110398

2013-2014

1. -

2. 1 :

3. 2: "

:

'' "

4. 3: 21

[1920]

:

1. Geoff Eley, ,

1923-2000, ' , , , 2010.

(: . 468--695).

2. .

27

.

:

. ,

. , ( Eley

) , , .

(, , , internet)

.

200-400 (20 - 40

).

1. (International Working Men's Association) (1864-1876) (., ).

2. (. , ).

3. (. , ).

4. 21 [Comintern] [1920] (. ).

5. 1928 [Comintern] (. G. Eley, . 471-474).

6. G. Eley: " 1928 [....]. , , , " ( G. Eley, . 484).

7. (. G. Eley, . 17).

8. : ) ; ( G. Eley, . 17) ) ; ; ( G. Eley, . 17) ) , , ; ( G. Eley, . 17) ) ; ( G. Eley, . 17). ) ' ; ( G. Eley, . 18).

9. ; ( G. Eley, . 495-498).

10. " " (G. Eley, . 516). ;

11. ' ( G. Eley, . 18).

12. ( G. Eley, . 19, . 554-560).

13. : " , , " " (. , . : G. Eley).

14. ( G. Eley, ).

15. : , , ( G. Eley, . 19, . 564-574. : . 23).

16. To 20 ( 1956) ( 1956): ( G. Eley, . 20).

17. O 1968, : G. Eley " '1968' '1945'" (. 619). (. G. Eley, . 21).

18. ; (. G. Eley, . 21, . 628-631).

19. 1968, (. G. Eley, 22).

20. (. G. Eley,

. 23).

21. ) : ) ; (. G. Eley, . 23).

22. , , ; (. , ).

23. ; (. , ).

24. -

25. ; .

26. (. , ).

27. ,

Barbara Steiner: "Communists we are no longer, Social Democrats we can never

be"(. , ).

(2013)

, ,

,

,

concepts-moving targets (McLaughlin, 2012, . 34).

"" , ,

.

, ,

, , ,

, , , ,

. , , ,

, ,

. , -

- . ,

, , , "" -

, -

" ",

. ,

, , ,

, - ,

" " .

, ,

,

.

, ,

.

,

.

, ,

(

), - -

.

. , ,

,

"" .

,

(: 1960) (: 1970

1980), .

" ",

( ). ,

""

"" , ,

.

:

1.

(International Working Men's

Association) (1864-1876),

: ,

, ,

"

" (Droz, 1966, . 13).

- -

.

.

:

( ),

, ,

, "

".

', ,

" "

,

-

.

19 ,

. ,

, "", 1880,

-

". ,

"" ""

,

. ' , ""

, 1880, "",

, ,

"" (

, ).

( 1875),

, ,

- ,

. , ,

,

, 1896

(: 14 1889) ( . Moschonas, 2002, . 17-23).

, ,

project, a "bifurcated project" Francis Sejersted (Sejersted,

2011). "",

1,

( ):

( ,

)2

1 (1891)

1897 .

2 : ,

, ,

.

( )

(

).

,

, :

,

.

, " "

Jan Otto Andersson,

() "

", ",

, ",

- ( Kagarlitsky, 2000, .

98).

1890-1914 , ,

.

, ""

, ,

( "

") .

,

.

, ,

, " ",

society-building project 4+1 .

+ ( )

(, , )

, ,

, ""

.

:

"",

"",

, .

(,

, ,

, ) , ,

( ,

, ,

" ",

).

,

(

)

. Bernstein,

Kautsky, Branting,

Lenin Luxemburg, ( Engels

)3, , ,

.

2.

, , (

, ), , ,

, , "". ,

,

,

, '' ()

.

3 Friedrich Engels 1895.

,

(

).

.

, ,

. .

- ,

1920,

.

,

.

"",

, ,

, .

, ,

'

1919 (Comintern

Communist International). ,

- :

-

,

. + ( )

"+ ":

corpus

.

, "

" - - .

,

" "

,

. ,

, ,

, , " "

-

.

, , (, , , , ) " " (Derber et al., 1995, .9).

1.

.

20 -

- ,

, ,

. ,

Eustach Kouvelakis (2001, . 50). ,

, :

" , ", Slavoj

Zizek 2011 (Zizek, 2011).

. ,

,

- -

. , , ,

,

.

, ,

(Pereira, 2010, . 10). , ,

(

) , , .

.

(, ).

, (Pereira, 2010, . 7) . novum . , , , , - , , , . "is now caracterized by an excessive and destructive fragmentation" (Derber et all, 1995, . 13) , : . , , (Moschonas, 2011).

,

.

(, , , action

directe, ), New Left,

, ,

()- . ,

,

,

,

(

) .

, 2009

. ,

, - ,

, ,

.

Maisons rouges (Lazar, 1992).

, ,

, 4.

.

4 , ()

( , 2012).

,

.

2. H :

" ", ,

, , ,

,

.

1920-1960,

identity-oriented movements 1960

(. Schwerner,1995, . 33)

1970 1980 (

).

:

--: -

. ,

" "

,

-

,

. ,

-

,

.

1990 ,

, 2000. , ,

, ,

, , (

) -

. ,

- ,

-

""

( ) , ,

. ,

, -

.

"pense critique" (Badiou, etc.)

.

:

. .

, , 1950,

. , ,

1985-1999,

( ) ,

1990,

. "

" ..

raison dtre .

,

,

,

.

,

,

(

).

..

,

. , ,

:

.

.

()

GUE-NGL ( -

) .

(

: , ,

,

, , ) , ,

.

Die Linke ( ), ,

, ,

.

- ,

""

. ,

(Eurohostile) ,

()

. -

( ),

( )

, ,

,

.

( 5) ,

David Bell (1996, . 232). , ,

.

: -

, ,

.

, ,

1960 1970 ( , ,

, , , ,

, - .)6,

. ,

- ( ),

5

" " . (. :

Marijnissen, 2007, . 210-214).

6 , ,

. Paul Edward Gottfried (2005).

. ,

, "" ,

Lutte Ouvrire "" (

)

.

. ,

, ,

- ( -,

),

- .

,

(, , ,

) , , ,

, ,

focus

- - .

: ,

.

, ,

(. March 2008: 9).

(

) , ,

.

( )

,

-mainstream

,

(Heine, 2009, . 158-161).

:

( , mouvement altermondialiste,

() .)

( ,

, .., ).

, , ,

, . ,

,

.

,

( , , ).

, ""

,

,

(

( , ,

, )

(.., [

], ).

,

- - .

.

, .

: in statu nascendi

.

-

-

.

.

.

( )

.

. ,

,

, " ",

1960 1970 (

, , , , -

.), , ,

, , .

( "

", /, , .).

,

(

" ").

O , ,

(March, 2008, . 9 Heine

2009) "

" (Bale Dunphy, 2012, . 48) ,

, , ,

, "" ""

. , ,

, ,

, , , .

"" ,

""

. ,

.

, ,

, .

,

"" , ,

"" , , .

,

, () , (

) ,

, , -

,

.

"-". mainstream ,

, " "

, , ,

"" (

),

"", , , , .

,

.

( )

" ",

mainstream .

,

.

, , ,

, mainstream

, ,

" "

.

..

, , ""

( ,

), ,

(, , )

,

,

. ,

,

:

, ,

- -

. (. Moschonas 2011 ). ,

, ,

"" ,

(: , ).

"

"

.

-

.

,

, , ( , ,

).

. , ,

, , -,

, ,

, ,

.

.

,

.

"" (

), ,

, "" ( , ,

), ""

,

.

, , ,

,

, ,

,

.

, 1914-1917.

, ,

.

Barbara Steiner: "Communists we are

no longer, Social Democrats we can never be" (Steiner, 2012, . 65).

Bale T. Dunphy R. (2012), "De parias participants" in De Waele J.M Seiler

D.-L., Les partis de la gauche anticapitaliste en Europe, Paris: Economica, . 32-

49.

Bell, D. (1996), Western communist parties and the European Union in Gaffney

John (.), Political Parties and the European Union, London New York:

Routledge, . 220-234.

Derber Ch. with K.M. Ferroggiaro et al. (1995), What's Left?: Radical Politics in the

Postcommunist Era. Massachusetts: University of Massachusetts Press.

Droz, J. (1966), Le socialisme dmocratique 1864-1960, : Armand Colin.

Gottfried, P.E., (2005), The Strange Death of Marxism, The European Left in the New

Millennium. Columbia-London: University of Missouri Press.

Heine S.(2009), Une gauche contre l'Europe ? Bruxelles: Ed. de l'Universit de

Bruxelles.

Hobsbawm E. (2009), "Une rponse la propagande librale" (),

Libration, 23 mai, http://www.liberation.fr/politiques/0101568935-une-reponse-a-la-

propagande-liberale[: 23/01/2012]

Zizek S. (2011), "Seule une gauche radicale peut nous sauver", Slavoj Zizek La Quinzaine littraire, no 1035, 1er avril 2011.

. (2012),

, : , :

:

, : 2011-12.

Kagarlitsky, B. (2000), The Return of Radicalism, Reshaping the Left Institutions.

: Pluto Press.

Kouvelakis E. (2001), Crises du marxisme, transformation du capitalisme, in Bidet

J. Kouvelakis E., Dictionnaire Marx contemporain, Paris: PUF, . 41-56.

Lazar M. (1992), Maisons rouges, Paris: Aubier.

March L (2008), Contemporary Far Left Parties in Europe, From Marxism to the

Mainstream? International Policy Analysis, Bonn: Friedrich Ebert Stiftung.

Marijnissen, J., (2007), ! . : .

., (2013) " : '' " .-. . (, ), : , ( )

Moschonas G. (2011), "The European Union and the dilemmas of the radical Left:

Some preliminary thoughts", Transform!, 09/2011, . 8-23.

Moschonas, G. (2002), In the Name of Social Democracy, The Great Transformation.

London:Verso, 2002.

Pereira I. (2010), Les grammaires de la contestation, Paris: Les Empcheurs de

penser en rond/La Dcouverte.

Schwerner C., (1995), "Beyond socialism and identity politics: The U.S. Left after the

Fall, Derber Ch. with K.M. Ferroggiaro et al. (1995), What's Left?: Radical

Politics in the Postcommunist Era. Massachusetts: University of Massachusetts Press.

Sejersted, F. (2011), The Age of Social Democracy, Norway and Sweden in the

Twentieth Century, Princeton: Princeton University Press.

Steiner, . (2012), "Communists we are no longer, Social Democrats we can never be the Swedish Left Party". B. Daiber, C. Hildebrandt, . Striethorst (eds.), From Revolution to Coalition Radical Left Parties in Europe, Rosa Luxemburg Stiftung : Rosa-Luxemburg-Foundation, Manuskripte.

" : '' "

i

.-. . (, ), : ,

2014 ( )

:

.

, ,

-

.

-

,

(Arnove, 2000).

, ,

.

20 -

- ,

, ,

. ,

Eustach Kouvelakis, (2001, 50).

: .

,

,

. ,

, ,

.

, (..)

.

. , , , (

) ( actors)

( )

, o " "

. . ,

..,

,

, . .

, ( ,

) , ,

, .

,

.

. ,

1980, ,

, ( ),

, : )

)

, ,

)

.

M :

,

- - .

, , ,

,

. , ,

(Pereira, 2010, . 10). ,

,

( ) , ,

. .

.

( )

""

.

"", ,

.

,

(Pereira, 2010, . 7)

,

. novum

.

, , ,

, - ,

, ,

.

.

, ,

. ,

, ,

.

,

. ,

, ,

,

(Hobsbawm, 2009). ,

,

,

,

. , , ,

. ,

, , , ,

ii.

, ,

( 1990), ,

, . , ,

(De Waele Vieira, 2012, . 57-58).

(, ,

, , , )

(, , ) -

- ,

, (, ).

, ,

, -

. ,

.

,

.

,

.

,

, -

, .

, ,

, ,

, - .

Maisons rouges (Lazar, 1992) .

,

. .

,

, .

,

,

. ""

.

.. -

.

. , , 1950,

(. ). ,

, 1985-1999,

( ) ,

1990,

.

. ,

, - -.

,

1950 1960. , ,

,

.

.

, ,

..

raison dtre .

,

,

(

).

,

,

,

.

. , ,

Franois Mitterrand (

Jacques Delors),

(

, ,

, , 1980 1990, ). ,

,

, ,

1990 , ,

(Caramani, 2010 Bardi . .,

2010). , ,

(),

.

, ..

,

. , ,

,

, ( )

. ..

, ,

(Moschonas, 2011b).

,

.

;

. ..,

,

, , big issues

- .

. , .

.

: ,

, - , -

:

(Jabko, 2009, . 259, 264-

265). (

),

, (

) ,

.

( ),

.

, ,

, ,

,

:

, ,

. ,

: ) (

) ) ,

()

, , ) ,

,

) ,

(. Moschonas, 2009, . 173-175.

:, 2004, . 65-66).

, , ,

. ,

-

. ..,

,

,

. H o ,

- , ratio essendi- .

, -,

-

. ,

,

( ), ,

- , .

:

)

) (

),

) (,

,

, ,

).

actor,

(

, ).

,

, actor

, ,

: , ,

,

, ,

.

, ,

-, . ,

(

)

( ),

(

). ,

, ,

, ,

.

, ,

..

, : )

.. , , ,

( ) ) -

-

,

( ).

,

, .., o

, , ,

. -

- ,

milieu

. , (

),

, :

, ,

(

, ).

, , ,

, . ,

,

,

,

. ,

.

, -

- -

,

26

- ( , ,

- 27,

).

. ,

,

, .

.

,

,

.

. ,

(action directe) .

. ,

.

, ,

.

, , , ( )

, , ,

.

(. , 2005, . 25-26),

- ,

- "" ,

. , ,

(. Klein, 2010).

..

: David Hanley (2008, 143)

.

. 1950

1960, , , ,

(

) ,

, (Bell, 1996, . 222-223).

Schuman ,

,

(Bell, 1996, . 222).

1950 1960.

, ,

1973,

,

,

.

iii. ,

,

.

,

. ( ,

, ),

,

. ( ,

, ), ,

. ,

(Dunphy, 2004, . 67).

1989,

,

(. Dunphy, 2004,

.53-71). , 1950

( 1960

1970)iv ,

1970, , .

,

,

(Bell, 1996,

. 225),

.

.

1970 .

, ,

. ,

, :

.

.

() GUE-NGL (

- ) .

(

) , ,

. Die Linke ( ),

, ,

, ,

.

- ,

. ,

(Eurohostile) ,

()

.

- (

), (

) ,

, ,

.

,

.

,

(: ,

, ,

, , ). ,

..,

,

, ,

.

, ,

(Heine, 2009, . 158-161). ,

, ,

(,

, ). , ,

,

,

...

-

-, ,

,

.

(

) , , ,

. ,

.., ,

.

, , , ,

v. ,

(hard euroscepticism),

- . ,

, Richard Dunphy (2004),

(strong reformism)vi.

- -

.

.

1970 1980

. ,

(

)

1950 1960. ,

, 1970,

.

.

, ,

.

: ;

(europeanisation)

. ,

2004,

.

.

: -

- , ,

.

.

(Hanley, 2008, .

147) .

, ,

,

.

( , ,

, )

(.., [ ],

),

, ,

,

.

-

,

. ,

, , ,

- ,

,

-mainstream

. 2005

2010

. ,

, ,

,

vii.

, .

,

.

,

. , , ,

.

, ,

- - .

, (

)

.

. , ,

, , -,

-

, ,

. , ,

.

,

. , ,

,

, , ,

, "" .

, , ,

success story.

,

.

. ..

. , ,

.

,

.

1. .., ,

,

. ,

,

, .

. ,

, , . ,

. , .

,

, .

,

.

2.

( )

1970 1980

1950 1960.

,

.

, ,

, ..

, , ,

- ( -

). , ,

, ..

.

,

, .

3. 1970,

(

)

.

(

) (

). ,

,

.

,

(

-). , ,

.

(

).

, .

, , ,

. ..

, ,

, , . , ,

go-it-alone .

.

4.

,

.

,

, ,

,

, , -,

,

.

, .

.

(ger.moschonas@gmail.com)

,

Arnove A. (2000) "The Fall of Stalinism: Ten Years On" , International Socialist

Review, Issue 10, Winter 2000 in

http://www.isreview.org/issues/10/TheFallOfStalinism.shtml[: 23/01/2012]

Bale T. Dunphy R. (2012), "De parias participants" in De Waele J.M Seiler

D.-L., Les partis de la gauche anticapitaliste en Europe, Paris: Economica, . 32-

49.

Bardi L. et al, (2010), How to create a Transnational Party System, European

Parliament, Directorate General for Internal Policies, Policy Department C: Citizens'

Rights and Constitutional Affairs.

Bell, D. (1996), Western communist parties and the European Union in Gaffney

John (.), Political Parties and the European Union, London New York:

Routledge, . 220-234.

Borioni P, Di Giacomo M. Soare S. (2012), "Le Parti de la Refondation Communiste: traditions et dfis" in De Waele J.M Seiler D.-L., Les partis de la gauche anticapitaliste en Europe, Paris: Economica, . 177-197.

Caramani D. (2010), The Europeanisation of Electoral Politics: An Analysis of

Converging Voting Distributions in 30 European Party Systems, 19702008, National

Centre of Competence in Research (NCCR), Working Paper No. 42.

Dunphy R. (2004), Contesting Capitalism? Left parties and European Integration,

Manchester: Manchester University Press.

Klein D. (2010), The Second Great Transformation and the Left, Strategy Paper,

February 2010, Brussels: Rosa Luxemburg Foundation.

De Waele J.M. Vieira M. (2012), "La famille de la gauche anticapitaliste en

Europe", in De Waele J.M Seiler D.-L., Les partis de la gauche anticapitaliste en

Europe, Paris: Economica, . 50-85

Hanley D. (2008), Beyond the Nation State, Parties in the Era of European

Integration Hampshire New York: Palgrave Macmillan.

Heine S.(2009), Une gauche contre l'Europe ? Bruxelles: Ed. de l'Universit de

Bruxelles

Hobsbawm E. (2009), "Une rponse la propagande librale" (),

Libration, 23 mai, http://www.liberation.fr/politiques/0101568935-une-reponse-a-la-

propagande-liberale[: 23/01/2012]

Jabko N. (2009), LEurope par le march, Histoire dune stratgie improbable, Paris:

Presses de Sciences Po.

Kouvelakis E. (2001), Crises du marxisme, transformation du capitalisme, in Bidet

J. Kouvelakis E., Dictionnaire Marx contemporain, Paris: PUF, . 41-56.

Lazar M. (1992), Maisons rouges, Paris: Aubier.

March L (2008), Contemporary Far Left Parties in Europe, From Marxism to the

Mainstream? International Policy Analysis, Bonn: Friedrich Ebert Stiftung.

Moschonas G. (2011a), "The European Union and the dilemmas of the radical Left:

Some preliminary thoughts", Transform!, 09/2011, . 8-23.

Moschonas G. (2011b), Historical decline or change of scale? The electoral

dynamics of European Social-democratic parties 1950-2009, in Cronin J, Ross G,

Shoch J,(.), What's left of the left, Duhram, N.C: Duke University Press, . 50-

85.

Moschonas G. (2009), "Reformism in a 'Conservative' System: The European Union

and Social democratic Identity" in Callaghan J. Fishman N., Jackson B. McIvor

M., In Search of Social Democracy : Responses to Crisis and Modernisation,

Manchester: Manchester University Press, . 168-192.

. (2005), , : .

Pereira I. (2010), Les grammaires de la contestation, Paris: Les Empcheurs de

penser en rond/La Dcouverte.

Raynaud P. (2006), L'extrme gauche plurielle, Paris: CEVIPOF/Autrement.

. (2004), ;, : .

i Transform!

(Moschonas, 2011a). H .

ii ,

(. Raynaud,, 2006, . 111-171).

iii 1969 7

. 1973, 4 .

iv 1963

. 15 ( 1979), , (Dunphy, 2004, . 74, 79 Borioni, Di Giacomo Soare, 2012, . 192).

v , ,

(March, 2008, . 9 Heine 2009) " " (Bale Dunphy, 2012, . 48). , , "" , . , .

vi

, David Bell (1996, 232). , , .

vii , ,

( , , 5-7 2010).

21

1. , . , , . . ' , , , , , , . , , , , . , , . , , , - -, , , , , .

2. , ( , , , , , ) , , , .

3. , . , . , , , . , , , , .

4. , . , , . ,

.

5. , . , , , , . , . , . , , , .

6. , , , , , , , , , .

7. , , . . , , . , , , , , , , , ' ' . , .

8. , , , . , , , , , , , , .

9. , , , , . , , .., . , . .

10. , , . . , , , .

11. , , , , .

12. , . , , , , .

13. , , () , .

14. , , , . . , ..,

, .

15. , , . , , . , .

16. , . , , , . , , , , , ' , , .

17. , , . , ( ). , . . , , .

18. , .

19. , , , , , . , , , .

20. , , , , , , , , . . , 7.

21. , , . .

: () - 21 | - http://www.pare-dose.net/4963#ixzz2Sgowf0om