2H5
H O C H 2 C C H 2 O H
C 2 H 5
2,2-DIETHYL PROPANEDIOL-1,3
b.p. at 10 mm.
f.p. sol. in HoQ at 20°C
2-Ethyl-2-Butyl Propanediol·!^ 2,2-Diethyl Propanediol-1,3
145°C. 125°C.
41.4°C. 61.3°C.
0.8% by weight 2 5 % by weight
Samples and a technical information bulletin describing these diols are avai lab le on request.
A Division of IfitiOR Carbide aticf Carbon Corporation ·
^S-Ei^nd^S^N ^ïh^Gàha^qrr^rbider and
J U N E 1 5 , 1 9 5 3 2485 »
THE CHEMICAL WORLD THIS WEEK
plane tires. Increasing American and European production capacity will probably bring about more extensive use of the material. Terylene, or as it is known in the U. S., Dacron, ha s properties that make its adoption for tire cord an interesting probability.
There are a number of difficulties to be overcome before nylon and Terylene can corne into general use for tire cords. Both exhibit a tendency to shrink on heating. Also both, and especially Terylene, adhere poorly to rubber.
There is also a great effort being expended on improving the qualities of rayon. In Europe the Lilienfeldt process is in t h e pilot plant stage and is said to produce a rayon t i re yarn having. tensile strength 100% greater than standard. It is possible that this material will be produced on a full scale within 12 months.
Protect ive Coat ings . As the formulation of paints becomes more of a science and less of an art, the need for chemists in the protective coatings industry becomes greater. I n Canada, as in the United States, the entrance of well-qualified chemists and chemical engineers into this field has been somewhat less than might be desired. In order to point out the opportunities in t h e paint and allied industries, t h e protective coatings section of the CIC plans to distribute literature to science students. I t is hoped that this will attract a greater number of technically trained men to t he industry.
Uranium Ores . It may b e possible to concentrate low-grade Saskatchewan uranium ores by flotation methods. Describing work being carried on at the University of Saskatchewan, A. B. Van Cleave stated that t he Saskatchewan ores contain less than 0.1 % U309 disseminated as small crystals of uranite in a coarse granite pegmatite. So far, the ores have not responded well to flotation treatment, but it is thought that results are encouraging enough to promise an eventual economical process, perhaps through t h e addition of a leaching step.
Blood Preserva t ion . The problem of blood preservation is becoming increasingly important. In preserving whole blood, the ordinary method of storing in citrate and glucose allows t he red cells lo die at the ra te of 1% each day. In order to store sufficient blood to cope with any large scale emergency, preservation methods will have to b e made more efficient.
When t he metabolism of the red blood cell is better known, i t may be possible to determine 'which enzyme systems break down and cause the death of t he cells, said O. F . Denstedt, McGill University. Prof. Denstedt described t he several directions in which he and his students are seeking the answer t o the problem. Once it is known which enzyme systems tend to break down easily, i t may be possible to supply nutrient materials in the preserving medium to keep the cells alive longer.
In studying t h e tricarboxylic acid cycle ( Continued on page 2490 )
The Cover.
Spinks Elected CIC President; Steacie Receives CIC Medal J. W. T. Spinks Π Π Η Ε ELECTION of John W . T. Spinks
to the presidency of the Chemical Institute of Canada brings to the head of Canada's largest scientific society not only an outstanding teacher and research worker, but also a man with a broad interest in t h e humanities. Dr. Spinks is head of t h e department of chemistry and dean of t h e college of graduate studies at the University of Saskatchewan at Saskatoon. A physical chemist, Dr . Spinks has done his best known work in recent years in the realm of radioactive tracer chemistry.
Dr. Spinks does not believe that a young person should make elaborate plans for his future. He attributes the particular turn his o w n career has taken largely t o chance. He was horn in Methwold, England, in 1908 and received the bachelor's degree from Kings College, University of London, in 1928. The doctorate was granted by the same institution in 1930 for work done under A. J. Allmand.
While Spinks was still a graduate student it happened that an old schoolmate of Prof. Allmand, Thorbergur Thorvaldson, paid h im a visit. At that time Dr. Thorvaldson was head of the depar tment of chemistry at Saskatchewan and he was looking for a young man for his staff. Spinks was recommended. Faraway Saskatchewan appealed to the adventurous nature of the young Englishman and he readily accepted t h e appointment.
Dr . Spinks found t h e atmosphere at the university stimulating and still finds it so . H e says that h e immediately found a lot of work to do and he has kept busy ever since. His first research the re was in photochemistry. With the exception of a year spent at Darmstadt, Germany, in 1933 and 1934 and his wart ime work, Dr. Spinks has remained at the University of Saskatchewan. He succeeded Prof. Thorvaldson as head of the depar tment of chemistry when the lat ter retired in 1948. The following year Dr . Spinks w a s made dean of the college of graduate studies.
F rom March 1943 until September 1944, D r . Spinks was attached to the Royal Canadian Air Force as an operations research officer. Dur ing this t ime, he developed a scientific procedure for locating planes lost at sea. T h e method consisted of setting up probability areas a n d then carrying on a systematic search in these areas. Many flyers owe their
lives to this accomplishment oi Dr. Spinks. He was awarded t h e Medal of the British E m p i r e for this work,
F rom September 1944 until August 1945, Dr. Spinks was assigned by the National Research Council of Canada to the Atomic Research Project in Montreal. O n returning t o Saskatchewan after t he World War I I , he at once set about applying his knowledge of radioactive elements to a number of tracer experiments. Many of these investigations have been cooperative endeavors combining the efforts of his own and other departments . Included were studies on poultry metabolism, vitamin Κ and dicumarol, chromosome breakage, movement of soil inhabiting and flying insects, development of a soil moisture meter , and diffusion studies, in cement.
One application of radioactive tracer techniques which fits in very well with an old hobby of Dr. Spinks's is the employment of the carbon-14 dat ing method to determine the age of arche-ological remains. His interest in archeology goes back to his 15th year. The Indian remains in Saskatchewan · offer a fruitful source of material.
E. W. R. Steacie "P VV. R. STEACIE is not a newcomer *~*m to our cover, having appeared twice before, on June 20, 1949, and July 23 , 1951. He is president of the National Research Council of Canada and has received the Cronstedt Medal, highest award of the CIC, for his prominent contributions to chemistry in Canada.
Before joining the National Research Council in 1939, Dr. Steacie taught for 13 years at McGill University in •Montreal. Chemical kinetics, gas phase reactions, and photochemistry are the special fields in which Dr. Steacie's work is bes t known.
The N R C is engaged in a vast number of projects in applied science, but Dr. Steacie's strong interest in fundamental research is largely responsible for the academic air which prevails in the NRC laboratories. Half of the staff positions a re filled by means of postdoctoral fellowships which do not last more than two years. This constant influx of fresh ideas, coupled with the continuity provided by the permanent staff, has resulted in an organization which is indeed a credit to Canada.
2486 C H E M I C A L A N D E N G I N E E R I N G N E W S
THE CHEJVIICAA WORLD THIS WEEK
in the red cells of chickens, it was found that l>oth the in tac t cells and those that had been hemolyzed were able to synthesize titrate, provided succinate and pyruvate «re available. Metaholism of citrate in the hemolyzed cells were increased when adenosine tr iphosphate, cysteine, a n d coenzyme A were added. A similar utilization of citrate was noted by t h e hemolysate from red blood cells of rabbits. However, in this case an increased metabolic rate resulted only when diphosplioj>yridine nucleotide and triphos-phopyridine nucleotide were added . Iso-citric dehydrogenase occurs in both avian and rabbit cells.
Dr. Deiistedt said he had been able to demonstrate the presence of a DPN-ase on the outer surface of human red blood cells. This was the first time that the enzyme had been shown to exist in h u m a n cells, although i t had been known to occur in rabbits. T b e DPN-ase is a powerful enzyme whicb is able to split off the nicotinamide from the coenzyme, DPN.
Working with red blood cells from rabbits a n d humans, Dr . Denstedt found tha t ribose-5-phosphate is oxidized anaerobi-cally by ferricyanide o r aerobically by ethylene b lue in the presence of hemoly-sates of rabbit o r human cells. The intact cells will n o t promote this reaction since cell membrane does not permit t h e passage o f either rib>ose-5-phosphate or ferricyanide. Oxidation of the ribose ester with ferricyanide is independent of pyridine nucleotides. In t h e case of methylene blue, however, either DPN or TPN is definitely required. -Cyanide inhibits t h e reaction, but azide Has n o effect.
D-Ribose, υ-arabinose, glucose, and fructose were found to be slowly oxidized by ferricyanide in t h e presence of hemolyzed red cells. No pyridine nucleotides were necessary for this reaction. Although glyoxa.1 a n d inethylglyoxal are rapidly oxidized b y ferricyanide wi thout a catalyst, the ra te is greatly speeded up when hemolyzed red cells are present. The reaction will n o t take place aerobically with methylene blue and it is not affected by DPN o r TPN. Glycolaldehyde is only slowly oxidized by ferricyanide using the hemolyzed cells as a catalytic agent, while glycolic acid and oxalic acid were not at all afFectecL
Physical Chemistry. The first products formed in experiments o n the thermal de composition of methyl disulfide were methyl mercaptan and a' nonvolatile substance thought to be a thioformaldehyde polymer, according to W . A. Bryce, University of British Columbia. Hydrogen sulfide, carbon disulfide, ethylene, free sulfur, a n d polysulfides are formed in subsequent reactions. These latter reactions continue long after the disulfide has disappeared . It is believed that they result from the degradation of the postulated thioformaldehyde polymer. The decomposition reactions were carried out in all-glass apparatus and t h e course of the reaction was followed by measuring pressure
changes and analyzing the reaction mix-Lure at intervals during the process.
Growth of crystals of ethylenediamine tartrate is slowed down considerably by the addition of boric acid. T h e additive also changes the habit of the crystals, according to A. H. Booth, Atomic Energy of Canada, Ltd. These crystals are used as a substitute for quartz in certain electronic equipment. I t is thought possible that by slowing down crystal growth this way, flawed crystals may be prevented from forming in production operations.
Analyt ical Chemistry. A l u m i n u m concentrat ions of less than 1.0<7r can be de
termined with an accuracy of approximately 1 5 % by a new method developed by J. B. Zimmerman, Depar tment of Mines and Technical Surveys, Ottawa. The sample is dissolved and the impurities are precipitated with sodium hydroxide. The pi I of the sodium aluminate solution is adjusted to 4.6 and 8-hydroxyquinoline is added. The complex which forms is extracted with chloroform and subjeeted to fluorimetrie measurement at 410 ιημ. The procedure is esepcially valuable in cases in which the aluminum value is l o w and iron or phosphates are present. It has been used on samples of iron, steel, a n d ores.
Among the speakers a t the CMRA symposium were (left to r ight) : Paul W . Cornell, Gulf Oil; Edward H. Riddle, Rohm & Haas ; and A. J. Weithj Jr . , American Cyanamid Co.
C&EN REPORTS: Chemical Marke t Research Association
Acrylonitrile Capacity Expected to Hit 190 Million Pounds in 1955
Promising uses predicted for acrylonitrile, butadiene, ethylene, acrylates
NEW YORK.-By 1955, the nation's acrylonitrile capacity will reach approximately 190 million pounds, predicted Archie J. Weith, Jr., of American Cyanamid Co., one of the principal speakers at the all-day meet ing of the Chemical Market Research Association held here on June 4. This sizable capacity stands in sharp contrast to acrylonitrile production of about 17 million pounds in 1950, 30 million in 1951, and 50 million in 1952.
The future will also br ing about a significant change in t he end-use pattern of this material, said Dr . Wei th . By 1955, approximately 6 0 % of U. S. acrylonitrile will be employed in the production of
fibers, 2 5 % for rubber and plastics, and 1 5 % for new uses. In 1950, about 7 5 % of the nation's acrylonitrile "went into rubber and plastics and 2 5 % into fibers, while in 1945 virtually all of acrylonitrile produced was used in the manufacture of nitrile-type rubber.
Although the present sell ing price of acrylonitrile is about 43 cents p e r pound, American Cyanamid has established a price of 31 cents per pound which will take effect when its new acrylonitrile plants goes into commercial operation early in 1954. This is approximately a 3 0 % price cut. "It is very seldom .that new processes can allow such a marked read-
2490 C H E M I C A L A N D E N G I N E E R I N G NEWS