2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise ›...

53
Deep Inelastic Electron Scattering ( ) ( ) [ ] 2 2 2 1 2 2 tan , 2 , θ ν ν σ σ Q W Q W d d E d d d Mott + × Ω = Ω ( ) 2 2 2 + = + = = h h tgt beam E E E E W s energy available to produce particles in final state Experimentally, W 2 and W 1 seem to depend on only one variable “scaling” (anticipated by Bjorken, 1967) from Nobel lectures, 1990 ( ) ( ) ) ( 2 ) ( ) ( , ) ( , 1 2 2 2 2 1 2 1 x xF x F x F Q W M x F Q W = = = ν ν ν 1 , 1 0 , 2 2 = < < = partons tgt x x M Q x ν scaling good when (Q 2 ,ν) , and if the partons have no transverse momentum . 6/30/2009 1 E. Beise, U Maryland these are not the same F’s as in elastic scattering

Transcript of 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise ›...

Page 1: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

Deep Inelastic Electron Scattering

( ) ( )[ ]222

12

2 tan,2, θννσσ QWQWdd

Eddd

Mott

+×⎟⎠⎞

⎜⎝⎛

Ω=

′Ω

( )2

22 ⎟⎠

⎞⎜⎝

⎛+′=+== ∑

hhtgtbeam EEEEWs

energy available to produce particles in final state

Experimentally, W2 and W1 seem to depend on only one variable

“scaling” (anticipated by Bjorken, 1967)

from Nobel lectures, 1990

( )( )

)(2)(

)(,

)(,

12

22

2

12

1

xxFxF

xFQWM

xFQW

=

=

=

ννν1,10,

2

2

=<<= ∑ partonstgt

xxMQx

ν

scaling good when (Q2,ν) →∞, and if the partonshave no transverse momentum .

6/30/2009 1E. Beise, U Maryland

these are not the same F’s as in elastic scattering

Page 2: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

Hadron Physics

Lecture #1:    The quark model, QCD, and hadron spectroscopy

Lecture #2:   Internal structure of hadrons:  momentum and spin

Lecture #3:    Internal structure of hadrons:  charge, magnetism, polarizability

Lecture #4:   Hadrons in nuclei, hadrons  as laboratories(and miscellaneous  topics)

NNPSS 2009 2E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 3: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

referencesHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons

Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture noteshttp://www.physics.umd.edu/courses/Phys741/xji/lecture_notes.htm

Review articles:

C.F. Perdrisat, V. Punjabi and M. Vanderhaegen, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 59 (2007) 694-764, arXiv: hep-ph/0612014.

J. Arrington, C.D. Roberts and J.M Zanotti, J. Phys. G 34 (2007) S23, arXiv: nucl-th/0611050

Donnelly and Raskin:T.W. Donnelly and A.S. Raskin, Ann. Phys. 169, 247 (1986).

NNPSS 2009 3E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 4: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

Properties of Hadrons: charge, magnetism, polarizability

Nucleon electromagnetic form factors

2-γ exchange

Meson form factors

Nucleon polarizabilities (maybe…)

NNPSS 2009 4E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 5: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

The Proton

|P> = |uud> + |uudqq> + |uudg> + |uudqqg> + …

or

|P> = |p> + |pπ0> + |nπ+> + |p π+ π- > + |pη> + |Λ0 K+> +…

JP = 1/2+ ; I3 = +1/2 (see Particle Properties Data Book, http://pdg.lbl.gov)

charge = e ( to 10-21) r.m.s. charge radius = 0.8768 ± 0.0069 fm2

mass = 938.27231(28) MeV/c2

μp = 2.792847337 ± 0.000000029 μN (= eh/2mNc)elec. dipole moment = (−3.7 ± 6.3) × 10-23 e-cmelectric polarizability = (12.0 ± 0.6) × 10-4 fm3

magnetic polarizability = (1.9 ± 0.5) × 10-4 fm3

mean lifetime = > 5.8 × 1029 years (any decay mode)

NNPSS 2009 5E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 6: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

The proton’s magnetic momentNobel Prize, 1943: "for his contribution to the development of the molecular ray method and his discovery of the magnetic moment of the proton"

μp = 2.5 nuclear magnetons, ± 10% (1933)

Otto Stern

2002 experiment:μp = 2.792847351(28) μNμn = −1.91304274(45) μN

2006 theory:μp ~ 2.8 μNμn ~ −1.8 μN

How do the quarkcontributions add up?

How are charge and magnetism distributed?

NNPSS 2009 6E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 7: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

The neutronJP = 1/2+ I3 = −1/2 (see Particle Properties Data Book, http://pdg.lbl.gov)

charge = −0.41 ±1.1 (× 10-21 e)r.m.s. charge radius = −0.1161 ± 0.0022 fm2

mass = 939.565346(23) MeV/c2

μn = −1.913042793 ± 0.000000023 μN (= eh/2mNc)elec. dipole moment = < 0.29 × 10-25 e-cm (90% C.L.)electric polarizability = (11.6 ± 1.5) × 10-4 fm3

magnetic polarizability = (3.7 ± 2.0) × 10-4 fm3

mean lifetime = 885.7 ± 0.8 sec

NNPSS 2009 7E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 8: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

1930’s:(Chadwick NP 1935)(Stern NP 1943)

1950’s:

proton charge radius from (e,e’)(Hofstadter NP 1961)

1970’s:

partons in proton via inelastic (e,e’)(Friedman,Taylor,Kendall, NP 1990)

1990’s:

polarized targets/polarimetryIntense CW electron beamsimprovement in polarized e sourcesprecision Parity Violation exps

μp ~ 3 μN rp ~ 1 fm

luminosity:(SLAC, 1978) ~ 8 x 1031 cm-2-s-1

(JLab, 2000) ~ 4 x 1038 cm-2-s-1

22 (GeV/c)101.0fm1.01 −=⇔→= Qd

SU(3) and hadron structureadvances in Lattice QCDEFT, Fewbody theory

NNPSS 2009 8E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 9: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

Why study hadron form factors?They give us the ground state properties of (visible) matter:

size and shape, charge and magnetism distributionsspin and angular momentum

They are required elsewherebaseline for structure of nuclei at short distancesProton charge radius Lamb shiftprecision symmetry tests at low Q2

needed input for ν-N interactions: impact on ν oscillation data

χPT

latticeQCD

pQCD

form factors

Benchmarks for connecting QCD across energy/distance scales

GPD’s

low energylong distancenonperturbative

high energyshort distanceperturbative

NNPSS 2009 9E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 10: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

nn p

π−

Views of the Nucleon

explicit sea quarks

“quark model”

QCD/partondescription

π

ππ

“pion cloud” description

udduugluons

s

π−

chiral Pert. Theory

NNPSS 2009 10E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 11: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

Jefferson Laboratory

E ~ 6 GeVContinuous Polarized Electron Beam

> 100 μAup to 80% polarizationconcurrent to 3 Halls

12 GeV Upgrade

NNPSS 2009 11E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 12: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

Mainz Microtron

0.8 GeV CW beam, now 1.5 GeVpolarized D/3He external targets

neutron EM form factors at low Q2

parity violation and Weak form factors

NNPSS 2009 12E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 13: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

MIT‐Bates Laboratory

BLAST detector

BLAST program:

neutron and protonform factors at low Q2

proton charge radius

deuteron structure via vector and tensor polarization

CW 1 GeV polarized beam

polarized internal H/D/3He targets

NNPSS 2009 13E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 14: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

Kinematics of electron scattering

p

k’k

p’

A common reference frame to work in is the LAB frame with a stationary target:

'),(cos'ˆˆ

)','('),(

)',(')0,(

kkqqkk

kEkkEk

pEpMp R

−===⋅

==

==

r

rr

r

νθ

μ)0(2222 >−=−= Qqq rνμ

It is common to assume the electron is massless (extreme relativistic limit). In the case of elastic scattering, energy and 3-momentum are each conserved:

can usually eliminate the recoiling target variables

222 sin'4 θEEQ =

case 1: elastic scattering

recME

fEEE =+

=2

22 sin1'

θin elastic scattering E’, θ are 100%correlated

REMEME =+=−+ ν' '' pqkk rrrr==−

NNPSS 2009 14E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 15: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

unpolarized cross section

( )2

2222 sin12

1)2(

1 Mdd

ME θπ

σ+

Using Fermi’s Golden rule, we integrate over the recoiling target quantities, average over initial spin states, sum over final spin states, and, for elastic scattering, integrate over an energy-conserving delta function. This gives:

p

k’k

p’

All the details of the interaction are in the invariant amplitude2 |M|2.

μνμνα Wl

QM 4

22 =

strength and photon propagation

lepton current hadron current

)'()()()'( kukukukul νμμν γγ=

PJPPJPW νμμν ''=

pointlike leptons

all the excitement is in

)(]?)['( pupuJ =μ

NNPSS 2009 15E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 16: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

the hadronic current)(]?)['( pupuJ =μ

In elastic scattering: the target is left intact and we measure its response to the EM current.

⎥⎦⎤

⎢⎣⎡ += ν

μνμ σκγ qiQFM

QF )(2

)(]?[ 22

21

The cross section becomes:

( ) ⎥⎦

⎤⎢⎣

⎡++⎟⎟

⎞⎜⎜⎝

⎛+⎟

⎠⎞

⎜⎝⎛

Ω=

Ω 222

212

22

22

22

1 tan24

' θκκσσ FFMQF

MF

EE

dd

dd

Mott

if the target is spin ½ and has no structure then: 0,1 21 == FFif the target is spin 0 then it has no magnetic moment so term with 02 →F

κ = anomalous part of magnetic moment

NNPSS 2009 16E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 17: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

Form factors: spin 0 target

e

e'θ

ΔΩ

ΔΩ=

Ω tgte NNcounts

dd #σ

242

22

0 sin4 θ

ασEZ

dd

=⎟⎠⎞

⎜⎝⎛

Ω

EE

dd

dd

M

′⋅⎟

⎠⎞

⎜⎝⎛

Ω=⎟

⎠⎞

⎜⎝⎛

Ω 22

0

cos θσσ

22 )(QFdd

dd

M

⋅⎟⎠⎞

⎜⎝⎛

Ω=⎟

⎠⎞

⎜⎝⎛

Ωσσ

Rutherford

Mott

Scattering from an extended object:

form factor DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevC.71.054323

Q = (v,q)

e

e'

NNPSS 2009 17E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 18: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

Form factors: spin 0 target

J.M. Cavedon, PhD thesis, Orsay, France (1980)

e

e'θ

ΔΩ

ΔΩ=

Ω tgte NNcounts

dd #σ

242

22

0 sin4 θ

ασEZ

dd

=⎟⎠⎞

⎜⎝⎛

Ω

EE

dd

dd

M

′⋅⎟

⎠⎞

⎜⎝⎛

Ω=⎟

⎠⎞

⎜⎝⎛

Ω 22

0

cos θσσ

22 )(QFdd

dd

M

⋅⎟⎠⎞

⎜⎝⎛

Ω=⎟

⎠⎞

⎜⎝⎛

Ωσσ

Rutherford

Mott

circa 1980

Scattering from an extended object:

Krrr

+−== ∫ ⋅

61)()(

2232

rqrdreqF rqi ρ

form factor

Q = (v,q)

e

e'

NNPSS 2009 18E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 19: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

Spin ½ hadrons: Sachs Form Factors

)(2

)()()( 22

21 pu

mqiQFQFpuJ ⎥

⎤⎢⎣

⎡+= ν

μνμ σκ

sMEs Gm

qiGJ χσχμ ⎟⎠⎞

⎜⎝⎛ ×

+= ′ 2*

vv

21

21

FFGFFG

M

E

κτκ

+=−=

The nucleon e.m. current

as seen in the Breit frame

charge and current contributions in this frameare represented by Sachs form factors:

slide from J. J. Kelly

0)0(

1)0(

=

=nE

pE

G

G ( )

N

nn

nM

N

pp

pM

G

G

μμκ

μμ

κ

=−==

==+=

91.1)0(

79.21)0(

2

2

4 NMQ

NNPSS 2009 19E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 20: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

“Rosenbluth” Separation

• GMdominates for large τ.• Must control kinematics, acceptances, and radiativecorrections very accurately because coefficient is strong function of angle.

• As Q2 increases, the contribution from εGE

2 gets very small (even for the proton)

22)1(EM

M

GGdd ετσ

στε

+=Ω

+

SLAC NE11, Bosted et al.

slide from J. J. Kelly

[ ]222

2

tan)1(211,

4 θτετ

++==

MQ

intercept slope

NNPSS 2009 20E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 21: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

)()()( 222 QGQGQF ME τε +→

proton form factors

τ, ε depend on scattering angle

Nonrelativistically, as with nuclei, the textbook description is

)/(0

0)( rrer −= ρρ

( )220

2

2

11)(

rQQGD

+=

from J. Arrington, Phys. Rev. C 69 (2001) 022201

BUT quarks are highly relativistic: this is reference frame dependent, and thus can’t be interpreted as a 3-D charge distribution

“dipole”

using the Rosenbluth technique only here

NNPSS 2009 21E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 22: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

charge and magnetism distributionsThese are at best qualitative, and are reference frame dependent. But we can correctly call them “Breit frame distributions”

BLAST fit from D. Hasell, CIPANP 2009

Reference frame independent approach:Look only at the transverse dimensions, which are the same in all frames.

)()(~)2(

)(

)()2(

)(

22

222

22

23

3

bqGebdzbdz

zbr

qGerdr

Ebqi

chg

Erqi

chg

ρπ

ρ

πρ

==+

+=

=

⊥⋅−∞

∞−

⋅−

∫∫

rr

rr

see G. Miller, PRL 99 (2007)112001NNPSS 2009 22E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 23: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

Generalized Parton Distributions

Elastic Scatteringtransverse quark

distribution in coordinate space

DISlongitudinal

quark distributionin momentum space

DES (GPDs)fully-correlated

quark distribution in both coordinate and

momentum space

GPDs yield 3-dim quark structure of the nucleon

Burkardt (2000, 2003)

Belitsky, Ji, Yuan (2003)

slide from F. Sabatie, CIPANP 2009

NNPSS 2009 23E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 24: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

Polarized e‐N scattering• Polarized beam + polarized target:

• Polarized beam + polarization of recoil nucleon:

unpol

EMM GGbGaAσ

θθσσσσ )()( *2* +

∝+−

=↑↓↑↑

↑↓↑↑

2

'

tan2

)(e

p

ee

L

T

M

E

MEE

PP

GG θ+

−=

p p

n

pnede ++→+rr

→ neutron charge

...3 ++→+ neeHerr

→ neutron magnetism

)'( need rr

)'( peep rrneutron charge

proton GE/GM

Donnelly + Raskin, Ann. Phys. 169 (1986)247

Akhiezer+Rekalo, Sov.JPN 3 (1974) 277Arnold,Carlson+Gross, PRC 21 (1980) 1426

eHr

3p

n dr

NNPSS 2009 24E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 25: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

Proton recoil polarization experiments

( ))(1 PSAhPSdddp

d

eNN

′⋅++⋅+=ΩΩ

vvvvσσ

electron helicity

( ) ( )2

'

tan2

e

MEE

PP

GG ee

L

S

M

E θ+′′

−=Measure direction of proton polarization by looking for small phase shift in rotation of proton’s polarization vector through a polarimeter

Front trackingRear tracking

NNPSS 2009 25E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 26: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

example of Focal Plane polarimeter (Hall C, Jlab)

Detect electrons with magnetic spectrometer (GEP-I, GEP-II) or with a calorimeter (GEP-III): this determines all the kinematics of the scattering reaction. Measure the polarization with polarimeter behind a magnetic spectrometer. Need also to worry about g-2 precession in the spectrometer magnets!

NNPSS 2009 26E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 27: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

The proton: recoil polarization vs. cross sections

Pol’n data indicate BIG differences charge and magnetism distributions

In pQCD description, seems to be that orbital motion of quarks is important in GE

P (Belitsky, Ji + Yuan PRL 91 (2003) 092003)

Cross section data disagree with polarization data:

Looks like 2-γ exchange is important in the cross section data

NNPSS 2009 27E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 28: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

2‐photon exchange

p

k’k

p’

the scattering amplitude goes like

+

the cross section goes like:

)Re(2

)(

22

22

γ

γσ

AAA

AAd

e

bornborn

born

±∝

++∝Ω

±

K

“Born” term

In terms of form factors:additional terms addcorrections of a few %

comparable to size of the GE

P term of the cross section

⎪⎭

⎪⎬⎫

⎪⎩

⎪⎨⎧

⎟⎟⎟

⎜⎜⎜

⎟⎟⎟

⎜⎜⎜

⎛+++∝

Ω MM

E

M

EM

GMF

G

G

G

GG

dd

~~

Re~

~2~

~~

23

2

22

νετεεττ

σ

2γ only

these are now complex

NNPSS 2009 28E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 29: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

J. Lachniet, PR-07-005,Exclusive Reactions Workshop, May 2007

e+

e+

at JLab

Also plans for positron exps atNovosibirsk, Siberia and with BLAST at DESY

NNPSS 2009 29E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 30: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

the neutron no free neutron targets exist! Must use a nucleus

simplest case unpolarized elastic e-d scattering-- need to know n-p wave function very well-- not too bad for magnetism, but charge is hugely

dominated by the proton p

n

e

e'

next simplest case unpolarized quasielastic e-d scattering-- direct interaction with nucleon, don’t need to know so much about n-p

interaction-- Better than above for magnetism, especially if can detect the outgoing

neutron-- but, knowledge of efficiency of neutron detector is very important

[ ]...++∝Ω LTdEdd εσσσ ( ) ( ) 22

0

222 npQ

nM

pMT GG μμσ +⎯⎯ →⎯+∝

( ) ( ) ( ) ( )220

22 012 +⎯⎯ →⎯+∝→Q

nE

pEL GGσ

NNPSS 2009 30E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 31: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

the neutron in deuteriump

n

pnede ++→+rr

→ double polarization needed to measure the neutron charge distributionpnede ++→+

rr

)',()',(

peedneed

→ neutron magnetism

→ helps to detect the neutron – identifies the nucleon involved in the scattering

Lachniet et al, arXiv:0811.1716

NNPSS 2009 31E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 32: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

from M. Jones, HUGS 2009

NNPSS 2009 32E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 33: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

the neutron in 3He

p p

n

eHr

3

p p

n

p p

n+ +

“S”88.2%

“S-prime”1.5%

“D”9.8%

%3%86

−==

p

n

PP

)',(3 eeeH rrOK for neutron magnetism proton is small correction

)',(3 neeeH rrneed to detect the neutronmeasure asymmetry don’t need detection efficiency (much)

unpol

EMM GGbGaAσ

θθσσσσ )()( *2* +

∝+−

=↑↓↑↑

↑↓↑↑

NNPSS 2009 33E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 34: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

Polarized 3HeJlab Hall A target, from A. Kelleher

from W. Korsch, U Ky

NNPSS 2009 34E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 35: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

The neutron magnetic form factor: low Q2

•Xu et al, PRC 67 (2003) 012201Q2 < 0.3 (GeV/c)2: need Fadeev calc of 3He wave fn, including MEC/FSIQ2 > 0.3 (GeV/c)2: PWIA works well, relativity important

)',(3 eeeH rr

Kubon et al, PLB 524 (2002) 26.

requires precise determination of neutron detection efficiency.

)'()',(

peedneed

NNPSS 2009 35E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 36: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

example: Jlab Hall A experiment

G. Cates, CIPANP 2009

NNPSS 2009 36E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 37: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

neutron’s charge form factor (high Q2)

B. Plaster, et al.,PRC 73, 025205 (2006)

)',( need rr

preliminary results(don’t quote these)

)',(3 neeeH rr

G. Cates, CIPANP 2009

NNPSS 2009 37E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 38: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

BLAST at MIT‐Bates

Storage Ring: 50 MeV, >200 mA, Pe ≈ 65%

Polarized Internal GasTarget: Polarized hydrogen, vector/tensor polarized deuterium DRIFT CHAMBERS

CERENKOVCOUNTERS

SCINTILLATORS

NEUTRON COUNTERS

TARGETBEAM

BEAM

COILSLarge Detector acceptance:0.1 < Q2/(GeV/c)2 < 0.820o < θ < 80o, -15o < φ < 15o

Simultaneous detection of e±, π±, p, n, d

http://mitbates.lns.mit.edu/bates/control/main

NNPSS 2009 38E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 39: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

neutron charge at low Q2

constraint from charge radius measurements

NNPSS 2009 39E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 40: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

INTERLUDE: the NEUTRON CHARGE RADIUSfrom NEUTRON-ELECTRON SCATTERING

S. Kopecky et al, Phys Rev. C 56, 2229 (1997)

<rn2> - neutron mean squared charge radius

bne - neutron-electron scattering length(related to phase shift upon scattering)

Nuclear scattering length bc >> bne, so rely on interference term and high Z:

bne = 1.33 ± 0.27 ± 0.03 fm (208Pb)yields <rn

2> = −0.115 fm2

NNPSS 2009 40E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 41: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

Form Factors in Lattice QCD (a sampling)

LHPC collab.: (hep-lat/0610007)

(p - n): lattice calculationapproaches data as pionmass approaches physical value

Extrapolate lattice-determined magnetic moments and GM

p,n using guidance from chiral effective theory

Wang, etal, Phys.Rev.D75:073012,2007:

neutron

data

fit to data

NNPSS 2009 44E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 42: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

Spin 0: π and K Electromagnetic Form Factors

Charge radii are knownfrom π-e and K-e scattering

Light mesons important in nucleon structure

Theoretically “clean”…

Experimentally “unclean”: moving target…

22

22

fm05.034.0

fm01.044.0

±=

±=

+Kr

2

22 8)(

2 QfQF s

Q

ππ

πα∞→

( ) φσεφσεεσσεφ

σπ 2coscos122dt

ddt

ddt

ddt

ddtdd TTLTTL ++++=

),()()(

2222

2

tQFtgmt

tQdt

dNN

Lππ

π

σ−

−∝

NNPSS 2009 45E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 43: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

pion electroproduction

Q2= |q|2 – ω2t=(q - pπ)2

W=√-Q2 + M2 + 2Mω

scattering plane

reaction plane

( ) φσεφσεεσσεφ

σπ 2coscos122dt

ddt

ddt

ddt

ddtdd TTLTTL ++++=

nepe ++→+ π'

( ) ( ) 022222 <⋅+−−−=−= qpqpEpqt rrπππ ν

Need to extrapolate to t = mπ2, the “pion pole”

slide from T. Horn, JLab

NNPSS 2009 46E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 44: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

47

• Hall C spectrometers– Coincidence measurement – SOS detects e-

– HMS detects π+

• Targets– Liquid 4-cm H/D cells– Al (dummy) target for background

measurement– 12C solid targets for optics calibration

HMS Aerogel– Improvement of p/π+/K+ PID at large

momenta, first use in 2003– Built by Yerevan group

[Nucl. Instrum. Meth. A548(2005)364]

Measurement of Fπ (in Hall C, Jlab)

slide from T. Horn, JLabNNPSS 2009 47E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 45: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

Hall C: two spectrometersone suited for K detectionfloor space for addt’l detectorspolarized d target

JLab Experimental Equipment

G0 detector

NNPSS 2009 48E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 46: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

Pion form factorT. Horn et al., PRL 97 (2006)192001

V. Tadevosyan et al., nucl-ex/0607007

P. Brauel et al., Z. Phys. C3 (1979) 101H. Ackermann et al., Nucl. Phys. B137 (1978) 294S. R. Amendolia et al., Nucl. Phys. B277 (1986) 168

T. Horn et al., PRC 78 (2008) 058201The part needed for Fπ is well-described by model calculation, can be used to extra the form factor

Slides from T. Horn

calculation is Vanderhaeghen, Guidal, Laget, PRC 57 (1998), 1454

NNPSS 2009 49E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 47: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

Weak nucleon form factors 

( )N

EN

AN

F

NN u

qFM

qiqqqqF

MG

qFM

qiqF

uNJN

⎥⎥⎥⎥⎥

⎢⎢⎢⎢⎢

−−

++

=

)(2

)(

)(2

)('

255

222

22

21

γσγγγ

σγ

νμν

μνν

μγ

γν

μνμ

γ

γμ

NZ

N

ZN

Z uqFM

qiqFuNJN

⎥⎥⎦

⎢⎢⎣

⎡+= )(

2)(' 2

22

1

νμν

μμ

σγ

NPN

ZAN

Z uqqGM

qGuNJN 522

5 )(1)(' γγ μμμ ⎥⎦

⎤⎢⎣

⎡+=

nucleons:

pointlike fermions:

( )54:Weak

:EM

γγ

γ

μ

μ

fA

fV

W

Z

f

ggM

gMi

ieQ

+

Qf gVf gA

f ν 0 1 −1

e,μ− −1 −1 + 4 sin2θW +1

u,c,t +2/3 1 − 8/3 sin2θW −1 d,s,b −1/3 −1 + 4/3 sin2θW +1

time reversal violating

ignore

NN

N uqFM

qiqFuNJN

⎥⎥⎦

⎢⎢⎣

⎡+= )(

2)(' 2

22

νμν

μγγ

μ

σγ

NNPSS 2009 51E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 48: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

polarizabilitiescharge = e ( to 10-21) r.m.s. charge radius = 0.8768 ± 0.0069 fm2

mass = 938.27231(28) MeV/c2

μp = 2.792847337 ± 0.000000029 μN (= eh/2mNc)elec. dipole moment = (−3.7 ± 6.3) × 10-23 e-cmelectric polarizability = (12.0 ± 0.6) × 10-4 fm3

magnetic polarizability = (1.9 ± 0.5) × 10-4 fm3

mean lifetime = > 5.8 × 1029 years (any decay mode)

charge = -0.41 ±1.1 (× 10-21 e)r.m.s. charge radius = −0.1161 ± 0.0022 fm2

mass = 939.565346(23) MeV/c2

μn = −1.913042793 ± 0.000000023 μN (= eh/2mNc)elec. dipole moment = < 0.29 × 10-25 e-cm (90% C.L.)electric polarizability = (11.6 ± 1.5) × 10-4 fm3

magnetic polarizability = (3.7 ± 2.0) × 10-4 fm3

mean lifetime = 885.7 ± 0.8 sec

proton

neutron

NNPSS 2009 58E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 49: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

p+

p+p+

p+

p+

p+

p+

p+

Electric polarizability: proton between charged parallel plates

Proton electric polarizability

Pioncloud

+ + + + + + + + + + + + +

- - - - - - - - - - - - -

Er

slide from H. Weller,see HUGS 2009

NNPSS 2009 59E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 50: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

d

u u

p+

p+

p+

p+

Magnetic polarizability: proton between poles of a magnet

Proton magnetic polarizability

Diamagnetic + Paramagneticpion cloud

ParamagneticD(1232)

Br

N N N N N N N N N N N

S S S S S S S S S S S

slide from H. Weller,see HUGS 2009

NNPSS 2009 60E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 51: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

Electric and magnetic polarizabilities

• the numbers are small:  the nucleon is very “stiff”

†M. Schumacher, Prog. Part. and Nucl. Phys. 55, 567 (2005) and PDG.

3410)6.00.12( fmx −±=α3410)6.09.1( fmx −= mβ

proton3410)5.16.11( fmx −±=α

3410)0.27.3( fmx −= mβ

neutron (best gotten from the deuteron)

e

m

( )( )( )

( )( ) ⎥⎥⎥⎥

⎢⎢⎢⎢

+

⎟⎟⎟⎟

⎜⎜⎜⎜

−−+

++−+⎟

⎠⎞

⎜⎝⎛

⎟⎟⎠

⎞⎜⎜⎝

⎛=

ΩK

2

2

22

222

cos121

cos121

'4cos121'

4 θβα

θβαωωπθ

ωω

πσ

γγ eM

Me

dd

spin polarizabilities…via Compton Scattering at Eγ > 50 MeV

NNPSS 2009 61E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 52: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

measurements of the proton polarizabilities

Future measurements will improve these, with the new facility at the Duke University FEL, HiGs

NNPSS 2009 62E. Beise, U Maryland

Page 53: 2 - Institute for Nuclear Theory › NNPSS › 2009_school › talks › beise › Lecture3.pdfHalzen & Martin: Quarks and Leptons. Xiangdong Ji: Graduate nuclear physics lecture notes.

Why study hadron form factors?They give us the ground state properties of (visible) matter:

size and shape, charge and magnetism distributionsspin and angular momentum

They are required elsewherebaseline for structure of nuclei at short distancesProton charge radius Lamb shiftprecision symmetry tests at low Q2

needed input for ν-N interactions: impact on ν oscillation data

χPT

latticeQCD

pQCD

form factors

Benchmarks for connecting QCD across energy/distance scales

GPD’s

low energylong distancenonperturbative

high energyshort distanceperturbative

NNPSS 2009 63E. Beise, U Maryland