Early decrease in density of mononuclear leukocyte β-adrenoceptors in depressed patients following...
Transcript of Early decrease in density of mononuclear leukocyte β-adrenoceptors in depressed patients following...
Prq Nan-Psychophammco 1. & BioL Psychtat. 1991. Vol. 15. pp. 357-367 0276-5646/91 $0.00 + .50
Prtnted In Great Britain. All rights reserved 0 1991 Pergamon Press plc
EARLY DECREASE IN DENSITY OF MONONUCLEAR LEUKOCYTE f3-ADRENOCEPTORS IN DEPRESSED
PATIENTS FOLLOWING AMINEPTINE TREATMENT: POSSIBLE RELATION TO CLINICAL EFFICIENCY
PASCALE MAZZOLAl, REGINE JEANNINGROSl, JEAN M. AZORIN2,
LAURENCE ALIGNE2 and RENE TISSOTll 2
'Unite de Psychiatric Biologique, C.N.R.S., Marseille, France.
'Clinique de Psychiatric et de Psychologie Medicale, C.H.U. Timone, Marseille, France.
(Final form, September 1990)
Mazzola, Pascale, Regine Jeanningros , Jean M. Azorin , Laurence Align& and Rene Tissot : Early decrease in density of mononuclear leukocyte i3- adrenoceptors in depressed patients following amineptine treatment: Possible relation to clinical efficiency. Prog. Neuro-Psychopharmacol. & Biol. Psychiat. 1991, =:357-367.
1. The effect of chronic amineptine treatment (2OOmg/day) on iS-adrenoceptor density of intact mononuclear leukocytes ( MNL 1 was examined in unmedicated major unipolar depressed patients.
2. Pretreatment parameters of (-I- [12511 -iodopindolol specific binding did not differ significantly from age- and sex-matched healthy controls as the patients were only moderately depressed.
3. All patients showed a highly significant clinical improvement as assessed by the AMDP-depression scale after one week of amineptine (D7), while 2 patients relapsed after one month of treatment (D28) and were considered to be non-responders.
4. The maximal density of %-adrenoceptors ( BIMX 1 was significantly decreased at D7 (by 33%) compared to pretreatment level ( DO ) in the treatment responders and remained lower at D28, although the difference was no longer significant. No alteration in B-receptor affinity (Kd) was detected during the treatment.
5. These results indicate that treatment with amineptine, an anti- depressant drug known to selectively inhibit the dopamine uptake system, can rapidly affect MNL iS-adrenoceptors.
6. Moreover, the present findings show that the reduction in MNL is- adrenoceptor density, which is associated with a stable clinical improvement, may provide a predictive index for successful anti- depressant treatment.
uvwora: Amineptine treatment, B-adrenoceptor, Depression, Mononuclear leukocyte
. . Abbrevlatlons: AMDP Depression scale (AMDP-D), day (D), maximal number of binding sites (Bmax), mononuclear leukocytes (MNL), platelet poor plasma (PPP)
357
358 P. Mazzola etal.
Amineptine is a tricyclic antidepressant drug with peculiar biochemical
properties. Unlike most other tricyclic agents, amineptine selectively
inhibits dopamine uptake from synaptosomal preparations of rat cortex (Ceci
et al., 1986; Bonnet et al., 1987). Chronic treatment with amineptine
induced down-regulation of B-adrenoceptors in the rat cortex, a feature
common to the majority of antidepressant agents which has been postulated
related to their clinical efficiency (Sulser et al., 1978; Maj et al.,
1984). In the absence of direct methods for studying l3-receptors in the
human central nervous system, it has been demonstrated that leukocytes
provide a useful peripheral model for investigating S-receptors in
depressive illness (Bunney and Murphy, 1975; Landman et al., 1983; Pandey
et al., 1987). A decrease in lymphocyte &-adrenoceptor density in
untreated depressed patients has been found when compared to healthy
controls (Extein et a1.,1979; Pandey et al.,1985 and 1987; Carsten et al.,
1987; Magliozzi et al,. 1989). Recently, we have found a significantly
lower number of iodopindolol binding sites in intact mononuclear leukocytes
in patients suffering from major unipolar depression. This decrease in
maximal binding was correlated with symptom severity in different DSM-III
depression subtypes (Jeanningros et al., 1990). So far, only one report
has been made on the effect of antidepressant treatment on peripheral 15-
adrenoceptors. Trazodone or amitriptyline have been shown to induce a
decrease in lymphocyte &-adrenoceptor binding in depressed Patients who
responded to treatment (Healy et al., 1983 and 1985).
In this study, we investigated the influence of chronic treatment with
amineptine, a drug known to rapidly improve different types of depressive
syndromes, on intact MNL B-adrenoceptors in unipolar major depressed
patients. In addition, the affinity of amineptine for MNL i3-adrenoceptors
was studied both in patients before treatment and in sex- and age-matched
controls.
Ten major unipolar depressed patients (6 men and 4 women) diagnosed
according to the DSM-III 'criteria (American Psychiatric Association 1980)
Leukocyte p-receptors and amineptlne treatment 359
with a mean age (f S.E.M.) of 44.1 f 3.4 (range: 30 to 66 years) gave
informed consent to the ethically approved research procedures. All
depressed patients had a AMDP-D score of f0 or more with a mean score f
S.E.M. = 26.7 f 3.4. Criteria for exclusion were medical illnesses such as
asthma , congestive heart failure, hypertension, atopic eczema or the use
of drugs (e.g. steroids, %-agonists and E-antagonists) that may alter beta-
receptor function. The control population consisted of ten physically and
mentally healthy volunteers, matched for age and sex.
All patients were treated with amineptine (200 mg/day) after an
antidepressant wash-out period of 10 days, and received no other
psychotropic medication, except benzodiazepines (equivalent to 5-20 mg
Diazepam).
The clinical state of the depressed patients was evaluated using the
depression items from the AMDP scale (AMlIP-D) before treatment and after
the first and the fourth week of treatment. Patients whose scores at the
end of the trial period had been lowered by at least 50% from their
pretreatment level, were considered as responders. Two patients stopped the
treatment before day 28 on their request although one of them had clearly
improved . Upon entering the study, both patients and volunteers underwent
mononuclear leukocyte S-receptor determination. Following the onset of
amineptine treatment, binding assessments were carried out at day 7 (D7)
and day 28 (D28).
Between 7:30-8:00 a.m., after the subjects had rested in bed for 30 min,
blood samples (50 ml) were withdrawn into glass tubes, anticoagulated with
heparin (10 UI/ml), and immediately processed at room twerature. After a
first centrifugation at 215 x g for 10 min, the pellet was preserved and
the platelet rich plasma layer was carefully aspirated and centrifuged at
2,000 x g for 15 min to produce platelet poor plasma (PPP). PPP and the
pellet were pooled, diluted 1:2 with 20mM Hepes, 154 mM NaCl, pH 7.5 and
then carefully layered on Ficoll-Hypaque gradient (density 1.077 g/ml:
Sigma). The mononuclear' leukocytes were isolated by centrifugation
360 P. Mazzola et al.
according to Boyum's method (1968). Finally, the cells were washed with the
same buffer and counted in a Neubauer cell. The lymphocyte yield from this
isolation procedure was greater than 85% with less than 3.5 platelets per
MNL. Cell viability as demonstrated by tryptan blue exclusion was greater
than 95%.
MNL cells ( 2 x 105 - 6 x lo5 ) were incubated in duplicate in
siliconized polypropylene tubes. The incubation buffer consisted of 8mM
Hepes, 62 mM NaCl, pH 7.35 containing 9 concentrations varying from 12 to
380 pM (-) [lz51] -iodopindolol with or without 1 p (-)propranolol to
define non-specific binding. Samples were incubated for 30 min at 37 'C,
then the incubates were diluted by adding 3ml of 154 mM NaCl containing
1OmM Tris HCl, pH 7.4 at 4OC and rapidly filtered through Wathman GF/C
filters. The incubation tubes and the filters were washed with 3ml or 6 ml
of the ice cold buffer respectively. The binding fulfilled conventional
criteria for saturability. The saturation data were regressed as specific
bound/free versus bound by Scatchard analysis (Scatchard, 1949). The
regression coefficients were above 0.90, indicating monophasic Scatchard
plots. Specific binding was at least 75% of total binding at the Kd value.
Inhibition by amineptine (1 pM - 0.3 mM) of 280 pM (-) [12511iodopindolol
binding was assessed on intact mononuclear leukocytes in depressed patients
and controls. IC,, values (concentration that inhibits 50% of specific
binding) were calculated by computer analysis.
The Wilcoxon T test was used for comparisons between paired samples.
Correlation was evaluated by the Spear-man Rank correlation.
Before treatment, the mean Bmax value of [12sIl -iodopindolol binding in
the depressed patients was the same as that for the age- and sex-matched
controls both in the responders and non-responders.
Leukocyte p-receptorsand amineptinetreatment 361
Table 1
Depression Evaluation and Iodopindolol Binding on MNh Cells
in Patients before and during Amineptine Treatment.
AMDP-D score Bmax (sites/cell)
Controls
(n=lO) 1835 f 153 -
All depressed
DO (n=lO)
D7 (n=lO)
D28 (n=8)
26.7 f 3.4 1653 f 150
10.6 f 1.5' 1596 f 247
12.7 f 4.Sa 1344 f 260
Responders
DO (n=7)
D7 (n=7)
D28 (n=6)
28.4 f 4.2
10.3 f 2.lb
6.3 f 1.6a
1818 f 163
1205 f 120agd
1383 f 344
Non-responders
DO (n=3)
D7 (n=3)
D28 (n=2)
22.7 f 6.6 1270 f 214
11.3 f 2.0 2509 f 470
32.0 f7.0 1228 f 319
All data are mean f S.E.M.
Scores were evaluated using the depression items from the AMDP scale.
a p<0.03; b p<0.02; c ~~0.01, significantly different from DO value;d p<0.03
significantly different from control value, Wilcoxon T test.
After the first week of treatment, all the patients had a clear clinical
improvement and mean AMDP-D score decreased by 60% compared to the
pretreatment value. However, out of the 8 patients who underwent the
treatment for 4 weeks, 6 patients fully improved, while 2 patients relapsed
and were considered to be non-responders (Fig. 1).
When all the depressed patients were considered, mean Bmax value at D7
and D28 of amineptine administration did not differ significantly from the
362 P. Mazola etal.
baseline level _ However, at D7, the responders exhibited a large and
significant decrease in Bmax f34%), while the non-responders showed a non-
significant Bmax increase (49%) compared to their baseline level (Table 11.
It is worth noting that non-responders had the lowest pretreatment Bmax
values (Fig. 21.11-1 all patients, individual changes in ANDP-D score after
one month of treatment were highly correlated with respective Bmax changes
during the first week of amineptine treatment (Fig. 3).
Bmax Values at D28 were lowered by 24% in the responders compared to DO
values but the difference did not reach statistical significance. Two
patients exhibited a large increase in Bmax between D'7 and D28 (Fig. 2).
Kd values in depressed patients before treatment did not differ from the
age-and sex-matched controls ( mean f S.E.M. = 43.8 f 10.1 vs. 47.6 f 7.6
pM, n=lO, respectively, NS) and remained stable throughout the treatment.
Amineptine failed to inhibit I-) 112511 -iodopindolol binding, even at a
concentration of 0.3 mM, and the IC50 value could not be determined.
The unaltered maximal density of [1251]-iodopindolol binding sites on
mononuclear leukocytes observed in moderately unipolar depressed patients
before treatment compared to controls is in line with our previous
studies. We have shown that the decrease in the number of S2-adrenoceptors
depends on depression severity rather than on its nosographical adherence
(Jeanningros et al., in press). The advantages of using both iodopindolol
as a ligand and intact cells to assess S-adrenoceptor binding in leukocytes
have been discussed in this recent report.
This is the first report of an early decrease in f52-adrenoceptor density
in intact mononuclear leukocytes from depressed patients successfully
treated with amineptine, a selective dopamine uptake inhibitor. The
rapidity of this peripheral effect contrasts with the usual long latency
observed at the central level in Rat following chronic antidepressant
Leukocyte p-receptors and amineptine treatment 363
50
40
E
8 m 30
cl
d, 20
0 0 7 14 21 28
Days of treatment
Fig-l. Individual variations of AMDP rating scores for depression in
depressed patients before treatment (n=lO), and after the first (n=lO) and
the fourth (n-8) week of amineptine treatment. At D7 and at D28, the AMDP-D
scores were significantly lowered as compared to the DO (p<O.Ol and pCO.03,
respectively, Wilcoxon T test). Black triangles represent the treatment
responders and white squares represent non-responders.
z
1300-
In
300 : I I I 1 0 7 14 21 28
Days of treatment
Fig.2. Individual variations of Bmax values in depressed patients before
treatment (n=lO) and after the first( n=lO), and the fourth (n=e) week of
amineptine treatment (ZOOxng/day). At D7, Bmax value of treatment responders
(black triangles) were significantly lowered (pCO.03, Wilcoxon T test). The
non-responders are represented by white squares.
P. Mazzola et al.
r= 0.82; ~~0.01; n=8
-80 -60 40 -20 0 20 40 60 80 100 120
Bmax variation (%I from DO to D7
Fig.3. Relationship between early Bmax changes (after one week of
amineptine treatment) and late AMDP-D score changes ( after one month of
treatment) in depressed patients. Data are relative variations in %.
administration. with amineptine, cortical B-adrenoceptor number decreased
after 2 weeks (Ceci et al., 1986). However, it is unlikely that changes in
circulating &-receptors reflect changes associated with g-receptors at the
central level. In a recent study, Chalezka-Franazeck and Vetulani (1986)
reported that chronic administration of imipramine in rat for 2
months did not affect [3H] -dihydroalprenolol binding to lymphocyte
membranes, though this treatment reduced such binding to the cerebral
cortex.
The few reports on the influence of antidepressant therapies on leukocyte
IS-receptor density have led to inconsistent results. Cooper et al., (1985)
failed to find any significant difference in the number of lymphocyte [3H]-
dihydroalprenolol binding sites after ECT therapy even when the depressed
patients recovered. In contrast, Healy et al., (1983 and 1985) showed that
a three week administration of trazodone or amitryptiline reduced the
density of lymphocyte &-adrenoceptors in moderately depressed patients.
In agreement with the present results, this decrease was only observed in
Leukocyte p-receptors and amineptine treatment 365
treatment responders. However, Bmax changes in the Healy's study only
occured after 3 weeks of treatment and lasted more than 6 weeks. This
difference in the time course of the antidepressant effect could depend on
the action pattern of the antidepressant drug used. Amineptine is
characterized by the rapidity of its clinical efficiency. The Emax decrease
occurred after the first week of amineptine administration as seen by high
patient improvement. After one month of amineptine, Bmax changes were not
similar in all the responders, despite their full clinical improvement.
Five responders exhibited a Bmax decrease and 3 exhibited a Bmax increase
between D7 and D28.
The drastic decrease seen after seven days of amineptine treatment was
only observed in patients who exhibited a stable clinical improvement after
one month of treatment. The non-responders failed to show a similar change
despite a clear but transient improvement at D7. The fact that in all
depressed patients the variation of their clinical state following one
month of treatment was linearly proportional to changes in their i3-receptor
density after one week of treatment is a crucial point. Indeed, the early
reduction in MNL %-adrenoceptor number could be an easily determinable
predictive index for successful antidepressant treatment. Further data are
needed to confirm these results and to examine what parameters may
influence the time course of this effect, e.g. the type of the
antidepressant agent, nosographical category or depression severity.
The present data show that chronic treatment of depressed patients with
amineptine, a drug known to selectively inhibit the dopamine uptake system,
can rapidly decrease the maximal number of mononuclear leukocyte i3-
adrenoceptors. This peripheral effect, which was associated with a stable
clinical improvement, could represent a predictive index of therapeutic
success.
This research was supported by Servier Laboratories of France. The
authors wish to thank H&&ne Rescigno for her technical collaboration.
366 P. Mazzola eta1
American Psychiatric Association. (1980) Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders. 3rd edition. APA, Washington, D. C.
Bobon, D. (1981) Le systeme AMDP. 2e Bdn. D. Bobon (Ed). Mardaga, Bruxelles, pp 151.
Bonnet, J.J., Chagraoui, A., Protais, P. and Costentin, J. (1980 ) Interactions of amineptine with the dopamine uptake system: neurochemical in vitro and in vivo studies . J. Neural. Trans. 69: 211-220.
Boyum, A. (1968) Isolation of mononuclear cells and granulocytes from human blood: isolation of mononuclear cells by one centrifugation and of granulocytes by combining centrifugation and sedimentation at lg. Stand. J. Clin. Lab.Invest Suppl. 21: 77-89.
Bunney, W. E. and Murphy, D. L. (1975) Strategies for the systematic study of the neurotransmitter receptor function in man. In: Pre- and postsynaptic receptors, E. Usdin , W.E. Bunney (eds), pp 283-312. Dekker M. Inc., New York.
Ceci, A., Garattini, S., Gobbi, M. and Mennini T. (1986) Effect of long term amineptine treatment on pre-and postsynaptic mechanisms in rat brain. Br. J. Pharmacol. 88: 269-275.
Carstens, M.E., Engelbercht, A.H., Russel, V.A., Aalbers, C., Gagiano, C.A. and Chalton, D.O., Taljaard, J.J.F. (1987) Beta-adrenoceptors on lymphocytes of patients with major depressive disorder. Psychiatry Res 20: 239-248.
Chaleska-Franaszek, E. and Vetulani, J. (1986) Lack of effect of chronic imipramine administration of B-adrenoceptor density on rat lymphocytes.Pol. J. Pharmacol. Pharm. 38:385-390.
cooper, S.J., Kelly, J.G. and King D.J. (1985) Adrenergic receptors in depression: effect of electroconvulsive therapy. Brit. J. Psychiat 147: 23-29.
Bxtein, I.,Tallman, J., Smith, C.C. and Goodwin F.K. (1979) Changes in lymphocyte beta-adrenergic receptors in depression and mania. Psychiatry. Res. 1: 191-197.
Landmann, R., Biirgisser R. and Biihler F-R. (1983) Human lymphocytes as a model for beta-adrenergic receptors in clinical investigation. J. Recept. Res. 3: 71-88.
Healy, D., Carney P.A. and Leonard B.E. (1983) Monoamine-related markers of depression: Changes following treatment. J. Psychiat. Res. 17: 251-260.
Healy, D., Carney, P.A., 0' Halloran, A. and Leonard B.E. (1985) Peripheral adrenoceptors and serotonin receptors in depression: changes associated with response to treatment with trazodone or amitriptyline. J. Affect. Disor. 9: 286-296.
Jeanningros, R., Mazzola, P., Azorin, J.M., Samuelian, C. and Tissot R. (1990) Beta-adrenoceptor density of intact mononuclear leukocytes in subgroups of depressive disorders. Biol. Psych. in Press.
Magliozzi, J.R., Gietzen, D., Maddock, R.J, Haack, D., Doran, A.R, Goodman, T. and Weiler P.G. (1989) Lymphocyte beta-adrenergic density in patients with unipolar depression and normal controls. Biol. Psych. 26: 15-25.
Leukocyte p-receptorsandamineptine treatment 367
Maj, J., Przegalinski, E. and Mogilnicka, E. (1984) Hypotheses concerning the mecanism of action of antidepressant drugs. Rev. Physiol. Biochem. Pharmacol. 100: l-74.
Pandey, G.N., Janicak, P. and Davis J.M. (1985) Studies of beta-adrenergic receptors in leukocytes of patients with affective illness and effects of antidepressant drugs. Psychopharmacol. Bull. 21: 603-609.
Pandey, G.N., Janicak, P.G. and Davis J.M. (1987) Decreased beta-adrenergic receptors in the leukocytes of depressed patients. Psychiatry. Res. 22: 265-273.
Scatchard. G. (1949) The attraction of nroteins for small molecules and ions. Ann. Ny. Acad. Sci. 51: 660-672:
Sulser, F., Vetulani, J. and Mobley PL. (1978) Mode of action of antidepressant drugs. Biochem. Pharmacol. 27: 257-261.
Inquiries and reprint request should be addressed to :
R&ine Jeanningros, Ph. D. Unite de psychiatric biologique, C.N.R.S. Faculte de medecine 27 Bd Jean moulin 13385 Marseille cedex 5, France