BOOK REVIEWS
Transcript of BOOK REVIEWS
BOOK REVIEWS
Instrumental Methods of Chemical Analysis, 3rd Edition. Galen W. Ewing. χ + 627 pages. McGraw-Hill Book Co., 330 West 42nd St., New York, Ν. Υ. 10036. 1969. $12.50
Reviewed by Jonathan W. Amy, Department of Chemistry, Purdue University, Lafayette, Ind. 47907
This Third Edition is an attempt to survey modern analytical instruments and techniques and to present this information in a comprehensible manner for undergraduate or first-year graduate students. I t is designed to follow or run concurrently with Physical Chemistry. Like previous editions, the book is divided into a descriptive section and a section containing 25 laboratory experiments.
As in the Second Edition, related methods are grouped together; basic principles are discussed in an introductory chapter, followed by detailed descriptions of specific methods. Thus, the interaction of matter is treated in the general case. Terms are defined, using 1963 NBS designations, relationships are presented, and the physics of emission, dispersion, and detection of radiant energy is discussed in a readable manner. Following this is a long chapter on absorption of ultraviolet and visible radiation, complete with 13 problems. Both the methodology and instrumentation are covered.
A separate chapter defines fluorim-etry and phosphorimetry and briefly describes several commercial instruments. This is work done prior to 1966, and omits mention of high-speed pulse systems. The chapter on infrared spectrometry covers structural correlations, instrumentation, and sampling techniques. Problems associated with the chapter emphasize the quantitative aspects of infrared, as does the suggested experiment on the quantitation of xylene isomers. A long chapter on the analytical aspects of flames helps to put flame emission, atomic absorption, atomic fluorescence, and flame absorption in proper perspective. Polar-imetry, ORD, scattering of radiation, emission, and X-ray methods complete the section on spectrometry.
Electrochemistry is covered in five chapters, starting with an introductory chapter defining terms and conventions. A number of problems are given with each chapter and operational amplifier circuitry is used in many of the equipment illustrations.
NMR, radioactivity, and mass spectrometry have been grouped together as methods which look at the nuclei and the interaction of matter and electromagnetic forces. This material is sufficient to give an understanding of the physical basis of the methods, but does not go into nearly the detail some would like.
A good chapter on interphase separations introduces chromatography, extraction, and electrical separation methods. These need to be unified, as done by the author, so that students will relate the various techniques. Some would argue that separations are not instrumental analysis, but there is a lot of effort being expended in this area and it belongs in such a book.
A book of this type crams a great deal of subject matter between its covers. The treatment of individual subjects may seem slighted, yet expansion could come only at the expense of other material or of price. The Third Edition is 170 pages longer than its predecessor, and a definite improvement; at two cents a page, done in nice type and binding, it is a bargain. There are omissions, such as a page index for the experiments, references to high-speed liquid chromatography, the excellent mass spectrometry books of McLafferty and Djerassi, data handling and acquisition, and automation. There are incorrect statements, such as the statement that the Mattauch-Herzog design is the most widely used double-focussing mass spectrometer. References are mostly 1966 or before. By nature, instrumentation books are bound to be obsolete by the time they are published. This effort provides a sound base for a course in instrumental methods of analysis.
Catalytic and Kinetic Waves in Polarog-raphy. Stal' G. Mairanovskii. xiv + 352 pages. Plenum Publishing Corp., 227 W. 17th St., New York, Ν. Υ. 10011. 1968. $19.50
Reviewed by Stanley Bruckenstein, Chemistry Department, State University of New York at Buffalo, Buffalo, Ν. Υ. 14214
Mairanovskii sets as his goal in this book to demonstrate, using selected examples, the importance of kinetic currents in polarography. He proceeds by discussing methods of investigating electrode processes at the DME which are complicated by chemical and electro
chemical steps, then illustrates how the relevant kinetic parameters may be obtained. Next he discusses how the reactivity of organic compounds can be determined from half wave potential after taking into account the structure of the electric double layer, adsorption phenomena, and concomitant chemical reactions.
The presentation and organization of this book is excellent, and it is a success using a viewpoint broader than that proposed by Mairanovskii. No existing monograph on polarography presents and discusses polarographic kinetic currents and the factors which affect them with such an excellent balance of theory and experiment. This authoritative book should be useful at the senior/graduate student level, providing a lucid introduction to the influence of adsorption, the ψ-potential, and chemical reactions upon polarographic current-potential curves.
Even though the author states that the work cited in this book is largely drawn from his laboratory (N. D. Zelinskii Institute of Organic Chemistry in Moscow), adequate mention of the key non-Soviet literature is given. Aside from an occasional non-idiomatic word or phrase, the translation is excellent.
"Catalytic and Kinetic Waves in Polarography" is a welcome contribution to the literature and belongs in the library of the serious electrochemist.
Analysis of Paper. B. L. Browning, ix + 342 pages. Marcel Dekker, Inc., 95 Madison Ave., New York, Ν. Υ. 10016. $18.75
Reviewed by O. A. Battista, FMC Corporation, Princeton, N. J. 08540
Dr. Browning has compiled a useful book in "Analysis of Paper" which has value for investigators in fields ranging far beyond the paper industry per se.
Today, the impact of a growing host of polymer, even metal, coatings on paper and paperboard products is evident all about us. The underlying vehicles of such products are paper webs, cellulose fibers, or more crude vegetable fibers. This reviewer has often searched for a definitive volume to help in the accurate measurement of specific chemical and physical properties of paper and paperboard without satisfactory success. This new book fills this need and does even more.
In addition to providing test meth-
VOL. 4 1 , NO. 8, JULY 1969 · 57 A
New Books
Circle No. 54 on Readers' Service Card
5 8 A · ANALYTICAL CHEMISTRY
ods for determining a wide range of components in coatings—be they rosin, starch, proteins, waxes, or pigments— it does describe the key processing steps so vital to the commercialization of paper and paper-based products. The test methods are, of course, most useful to the paper laboratory technicians and scientists. The descriptive information relating to processing techniques and terminologies native to the vast papermaking science are of special use to investigators concerned more with processes and products indirectly related to the paper industry.
One of the hazards of authoring a book such as this one, which is the first of its kind, is that it may be very well done and become a classic reference work, or it may be nothing more than a hodge-podge of disjointedly-orga-nized previously-published material. I believe this volume will stand the test of time and qualify for much use by anyone sufficiently involved with the paper and paperboard industry who decides to give it some space on his bookshelf.
Calculations of Analytical Chemistry. 7th ed. L. F. Hamilton, S. G. Simpson, and D. W. Ellis. 511 pages. McGraw-Hill Book Co., 330 West 42ndl St., New York, Ν. Υ. 10036. 1968. $8.50
Reviewed by Gilbert H. Ayres, Department of Chemistry, The University of Texas at Austin, Austin, Texas 78712
The seventh edition of this well-known book retains the general features that have made previous editions so useful—-namely, brief discussion of principles and methods, illustrative calculations, and many problems (some with answers) for student practice. Some parts of the book are suitable for nearly every academic level, from freshmen to beginning graduate students. Problems on "classical" methods are widely varied in terms of the unknown quantity, thus giving the student experience in a variety of applications of analytical measurements.
Titrimetric methods involving EDTA are now included. An important change from previous editions is the use of the ITJPAC conventions for half-cell reactions and electrode potentials. Teachers who cover several of the physico-chemical techniques will welcome the inclusion of sections and problems on absorption and emission spectrometry, NMR, mass spectrometry, chromatography, X-ray and radiochemical methods, TGA and DTA, etc.: these are areas in which appropriate problems are not easily manufactured, and several problems are based on
methods reported in the recent literature.
For teachers who prescribe this book for the same course semester after semester, it is unfortunate that there are relatively few new—i.e., different numerical data—problems on classical methods; indeed, many of these problems have been carried through several previous editions. (The implications should be obvious.) The treatment of simultaneous equilibria—for example, polyprotic acids and composition of buffer mixtures—is very brief and elementary. In the area of compleximetric titrations, this reviewer has a preference for what seems to be a more logical definition of equivalent weight than that used by the authors.
More recent (and presumably more reliable) values of some of the ionization constants and solubility product constants, than those given in the Appendix tables, have been published. Of course, this does not detract from the utility of calculation methods based on the constants. In Table 12, it is noted that mercurous sulfide is listed as HgS.
In Chapters 20 and 21, the authors still retain the obsolete symbols / and I0 ("intensity"), along with the correct symbols Ρ and P0. In defining the terms in the Beer-Lambert law, A = abc, the authors state "the concentration c is expressed in grams per liter." In this form of the law, c could be expressed in any concentration units whatever, such as parts per million, or even ounces per gallon, whereupon the absorptivity a would have the dimensions consistent with the units in which c (and also b) is expressed. It is only the molar absorptivity, e, that stipulates the concentration units that must be used. I t is difficult to guess how rapidly the long-used wavelength unit ταμ (millimicron) will give way to the recently adopted nm (nanometer).
Very few typographical errors were noted. The larger size and modern style of type and the general format of the seventh edition make for easier reading and for quicker location of specific sections and problems. The book is highly recommended as a source of problems for student drill; as for any skill, proficiency in problem solving comes only with much practice.
New Books
Analytical Applications of 1,10-Phen-anthroline and Related Compounds. Alfred A. Schilt. viii + 193 pages. Pergamon Press, Inc., 44-01 21st St., Long Island City, Ν. Υ. 11101. 1969. $9
The author, in writing this book, had in mind first the provision of a
Circle No. 6 on Readers' Service Card >-
U S E IT A N V W H E R E , A N Y T I M E I
FERRETMETER FOR PORTABLE ALLOY METAL SORTING
• Excellent for Monel, Inconel, Hastalloys and Titanium.
• Sorts pure Titanium from alloyed.
• No batteries or electrical connections.
• Checks high alloy turnings accurately!
• Nothing to maintain or wear out except inexpensive file probe.
• Perfect for steel warehouses and pipe sorting. Easily sorts look-alike alloys!
Write For FREE B r o c h u r e
STEELMET INC.
P.O. BOX 100, WILSON STATION, CLAIflTON. PENNA. 15025, U.S.A.
TELEPHONE (412) 462-8012 TELEX: 86-6132