First detection of Gunn-Peterson...

30

Transcript of First detection of Gunn-Peterson...

Page 1: First detection of Gunn-Peterson Effectsancerre.as.arizona.edu/~fan/Home/AST541_files/week15-2018.pdf · Pathfinders: 1% to 10% of a square kilometer array MWA (MIT/CfA/ANU) 32 Tile
Page 2: First detection of Gunn-Peterson Effectsancerre.as.arizona.edu/~fan/Home/AST541_files/week15-2018.pdf · Pathfinders: 1% to 10% of a square kilometer array MWA (MIT/CfA/ANU) 32 Tile
Page 3: First detection of Gunn-Peterson Effectsancerre.as.arizona.edu/~fan/Home/AST541_files/week15-2018.pdf · Pathfinders: 1% to 10% of a square kilometer array MWA (MIT/CfA/ANU) 32 Tile

First detection of Gunn-Peterson Effect

Page 4: First detection of Gunn-Peterson Effectsancerre.as.arizona.edu/~fan/Home/AST541_files/week15-2018.pdf · Pathfinders: 1% to 10% of a square kilometer array MWA (MIT/CfA/ANU) 32 Tile
Page 5: First detection of Gunn-Peterson Effectsancerre.as.arizona.edu/~fan/Home/AST541_files/week15-2018.pdf · Pathfinders: 1% to 10% of a square kilometer array MWA (MIT/CfA/ANU) 32 Tile

Three stages

Pre-overlap

Overlap

Post-overlap

From Haiman & Loeb

Page 6: First detection of Gunn-Peterson Effectsancerre.as.arizona.edu/~fan/Home/AST541_files/week15-2018.pdf · Pathfinders: 1% to 10% of a square kilometer array MWA (MIT/CfA/ANU) 32 Tile

The end of dark ages: Movie

Page 7: First detection of Gunn-Peterson Effectsancerre.as.arizona.edu/~fan/Home/AST541_files/week15-2018.pdf · Pathfinders: 1% to 10% of a square kilometer array MWA (MIT/CfA/ANU) 32 Tile

First detection of Gunn-Peterson Effect

Page 8: First detection of Gunn-Peterson Effectsancerre.as.arizona.edu/~fan/Home/AST541_files/week15-2018.pdf · Pathfinders: 1% to 10% of a square kilometer array MWA (MIT/CfA/ANU) 32 Tile

Fan 2013

Page 9: First detection of Gunn-Peterson Effectsancerre.as.arizona.edu/~fan/Home/AST541_files/week15-2018.pdf · Pathfinders: 1% to 10% of a square kilometer array MWA (MIT/CfA/ANU) 32 Tile

Accelerated Evolution at z>5.7• Optical depth evolution

accelerated– z<5.7: τ ~ (1+z)4.5

– z>5.7: τ ~ (1+z)>11

– End of reionization?

(1+z)4.5

(1+z)11

XF et al. 2006

Mortlock et al. 2011

Page 10: First detection of Gunn-Peterson Effectsancerre.as.arizona.edu/~fan/Home/AST541_files/week15-2018.pdf · Pathfinders: 1% to 10% of a square kilometer array MWA (MIT/CfA/ANU) 32 Tile

Evolution of Lyman Absorptions at z=5-6

Δz = 0.15

transparent

opaque

Page 11: First detection of Gunn-Peterson Effectsancerre.as.arizona.edu/~fan/Home/AST541_files/week15-2018.pdf · Pathfinders: 1% to 10% of a square kilometer array MWA (MIT/CfA/ANU) 32 Tile

z~7 quasar: first IGM damping wing?

• substantial damping wing: f(HI)>=0.1Mortlock et al. 2011

Page 12: First detection of Gunn-Peterson Effectsancerre.as.arizona.edu/~fan/Home/AST541_files/week15-2018.pdf · Pathfinders: 1% to 10% of a square kilometer array MWA (MIT/CfA/ANU) 32 Tile

Gunn-Peterson Damping Wing in z=7.54 Quasar

Banados+17

near-zone (1.3Mpc)

Page 13: First detection of Gunn-Peterson Effectsancerre.as.arizona.edu/~fan/Home/AST541_files/week15-2018.pdf · Pathfinders: 1% to 10% of a square kilometer array MWA (MIT/CfA/ANU) 32 Tile

Quasar near-zone Sizes

• Size of HII region Rs ~ (LQ tQ / fHI )1/3

• near-zone size evolution consistent with rapid increase of neutral fraction at z>6

• Can be applied to higher z and fHI with lower S/N data

Shapiro, Haiman, Mesinger, Wyithe, Loeb, Bolton, Haehnelt, Maselli et al.

zem

Page 14: First detection of Gunn-Peterson Effectsancerre.as.arizona.edu/~fan/Home/AST541_files/week15-2018.pdf · Pathfinders: 1% to 10% of a square kilometer array MWA (MIT/CfA/ANU) 32 Tile

WMAP: early reionization?

Page 15: First detection of Gunn-Peterson Effectsancerre.as.arizona.edu/~fan/Home/AST541_files/week15-2018.pdf · Pathfinders: 1% to 10% of a square kilometer array MWA (MIT/CfA/ANU) 32 Tile

History of CMB polarization measurement

Page 16: First detection of Gunn-Peterson Effectsancerre.as.arizona.edu/~fan/Home/AST541_files/week15-2018.pdf · Pathfinders: 1% to 10% of a square kilometer array MWA (MIT/CfA/ANU) 32 Tile
Page 17: First detection of Gunn-Peterson Effectsancerre.as.arizona.edu/~fan/Home/AST541_files/week15-2018.pdf · Pathfinders: 1% to 10% of a square kilometer array MWA (MIT/CfA/ANU) 32 Tile
Page 18: First detection of Gunn-Peterson Effectsancerre.as.arizona.edu/~fan/Home/AST541_files/week15-2018.pdf · Pathfinders: 1% to 10% of a square kilometer array MWA (MIT/CfA/ANU) 32 Tile

same CMB, different history

Page 19: First detection of Gunn-Peterson Effectsancerre.as.arizona.edu/~fan/Home/AST541_files/week15-2018.pdf · Pathfinders: 1% to 10% of a square kilometer array MWA (MIT/CfA/ANU) 32 Tile
Page 20: First detection of Gunn-Peterson Effectsancerre.as.arizona.edu/~fan/Home/AST541_files/week15-2018.pdf · Pathfinders: 1% to 10% of a square kilometer array MWA (MIT/CfA/ANU) 32 Tile

Signal I: Global (all sky) emission (eg. TCMB)

Signal ~ 20mK

Feedback ‘slows-down’ galaxy formation

No Feedback

Furlanetto, Oh, Briggs 06

Interplay of ρ, T, f(HI)

Page 21: First detection of Gunn-Peterson Effectsancerre.as.arizona.edu/~fan/Home/AST541_files/week15-2018.pdf · Pathfinders: 1% to 10% of a square kilometer array MWA (MIT/CfA/ANU) 32 Tile

RFI mitigation: location, location location…

100 people km^-2

1 km^-2

0.01 km^-2

Chippendale & Beresford 2007

~VLA

Page 22: First detection of Gunn-Peterson Effectsancerre.as.arizona.edu/~fan/Home/AST541_files/week15-2018.pdf · Pathfinders: 1% to 10% of a square kilometer array MWA (MIT/CfA/ANU) 32 Tile

Pathfinders: 1% to 10% of a square kilometer array

MWA (MIT/CfA/ANU)

32 Tile array deployment in WA 200921CMA (China): 10,000 Dipole array working in Western China 2008

Site Type Freq MHz Area m2 Goal Date

GMRT India Parabola 150-165 4e4 CSS 200921CMA China Dipole 70-200 1e5 PS 2008PAPER GB/Oz/SA Dipole 110-200 5e3 PS/CSS 2009

MWAdemo Oz Aperture 80-300 1e4 PS/CSS 2009LOFAR NL Aperture 115-240 1e5 PS/CSS 2010

SKA ?? Aperture 30-300 1e6 Imaging ??

Page 23: First detection of Gunn-Peterson Effectsancerre.as.arizona.edu/~fan/Home/AST541_files/week15-2018.pdf · Pathfinders: 1% to 10% of a square kilometer array MWA (MIT/CfA/ANU) 32 Tile

Reionization by stellar sources?

Necessary for reionization 6<z<9 (Stiavelli et al 2003)

• Large uncertainties in reionization photon budget:– IGM clumpiness; IMF; escape

efficiency– Large cosmic (sample) variance in

deep field data– Galaxy luminosity function at high-

z

Page 24: First detection of Gunn-Peterson Effectsancerre.as.arizona.edu/~fan/Home/AST541_files/week15-2018.pdf · Pathfinders: 1% to 10% of a square kilometer array MWA (MIT/CfA/ANU) 32 Tile
Page 25: First detection of Gunn-Peterson Effectsancerre.as.arizona.edu/~fan/Home/AST541_files/week15-2018.pdf · Pathfinders: 1% to 10% of a square kilometer array MWA (MIT/CfA/ANU) 32 Tile
Page 26: First detection of Gunn-Peterson Effectsancerre.as.arizona.edu/~fan/Home/AST541_files/week15-2018.pdf · Pathfinders: 1% to 10% of a square kilometer array MWA (MIT/CfA/ANU) 32 Tile
Page 27: First detection of Gunn-Peterson Effectsancerre.as.arizona.edu/~fan/Home/AST541_files/week15-2018.pdf · Pathfinders: 1% to 10% of a square kilometer array MWA (MIT/CfA/ANU) 32 Tile
Page 28: First detection of Gunn-Peterson Effectsancerre.as.arizona.edu/~fan/Home/AST541_files/week15-2018.pdf · Pathfinders: 1% to 10% of a square kilometer array MWA (MIT/CfA/ANU) 32 Tile
Page 29: First detection of Gunn-Peterson Effectsancerre.as.arizona.edu/~fan/Home/AST541_files/week15-2018.pdf · Pathfinders: 1% to 10% of a square kilometer array MWA (MIT/CfA/ANU) 32 Tile
Page 30: First detection of Gunn-Peterson Effectsancerre.as.arizona.edu/~fan/Home/AST541_files/week15-2018.pdf · Pathfinders: 1% to 10% of a square kilometer array MWA (MIT/CfA/ANU) 32 Tile