MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab,...

82
K. Long, 19 January, 2006 MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory

Transcript of MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab,...

Page 1: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

K. Long, 19 January, 2006

MICE, in preparation for theNeutrino Factory

Page 2: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Neutrinos in the Standard ModelStandard Model neutrino:

Mass = 0Dirac spinor

νL and νR present (νR and νL not present)

Quantum numbers:Weak isospin – ½

No conserved quantum numbersOnly νL and νR interact

Quantum numbers such that νR and νL are sterile

Page 3: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Standard neutrino Model (SνM)?The observation of neutrino oscillations implies:

Mass ≠ 0 and neutrino masses not equalνL and νR present

and can interactNo conserved quantum numbers and mass ≠ 0

Dirac spinorMajorana spinor

Neutrino could be its own antiparticle

Mass states mix to produce flavour states

10000

c0010

0

00

001

321

12121212

13-i

13

i1313

23232323

e

⎟⎟⎟

⎜⎜⎜

⎟⎟⎟

⎜⎜⎜

⎛−

⎟⎟⎟⎟

⎜⎜⎜⎜

−⎟⎟⎟

⎜⎜⎜

−=

⎟⎟⎟

⎜⎜⎜

ννν

ννν

δ

δ

τ

µ cssc

es

esc

cssc

CP violation

Page 4: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Plan:

Motivation

Sources for era of precision & sensitivity

Neutrino Factory R&D

MICE

Conclusions

Page 5: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Motivation: understanding the mixing matrixPresent knowledge of the parameters:

Presently unknown:Sign of ∆m2

23 – discovery Precision determination of θ13

Search for non-zero δ – discovery

As important as study of CKM matrix …

Lisi

Parke

Page 6: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Motivation: key issues in particle physics

de Gouvea

The origin of massNeutrino mass very small

Different origin to quark and lepton mass?

Page 7: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Motivation: key issues in particle physicsThe origin of mass

Neutrino mass very smallDifferent origin to quark and lepton mass?

The origin of flavourNeutrino mixing different from quark mixing

‘Natural’ explanation in ‘see-saw’ models?

de Gouvea

Page 8: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Motivation: key issues in particle physicsThe origin of mass

Neutrino mass very smallDifferent origin to quark and lepton mass?

The origin of flavourNeutrino mixing different from quark mixing

‘Natural’ explanation in ‘see-saw’ models?

The quest for unification‘Unified’ theories relate quarks to leptons

Generating relationships between quark and lepton mixing angles

Page 9: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Motivation: key issues in cosmologyThe origin of dark matter & dark energy

~96% of matter/energy is not understoodNeutrinos:

Contribution as large as baryonic matter?In some models neutrinos impact on dark energy

The absence of anti-matterCP violation in lepton sector underpins removal of anti-matter

‘Dirac’ phase, δ, not directly responsible, but,Relationship of relevant (Majorana) phases to δ is model dependent

Explanation of (absence of) large-scale structureNeutrino interacts only weakly – possible means of communication across large distances?In some models, super-symmetric partner to neutrino may be responsible for inflation

Page 10: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Motivation: the next generation

NOνANOνA

P.Huber et al., hep-ph/0403068

Page 11: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Motivation: timescalesR

equire 2ndgeneration facility

in second half of next decade

Mezzetto

Page 12: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Neutrino source – options:Second generation super-beam

CERN, FNAL, BNL, J-PARC II

Neutrino Factory

Beta-beam

Page 13: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Super-beams: SPL-Frejus

TRE

CERN SPLLSM-Fréjus

Near detector

130km

Campagne

440 kTon H2OHorn/targetDecay tunnel

New optimisation: 4 MW;Energy: 3.5 GeVParticle production

Page 14: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

SPL-Frejus: performance

2yrs (+)8yrs (−)

3×10-4

Campagne

T2K×10, 5 yrs

‘Old’ (2.2 GeV)

Rates

Rates and energy

spectrum

Assumes 2%systematic

uncertainties

Page 15: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Neutrino Factory: sensitivity

Neutrino Factory: 1021 decays/year; 50 GeV50 kTon magnetised iron calorimeter3000 km base line P.Huber et al., hep-ph/0412199

Page 16: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Neutrino Factory: sensitivity

2nd L at MB=Magic Base Line(7500km)

mass hierarchyremoved

Synergy of NuFact-II(3000 km)+T2HK

P.Huber et al., hep-ph/0412199

Page 17: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Beta-beam

Optimisation

Beam energy (γ)

Detector:H2O CkovTASD

considered

Page 18: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Neutrino Factory / beta-beam

Page 19: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Super-beam/beta-beam/Neutrino FactoryNeutrino Factory offers best performance

Best sensitivity to δUnless sin22θ13 is large

NF optimisation for large sin22θ13 to be reviewed

Best ‘discovery reach’ in sin22θ13

High-γ beta-beam competitiveγ ~ 350 requires ‘1 TeV proton machine’

High-performance super-beam has δ ≠ 0 discovery potential if sin22θ13 is large

Multi-megawatt class proton sourceMegaton scale H2O Cherenkov

Page 20: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

The challenge: time-scales

Incremental

Era ofsensitivity & precision

Optimum scheduleScience drivenPotential match to funding window

Challenge:To make the case!

International scoping study

1-year study of Neutrino Factory and super-beam facility… a step on the way?

Era ofsensitivity & precision

Page 21: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Neutrino Factory - concept

Page 22: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Neutrino Factory – concept

500 m

Page 23: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

To G Sasso

To Soudan

[ 900–1000 m below ground ]

3 × FFAGs 3–8 GeV

8–20 GeV20–50 GeV

3 GeV linacCooling

Phase rot.Target

~10 GeV synch. + booster + linac To G Sasso

To Super-K (1000 m,

projection)

To G Sasso (100 m)

To Soudan (500 m)Return leg

Return leg (vertical)

Super-beam to Gran SassoInjector linac: 100m, surfaceSynchrotrons: 50m and 100m ∅

SurfaceExtraction line: 50m, surfaceTarget: SurfaceDecay channel: 100m

Points to Gran Sasso

Neutrino FactoryTarget: SurfaceDecay channel: 50m, surfacePhase rotation: 50m, surfaceCooling: 100m, surfaceFFAG 3-8 GeV: 64m ∅, surfaceFFAG 8-20 GeV: 160m ∅, 15m below groundFFAG 20-50 GeV: 400m ∅, 30m below groundRace-track storage ring:

Leg to Gran Sasso 503.5mLeg to Soudan 563.7m

Findlay ‘four-straight’ storage ring:Leg to Gran Sasso 100mLeg to Soudan 500mLeg to SuperKamiokande 1000m

Page 24: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Neutrino Factory R&D: highlights

Proton driverComment on front end

Target and capture

CoolingMICE

Acceleration

Page 25: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

The proton driver

Page 26: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Proton driver & its front endProton labs all have proton-driver plans

… too much detail to cover here!Importance to inject ‘good’ beam:

Parallel front-end developments (in Europe):3 MeV test placeCERN

FETSRAL

High EnergySuperConducting Elliptical Cavities

(5-cell 704 MHz)

Injector

(352 MHz)

IntermediateAcceleration

SC or NCResonators

500

MeV 600 MeV XADS

200

MeV

100

MeV

5M

eV

100

keV

SOURCE RFQ CH - DTL orQWR - Spoke

Low Betaβ=0.47

Medium Betaβ=0.65

High Betaβ=0.85

1-2 GeV EURISOL

High EnergySuperConducting Elliptical Cavities

(5-cell 704 MHz)

Injector

(352 MHz)

IntermediateAcceleration

SC or NCResonators

500

MeV 600 MeV XADS

200

MeV

100

MeV

5M

eV

100

keV

SOURCE RFQ CH - DTL orQWR - Spoke

Low Betaβ=0.47

Medium Betaβ=0.65

High Betaβ=0.85

1-2 GeV EURISOL

High EnergySuperConducting Elliptical Cavities

(5-cell 704 MHz)

High EnergySuperConducting Elliptical Cavities

(5-cell 704 MHz)

Injector

(352 MHz)

IntermediateAcceleration

SC or NCResonators

500

MeV 600 MeV XADS

200

MeV

100

MeV

5M

eV

100

keV

SOURCE RFQ CH - DTL orQWR - Spoke

Low Betaβ=0.47

Medium Betaβ=0.65

High Betaβ=0.85

1-2 GeV EURISOL

Injector

(352 MHz)

IntermediateAcceleration

SC or NCResonators

500

MeV 600 MeV XADS

200

MeV

100

MeV

5M

eV

100

keV

SOURCE RFQ CH - DTL orQWR - Spoke

Low Betaβ=0.47

Medium Betaβ=0.65

High Betaβ=0.85

1-2 GeV EURISOL

EUROTRANS

CW or Pulsed LINAC

High EnergySuperConducting Elliptical Cavities

(5-cell 704 MHz)

Injector

(352 MHz)

IntermediateAcceleration

SC or NCResonators

500

MeV 600 MeV XADS

200

MeV

100

MeV

5M

eV

100

keV

SOURCE RFQ CH - DTL orQWR - Spoke

Low Betaβ=0.47

Medium Betaβ=0.65

High Betaβ=0.85

1-2 GeV EURISOL

High EnergySuperConducting Elliptical Cavities

(5-cell 704 MHz)

Injector

(352 MHz)

IntermediateAcceleration

SC or NCResonators

500

MeV 600 MeV XADS

200

MeV

100

MeV

5M

eV

100

keV

SOURCE RFQ CH - DTL orQWR - Spoke

Low Betaβ=0.47

Medium Betaβ=0.65

High Betaβ=0.85

1-2 GeV EURISOL

High EnergySuperConducting Elliptical Cavities

(5-cell 704 MHz)

High EnergySuperConducting Elliptical Cavities

(5-cell 704 MHz)

Injector

(352 MHz)

IntermediateAcceleration

SC or NCResonators

500

MeV 600 MeV XADS

200

MeV

100

MeV

5M

eV

100

keV

SOURCE RFQ CH - DTL orQWR - Spoke

Low Betaβ=0.47

Medium Betaβ=0.65

High Betaβ=0.85

1-2 GeV EURISOL

Injector

(352 MHz)

IntermediateAcceleration

SC or NCResonators

500

MeV 600 MeV XADS

200

MeV

100

MeV

5M

eV

100

keV

SOURCE RFQ CH - DTL orQWR - Spoke

Low Betaβ=0.47

Medium Betaβ=0.65

High Betaβ=0.85

1-2 GeV EURISOL

High EnergySuperConducting Elliptical Cavities

(5-cell 704 MHz)

Injector

(352 MHz)

IntermediateAcceleration

SC or NCResonators

500

MeV 600 MeV XADS

200

MeV

100

MeV

5M

eV

100

keV

SOURCE RFQ CH - DTL orQWR - Spoke

Low Betaβ=0.47

Medium Betaβ=0.65

High Betaβ=0.85

1-2 GeV EURISOL

High EnergySuperConducting Elliptical Cavities

(5-cell 704 MHz)

Injector

(352 MHz)

IntermediateAcceleration

SC or NCResonators

500

MeV 600 MeV XADS

200

MeV

100

MeV

5M

eV

100

keV

SOURCE RFQ CH - DTL orQWR - Spoke

Low Betaβ=0.47

Medium Betaβ=0.65

High Betaβ=0.85

1-2 GeV EURISOL

High EnergySuperConducting Elliptical Cavities

(5-cell 704 MHz)

High EnergySuperConducting Elliptical Cavities

(5-cell 704 MHz)

Injector

(352 MHz)

IntermediateAcceleration

SC or NCResonators

500

MeV 600 MeV XADS

200

MeV

100

MeV

5M

eV

100

keV

SOURCE RFQ CH - DTL orQWR - Spoke

Low Betaβ=0.47

Medium Betaβ=0.65

High Betaβ=0.85

1-2 GeV EURISOL

Injector

(352 MHz)

IntermediateAcceleration

SC or NCResonators

500

MeV 600 MeV XADS

200

MeV

100

MeV

5M

eV

100

keV

SOURCE RFQ CH - DTL orQWR - Spoke

Low Betaβ=0.47

Medium Betaβ=0.65

High Betaβ=0.85

1-2 GeV EURISOL

EUROTRANS

CW or Pulsed LINAC

EUROTRANSEUROTRANS

CW or Pulsed LINACRFQ

MEBT

Superconducting main linacTRIPS

SPES-1LegnaroRFQ

MEBT

Superconducting main linacTRIPS

SPES-1Legnaro

CERN: 3 MeV test place; Linac 4; SPLCCLRC: Front-end test stand; 180 MeV linacCEA: SPES-1INFN: IncipitCNRS, IPN, IN2P3, Eurotrans: PDS-XADSEurisol, HIPPI…

Synergy!Breadth of applications is a great strength

Page 27: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Target and capture

Emphasis on target work, but

significant progress in phase-rotation and bunching schemes pion/muon rates vs proton energy etc. etc.

Page 28: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Target and captureTwo schemes:

Horn: good match to super-beamTapered solenoid: possible to capture µ+ and µ-

simultaneously (US Study IIa)2.2 GeV protonsAt 4MW

Protons

Current of 300 kA

π

B∝1/RB = 0

Hg Jet

Study II

CERN

Page 29: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Target: evaluation of optionsSolid target:

Lifetime: beam-induced shock leads to fractureIrradiation tests:

Exposure of various candidate materials to pulsed proton beam at BNL and at CERNAnnealing of target material through ‘baking’ also being studied

Shock test (UKNF):Current pulse to simulate heating Thin (tantalum wire)Numerical models (LS-Dyna) being studied

to vacuum pump

heater

test wire

insulators

to pulsed power supply

to pulsed power supply

water cooled vacuum chamber

Schematic diagram of the test chamber and heater oven.

to vacuum pump

heater

test wire

insulators

to pulsed power supply

to pulsed power supply

water cooled vacuum chamber

Schematic diagram of the test chamber and heater oven.

Bennett

Page 30: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Target: evaluation of optionsLiquid-mercury jet:

To date, have tested:Effect of beam on jet without magnetic fieldDevelopment of jet in a solenoidal magnetic field

Progress in modelling results

Lettry/Robert: laser ⊕ water jet

Cavitation, surface ripplesSamulyak

Page 31: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

High-power target experiment

Solenoid

ProtonBeam

Hg DeliverySystemBeam

Attenuator

Page 32: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

High-power target experimentProposal to CERN ISOLDE/nTOF committee

Studies of a target system for a 4 MW, 24 GeV proton beam

Spokespersons: H.Kirk (BNL), K.McDonald (Princeton)APPROVED! MERIT (nTOF11)

Participating institutes:BNL, CERN, KEK, ORL, Princeton, RAL

Mercury jet:1 cm diameter; 20 m/s

PS delivers:1012 – 1013 protons per 2 µs spill in 4 bunchesBeam spot ~3 mm diameter

Page 33: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

MERIT: objectivesEffect of increasing charge density:

7×1012 – 28×1012 protons per spillEffect of magnetic field on jet dispersal:

0 – 15 TCavitation:

50 Hz operation

250 to 1500 ns500 ns

Beam

Profile

Pump Probe

Page 34: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

MERIT: preparationsTarget:

Viewing system under developmentMercury pump system under development

Jet deflector Hg Jet Z=0 view-port

Secondary containment

Primary containment

Proton beam

Page 35: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

MERIT: preparationsMagnet:

LN2 Operation15 T (5.5 MW pulsed power)15 cm warm bore1 m long beam pipe

Page 36: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

nTOF11: schedule2005

March nToF11 approvedSpring solenoid construction completedSummer solenoid testsWinter construction of Hg system

2006April solenoid test finishedJune solenoid shipped to CERNautumn integrated test at CERNDecember fully ready for beam

2007April final run at PS start-up

Page 37: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Ionisation cooling and MICE

Emphasis on MICE, but

important progress on new cooling schemes: ring coolers, FFAG 6D coolers, helical coolers, …

Page 38: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Cooling and the Neutrino Factory

Page 39: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Acceleration

µ

Liquid H2 Acceleration

µ

Liquid H2

µ

Liquid H2

PrincipleIonisation cooling

Large emittanceclose to a focus

Small emittance

Practice

MICE:Design, build, commission and operate a realistic section of cooling channelMeasure its performance in a variety of modes of operation and beam conditions

i.e. results will allow NuFact complex to be optimised

Page 40: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

MICE collaborationUniversite Catholique de Louvain Belgium

INFN: Bari, Frascati, Genova, Legnaro, Milano, Napoli, Padova, Trieste ROMA TRE university, Italy

KEK, Osaka University Japan

NIKHEF The Netherlands

CERN

Geneva, PSI Switzerland

Brunel, Edinburgh, Glasgow, Liverpool, Imperial, Oxford, RAL, Sheffield UK

ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL,Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, Iowa, Mississippi, UC Riverside, Illinois-UC Enrico Fermi Institute, Illinois Institute of Technology USA

THE MICE COLLABORATION3 continents7 countries40 institute members140 individual members - Engineers & physicists (part. & accel.)

Universite Catholique de Louvain Belgium

INFN: Bari, Frascati, Genova, Legnaro, Milano, Napoli, Padova, Trieste ROMA TRE university, Italy

KEK, Osaka University Japan

NIKHEF The Netherlands

CERN

Geneva, PSI Switzerland

Brunel, Edinburgh, Glasgow, Liverpool, Imperial, Oxford, RAL, Sheffield UK

ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL,Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, Iowa, Mississippi, UC Riverside, Illinois-UC Enrico Fermi Institute, Illinois Institute of Technology USA

THE MICE COLLABORATION3 continents7 countries40 institute members140 individual members - Engineers & physicists (part. & accel.)

Spokesman: A.Blondel (GVA)Deputy: M.Zisman (LBNL)Proj. Man.: P.Drumm (RAL)

Page 41: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

MICE on ISIS at RAL

Page 42: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

MICE TargetConcept:

Target dips into halo of ISIS beam

On demand 1 – 3 Hz operation

Engineering:Require to separate vacuum surrounding target mechanism from ISIS machine vacuum

Page 43: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

MICE Muon Beam: targetPre-prototype:

Gain experience with construction and operation

Page 44: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

MICE Hall: hydrogen-system R&D

Pressuregauge

Non-returnvalve

-P P VP Vacuum pumpBursting diskPressure

relief valveValvePressure

P

Chiller/Heater Unit

Helium supply

Hydrogen supply

P

Nitrogen supply

PP

1 m3

P

-P P VP Vacuum pumpBursting diskPressure

relief valveValvePressureregulator

CoolantOut

(20m3 capacity)

Metal Hydride storage unit

(20m3 capacity)

P

PP

VP02

VP01

Heater /Chiller

1 bar diff

PP

PP

Helium supply

Hydrogen supply

Extract hood

P

Nitrogen supply

PP

PP

1 m3

Vent manifold

PG01

RV06

PV01

PV18

PV03

PV05

PV07

PG03PPG02

PV20Test absorber module

In

Absorbervolume

0.5 bar diff

0.9 bar diff

PV19CV04

CV17RV10

BD09

HV08

0.5 bar diff RV13

0.9 bar diff BD12

HV11

PV14

Non returnvalve 0.1 bar RV21

Buffervessel

PV15

PP

PV02

Argon jacket

TTS3

T

T

TS1

Temperaturesensor

H2

H2

H2

Pressuregauge

Non-returnvalve

-P P VP Vacuum pumpBursting diskPressure

relief valveValvePressure

P

Chiller/Heater Unit

Helium supply

Hydrogen supply

P

Nitrogen supply

PP

1 m3

P

-P P VP Vacuum pumpBursting diskPressure

relief valveValvePressureregulator

CoolantOut

(20m3 capacity)

Metal Hydride storage unit

(20m3 capacity)(20m3 capacity)

Metal Hydride storage unit

(20m3 capacity)

P

PPPP

VP02

VP01

Heater /Chiller

1 bar diff

PPPP

PPPP

Helium supply

Hydrogen supply

Extract hood

P

Nitrogen supply

PPPP

PP

1 m3

Vent manifold

PG01

RV06

PV01

PV18

PV03

PV05

PV07

PG03PPG02

PV20Test absorber module

In

Absorbervolume

0.5 bar diff

0.9 bar diff

PV19CV04

CV17RV10

BD09

HV08

0.5 bar diff RV13

0.9 bar diff BD12

HV11

PV14

Non returnvalve 0.1 bar RV21

Buffervessel

PV15

PPPP

PV02

Argon jacket

TTTS3

TT

TT

TS1

Temperaturesensor

H2H2

H2H2

H2H2

Simplified PID

Page 45: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

MICE Hall: hydrogen-system R&D

Condenser

LH2 dummy absorber

Level sensors

Cryocooler SRDK-4151.5 W @4.2K35/45 W @50K

Radiation shield

Hydrogen inlet and outlet

He inlet and outlet

Cu bottom plate with heat exchanger

Condenser

LH2 dummy absorber

Level sensors

Cryocooler SRDK-4151.5 W @4.2K35/45 W @50K

Radiation shield

Hydrogen inlet and outlet

He inlet and outlet

Cu bottom plate with heat exchanger

Dum

my absorber and cryostat

Page 46: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Muon Ionisation Cooling Experiment

Page 47: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

MICE: cooling performanceTransverse emittance:

Cooling effect:Cooling termHeating term

For MICE:Liquid hydrogen only:

VmT41

µ=ε

( )0

3

2

2 2GeV 014.0XEmdz

dEEdz

d TTT

µββ

ε−=

ε

Page 48: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Cooling Measurement

Page 49: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Iron Shield

Iron Shield Brackets

Cold Mass Support

Coolers

Vent Stack

Lead Neck

Radiation Shield Space

Tracker Magnet Stand

Cooler Neck

Iron Shield

Iron Shield Brackets

Cold Mass Support

Coolers

Vent Stack

Lead Neck

Radiation Shield Space

Tracker Magnet Stand

Cooler Neck

Lead Neck

Cold Mass Support

Liquid He Tube

Fill & Vent Neck

Condenser

4 K Cooler

He Gas Tube

The 50 K shields are not shown.

Drawing by S. Q. Yang

Lead Neck

Cold Mass Support

Liquid He Tube

Fill & Vent Neck

Condenser

4 K Cooler

He Gas Tube

The 50 K shields are not shown.

Drawing by S. Q. Yang

Spectrometer: solenoid LBNL

Page 50: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Spectrometer: trackerKEK test: 30Sep05 – 07Oct05

Brunel, Edinb’gh, FNAL, Gva, IIT, Imperial, KEK, Liverpool, Osaka, Riverside, UCLA

Page 51: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Spectrometer: tracker

Page 52: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Spectrometer: tracker; electronicsTwo VLPC cassettes borrowed from D∅Prototype AFE II boards borrowed from D∅

Some MICE specific interface boards

Cryostat design/built for MICE

Cryocooler for refrigeration

Commissioning of AFE II – FNAL experts:

Require expertise in tracker team

Page 53: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Spectrometer: trackerPrototypes:

First light!

Page 54: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Upstream Cherenkov Mississippi

Page 55: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Time-of-flight/trigger Milan/Pavia

Page 56: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

ToF/triggerPrototype development/performance tests

Issues:Rate (especially ToF0)Operation in magnetic field

50 gauss50 gauss 1 MHz1 MHz1 MHz

Page 57: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Downstream Cherenkov Louvain

Page 58: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Muon calorimeter:Task: µ/e separation Rome III, Trieste

Page 59: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Muon calorimeter: development

Base line design completeTesting of components underway

Page 60: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

MICE: cooling channel

Page 61: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Focus-coil module:Focus-coils:

5 TField flip (focus)Conceptual & now detailed design of magnetsSafety analysis

KEK, IIT, FNAL, RAL,Oxford, Missippi

Page 62: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

201 MHz Cavity Ingredients

Layout of cooling lines

Cavity body + water cooling linesPorts and flanges RF loop couplersCavity support structureCavity tunersCeramic RF windows (~4”)Curved Be windowsMICE specifics

TunersIntegration

joints and flanges Possible LN2 operation

LBNL

Page 63: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Cavity prototype: MuCool

E-beam weldingPortsWater cooling lines

• Couplers assembled first time(mid-April-2005)

• First low power measurement• frequency ~ 199.5 MHz• coupling ~ 5 (max)• Q ~ 5000

JLab FNAL

Now, preparing to condition in MTA at FNAL

Page 64: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

MICE Collaboration Meeting at RALOctober 22 ~ 24, 2005

Curved Be windows• Each cavity will require a pair of 0.38 mm thick pre-

curved beryllium windows with Ti-N coating

• Double-curved shape prevents buckling caused by thermal expansion due to RF heating

• Thermally induced deflections are predictable

• A die is applied at high temperature to form window

• Copper frames are brazed to beryllium windows in a subsequent process

Page 65: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Cooling channel: RF powerRequire 1 MW/cavity to produce 8 MV/mWill use 4 × 2.5 MW amplifiers

2 circuits from LBNL2 circuits being negotiated from CERN

2 MW Amplifier

2 MW Amplifier

Master OscillatorControls etc

201 MHz Cavity Module

2 MW Amplifier

2 MW Amplifier

201 MHz Cavity Module

LBNL

CERN300 kW Amplifier

300 kW Amplifier

300 kW Amplifier

300 kW Amplifier

HT Supplies

HT Supplies

Daresbury

2 MW Amplifier

2 MW Amplifier

Master OscillatorControls etc

201 MHz Cavity Module

2 MW Amplifier

2 MW Amplifier

201 MHz Cavity Module

LBNL

CERN300 kW Amplifier

300 kW Amplifier

300 kW Amplifier

300 kW Amplifier

HT Supplies

HT Supplies

Daresbury

Page 66: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Cooling channel: RF powerRefurbishment has begun:

Risk: supply of components

Page 67: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

µStep I: Spring 2007

µStep II

µStep III

µStep IV

µStep V

Study Systematically

Approved!

In preparation

µ

Step VI 2009?

Page 68: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

MICE Phase I on ISIS at RAL

Page 69: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Accel & store

Rapid accelerationMuons decay

Large apertureReduce constraints on cooling channel

Favoured scenario:Fixed field alternating gradient (FFAG) accelerators

Storage ring:Concept development (US)

Page 70: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

FFAG R&DPRISM: culmination of Japanese scaling-FFAG R&D

Built on success ofPOP machines

International activitydeveloping non-scaling FFAGconcept

Electron model:POP machine for non-scaling FFAG

Page 71: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Comments and conclusionsSeveral studies at the turn of the century

US Studies I and IIECFA/CERN StudyNuFact-J Study

established feasibility & R&D programmeR&D programme is now maturing:

International Muon Ionisation Cooling ExperimentInternational high-power targetry experimentInternational rapid acceleration (FFAG) programme

In parallel, continued concept development

Page 72: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Desirable timescale

T2K/NOνA start

First sin2θ13?

Complete phase 1?

MINOS, MiniBOONE, CNGS, KamLAND, SK, T2K, …

Era of precision and sensitivity

Next generation facility

Page 73: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Desirable timescale

Era of precision and sensitivity

Next generation facility

Build

Concept development(design studies)

leading to consensusprogramme

Super-beam Neutrino Factory Beta-beam

Page 74: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Conclusion:Clear programme:

Present experiments to: Tie down θ12, θ23, ∆m12

2, ∆m232

Next generation of experiments to:Make first measurement of θ13 (or set limit)Begin search for leptonic CP violation

Energetic programme of R&D by which to:Arrive at a consensus programme for the era of precision and sensitivityOptions:

Second-generation super-beamBeta-beamNeutrino Factory

alone or in combination

A fantastic programme!

Page 75: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10
Page 76: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Backup slides

Page 77: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

BNL-VLBL VirenUpgraded AGS at 28 GeV

Replace booster with 1.2 GeV SC linac

Assume UNO: 500 kTon H2ORunning assumptions:

ν: 1 MW, 5 yrsν: 2 MW, 5 yrs

Performance updated:Example only →

Page 78: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

BNL-VLBL: sensitivity Viren

~2×10-3

Very long baseline:Sensitivity to ∆m23

2 from matter effects

Page 79: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Super-NOνA Winter

~ 70

0m A

ctive

Len

gth

8 GeV

Lin

ac

8 GeV

neut

rino

MainIn

jecto

r@

2 MW

SY-1

20Fi

xed-

Targ

et

Neutri

no“S

uper

-Bea

ms”

NUMIOff-

Axis

~ 70

0m A

ctive

Len

gth

8 GeV

Lin

ac

~ 70

0m A

ctive

Len

gth

8 GeV

Lin

ac

8 GeV

neut

rino

8 GeV

neut

rino

MainIn

jecto

r@

2 MWMain

Injec

tor

@2 M

W

SY-1

20Fi

xed-

Targ

etSY-1

20Fi

xed-

Targ

et

Neutri

no“S

uper

-Bea

ms”

NUMIOff-

Axis

Neutri

no“S

uper

-Bea

ms”

NUMIOff-

Axis

810 k

m

Page 80: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

Supa-NOνA: sensitivity Winter

Page 81: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10
Page 82: MICE, in preparation for the Neutrino Factory · 2017-01-11 · Sheffield UK ANL, BNL, FNAL, JLab, LBNL, Universities of Fairfield, Chicago, UCLA Physics, Northern Illinois, ... RV10

T2K II sensitivity

3 × 10-4