8/12/2019 41010

1/12

,

!"!"# $, %& '$ ( %))*% (+ -. / 01)2# 2 34 )

/' %*% , , , , , !"# $ , % ,, % # &' ' % ! , , % # $ , % ( % )%* %# +, ' , " -. % , / , 012 3#4, 5 #+ % " % / 5 ( , %6 , %, ' . %, ! # 7' % "" ! #5( + 6*%+ % % % , " /" , % 5 "# + % % , ' # + % ' , % % , %, # % % ', , 66 %# "% % % 8

9# :4; " "% 5 / :,444 , % 5, "5 ! ?1@A %, % % %,

8/12/2019 41010

2/12

3# B4; " "% C "" / 3D %5, %"% ,

:# 34; " % #37 (+7 $)

E1FAG>HIGJ6KJL1M /344B5Digital art history.E>=NOJF /344P5 Scholarship in the digital age .QJO1=>F JFR K1FR1=RSF1 /344P5 Theorizing digital cultural heritage: a critical discourse.TSF JFR U1@VA /344P5The digital museum: a think guide.KJWJFJNV /34445 Dream spaces: memory and the museum .XJ@T>FJMR /344Y5Digital heritage: applying digital imaging to cultural heritage.XJ=AZ JFR [>F1I /344P5 Museum informatics: people, information, and technology inmuseums.XSMM1= /344\5 The comfort of things .]J==Z /344P5 Recoding the museum : digital heritage and the technologies of change #^V>OJI JFR XSFA_ /9``\5 The virtual and the real : media in the museum #^a=GM1 /344P5Evocative o !ects: things "e think "ith .0SA@>O2 /344:5 b16SOJNSFSFN AV1 OaI1aO8 21Z>FR AV1 OJaI>M1aO#

61%1 (5+%%#. $ %&&'() *+ - +/'0'/1) 2)( + 3- +/'0'/()24 5*/'046 5*) 7'8591) 2)( 5*+& -' (*(5*(242 +/'&'7( c EJA1I /344Y5 daFRJO1FAJM L>=OI >L SFL>=OJAS>F#U>>

8/12/2019 41010

3/12

E1J=OJF /344P5 b1HM1RN1#QISG_1FAOSVJMZS 9``: 60VZ H1 F11R AVSFNI#]1J=@1 /9`\Y5 ^VSFGSFN J2>aA AVSFNI#QJO1=>F JFR b>2SFI>F /344P5 TSNSAJM GF>HM1RN1I@J=1AS@JM, MM1@AS>F RJAJ2JI1I SF J RSNSAJM 1@V#

7 E1J=OJF /9``Y5 Research agenda for net"orked cultural heritage.EMJ@GJ2Z /9` P5 EaSMRSFN SFA1N=JA1R OaI1aO SFL>=OJAS>F =1A=S1WJM IZIA1OI8 =NJFSIJAS>F JFR J@@1II#eJ=RSF /9`B\5 d>a= @>R1I L>= AV1 R1I@=SF >L J=ASLJ@AI8 JF 1IIJZ SF J=@VJ1>M>NS@JM A1@VFSwa1JFR AV1>=Z#T>1== /344:5 ^V1 QvTlQ Q>F@1R1M8 gF lFA>M>NS@JM gt1OJFAS@ vFA1=>L X1AJRJAJ#e>>ROJF /9`PY5 Ganguages of art: an approach to a theory of sym ols # QVJ=Z >L F>AJAS>F*, 93P69P:# 7 8H A559 *+ *%I&+ , h# D, % ., 9\B63DP#

b>II /344:5 ^>HJ=RI J I1OJFAS@ H12 L>= V1=SAJN1 =1I>a=@1I#]=>HF /9`\35 XSFR SF OJAA1=8 JF SFA=>Ra@AS>F A> OJA1=SJM @aMAa=1 AV1>=Z JFR O1AV>R#^J2>=IGZ /9``45 ^V1 RSI@a=ISW1 >2?1@A#^SMM1Z /9`` 5Metaphor and material culture. QVJMSR O1AJ=8 AV1 JFJMZISI >LOJA1=SJM L>=OI*, :Y6PY#

J. K (2L*+*), )8 9&*(2L*+*) 2)( N+0()24 )&)-)/)@?@4c E=>HF /34495 ^VSFN AV1>=Z#QJO1=>F /344P5 E1Z>FR AV1 @aMA >L AV1 =1=S@JM RSNSAJM >2?1@AI 6A=JRSAS>FJM @>F@1=FI, F1H RSI@>a=I1I#

U1SR1NN1=^=JFA /9``\5 0V1F JMM x>aCW1 e>A SI )^V1 b1JM ^VSFN*8 XaI1aOI JFR gaAV1FAS@SAZ SF AV1m1AH>=G1R 0>=MR#0JMIV /344P5 bSI1 JFR LJMM >L AV1 IA6A>N=JM>NZ JFR AV1A=JFIL>=OJAS>F >L J=A#7 E1J=OJF JFR ^=JFA /9` \5 gaAV1FAS@SAZ >L RSNSAJM =1I>a=@1I8 A>HJ=RI J IAJA1O1FA >L=1waS=1O1FAI SF AV1 =1I1J=@V @1II# VAA=NyRMS2y?aF1`\y4Y21J=OJF#VAOME1F?JOSF /9`:Y5 ^V1 H>=G >L J=A SF AV1 JN1 >L O1@VJFS@JM =1Ra@AS>F#VAA=Ny=1L1=1F@1yIa2?1@AyI>=GIyN1y21F?JOSF#VAOE1II1= /9``P5 ^V1 @VJFNSFN =>M1 >L A>N=JMM1@AS>FI HSAV AV1 JRW1FA >L RSNSAS_JAS>F#

Ug^vv JFR mvmQU /344:5 ^V1 mvmQU eaSR1 A> N>>R L @aMAa=JM V1=SAJN1 OJA1=SJMI#XSA@V1MM /9``35 ^V1 =1@>FLSNa=1R 1Z18 WSIaJM A=aAV SF AV1 IA6A>N=JaII>a JFR T=1AAJGSI 344: 6 ]V>A>=1JMSIO JFR F>F6A>=1JMSIO SF WS=AaJM V1=SAJN1=1FtVJFGI /9``P5 ]V>A>N=JM>NS@JM SOJN1# vF E# X>MZF1Jap /1R5 ^V1 QaMAa=JMzSL1 >L vOJN1I8 nSIaJM b1F SF g=@VJ1>M>NZ, z>FR>F, b>aAM1RN1, 9``P#tA1W1FI>F /344Y5 TSNSASIJAS>F N=JOO1I SF AV1 nrg# vF XJ@T>FJMR /344Y5Digital heritage:applying digital imaging to cultural heritage, .

O. P&47+, N+0()24 Q()*4/+5+ 2)( N+0()24 9-(7% 9()

c TJMMJI /344P5gF JN1F@Z6>=S1FA1R J RSNSAJM @a=JAS>F AV1>=Z JFR

8/12/2019 41010

4/12

KJWJFJNV /34445 T=1JO I=Z JFR AV1 OaI1aO# QVJMM1@AS>FI >L>2?1@AI, >= O1O>=S1If*, ``694P#z>H1FAVJM /9`\`5 XJA1=SJM F JFR SAI JMA1=FJASW1I#X@QJ=AVZ /344P5dSFRSFN J LaAa=1 L>= RSNSAJM @aMAa=JM V1=SAJN1 SFL>=OJAS>F =1I>a=@1I aISFN@>FA1pAaJM SFL>=OJAS>F L=JO1H>=GI#

7 E1II1= /34445 TSNSAJM M>FN1WSAZ#Q>FIAJFA>aM>I JFR TJMMJI /344\5 gIL J RSNSAJM @a=JAS>F JN1FRJ#Q>FF1=A>F /9`\`5 U>H I>@S1AS1I =1O1O21=#U1RIA=>O /34435 g=@VSW1I, O1O>=Z JFR SFA1=LJ@1I HSAV AV1 O JFR b>II /344:5 vFW1IA A> IJW18 =1=A JFR =1@>OO1FRJAS>FI >L AV1 mtd6Tqzlt0>=GSFN e=>a< >F TSNSAJM g=@VSWSFN JFR ]=1I1=WJAS>F#z>H1FAVJM /9``\5 ^V1 V1=SAJN1 @=aIJR1 JFR AV1 ISMI >L VSIA>=Z#b>AV1F21=N /9```5 gW>SRSFN ^1@VF>M>NS@JM {aS@GIJFR8 dSFRSFN J nSJ2M1 ^1@VFS@JM d>aFRJAS>FL>= TSNSAJM ]=1I1=WJAS>F#T>F>WJF /9``P5 ^V1 E1IA >L vFA1FAS>FI8 ]a2MS@ g@@1II, AV1 012 r AV1 qW>MaAS>F >L XaI1aO

gaA>OJAS>F#VAAOyOH`PyIF>WJF#VAOb>II /34445 QVJFNSFN A=JSFI JA 0SNJF8 TSNSAJM F JFR AV1 LaAa=1 >L I@V>MJ=IVSL qb]gmq^ SF IaF JFR F SF qa=>IIy4P=>II#VAOMb>HMJFRI /9``:5 ^V1 =>M1 >L O1O>=Z SF AV1 A=JFIOSIIS>F >L @aMAa=1#baI2=SRN1 /344Y5 }qp@aI1 O1 ###C8 I>O1 TSNSAJM F LJMMJ@S1I#baI2=SRN1 /344P5 Q=1JA1, @a=JA1, =16aI18 AV1 1pa=I1 >L RSNSAJM =1I1J=@V RJAJ#

. +0()24 *9I&' '@1), -/)2*(2% *+ @&A5+ 2)( 8-'Q'7% *?& )& /?-(5*(2A& 9-(5*+7A&

c E>=NOJF /344P5 Scholarship in the digital age: information, infrastructure, and the ;nternet. QVJ= SFL>=OJAS>F*, 9D`69PP, r QVJ= F>AfQ>V1F 1A JM 9``P 6TSNSAJM @aMAa=1 JFR AV1 L J=A JFR J=A VSIA>=Z#bVZF1 /9``P5 vOJN1I JI qWSR1F@1 SF g=A USIA>=Z JFR b1MJA1R TSI@S= HSMR J@=1f X1AJ=I JFR IA>=S1I L>=VaOJFSAS1I @>O=ASFN AVSFNI >aA# @MJIISLS@JAS>F JFR vAI @>FI1wa1F@1I# QVJ=S@JM H>=G JFR 2>aFRJ=Z SFL=JIA=a@Aa=1I8 1F=S@VSFN AV1>=S1I >L@MJIISLS@JAS>F*, 3\B6:9P#TJMMJI /9```5 UaOJFSIAS@ =1I1J=@V, SFL>=OJAS>F =1I>a=@1I JFR 1M1@A=>FS@ @>OOaFS@JAS>F#TJMMJI /344P5g=@VJ1>M>NS@JM GF>HM1RN1, WS=AaJM 1pVS2SAS>FI JFR AV1 I>@SJM @>FIA=a@AS>F >LO1JFSFN#TJIA>F /344D5 tVFI>F /344:5 0V1=1 vI AV1 zSIA HSAV gMM AV1 mJO1If vFL>=OJAS>F6t11GSFN E1VJWS>=>L e1F1JM>NSIAI#VAAFA1FAyM:PBa?4DP33DP:PFUJOOJ /344D5 ^V1 =>M1 >L OaI1aOI SF >FMSF1 A1J@VSFN, M1J=FSFN JFR =1I1J=@V#VAAFRJZ#>=NySIIa1IySIIa1`|ByVJOOJU>RR1= 9` P 6 gMHJZI O>O1FAJ=Z LMaSR JFR LM1pS2M1 6 A>HJ=RI J =1LM1pSW1 1p@JWJAS>F

O1AV>R>M>NZ#

http://dl.dropbox.com/u/105458/Lowenthal%201989%20-%20Material%20Preservation%20and%20Its%20Alternatives.pdfhttp://dl.dropbox.com/u/105458/McCarthy%202007%20-%20Finding%20a%20future%20for%20digital%20cultural%20heritage%20resources%20using%20contextual%20information%20frameworks.pdfhttp://dl.dropbox.com/u/105458/McCarthy%202007%20-%20Finding%20a%20future%20for%20digital%20cultural%20heritage%20resources%20using%20contextual%20information%20frameworks.pdfhttp://dl.dropbox.com/u/105458/McCarthy%202007%20-%20Finding%20a%20future%20for%20digital%20cultural%20heritage%20resources%20using%20contextual%20information%20frameworks.pdfhttp://www.google.gr/url?sa=t&source=web&cd=2&ved=0CB0QFjAB&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.dcu.gr%2Fdcu%2FDocuments%2Fdocuments%2Faspects-of-a-digital-curation-agenda%2Fen%2Fattachment&ei=wQnbTNmtBciK4Qbnw5CsCQ&usg=AFQjCNEQLfTLz9QGrLaGb816DMLIfdEczw&sig2=CNc3-xXb_K0ofcw5jh8IQAhttp://www.google.gr/url?sa=t&source=web&cd=2&ved=0CB0QFjAB&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.dcu.gr%2Fdcu%2FDocuments%2Fdocuments%2Faspects-of-a-digital-curation-agenda%2Fen%2Fattachment&ei=wQnbTNmtBciK4Qbnw5CsCQ&usg=AFQjCNEQLfTLz9QGrLaGb816DMLIfdEczw&sig2=CNc3-xXb_K0ofcw5jh8IQAhttp://dl.dropbox.com/u/105458/Hedstrom%202002%20-%20Archives%20memory%20and%20intefaces%20with%20the%20past.pdfhttp://dl.dropbox.com/u/105458/Hedstrom%202002%20-%20Archives%20memory%20and%20intefaces%20with%20the%20past.pdfhttp://delos-noe.iei.pi.cnr.it/activities/internationalforum/Joint-WGs/digitalarchiving/Digitalarchiving.pdfhttp://delos-noe.iei.pi.cnr.it/activities/internationalforum/Joint-WGs/digitalarchiving/Digitalarchiving.pdfhttp://www.archimuse.com/mw97/speak/donovan.htmhttp://eprints.erpanet.org/45/01/seamusross_wigan_paper.pdfhttp://www.dlib.org/dlib/july04/ross/07ross.htmlhttp://dl.dropbox.com/u/105458/Rowlands%20-%20The%20role%20of%20memory%20in%20the%20transmission%20of%20knowledge.pdfhttp://dl.dropbox.com/u/105458/Rowlands%20-%20The%20role%20of%20memory%20in%20the%20transmission%20of%20knowledge.pdfhttp://dl.dropbox.com/u/105458/Rusbridge%202007%20-%20Create%2C%20curate%2C%20re-use%20The%20expanding%20life%20course%20of%20digital%20research%20data.pdfhttp://books.google.gr/books?id=ZDDu3CuzDdMC&lpg=PP1&ots=Er96qd-_KF&dq=borgman%20scholarship%20digital%20age&hl=en&pg=PA149#v=onepage&q&f=falsehttp://dl.dropbox.com/u/105458/Cohen%20et%20al%201997%20-%20Digital%20culture%20and%20the%20practices%20of%20art%20and%20art%20history.pdfhttp://academic.reed.edu/art/faculty/rhyne/papers/images.htmlhttp://academic.reed.edu/art/faculty/rhyne/papers/images.htmlhttp://www.newcastle.edu.au/centre/cllc/ca2004/http://www.sis.pitt.edu/~gbowker/classification/http://library.panteion.gr:8080/dspace/bitstream/123456789/792/1/dallas+2.pdfhttp://soi.cnr.it/archcalc/indice/Suppl_1/4_Dallas.pdfhttp://soi.cnr.it/archcalc/indice/Suppl_1/4_Dallas.pdfhttp://soi.cnr.it/archcalc/indice/Suppl_1/4_Dallas.pdfhttp://archivists.metapress.com/content/l375uj047224737nhttp://firstmonday.org/issues/issue9_5/hammahttp://dl.dropbox.com/u/105458/Hodder%201997%20-%20Always%20momentary%20fluid%20and%20flexible%20-%20towards%20a%20reflexive%20excavation%20methodology.pdfhttp://dl.dropbox.com/u/105458/Hodder%201997%20-%20Always%20momentary%20fluid%20and%20flexible%20-%20towards%20a%20reflexive%20excavation%20methodology.pdfhttp://dl.dropbox.com/u/105458/Hodder%201997%20-%20Always%20momentary%20fluid%20and%20flexible%20-%20towards%20a%20reflexive%20excavation%20methodology.pdfhttp://dl.dropbox.com/u/105458/Lowenthal%201989%20-%20Material%20Preservation%20and%20Its%20Alternatives.pdfhttp://dl.dropbox.com/u/105458/McCarthy%202007%20-%20Finding%20a%20future%20for%20digital%20cultural%20heritage%20resources%20using%20contextual%20information%20frameworks.pdfhttp://dl.dropbox.com/u/105458/McCarthy%202007%20-%20Finding%20a%20future%20for%20digital%20cultural%20heritage%20resources%20using%20contextual%20information%20frameworks.pdfhttp://www.google.gr/url?sa=t&source=web&cd=2&ved=0CB0QFjAB&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.dcu.gr%2Fdcu%2FDocuments%2Fdocuments%2Faspects-of-a-digital-curation-agenda%2Fen%2Fattachment&ei=wQnbTNmtBciK4Qbnw5CsCQ&usg=AFQjCNEQLfTLz9QGrLaGb816DMLIfdEczw&sig2=CNc3-xXb_K0ofcw5jh8IQAhttp://dl.dropbox.com/u/105458/Hedstrom%202002%20-%20Archives%20memory%20and%20intefaces%20with%20the%20past.pdfhttp://delos-noe.iei.pi.cnr.it/activities/internationalforum/Joint-WGs/digitalarchiving/Digitalarchiving.pdfhttp://delos-noe.iei.pi.cnr.it/activities/internationalforum/Joint-WGs/digitalarchiving/Digitalarchiving.pdfhttp://www.archimuse.com/mw97/speak/donovan.htmhttp://eprints.erpanet.org/45/01/seamusross_wigan_paper.pdfhttp://www.dlib.org/dlib/july04/ross/07ross.htmlhttp://dl.dropbox.com/u/105458/Rowlands%20-%20The%20role%20of%20memory%20in%20the%20transmission%20of%20knowledge.pdfhttp://dl.dropbox.com/u/105458/Rusbridge%202007%20-%20Create%2C%20curate%2C%20re-use%20The%20expanding%20life%20course%20of%20digital%20research%20data.pdfhttp://books.google.gr/books?id=ZDDu3CuzDdMC&lpg=PP1&ots=Er96qd-_KF&dq=borgman%20scholarship%20digital%20age&hl=en&pg=PA149#v=onepage&q&f=falsehttp://dl.dropbox.com/u/105458/Cohen%20et%20al%201997%20-%20Digital%20culture%20and%20the%20practices%20of%20art%20and%20art%20history.pdfhttp://academic.reed.edu/art/faculty/rhyne/papers/images.htmlhttp://www.newcastle.edu.au/centre/cllc/ca2004/http://www.sis.pitt.edu/~gbowker/classification/http://library.panteion.gr:8080/dspace/bitstream/123456789/792/1/dallas+2.pdfhttp://soi.cnr.it/archcalc/indice/Suppl_1/4_Dallas.pdfhttp://soi.cnr.it/archcalc/indice/Suppl_1/4_Dallas.pdfhttp://archivists.metapress.com/content/l375uj047224737nhttp://firstmonday.org/issues/issue9_5/hammahttp://dl.dropbox.com/u/105458/Hodder%201997%20-%20Always%20momentary%20fluid%20and%20flexible%20-%20towards%20a%20reflexive%20excavation%20methodology.pdfhttp://dl.dropbox.com/u/105458/Hodder%201997%20-%20Always%20momentary%20fluid%20and%20flexible%20-%20towards%20a%20reflexive%20excavation%20methodology.pdf

8/12/2019 41010

5/12

8/12/2019 41010

6/12

8/12/2019 41010

7/12

8/12/2019 41010

8/12

UJOOJ /344D5 E1@>OSFN TSNSAJM#VAAS#>=Ny94#9443y2aMA#:33U>>L WSIaJM @aMAa=1# QVJL AV1 OaI1aO*, 9B969Y9#KJWJFJNV /34445 T=1JO I=Z JFR AV1 OaI1aO#K11F1 /344B5 d=JNO1FAI >L AV1 H>=MR8 aI1I >L OaI1aO @>MM1@AS>FI# QVJMM1@AS>FI

JFR RSNSAS_JAS>F*, 9:\69BP#KF1MM /344:5 ^V1 IVJL AVSFNI A> @>O18 OaI1aOI SF AV1 A1@VF>M>NS@JM MJFRI@JFJMR JFR gMIL>=R /9`\`5 g OaI1aO L>= AV1 NM>2JM WSMMJN18 AV1 QJFJRSJF XaI1aO >LQSWSMS_JAS>F#uJ=AZ /344P5 ^V1 @VJFNSFN FJAa=1 >L SFL>=OJAS>F H>=G SF OaI1aOIVAAS#>=Ny94#9443yJIS#34DD:^=JFA /344P5 Qa=JASFN @>MM1@AS>FI GF>HM1RN18 OaI1aOI >F AV1 @Z21=SFL=JIA=a@Aa=1#

86+$EJA1I, XJ=@SJ [# 344Y# daFRJO1FAJM L>=OI >L SFL>=OJAS>F# [>a=FJM >L AV1 gO1=S@JF t>@S1AZ L>=vFL>=OJAS>F t@S1F@1 JFR ^1@VF>M>NZ BP /\5894::694DB#

E1J=OJF, TJWSR# 344P# b1HM1RN1# vF XaI1aO SFL>=OJAS@I8 =OJAS>F, JFR A1@VF>M>NZ SF OaI1aOI, 1RSA1R 2Z ]# d# XJ=AZ JFR E# K# [>F1I# m1H x>=G rz>FR>F8 b>aAM1RN1#, 1R# 9``Y# b1I1J=@V JN1FRJ L>= F1AH>=G1R @aMAa=JM V1=SAJN1# tJFAJ X>FS@J, Qg8 e1AAZg=A USIA>=Z vFL>=OJAS>F ]=>N=JO#E1J=OJF, TJWSR, JFR [1FFSL1= ^=JFA# 9``\# gaAV1FAS@SAZ >L RSNSAJM =1I>a=@1I8 A>HJ=RI JIAJA1O1FA >L =1waS=1O1FAI SF AV1 =1I1J=@V @1II# T6zS2 XJNJ_SF1 /[aF1 9` \5,VAA=NyRMS2y?aF1`\y4Y21J=OJF#VAOM#E1F?JOSF, 0JMA1=# 9`:Y# ^V1 H>=G >L J=A SF AV1 JN1 >L O1@VJFS@JM =1Ra@AS>F# /9Py:y344Y5,VAA=Ny=1L1=1F@1yIa2?1@AyI>=GIyN1y21F?JOSF#VAO#E1II1=, U>HJ=R# 9``P# ^V1 @VJFNSFN =>M1 >L A>N=JMM1@AS>FI HSAV AV1 JRW1FA >LRSNSAS_JAS>F# vF ^V1 HS=1R OaI1aO 8 1O1=NSFN A1@VF>M>NZ JFR @VJFNSFN F1I6eJ=OSM# 0JIVSFNA>F, TQ8 gO1=S@JF gII>@SJAS>F >L XaI1aOI## 9``P# ^V1 A=JFIL>=OJAS>F >L AV1 OaI1aO JFR AV1 HJZ SA}I M>NZ JFR @VJFNSFN F1I6eJ=OSM#0JIVSFNA>F, TQ8 gO1=S@JF gII>@SJAS>F >L XaI1aOI## 3444# TSNSAJM M>FN1WSAZ# vF UJFR2>>G L>= RSNSAJM ?1@AI8 J OJFJN1O1FA A>>M L>=F JFR J@@1II, 1RSA1R 2Z X# tSAAI# gFR>W1=, XJII#8 m>=AV1JIA T>@aO1FAQ>FI1=WJAS>F Q1FA1=#EMJ@GJ2Z, [SOi tJFR>=1, E1AV# 9``P# EaSMRSFN SFA1N=JA1R OaI1aO SFL>=OJAS>F =1A=S1WJMIZIA1OI8 =NJFSIJAS>F JFR J@@1II# g=@VSW1I JFR XaI1aOvFL>=OJAS@I 99899P69DY#E>1VF1=, KS=IA1F, ]V>121 t1FN1=I, JFR e1=S eJZ# 344B# gLL1@ASW1 = @=1JASW1 1pF# TSNSAJM Q=1JASWSAZ 9Y /358P`6\`#E>=NOJF, QV=SIASF1 z# 344P# t@V>MJ=IVS< SF AV1 RSNSAJM JN18 SFL>=OJAS>F, SFL=JIA=a@Aa=1, JFR AV1vFA1=F1A# QJO2=SRN1, Xgi z>FR>F8 Xv^ ]=1II#E>HG1=, e1>LL=1Z Q, JFR taIJF z1SNV tAJ=# 9```# t>=ASFN AVSFNI >aA# @MJIISLS@JAS>F JFR vAI@>FI1wa1F@1I# QJO2=SRN1i z>FR>F8 Xv^ ]=1II#E>ZR bJZHJ=R, 0# 9``D# nSIS>FI >L oJFJRa8 ]JaM lAM1A /9\Y\69`DD5 JFR VZHF, T1S=R=1# 344P# ^1 gVaJ USG>8 RSNSAJM @aMAa=JM V1=SAJN1 JFR SFRSN1F>aI >2?1@AI, FO1FAI# vF ^V1>=S_SFN RSNSAJM @aMAa=JM V1=SAJN18 g @=SAS@JM RSI@>a=I1, 1RSA1R 2Z dQJO1=>F JFR t# K1FR1=RSF1# QJO2=SRN1, Xg8 Xv^ ]=1II#E=>HF, XS@VJ1M d# 9``\# QJF QaMAa=1 E1 Q>M>NZ :` /3589`:6333#Ea@GMJFR, XS@VJ1M K# 9``\# 0VJA SI J RSNSAJM R>@aO1FA f T>@aO1FA maO =Swa1 3 /3583396

3:4#

http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/bult.322http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/asi.20443http://www.dlib.org/dlib/june98/06bearman.htmlhttp://www.dlib.org/dlib/june98/06bearman.htmlhttp://www.marxists.org/reference/subject/philosophy/works/ge/benjamin.htmhttp://www.marxists.org/reference/subject/philosophy/works/ge/benjamin.htmhttp://dx.doi.org/10.1002/bult.322http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/asi.20443http://www.dlib.org/dlib/june98/06bearman.htmlhttp://www.marxists.org/reference/subject/philosophy/works/ge/benjamin.htm

8/12/2019 41010

9/12

QJO1=>F, dS>FJ# 344P# E1Z>FR AV1 @aMA >L AV1 =1=S@JM RSNSAJM>2?1@AI 6 A=JRSAS>FJM @>F@1=FI, F1H RSI@>a=I1I# vF ^V1>=S_SFN RSNSAJM @aMAa=JM V1=SAJN18 g @=SASRSI@>a=I1, 1RSA1R 2Z d# QJO1=>F JFR t# K1FR1=RSF1# QJO2=SRN1, Xg8 Xv^ ]=1II#QJO1=>F, dS>FJ, JFR tJ=JV K1FR1=RSF1, 1RI# 344P# ^V1>=S_SFN RSNSAJM @aMAa=JM V1=SAJN18 J@=SAS@JM RSI@>a=I1# QJO2=SRN1, Xg8 Xv^ ]=1II#QJO1=>F, dS>FJ, JFR U1M1FJ b>2SFI>F# 344P# TSNSAJM GF>HM1RN1I@J=1AS@JM,MM1@AS>F RJAJ2JI1I SF J RSNSAJM 1@V# vF^V1>=S_SFN RSNSAJM @aMAa=JM V1=SAJN18 g @=SAS@JM RSI@>a=I1, 1RSA1R 2Z d# QJO1=>F JFR t#K1FR1=RSF1# QJO2=SRN1, Xg8 Xv^ ]=1II#QVJF, t12JIASJF# 344P# ^JNNSFN JFR I1J=@VSFN 6 I1=1FRSMM1@AS>FRJAJ2JI1I# vF XaI1aOI JFR AV1 012 344P8 ]=>@11RSFNI, 1RSA1R 2Z T# E1J=OJF JFR [# ^=JFA#^>=>FA>8 g=@VSW1I JFR XaI1aO vFL>=OJAS@I#QVaF, taIJF, bS@V QV1==Z, [1FFSL1= ^=JFA, JFR E=a@1 0ZOJF# 344Y# IA1W1#OaI1aO8 JF>FN>SFN 1p@SJM AJNNSFN, L>MGI>F>OZ, JFR OaI1aOI# vF XaI1aOI JFR AV1 012344Y8 g=@VSW1I r XaI1aO vFL>=OJAS@I#QMSLL>=R, [JO1I# 9``P# XaI1aOI JI @>FAJ@A _>F1I# vF b>aA1I 8 A=JW1M JFR A=JFIMJAS>F SF AV1MJA1 AH1FAS1AV @1FAa=Z# QJO2=SRN1, XJII# i z>FR>F8 UJ=WJ=R sFSW1=ISAZ ]=1II#Q>FF1=A>F, ]JaM# 9`\`# U>H I>@S1AS1I =1O1O21=, ^V1O1I SF AV1 I>@SJM I@S1F@1I# QJO2=SRN1qFNMJFR i m1H x>=G8 QJO2=SRN1 sFSW1=ISAZ ]=1II#Q>FIAJFA>aM>I, ]JF>I, JFR Q>IASI TJMMJI# 344\# gIL J RSNSAJM @a=JAS>F JN1FRJ#]JFJM Q>FL1=1F@1 >F TSIA=S2aA1R UaOJF6XJ@VSF1 tZIA1OI /344\5,JA gAV1FI#TJMMJI, Q>IASI# 9```# UaOJFSIAS@ =1I1J=@V, SFL>=OJAS>F =1I>a=@1I JFR 1M1@A=>FS@@>OOaFS@JAS>F# vF qM1@A=>FS@ Q>OOaFS@JAS>F JFR b1I1J=@V SF qa=>HIJFR U#6T# E>1@G1=# zap1O2>a=N8 qa=>OOSIIS>F## 344P# gF JN1F@Z6>=S1FA1R J RSNSAJM @a=JAS>F AV1>=Z JFR =OJAS@I X11ASFN /vQUvX4P58 ]=>@11RSFNI, JA^>=>FA>## 344P# g=@VJ1>M>NS@JM GF>HM1RN1, WS=AaJM 1pVS2SAS>FI JFR AV1 I>@SJM @>FIA=a@AS>F >L

O1JFSFN# vF nS=AaJM OaI1aOI JFR J=@VJ1>M>NZ8 AV1 @>FA=S2aAS>F >L AV1 vAJMSJF mJAS>FJMb1I1J=@V Q>aF@SM# g=@V1>M>NSJ 1 QJM@>MJA>=S, taI@JAS# b>OJ8gMM}SFI1NFSJ R1M NSNMS>#TJIA>F, z>==JSF1# 344D# t2?1@A M1II>FI L=>O J=A JFR I@S1F@1,1RSA1R 2Z z# TJIA>F# m1H x>=G8 >F1 E>>GI#TS EMJI, mS@>M1AAJ, qW1MZF1 e>22>, JFR ]J>M> ]J>MSFS# 344B# :T H>=MRI JFR @aMAa=JM V1=SAJN18=1JMSIO WI# WS=AaJM =OJAS@I#TS1=GSFN, zZFF T#, JFR [>VF U# dJMG# 9``\# gaRS1F@1 JFR J@@1IIS2SMSAZ# vF ^V1 WS=AaJM JFR AV1=1JM 8 O1RSJ SF AV1 OaI1aO, 1RSA1R 2Z t# ^V>OJI JFR g# XSFA_# 0JIVSFNA>F, TQ8 gO1=S@JFgII>@SJAS>F >L XaI1aOI#TS1A_, t#, U# E1II1=, g# E>=RJ, JFR ]# z WZ# 344D# nS=AaJM XaI1aO />L QJFJRJ58 ^V1 m1pAe1F1=JAS>F8 QJFJRSJF U1=SAJN1 vFL>=OJAS>F m1AH>=G#

T>1==, XJ=ASF# 344:# ^V1 QvTlQ Q>F@1R1M8 gF lFA>M>NS@JM gt1OJFAS@ vFA1=>L X1AJRJAJ# gv XJNJ_SF1 3D /:58PB6`3#T>F>WJF, K1WSF# 9``P# ^V1 E1IA >L vFA1FAS>FI8 ]a2MS@ g@@1II, AV1 012 r AV1 qW>MaAS>F >LXaI1aO gaA>OJAS>F# vF XaI1aOI JFR AV1 H12 }`P8 @11RSFNI, 1RSA1R 2Z T# E1J=OJF JFR[# ^=JFA# ]SAAI2a=NV8 g=@VSW1I r XaI1aO vFL>=OJAS@I#TaLL, 01FRZ, JFR QJAV1=SF1 [>VFI>F# 344:# 0V1=1 vI AV1 zSIA HSAV gMM AV1 mJO1IfvFL>=OJAS>F6t11GSFN E1VJWS>= >L e1F1JM>NSIAI# gO1=S@JF g=@VSWSIA YY /958P`6`B#q@>, sO21=A># 9`\Y# dJSAV SF LJG1I8 A=JW1MI SF VZFR>F8 XSF1=WJ#dM>=SRS, za@SJF># 9```# ]VSM>I>ORa@AS>F# z>FR>F8 b>aAM1RN1#dMZFF, E1=FJR1AA1# 344P# ^V1 O>=M>NZ >L I=S_SFN RSNSAJM@aMAa=JM V1=SAJN18 g @=SAS@JM RSI@>a=I1, 1RSA1R 2Z d# QJO1=>F JFR t# K1FR1=RSF1# QJO2=SRN1,Xg8 Xv^ ]=1II#

8/12/2019 41010

10/12

8/12/2019 41010

11/12

[1HSAA, QJ=1Z, JFR baOSG> lZJOJ# 3449# nSIaJM O1JFSFN8 J I>@SJM I1OS>AS@ J>G >L WSIaJM JFJMZISI, 1RSA1R 2Z ^# WJF z11aH1F JFR Q# [1HSAA# z>FR>F i ^V>aIJFRlJGI QJMSL#8 tgeq#[>F1I6eJ=OSM, KJAV1=SF1# 9``P# zJZSFN AV1 L>aFRJAS>F8 AV=11 R1@JR1I >L @>OM>NZSF AV1 OaI1aO# vF ^V1 HS=1R OaI1aO 8 1O1=NSFN A1@VF>M>NZ JFR @VJFNSFN F1I6eJ=OSM# 0JIVSFNA>F, TQ8 gO1=S@JF gII>@SJAS>F >L XaI1aOI#[>F1I, E# KJAV1=SF1# 344P# ^V1 A=JFIL>=OJAS>F >L AV1 RSNSAJM OaI1aO# vF XaI1aO SFL>=OJAS@I8=OJAS>F, JFR A1@VF>M>NZ SF OaI1aOI, 1RSA1R 2Z ]# d# XJ=AZ JFR E# K# [>F1I# m1Hx>=G r z>FR>F8 b>aAM1RN1#[>F1I, e# KJAV1=SF1, 1R# 9``P# ^V1 HS=1R OaI1aO 8 1O1=NSFN A1@VF>M>NZ JFR @VJFNSFNF, TQ8 gO1=S@JF gII>@SJAS>F >L XaI1aOI#KJWJFJNV, eJZF>=# 9`\`# l2?1@AI JI 1WSR1F@1, >= F>Af vF XaI1aO IAaRS1I SF OJA1=SJM @aMAa=1,1RSA1R 2Z t# X# ]1J=@1# z1@1SIA1=, z>FR>F r 0JIVSFNA>F T#Q#8 z1S@1IA1= sFSW1=ISAZ ]=1II rtOSAVI>FSJF vFIASAaAS>F ]=1II## 3444# T=1JO I=Z JFR AV1 OaI1aO# z>FR>Fi m1H x>=G8 z1S@1IA1=sFSW1=ISAZ ]=1II#K11F1, ta_JFF1# 9` \# TSNSAJM @>MM1@AS>FI 8 OaI1aOI JFR AV1 SFL>=OJAS>F JN1# lpL>=R,qFNMJFR i E>IA>F8 EaAA1=H>=AV6U1SF1OJFF## 344B# d=JNO1FAI >L AV1 H>=MR8 aI1I >L OaI1aO @>MM1@AS>FI# lpL>=R8 qMI1WS1=EaAA1=H>=AV6U1SF1OJFF#KF1MM, tSO>F# 344:# ^V1 IVJL AVSFNI A> @>O18 OaI1aOI SF AV1 A1@VF>M>NS@JM MJFRI@J@S1AZ 9 /:589:369DY#z>H1FAVJM, TJWSR# 9`\B# ^V1 =1SNF @>aFA=Z# QJO2=SRN1 QJO2=SRN1IVS=1 i m1Hx>=G8 QJO2=SRN1 sFSW1=ISAZ ]=1II## 9`\`# XJA1=SJM F JFR SAI JMA1=FJASW1I# ]1=IL VSIA>=Z# m1H x>=G8 QJO2=SRN1sFSW1=ISAZ ]=1II#XJ@T>FJMR, e1>=N1, JFR tA1=R# 9`\ # g OaI1aO L>= AV1 NM>2JM WSMMJN18 AV1QJFJRSJF XaI1aO >L QSWSMS_JAS>F# UaMM8 QJFJRSJF XaI1aO >L QSWSMS_JAS>F## 9``9# ^V1 OaI1aO JI SFL>=OJAS>F aASMSAZ# XaI1aO XJFJN1O1FA JFR Qa=JA>=IVSFJMR, zSFRIJZ, 1R# 344Y# TSNSAJM V1=SAJN18 J=R8 EaAA1=H>=AV6U1SF1OJFF#XJF>WS@V, z1W# 3449# ^V1 MJFNaJN1 >L F1H O1RSJ# 9IA Xv^ ]=1II L SFL>=OJAS>F H>=G SF OaI1aOI [>a=FJM >L AV1gO1=S@JF t>@S1AZ L>= vFL>=OJAS>F t@S1F@1 JFR ^1@VF>M>NZ B\ /958`P694P#XJ=AZ, ]JaM d#, JFR E# KJAV1=SF1 [>F1I, 1RI# 344P# XaI1aO SFL>=OJAS@I8 =OJAS>F,JFR A1@VF>M>NZ SF OaI1aOI# m1H x>=G r z>FR>F8 b>aAM1RN1#X@QJ=AVZ, e>HJF# 344P# dSFRSFN J LaAa=1 L>= RSNSAJM @aMAa=JM V1=SAJN1 SFL>=OJAS>F =1I>a=@1I

aISFN @>FA1pAaJM SFL>=OJAS>F L=JO1H>=GI# vF ^V1>=S_SFN RSNSAJM @aMAa=JM V1=SAJN18 g @=SAS@RSI@>a=I1, 1RSA1R 2Z d# QJO1=>F JFR t# K1FR1=RSF1# QJO2=SRN1, Xg8 Xv^ ]=1II#X@QJ=AZ, 0SMMJ=R# 344D# ^=11, Aa=L, @1FA=1, J=@VS ( >= HSMR J@=1f X1AJ=I JFR IA>=S1IL>= VaOJFSAS1I @>OO= zSA1=J=ZJFR zSFNaSIAS@ Q>OL m1H@JIAM1, mt0 gaIA=JMSJ#X1V>, z>GOJF v#, JFR U1M1F b# ^S22># 344:# X>R1MSFN AV1 SFL>=OJAS>F6I11GSFN 21VJWS>= >LI>@SJM I@S1FASIAI8 qMMSI}IAaRZ =1WSISA1R# [>a=FJM >L AV1 gO1=S@JF t>@S1AZ L>= vFL>=OJAS>F t@S1F@JFR ^1@VF>M>NZ BD /Y58BP46B\P#X1IIVJO6XaS=, KSA# 344B# gLL1@A, SFA1=F JFR A1@VF>M>NZ# la=FJM P#XSM1GS@, tMJWG># 344P# ^>HJ=RI AJFNS2M1 WS=AaJMSAS1I8 AJFNSJMSAS1I# vF ^V1>=S_SFN RSNSAJM @aMV1=SAJN18 g @=SAS@JM RSI@>a=I1, 1RSA1R 2Z d# QJO1=>F JFR t# K1FR1=RSF1# QJO2=SRN1, Xg8 Xv^]=1II#

XSA@V1MM, 0SMMSJO [# 9``3# ^V1 =1@>FLSNa=1R 1Z18 WSIaJM A=aAV SF AV1 IA6A>N=JFR>F8 Xv^ ]=1II#

8/12/2019 41010

12/12

# 9``B# QSAZ >L 2SAI 8 IF8 Xv^ ]=1II#X>==SII1Z, QV=SIASF1, JFR T>aNMJI 0>=AI# 9``\# g = AV1 OaI1If m1N>ASJASFN AV1 =>M1 >LA1@VF>M>NZ SF OaI1aOI# vF ^V1 WS=AaJM JFR AV1 =1JM 8 O1RSJ SF AV1 OaI1aO, 1RSA1R 2Z t#^V>OJI JFR g# XSFA_# 0JIVSFNA>F, TQ8 gO1=S@JF gII>@SJAS>F >L XaI1aOI#Xa==JZ, [JF1A U>=>HSA_# 9``\# UJOM1A >F AV1 V>M>R1@G 8 AV1 LaAa=1 >L FJ==JASW1 SF @Z21=IF, e1>=N1 KJ=JGJAIS>ASI, gOZ vIJ=R, JFR v>F gFR=>aAI>aM>I# 344\# EaSMRSFNJF JRJFR zSL1# vF XaI1aOI JFR AV1 0128 g=@VSW1I r XaI1aOvFL>=OJAS@I#l=FJ, qMS_J21AV, JFR QVJ=M1I ]1AASAA# 9``\# vFL>=OJAS>F OJFJN1O1FA SF OaI1aOI# gMR1=IV>A,UJO>OLS1MR, n1=O>FA8 e>H1=#]J@G1=, bJFRJMM, JFR K1F [>=RJF# 3443# XaMASO1RSJ 8 L=>O 0JNF1= A> WS=AaJM =1JMSAZ# qp=G z>FR>F8 0#0# m>=A>F#]J==Z, b>II# 344P# b1@>RSFN AV1 OaI1aO 8 RSNSAJM V1=SAJN1 JFR AV1 A1@VF>M>NS1I >L @VJFN1,XaI1aO O1JFSFNI# z>FR>F8 b>aAM1RN1#