The Cygnus Region: An Extended TeV Sourcejkelley/talks/Extended_Cygnus.pdf · 2005. 9. 2. · What...

11
The Cygnus Region: An Extended TeV Source John Kelley September 2, 2005

Transcript of The Cygnus Region: An Extended TeV Sourcejkelley/talks/Extended_Cygnus.pdf · 2005. 9. 2. · What...

Page 1: The Cygnus Region: An Extended TeV Sourcejkelley/talks/Extended_Cygnus.pdf · 2005. 9. 2. · What We’ve Seen •For a 4σ marginal discovery, we would need 35 events on a background

The Cygnus Region:An Extended TeV Source

John KelleySeptember 2, 2005

Page 2: The Cygnus Region: An Extended TeV Sourcejkelley/talks/Extended_Cygnus.pdf · 2005. 9. 2. · What We’ve Seen •For a 4σ marginal discovery, we would need 35 events on a background

,

Milagro Results

• ICRC: Milagro presents5.5σ detection ofextended TeV γ source

• Total flux is 2x Crab!(brightest in sky)

• Extended nature meansHESS, other IACT havedifficulty imaging

Figure from astro-ph/0503244

Page 3: The Cygnus Region: An Extended TeV Sourcejkelley/talks/Extended_Cygnus.pdf · 2005. 9. 2. · What We’ve Seen •For a 4σ marginal discovery, we would need 35 events on a background

• In galactic coordinates, region extent is approx.b ∈ (-1º, 4.5º), l ∈ (74º, 85º)

• Corresponds to Cygnus region of galactic plane

Page 4: The Cygnus Region: An Extended TeV Sourcejkelley/talks/Extended_Cygnus.pdf · 2005. 9. 2. · What We’ve Seen •For a 4σ marginal discovery, we would need 35 events on a background

,

CO Maps

• Molecular COsurveys (radio)indicate densecloud in samelocation

• Suggestive ofhadronic origin

Page 5: The Cygnus Region: An Extended TeV Sourcejkelley/talks/Extended_Cygnus.pdf · 2005. 9. 2. · What We’ve Seen •For a 4σ marginal discovery, we would need 35 events on a background

• Purple box shows Milagro region from slide 3• CO data from Dame, Hartmann, and Thaddeus, astro-ph/0009217

Page 6: The Cygnus Region: An Extended TeV Sourcejkelley/talks/Extended_Cygnus.pdf · 2005. 9. 2. · What We’ve Seen •For a 4σ marginal discovery, we would need 35 events on a background

,

Neutrino Implications

• Extended source (~5º by 10º) means pointsource searches are less effective

• Can possibly utilize some of galactic planemachinery to examine this region (insteadof entire plane)

• Don’t look at longitude distribution!

Page 7: The Cygnus Region: An Extended TeV Sourcejkelley/talks/Extended_Cygnus.pdf · 2005. 9. 2. · What We’ve Seen •For a 4σ marginal discovery, we would need 35 events on a background

,

Ideas on How to Proceed

• Define signal region precisely by using Milagroresults and CO maps

• Determine how best to generate signal MC(current line source technique not OK)

• Re-optimize on-source region

• Request “re-unblinding”

Page 8: The Cygnus Region: An Extended TeV Sourcejkelley/talks/Extended_Cygnus.pdf · 2005. 9. 2. · What We’ve Seen •For a 4σ marginal discovery, we would need 35 events on a background

3º search bin around Cyg X32000-03 pt. src. analysis

4.2º search bin2000-02 pt. src. analysis

Page 9: The Cygnus Region: An Extended TeV Sourcejkelley/talks/Extended_Cygnus.pdf · 2005. 9. 2. · What We’ve Seen •For a 4σ marginal discovery, we would need 35 events on a background

Eyeball optimal radius,circular bin: 5.5º

Page 10: The Cygnus Region: An Extended TeV Sourcejkelley/talks/Extended_Cygnus.pdf · 2005. 9. 2. · What We’ve Seen •For a 4σ marginal discovery, we would need 35 events on a background

,

What We’ve Seen

• For a 4σ marginal discovery, we would need 35 events ona background of 16.7 (2000-03 data sample)

• Zeuthen point source search would have seen a moderateexcess of 10-11 events on 4.96 from Cyg X-3 (reality: 6)

• 2000-02 (You-Ren) sample: given what we need forextended source discovery, we would have seen 6-7 eventson 1.29 (reality: 1)

Page 11: The Cygnus Region: An Extended TeV Sourcejkelley/talks/Extended_Cygnus.pdf · 2005. 9. 2. · What We’ve Seen •For a 4σ marginal discovery, we would need 35 events on a background

,

Conclusions

• Existing point source searches not optimal,but most likely sufficient (for existing data)

• Should consider defining new on-sourceregion for future point-source searches,though