7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

1/45

H

:

, , ()

[ . .156, . 1773, 2004, . 798-850.]

...

...

. ...

... ,

.

P.F.Strawson

, .. Putnam

1. :

E

.

. ,

,

o ,

1

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

2/45

.

,

1.

,

,

,

,

2, -

. , , , , .

, (Russell) (Moore),

(James) (Dewey)

(Peirce),

,

, ,

3.

,

, ,

1 . (MichaelFriedman), Parting of the Ways, Carnap, Cassirer and Heidegger, Open Court, ,2000. , , , , . Simon Critchley, Continental Philosophy, A VeryShort Introduction, Oxford University Press, , 2001, . 17-31. , . , .2 , (Brentano) (Frege). ichael Dummett, Ursprnge der analytischen Philosophie, Suhrkamp,, 1988. , , .3 , , , .

2

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

3/45

, a priori

. ,

,

-

-

.

,

,

17704.

,

, .

,

,

.

,

,

.

(Strawson), (Putnam), (Lear)

(McDowell).

,

. , ,

, ,

,

.

4 , (Frege) (Quine), . Robert Hanna,

Kant and the Foundations of Analytic Philosophy, Clarendon Press, , 2001.

3

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

4/45

.

,

. ,

. ,

. ,

.

.

,

a priori ,

,

. ,

a priori

,

5.

.

, ,

,

,

5 , , a priori . (12/25)-.. , ...(1) [ , - . , E , , 1977-1978 ., 1999.]

4

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

5/45

6,

,

.

.

,

,

, ,

a priori ,

. ,

,

.

.

2. :

;

.

6 , a priori , , . , . a priori , , . , ,

... ( , VI)

5

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

6/45

50, ,

, ,

, (Ryle)

(Austin)7.

,

Individuals [A ] 1959,

,

, ,

.

K,

,

, -. X ,

, 8.

,

.

:

9

,

. ,

7 , , ..,( ), , : O

, . , , , 2003, . 9-39. , , , .8 . Individuals, ssay in Descriptive Metaphysics, Methuen, , 1959, . 9-11. Y , (), , , K. (.), ,A, 1980, . 485-577.9 identification reidentification . . .. . 528-29.

6

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

7/45

10.

,

, (

).

Kant , he Bounds

of Sense, [ ] 1966,

11. O

Individuals, .

,

, , , a priori ,

,

. , ,

a priori

() 12.

, 13,

,

, , ,

14. ,

10 B. , ..11The Bounds of Sense,Methuen, , 1966.12 Individuals,

. B. ryanMagee, Conversation with Peter Strawson, Bryan Magee,Modern British Philosophy, Secker andWarburg, , 1971, . 115-130, 122.13 , Are There A Priori Concepts? 1939 (Proceedings of the AristotelianSociety), J.L. Austin, Philosophical Papers, 3 ., xford University Press,, 1979, . 32-54, 34.

, .14Individuals, .. 40. .

7

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

8/45

,

. , he Bounds of Sense

: A

,

15,

16.

,

Individuals:

...

. ..

o (self-reflexive)

-

- .

,

, , ..

..., ...

17. ,

,

15The Bounds of Sense, .., . 15 44 .16 Magee, .., . 12317The Bounds of Sense, .., . 271-2.

8

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

9/45

.

.

, . :

. 18.

The Bounds of Sense,

.

a priori .

,

.

, ,

. O,

1968,

,

,

.

19.

18 , . 273.19 Stroud, ,

9

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

10/45

,

. ,

,

20. ,

.

modus ponens .

:

(1)

(2) ,

,

(3)

. . arry Stroud, TranscendentalArguments, he Journal of Philosophy . 65, 1968, . 241-256, 245-246, Stroud, Understanding Human Knowledge, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2000,9-25. . , The Goal of TranscendentalArguments, he Synthetic A Priori in Strawsons Kantianism Understanding Human Knowledge,. 203-223 224-245.20 , ,

, , , sub specie aeternitatis ( ). , .. ,

, . , . (VII)

10

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

11/45

, (1) , ,

(2) , ,

:

(2) ( ) ,

,

(2) ( ) ,

:

(3) ( ) 21.

status

(2), (2) (3) ,

, ,

(

). ,

(1)

- -

(2)

(3),

,

.

, 1985, -

,

. ,

, ,

21 Mo , A.W. Moore Conative TranscendentalArguments, Robert Stern (.) Transcendental Arguments, Problems and

Prospects, Oxford University Press, , 2000, . 271-292, 271. ..

11

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

12/45

, 22. ,

, ,

.

,

23. ,

,

,

(idle)24.

, , .

,

22 . P.F. Strawson, Scepticism and Naturalism: Some Varieties, Methuen, , 1985 [ Woodbridge 1983 - . . , ..] , .

. . .

P.F. Strawson, Scruton and Wright on Anti-Realism etc. , Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, .77, 1976, . 15-21. Crispin Wright, Strawson on Anti-Realism, Synthese,. 40, 1979, . 283-299. , , . (. , , ) -, , . . Michael Dummett, Realism, , ruth and Other Enigmas, Duckworth, , 1978, . 145-165.23 , , . , , , , . . Stern,(.) Transcendental Arguments, Problems and Prospects, .. , TheGoal of Transcendental Arguments, he Synthetic A Priori in Strawsons Kantianism, .. Barry Stroud, The Quest for Reality, Subjectivism and the Metaphysics of Colour, Oxford UniversityPress, , 2000.24 . , .. . 82-85.

12

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

13/45

, .

25.

,

, , ,

,

. H

.

, ,

The Bounds of Sense,

, ,

,

.

. ,

'

26.

.

-27

,

. ,

25 . , .. Analysis and Metaphysics, n Introduction to Philosophy[ , ] Oxford University Press, , 1992.26 B. , .., .. , ..,

Analysis and Metaphysics, ..27 -, . Marcel Niquet, Tranzendentale

Argumente: Kant, Strawson und die Aporetik der Detranszendentalisierung, Suhrkamp, 2000.

13

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

14/45

28.

;

, , ,

;

;

,

29

, ,

. ,

-,

,

,

, , , .

28 B. Entity and Identity [ ], Oxford University Press, O, 1997, . 232-243. Analysis and Metaphysics,.., . 56-7, 123-4. . , .J. Glock (ed.) Strawson and Kant, Oxford UniversityPress, O, 2003. - . P. F. Strawson, Kants New Foundations ofMetaphysics, Entity and Identity, .., . 232-243, 232 ( D.Henrich, R.- P.Horstman (.), etaphysik nach Kant, Klett- Gotta, , 1987).29 . homas Nagel, , . . , , , 2000, .16: . . ... , , , , ... . . (., . 21). ,

, , , . . Strawson, ants New Foundation of Metaphysics, .., . 233.

14

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

15/45

.

-

.

3.

30

31.

.

,

,

-

,

, . ,

- (Skolem-Lwenheim)

,

. , - -,

,

.

.

30 . Hilary Putnam,athematics, Matter and Method,Philosophical Papers, .1, 2 . CambridgeUniversity Press, , 1979 (1975), .vii, ind, Language and Reality, Philosophical Papers,.2, Cambridge University Press, , 1975, . vii-xi .31 . . Saul Kripke,Naming and

Necessity, Harvard University Press, , ., 1980.

15

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

16/45

.

.

, ,

.

K, ,

,

.

Kant, -

-,

.

John Locke 1976,

1990 (Conant) Realism with a

Human Face [ ]32. H

Reason Truth and History [ ,

] 1981, Realism

and Reason [ ] 1983 Paul

Carus, The Many Faces of Realism [ ], 198733.

,

. ,

,

.

- ,

(from a Gods eye point of view), -

32 , Hilary Putnam, eaning and the Moral Sciences [ ], Routledge andKegan Paul, , 1978, John Locke, Realism with a Human

Face, Harvard University Press, , ., 1990.33 ilary Putnam, Reason, Truth and History, Cambridge University Press, , 1981, Realismand Reason, Philosophical Papers, . 3, Cambridge University Press, , 1983, he Many

Faces ofRealism, Open Court, , , 1987 [ , .., . , , , 1998].

16

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

17/45

(sub specie aeternitatis) - , ,

, ,

, .

,

.

, ,

, ,

() ' 34.

, .

, -

-

.

,

, ,

-

.

,

, - '

. , ,

, ,

,

34Reason, Truth and History, .., . xi., , .., . 1. ( mind, , ). (absolute conception of reality), , .ernard Williams,Descartes, The Project of Pure nquiry, Penguin, , , 1978,.65-7 .

17

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

18/45

.

,

,

, ,

, . ,

,

.

, ,

.

.

.

-

,

,

,

.

, , , , -

-,

35, ,

.

,

-, .

Reason, Truth and History, 35 , , .

18

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

19/45

, , .

, ,

,

,

36.

, ,

,

, o , .

.

,

(Schulbegriff),

(Weltbegriff),

K 37.

, ,

.

o . ,

,

,

.

36 . Curtis Brown, Internal Realism: Transcendental Idealism?, Peter French,Theodore Uehling, Howard Robinson (.), Realism and Antirealism, Midwest Studies in PhilosophyXII, University of Minnesota Press, , 1988, . 145-155.37 , , , . (conceptus cosmicus), , , , . (teleologia rationishumanae) , (838/866 839/867).

19

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

20/45

,

,

,

(Quine) .

,

.

38. K

,

(Derrida), (Foucault),

.

,

.

.

, , ,

. -

, ,

-

,

.

-

- 39. K

38 ., , Why Reason Cant Be Naturalized Realism and Reason, .., . 229-247,Representation and Reality , The MIT Press, , ., 1988.39 , .., . xxxvi. - . . Hilary Putnam, The Collapse ofthe Fact-Value Dichotomy, arvard University Press, , ,, 2002,thics Without Ontology,

20

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

21/45

,

, , -

40.

, , -

,

. ,

,

,

.

, , ,

K- A (Apel) (Habermas),

, ,

.

,

, ,

41.

, ,

,

. ,

, o , -

, -

42.

arvard University Press, , ,, 2004.40 , .., . xxxvii.41 (Henrich). , . 53-82, 67-69.42 , , John Dewey, 1994, The

Journal of Philosophy Sense, Nonsense and the Senses, . 91, .445-517,

21

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

22/45

,

,

,

. ,

, ,

,

.

,

,

,

, ,

, , .

, (interface)

,

.

,

,

,

,

.

, Sense

and Sensibilia43.

,

,

.

, ,

Words andLife, Harvard University Press, , ., 1990. , , . , , .., . xv-xxxii, Claudine Tiercelin,Hilary Putnam,lhritage pragmatiste, Presses Universitaires de France, , 2002.

43 . J.L.Austin, Sense and Sensibilia, Oxford University Press, , 1962

22

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

23/45

(second

naivet),

, , -

. -

,

, ,

.

. O ,

. O 44

, o ,

,

. ,

,

.

o Reason, Truth and History,

,

.

. ,

;

,

, ;

44 . .3.

23

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

24/45

-

,

.

4.

. ,

,

,

45. ,

:

.

, , ,

. , ,

' 46.

,

. Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus

45 , ., , , P.M.S.Hacker, Insight and Illusion, Clarendon Press, , 1972, Leslie Stevenson, The Metaphysics of

Experience, Clarendon Press, , 1982, Stylianos Virvidakis, Transcendental Arguments,Transcendental Idealism and Scepticism ( ), Princeton University, 1984 .46 , , ' .... , , : , ( ) , , - L.Wittgenstein,Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus, . . , . 7-8, - 1971,. 183-4. . 6.44 7, . 270-271.

24

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

25/45

.

,

( ) ,

.

Tractatus ,

,

. , , ,

, - -,

, , ,

, .

, , ,

.

. , -

a priori

. ,

,

,

, ,

, ,

, , .

, ,

, (bersicht)

47. ' ,

47 . L. Wittgenstein, , . . , , ,1977, 90: ... , ..

25

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

26/45

- .

.

. ,

,

, . ,

, - ,

48.

,

49.

,

,

, -,

.

,

,

,

. ,

, ,

48 . Leslie Stevenson, Wittgensteins Transcendental Deduction and Kants Private Language Argu-ment, Kant-Studien, . 73, 1982, . 321-337, Virvidakis, Transcendental Arguments,Transcen-dental Idealism and Scepticism, .. B. (5) , 49 , . , O

", , , , A, 1988, . 122-136.

26

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

27/45

-

, .

,

,

, , 50,

. ,

,

, ,

, .

,

.

,

, ,

.

, , -

. ,

, , , ,

- , -,

, ,

, ,

-

, 51.

50 .51 , .Gerold Prauss, Erscheinung bei Kant, Walter De Gruyter, , 1971, ant und das Problem der

Dinge an Sich, Bouvier, , 1974 enry Allison, Kants Transcendental Idealism, An

27

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

28/45

,

52. ,

,

. ,

,

a priori

, ,

. ,

(Williams) ,

53

. ,

,

Interpretation and Defense, 2 ., ale University Press, , 2004. , , . ., , , , , (236/295 260/315). ,

.52 Strawson . , , . B. P.F. Strawson, Sensibility and Understanding, and the Doctrine ofSynthesis: Comments on Henrich and Guyer, Eckart Frster, (.), Kants Transcendental

Deductions, Stanford University Press, 1989, , 69-77, 73.53 H . B. Jonathan Lear, Leavingthe World Alone, he Journal of Philosophy . 79, 1982, . 382-403 [A . X., , . 16/2, 1998, . 201-227] TheDisappearing We, Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society,. . 58, 1984, . 219-258 [ , . . , . 13/1, 1994], TranscendentalAnthropology, Philip Pettit, John McDowell, (.), Subject, Thought and Context, ClarendonPress, , 1986, . 267-298. Jonathan Lear,Open Minded, Harvard University Press, , ., 1998, . 247-300. , . Bernard Williams, Wittgenstein and Idealism, Geoffrey Vesey(), Understanding Wittgenstein, Macmillan, , 1976, , oral Luck, Cambridge University Press, K, 1981, .144-163. . Virvidakis, ranscendental Arguments, Transcendental Idelalism and Scepticism, .. .152-257 Wittgenstein and the Development of Transcendental Philosophy, R. Haller & J. Brandl (.),Wittgenstein; Towards a Re-Evaluation, Proceedings of the 14th Wittgenstein-Symposium: CentenaryCelebration, 13th to 20th August 1989, Hlder-Pichler-Tempsky Verlag, K ,1990, . 144-146.

28

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

29/45

.

. , ,

a priori,

, ,

. , ,

, ,

,

,

, , 54.

status ,

;

, ,

,

;

, ,

-

,

55.

,

56,

54 L. Wittgenstein, On Certainty / Uber Gewissheit, . G.E.M. Anscombe, G.H. von Wright, .Denis Paul, G.E.M. Anscombe, Blackwell, , 1974. , status , .. , ,

, a priori, . (. 111,211, 234, 97-98). , , a priori. , . . Strawson,ants New Foundation of Metaphysics, .., . 234-235.55 Lear, , .., .225.56 our mindedness, being minded as we are, .

29

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

30/45

, , ,

, , ,

57:

,

.

,

.

, '

,

. ,

, '

.

58.

, :

, ,

, 59. Tractatus,

,

,

. ,

,

, , ,

60, ,

61.

, -

57 Lear, ranscendental Anthropology, .., .298.58 Lear, , .., . 206-207.59 Lear, , .. 71-73.60 Wittgenstein, , .. ( ), 241.61 . Williams, Wittgenstein and Idealism, .. . 146-147.

30

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

31/45

.

:

, 62.

,

, ( ),

,

..

H

.

, , , ,

,

,

63. ,

,

,

64.

, -

,

,

62 Lear, , .., . 20763 Lear, , .., . 214. Donald Davidson, Proceedings and

Addresses of the American Philosophical Association, . 67, 1973/4, . 5-20, Donald Davidson, Inquiries into Truth and Interpretation, Clarendon Press, , 1984, . 183-198[ , .. ., , . 11/1,O 1992, .13-29]. , , , . . Strawson, ants New Foundation of Metaphysics, .., . 233-234, Stelios Virvidakis, The Transcendental Strategy Against Scepticism and Relativism, Skepsis 3 (1992):33-45.64 Lear, , .. . 52: .

31

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

32/45

65.

status

,

,

,

,

.

, (resolute), e

Tractatus66, , , (Diamond)

,

. , ,

. ,

,

67.

, ,

,

65 , , , . A.W.Moore, Points of View, Clarendon Press, 1996, Michael Forster,Wittgenstein on the Arbitrariness of Grammar, Princeton University Press, , 2004. . Strawson, Kants New Foundation of Metaphysics, .., 234-35. Graham Bird, Beyond the Limits of Thought,Cambridge University Press, , 1995, Mark Sacks, The World We Found, The Limits ofOntological Talk, Duckworth, , 1989. . , , Barry Stroud, The Allure of Idealism, Proceedings of the

Aristotelian Society, . . 58, 1984, [ , . ., . 13/1, 1994, . 61-77].66 . lice Crary, Rupert Reed (.), he New Wittgenstein, Routledge, , 2000. , Ludwig Wittgenstein, Cogito, . 1, 2004, .116-117. , , , Tractatus . , , Tractatus,

, . , ,E , , 1995. . .67 . Stroud, , ...

32

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

33/45

, .

-

,

.

5.

-

.

,

68

.

. ,

.

.

80, M,

,

. ,

,

,

,

69.

M ,

68 , , - . , (quietism) , , . ,. Joachim Schulte, Wittgensteins Quietism, Uwe Meixner (.), Metaphysik in

postmetapysischen Zeitalter, bv&htp, , 2001, . 37-50.69 , . Lewis White Beck, Kants Strategy, , Essays on Kant and Hume, Yale University Press, ,1978, . 3-19.

33

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

34/45

, ,

.

, (Wright)

,

.

, :

, .

,

.

, ,

70.

,

, ,

-

,

[- ].

, , :

.

.

70 B. J.McDowell, Anti-Realism and the Epistemology of Understanding, erman Parret, JacquesBouveresse (.), Meaning and Understanding, Walter de Gruyter, , 1981, .225-248, , Meaning, Knowledge and Reality, Harvard UniversityPress, K, ., 1998, .314-343, 342. Wittgenstein on Following a Rule, Synthese, .58,1984, . 325-363, , Mind, Value and Reality, HarvardUniversity Press, K, ., 1998, .221-262,

, , [Wittgenstein , .. ., , .13/2-3,- 1995, . 175-214.]

34

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

35/45

71.

,

(Kripke)

72.

,

,

,

. , ,

73.

, ind and World[

] 199474.

. ,

,

.

, ,

71 , . 342-343.72 Wittgenstein on Following a Rule, Synthese, .58, 1984, . 325-363, , Mind, Value and Reality, Harvard University Press, K, ., 1998,.221-262, [ Wittgenstein ,.. ., , .13/2-3, - 1995, . 175-214.], . , Wittgenstein , , .13/2-3, . 137-173.73 McDowell, Wittgenstein on Following a Rule, .., 201.74 John McDowell,Mind and World, Harvard University Press, , . 1994.

35

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

36/45

(space of reasons) ,

,

.

, ,

,

.

-

(Sellars)75. ,

,

.

, ,

. ,

. , ,

.

, ,

,

. ,

,

, ,

,

.

75 . Wilfrid Sellars, Empiricism and the Philosophy of Mind, (yth of the Given). Herbert Feigl &Michael Scriven (.)Minnesota Studies in the Philosophy of Science, .1,: University of MinnesotaPress, , 1956, Sellars, Science, Perception and

Reality, Routledge and Kegan Paul, , 1963 Ridgeview, , 1991. , , (Harvard University Press, , ., 1997).O .

36

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

37/45

76.

,

, ,

.

.

,

. , ,

,

,

.

77.

,

Mind and World,

, ,

, mpiricism and the

Philosophy of Mind78.

76 Mind and World, ., X , McDowell , . 19/1, 2001, . 87-106.77 Mind and World, . ,Pascal Engel, L'espace des raisons est-il sans limites?, ..pel, J.Barnes et al., Un sicle de

philosophie, Gallimard, , 2000, . 231-176, Richard Bernstein, McDowells DomesticatedHegelianism, Michael Friedman, Exorcizing the Philosophical Tradition, icholas Smith (.)

Reading McDowell, .., 9-24, 25- 57 Sally Sedgwick, cDowell's Hegelianism, EuropeanJournal of Philosophy, .5:1, 1997, . 21-38, Andrew Bowie, John McDowell's Mind and Worldand Early Romantic Epistemology,Revue Internationale de Philosophie, . 3, 1996, . 515-554. , . , .. . , , , , (. ).78 . John McDowell, , Having the World in View: Sellars, Kant and Intentionality, The Journal of

Philosophy, . 95, 1998, . 431-491.

37

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

38/45

(Brandom)

, , 79.

.

.

, , -

.

, ,

, , ,

, ,

Science andMetaphysics80. -

, ,

, ,

,

.

, , o

, ,

, .

( ) -

:

(, ,

),

.

79 , , . JohnMcDowell, , . ., , . 21/1, . 65-90,Robert Brandom, K : E, , . . , , . 21/1, .91-112, , Sellars, , . 21/1, 45-64. .80 . W. Sellars, Science and Metaphysics, Variations on Kantian Themes, Routledge and Kegan Paul,

, 1967.

38

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

39/45

.

,

.

,

.

,

.

,

, .

. ,

,

.

,

.

.81

,

. ,

,

81McDowell, , .., . 85-86. , , (. .23) - Empiricism and thePhilosophy of Mind, . Twentieth Century TranscendentalArguments: A Neglected Option? ( A- 2003). , . Stelios Virvidakis, n McDowells Conception of the Transcendental, Teorema.

39

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

40/45

82. B,

M, ,

,

, '

.

.

, "

",

:" "83. , M

, Mind and World, -

,

.

, ,

. , , "

"

,

.

, .

,

,

82 . random, K , .., , , R.Brandom,Articulating Reasons: An Introduction to Inferentialism, Harvard University Press, , .,2000.83 ,K , E , (51 /75).

40

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

41/45

. ,

a priori

,

a priori .

,

,

,

.84. ,

, -

(reminders) , , , ,

. , , ,

,

85.

,

, 86.

, ,

, ( Mind and

World) ,

,

87,

.

84 . John McDowell,Replies to Commentators (Brandom, Collins, Peacocke, Rorty, Wright), Philosophy and

Phenomenological Research . 57, 1997, . 403-431.85 . Wittgenstein, , .., 309. Mind and World, Jonathan Weinberg, "John McDowell, Mind and World," Nous, . 32:2, 1998, . 247-264, ,, aximilian de Gaynesford, John McDowell, Polity Press,, 2004.86 cDowell,ind and World, .. . 158-159.87 cDowell, Having the World in View: Sellars, Kant and Intentionality, .446, 469.

41

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

42/45

.

, , (from

sideways on),

, 88.

,

.

6. -

,

:

)

,

,

50.

)

-

. ,

-

.

)

,

,

-

. 88 Tractatus. (., . 66).

42

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

43/45

-

.

) ,

, ,

,

,

-

, , ,

,

.

) , -

,

,

,

.

,

,

. , ,

, .

, ,

. ,

,

89.

89 . , ..., ., et.al., , , 2001, antian Constructivism in

43

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

44/45

,

.

.

,

,

.

. , , ,

.

, . ,

,

.

.

,

K ,

, ,

. ,

,

,

Moral Theory in J.Rawls, Collected Papers, (. Samuel Freeman), Harvard University Press,, ., 1999, .303 358 -.

44

7/30/2019 46614466-O-------

45/45

,

,

90.

45