DYTIKOS DIAFVTISMOS -VOULGARIS

download DYTIKOS DIAFVTISMOS -VOULGARIS

of 79

description

XOYLIARA MARIA

Transcript of DYTIKOS DIAFVTISMOS -VOULGARIS

  • EI:

    :

    : .

    2013

    1584

  • 1

    &

  • 2

    , ,

    , 18

    ,

    ,

    . ,

    , ,

    , .

    , ,

    .

    ABSTRACT

    Eugenios Voulgaris, prominent scholar, theologian and ecclesiastical writer, was a

    leading figure of the 18th century, who lived during the great intellectual ferment in the

    West, and is considered by most researchers the introducer of the ideas of the European

    Enlightenment in the Greek area. His contact with the ideological trend of the

    Enlightenment, combined with his versatile teaching, writing and translation work has

    conduced to linking the Greek education with the modern European thought and science,

    thus contributing to the awakening of the nation in a variety of ways. In this paper an

    attempt is made to detect not only the influence of Western Enlightenment on his thought

    but also the points he deviated from this intellectual movement in the light of his Orthodox

    Theology.

  • 3

    ............................................................................................................................... 2

    ........................................................................................................................... 3

    ............................................................................................................................... 5

    ............................................................................................................................... 6

    .............................................................................................................. 7

    ...................................................................................................... 9

    .................................................................................................. 12

    ............................................................................................................... 16

    1. .................................................... 17

    1.1. .................................................................. 17

    1.2. ................................................................................................................. 19

    1.3. ............................................................................................................... 23

    1.4. .......................................................................................................... 26

    2. ................................................... 30

    2.1. .................. 30

    2.2. ................................................................................. 32

    2.2.1. ................................................................................. 33

    2.2.2. ............................................................ 34

    2.2.3. ................................................................................ 36

    2.2.4. .................................................................... 37

    2.3. ....................................................................................................................... 40

    2.3.1. ............................................................................................ 41

    2.3.2. .......................................................................................... 44

    3. ..................................................... 46

    3.1. .................................................................................... 46

    3.2. .................................................... 56

  • 4

    3.2.1. .................................................... 56

    3.2.2. ............................................................. 58

    ..................................................................................................................... 65

    : ............................. 69

    : .................. 72

    ....................................................................................................................... 75

    ........................................................................................................................... 78

    ............................................................................................................. 78

  • 5

    ,

    ,

    .

    ,

    ,

    ,

    .

    ,

    ,

    .

    .

    ,

    .

    , ,

    .

    ,

    ,

    , .

    .

    . , . , .

    .

    .

    , , . ,

    . ,

    .., .

  • 6

    ,

    ,

    .

    ,

    . ,

    , ,

    .

    ,

    ,

    ,

    .

    , .

    ,

    ,

    ,

    , :

    1. ., ,

    ,

    Locke

    2

    , 3 .

    ,

    . ., ,

    1 ., , 1959, . 24.

    2 ., , 1988, . 4-5.

    3 ., , 1988, . 165.

  • 7

    , 4,

    .

    , .

    5,

    6.

    ,

    ,

    .

    ,

    , .

    . ,

    7 .

    , ,

    8.

    ,

    ,

    .

    ,

    , ,

    .

    4 . , , 2009, . 94.

    5 ., , , 1996, . 54.

    6 ., , , .12-13 .-. 1990, . 175.

    7 ., , , , 2001, . 84.

    8 . , , , 2008, . 30.

  • 8

    .

    .

    ,

    .

    :

    ,

    ,

    , . ,

    ,

    . ,

    -

    ,

    .

    Locke. , , ,

    ,

    ,

    .

  • 9

    17 18

    ,

    , .

    , , ,

    ,

    , ,

    .

    , Denis

    Diderot, John Locke Jean-Jacques Rousseau. Kant9

    :

    , .

    ()

    . .

    .

    , .

    ,

    . ,

    ,

    , , ,

    10. ,

    ,

    , ,

    . , .

    Rene Descartes ,

    Hobbes Spinoza ,

    .

    9 Kant I. .., ; , ., , 1989, . 19.

    10 . , : , , 2005, . 15.

  • 10

    John Locke ,

    , .

    1721 1795.

    , , .

    , ,

    .

    ,

    ,

    , .

    ,

    Diderot.11

    ,

    , .

    ,

    . Diderot

    , , Rousseau J.- J.,

    Montesquieu dAlembert.

    . , ,

    .

    , 12.

    ,

    - .

    ,

    , , , .

    ,

    .

    15 16 , ,

    11 ., , , 1996, . 13-16.

    12 ., , 2009, . 6.

  • 11

    Leibniz, Christian Wolff

    Descartes13.

    .

    , 18

    ,

    . ,

    14.

    13 . , , , 2005, . 458-461.

    14 . . , , , 1996 , . 13-18.

  • 12

    , , ,

    . ,

    , ,

    , .

    , ,

    .

    , , 17 ,

    ,

    , 15.

    ,

    , .

    . ,

    , ,

    .

    16.

    ,

    ,

    .

    .

    .

    ,

    , ,

    15 ., , , , 2009, .1.

    16 ., , , , 2009, . 25-26.

  • 13

    .

    ,

    17. 1669,

    : ) (

    ),

    ) ( ) ) .

    ,

    .

    ,

    , .

    , ,

    . :

    . 15 ,

    . ( )

    , ,

    , 18.

    ,

    , 19.

    ,

    ,

    . :

    ( , , , ),

    ( , ,

    17 . : , University Studio Press, 2001, .78.

    18 ., , , , 2006,

    . 83.

    19 , , .

  • 14

    ) 20 .

    ( 1780),

    , 21.

    , ,

    .

    1805

    .

    , ,

    .

    , ,

    . , , ,

    .

    , , ,

    , ,

    .

    . .22

    , , ,

    , , . .

    20

    ,

    .

    ,

    .

    21 , :

    , , . .,

    , , ., , , 1975, . 3.

    22 ., , , . 2, 1980-

    1981, . 223.

  • 15

    .23.

    , ,

    . ,

    , , 24.

    ,

    ,

    .

    18

    1774. 18

    , ,

    ,

    , .

    1821 ,

    . ,

    25 26.

    , ,

    Bacon Hobbes,

    . , ,

    (1800),

    (1718)27. ,

    23 ., , , , 2009, . 25.

    24 ., , , 1-3 2006 , . 599.

    25 . . . , , , . ., , , 1996, . 75-77.

    26 ., , 2009, . 14-15.

    27 ., , 2009, . 14-15 ., , , 1996, . 41-42.

  • 16

    , .

    .

    ,

    . ,

    .

    :

    , .

    .

    ,

    , .

  • 17

    1.

    ,

    ,

    .

    1.1.

    17 ,

    ,

    . ,

    ,

    .

    ,

    .

    ( ) .

    ,

    16 17 . ,

    .

    , ,

    28.

    , 29.

    , (

    )30,

    . ,

    ,

    28 . . , , , 1996, . 28.

    29 . , . , , 1-3 2006, . 525-527.

    30 1454 , , .

  • 18

    , .

    ,

    .

    , ,

    31.

    17 ,

    1624,

    ,

    .

    , , . ,

    , ,

    . ,

    , 15

    17

    . ,

    .

    ,

    ( 1641) ,

    ,

    , 1646.

    ,

    , 32.

    , ,

    .

    31 . , 18 . , , 2001, . 52-55.

    32 . . , , , 1996 , . 27-32.

  • 19

    1.2.

    O (1716-1806)

    .

    .33 .34

    .

    ,

    , 35

    . ,

    Stephen Batalden36 .

    , ,

    37. .38,

    (1665-1763)

    (1725-1730/31). , 1725,

    (

    )39,

    , .

    Locke. 40.

    ,

    33 ., , . ', . . , 1838, . - : ., , . .

    34 ., , / , . . , . , A. (Anton v. Haykul), 1830-1832, . 559.

    35 ., , . , . -.

    36 Batalden S., Catherine II ' s greek prelate Eugenios Voulgaris in Russia 1771- 1806, New York 1982, . 1

    37 . , , , 1766, --, ., , 2010, . . 16 , : , . , 2010.

    38 ., . 1453-1821, ., 1868.

    39 ., John Locke, : , , 1988, . 2-3.

    40 . , , , 1986, . 119-122.

  • 20

    . .,

    , ,

    41. ,

    , .

    .

    42. 1737 1738

    .

    ,

    ,

    . , ,

    (, ),

    (, , ).

    . .

    , ,

    ( , )

    1740-1742,

    .

    .

    Giuseppe Suzz,

    43.

    ,

    .

    .

    . ,

    41 ., (16 -18 .), , , 2003, . 184.

    42 - ., . - 1770-1774, , 1982, . 36,58-59.

    43 ., : . 19 . , , , . 10, 1996, . 143-144.

  • 21

    .

    ,

    , ,

    .

    , . ,

    , , .

    , .

    ,

    , ,

    44.

    , 1742 1753

    , 1750-1751/1752

    - , . Podskalsky G.45.

    1742-1745,1748/1749-1753 ,

    , 1745-1748/1749. 46 ,

    Locke, Leibniz, Christian Wolff

    Descartes47, .

    , 1753-1759 ,

    1759-1762/1763

    48. ( ,

    ), ,

    .

    44 . , , , 1985, . 85-87.

    45 Podskalsky G., 1453-1821, . . . , 2005, . 429.

    46 26 , ( , ). .

    47 , ., , , 1996, . 57.

    48 .

  • 22

    : - ( )

    - - - ,

    18 .

    ,

    . (1766),

    , .

    1771 ,

    .

    , (1772).

    ,

    , , ,

    , , ,

    , 1767,

    49.

    1774 -

    -

    . 1775

    ( ) ,

    Batalden50,

    .. 1779 .

    49 1771 :

    , ,

    [= ] [= ],

    [=] !

    , ,

    .

    , ,

    . ,

    . ,

    , , . , .,

    , , . 19, 1993, . 68-69.

    50 Batalden S., Catherine II ' s greek prelate Eugenios Voulgaris in Russia 1771- 1806, Columbia University

    Press, New York 1982, . 53.

  • 23

    . ,

    ,

    .

    .

    ,

    51.

    ,

    , (

    ),

    .

    1806 ,

    .

    1.3.

    ( ) ( )

    .

    . , ,

    , .

    ,

    .

    .

    , .

    . ,

    , ,

    . , ,

    . , ,

    51

    Batalden S., Catherine II ' s greek prelate Eugenios Voulgaris in Russia 1771- 1806, Columbia University

    Press, New York 1982, . 72.

  • 24

    . ,

    52.

    ,

    ,

    . ,

    (

    ) 53.

    , ,

    .

    .

    , .

    , - Batalden54 -

    ,

    .

    (1756),

    .

    ( )

    .

    ,

    ,

    52 . . , . , , 1-3 2006, . 350-363.

    53 Batalden S., . , , 1-3 2006, . 43-44.

    54 Batalden S., Catherine II ' s greek prelate Eugenios Voulgaris in Russia 1771- 1806, Columbia University

    Press, New York 1982, . 59-64.

  • 25

    . Podskalsky G.,

    55.

    ,

    . 1766

    , , Memnon ou la sagesse

    humaine . 1766

    ,

    , .

    56.

    , 57,

    .

    1768 Essai historique et

    critique sur les dissensions des eglises de Pologne

    . . 58

    ,

    .

    59 .

    ,

    ,

    . , 1768-1775

    .

    55 odskalsky G. , ,

    , Podskalsky G.,

    1453-1821, . . . , 2005, . 431-432.

    56 , . 66.

    57 ., , . , . .

    58 ., , . , . .

    59 : , 1767, , .

  • 26

    , ,

    ,

    . .

    ,

    ,

    , 60, .

    1.4.

    , ,

    , ,

    .

    ,

    ,

    61. , ,

    , ,

    . .

    . 1753 ,

    1750-1751/1752 . , 1753,

    , ,

    , , .

    , ,

    .

    . ,

    . ,

    , ,

    60 , , . .

    61 . , , , .1, 1850-1851, . 496-497.

  • 27

    ,

    , ,

    ,

    , .

    ,

    s Gravesande W. ( ), Genovesi

    A. ( ), Wolff C. ( ) 62 ..

    ,

    , . .

    , ,

    , 63.

    .

    . .

    , ,

    .

    ,

    64 .

    .

    ,

    65.

    66.

    :

    , ,

    ,

    . .,

    62 . , , , 1988, . 123.

    63 ., , . 1832, . 566.

    64 . , , , , 2001, . 76-77.

    65 ., : . 19 . , , . 9 & 10, 1996, . 87-108. . 139-183.

    66 ., , . , . 54-64.

  • 28

    , ,

    ,

    , 67.

    ,

    ,

    ,

    68.

    , ,

    . ,

    , 1759.

    ,

    , .

    :

    , .

    , ,

    . ,

    ,

    , , 69.

    ,

    70.

    ,

    ,

    .

    .

    26 1761,

    67 . , , , .1, 1850-1851, . 499.

    68 ., : . 19 . , , , . 9, 1996, . 90-91.

    69 . , , . 19 . , , , . 9, 1996, . 87-88.

    70 ., , . , . .

  • 29

    , 71.

    , ,

    ,

    . ,

    . , .

    ,

    ,

    72.

    .

    ,

    73. .

    , .

    , ,

    , ,

    74.

    ( ), .

    , ,

    .

    , 20 ,

    .

    , .

    71 ., , (), . 11 , 1967, . 56.

    72 . , , : , .2 , , , . 353.

    73 ., : (1453-1821), 1868, . 569.

    74 . , Voltaire J.Locke . , , . 52, 2002, . 79-80.

  • 30

    2.

    , .

    2.1.

    (1757-1761), 1759

    .

    ,

    75 76.

    77, . ,

    ,

    78.

    ,

    .

    17

    , , 79,

    , . ,

    ,

    ,

    .

    ,

    75 ., , . , . 41-45.

    76 ., , . , . 45-46.

    77 ., , 1985, . 175-198.

    78 . (.), , , , , 8, , 1957, . 29.

    79 ., , . , . 64.

  • 31

    ,

    . 80

    ,

    , 3

    (381 )81 9 , 17 28 (451

    )82.

    .

    , ,

    ,

    ,

    .

    83, , , .

    ,

    , o

    .

    ,

    , . 84 ,

    , ,

    .

    80 ., , . . 69.

    81 .(, , , , ) .

    82 9 17 28 . . . , , 1992, . 835-839.

    83 . 1.35-41 , . , . ; ; . , ' . . .

    84 ., , . . 72.

  • 32

    ,

    ,

    .

    85 ,

    ,

    .

    86 .

    87. ,

    , ,

    ,

    .

    2.2.

    Essai historique et critique sur les dissensions des eglises de

    Pologne

    .

    -

    ,

    . ,

    ,

    . ,

    85 ., . , , 1-3 2006, . 238.

    86 ., , . ', . 73-74.

    87 , ,

    ( ) . ., , . ', . 77., ( (), .6, 1965, .367.

  • 33

    .

    88.

    ,

    .

    , ,

    89,

    ,

    .

    2.2.1.

    :

    ,

    ,

    , , ,

    ,

    ,

    90.

    , ,

    . ,

    , .

    , ,

    .

    88 ., , . ', . . , ,1838, . .

    89 ., B ( ), , 1-3 2006 , . 304.

    90 ., , . ', . . , ,1838, . 151, : .

  • 34

    2.2.2.

    :

    , , 91.

    ,

    , ,

    .

    , 92.

    , 93.

    :

    .

    ,

    6. 25.

    . ,

    ,

    .

    94.

    .

    ,

    .

    : , , ,

    , ,

    , ,

    , ,

    91 , . 151.

    92 , . 152.

    93 , . 153.

    94 , . 153-154.

  • 35

    (, ). ,

    .

    , . ,

    ,

    ,

    , ,

    . , , ,

    95.

    .

    96.

    , ,

    ,

    ,

    .

    ,

    , .

    .

    . ,

    . ,

    ,

    .

    97.

    :

    ,

    95 , . 157.

    96 , . 158.

    97 , . 160 ..

  • 36

    .

    . ,

    ,

    .

    .

    .

    ,

    .

    , , ,

    .

    2.2.3.

    ,

    ,

    . , ,

    .

    ,

    98.

    . 99

    .

    , , ,

    ,

    .

    98 , . 171.

    99 , .

  • 37

    . ,

    . ,

    .

    .

    .

    , ,

    .

    , ,

    . ,

    ,

    , .

    .

    , ,

    .

    , (,

    , ..), (, ,

    ). .

    .

    ,

    100.

    2.2.4.

    ,

    101.

    100 , . 170-192.

    101 , . 193-223.

  • 38

    (320-390 .)

    102

    . 103

    . -

    . -

    .

    , ,

    .

    ,

    .

    , , .

    .

    , ,

    104.

    ,

    ,

    .

    102 ,

    .

    103 .

    104 , . 199.

  • 39

    , , ,

    , .

    , .

    .

    . ,

    ,

    .

    .

    ,

    ,

    .

    ,

    ,

    .

    , .

    .

    . ,

    ,

    ( , )

    .

    , ,

    ,

    .

    105

    .

    ,

    105 .

  • 40

    ,

    106.

    , ,

    ,

    , , .

    107.

    2.3.

    , ,

    108,

    .

    . ,

    , .

    ,

    , ,

    .

    ,

    , 109

    ,

    110.

    106 ., , . , . .

    107 , . 223.

    108 ., , , 1766, --, ., , , 2010. .

    109 ,

    110 , . , 2010, .. 66, 86-87.

  • 41

    .

    . ,

    ,

    . .

    2.3.1.

    . ,

    ,

    ,

    .

    ,

    .

    , ,

    ,

    , , .

    111. , ,

    .

    , .

    , Bacon .,

    .

    , ,

    ,

    . , ,

    ,

    111 , . 37.

  • 42

    ,

    112.

    .

    .

    113 ,

    .

    114.

    , ,

    .

    ( ,

    ). ,

    ,

    115 ,

    ,

    . , 116

    117.

    ,

    17 18 , :

    112 ., , 2010, . 114-127 , , , . 25, . , 1996, . 39-48.

    113 , . 49.

    114 , . 50.

    115 , . 58.

    116 3

    117 ., , 2010, . 128-134.

  • 43

    , , .

    118.

    ,

    , ,

    .

    , ,

    , .

    ,

    (, , ), ,

    119.

    ,

    . ,

    120, : 121,

    , ,

    , ,

    , .

    122, (

    , , ,

    ). , ,

    ,

    123.

    118 ., , 2010, . 134-140.

    119 ., , 2010, . 140-142.

    120 , . 130.

    121 , : , , 2005. , , ., , 2010, . 143 (. 539).

    122 , , ., , 2010, . 144 (. 543).

    123 ., , 2010, . 142-144.

  • 44

    2.3.2.

    124

    ,

    Locke

    ( ),

    125: . . . .

    .

    126, ,

    ,

    127. 128 .

    ,

    ,

    . ,

    ( ),

    ( ) (

    , ),

    , .

    129,

    .

    ,

    124 ., , 2010, . 146-153.

    125 , . 157.

    126 ., , 2010, . 153-159.

    127 .

    128

    , ., , 2010, .154.

    129 ., , 2010, . 160-162.

  • 45

    ,

    .

    , 130,

    , .

    ,

    , ,

    . ,

    ,

    .

    131

    ,

    , , ,

    .

    , .

    . ,

    , ,

    . ,

    . ,

    , ,

    . ( ),

    ( ) .

    .

    130 ., , 2010, . 162-165. 131 ., , 2010, . 166-170.

  • 46

    3.

    132. .,

    , : ,

    ,

    133.

    ,

    ,

    .

    3.1.

    ,

    . 1766,

    , , ,

    .

    Essai historique et critique sur les dissensions des eglises de Pologne,

    1768

    . .

    , 1767,

    .

    Locke

    , Epistola de tolerantia,

    . 1764

    132

    . , , , .12-13 .-. 1990,

    . 175.

    133 ., , . , . .

  • 47

    . .

    ,

    , ,

    134.

    Essai historique et critique sur les dissensions des eglises

    de Pologne, 1767,

    . ,

    ,

    .

    , ,

    .

    .

    ,

    , ,

    135

    ,

    .

    134 . , Voltaire J.Locke . , , . 52, 2002, . 88.

    135 ,

    ,

    ,

    .

    (1555), , (1648),

    (1598 1787),

    (1689)

    (1781) . . ,

    (.-. .), , 2001, . 17-18.

  • 48

    .

    . 136

    137,

    138

    139.

    .

    ,

    ,

    . ,

    ,

    tolerantia ,

    , Tolerantiam

    140. .

    .141 142, ,

    143.

    136 . , , , 2008, .77.

    137 ., , . , . 9.

    138 ., , . , . 13.

    139 ., , . , . 25 74

    140 , . 151.

    141 ., , , 1996, . 65.

    142 ., . , , .7, 1990, . 12-13, . 171.

    143 . , , , , 2001, . 86.

  • 49

    tolerantia . .

    ,

    .

    ,

    .

    ,

    ,

    .144

    .,

    , ,

    Locke. Locke

    145, ,

    ,

    . Locke

    , ,

    146.

    Locke

    147.

    Locke

    .

    Locke. , Locke,

    144 . , , , 2009, . 36-37.

    145 Locke J., .Epistola de tolerantia (.-.-. ), . , 1998, . 125 ..

    146 . , Voltaire J.Locke . , , . 52, 2002, . 91-100.

    147 . , Voltaire J.Locke . , , . 52, 2002, . 100-101.

  • 50

    , ,

    ( ).

    Locke

    .

    Locke

    ,

    . ,

    ,

    .

    ,

    .

    ,

    ,

    ,

    , .

    ,

    , . Locke148,

    149 ,

    ,

    .

    ,

    Locke J. 18 ,

    , , ,

    , , , , , , ,

    .

    148 . . Locke J., .Epistola de tolerantia (.-.-. ), . , 1998, . 153-154.

    149 , , , . 175-176.

  • 51

    .150 Locke

    151.

    .

    ,

    Samuel Pufendorf ,

    (1687) 152. Locke

    ,

    , 153.

    ,

    154. ,

    17 , Hugo Grotius155,

    156.

    2 .

    ,

    150 ., , , 1-3 2006, . 260.

    151 Hunger H., , , . , , 1987, . 245-256.

    152 ., . , , 1-3 2006, .119.

    153 , . 198.

    154 , . 205-206.

    155 Hugo Grotius (16 -17 .) , , . , , . , , , : , , .

    156 . , , , .12-13 .-. 1990, . 176.

  • 52

    . 157, Locke158,

    , 159,

    .

    , ,

    ,

    ,

    .

    ,

    .

    . ,

    ,

    , Bacon, s Gravesande,

    Wolff, Buddeus, Brucker, Leibnitz, Locke,

    160, 161.

    , .162 , 163

    164.

    , ,

    ,

    .

    ,

    .

    ,

    157 , . 207.

    158 Locke J., .Epistola de tolerantia (.-.-. ), . , 1998, . 185-187.

    159 . 9, 1-26 10, 1-15.

    160 , . 37.

    161 1 .

    162 , . 377 . 1.

    163 , . 362 , .1, . 405 . 2 3.

    164 , . 356 , .1, . 399 . 2, 405 . 2, 406 . 1.

  • 53

    165.

    .

    ,

    , 166.

    John Locke,

    . Essay Concerning

    Human Understanding,

    167 :

    ,

    , 168.

    Locke . ,

    Locke , (

    )169 170 ( Locke reflection),

    , ,

    , 171.

    172, Locke

    ,

    .

    .

    , . ,

    , Locke,

    .

    165 ., , , 1996, . 57.

    166 , . 37, . 396, . 1, . 408 . 1.

    167 . , , 1988, . 17.

    168 , . 139, . 2.

    169 , . 160.

    170 , . 159.

    171 , . 158.

    172 ., , , , . 10, 2005, . 136-146.

  • 54

    , 173.

    ,

    .

    ,

    , 174.

    , 175

    , ,

    Des Mensonges Imprimes et du Testament Politique du Cardinal de

    Richelieu ,

    .

    ,

    .

    Leibniz

    s Gravesande Genovesi.

    176, ,

    Leibniz ,

    177.

    Christian Wolff, Philosophia Rationalis

    sive Logica ,

    . ,

    178. Wolff

    , Wolff

    Locke. O Wolff

    173 , . 66-67.

    174 , . 63-65.

    175 , . 311, . 1.

    176 , . 408-409, . 1.

    177 ., , . 101, 102 . 356.

    178 , . 139-140.

  • 55

    179. Wolff

    . ,

    Wolff

    ,

    , .

    Wolff,

    180.

    Bacon ,

    ,

    181.

    , ,

    Bacon182

    . Henderson

    Locke, .

    Bacon, 183.

    ,

    .

    . ,

    . ,

    ,

    , , ,

    184.

    179 , . 127-128, . 1.

    180 ., , , 1996, . 62-63.

    181 , . 137.. 1.

    182 ., , . 134.

    183 ., : , , 2005,

    . 340.

    184 ., , . 70.

  • 56

    3.2.

    , ,

    ,

    .

    3.2.1.

    185

    . 1054,

    ,

    . , ,

    . (1215)186.

    (1277-1280)

    187 (1439)188,

    , .

    17 , ,

    ,

    ,

    .

    ,

    185 . unio . , , .

    186 , .

    187 / , , .

    188 : ., Filique, . .

  • 57

    .

    () ,

    .

    , . 1626-1641,

    189.

    , ,

    ,

    . ,

    , o

    ,

    .

    .

    . ,

    190, .

    ,

    .

    ,

    .

    -. 1596,

    191 .

    . ,

    .

    189 ., ,

    1626-1641, , . 29, 1994, . 120-121.

    190 , . , , 2001, . 83.

    191 , .

  • 58

    , . ,

    ,

    ,

    192.

    3.2.2.

    , 2

    ,

    , .

    ,

    ,

    . ,

    , ,

    .

    . ,

    , ,

    ,

    ,

    193.

    .

    .

    194, , , ,

    ; !

    !

    192 . , 1793 : , , 1-3 2006, . 140-143.

    193 . , , , .1, 1850-1851, . 501.

    194 ., , . . 83.

  • 59

    Podskalsky G. ,

    195. , ,

    ,

    , 196,

    . ,

    ,

    , ,

    197.

    ,

    ,

    , .

    Locke, ,

    Locke ,

    , . Locke,

    , ,

    198, .

    , Locke

    ,

    -

    195 Podskalsky G., 1453-1821, . . . , 2005, . 432.

    196 Podskalsky G., 1453-1821, . . . , 2005, . 439.

    197 . , , , 2008, . 38-40.

    198 Locke J., . Epistola de tolerantia (.-.-. .), , 1998, .141. , , . , , , ,

  • 60

    , , .

    , 2 , ,

    .

    .

    , ,

    .

    ,

    , , ,

    ( 3.15), ( . 2.23)

    ( 2.23, 4.2, 4.5).

    , ,

    199

    200.

    - .

    ,

    ,

    Henderson201. ,

    202,

    . ,

    , , , ,

    203.

    ,

    (. 18.8, 9, 17)

    ( 3.10, .. 5.9,11)

    . ( , G 31), (

    , PG 57), ( , . PG 123),

    ( , ). ( ),

    (. 5.9-13), ,

    199 , . 153-154.

    200 . 28.19-20.

    201 Henderson G. , 1620-1830. , . . . , (), 1994, . 107.

    202 , . 157, . .

    203 , . 165-169.

  • 61

    ,

    .

    ,

    ,

    , 204.

    , , ,

    ,

    , , .

    , 205 ,

    ,

    .

    , 206,

    ,

    207.

    ,

    (. 5), ,

    ,

    .208.

    ,

    , ,

    . ,

    , . ,

    204 , , , , . 169. 205, . 169. 206 , . 170. 207 . , , , 2009, . 59-60. 208 , . 174.

  • 62

    ,

    ,

    .

    . ,

    Locke ,

    , , ,

    .

    ,

    .

    , Bossuet.

    209,

    ,

    210. Bossuet,

    , ,

    . ,

    Bossuet, 211.

    , .

    209 , . 201.

    210 , . 211, 217

    211 ( , ) , , , , . () , , , ( , , ) , , , ; , . 211.

  • 63

    (24.8.1572)212

    ,

    , ,

    . ,

    ,

    .

    , 213.

    ,

    . ,

    ,

    214 .

    ,

    215 ,

    , (),

    . 216

    ,

    , , ,

    ,

    217. ,

    212 ,

    . . ,

    . 218.

    213 ., : , , 2005 .339.

    214 18 . . .

    215 , . 199. 216 ., , , , . 10 , 2005, . 136-137.

    217 , .158. . 2.9 , , .

  • 64

    218

    () .

    ,

    ,

    . ,

    219.

    .

    ,

    ,

    .

    220.

    .

    ,

    221.

    218 , . 261.

    219 , . 63-64.

    220 ,61-65.

    221 ., , , 2008 .

    40.

  • 65

    .

    , ,

    . ,

    .

    ,

    ,

    .

    ,

    ,

    ,

    .

    , 222.

    .

    ,

    , ,

    . , ,

    .

    , 20 ,

    ( ),

    ,

    , .

    222

    .

  • 66

    . ,

    , :

    ,

    .

    223.

    .

    , Essai historique et critique sur les

    dissensions des eglises de Pologne,

    .

    ,

    ,

    , .

    ,

    224.

    , ,

    .

    , Wolff, Locke 225,

    223 , , . , , , , , . , , , . , (PG 36, . 508-509).

    224 ., ( ), , 1-3 2006, . 299-304.

    225 , , .

  • 67

    .

    , .,

    ,

    . .

    ,

    226

    ,

    , 227.

    Batalden228

    . , ,

    .

    ,

    ,

    .

    . .,

    ,

    ,

    ,

    ,

    229.

    226 . , , , 2008, .30.

    227 .,

    , , . 71-72, 1994, .92.

    228 Batalden St., . , , 1-3 2006, . 34-45.

    229 ., , , . 54, 1995, . 33.

  • 68

    .

    , ,

    , .

    , , ,

    - .

    .,

    ,

    ,

    ,

    230 ., .

    . ,

    ,

    231,

    .

    230 . (.), , , , , 8, , 1957, . 29.

    231 . , , , .12-13 .-. 1990, .169.

  • 69

    :

    . 2 . ,

    1801.

    . , 1784 [

    ].

    . .

    ,

    ,

    . , 1775 [

    , Legrand

    ].

    ,

    , 1805.

    "Breves Adnotatiunculae, in numero 68". . [ .

    [Batalden, 1982:

    150]].

    "Contra existementem se solvissa per elementarem geometriam problema: Datis

    duabus rectis lineis, invenire duas medias in proportione continua". .

    [ .

    [Batalden, 1982: 150]].

    . , 1804.

    . , 1805.

    , , ,

    , . , 1774.

    . , 1773.

  • 70

    " ad Binas Philosophicas Questiones ex operibus philosophicis

    doctissimis Theophanis Procopovitz". . [

    [Batalden, 1982: 150]].

    . , 1850.

    . , 1797.

    . , 1775. [

    , , :

    ].

    " ". , 1812.

    [

    ].

    Istoricheskoe rozyskanie o vremeni kreshcheniia rosiiskoi velikoi kniagini Olgi.

    , 1792. [ , -.

    ].

    .

    .

    , 1806.

    " ". .

    . , 1766.

    " ".

    , 1838.

    ,

    . , 1767.

    "Otvet mitropolitu rimsko-katolicheskoi tserkvi Stanislavu Sestrentsevichu na

    vopros ego, Kakim iazykom govorili drevnie sarmaty?". 1805. [

    .

    [Batalden, 1982: 155]].

    [Otvet preosviashchennomu Methodiiu, arkhiepiskopu Tverskomu] , 1805.

    [. .

  • 71

    Latinskaia tserkovnaia istoriia [Batalden,

    1982: 155]].

    . , 1805.

    . . , 1844.

    . , 1868.

    "Problematis Censura". .

    de Zichis ad Czechos designandos extorsis: Tum de erroribus a P.

    Dobnero in lingua commissis. , 1772.

    . , 1768. [

    ].

    , .

    , 1772.

    " ". .

    . , 1805.

    . , 1872.

    , . , 1768-1775.

    [ ,

    ].

    . ,

    1756.

    "Zapiska o luchshem sposobe vossoedineniia uniatov s pravoslavnoiu tserkoviu".

    1887. [ , ,

    . ].

    ( : http://www.lib.uoa.gr/hellinomnimon/authors//Voulgaris.htm)

  • 72

    :

    [ -

    [1939, 1941, 1957], Batalden [1982]

    [1993]. Pourchot

    ,

    .]

    -

    Aurelius Augustinus ( ) [354-430]. . ,

    1804.

    Bossuet, Jean Benigne [1627-1704].

    , . .

    Duhamel, Jean-Baptiste [1624-1706]. . .

    Fortunato de Brescia [1701-1754]. . , 1805.

    Gavriil (Petrov) [1730-1801]. ,

    - . ,

    1799.

    Genovesi, Antonio [1712-1769]. . , 1806.

    Horn, Georg [1620-1670]. "

    ". .

    Jenyns, Soame [1704-1787].

    . . , 1842.

    Jenyns, Soame, Velgos Deausovros Augustin Calmet [1672-1757].

    . , 1804.

    Lange, Joachim [1670-1744]. . , 1776.

    Leclerc, Pierre [1706-1773 (;)] . .

    Locke, John [1632-1704].

    . .

    Petrov, Vasilii Petrovich [1736-1799].

    . , 1775.

  • 73

    Platon (Levshin) [1737-1812].

    .

    , 1801.

    Pourchot, Edme.

    . .

    Prokopovich, Feofan [1681-1736]. "

    " , .

    , 1784.

    Prokopovich, Feofan [1681-1736]. ., 1916.

    Quirini, Angelo Maria [1680-1755] Feith, Everard [1585 (;)1625 (;)].

    ' . . :

    . , 1804.

    Samuil (Mislavskii) [1731-1796]. . , 1779.

    Samuil (Mislavskii) [1731-1796].

    ,

    . , 1779.

    Segner, Johann Andreas von [1704-1777].

    . , 1767.

    SGravesande, Willem Jacob van [1688-1742]. ,

    . : . . ,

    1805.

    Tacquet, Andre [1612-1660].

    . , 1805.

    Tierce, G. della. : . , 1772.

    Voltaire, Francois Marie Aruet de [1694-1778]. . ,

    1766.

    Voltaire, Francois Marie Aruet de [1694-1778].

    . . , 1768.

    Voltaire, Francois Marie Aruet de [1694-1778].

    . , 1771(;).

    Voltaire, Francois Marie Aruet de [1694-1778]. .

    , 1771(;).

  • 74

    Voltaire, Francois Marie Aruet de [1694-1778]. .

    , 1772(;).

    Voltaire, Francois Marie Aruet de [1694-1778]. [ , ].

    . , 1771(;).

    Wolff, Christian [1679-1754]. . .

    Wucherer, Johann Friedriech. .

    .

    Zoernikav, Adam [ 17 .]

    . 2 . , 1797. [

    [Batalden, 1982: 164]. T

    .]

    -

    [1729-1796].

    '. , 1771.

    [1729-1796].

    ,

    . .

    [. 570 - . 478 ..] Stikhotvoreniia. , 1794.

    [70-19 ..] ' .

    , 1786.

    [70-19 ..] ' . 3 .

    , 1791-1792.

    , .

    . , 1771(;).

    .

    ., 1805.

    ( : http://www.lib.uoa.gr/hellinomnimon/authors//Voulgaris.htm)

  • 75

    ., , 1988

    .,

    , , . 19, 1993

    ., ,

    . ', . . , 1838

    ., ,

    . ', . . , 1838

    ., , , 2005

    Batalden S., Catherine II ' s greek prelate Eugenios Voulgaris in Russia 1771- 1806,

    Columbia University Press, New York 1982

    Batalden S., . ,

    , 1-3 2006

    .,

    (.-. .), , 2001, . 17-18.

    ., , 1766

    --, ., ,

    , 2010

    ., , , 1992

    , , PG 36

    ., ,

    (), . 11 , 1967

    ., Voltaire J.Locke

    . , , . 52, 2002

    ., , 2009

    ., ,

    ,

    , . 10 , 2005

    . , , , 1994

  • 76

    Henderson G., 1620-1830.

    , . . . , (),

    1994

    Hunger H., , , .

    , , 1987

    (), . 6 , 1965

    ., . ,

    , 1-3 2006

    ., ,

    1626-1641, , 29, 1994

    ., , , .1, 1850-1851

    Kant I. .., ; , .,

    , 1989

    ., , , 1986

    ., , ,

    2008

    ., , ,

    1996

    ., , , .12-13

    .-. 1990

    ., , , . 54, 1995

    Knapp M., Evgenios Vulgaris in Einfluss der Aufklarung, Amsterdam 1984

    ., , ,

    . 2, 1980-1981

    ., . ,

    , 1-3 2006

    , , ,

    . 25, . , 1996

    Locke J., . Epistola de tolerantia (.-.-.

    .), , 1998

  • 77

    ., : .

    19 . , , . 9

    & 10, 1996

    ., , , 2009

    ., , , , 2001

    ., ( ),

    , 1-3 2006

    - ., . - 1770-1774,

    , 1982

    .,

    , , . 71-72, 1994

    ., , , ., , , 1975

    ., : ,

    , 2005

    ., , 1956

    . ., .

    ,

    , 1-3 2006

    .,

    18 .

    ,, , 2001

    ., . ,

    , 1-3 2006

    ., , ,

    , 2006

    Podskalsky G., 1453-1821.

    , . . .

    , 2005

    ., :

    (1453-1821), 1868

    ., ,

    , 1-3 2006

  • 78

    . (.), , , , , 8,

    , 1957

    ., (16 -18 .),

    , , 2003

    . , , 1992

    ., , 1985

    ., :

    , University Studio Press, 2001

    ., .

    : John Locke

    , , 2008

    Conticello C., La Theologie Byzantine et sa Tradition II, Turnhout Brepols Publishers,

    2002

    .,

    , ,

    . . , . , A.

    (Anton v. Haykul), 1830-1832

    http://anemi.lib.uoc.gr/metadata/5/5/7/metadata-22-0000240.tkl (

    10-9-13 16:22.)

    http://www.lib.uoa.gr/hellinomnimon/authors//Voulgaris.htm (

    22-9-13 20:32.)