Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This...
Transcript of Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This...
![Page 1: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Neutrinos Beyond the νStandard Model
Belén GavelaUniversidad Autónoma de Madrid and IFT
![Page 2: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
BeyondStandardModel because
1) Experimental evidence for new particle physics:
*** Neutrino masses *** Dark matter ** Matter-antimatter asymmetry
2) SM fine-tunings/uneasiness
![Page 3: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
We ~understand ordinary particles= excitations over the vacuum
We DO NOT understand the vacuum = state of lowest energy:
SU(3) x SU(2) x U(1) x classical gravity
![Page 4: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
We ~understand ordinary particles= excitations over the vacuum
We DO NOT understand the vacuum = state of lowest energy:
•The gravity vacuum: cosmological cte. Λ , Λ ∼ 10−123 ΜPlanck
* The QCD vacuum : Strong CP problem, θQCD <10-10
* The electroweak vacuum: Higgs-mass, v.e.v.~O (100) GeV
SU(3) x SU(2) x U(1) x classical gravity
4
_
![Page 5: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
We ~understand ordinary particles= excitations over the vacuum
We DO NOT understand the vacuum = state of lowest energy:
•The gravity vacuum: cosmological cte. Λ , Λ ∼ 10−123 ΜPlanck
* The QCD vacuum : Strong CP problem, θQCD <10-10
* The electroweak vacuum: Higgs-mass, v.e.v.~O (100) GeV
SU(3) x SU(2) x U(1) x classical gravity
The Higgs excitation has the quantum numbers of the EW vacuum
4
_
![Page 6: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
BSM because
1) Experimental evidence for new particle physics:
*** Neutrino masses *** Dark matter ** Matter-antimatter asymmetry
2) SM fine-tunings/uneasiness, i.e. in electroweak:
*** Hierarchy problem *** Flavour puzzle
![Page 7: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
0.8 0.5 ?(<10º) -0.4 0.5 -0.7
-0.4 0.5 +0.7
VPMNS =
~1 λ λ3
λ ~1 λ2
λ3 λ2 ~1
VCKM = λ~0.2
Leptons
Quarks
More wood for the Flavour Puzzle
Why so different?
![Page 8: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
0.8 0.5 ?(<10º) -0.4 0.5 -0.7
-0.4 0.5 +0.7
VPMNS =
~1 λ λ3
λ ~1 λ2
λ3 λ2 ~1
VCKM = λ~0.2
Leptons
Quarks
More wood for the Flavour Puzzle
Maybe because of Majorana neutrinos?
![Page 9: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Dirac o Majorana ?
•The only thing we have really understood in particle physics is the gauge principle
•SU(3)xSU(2)xU(1) gauge allow Majorana masses….
Lepton number was an accidental symmetry of the SM:unless you impose it by hand, Majorana masses will be there
Anyway, it is for experiment to decide
![Page 10: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Main physics goals in ν physics
• To determine the absolute scale of masses
• To determine whether they are Majorana
• To discover Leptonic CP-violation
Let us go for those discoveries !
![Page 11: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Can we foresee how to go beyond?
![Page 12: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Neutrino masses indicate new physics beyond the SM
Maybe new physics could appear also in neutrino couplings ?
![Page 13: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Neutrino masses indicate new physics beyond the SM
Maybe new physics could appear also in neutrino couplings ?
?
![Page 14: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
NSI = non-standard neutrino interactions
![Page 15: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Λ > v
![Page 16: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Two topics
• “Seesaw NSI” and the flavour puzzle
• “Why not” NSI
![Page 17: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
How to go about it model-independent ?….
Effective field theory
Recall Fermi’s times,
GF (eL γµ νe) (n γµ p)
U(1)em gauge invariant
--
n
p
νe
e
![Page 18: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
How to go about it model-independent ?….
Effective field theory
Glashow, Weinberg, Salam times:
U(1)em gauge invariant
GF
![Page 19: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
How to go about it model-independent ?….
Effective field theory
Glashow, Weinberg, Salam era:
SU(2) xU(1)em gauge invariant
(Lα γµ Lα) (QLβ γµQβ)
Qβ
Qβ
--
Mediator decomposition
![Page 20: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
In the spirit of Fermi,
Can we build Standard Model operators that give mass to the neutrinos
and/or new flavoured couplings ?
YES!
ν masses and couplings beyond the SM
![Page 21: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
L= Llow-energy + Od=5 + Od=6 +…… M M2
If new physics scale M > v
![Page 22: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
L= LSU(3)xSU(2)xU(1) + Od=5 + Od=6 +…… M M2
If new physics scale M > v
![Page 23: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Dimension 5 operator:
It’s unique → very special role of ν masses:lowest-order effect of higher energy physics
→ λ/M (L L H H) λv/M (νν) 2
Od=5
ν masses beyond the SM
The Weinberg operator
![Page 24: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Dimension 5 operator:
It’s unique → very special role of ν masses:lowest-order effect of higher energy physics
→ λ/M (L L H H) λv/M (νν) 2
Od=5
ν masses beyond the SM
This mass term violates lepton number (B-L) → Majorana neutrinos
The Weinberg operator
![Page 25: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Dimension 5 operator:
It’s unique → very special role of ν masses:lowest-order effect of higher energy physics
→ λ/M (L L H H) λv/M (νν) 2
Od=5
ν masses beyond the SM
This mass term violates lepton number (B-L) → Majorana neutrinos
is common to all models of Majorana νs Od=5
The Weinberg operator
![Page 26: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
New Standard Model νSM ?
LνSM = LSM + cd=5 Od=5 + …… ΛLN
![Page 27: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
3 generic types (Ma)
δL=cd=5 Od=5
ν masses beyond the SM : tree level
![Page 28: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
2 x 2 = 1 + 32 x 2 = 1 + 3
ν masses beyond the SM : tree level
![Page 29: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
2 x 2 = 1 + 32 x 2 = 1 + 3
ν masses beyond the SM : tree level
![Page 30: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
mν ~ v2 cd=5 = v2 YN YN /MN
T
Fermionic Singlet Seesaw ( or type I)
2 x 2 = 1 + 3
ν masses beyond the SM : tree level
![Page 31: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
mν ~ v2 cd=5 = v2 YN YN /MN
T
Fermionic Singlet Seesaw ( or type I)
2 x 2 = 1 + 3
Which allows YN~1 --> M~MGut
YN~10-6 --> M~TeV
ν masses beyond the SM : tree level
![Page 32: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
ν masses beyond the SM : tree level
2 x 2 = 1 + 3
![Page 33: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
ΔΝ Σ
The Seesaw models
Y YY
YNT 1 YΝ
MN
__mν~ v2
YΔ µ
MΔ2
__mν~ v2
YΣT 1 YΣ
MΣ
__mν~ v2
Y Yµ
![Page 34: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
ΔΝ Σ
The Seesaw models
Heavy fermion singlet NR Minkowski, Gell-Mann, Ramond, Slansky, Yanagida, Glashow, Mohapatra, Senjanovic
Heavy scalar triplet ΔMagg, Wetterich, Lazarides, Shafi, Mohapatra, Senjanovic, Schecter, Valle
Heavy fermion triplet ΣRMa, Roy, Senjanovic, Hambye et al., …
Y YY
Y Yµ
![Page 35: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
Which are the new exotic couplings,
that is, d=6 operators, in Seesaws?
Those fields, NR , Δ, ΣR, would mediate other processes too….
![Page 36: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
(Abada, Biggio, Bonnet, Hambye, M.B.G.)
(type I)
(type III)
(type II)
![Page 37: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
Y Y M
+2Cd=6~
(type I)
(type III)
(type II)
(Abada, Biggio, Bonnet, Hambye, M.B.G.)
NSI
![Page 38: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
In all fermionic seesaws
the neutrino mass matrix is larger than 3x3
3 x 3
The complete theory of ν masses is unitary.
All fermionic Seesaws exhibit non-unitary mixing
Non-unitariry NSI
![Page 39: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
N
νl
ν
i.e.
at low energies
NSI ε
All fermionic Seesaws exhibit non-unitary mixing
N =(1 + ε ) UPMNS
![Page 40: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
Antusch, Biggio, Fdez-Martinez, Lopez-Pavon, MBG
![Page 41: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
Antusch, Biggio, Fdez-Martinez, Lopez-Pavon, MBG
![Page 42: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
….. because non-unitarity affects simultaneously:
matter propagation + production and detection (= rare decays…)
Antusch, Biggio, Fdez-Martinez, Lopez-Pavon, MBG
![Page 43: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
Y Y M
+2
Exotic leptonExotic lepton couplings couplings
Cd=6~
(type I)
(type III)
(type II)
(Abada, Biggio, Bonnet, Hambye, M.B.G.)
![Page 44: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
For all scalar and fermionic Seesaw models, present bounds:
or stronger
![Page 45: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/45.jpg)
Observable effects?
Obviously requires scale near the TeV
![Page 46: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/46.jpg)
M~1 TeV is suggested by electroweak hierarchy problem
NH
H
H
Δ
Σ
L
L
(Vissani, Casas et al., Schmaltz)
(Abada, Biggio, Bonnet, Hambye, M.B.G.)
![Page 47: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/47.jpg)
Could d=6 be stronger than d=5 ?
* Two independent scales in d=5, d=6 may result from asymmetry principle: lepton number Cirigliano et al; Kersten,Smirnov; Abada et al
* d=5 requires to violate lepton number * d=6 does not violate any symmetry
Λ5~ΛLN >> Λ6 ~ ΛLFV ~ TeV
![Page 48: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/48.jpg)
ΛLN >> ΛLF~TeV ?
There is a sensible physics motivation:
Origin of lepton/quark flavour violation linked/close to theEW scale
(Effective) Lepton number breaking scale higher andresponsible for the gap between ν and other fermion
Cirigliano, et al
flavour
fl ~
![Page 49: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/49.jpg)
Seesaw mechanism
vs
Minimal Flavour Violation
T. Hambye, D. Hernández, P. Hernández, MBG
![Page 50: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/50.jpg)
•Flavour data (i.e. B physics) consistent with all flavour physics coming from Yukawa
Minimal Flavour violation (MFV)
in BSM
![Page 51: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/51.jpg)
•Flavour data (i.e. B physics) consistent with all flavour physics coming from Yukawa
Minimal Flavour violation (MFV)
in BSM
L= LSM + cd=6 Od=6 +……
It is very predictive for quarks: Od=6 ~ Qα Qβ Qγ Qδ
_ _
i.e. Yαβ Yγδ
Cd=6 Od=6 ~ Qα Qβ Qγ Qδ
~Λflavour
+
2
![Page 52: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/52.jpg)
WHY MFV?
G. Isidori, Y. Nir, G. Perez, 1002.0900
FOR QUARKS
WITHOUT MFV: ~ 102 TeV WITH MFV: ~ TeV >>
![Page 53: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/53.jpg)
MFVregion
Smith
SM
Smith
![Page 54: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/54.jpg)
L=
LSM
+
What happens in the presence of neutrino masses?Cirigliano, Isidori, Grinstein, Wise
ΛLN Λflavour
Delicate:
* Majorana masses are model dependent : cd=5(Ye,?), cd=6(Ye,?)
* Requires to separate lepton number from flavour origin
![Page 55: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/55.jpg)
An unsuccessful model: simplest type I
N
mν
Hambye, Hernandez2, Gavela
![Page 56: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/56.jpg)
A successful model: Scalar-triplet Seesaw (type II)
Δ
MΔ2
µΔ
YΔ
L L
![Page 57: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/57.jpg)
A successful model: Scalar-triplet Seesaw (type II)
Δ
MΔ2
µΔ
YΔ
ΔYΔ
L LYΔ
Λfl = MΔ
ΛLN = MΔ2 / µΔ
L L
![Page 58: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/58.jpg)
mν∼
L L
* Neutrino masses OK* Measurable flavour OK* Predictivity OK
Correlations among weak processes, i.e. µ eγ /τ eγ /τ µγ
![Page 59: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/59.jpg)
Successful fermionic-mediated Seesaws:
One more mediator, one more scale…. i.e. Inverse seesaws
0 YNT v
YN v ΜΝ
Lm =Instead of
![Page 60: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/60.jpg)
Successful fermionic-mediated Seesaws:
One more mediator, one more scale…. i.e. Inverse seesaws
00
00
![Page 61: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/61.jpg)
Successful fermionic-mediated Seesaws:
One more mediator, one more scale…. i.e. Inverse seesaws
00
00
LeLµ
LτNR NR
´
i j
![Page 62: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/62.jpg)
Successful fermionic-mediated Seesaws:
One more mediator, one more scale…. i.e. Inverse seesaws
00
00
Lepton number conserved
U(1)
Λfl = Λ ΛLN = ∞
Y Y Λ
+2Cd=6~
![Page 63: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/63.jpg)
Successful fermionic-mediated Seesaw:
One more mediator, one more scale…. i.e. Inverse seesaws
Lepton number violated by any of those 3 entries
Wyler,Wolfenstein; Mohapatra,Valle, Branco,Grimus,Lavoura,Malinsky, Romao…
![Page 64: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/64.jpg)
Successful fermionic-mediated Seesaw:
One more mediator, one more scale…. i.e. Inverse seesaws
Lepton number violated by any of those 3 entries
Wyler,Wolfenstein; Mohapatra,Valle, Branco,Grimus,Lavoura,Malinsky, Romao…
Λ may be ~ TeV and Ys ~1, and be ok with mν
![Page 65: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/65.jpg)
Case: Three light active families + one NR + one NR ́
µ´ is irrelevant (at tree-level)
Hambye, Hernandez2, B.G. 09
-- one massless neutrino -- just one low-energy Majorana phase arguably the simplest model of neutrino mass
![Page 66: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/66.jpg)
Case: Three light active families + one NR + one NR ́
µ´ is irrelevant (at tree-level)
Hambye, Hernandez2, B.G. 09
*Yukawas are completely determined from UPMNS+mν, except for anormalization + a degeneracy in the Majorana phase
Hambye, Hernandez2, B.G. 09
![Page 67: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/67.jpg)
Case: Three light active families + one NR + one NR ́
µ´ is irrelevant (at tree-level)
Hambye, Hernandez2, B.G. 09
*Yukawas are completely determined from UPMNS+mν, except for anormalization + a degeneracy in the Majorana phase
Hambye, Hernandez2, B.G. 09
i.e.
Normal hierarchy
![Page 68: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/68.jpg)
![Page 69: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/69.jpg)
α
α
θ13
![Page 70: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/70.jpg)
Degeneracy in the Majorana phase α
![Page 71: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/71.jpg)
*Leptogenesis OK for small mass splittings between theright handed (heavy) neutrinos (Blanchet, Hambye, Josse-Michaux 09)
*
(Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing)
This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM:
![Page 72: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/72.jpg)
(Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)
Y2 v2/M2
θ13
Y2 v2/M2 θ13 N~UPMNS + Y+Y v2/M2
![Page 73: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/73.jpg)
νµ --> ντ
![Page 74: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/74.jpg)
i.e.
Normal hierarchy
![Page 75: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/75.jpg)
θ13α
Y2 v2/M2
![Page 76: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/76.jpg)
MINSIS could also improve by two ordersof magnitude the search for light steriles coupled to the heavier families
… but this is another story
![Page 77: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/77.jpg)
“Why not” NSIs
(Non-Seesaw NSIs)
![Page 78: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/78.jpg)
NSNIS PROPAGATING IN MATTER i.e., purely matter NSI?
NSI
![Page 79: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/79.jpg)
NSNIS PROPAGATING IN MATTER i.e., purely matter NSI?
(q γµ q)-NSI
q q
![Page 80: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/80.jpg)
BOUNDS
C. Biggio, M. Blennow, E. Fdez-Mtnez, 0907.0097
*Absolute maxima:
from ν scattering in NuTevand in CHARM II
![Page 81: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/81.jpg)
BOUNDS
C. Biggio, M. Blennow, E. Fdez-Mtnez, 0907.0097
*Absolute maxima:
•Also from atmospheric data, unless cancellations among epsilons:
|εµτ| < 5 10−2
Fornengo, Maltoni, Tomás-Bayo, Valle,hep-ph 0108043
from ν scattering in NuTevand in CHARM II
![Page 82: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/82.jpg)
NSI -------------------------->Dangerous four charged lepton couplings
SU(2) x U(1) gauge invariance
Potential Trouble:
![Page 83: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/83.jpg)
NSI -------------------------->Dangerous four charged lepton couplings
SU(2) x U(1) gauge invariance
Potential Trouble:
![Page 84: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/84.jpg)
Λ > v
The new physics has to CONTAIN the SM
The new couplings MUST have a SU(3)xSU(2) xU(1) gauge invariant formulation
![Page 85: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/85.jpg)
![Page 86: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/86.jpg)
Systematical analysis
ONSI =
(Berezhiani, Rossi)
(Davidson, Kuypers)
τ
τ
![Page 87: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/87.jpg)
Systematical analysis
ONSI =
(Berezhiani, Rossi)
(Davidson, Kuypers)
τ
τBut it also produces τ --> µ νeνe !And µ --> e ντνe
-εµτ < 3 10−2
Fdez-Martinez
-
![Page 88: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/88.jpg)
Systematical analysis
But it illustrates the theoretical prize to pay for large But it illustrates the theoretical prize to pay for large NSI NSI (Antusch, Baunman, Fdez-Martinez; D. Hernandez, Ota, Winter + MBG )
![Page 89: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/89.jpg)
Finally, gauge invariance implies:
•From d=6 ops.: εµτ < 3 10−2
•Or you avoid alltogether d=6 ops. combining d=8 ones with a very strong -unbelievable- fine-tuning ! (check
cancellantions in our table if you have the stomach for it)
![Page 90: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/90.jpg)
Would give even stronger bounds…
![Page 91: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/91.jpg)
Davidson+Kuypers
Constraints are then stronger and odds even worse:
![Page 92: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/92.jpg)
SEVERELY CONSTRAINED: S. Antusch, J. P. Baumann, E. Fdez-Mtnez; 0807.1003F. Cuypers, S. Davidson; hep-ph/ 9609487
![Page 93: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/93.jpg)
S
Davidson+Kuypers….. Antusch,Baumann, Fdez.-Martinezz
•This S is disconnected from the seesawmechanism… although connected toradiatively generated masses -Zee model-
•d=6 NSI are very very constrained.
εµτ < 2 10−3
![Page 94: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/94.jpg)
(Antusch, Baunman, Fdez-Martinez; D. Hernandez, Ota, Winter + MBG )
![Page 95: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/95.jpg)
(Antusch, Baunman, Fdez-Martinez; D. Hernandez, Ota, Winter + MBG )
Require at least 2 new fields ( and unrelated to seesaw)
![Page 96: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/96.jpg)
(Antusch, Baunman, Fdez-Martinez; D. Hernandez, Ota, Winter + MBG )
TERRIBLY COMPLICATED
![Page 97: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/97.jpg)
D. Hernandez, Ota, Winter + MBG
Complete list of d=8 operators and their mediators
![Page 98: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/98.jpg)
![Page 99: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/99.jpg)
MINOS: neutrino/antineutrino difference (?) in νµ disappearance ??
![Page 100: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/100.jpg)
Could MINOS effect, if ever it becomes a signal (which is NOT), be NSI?
•Certainly not NSI related to non-unitarity (ie. Seesaw related), as the bounds are too strong
*What about a Why Not” NSI, i.e. purely matter NSI?
![Page 101: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/101.jpg)
ντ ντ
ντ νµ-ντ νµ
-
Could MINOS effect, if ever it becomes a signal (which is NOT), be matter NSI?
![Page 102: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/102.jpg)
ντ ντ
ντ νµ-ντ νµ
-
Could MINOS effect, if ever it becomes a signal (which is NOT), be matter NSI?
Two weeks ago: Mann et al.: arXiv:1006.5720
εµτ
![Page 103: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/103.jpg)
ντ ντ
Could MINOS effect, if ever it becomes a signal (which is NOT), be matter NSI?
Two weeks ago: Mann et al.: εµτ arXiv:1006.5720
εµτ εµτ
εµτ
![Page 104: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/104.jpg)
εµτ = -They claim
C. Biggio, M. Blennow, E. Fdez-Mtnez, 0907.0097
To be compared with the bounds:
![Page 105: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/105.jpg)
εµτ = -They claim
C. Biggio, M. Blennow, E. Fdez-Mtnez, 0907.0097
To be compared with the bounds:
Plausible? NO! : gauge invariance -> εµτ < 3 10-2 from d=6,
or d=8 ops. with ad hoc cancellat.
![Page 106: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/106.jpg)
This morning: Kopp, Machado,Parke
“Could it be εµτ matter NSI?” arXiv:0076594
* It is a similar analysis, but taking into account both εµτ and εττ and performing a simulation of MINOS event spectrum:
|εµτ| =They claim
(Signs can be changed, eightfold degeneracy)
* Discovery at NOνA in less than one nominal year
* They acknowledge that gauge invariance disfavours d=6 ops., and d=8 ops. unlikely:
![Page 107: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/107.jpg)
This morning: Kopp, Machado,Parke
“Could it be εµτ matter NSI?” arXiv:0076594
* It is a similar analysis, but taking into account both εµτ and εττ and performing a simulation of MINOS event spectrum:
|εµτ| =They claim
(Signs can be changed, eightfold degeneracy)
* Discovery at NOνA in less than one nominal year
* They acknowledge that gauge invariance disfavours d=6 ops., and d=8 ops. unlikely:
![Page 108: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/108.jpg)
This morning: Kopp, Machado,Parke
“Could it be εµτ matter NSI?” arXiv:0076594
* It is a similar analysis, but taking into account both εµτ and εττ and performing a simulation of MINOS event spectrum:
|εµτ| =They claim
(Signs can be changed, eightfold degeneracy)
* Discovery at NOνA in less than one nominal year
* They acknowledge that gauge invariance disfavours d=6 ops., and d=8 ops. unlikely:
UNBELIEVABLE MODEL OF NEW PHYSICS
![Page 109: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/109.jpg)
My conclusion:
a νµ/νµdifference in MINOS
based on matter νµ <--> ντ NSI (Λ > v)
is terribly unlikely
because of gauge invariance
-
![Page 110: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/110.jpg)
Anyway, at maximum εµτ < 0.33 AND Atmospheric indicate < 5 10-2 unless brutal cancellations among different ε
Why everybody forgets atmospherics?
![Page 111: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/111.jpg)
What about steriles lighter than the electroweak scale, with matter effects, for the MINOS “would-be” effect?
Steriles lighter than MW evade non-unitarity bounds and some of the pure matter NSI bounds
Ie. Ann Nelson and collab.; light steriles, gauged B-L
νsterileνsterile
More promising ? :
Engelhardt, Nelson and Walsh, arXiv:1002.4452
![Page 112: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/112.jpg)
All this underlies the importance
of searching for νµ <--> ντ transitions
in general (i.e. at near detectors)
![Page 113: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/113.jpg)
And light steriles for the new MiniBoone data?
•Interesting: Same L/E than LSND, but different L and E --> different backgrounds
CP in vacuum?:CP does not depend on L/E if matter effects negligible, but differs for neutrinos and antineutrinos
seems difficult (arXiv:0906.1997 and arXiv:0705.0107) but.. ?
![Page 114: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/114.jpg)
And light steriles for the new MiniBoone data?
•Interesting: Same L/E than LSND, but different L and E --> different backgrounds
CP in vacuum?:CP does not depend on L/E if matter effects negligible, but differs for neutrinos and antineutrinos
seems difficult (arXiv:0906.1997 and arXiv:0705.0107) but.. ?
Anyway,
all those Fnal data are only 2 σ !!!
only combined they are intriguing
![Page 115: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/115.jpg)
And light steriles for the new MiniBoone data?
•Interesting: Same L/E than LSND, but different L and E --> different backgrounds
CP in vacuum?:CP does not depend on L/E if matter effects negligible, but differs for neutrinos and antineutrinos
seems difficult (arXiv:0906.1997 and arXiv:0705.0107) but.. ?
Recall: Paul the octopus predictions
are a 2.6 σ effect!!!
![Page 116: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/116.jpg)
2.6 σ effect for the world cup ! (Marc Sher)
![Page 117: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/117.jpg)
It is an appearance experiment (Spain)
![Page 118: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/118.jpg)
![Page 119: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/119.jpg)
Conclusions Neutrino masses and mixings have added a precious piece to the flavour puzzle
Hopefully we will get to the physics behind it…
….. if new scale under # TeV
![Page 120: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/120.jpg)
Conclusions Neutrino masses and mixings have added a precious piece to the flavour puzzle
Hopefully we will get to the physics behind it…
….. if new scale under # TeV•Scalar seesaws and extended fermionic seesaws respect Minimal Flavour Violation
•SM + 2 heavy neutrinos, with approximate U(1)LN is very successful: almost fully determined by light masses and mixings
•Non-unitary mixing is a NSI characteristic of fermionic seesaws. Keep improving bounds!
•Pure matter-NSI severely constrained by gauge invariance; unlikely explanation of the (non-existing) MINOS ν/ν signal. But keep tracking νµ−ντ and νµ−νsterile couplings
-
![Page 121: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/121.jpg)
Back-up slides
![Page 122: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/122.jpg)
YES! These effects ARE non-standard neutrino interactions
W -
Matter
µ
ν
ee
e
τ u
d
ννUPMNS
Standard scenario
![Page 123: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/123.jpg)
YES! These effects ARE non-standard neutrino interactions
W -
Matter
µ
ν
ee
e
τ u
d
ννNN
NNNN
NN
NN
+
++
Non-Unitary Mixing Matrix
![Page 124: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/124.jpg)
Matter
µ
ν
e ee
τu
d
νν
Non-Unitary Mixing Matrix
YES! These effects ARE non-standard neutrino interactions…
…affecting simultneously production, propagation and detection.
![Page 125: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/125.jpg)
Matter
µ
ν
e ee
τu
d
νν
Non-Unitary Mixing Matrix
YES! These effects ARE non-standard neutrino interactions…
…affecting simultneously production, propagation and detection.
These NSI are a generic signature of fermionic Seesaws
![Page 126: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/126.jpg)
Matter
µ
ν
e ee
τu
d
νν
Non-Unitary Mixing Matrix
YES! These effects ARE non-standard neutrino interactions…
…affecting simultneously production, propagation and detection.
To be compared with popular non-standard interactions, with either:
Matter
µ
ν
ee
e
τ u
d
ν ν
Exotic production
![Page 127: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/127.jpg)
Matter
µ
ν
e ee
τu
d
νν
Non-Unitary Mixing Matrix
YES! These effects ARE non-standard neutrino interactions…
…affecting simultneously production, propagation and detection.
W -
Matter
µ
ν
e e
τ u
d
ν
e
ν
Exotic propagation
![Page 128: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/128.jpg)
Matter
µ
ν
e ee
τu
d
νν
Non-Unitary Mixing Matrix
YES! These effects ARE non-standard neutrino interactions…
…affecting simultneously production, propagation and detection.
To be compared with popular non-standard interactions, with either:
W -
Matter
µ
ν
ee
e
τ u
d
ν ν
Exotic detection
![Page 129: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/129.jpg)
Matter
µ
ν
e ee
τu
d
νν
Non-Unitary Mixing Matrix
YES! These effects ARE non-standard neutrino interactions…
…affecting simultneously production, propagation and detection.
These NSI are a generic signature of fermionic Seesaws
![Page 130: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/130.jpg)
New CP-violation signals even in the two-family approximation
i.e. P (νµ ---> ντ ) = P ( νµ ---> ντ ) _ _
Increased sensitivity to the moduli |N| in future Neutrino Factories
E. Fdez-Martinez, J.Lopez, O. Yasuda, M.B.G.
![Page 131: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/131.jpg)
If we parametrize with
22
4sin)2sin(2 !!
"
#$$%
& '()
E
LmiP *+,-,-
If L/E small
Can we measure the phases of N ? E. Fdez-Martinez, J.Lopez, O. Yasuda, M.B.G.
PMNSUN !+" )1( #+ε)(1 + ε) ε = −v2 cd=6
2εαβ
222
22 42
sin)2sin()Im(24
sin)2(sin !"!"!" #$#$ +%%&
'(()
* +,%%&
'(()
* +=
E
Lm
E
LmP
SM CP violating interference
Zero dist. effect
2Im(εαβ)- 4|εαβ|2
4
![Page 132: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/132.jpg)
Measuring non-unitary phases
Present bound from τ → µ γ
Sensitivity to|εµτ|
Sensitivity to
δµτ
|εµτ|
For non-trivial δµτ , one order of magnitude improvement for |N|
![Page 133: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/133.jpg)
!!"
#$$%
& '(=(
E
LmPP
2sin)2sin()Im(4
2
23
23)* µ++µµ+
The CP phase δµτcan be measured
At a Neutrino Factory of 50 GeV with L = 130 Km
In Pµτ there is no13
sin! 12!or suppression:
|εµτ|
δµτ
![Page 134: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/134.jpg)
•Also today! Antusch et al.--> impact of e-tau non-unitary contribution to the golden channel in standard nufact setup, detector at ~ 1000 km
Good prospect for νµ−ντ channel at near detector -O(100 km)
* Recently: Goswami+ Ota; Altarelli+Meloni, Tang+Winter at nufact
![Page 135: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/135.jpg)
Singlet and triplet Seesaws differ in the the pattern of the Z couplings
Fermion-triplet seesaws:
similar - although richer! - analysis
For M ≈ TeV → |Y| < 10-2
(Abada et al. 07))
WΣ+
Σ 0 gauge coupling
g
![Page 136: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/136.jpg)
For the Triplet-fermion Seesaws (type III):
(NN+-1)αβ=
(Abada et al 07)
![Page 137: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/137.jpg)
Scalar triplet seesaw Bounds on cd=6
![Page 138: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/138.jpg)
Scalar triplet seesaw
Combined bounds on cd=6
![Page 139: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/139.jpg)
Obervable non-standard interactions from
YΔ YΔ/M2 (L L ) (L L ) ____
in scalar triplet seesaw ???
Barely so ! (Malisnky Ohlsson and Zhang 08):
--- Require Yukawa couplings are almost diagonal--> degenerate neutrino spectrum
--- Not excluded are
µ− --> e-
νe νµ … Wrong sign muons at near detector
δγβα+
![Page 140: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/140.jpg)
No ν masses in the SMbecause the SM accidentally preserves B-L
• right-handed νR →
Would require YΝ~10-12 !!! Why νs are so light???
Why νR does not acquire large Majorana mass?
.. .. ~
chmchlHYRLDRL+!+ """"
i.e. Adding singlet neutrino fields NR
δL ∼ M (ΝRΝR) OK with gauge invariance
NR+ NR+
NR
Seesaw modelSeesaw model
YΝNR
Which allows YN~1 --> M~MGut
L-
![Page 141: Neutrinos Beyond the Standard Model · 2010. 7. 19. · (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li ongoing) This model with just 2 heavy neutrinos added to SM: (Alonso, Gavela, Hernandez,Li …ongoing)](https://reader035.fdocument.org/reader035/viewer/2022063021/5fe3d5878c58a470cf163af4/html5/thumbnails/141.jpg)
N elements from oscillations & decays
with unitarityOSCILLATIONS
without unitarityOSCILLATIONS
+DECAYS
3σ
.79 - .88 .47 - .61 < .20|U| = .19 - .52 .42 - .73 .58 - .82
.20 - .53 .44 - .74 .56 - .81
M. C. Gonzalez Garcia hep-ph/0410030
.75 - .89 .45 - .65 <.20
|N| = .19 - .55 .42 - .74 .57 - .82
.13 - .56 .36 - .75 .54 - .82
MUV
Antusch, Biggio, Fernández-Martínez, López-Pavón, M.B.G. 06