Archibald Cochrane  ¹®¼±„±

download Archibald Cochrane  ¹®¼±„±

of 72

  • date post

    01-Mar-2018
  • Category

    Documents

  • view

    214
  • download

    0

Embed Size (px)

Transcript of Archibald Cochrane  ¹®¼±„±

  • 7/25/2019 Archibald Cochrane

    1/72

  • 7/25/2019 Archibald Cochrane

    2/72

  • 7/25/2019 Archibald Cochrane

    3/72

  • 7/25/2019 Archibald Cochrane

    4/72

  • 7/25/2019 Archibald Cochrane

    5/72

    ARCHIBALD COCHRANE

    -

    2008

  • 7/25/2019 Archibald Cochrane

    6/72

  • 7/25/2019 Archibald Cochrane

    7/72

  • 7/25/2019 Archibald Cochrane

    8/72

  • 7/25/2019 Archibald Cochrane

    9/72

    fi fi -

    , Effective-

    ness and efficency: random reflections on heal th services,

    Archibald Cochrane ,

    .

    fi -

    -

    -

    -

    , -

    fi

    fi

    .

    Cochrane -

    -

    fi, -

    ,

    fi .

    , fi

    fi

    (1936-37), (1941),

    fi -

    [ 9]

  • 7/25/2019 Archibald Cochrane

    10/72

    (1941-45), -

    fi .

    , Archibald C och-

    rane

    , -

    fi

    -

    -

    fi

    .

    fi fi

    fi fi

    Cochrane, -

    fi Forum

    -

    fi

    1998,

    -

    .

    . .

    2007

    [ 10]

  • 7/25/2019 Archibald Cochrane

    11/72

    AR C H I B AL D C O C H R ANE

    KAI H

  • 7/25/2019 Archibald Cochrane

    12/72

  • 7/25/2019 Archibald Cochrane

    13/72

    -

    1 Archibald Cochrane. -

    , fi.

    fi , fi

    fi fi -

    fi fi

    fi fi

    . .

    Archibald Cochrane fi

    -

    fi -

    , -

    fi , -

    fi, fi

    fi ,

    -

    [ 13]

    1. Cochran e A., with B lythe M., One Mans Medicine: An

    Autobiography of Professor A rchie Cochr ane, The Memoir

    Club, British Medical Journal, 1989 London .

  • 7/25/2019 Archibald Cochrane

    14/72

    -

    .

    ,

    fi fi

    80 -

    -

    .2

    12 1909 Gala-

    shiels

    , 19

    1917 .

    -

    ,

    Kings College Cambridge,

    ,

    .

    \30

    Theodor Reik,

    ,

    fi . -

    [ 14]

    2. -

    fi fi Cochrane

    : fi ., : -, , , 1982

    fi ., fi . fi, fi-

    fi , ,

    2000.

  • 7/25/2019 Archibald Cochrane

    15/72

    -

    ,

    ,

    .

    E fi

    ...

    fi

    1930.

    fi -

    fi.

    (

    ), -

    . fi fi

    fi -

    fi-

    , fi fi (fi fi fi -

    fi ).

    fi :

    .

    fi fi fi-

    fi, fi

    -

    .

    . fi fi -

    fi fi , -

    fi ...

    ARCHIBALD COCHRANE

    [ 15]

  • 7/25/2019 Archibald Cochrane

    16/72

    fi

    , -

    fi

    . -

    fi -

    fi

    fi ,

    fi.3

    fi

    Cochrane.

    Aragon fi -

    Jarama

    Burnette -

    Franco. fi -

    fi fi -

    , ,

    . -

    fi , -

    fi Mc D ade

    fi .4

    [ 16]

    3. Cochrane A.L., Effecti veness and Eff iciency: Random

    Reflections on Health Services, The Nuf field Provincial Hospitals

    Trust, 1972, Lond on. -

    fi -fi: , -

    . fi , fi , 2000.

    4. Cochrane -

    1936-37 Mc D ade,

  • 7/25/2019 Archibald Cochrane

    17/72

    Jarama.

    fi fi .

    .

    fi fi.

    Cochrane -

    fi-

    ,

    fi . fi -

    fi -

    ,

    ,

    .

    fi , - fi, -

    : , fi

    , fi

    fi . fi-

    , fi -

    fi fi

    . fi

    -

    .5

    ARCHIBALD COCHRANE

    [ 17]

    : There s a valley in Spain call ed Jarama /I t s a place that we all know too well , / For tis there that we

    wasted our manhood / And most of our old age as well.

    5. Cochran e A., Cochran es O bituary, Br itish Medical

    Journal, 1988, 297: 63.

  • 7/25/2019 Archibald Cochrane

    18/72

    Richard Doll, fi

    Cochrane:

    fi , Archie fi fi

    University College, fi -

    fi -

    fi fi -

    fi .6

    , ,

    1940, fi -

    . -

    -

    fi Elsterhorst

    Wittenberg-am-Elbe,

    fi .

    fi

    fi , -

    , fi

    .

    [ 18]

    6. D oll R., A Remin iscence of Archie Cochrane, Maynard A. Chalmers I . , Non-Random Ref lecti ons on

    Heal th Services Resear ch: On the 25th Anniversary of A rchie

    Cochranes Effectiveness and Efficiency, British Medical

    Journal, 1997, London.

  • 7/25/2019 Archibald Cochrane

    19/72

    fi

    fi Coch-

    rane, fi -

    fi

    ,

    . , .

    Eliot , Yeats, S tevenson, fi

    -

    P uskin, Heine, G oethe, Rilke, -

    . ,

    fi, -

    , -

    fi Goethe.7

    fi fi fi,

    fi

    fi fi

    Goethe -

    fi -

    Elstenhorst, fi Witten-

    berg-am-Elbe, fi -

    ARCHIBALD COCHRANE

    [ 19]

    7. : Nur wer die

    Sehnsucht weiwas ich leibe, / A l lein und abgetr ennt von al ler

    Freude. [Only someone who knows longing can understand my

    suffer ing, / A lone and separated f rom happiness.

  • 7/25/2019 Archibald Cochrane

    20/72

    ,

    William Bat ler Yeats.8

    fi;

    Pearse Connolly,

    fi ;

    fi, fi fi

    fi fi fi

    fi fi .

    Dick Cohen fi

    Cochrane

    : fi

    fi

    fi

    Wittenberg fi

    .9

    -

    fi fi,

    fi fi Puskin.10

    [ 20]

    8. Wittenberg, 27

    1945. Co-

    chrane .

    Yeats : But werecan we draw water / Said Pearse to

    Connoll y, / When all the wells are parched away?/ Plain, as plain

    can be; / Theres nothing but our own red blood / Can make a r ightrose tree. / To bundle time away that the night come.

    9. C ohen D., Archie Cochran e: an Appreciationin

    Maynard A. and C halmers J. op. cit .

    10. 21 1945 -

  • 7/25/2019 Archibald Cochrane

    21/72

    , fi,

    Georgia

    .

    M fi fi

    Rockfeller

    1948, fi

    -

    . Bradford H ill, fi-

    -

    , .

    Cochrane fi Nye Bevan,

    fi fi ,

    S ir Brad ford Hill B -

    fi fi .

    fi

    Rhond da Fach -

    -

    fi fi -

    fi . Louis

    Masset fi -

    ARCHIBALD COCHRANE

    [ 21]

    . Cochrane fi

    Puskin : Sing not again fair maiden, the songs of

    sad Georgia / They remind me of another life and a distant shore.

  • 7/25/2019 Archibald Cochrane

    22/72

    Cochrane fi fi

    :

    Rhondda, fi

    fi fi,

    , -

    Jaguar Cochrane. fi

    fi fi -

    -

    1973, fi

    .11

    1972

    fi fi -

    fi:

    ,

    ,

    .

    , fi -

    fi. fi -

    fi--

    fi fi fi

    (

    fi Masefield):12

    [ 22]

    11. Cochrane fi Louis Masset

    L inflat ionmdical : Rflxions sur l eff icacitde la mdecine, E d ition s

    G alillee 1977, Paris.

    12. fi

    Cochrane, op. cit . I have

  • 7/25/2019 Archibald Cochrane

    23/72

    fi

    fi

    fi -

    fi

    fi-

    fi fi .

    , fi,

    Cochrane. -

    fi

    Western Mail fi

    Cochrane fi

    fi -

    -

    fi , Collin Dollery

    British Medical Journal fi fi-

    fi .

    , fi: ... -

    fi -

    .

    fi -

    ARCHIBALD COCHRANE

    [ 23]

    seen good deeds done by men w ith / ugly faces, / and f lowers

    grow in stoney places, / So I tr ust too.

  • 7/25/2019 Archibald Cochrane

    24/72

    . fi -

    fi fi

    fi Archie Cochrane. -

    fi

    .

    -

    Cardiff fi

    , -

    -

    fi.

    Cochrane

    Richard Doll:

    , fi

    -

    fi fi-

    -

    fi

    fi. fi

    fi fi

    ., fi -

    .13

    fi , Tomas

    Mc Keown 14 : fi

    , fi

    , fi

    [ 24]

    13. D oll R. op. c it

    14. Mc Keow n, T, The Role of Medicine: D ream, Mir age of

    Nemesis?, P rinceton University P ress, 1979, P rinceton.

  • 7/25/2019 Archibald Cochrane

    25/72

    -

    fi -

    fi .

    Cochrane

    fi fi fi

    Thomas S terns

    Eliot15

    :

    fi

    -

    .

    Archibald Cochrane fi -

    fi , -

    ,

    . -

    fi fi fi ,

    ,

    fi

    ARCHIBALD COCHRANE

    [ 25]

    15. Cochrane op. ci