VARIETIES OF SECULARISM

IN A SECULAR AGE

Edited by

MICHAEL WARNER

JONATHAN VANANTWERPEN

CRAIG CALHOUN

H A R V A R D U N I V E R S I T Y P R E S SCambridge, Massachusetts, and London, England 2010

Contents

A Note on Citations vii

Editors' Introduction ι

1. Confronting Modernity: Maruyama Masao, Jürgen Habermas,

and Charles Taylor 32

R O B E R T N. B E L L A H

2. A Closer Walk on the Wild Side 54

J O H N M I L B A N K

3. The Sacred, the Secular, and the Profane:

Charles Taylor and Karl Marx 83

W E N D Y B R O W N

4. Completing Secularism: The Mundane in the Neoliberal Era 105

S I M O N D U R I N G

5. Belief, Spirituality, and Time 126

W I L L I A M E. C O N N O L L Y

6. What Is Enchantment? 145

A K E E L B I L G R A M I

7- This Detail, This History: Charles Taylor's Romanticism 166

COLIN JAGER

C O N T E N T S

8. Disquieted History in A Secular Age 193

J O N B U T L E R

9. When Was Disenchantment? History and the Secular Age 217

J O N A T H A N S H E E H A N

10. The Civilizational, Spatial, and Sexual Powers of the Secular 243

NlLUFER GÖLE

11. A Secular Age: Dawn or Twilight? 265

JOSÉ CASANOVA

12. Can Secularism Be Other-wise? 282

SABA MAHMOOD

Afterword: Apologia pro Libro suo 300

CHARLES TAYLOR

Contributors 32$

Name Index 32η

Subject Index 333

[ vi ]