. , ; , . , 2002.

,,1.4.1

.......................................................................... 9 1. .......................................... 9 2. ............................................ 15 : .............................................................. 23 2.1.: .............................................. 23 2.2.: ........................................ 42 : ............................................................ 71 ......................................................... 87 ............................. 87 1. ................................................ 88 1.1.......................... 106 1.2. ........................................................ 107 1.3. .......................................................... 116 1.4. ........................................................... 124 1.5. ......................................................... 132

6

.................................................... 135 ........... 135 1.H ...... 135 2.1 137 3............................................... 140 3.1. ......... 144 3.2. .......... 146 ................................... 148 H .................................... 156 ................................. 159 ........................ 162 ...................................................... 164 ................................... 165 .................................................... 169 ......................... 170 3.3. ............................................................... 171 3.4. ...................... 174 3.5./ .............. 176 4. ................................................ 179 5. ........................................................ 181 ......................................................... 183 .......................................................................... 183 1.T ............................................................ 186 2.H ........................................................ 190 3. ............................................... 195 4. ...................................................... 199 4.1. ....................................... 202

7

4.2. ..................................... 205 4.3. ................................... 206 4.4.... 207 4.5. ....................................... 209 5.(:) ..... 210 .................................................... 219 :,,

.................................................................................. 219 1. ............................................................. 220 1.1. ................................................... 220 1.2. .......... 222 1.3. ..................................... 230 2. ............................................................ 234 2.1. ............................... 234 2.2. ........................ 236 2.3................................ 237 2.4. .......................... 239 2.5. .......................... 241 3. ............................................................. 243 4. ................................ 247 5.: ........... 254 ....................................................................... 259 ............................................................... 269 . ..................................................................... 269 B. ...................................................... 272 ............................. 279

1. , , ; ; (rationalismus) ; ()ratio; ; : ; ; , : , , ( ), . , . , , : ,

10

. , ( ) ,,, ( ). , , , , , . , , . , . , () . , , . . : ,

11

, ( , , , ) ... , , , . 1. , . . 1

. , , (. .), 1978,. 78: : . , ... , .

12

, , , , . ,, (rationalismus) ratio, , . , , , , , , ,, 20. 20, . , , , , . ( ,, ,), .

13

, . , (, ) , ,, . , . cogito. , , ,, , , , 2. , . , . . , (Die Aufklrung im Rahmen des neuzeitlichen Rationalismus, 1981) , 1987, 1, . 63: , .2

14

, : , . , , , . , ,. , : () , . , [...] , [...] , . , 3. , ()

. , , 1987, 1, . 4849.3

15

., , , . . 2. , , . , , (,, ) 20. ( ). . : , ( ) . : , . , , .

16

,ratio . ( ) , , . , 20 . : . 4 ( ), . , ratio. , , .

4 . ( , 1987, 1, . 355), , , a priori , ,. .

17

O . . , , . , : , . . . , (). , ,, , ... , . , , , ,, .

18

, , , , () , , , . . (, , , , , , , , ) . , ,, ,, . , : , . , , . , , , . , , ,

19

, , , ( ) . . , . ,. : . , , . , , , . , , . , , ,

20

: . ( ) 5. , . , , , , , . , , : . . : , : , ( 19, 2005) ( 85, 2003)(110, 2004) ( 127, 2007). .5

21

, .,, , , , 6.

6

., . ,2006,.15.

2.1.: ; ; , , ; ; , , . 18 . ,, , , , . , () 7. . . , , 1987, 1, , , . 353457, 7

24

, . . , , , . ratio8,

(. 336337): , entia rationis, . , , , . , ., ,, (), () . , . 8 , . Gilson (Le thomisme, Paris 1972, . 263 ..), ratio () ,, .

25

., , , , , . ,, . ,, ., , . Kant. , Kant : ,, , o a priori. Kant : 9. ,, Kant

9

.Kant,,.

26

, . Kant , ., ratio, . , , , . : , . , , ,., apriori, ., , . ( ;), , . , , Kant

27

. : , , . , . , , , , ( ) . , , . , , , . Kant ratio, 10 .

Kant.., , 1983, . 73: , , . . , 10

28

. , , , x . H , . (Sein) (Sollen)11. Kant , , ( ) . , ( ), . , . . , . . , cogito, . 11.,,1984,.48.

29

, . , 20 .. , . , , . , , . 12. K. Popper , , ( Popper). ( ), Popper ( ) .

12

H. Heimsoeth, 20 ., Windelband Heimsoeth, (. . ), . 3, .203.

30

. Popper , (induction) (confirmation). , , ,, . . . . . . , . 13. , . 20 . : , ,

13

K. Popper, (The Open Society and its Enemies, 1945) (..),.1,1980,.267.

31

, . , , , . , , , 14. Popper . 15 , . ( ) . , .14 15

K.Popper,,.1,.7779. K. Popper, ,. 1,. 447,. 23: ... , ().

32

: , . . ,., , . Popper . . , : . Popper 16. , . , . (Kuhn, Lacatos, Feyerabend) . , ,

16

K.Popper,,.2,.343.

33

,, , , . , : , , . . Kuhn .,, , , , . Kuhn . , , , , . Kuhn . , . , , , . Kuhn,, , ,.

34

, ,, 17. , () . 18. Kuhn . , . apos teriori . 19. Kuhn ( ): , : ;., . Kuhn, , 1981,.25. 18 . Kuhn, (Structure of Scientific Revolutions, 1962) (. . , . . , . ),1981,.94. 19, I. Lacatos. ( ) ,. : .17

35

;20. , P. Feyerabend, , , 21. , .

. Kuhn, , . 66. . . 108: , , , . 1630, Descartes , , , . ., : . , : . . 21 P. Feyerabend, (Against Method, 1975) . (..,.), 1982,.64.20

36

, 22.,, . 23. Feyerabend , , . , , ! , , . , , 24. Feyerabend : P. Feyerabend, (Erkenntnis fr freie Menchen) (..),1986,.17. 23 P. Feyerabend, How to be a Good Empiricism A Plea for Tolerance in Matters Epistemological, The Philosophy of Science (. Nidditch), Oxford 19774. . , . 24 P. Feyerabend, , 30: , ,, , , .22

37

. , , , .... 25. , , Feyerabend, . , , , . , , . . , , ,,, 26. ,, , , : , P. Feyerabend, ., .49. 26 P. Feyerabend, ., .76.25

38

,. , , , , 27. Feyerabend . . A posteriori . ,

27 P. Feyerabend, . , . 101.: , ,, ,, , , , . ,, . , . , , . (: Kant).

39

. Weber28, ( ) , . ratio, . (). , , : , . J. Habermas , , 29. .

O M. Weber Die protentantische Ethik, Hamburg 1973, . 29 J. Habermas, Erkenntnis und Interesse, 1965. J. Habermas, , . , 1990, .28.28

40

. ( ,,) 30. , . a priori .

30

H. Marcuse, Der eindimensinale Mensch, Neuwied 1967, . 172: a priori, . , , . [...] , ,, . , , . , , . , .

41

a posteriori . Habermas 31. , ,. , , , . , . . , (kommunikative Rationalitt) (kommunikative Verstndigung). , , , . , , , , 31

, Theorie des kommunikativenHandelns,Frankfurt1981,J.Habermas .

42

, 32. 2.2.: L. Wittgenstein , Tractatus LogicoPhilosophicus, ( ). , : 33. , : , 34. , : . , . 35.

.,,1984,.76. L. Wittgenstein, Tractatus LogicoPhilosophicus, 1921 (.. , 1978), 2.12 (. 50)., 4.014: ,,,, . . 34L.Wittgenstein,TractatusLogicoPhilosophicus,2.15(.50) 35 L. Wittgenstein, Tractatus LogicoPhilosophicus, 3.01 (. 53) 4.121 (. 73).32 33

43

: . , , . ().36 , , : . , ( ). L. Wittgenstein, , , . , .,, : . , 37. . : ,38. Tractatus Wittgenstein . : ( )39. ( L.Wittgenstein,TractatusLogicoPhilosophicus,1.1,2.2.01(.45). L.Wittgenstein,TractatusLogicoPhilosophicus,6.522(.131). 38 (7) Tractatus, Wittgenstein. 39L.Wittgenstein,TractatusLogicoPhilosophicus,4.11(.71).36 37

44

Tractatus Wittgenstein) . , , . , . , , . , , , . , , . , Witt genstein . . , , , . ,. Wittgenstein ( )

45

. ,, . () . ( ), Wittgenstein . Wittgenstein Tractatus , . . Witt genstein ( ), . : (, ) .

46

. , ratio ( ) , . :, , . (, ,, ,,...) (;): . , . , . . , 40.40., (L institution imaginaire de la socit, 1975) (..,.,.), 1978, . 258:

47

, : , . , , 41.

, , ,. , : ( ), (). 41., ,. 347: . , , , ,, , . , (): , , , , ( ) [...]. ( , ) . , ( ), ,

48

,, ,42, , , . , tre ( ) tre tre. . : , , . , . , . ,, , ., , ,, (.. ). 42., ,. 259: , , . [...] , , , , , ,.

49

, , . , , , , 43. . , , , , , ,. . , , ,. , , , , . [...] , , , , ,

43

.,,.464.

50

, . , , , , 44. , , . , , ,, . , , , , . , , ,45. , , . , , , .

44 45

.,,.464465. .,,.465.

51

. , ( , ,)46. . 47. . , , . 465: res (extensa cogitans, ) . , , , . 47 . , (Le Carrefours du labyrinthe 1978) (..), 1991,. 280: ,, . . , , , , , , . , , , , . , , . ,,46

52

, . ( ) , , , , 48. , ,

, , , . , , . 48., ,. 186: , , , ,, , ,, : , , (,,), , , .

53

, 49. . . , . , , , , de iure . , .

. , ,. 102103: , .[...] , ,. , , ,. [...] , . , , , , , ., , , . , ,;49

54

, ,, , , ,, , , , 50. , ,, : , ,, , , , , [] 51. , , . . ( ). ,

50 51

.,,.83. .,,.134.

55

52. , . , ,. . ,,: , , . . Heidegger . , , . 116: . , ,, : , , , ,,. , . , . ,, .52

56

ratio . , . , . , . To , . 53. ( , , ) ., ,: .: .. Heidegger,, : . , , , . ( , ),

53

. . , , 1983, . 65: : cogito . .

57

, , . , ( ) , ,. . Heidegger: ; , . . , , , , . , , . , ,, 54.

M. Heidegger, (Einfhrung in die Metaphysik, 1953) (. . ), 1973, . 135136: , , [. ]. Wahrheit. [...] , . , :,. ,.: . . . . : , [], 54

58

Heideg ger ( !) . , . , , , , . . :: .. :, . , ,. , , , . , , 55. , , () , , , . Heidegger , , . , ( ) . . [...] , , , . , ,.,,: ,. 55M.Heidegger,,.51.

59

. 56. . , adaequatio intel lectusetrei,. , : , ,,,. , ,. . , , , . . Heideg ger. ,, . , .ratio, , , , ( )57., .56 57

M.Heidegger,,.154155. M. Heidegger, Der Satz vom Grund, Pfullingen 19785,. 167 ( . M. Heidegger, (Was ist das die Philosophie?,

60

, Heidegger ( )., , , . , , , , , ,. , , , , . , . . , () () . Heidegger , 1956) ;, 1986, . 250): H ratio reor: , [unterstellt wird],. , . : , rechnen []. [mit etwas rechnen]: . [auf etwas rechnen]: .

61

cogito. 58. . . , . ( , , , ...). , . , , . , 59. , () , .58 M. Heidegger, Holzwege (Gesamtausgabe 5), Frankfurt am Main 1977, . 267. 59.,,2004.

62

, , 60 , 20 .61.

. ( ,1976) , (). . . , , . , , . 61 (). :., , 1993, . 128138: , .[...], . [...] , . . [...] , ( ) : (, , , ) 60

63

, , ( ), . (Planck, Einstein, Heisenberg, Feynmann..) : . , , ,. . ,

. . , . , , , , . . [...] : , . .

64

() . ., via nega tiva, 62. , , . ( ) , (), 63, . , ,

, ( , 1984,. 186): via negativa () . , . 63., , 1993,. 141: ,. .62

65

, , . : : ( , ) , , 64. (). , ,

64

. , , 2004, . 26. . . , , 135 ( ), 1986, . 15: , ( ) .

66

, 65. ,, , ,

. ., , 1989, ,.1718: (..), , , (quanta) . , .., , , . (), . , . : . [...] . .. , , : , , . [...] (), ,.65

67

. , , , ., : , . , , ( ) a priori , . , ,,66. , . , . ,

66

. , , 1984, . 277.

68

. , , 67. , . , . , 68. , . , ,, , ,,. , .,, (

. , , 1984, . 262. 68 . , , 1993, . 139: . . ,.67

69

). . , , , , . , , .,, , , . , , ( ). , , , , 69. , : [

69

. , , 1984, . 186.

70

] , ,,70.

70

,Testimonia16,3638.

. () : 71. , , (, ) . , , 72. ;

. , , 1984, . 208. 72., , 1981,. 2,.31.71

72

, . , . , , , , . , : . (),, , . 73. , , , ,

73

. E. R. Dodds, (The Greeks and the Irrational, 1951) (. . ), 1977.

73

, , 74. 75, , . , ,. , . , : , . , . 74. : J.P. Vernant, (. . ), 1966 Br. Snell, (. . ), 1984 W.Nestle,(..),1999. 75 , . , , .

74

, . ,, , . , . ( ) , 76. , , . , . 77, , . W. Jaeger, Aristotle, 1967, . XIII The organisation of Research. 77 P. Hadot, (Questce que la philosophie antique?, 1995) (..),2002,.126.76

75

. , , . ,,. ,, . : /. ,, () ( /). . , . ), , : , 78. .

78

,2a47.

76

. . ) () () : ... , , 79. , , : , , 80. : ) : , 16a 19 16a 2628.. , 1458a 34 b 5: ,. 80,437a1215.79

77

, , , . , 81. ; ) : 82 ): , 83 ) , , (): , 84. O . ,165a612. ,101b38. 83,72b1820. 84,1028b24.81 82

78

. , ,( , ). . , , , , . ,, ,85. ,, ., 86. minimum . , :

,1075a310. P. Hadot, ,. 126127: [] , , , . , ., ,, , habitus: , , , . , .85 86

79

, ,87. , . , , : 88. . 89.

, 1147a 2122. [: , , , ,]. 88 ( ,),., . , 1986. 89 P. Feyerabend, (In defence of Aristotle: Comments on the Condition of Content Increase) (. . ), 1987, . 11: , .,, ,87

80

. , 90.., . : , . 90 . , . , , 1984,. 206207: , . , , () . . , , . () . () , . , , . , , . . , , , ,, , . Av, , ( ), . , , , . (

81

: . , ... 91 . .: , , : , . ,, , . 92.

). 91 corpus1500! 92 , 1137b 1319. [: /, ,/ .

82

: 93. , , , , , 94./, , , . , , , , / ,,]. 93,1137b2930. 94 , 1094b 1127: , ,. , , , , . , . , . , . [ : , ,,

83

. ,,: 95. () , 96!, . , ,,, , . , . . : ]. 95,663b2729. 96 , 32b 413: , , , , , , ,

84

( , , ), , . () . , . : , , , () , ! , , , , , , , : ,, 97.

, . 97 . P. Feyerabend, ,.7: , .

85

,, . , . ., . , . . (, ,,, ): . , , , , , , 98.

98

, 211a 611:. , , , .

99 , 100. , : ) , , Commentaria in Aristotelem Graeca XV, ed. M. Hayduck, Berlin 1897 ( , (1.521.7)).., ; , 2002, . : ) R. D. Hicks, De Anima. With translation, introduction and notes, Cambridge1907)S.D.Ross,Deanima.Edited,withintroductionandcommen tary,Oxford1961. 100 Kl. Oehler, (Subjektivitt und Selbstbewutsein in der Antike 1997) (. . ), ,..,. 36: , . , , . , 99

88

, , 101, , 102. 1. , . (, , )103, (, , , , )104, (), (

, , , , . 101 , 402a 47: [ ] , .[: , ]. . ( , 135, , 1986, . 1720), . 102 , , . . . . , ; ,2002, . 103,415a17. 104,414a3132.

89

), ()105. , , , 106 . : . , : . ( ) , .

, 432a 1517: ,,, ... 106 , 432a 2228: . , ,, , ... [:: . ,,, : , , : . , , ].105

90

,, , . , : . . , , , . :, . ,

91

, (!) . , , .: . . . , , .. , .. . , , , , , , ... , ,

92

107

: , , . , ( , (184a 1625): . . . , [: . , , . , , . . . , , ]. . .., ( ),1989,.7297.107

93

). , , in medias res, ,, . , ,, . , , . 108 , , . , :

108

.., ; ,2002,.141.

94

, , , 109. . ( , , ), ,, , : ... ,, , , , ,

, 415a 12: .109

95

110. . , . , . 111. ,, , , , 414a 2025. [: ... , ,, , , ,, , ]. 111 . . , ; , 2002, . 127: 12 .1 , . . , 414b 2227: , ,. . ,, ...110

96

: 112. , , . () ( ). , , , . , . , . . , , . , , 113.

, 412a 1921. , 412a 2728: . W. Charlton, Aristotles Definition of Soul, Phronesis 25 (1980)170186. 113 ,2 1069b 1520:, ( , ), , ,,.112

97

(,, )114. : () , 114 ( ) ,, . . , . , 2006,. 1415: , , () , , , . , ( ) , , , (,) ,, , ., , .

98

, , , ,., , , , . ,, ,: : , . ,(). () :, , ,: ,, , . , , ,. , ( ), , . .

99

, , , . , , . ,. , , (: ) , 115. , 116. ( ) , , . , , , . , , . M. Heidegger, (..), 1973, . 91: , ,, . , ,,. . . , , . 116., , 1981,. ,.98.115

100

() , ,, . ,. , ( ) () . : , , , (),, , ,. , , . . . ,

101

, ,, . (), . , , : , , , ( ), , . , : , ..., ,...117.

( ) . (,..,. ,., 1978,. 267): ... , , (, ),117

102

: , . ,, . . , , . . 118. 119: ,

,, . [...] , , . 118 ( , 412a 6). ,. 119 . , . . , . 1, 2006, . 321: , , ( :) (= ). , ,,

103

( ). . ,, . , .,, : , : , , , . , (,), : . , 120.

(=). 120 , ,. , : , 425b 2627: , . (.., 471.2930) :

104

,, 121. . , , , , . , ; , 122, , , . 121 , 414a 1112: [: ] 426a 911: , [: , ]. 122..., ; , 2002, . 71: , . R.Sorabji,AristotleonDemarcatingtheFiveSenses,Barnes,Schofield, and Sorabji (eds), Articles on Aristotle, vol. 4. Psychology and Aesthetics, New York1979.

105

. . (,,,,) , . , , (, ,). . ( ) , (,,). ( ) ,, , . , , , , , , . . . . . ( , :)

106

() , . . 1.1. , , , 123, . , , , . , , , , . , , 124. , , , : , , 434a 2226: , , [: . , ]. 124 , 414a 3233: ....123

107

, . , , , ,, 125. , , ,126. 1.2. : . , 127.

, 415a 23b 1: [:,, . , ,,, ]. 126,414a24415b1415b2627. 127 , 415a 12 417b 1618.. (..,. 152): ( ) ( ). . (.., 306. 27),125

108

() ( ). , , . , ,: .. , 128. . . . .

: . , . 128 , 414b 2833: , ,., , [: ,, , . , ,].

109

., , . . . , . , , . , . . . , : , , , , , .. , . ,

110

, . , . , , ,. , : ,, 129 , . , , 130.,, ( ) () . . 131,., .

, . 130 , 417a 69:, , , . 131,417b30:.129

111

132, ,,, , () 133. . , , : 134 , , , . , , , , ... ,,, , , . 133 . .., .., . 166, 7 (). (. 172) 134 , 424a 1724: , , , 132

112

135

, ! , ,. , , . , , () , , ., .. 136, . , , ,. [: , ,. ,, ,]. 135 , 431b 26 432a 1: , . . , [: , . . ,]. 136 , 432a 1516: ,, 424a 26:

113

! , , , . , . , . ( , ), . (: ) . :, , , , , . . [: , , , , , .. ] , 427a 1921: .

114

, ( ). 137.,, . : , , , , , . , , ( ) . , . , ,

, 425a 1420: , , , , , , [], , , , [: , ,,,, ,,,, , , , ].137

115

, . : , 138. . , , . , . ,, : . ! . . , , 1993,. 127128: , . , . , . , , .138

116

... , , ,, ,, , (), ...139 cogito. , cogito. 1.3. , , , .

, 1170a 29b 1. [: , (,, )...]139

117

( ): : ... , , , ...140. , , : . : 141. ,.

, 428b 1116. [: ... , , , , , , ...]. 141 , 429a 12. [: ].140

118

. : : . , . ; ; , , 142;142

, , . , 2006,. 4.2. 4.4. , () , . 58: , . , . :,

119

, , . ., ( ), . , 143

. ,: () . , , . ,, ( ) (), . . . 143 , (, ), , 425b 2325: [: . ,

120

, , . , : , 144. o , . , 145. . . . , , ( ]. 144 , 432a 910. (.., 569.1315): , , . 145 , 429b 1022. ( , 429a 3) (.., 6.46): .

121

) . , . , , ,146 , . . ( , . . , . , . , 1978, . 352): , . ( ..) , , (, ), , (, ) . , , , , . , () ( ), (, ) : ,().146

122

( !): , , 147. 148 . : 149. , , , , , ., , .: 150.

147 , 402b 2225. [: , , ]. 148 , . ( , 428a 11), , , ,415a11. 149 , 431b 2. . D. Frede, The Cognitive Role of Phantasia in Aristotle, Essays on Aristotles De Anima (eds. M. Nussbaum and A. Rorty),Oxford1992,279295. 150,432a1213431a1617.

123

, , , 151. , . : . , . , . . 151

, 427b 1416: , .. , , 433b 2630: ... . , , , . [ : , , , . ].

124

, , 152. , : . , . . , , . 1.4. . , ., ( ,. 268): ,:, . , , . , , , qp.152

125

153. , , () , ( ;): , . 154. , , : () , (): , , , . , 155.153 () , ., ,,,., , . 154 , 403a 89: ... ... . , 427b 28: [ ] 155 , 430a 1018: [] [] , , ,

126

: . , . , , . , , , .

, , , , . , [: ,, , . , , , , . ,, . , ].

127

, . , . , , . , . , . , 156. 157. . , ,432a45: . Kl. Oehler, (. . , ), .., . 40: , , , , ,, .156 157

128

. , ,, ,158. , , ,, ., . , . . , . . . , , . 158

, 432a 2,430a34: ,429a2729: , , .

129

, , ()()! , , . ,,: , , , 159. , , : 160. : , 161 , 429b 35. [: , , , , , ]. 160 , 408b 29. . , 736b 2729: . 161 , 430a 1725: , . [ , , .] 159

130

. , . o , , 162. , : , . , []

, , , [:, . , . , , , . , , ]. 162 .., . ,1989,.379..

131

163. , , . : ( ) 164, , . , . . . , ,, . : ,7 198a 35b 4. [: , ., , , ]. 164 , 1 250b 1115: , , ,, , 163

132

,, .165

1.5. , , : 166. ,, , . , , , 167. , , ()(,). , , .,, , . ,

,431b17. ,432b2829,431a916. 167 , 433a 1718, 433a 31b 1: , , . , 432b 57: , ,.165 166

133

, , : : .

1.H 1 , , () /168. , , (, ). , 168

, 1354a 1418: , , , [ :, , :,, ].

136

, . . . , . , ( ) ,, . . . , , , , . , (), , ( Habermas). , , .

137

, 169. (, , , , , , , , ) ,. ,, ,, . , , . 2.1 211 (1377a 30 1388b 30). 1 . . , , , , / (v ), ( ) , . :

169

,1356a1416.

138

, , , 170. . O .. ( ) , ! , , ,! ( ), , , . , .

170 , 1377b 2878a 1. [: , . , , ].

139

. : : ) , ,) , ( o , , : ),) . , , , , , 171. 172. :

. M. Heidegger, Sein und Zeit, Tbingen 197915, . 138: , . . . 172 , 171

140

, . , , . , ,, . . 3. 2: , . , , . 267: , . () . , ,, ( ), :.

141

, 173. 174. , , , . , ( ) , (. , ). . , .

, 1378a 1922. [: , , . .. , , ,]. 174 . Wrner, Pathos als berzeugungsmittel in der Rhetorik des AristotelesPathos,Affect,Gefhl(Hrsg.I.CrmerRgenberg),Mnchen 1981, : Diese Charakterisierung der Affekte, mit einem emphatischen es sind/ eingeleitet, was darauf hindeudet,daAristoteleshierseineeigenePositionwiedergibt,stelltjedoch weder eine Definition per genus proximum et differentiam specificam dar, noch erfllt sie die nach den Zweiten Analytiken erfordenlichen Kriterien einer solchen. Hierzu wurde die Angabe des Eidos, des Zugrundeliegenden und der Ursache gehren wodurch sich das Eidos im Zugrundeliegenden findet.173

142

... , ,,175. , ( ), , . . vo 176. . . W. Fortenbaugh, Aristotles Rhetoric on Emotions, Archiv fr Geschichte der Philosophie 52 (1970), . 5354, : This initial statement, we may suspect, is not offered as a final and precise definition of emotion. For it is to wide and can include physiological disturbances such as headaches and stomachaches that are accombanied by pain and that do affect judgment. Qualification is needed. In this respect Aristotlesimmediatelyfollowingremarksareimportant. 176 . . Wrner, Das Ethische in der Rhetrik des Aristoteles, Mnchen 1990, . 298299: Offenbar kommt es Aristoteles aufeinegenauereBestimmung der Affecte nicht an. Fr die Rhetorik ist vielmehr ausschlaggebend, da der Redner einen bestimmten Affect hinreichend klar identifizieren kann und Kenntnisse dafr verfgt, beeinflussen knnen. Gerade dies will Aristoteles eigenshervorheben.175

143

, , . ( ) ()177. . ( !) rei et intellectus , . , . , , . : ( ), . (,. 268) ( ) .177

144

. , , , . , , . , , . . : . , , , . , . 3.1. .

145

+ 178. , , . ( ), , 179. /180. T

, 1354a 2426: , [:,, ]. 179,1379a2630: ,, , . ... [: , ,, , . ...]. 180 , 1377b 2428:, , , , [: ,, ( ) ,,178

146

, . , , 181. 182. O . : 183. (, ,,,) , . . 3.2. , . , , , .

]. 181 , 1380a 23: . 182 , 1383a 89:, .,1387b18211388a2730. 183,1378a2426.

147

, . , , , ( ). , 184. , 185. , 186 211, .

: , 1102a 2728: ,.,, (1102a3233: , ) (1102b 1314: ,). T , (.: )(1102b3031). 185 W. Fortenbaugh, Aristotle, EmotionandMoralVirtue,Arethusa2(1969). 186 . A. Hellwig, Untersuchungen zur Theorie der Rhetoric bei Plato und Aristoteles, Hypomnemata 38 (1973), . 238239 W. Fortenbaugh, Aristotles Rhetoric on Emotions, Archiv fr Geschichte der Philosophie 52 (1970), . 5861 Fr. Solmsen, Aristotle and Cicero on the Orators playing upon the feelings, ClassicalPhilology33(1938),.393.184

148

. , . . : , , . , , , , . : de facto . (1378a301380a5)(1380a6b34) [] , 187.

187

, 1378a 30 32. [: () , ].

149

, ( ) . 188 , , , (=, , ). : (=), (= ) (=)189 , . , . , , , . : . , 1378a 3334: , . [: , .. ,]. 189., . ., ., 2004,. 484,. 26 27: , , . , .188

150

.,, ,. . : ) (.. , , ), , ) ) . oo . (o). , . , , , , , , ,

151

, 190. , [] . (). : , , , 191. : . ,,:

, 1379a 34b 2. [: .. , ... , , ,]. 191 , 1378b 14. [: ,. ,, . , ].190

152

) , . ) , , . ) . , . ,,, . , , . , . , , , . ,, , . : , ,

153

, , , 192. : . , . . . , . , ,, . : 193.

., . ., .,2004,.43. 193 , 1380a 9. [: ]. : :) , , , ) , 192

154

, 194. , . 195 . , .

.: , . (224b 1316) : ,, . , . ( ) ( ), . 194,1231b526. 195 , 1380a 912:, , [: , ,, ].

155

, , 196. , ., . 197. , . . , ,. , , , ., , , . . , , , , , , ( ) , , ().

, 1380b 1618: , [] ,. 197,1380a2729.196

156

. H(1380b351381b37)(1382a1a19) (): , , 198. : , . , , . . , 199. . , 1380b 361381a 1. [: , ,. : , , ]. 199 , 1156a 25: [: , ; : 198

157

, . : : . (, , ) . , 200. , , 201. . ( ) : 202., ]. 200,1381a2931. 201,1381a1113.

158

! . . , . , , . , , , ., . , . , , . , , ( !). , . , , . , : , ,. ,,.

202

,1381a2022.

159

. , ,. , . , : , . :... : , . , , 203. (1382a201383a12)(1383a13b10) 204. ., . , 1172a 2123: .[: , , ]. , 1340a 15: 204 , 1382a 2122. [: , ].203

160

, , : . 205, : , , , 206. , , , . , , : , . 1.3. . . . . . , ; , 2002, ,.179234. 206 , 1382a 2225. [: , , (.. ), ,,].205

161

, 207. . , . ,, . , ( .. ). . , . , , . , , ,,,..., , ( , 1382b 3033. [: : , , ].207

162

). , , : , , , 208. . . , . , , . ,, , . . (1383b111385a15) , , 209.208

,1383a1618.[: , .: ].

163

(, , ) . . , . , , . . , , . (..) , .

, 1383b 1215. [: (, ) , ].209

164

. . 210, . , , () , , , , , , , , . , . : ,. 211. , ,. (1385a16b10) , 212.

, 1384a 2223: , 211 , 1.20.8, 14: , . 212 , 1385a 1819. [: , , , ].210

165

, , . : ) , ) , ) , ) . , (,,) . 1385b 11 1386b 7 (1386b8151387a6 b21) , , 213. ( ), . . , 213

, 1385b 1316. [: , ,].

166

:, ,., . (, , ,,,) . : [= ,] , , , ,, 214. ( ) . , , , . , , 1385b 2327. [: ) , ) ( ),),) , ) ( )].214

167

. () , , , , , , , . , , . : 215. 216. . , , . , , :

,1386b911.[:, , ]. 216,401b1213:...215

168

: , 217. , , . : . :, . , , . ,( ), , . , 218. : , 219.,1387b9. ,1233b1826. 219,1.27.1,13.217 218

169

(1386b161387a51387b211388a30) : , 220. , ,. , . , . , . , ( , ). ,, . , . , ,. 220

, 1386b 1820. [:,, , , ].

170

(1388a31b28) : , 221. , 222, , . , . , , . 223 221 , 1388a 3235. [: , , , , ]. 222.. ., , .,,. 223 . , 1333b 1618: ,.

171

, . , . , ., . , . . 3.3. , , , . . To ,, () . , , . ,, , . ,

172

. , ., , , , ., , . , , , . , , , . . : . , , , . , , . ,, . . ,

173

. , , . 211 224, . . , 225 , . , : 226. ( ) . , . ,

T. Conley, and : Aristotle Rhetoric II 211, Hermes 1982 ,A.Hellwig,UntersuchungenzurTheoriederRhetoricbeiPlatound Aristoteles,Hypomnemata38(1973),.234. 225 E. Papadimitriou, Ethische und psychologische Grundlagen der aristotelischen Rhetoric,Frankfurt1979,.197. 226,1355a2933.224

174

. 3.4. , . , , 227; , ,; , , . , . , , . , , . . , . . , 227 S. R. Leighton, Aristotle and the Emotions, Phronesis 1982, .

175

, . . , , ., . , , , . , . o , . ,, . . , , , ( ) .

176

, . , . , . , . : 228. 3.5./ ,, . . , . (,) ( ). / .

228

,1354b1011.

177

. . . ,. , , . , , . , , , . . , . , . . ., , ( , , ) , , . , .

178

, . . , , . , . . , . , , 229. , . . , , : . , : . .

229

, 1384a 1516: , , , , ,,,,, .

179

. , ,. : . , . ., , . . , . . . . , ,230 . . 4. (,), ,

230

. . Wrner, Das Ethische in der RhetrikdesAristoteles,Mnchen1990,.303.

180

231

, . . ( ) , , , , , . , , . ,. , . , . ., , ,, . , . , , 232.,, , ,, .., ,100(2000),.266286. 232,1369a1521.231

181

,,,, , ,, ,,. 5. . , 233, , . . , , , . . . , : ; . . , , , . 233

.. .,,., . ,2006,.3845.

182

, . .

, , 234. ,

234

: F. Dirlmeier, Aristoteles. Nikomachische Ethik, Berlin 1956., , , , 1998 I. Dring, , , (Aristoteles, Darstellung und Interpretation seines Denkens, Heidelberg 1966), ., . . , 1999. ( 2...), In thica Nichomachea commentaria, ed. G. Heylbut, Aspasii in thica Nicomachea quae supersunt commentaria (C.A.G. 19), Berlin 1889. . ( ,. 268) ( ) .

184235

. , . ,

, 1103b 341104a 11:, , , ., , , . [: , , , , , . , , , ]. . , . . , 1, 2006, . 312: :) , , ) ( ) .235

185

. ( ) , . , 236 , , ,, , , . , ( ) , a posteriori . . . , , . , , 1103b 2630: ( ,,), , [: , ( , ), , ]. ,,1216b2023.236

186

, . . 1.T . , , . , , 237. ,,, , . : , ,

237

:,700b1525: , , . . . , . , . , .

187

...238 , . , . , , , (=) . ( ) , , : ,. , , : 239 ( ), (), (), (), (), ( , ), (). , .,

, 1362a 2123. [: , ...] 239 , 1217b 2526. . . , , ,1998,.260.238

188

, ,. , , . , , . , : . , , ,. : , . , . (.. ). , (=), . ( , , ,), , ,

189

240. , 241. . , , ., ( !) . : . 20 .

,1094a26b11. J. P. Vernant, (. . ), 1966,.110: , , , , . o , . homo sapienshomopoliticus, , , . , , , , .240 241

190

. , . . . , , , 242 , . . 2.H H , , , , , . , , . , , 243. , ,

, 1217a 2122: []. 243 ( ,1100b10)..1169b2831:, . [: ... , . ...].242

191

244, . , . , , , . , : , , . , , . , () , 245. ,,

, 52, 23: , . [Dring: , ]. 245 , 1097b 811:, , , . [ : ,, ,,,, , ]. (.., 16.1920): .244

192

. , , , . , , . ( , )., 246 , . :, 247. , , . .

, 1102a 56. , 1219a 34: . 247 , 1101b 1416: . [:,,, ].246

193

. ,(): 248 , . . , . , , . . . , . , . , . ,

248

, 1179a 1820. [: ].

194

249

. , ,, ,

249

, 1099a 31 b 8: , ., , , , , , ., , . [: ,, , .,, ,, . ,, ,.., ,, , , . , ]. (.., 13.2428) .

195

, 250. , 251 , , . 3. , , . , , , . , ., , ., .

(.., 16.1316): , , , ,. 251,2.8.1,36: , ,,.250

196

, , 252. , ., , , , , , , , 253. , , 254 . ,

, 412b 48:, . , , [: , . , , ]. . J. L. Ackrill, Aristotles Definitions of Psuch,. Barnes, Schofield, and Sorabji, ArticlesonAristotle,Vol.4,PsychologyandAesthetics,NewYork1979,.65 75. 253 . , ; , 2002. ., , . 119147, . 254,414a12.252

197

, 255 ( ,,,) 256. ,,, . ,

. M. Heidegger, Vier Seminare, Frankfurt am Main 1977,. 6667 ( . M. Heidegger, ;, 1986, . 162): ; , : , . Kant. . : ; () ;., M. Heidegger, (.. ),1973,.135136: . . . ( . , , , , , ). [] , , . , , . [...] :,. ,.[...] .:, [], , . , :,. 256,431b21.255

198257

. , , , , ,,,,, 258. , ., . , , ., , ,

, 1105b 20. ,. . Garver, Metaphysics of Morals, JournaloftheHistoryofPhilosophy27(1989),.728. 258 . W. Fortenbaugh, Aristotle on Emotion, London 1975 K. Jacobi, Aristoteles ber der rechten Umgang mit Gefhlen, Pathos, Affect, Gefhl: philosophische Beitrge, hrsg. von I. CrmerRgenberg, FreiburgMnchen 1981 S. Leighton, Aristotle and the Emotions, Phronesis 1982, . 154157. : . , . , 100, 2000, . 272273: . ( ), , : . : , ,, ()(). ,, .257

199

., . 4. ( )259. , ( ) , . , ,, (

M. Adler, (Aristotle for everybody. Difficult Thought Made Easy, 1978) . (.. ), 1996, . 132133: . . , : . . [...]. , , .. , . , . , ,.259

200

), 260. , , . . 261. , . , :

, 1106b 1827: , ,, . ., [], . [: , , , ,, , , , ,,, ,, ]. , 1105b 2528:, , , , ,. 261 (.., 20.48): , , .260

201

, , . , : ,. , .,, , . , . 262, . , . . ,. , , , . ,

262

,1106b8...

202

263

, . , , : 264. , , , 265. 4.1. , , , ,. , . .

, 1107a 68: , . [: , ,, , , ]. 264,1099a1718. 265,1175b1328.263

203

, . , , . ( ) ( ). , . , , . . . , , ., ., , , ,

204

,.,, , , ,. , . , . . , ,. , . , , .,, . . .,: 266 , .

266

,1114b3132.

205

267. , , . , , , : 268. 4.2. , 269 ,

, 1114a 914: , . . , , ,. [: , .,, , . , , ,,,. ]. 268 , 1163a 2223. [: ,]. 269 , 1.17.67: , . , , . , ,.267

206

, . , . , , , , . 4.3. , , ., . , . ,,: , 270. ,270

, 1144b 2627. [: ].

207

, , . , , . , , . . , . , , ., , , . , . 271. . 4.4. , 272 , 271 272

,1122b29,1144b1428. , 1113a 2933:, .

208

, . , . . , . , , .

, , . [: , : : , ]. , 39, 13: , . [Dring: ;,, ,].

209

( , ) , : , , , 273. , . : ! 4.5. : , , 274. , 1178a 1619. [: ,, ]. . , 1141b 23: .P.Aubenque,LaprudencechezAristote,Paris1963. 274 , 1106b 36 1107a 2. [: , ),) , ,,,273

210

,, , , . , . 5.(:) , , , : , 275 , . ,:

].., . .,1,2006,.329: , (= ) ( , ) . [...] . 275 , 95, 34. [Dring: , ,].

211

, 276. :277. , . , , ., , , , . T: , 278.

, 87, 12. [Dring: , ., , 1178b 78 1177a 1618: [] . , . 277 , 1178a 59: , . . .[: , . , , . ]. 278,1.3.2.12.276

212

279. , . : 280. . , 281., : , , , 282. , :

I. Dring, , , . (..), 1999,. 206 255 . 280 , 78, 12. [Dring: ]. 281 , 1072b 24: . ,1177a2526: . [: ,]. 282 , 1177a 32b 1. [:, , , , , , , ].279

213

. , , , ., , , 283. 284, , : , 285.

, 41, 58: , . [Dring: ]. 284,1072b2728. 285 , 85, 35. [Dring: , ].283

214

286.,, 287! ,, ,, . , , . , . , . . , , , 288.,65,67. , 110, 23: . [Dring: ]. 288 , 17, 1012: ,., [Dring: , . , 70, 13: , [Dring:286 287

215

. , (;), . , , . , : , 289!, . , ,., , ,

, , . ] , 40, 56: . 289 , 104, 16: , . , . , . [Dring: ,. . ].

216

290; . , 1177b 2478a 8: , . , ,. , . , , . , . , . , . [: , ( ). , , , , , . ,,, . ,, , , , , , . , , , 290

217

. , . : , , , , ,. , . , . : , , ,, : . . .

. , . , : ,. ,,].

: ,, ( 4 ): () , . ( ), (), . ,, , . 4, 1448b 419: . , . , , . , ,

220

. , , . , . 1. 1.1. 4 , . , 291. 4 , , ( , , , 292). , ,

, 1447a 1318: , .., :; ,.,.. ,.,..,..,2004, . 5970, (. 65): , , ( ) (.9). 292,1033a24b19.291

221

, , ,. ( ) , . (= ). : 293,, , . , . , , , . . , , P. Feyerabend, In defence of Aristotle: Comments on the Condition of Content Increase, RadnitzkiAnderson (eds), Progress and Rationality in Science, Dordrecht Reidel 1978, , .293

222

( ) . , . : , , . , . 1.2. , . () . , . , 294. , , , 534a 7b 7: , . , , 294

223

. , ,. , : ( , , ). . , 4 , , . ) : : . . ,:

. [: , , , , . ,, , ].

224

. , . ; ., ( , ): , . , (,, ). 295. , , ; , ,. ... , : , .

295

. , 956a 14: (. ) .

225

. ) , : . ( ) / , . 296. , ( ) ;, , 297: , ,

. , 980a 21: . 297 , 70a 710: , .296

226

298. 4. , . , . , . . . , , . , . , , .,,, ,

298

: B. A. Kyrkos,DiedichtungalsWissensproblembeiAristoteles,Athen1972,.98.

227

. , , 299. 300, . , . , 2006, . 31. :.., .,1989. 300 . , , 1984, . 7071: . Hegel, , . , . Marx, , . 299

228

. . ( ), . , (,). . , . () , , . ( ) :

. , ,. Freud, . , . , .

229

, , . 4 (1448b 419) . : . : . 301. , , ., (1448b 1924) , 302.

, . 19. . 302 (1448b l924), , . ( ), . , , , . B. A. Kyrkos, Die dichtung als Wissensproblem bei Aristoteles, Athen301

230

4 . . 1.3. , , . E , ( , ,) , , ; , . 303: , , , ()304.

1972,. 66. G. F. Else, Aristotles Poetics: The argument, Harvard 1957,. 127. 303. E. Belfiore, Pleasure, Tragedy and aristotelian psychology, Classical Quarterly 35 (1985). , S. Halliwell, Pleasure, Understanding, and Emotion in AristotlesPoetics,.244. 304. N. T. Croally, Euribidian polemic (The Troian women and the function of tragedy), Cambridge 1994, hedidacticproduction.

231

, . ,. ( ) () , ( ) , (). , , .,, , 305. , ,

(, 88, 18): , . , . , , . [Dring: . , ,, ., . , , , 305

232

, , , . . , , , . : , ,306.

,, ]. 306 . corpus: , 503a 2529: , , , , . , 711b 2227: , , . , ,,, .

233

307, . : , , . . , . , ; , ; ; (); , 307

. , 645a 715: ., , , , [: , , , . , , , ( , ), ,, , ;].

234

, , ; , . , , . . , , .,, . 2. 2.1. 308 . , ,309, , . , 278a 15: . , . 309 , ,105a13:., , 81a 38 b9. . . . , . , , , ,. J. P. Anton, 2004, .213217.308

235

() , , : , ; , ; , {}{}; , 310. : , 311. : 312.,918a38. ,67a2125:, . , . , ,. : . , , . 312,1050a12.310 311

236

: , . , , . . 2.2. 313 , . , 314.

, 4 , .. B. A. Kyrkos, Die dichtung als Wissensproblem bei Aristoteles, Athen 1972,.101. 314 , D. de Montmollin, La Poetique d Aristote, Neuchatel 1951,.24,.35,inferbysyllogistic reasoning. G. M. Sifakis, Learning fron art and pleasure in learning: an interpretation of Aristotle Poetics 4 1448b 819, Studies in Honour of T.B.L. Webster, Bristol 1986, . 215. D. W. Lucas, Aristotle, Poetics (Introduction, commentary and appendixes), Oxford 1968, . 72 G. F. Else, Aristotles Poetics:Theargument,Harvard1957,.130.313

237

: . , 315. ( ),.,, ;, ( ) , , . : , . 2.3. 316 .

,24b1923. G. M. Sifakis, .., . 217, : Aristotle uses the noun in the sence the imitating (art), the transitive participle (at Rhet. 1371b 6) to mean two different things: the image or likeness of the thing imitated or depicted bei the work of art and the imitat ing thing itself, the model of representation, which has an independent existanceinreality.315 316

238

( ) , , , . , () , ( ). 4 9 317. , ( ). . , , ,317 , 1451b 511: , . , , , [: , ,. : , . , .., ].

239

( , ) . ( ), . 2.4. . , . . , ( , ). .

240

, : , , , , , , , 318. . ( ) , .,, , ( ) 319, .

, 1371b 410. [: , ,.. (,,), , , : , ]. 319,1078b24.318

241

: 320. (). 2.5. , 4 . , ,. ; ; , . ,, , , , 320

, 1356b 1618. [: , , : ,].

242

, .,, , , . , . , , , , . , . () , (). . , . , ,, (,, ). (

243

), . , . , , . , , , . . 3. , , , , , . , , . , . ratio, .

244

: , 321. ,, , 322. , . 323: , ! : , . , : ,,72b1820. , 1072b 2224: , ,. 323,1455b23.321 322

245

, , 324. () , . . , , , , . , . ( ) . , . , 325,

,1450b371451a6. . . , , 1989, (. 1819): , , cogito. , 324 325

246

326

, . , , , . , . , , , .,

. , . , , . 326.., , .. , 1991,. 187: ., , , ..

247

, . . . , . . . . , ., , . 4. , , .

248

: , . , , ; 327, . O 328 . 329,: , . 330..B.A.Kyrkos,..,.100.E.Belfiore,Pleasure,Tragedyand aristotelianpsychology,ClassicalQuarterly35(1985),.349. 328 , 1340a 2328: ( ,, ,). 329 , 1174b 2628: , (). [ : , (,,)].327

249

, , , . , ,. . 331. . (): , , , 980a 2127. [: . : ,, ,, ]., , : , 981b 1011: . 331 , 1404b 1012: . [: , ,].330

250

, 332. , , . , , . , , ,. , 333: ... , , 334.

, 1175a 610. [: , , , , : , , ,.]. 333 J. Mette, Schauen and Stauen, Glotta 39 (1961),. 4971, (), (),(). 334 , 982b 1215. M. Heidegger, ; (..), 1986, . 65: , .332

251

, , , ( ), . , , . ; : . , 335. , , , . ( )

, : , v,:. . ,,,, . . : . . [...] o (tre en arrt). , . , ,. . , . 335 , 1371a 3133 , 1370b 15: .

252

( 336). ,, . , 337. , .

, 1370a 1827: . , , , , , [], . [:, , . , , ,,..,, , ,, . , ,, ]. 337 , 982b 1721: ... ... .336

253

338: () , , : () 339. , ., : , , 340.

, 1174b 2021:, . [: ]. 339 , 1153a 2223. [: (), ,]. 340 , 1175a 1215. [: , .., , ...].338

254

, . 5.: 341, , . . , ( 342). : 343. 4 , , . , , . ,

, 1175a 2528: . . [: .,, , , ,, ]. 342. G. M. Sifakis, ..,. 212: That art is instuctive by being pleasurable is also a proposition that would presumably raise no objection. But that art is pleasurable because it is instuctiveisapropositionthatfewpeoplewouldfindeasytoaccept. 343,1460a17.341

255

, . : 344. , , : 345. .,,. ,: 346. , . , , , . , , ,645a1213. , 1410b 10. ,1237a2326: ,. 346. , 1452a 17: , [ ] , .344 345

256

. , () 347 . . ( ) , 348. . , 349, . 11. ... ,

, 1175a 2021: ,. 348 . . . , . ,2006. 349 , 1175b 1315: , .... [: , , , ...].347

257

... 350. . : 351. , , , . : , 352. : , 353. , , , , , , 1369b 33 1370a 6. [: ,, . [...] , ]. 351 , 1371a 3334: . 352,1244b2324. 353,1245a9.350

258

., , , , , .

. , . (rationalismus). , . , , , , . , , , . , , cogito.

260

, . , : , . , , , . : . . , , . , , . . , .

261

, , . , , . , . , , . , . , ., , ,. , , , , , . ,

262

. , , . , , . . . , . ; ; , . , . , .

263

, , , , . , . . : . , . , , ,... , , . .

264

, , , . , . : , . , . . , , , . : , . , . , , . ,

265

. , () , , , . , . , . , . : ., , , ., , , a posteriori, . . ,, .

266

, . , , . , , , . , , , . , . (). , . ,, . , , . ,.

267

, . : , , . , , , , . , , , . , , . . ,, . , . .

. ) .1.ScriptorumClassicorumBibliothecaOxoniensis (Oxford): ,ed.L.MinioPaluello1949. ,ed.W.D.Ross,1964. ,ed.W.D.Ross,1958. ,ed.W.D.Ross,1966. ,ed.W.D.Ross,1961. ,ed.W.D.Ross,1970. ,ed.I.Bywater,1962. ,ed.R.Kassel,1965. ,ed.W.D.Ross,1957. ,ed.W.D.Ross,1959. .2.LesBellesLettres: ,ed.P.Moraux,1965. ,ed.C.Mungler,1966. .3.Teubner: ,ed.W.Jaeger,1913. ,ed.F.Susemihl,1884.

270

.4.HarvardUniversityPress. ,ed.F.Susemihl,1935. .5.: ,ed.I.Bekker,1831. .6. , ed. I. Dring, Aristotles protrepticus, Stockholm 1961. ) Commentaria in AristotelemGraeca , , C.A.G. IX, X, ed. H. Diels,18921895. , , C.A.G. XVI, XVII, ed. H.Vitelli,18871888. , , C.A.G. XV, ed.M.Hayduck,1897. ,InthicaNichomacheacommentaria,C.A.G.XV,ed.G. Heylbut,1889. ) . , . .,1999. . , , 100 () 2000,. 194226. . , . . ,A.,2002/2004. . , . . ( 1:, 2:), 2006.

271

. , . ., 1937. . , . ,,..

272

B. J. L. Ackrill, Aristotles Definitions of Psuch, Barnes, Schofield, and Sorabji (eds), Articles on Aristotle, Vol. 4, Psychology andAesthetics,NewYork1979. P.Aubenque,LaprudencechezAristote,Paris1963. M. Adler, (Aristotle for everybody. Difficult Thought Made Easy, 1978) . (..),1996. . . , . . (.), .,, ,,.J.P.Anton,1994, .205224. L.Arnhard,AristotleonPoliticalReasoning,Illinois1981. E. Belfiore, Pleasure, Tragedy and aristotelian psychology, ClassicalQuarterly35(1985). . , , .. (.), . , , ,,.J.P.Anton,1994, .314333. R. Cannicht, (The Ancient Quarrel between Philosophy and Poetry, 1980) (..), 1986. H.Cassirer,AristotlesSchriftvonderSeele,Tbingen1932. W. Charlton, Aristotles Definition of Soul, Phronesis 25 (1980), .170186. T. Conley, and:AristotleRhetoricII211,Hermes 1982. N. T. Croally, Euribidian polemic (The Troian women and the fuction oftragedy),Cambridge1994. F.Dirlmeier,Aristoteles.NikomachischeEthik,Berlin1956.

273

E. R. Dodds, (The Greeks and the Irrational, 1951) (..),1977. . , ,100(2000),.287291. I. Dring, , , (Aristoteles, Darstellung und Interpretation seines Denkens, 1966), . (. . ) . (. . ),1999. G.F.Else,AristotlesPoetics:TheArgument,Harvard1957. P. Feyerabend, (Against Method, 1975), . (. . , . ),1982. P. Feyerabend, In defence of Aristotle: Comments on the Condi tion of Content Increase, Progress and Ra tionalityinScience,edsRadnitzki,Anderson,DodrechtReidel1978. P. Feyerabend, (Erkenntnis fr freie Menchen 1979) (..),1986. W. Fortenbaugh, Aristotles Rhetoric on Emotions, Archiv fr GeschichtederPhilosophie52(1970),.5354. W.Fortenbaugh,Aristotle,EmotionandMoralVirtue,Arethusa 2(1969). W.Fortenbaugh,AristotleonEmotion,London1975. D. Frede, The Cognitive Role of Phantasia in Aristotle, Es says on Aristotles De Anima (eds. M. Nussbaum and A. Rorty), Ox ford1992,279295. . Garver, Metaphysics of Morals, Journal of the History of Phi losophy27(1989),.728. R. A. Gauthier S. Y. Jolif, L Ethique a Nicomaque, Tome II, LouvainParis1959. . , , 1981. . , , 1984.

274

. , , 135 ()1986,.1416. . , ,1989. .,,1993. .,,2004. .Gilson,Lethomisme,Paris19726. W. Grimaldi, Studies in der Philosophy of Aristotles Rhetoric, Wies banden1972. J.Habermas,TheoriedeskommunikativenHandelns,Frankfurt1981. J. Habermas, (...),1990. S. Halliwell, Pleasure, Understanding, and Emotion in Aristotles Po etics. P. Hadot, (Questce que la philosophie antique?, 1995) (..),2002. W.Hardie,AristotlesEthicalTheory,Oxford1968. A. Hellwig, Untersuchungen zur Theorie der Rhetoric bei Plato undAristoteles,Hypomnemata38,1973,.238240. M. Heidegger, (Was ist das die Philosophie?, 1956) ;(....),1986. M. Heidegger, (Einfhrung in die Metaphysik, 1953) (..),1973. M.Heidegger,SeinundZeit,Tbingen197915. H. Heimsoeth, 20 , Windelband Heimsoeth, (.. ),.3. R. D. Hicks, De Anima. With translation, introduction and notes, Cambridge1907. . , : ; ,.,.

275

. , . , . . , . . , 2004,.5970 I.Irwin,AristotlesFirstPrinciples,Oxford1988. I.Irwin,TheStructureofAristotelianHappiness,Ethics1991. K. Jacobi, Aristoteles ber der rechten Umgang mit Gefhlen, Pathos, Affect, Gefhl: philosophische Beitrge, hrsg. von I. Cr merRgenberg,FreiburgMnchen1981. W.Jaeger,Aristotle,1967. H.H.Joachim,Aristotle.TheNikomacheanEthics,Oxford1951. P.alatzidis,ImaginatinetimaginairechezAristote,Revuede PhilosophieAncienneIX,1(1991),158. R. Kannicht, (Der alte Streit zwischen Philosophie und Dich tung, Altsprachlicher Untericht 23, 1980) ,..,1988. . , (L institution imaginaire de la socit, 1975) (..,. ,.),1978. . , (Le Carrefours du labyrinthe, 1978) (..),1991. .,(DieAufklrungimRahmendesneuzeitlichenRationa lismus,1981),1987. . , , 135(),1986,.1720. .,.,1983. R.Kraut,AristotleontheHumanGood,Princeton1989. . Kuhn, (Structure of Scientific Revolutions, 1962) (. . , . . ,.),1981. D. Kurz, Akribeia, Das Ideal der Exactheit bei den Griechen bis Aristo teles,Goebinger.Akad.Beitraege8,1970. B. A. Kyrkos, Die dichtung als Wissensproblem bei Aristoteles, Athen 1972,.98. Lear,Katharsis,Phronesis33(1988).

276

S. R. Leighton, Aristotle and the Emotions, Phronesis 1982,. 154157. . , ,1920(1980),.422. . , , , , 1998. . , ., 100 ( ),2000,.266286. D. W. Lucas, Aristotle, Poetics (Introduction, commentary and appen dixes,Oxford1968. S.Mansion,BodyandSoulinAristotle,Philology49. H.Marcuse,DereindimensinaleMensch,Neuwied1967. J.Mette,SchauenandStauen,Glotta39(1961),.4971. D.deMontmollin,LaPoetiquedAristote,Neuchatel1951. . , . , 2006. W. Nestle, (. . ), 1999. A.Nicev,LnigmedelacatharsistragiquedansAristote,Sofia1970. K. Oehler, (Subjektivitt und Selbstbewutsein in der Antike, 1997) (. .),... E. H. Olmsted, The moral sense aspect of Aristotes ethical the ory,AmericanJournalofPhilology69(1948),.4261. E.Papadimitriou,EthischeundpsychologischeGrundlagenderaristo telischenRhetoric,Frankfurt1979. .,, 1983. . , . . (.), .,,

277

,,.J.P.Anton,1994, .260278. . , , , 1998. K. Popper, (The Open Society and its Enemies, 1945) (...),1980. P.Railton,MoralTheoryasMoralPractise,Nous25(1991),. 185190. A. Rorty, Aristotle on metaphysical status of Pathe, The Review ofMetaphysics37(1983/1984). D.Ross,Deanima.Editedwithintroductionandcommentary,Ox ford1961. . , . ,1989. . , ; ,2002. G. M. Sifakis, Learning fron art and pleasure in learning: an in terpretation of Aristotle Poetics 4 1448b819, Studies in Honour of T.B.L.Webster,Bristol1986,.214215. B. Snell, (. . ), 1984. F. Solmsen, Aristotle and Cicero on the Orators playing upon thefeelings,ClassicalPhilology33(1938). R. Sorabji, Aristotle on Demarcating the Five Senses, Bar nes, Schofield, and Sorabji (eds), Articles on Aristotle, vol. 4. Psy chologyandAesthetics,NewYork1979. .,,1937. J.P. Vernant, (.. ),1966. M.Weber,DieprotentantischeEthik,Hamburg1973. B.Williams,EthicsandtheLimitsofPhilosophy,London1984.

278

L. Wittgenstein, Tractatus LogicoPhilosophicus ( 1921),. .,1978. . Wrner, Pathos, als berzeugungsmittel in der Rhetorik des Aristoteles Pathos, Affect, Gefhl (Hrsg. I. Crmer Rgenberg),Mnchen1981. . Wrner, Das Ethische in der Rhetrik des Aristoteles, Mnchen 1990.

,2a47 75 ,402a47 ,402b2225 ,16a19 76 ,403a89 ,16a2628 76 ,408b29 ,24b1923 237 ,412a6 ,32b413 83 ,412a1921 ,67a2125 235 ,412a2728 ,70a710 225 ,414a1112 ,72b1820 77 ,414a12 ,72b1820 244 ,414a2025 ,81a38b9 234 ,414a24415b1 ,414a3132 ,101b38 77 ,414a3233 ,105a13 234 ,414b2227 ,414b2833 ,165a612 77 ,415a12 ,415a12 ,184a1625 92 ,415a11 ,198a35b4 131 ,415a17 ,211a611 85 ,415a23b1 ,224b1316 154 ,415b2627 ,250b1115 131 ,417a69 ,417b1618 ,401b1213 167 ,417b30 ,424a1724 ,425a1420 114 ,427b1416 ,425b2325 119 ,427b28 ,425b2627 103 ,428b1116 ,426a911 104 ,429a12 ,427a1921 113 ,429a2729

88 122 125 129 102 96 96 104 196 95 107 88 106 95 108 94 107 122 88 107 107 110 107 110 111 123 126 117 117 128

280,429b35 ,429b1022 ,430a34

129 120 128 126 129 132 122 122 132 197 112 128 127 120 122 112 89 89 132 132 132 132 123 106 76

,430a1018 ,430a1725 ,431a916 ,431a1617 ,431b2 ,431b17 ,431b21 ,431b26432a1 ,432a2 ,432a45 ,432a910 ,432a1213 ,432a1516 ,432a1517 ,432a2228 ,432b57 ,432b2829 ,433a1718 ,433a31b1 ,433b2630 ,434a2226 , 437a1215 , 503a2529 ,645a1213 ,663b2729 ,700b1525

, 711b2227 , 736b2729 ,918a38 ,956a14 ,980a21 ,980a2127 ,982b1215 ,982b1721 ,1028b24 ,1033a24b19 ,1050a12 ,1069b1520 ,1072b2224 ,1072b24 ,1072b2728 ,1075a310 ,1078b24 , 1094a26b11 , 1094b1127 ,1097b811 ,1099a1718 ,1099a31b8

232 129 235 224 225 249 250 252 77 220 235 96 244 212 213 78 240 189 82 191 202 194 190 192 192 147 147 147 147

,1100b10 232 ,1101b1416 255 83 186 ,1102a56 ,1102a2728 ,1102a3233 ,1102b1314 ,1102b3031

281

, 1103b341104a11 ,1103b2630 ,1105b20 ,1105b2528 ,1106b8 ,1106b1827 , 1106b361107a2 ,1107a68 ,1113a2933 ,1114a914 ,1114b3132 ,1122b29 ,1137b1319 ,1137b2930 ,1141b23 ,1144b1428 ,1144b2627 ,1147a2122 ,1153a2223 ,1156a25 ,1163a2223 ,1169b2831 ,1170a29b1 ,1172a2123 , 1177b241178a8 ,1174b2021 ,1174b2628 ,1175a610 ,1175a1215 ,1175a2021 ,1175a2528 ,1175b1315 ,1175b1328 ,1177a1618 ,1177a2526

184 ,1177a32b1 212 185 198 200 201 200 209 202 207 205 204 207 81 82 209 207 206 79 253 156 205 190 116 159 216 253 248 250 253 256 254 256 202 211 212 ,1178a59 ,1178a1619 ,1178b78 ,1179a1820 ,1216b2023 ,1217a2122 ,1217b2526 ,1219a34 ,1231b526 ,1233b1826 ,1237a2326 ,1237a2326 ,1244b2324 ,1245a9 ,1.3.2.12 ,1.17.67 ,1.20.8,14 ,1.27.1,13 ,2.8.1,36 ,1333b1618 ,1340a15 ,1340a2328 ,1354a1418 ,1354a2426 ,1354b1011 ,1355a2933 ,1356a1416 ,1356b1618 ,1362a2123 ,1369a1521 ,1369b331370a6 ,1370a1827 211 209 211 193 185 190 187 192 154 168 255 257 257 257 212 205 164 168 195 170 159 248 135 145 176 173 137 241 187 180 257 252

282

,1370b15 ,1371a3133 ,1371a3334 ,1371b410 ,1371b6 ,1377b2428 ,1377b2878a1 ,1378a1922 ,1378a2426 ,1378a3032 ,1378a3334 ,1378b14 ,1379a2630 ,1379a34b2 ,1380a23 ,1380a9 ,1380a912 ,1380a2729 ,1380b1618 ,1380b361381a1 ,1381a1113 ,1381a2022 ,1381a2931 ,1382a2122 ,1382a2225 ,1382b3033 ,1383a89 ,1383a1618 ,1383b1215 ,1384a1516 ,1384a2223 ,1385a1819 ,1385b1316 ,1385b2327 ,1386b911 ,1386b1820 ,1387b9 ,1387b1821

251 251 257 240 237 145 138 141 146 148 149 151 145 151 146 153 154 155 155 156 157 158 157 159 160 161 146 162 163 178 164 164 165 166 167 169 168 146

,1388a2730 ,1388a3235 ,1404b1012 ,1410b10 ,1447a1318 ,1448bl924 ,1450b371451a6 ,1451b511 ,1452a17 ,1455b23 ,1458a34b5 ,1460a17 ,17,1012 ,39,13 ,41,58 ,52,23 ,65,67 ,78,12 ,85,35 ,87,12 ,88,18 ,95,34 ,104,16 ,110,23

146 170 249 255 220 229 244 238 255 244 76 254 214 208 213 191 214 212 213 211 231 211 215 214