8/4/2019 (Canovan, , 2010)

1/12

YXPONA 58 EMATA

.1 -

fi fi

, , fi

,

fi . ,

. , fi fi

fi , fi

. fi

-

. fi fi

. fi -

, fi -

! *

MARGARET CANOVAN

Margaret Canovan fi - Keele University .

Hannah Arendt,

fi fi. fi

fi

Two Strategies for the Study of Politics,

Political Studies, . 30, . 4, 1982, . 544-552 Populism, Junction Books, 1981 The People , Polity, - 2005.

, 110, - 2010, . 58-69

R. B. Kitaj

004ORMOS 01-11-10 15:33 58

8/4/2019 (Canovan, , 2010)

2/12

fi -fi . fi fi fi fi fi - fi , . - fi fi fi fi - . fi, fi ,2 fi .

fi;

fi , -

fi, -fi , fi, . - fi, fi- .3 (fi) fi fi -, fi fi , fi . ,

fi fi . fi fi - fi fi . fi fi - fi - , fi - . fi fi .

fi

fi fi fi ( Paul Taggart) fi .4 fi . , fi fi fi.5

fi - , - -fi.6 fi , fi - fi fi fi , . - fi fi , , fi . Jean-Marie Le Pen Front National fi fi , , fi -, fi fi - .7

fi,

fi . , , - fi fi fi fi fi fi - ,8 - - fi fi- fi. fi (fi ) fi fi , fi -

. - fi, fi - fi. (fi ) fi - , , - fi, fi fi, fi - , . - fi .9 -fi fi , , , - - -fi fi . - , Michael Kazin fi -

YXPONA 59 EMATA

004ORMOS 01-11-10 15:33 59

8/4/2019 (Canovan, , 2010)

3/12

YXPONA 60 EMATA

fi fi . fi 1940 fifi fi fi 10

fi . fi fi fi fi , , , fi .

fi fi , - [authority]. - fi fi fi fi, fi

fi fi fi . - , .11 fi fi fi fi, fi fi fi fi fi. -, - fi fi fi, -

.12

, , fi . fi United We Stand fi Ross Perot . fi - - fi , - fi fi . fi- , fi fi fi , , . - ( ), , fi fi -, .fi , fi

Front National , fi-. , fi, fi fi : fi- fi fi fi13 [common people] fi fi fi[ordinary people], - fi . - fi , , fi (fi ) fi , - .14 fi fi - fi ,

. fi fi fi - fi fi - fi fi, fi .

fi , fi,fi fi fi.

, fi .15

fi , fi - fi fi ,fi [tabloid style]. fi , fi - . fi: - fi fi, - , , fi .16 fi , fi , - ,17 fi fi .18 - fi fi fi

004ORMOS 01-11-10 15:33 60

8/4/2019 (Canovan, , 2010)

4/12

fi - fi fi , , .

fi fi fi , ,, fi fi , fi , . . - fi fi fi .19 fi fifi fi . - fi fi .20

- . , -, fi fi fi fi fi .21

(, - fi , , ) fi

fi fi fi .22 fi fi , fi fi fi. fi . , fi fi - .23 fi, fi fi - .24 , .

fi fi;

, fi -

. fi, fi fi fi , - - - .25 fi - . fi fi -.26 fi fi ; fi ; fi fi ;

fi fi , fi , -

fi fi . , fi fi- fi, .27 Beetham ( fi ) fi , fi - , . - fi fi - fi

. fi - , fi fi .28

fi fi fi - , -. fi Sartori.29 fi fi -. , fi - , fi fi fi -, fi fi -.30 fi fi ,

YXPONA 61 EMATA

004ORMOS 01-11-10 15:33 61

8/4/2019 (Canovan, , 2010)

5/12

. fi - - fi - , fi fi ,fi , fi , fi fi. fi , fi -, fi, -, fi fi . fi - , .

, Michael

Oakeshott. Oakeshott fi fi fi - [civil association].31

fi , - fi, fi - : fi , fi - [enterprise association], - fi

, fi .

. , Oakeshott fi fifi fi , - fi , fi -, -fi fi. fi . , fi fi. fi , fi . fi - , , fi fi

. fi fi fi fi .

, , - fi fi fi, fi . , fi, fi fi fi - . fi , .32

Oakeshott. fi Oakeshott fi , fi fi , fi

, fi .33 fi fi. fi fi, fi fi, [] fi .34 - Oakeshott . , - fi, fi , fi

.35 , fi, , .

, , - . , fi - fi, fi fi - fi, . Oakeshott, fi , , fi fi _ - fi . ,fi, Oakeshott - fi- fi .

YXPONA 62 EMATA

004ORMOS 01-11-10 15:33 62

8/4/2019 (Canovan, , 2010)

6/12

fi fi Human Conduct, - Rationalism in Politics, . , , fi , fi ( ), -fi fi . fi , fi fi , fi, - , , , - . fi , , fi - .

fi

fi , ,, ( fi) -. fi, fi - fi, - fi fi fi , fi

fi fi -fi.

fi, fi fi -, fi , ( fi) -.36 fi fi vox populi vox dei, fi , fi fi, fi. fi fi () -, fi fi - fi.37 ( fi Sartori) fi. -, fi - ( : , -fi, )38 fi . -

, - :

(1) fi fi, fi . ,, - fi .

(2) - : fi fi (authority), - fi fi . fi fi , , fi - fi.

(3) , :, fi fi , . fi (fi fi) fi: fi, fi .

fi fi - - , fi - fi fi - . fi,

, - . - , fi fi . - -, , , , fi .

(1) fi , fi - fi fi . fi fi fi . Bobbio , fi fi - fi fi fi

YXPONA 63 EMATA

004ORMOS 01-11-10 15:33 63

8/4/2019 (Canovan, , 2010)

7/12

fi - .39 fi - - (fi fi - fi ), fi fi fi, fi - fi. fi , , , , fi fi - fi .

fi -

fi , - . - , - .fi . , fi, : fi fi . fi - fi .

, - . fi fi fi fi fi, fi fi. , - -, - fi. fi fi . , -, fi . -fi , fi- . fi fi fi , fi fi fi- fi fi fi fi - , . fi fi fi -, fi ,

, - . fi - , fi -, fi, fi , fi - . fi fi , fi ,, .40

(2) fi fi, - fi, fi fi , fi fi fi -fi , fi

fi. -fi fi fi fi. fi fi - : , fi, .

fi- fi fi , fi .

-

. fi, fi .fi ( fi RalfDahrendorf 1989), fi fi .41 fi, fi - fi. fi -, fi fi, - . fi fi, , fi, fi - ,42 - - fi . - fi , , fi - fi .43 fi

YXPONA 64 EMATA

004ORMOS 01-11-10 15:33 64

8/4/2019 (Canovan, , 2010)

8/12

fi - fi fi .

fi fi fi fi , fi . fi fi fi fi . ,fi fi , - -fi . fi fi , - . fi fi -

fi 1890 fi -. fi fi , fi fi . fi, fi fi fi . . , -, fi ,44 - fi , fi .

-

, fi . , fi; -, , , politicallycorrect , fi , ...: -, fi, , . fi -fi fi - , fi . fi fi fi fi - , - , .

-, fi -

, fi . fi - fi , - , fi fi fi. fi : fi fi fi - , fi fi . fi , fi fi . , fi .

fi , fi- . ,, fi , , fi.

(3) - fi fi . fi fi fi.45

fi

, , . fi fi .

fi : , fi fi .46 fi, fi . fi fi - . fi- fi - . ,

YXPONA 65 EMATA

004ORMOS 01-11-10 15:33 65

8/4/2019 (Canovan, , 2010)

9/12

fi . , fi ,

Marx fi fi

, .47 -

- - . -

fi fi .

Beetham -

fi , -

fi - .48 fi

fi fi fi fi -

fi . , ,

, . fi, -

fi fi . fi, fi

fi fi

. fi fi

fi . fi fi

fi fi. - fi fi

fi fi , fi, fi , -

.

fi . Weber, - fi fi -

fi . -

fi , vox Dei fi . , -

. fi -

fi ,

fi fi

fi .49

fi - fi fi. fi, vox populi. , , fi fi fi fi . fi - -. : fi fi - . fi

,fi fi . fi - fi, fi - Weber, - . fi - , -

fi.50

fi o fi - fi fi- - fi fi. -, , fi fi fi fi . fi fi . ; ; , fi

YXPONA 66 EMATA

004ORMOS 01-11-10 15:33 66

8/4/2019 (Canovan, , 2010)

10/12

, - ; , fi - 60 fi ;51

fi fi, fi fi . fi , fi - , - . , fi-, fi ( fi Oakeshott) -fi fi fi fi , fi .

fi fi - - fi : - , fi, - fi fi , fi- () .52 -fi fi fi fi ( fi fi - -),53 fi fi , fi -

- fi fi.54

fi - Sartori [politicos],55 fi fi fi . fi , fi- fi - fi . fi -fi fi fi , . fi , , fi - .56 fi fi , fi fi - fi

. fi fi - . -, fi , - .57

fi fi fi . fi . , fi - , , fi . fi fi fi -

.M: ,

fi

*

Political Studies, .. 47, 1999, . 2-16. fi - , , workshops ECPR , fi . John Horton Andrew Dobson Political Studies fi

fi.1 H.-G. Betz, Radical Right-Wing Populism in Western Europe

(Houndmills, Macmillan, 1994), . 4. - Betz fi Front National, fi FP, Lega Nord , Vlaams Block , Autopartei Tessin League, fiRepublikaner, fi , . - - fi Reform Party , OneNation Party Paulin Hanson , fi Ross Perot Pat Buchanan - .

2 T. S. Di Tella, Populism into the twenty-first century,Government and Opposition, 32 (1997), 187-200, . 190.

3 fi fi . D. Westlind, ThePolitics of Popular Identity: Understanding Recent Populist Movements

in Sweden and the United States (Lund, Lund University Press,1996). G. Ionescu and E. Gellner (.), Populism:its Meanings and National Characteristics (, Weidenfeld Nicholson, 1969), , fi . , - - . M. Canovan, Populism ( fi,

YXPONA 67 EMATA

004ORMOS 01-11-10 15:33 67

8/4/2019 (Canovan, , 2010)

11/12

Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, 1981) M. Canovan, Twostrategies for the study of populism, Political Studies, 30 (1982),544-52. - fi, fi- fi fi .

4 P. A. Taggart, The New Populism and the New Politics: New ProtestParties in Sweden in a Comparative Perspective (,Macmillan, 1996), . 32.

5 . J. Haider, The Freedom I Mean (Pine Plains, Swan, 1995), .104, 88.

6 Taggart fi , -, fi fi - fi - fi. fi fi

fi , fi Taggart (The New Populism,. 33, 35).

7 J. Marcus, The National Front and French Politics (,

Macmillan, 1995), . 54. fi . P.Manning, The New Canada (Toronto, Macmillan, Canada, 1992),. 2 Paulins People, The Weekend Australian,17-18 May1997, review section, . 1.

8 . Betz, RadicalRight- Wing Populism, . 42-47, 110-2; Taggart, The New Populism,. 34.

9 . C. Lasch, The True andOnly Heaven: Progress and its Critics ( fi, Norton, 1991) P. Piccone, From the New Left to the New Populism, Telos101 (1994), 173-208. fi . M.Canovan, G. K. Chesterton: Radical Populist ( fi, HarcourtBrace Jovanovich, 1977).

10 Kazin, Populist Persuasion, . 4. fi fi, - Westlind, The Politics of Popular Identity.

11 fi, . G. S. Jones, Languages of Class: Studies in EnglishWorking Class History 1832-1982 (Cambridge, CambridgeUniversity Press, 1983), . 96-100.

12 . M. Canovan, People, politicians and populism,Government and Opposition, 19 (1984), 312-27.

13 fi - . 14 - fi fi 1991 fi .Manning, The New Canada, . 361.

14 . Kazin, Populist

Persuasion, . 252. - . Haider, The Freedom I Mean, . 68.

15 . Manning, The New Canada, . 123,Paulines Peaople, . 1.

16 . Westlind, The Politics of Popular Identity, . 203. To E. Shils, The Torment of Secrecy(, Heinemann, 1956) .

17 . R. S. Katz and P. Mair, Changing models of partyorganization and party democracy, Party Politics, I (1995), 2-28, . 24.

18 J. Hayward (.), The Crisis of Representation in Europe, -, Frank Cass, 1995.

19 Kazin, Populist Persuasion, . 16 .20 Taggart, The New Populism, . 2, 37. fi George

Wallace . Kazin, Populist Persuasion,. 221-42.21 Westlind, The Politics of Popular Identity, . 106, 177.22 Betz, Radical Right-wing Populism, . 4. -

Canovan, Populism, . 158-69. DiTella, Populism into the twenty-first century, . 196-7_ A.Bozoki and M. Sfikosd, Civil society and populism in the EasternEuropean democratic transitions, Praxis International, 13 (1993),. 224-41.

23 Haider, The Freedom I Mean, . 106. - fi , , fi. . K. W. Kobach, The Referendum:Direct Democracy in Switzerland (Aldershot, Dartmouth, 1993)_W. Linder, Swiss Democracy: Possible Solutions to Conflict inMulticultural Societies ( fi, St. Martins, 1994).

24 . Westlind, The Politics of Popular Identity, . 209.25 I. Budge, The New Challenge of Direct Democracy (Cambridge,

Polity, 1996)_ T. E. Cronin, Direct Democracy: The Politics of

Initiative, Referendum and Recall (Cambridge, MA, HarvardUniversity Press, 1989).

26 B. Holden, Understanding Liberal Democracy ( fi, PhilipAlan, 1988), . 5. fi - fi fi fi,. I. McLean, Democracy and the New Technology (Cambridge,Polity, 1989).

27 D. Beetham, Liberal Democracy and the Limits ofDemocratization, D. Held (.), Prospects for Democracy,Political Studies, Special Issue, XL (1992), 40-53, . 41.

28 R. A. Dahl,A Preface to Democratic Theory(, University ofChicago Press, 1956), . 4-6, 34_ W. H. Riker, Liberalism AgainstPopulism: A Confrontation between the Theory of Democracy and the

Theory of Social Choice (San Francisco, Freeman, 1982). - fi fi

fi -fi fi (fi ) . , . G. Sartori, Democratic Theory(Detroit, Wayne State University Press, 1962), . 72-128_ S. M.Lipset, Political Man ( Heinemann, 1960), . 97-130_Shils, The Torment of Secrecy, . 98-104_ W. Kornhauser, ThePolitics of Mass Society (, Routledge and Kegan Paul,1960), . 227-30. : P.Bachrach, The Theory of Democratic Elitism - a Critique (Bfi,Little Brown, 1967)_ C. Pateman, Participation and DemocraticTheory(Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 1960).

29 G. Sartori, The Theory of Democracy Revisited (Chatham, NJ,

Chatham House, 1987), Vol.1, . 7-8, 12, 46, 81. N. Bobbio, The Future of Democracy(Cambridge, Polity, 1987), .8, 26-7.

30 . Iain McLean : fi - fi , . Democracy and The New Technology, . 36.

31 M. Oakeshott, Rationalism in Politics and Other Essays (,Methuen, 1962)_ On Human Conduct (fi, Clarendon,1975).

YXPONA 68 EMATA

004ORMOS 01-11-10 15:33 68

8/4/2019 (Canovan, , 2010)

12/12

32 M. Oakeshott, The Politics of Faith and the Politics of Scepticism

(New Haven, Yale University Press, 1996), . 21-38.

33 Oakeshott, The Politics of Faith, . 21-2, 30, 38.34 Oakeshott, The Politics of Faith, . 108.

35 Oakeshott, The Politics of Faith, . 128

36 A. Przeworski, Democracy and the Market (Cambridge,

Cambridge University Press, 1991), . 95.

37 J. Gray, Post-liberalism: Studies in Political Thought (,

Routledge, 1993), . 327.

38 . . Bobbio, The Future of Democracy, . 41_ D. B. Magleby,Direct Legislation: Voting on Ballot Propositions in the United States

(Baltimore, John Hopkins University Press, 1984), . 181.

39 N. Bobbio, Democracy and the International System, D.

Archibugi D. Held (.), Cosmopolitan Democracy: An Agenda

for a New World Order(Cambridge, Polity, 1995), . 17-41, . 33.

40 . C. Lefort, The Political Forms of Modern Society (Cambridge,Polity, 1986), . 279_ C. Lefort, Democracy and Political Theory(Cambridge, Polity, 1988), . 17-9.

41 R. Dahrendorf, Reflections on the Revolution in Europe (,

Chatto and Windus, 1990), . 10.

42 . Riker, Liberalism

Against Populism.

43 Archibugi Held, Cosmopolitan Democracy.44 N. Pollack, The Populist Mind (Indianapolis,

Bobbs-Merrill, 1967), . 337.

45 S. Holmes, Passions and Constraints: On the Theory of Liberal

Democracy(, University of Chicago Press, 1995), . 8, 163-

4, 167.

46 D. Beetham, Legitimation of Power (, Macmillan, 1991),. 94, 132-4.

47 K. Marx, Economic and Philosophical Manuscripts of 1844 (fi,

Foreign Languages Publishing House, 1961), . 69.

48 Beetham, Liberal Democracy and the Limits of

Democratization, . 42.

49 M. Weber, The Sociology of Religion (, Methuen, 1965), .

46-79.

50 V. Bogdanor, Western Europe, D. Butler and A. Ranney

(.), Referendums Around the World: the Growing Use of DirectDemocracy (Houndmills, Macmillan, 1994), . 24-97, . 69_

Budge, The New Challenge of Direct Democracy, . 103-4. . B.

Ackerman, We the People: I: Foundations (Cambridge MA,

Harvard University Press, 1991).

51 Kazin, Populist Persuasion, . 195-8_ N. Birnbaum, What can

we learn from the movements of 1968?, Constellations, I (1994),144-57.

52 Pateman, Participation and Democratic Theory, . 42-4 B. Barber,

Strong Democracy: Participatory Politics for a New Age (Berkeley,

CA, University of California Press, 1984), . 119, 152-4, 232,

237 J. Dryzek, Discursive Democracy: Politics, Policy and Political

Science (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 1990), . 119-

20 Fishkin, Democracy and Deliberation: New Directions forDemocratic Reform (New Haven, Yale University Press, 1991), .

81.

53 . Cronin, Direct Democracy, . ix.

54 . Pateman, Participation and Democratic Theory, . 42-4_ Barber,

Strong Democracy, . 119, 152-4, 232, 237 J. Fishkin, Democracy

and Deliberation, . 81.55 Sartori fi []

fi . Theory of Democracy Revisited, I, .

82.

56 . C. Mouffe, The Return of the Political(, Verso, 1993),

. 4-6, 145_ J. Keane, Democracy and the Media - Without

Foundations, Held, Prospects for Democracy, 116-29, . 123-6 M. Warren, What should we expect from more

democracy?, Political Theory, 24 (1996), 241-70 M. Saward,

Postmodernists, pragmatists and the justification of

democracy, Economy and Society, 23 (1994), 201-16.

57 . Oakeshott, The Politics of Faith, . 108-13.

YXPONA 69 EMATA

004ORMOS 01-11-10 15:33 69