Hydraprobe calibration O. Merlin, J. Walker, R. Panciera, H. Meade, D. Biasioni, R. Young, L....

16
Hydraprobe calibration O. Merlin, J. Walker, R. Panciera, H. Meade, D. Biasioni, R. Young, L. Siriwardena, A. Western 3 rd NAFE Workshop 17-18 Sept. 200

Transcript of Hydraprobe calibration O. Merlin, J. Walker, R. Panciera, H. Meade, D. Biasioni, R. Young, L....

Page 1: Hydraprobe calibration O. Merlin, J. Walker, R. Panciera, H. Meade, D. Biasioni, R. Young, L. Siriwardena, A. Western 3 rd NAFE Workshop 17-18 Sept. 2007.

Hydraprobe calibration

O. Merlin, J. Walker, R. Panciera, H. Meade, D. Biasioni, R. Young,

L. Siriwardena, A. Western

3rd NAFE Workshop 17-18 Sept. 2007

Page 2: Hydraprobe calibration O. Merlin, J. Walker, R. Panciera, H. Meade, D. Biasioni, R. Young, L. Siriwardena, A. Western 3 rd NAFE Workshop 17-18 Sept. 2007.

Objective

Derive/validate a calibration equation for:

• Roving HP measurements (HDAS)

• Continuous HP measurements (stations)

Page 3: Hydraprobe calibration O. Merlin, J. Walker, R. Panciera, H. Meade, D. Biasioni, R. Young, L. Siriwardena, A. Western 3 rd NAFE Workshop 17-18 Sept. 2007.

Hydraprobe (HP)

Dielectric sensor at 50MHz of 0-5cm soil

Measure real (εr -> SM) and

imaginary (εi -> SAL) dielectric constant (DC) + Temperature

Output is 4 voltages:

V1, V2, V3 (DC) and V4 (temperature)

Page 4: Hydraprobe calibration O. Merlin, J. Walker, R. Panciera, H. Meade, D. Biasioni, R. Young, L. Siriwardena, A. Western 3 rd NAFE Workshop 17-18 Sept. 2007.

Calibration data sets

NAFE’06 field measurements:

1 volumetric sample at 5 points in each of the 6 farms, every sampling day + 1 (or more) HP measurement

Complementary laboratory experiments– Goulburn soils (Lab’05, Daniele Biasioni)– Yanco soils (Lab’06, Hanna Meade)– Goulburn soils (Temp’06, Rocco Panciera)

Page 5: Hydraprobe calibration O. Merlin, J. Walker, R. Panciera, H. Meade, D. Biasioni, R. Young, L. Siriwardena, A. Western 3 rd NAFE Workshop 17-18 Sept. 2007.

Calibration approaches

Comparison HP / Grav measurements

Two different approaches:– Polynomial interpolation– General (multi-data) equations

Account for a range of:– Moisture conditions (linearity)– Soil types (from sand to clay)– Other parameters (temperature, ?)

HP

Grav

Page 6: Hydraprobe calibration O. Merlin, J. Walker, R. Panciera, H. Meade, D. Biasioni, R. Young, L. Siriwardena, A. Western 3 rd NAFE Workshop 17-18 Sept. 2007.

Calibration

1. Direct comparison between HP response (silt) and grav measurements

2. Estimate temperature effect on DC measurements

3. Test different calibration approaches:• Polynomial fit• Multi-data equations (from measured DC)

4. Apply calibration equations to • Roving measurements• Station-based HP data

Page 7: Hydraprobe calibration O. Merlin, J. Walker, R. Panciera, H. Meade, D. Biasioni, R. Young, L. Siriwardena, A. Western 3 rd NAFE Workshop 17-18 Sept. 2007.

Manufacturer-supplied algo versus grav measurements

Saturation of the predicted SM + soil-dependent

Linear behaviour of the real DC

εr

SM

HP response

Page 8: Hydraprobe calibration O. Merlin, J. Walker, R. Panciera, H. Meade, D. Biasioni, R. Young, L. Siriwardena, A. Western 3 rd NAFE Workshop 17-18 Sept. 2007.

Temperature effect

Effect of a 15°C increase on the measured DC

εrεi

Correction proposed

Page 9: Hydraprobe calibration O. Merlin, J. Walker, R. Panciera, H. Meade, D. Biasioni, R. Young, L. Siriwardena, A. Western 3 rd NAFE Workshop 17-18 Sept. 2007.

Application to Y2

Temperature correction

Uncorrected DC T-corrected DC

Page 10: Hydraprobe calibration O. Merlin, J. Walker, R. Panciera, H. Meade, D. Biasioni, R. Young, L. Siriwardena, A. Western 3 rd NAFE Workshop 17-18 Sept. 2007.

Loss-corrected equation

Seyfried et al., 2005

Function of loss tangent r

i

tan

Real DC

Grav

Page 11: Hydraprobe calibration O. Merlin, J. Walker, R. Panciera, H. Meade, D. Biasioni, R. Young, L. Siriwardena, A. Western 3 rd NAFE Workshop 17-18 Sept. 2007.

Comparison of calibration approaches

General equation (Seyfried et al., 2005)

Loss-corrected equation(Seyfried et al., 2005)

Page 12: Hydraprobe calibration O. Merlin, J. Walker, R. Panciera, H. Meade, D. Biasioni, R. Young, L. Siriwardena, A. Western 3 rd NAFE Workshop 17-18 Sept. 2007.

Polynomial fit

NAFE’05Saturation

Page 13: Hydraprobe calibration O. Merlin, J. Walker, R. Panciera, H. Meade, D. Biasioni, R. Young, L. Siriwardena, A. Western 3 rd NAFE Workshop 17-18 Sept. 2007.

Intrinsic limitation

Moisture content (% v/v)

Vol

tage

s (%

v/v

)

Page 14: Hydraprobe calibration O. Merlin, J. Walker, R. Panciera, H. Meade, D. Biasioni, R. Young, L. Siriwardena, A. Western 3 rd NAFE Workshop 17-18 Sept. 2007.

Assumptions

tan δ ~ tan δsat THP ~ T0-5cm

Applicability of the loss-corrected equation and temperature correction to roving measurements

Page 15: Hydraprobe calibration O. Merlin, J. Walker, R. Panciera, H. Meade, D. Biasioni, R. Young, L. Siriwardena, A. Western 3 rd NAFE Workshop 17-18 Sept. 2007.

Illustration

Page 16: Hydraprobe calibration O. Merlin, J. Walker, R. Panciera, H. Meade, D. Biasioni, R. Young, L. Siriwardena, A. Western 3 rd NAFE Workshop 17-18 Sept. 2007.

Conclusions

Seyfrield et al.’s equation validated with NAFE’06 data set

Developed a temperature correction for the measured real DC from lab data

Calibration applied to the NAFE data sets (about 17000 measurements for NAFE’06)

The application of this calib to all the new sites (20) in the Murrumbidgee is underway