Sotiropoulos Paper (1)

Click here to load reader

  • date post

    24-Dec-2015
  • Category

    Documents

  • view

    1
  • download

    0

Embed Size (px)

description

Sotiropoulos Paper (1)

Transcript of Sotiropoulos Paper (1)

  • '

    . "

    - , FYROM, - . - ; . - ; , - . . -, -- , .

    1. ,

    -

    t South East European a Sea Studies, 2005.6. 5, . 2: 243-257. .

    ,

    16/2006

  • 140 6

    , . '- ' . , ; , , ' ' . 6 - . -, - , .

    ( 2001, 2004, 2004, 2004). James S. Coleman, - , - (Coleman 1990). - , ,, . - -.

    - ' ' Pierre Bourdieu (Bourdieu 1984, 1989) , , : ' -' Bourdieu , . -. , - , .,

  • 6 V6 6 141

    . - .

    Francis Fukuyama , , Coleman . , , - (Fukuyama1995). ( ) - .

    Robert D. Putnam, , - (Putnam 1993). - . . -, , . - , -. Putnam -, - , , . . - (Bevort1997: 241). , Alexis de Tocqueville (- 2004), .

    , Nan , Karen Cook Ronald S. Burt '' . . , , (, ) ( 2001: 6-7).

  • 142

    - , .

    , ' ' . : , - . , , , ; - (Ostrorn 1994), - ( 2004). - w, , - , , .

    2. -

    , - , ; .- - . - . - , 1989 (Sotiropoulos 2002).

    - . - , , . , , . -

  • 6 V6 6 143

    . -, , , , , , , -. - . - , - (Gropas 2004: 64). - (,, ) - .

    , , Ivan rastev AJina Mungiu-Pippidi (Mungiu-Pippidi 2004). , - -. -, , - ( - ), , - , . - - . ' ' (Gropas2004): , , - . , - , . - . , 1989, - - , (Mungiu-Pippidi 2004).

    -

  • 144 6

    , - (Haerpfer et al. 2005: 245-246). - . , . w~Q ,

    , , , . Woolcock . Bougarel (Mihaylova2004: 66). - -.

    - - , - - . . , - ; , - , , - , - . , , - .

    3.

    , 2003 - , FYROM, -- ' ..' ('Integrating the Balkansinto the European ', IBEU).

  • 145

    .. (, -, ). , , (SAR, ), - (CLS, ), (, ) - (SEESP, ). - , - . , , (Mungiu-Pippidi 2004, Ganev et a1.2004).

    , . - (, Lin et al. 2001) (, , Bourdieu 1984). - . - , - .

    SAR (). BSS Gallup Internatonal CLS (). - 1.021 , 1.021 FYROM,1.600 , 816 402 . ( -- , ). , .

    . '' . - ,

  • 146

    ; , , ' , - ; , -.

    - - ; , . - - ., (-, FYROM, , ) - - - . , - ~.

    4.

    ; -, FYROM . , , , FYROM ' ' , , ( 1). . - ( , , - ), - , 'l . , - . - FYROM; -.

  • 147

    1. (%

    )

    - FYROM 47,6 65,2 47,4 37,9 71,9 ; 64,2 63,3 70,4 59,9 77,9; : (SAR) - BSS GalJup IntemationaJ, () SAR 2003.

    - . ' . : . , ' '. , FYROM - ' / ', FYROM ' ' : (Mungiu-Pippidi 2004: 57). , FYROM ' ' , . ' - ' ' ' ' ' (Mungiu-Pippidi2004: 58).

    ( 2). , FYROM . - ,

  • 148

    , , . ; , FYROM , . , - . - ( ) ( t, ).

    , , FYROM - ; ( ) '6, ( ) (Ganev et a). 2004).

    2. (% "

    )

    FYROM 41 49,1 106 240 110 364 284 140 251 88 25,9 215 8,8 ]9,5 87 283 21 10,3 21,S 6,8 49,9 290 143 23,2 12,0 m: 30,7 20,7 8,7 15,5 8,4 647 342 312 298 492 52,7 28 293 328 455 60,3 337 257 318 347 753 423 33 389 347 29,2 448 292 50,2; 4],8 27,0 146 26,7 274 58,4 50,] 22,2 3] 1 48,6 652 47,2 207 27,2 52,S 5] 8 42.7 249 262 505 469 41,7 226 337 35 ] 39,8 321 246 61 ]: . (SAR) - BSS Gallup International. (6) SAR 2003.

  • 149

    , , - q. (- ) . , , , ' , - (Mungiu-Pippidi 2004: 58). , FYROM ; .

    , , ' , , , , , (Ganev et al. 2004). , , ( , ...): , , . , . FYROM, - - .

    , , - FYROM ' - '( 3). . , - , - . - ; , / . ,

  • 150

    ' ' ( 3). , ( , ), - ' , ., (, , 25%) ' - '. ( ) FYROM . ' '.

    3.

    (% )

    - FYROMw Vt 35,6 24,0 54,8 25,6 77,3 O.Dy,w

    58,9 47,2 35,5 14,5 63,8 , vlo

    : (SAR) - BSS Gallup International, (6) SAR 2003.

    w -, panel, , . FYROM ; - . , , - -

  • . 151

    . , / FYROM, .

    , - - . : - -- , (Rose 1994,Howard 2002). , . -6 -, (Green 2002). , . . Dowley B.D.Siler , 6 . (Dowley & Siler 2002: 50024)., , - - (.., Tempest 1997, Elster et al.1998, Mishler & Rose 2000, Tismaneanu 2002, Giatzidis 2002). .

    5.

    , ; -. - . , , ( )

  • 152 6

    - , . , - .

    - , , . - - ' , - (Inglehart 1999). . - : , -, . , , , t -, - -.

    - -. ' ' ' ' (Offe 1999). , - , , - , -, , . - , - , - . , .

    ; . 2 ( -

  • 6 V6 6 153

    ), -6 - ' . , , -, , ; . . - - - - . - ' ' (, ). - ' , - .

    - . , . ' ', . , - - . 1989 , , 77 - (Warren 1999). ,, . , , CJ? , .

    . , , - , .

  • 154 6

    , , . -, - . , . -, , - - - (Warren 1999: 8). - ' -, .

    /' /' ( ) '' w( ). . , , , - , - . - '' w, ; ; , , , , , -. ' , - -. , , , ' (Warren1999: 12). , - . / , , - . , -

  • 6 6 6 155

    , -- -, - . , . , .( - ) .

    , - . ' ' . , ' . . , (Mansbridge 1999). - . ; , , .

    . - - ' ' (- ). - , , (Rose 1994: 29). , - - ' '. , - . , -

  • 156 6

    - (Skapska 1997: 158-159).

    . - ; , .. (Bechev and Andreev 2004). , .., ('Stabilization and Association Agreements') , , CARDS. , , - .. . , .

    6.

    - , . . , . , , . , - , . - , . (, ) -

  • 157

    . , - .

    , - ' . , , (, .) - ., ' ' . . , , , , - (. ' 2002 ' ' 2000' ., , PoLlack et al. 2004: 209, Malnar & Bernik2005: 2, 7, 8). - - - . , - .

    ( ) - ( ). , , , , ; -' , . , - -; , (.., ' ). , -

  • 158 6

    , -, , FYROM, -.

    , , - . , - , - - . - , - , , , , -. : , , ' , .

    , - . , - - - . , . : - - . .., . , .

    , . (2004). ' : - ', , 10: 34-47.

  • 6 V6 6 159

    , . (2004). ' - ', { , 10: 60-65.

    Bechev, D. & Svetlozar, . (2004). 'Top-down versus Bottom-up Aspects ofthe Institution Building Strategies n the Western Balkans', project. : www.eliamep.gr/3/4/wp.asp?pro-jectid=1&wpid=2

    , . (1997). 'Performances institutionnelles et traditions civiques enItalie. n relisant Robert Putnam', Revue franfaise de science politique, 47:234-247.

    Bourdieu, . (1984). Distnction: Social Critque of the Judgment of Taste.Cambridge : Harard University Press.

    Bourdieu, . (1989). noblesse d'etat: Grandes ecoLeset esprt de corps. Paris:Les 6ditions de minuit.

    Coleman, J. S. (1990). Foundations of Social Theory. Cambridge : HarardUniversity Press.

    Dowley, . . & Silver, . D. (2002)~ 'Social Capital, Ethnicity and Supportfor Democracy n the Post-Communist States', Europe-Asia Studes, 54:505-527.

    Elster, 1., Offe, C. & Preuss, U. . (1998). /nstitutonal Design in Post-Commu-nist Societes: Rebuilding the Ship ! Se, New ork: Cambridge U niversityPress.

    Fukuyama, F. (1995). Trust: The Socil Vltues nd the Cretion of Prosperity.New York: Free Press [. : , . ,: -. 1998].

    Ganev, G., Papazova, . & Dorosiev, R. (2004) 'Social Capital n the Balkans:Are Socio-demographic Factors Important? Can Policy Assumptions BeSupported?', project. :www.eliamep.g"/3/4/wp.asp?projectid= 1&wpid = 2

    Giatzidis, . (2002). An /ntroduction to Post-Colnmunist Bulgara: Politicl,Economic and Socl Trnsfom1tions, Manchester: Manchester UniversityPress.

    Green, . . (2002). 'Comparative Development of Post-Communist CiviISocieties' Europe-Asia Studies, 54: 455-471.

    Gropas, R. (2004). 'Functional Borders, SustainabIe Security and EU-BaIkanReIations', Southest EUlpean and Black Sea Studies, 4: 49-76.

    Haerpfer, C. W., Wallace, C. & Raiser, . (2005). 'Social' Capital and -

  • 160

    nomic Performance Post-Communlst Societies', Konlordos S.,., NetwDrks, Trust nd Socil Cpitl, Aldershot: Ashgate .

    . Howard, . (2002). 'The Weakness of Post-Communist Civil Society',Jourr,lof Democrcy, 13: 159-169.

    Inglehart, R. (1999). 'Trust, Well-being and Democracy' Warren . .,., Democra.cy and Trust, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

    , . (2004). ' ', , 10: 32-33.

    , . (2004). ' Alexis deTocqueville Robert D. Putnam: u u', , 10: 48-53.

    , ., Cook, . & Burt R. S., ., (2001). Social Capitl: Theoy Reserch. New York: Aldine de Gruyter.

    Malnar, . & Bernik, . (2005). 'Low SociaI Trust the Context of Tran-.sition'. 'Europe after Enlargement" - , 13-14 .

    Mansbridge, J. (1999). 'Altruistic ' Warren . ., ., Democrcynd Trust, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

    Mihaylova, D. (2004). Socil Cpital in Centrl nd Estern Europe, Centreior Policy Studies, Central European University, Budapest.

    Mishler W. & Rose, R. (2000). 'What Are the Origins of Political Trust?Testing Institutional and Cultural Theories in Post-Communist Societies'Comprtive Politcl Studies, 34: 30-62.

    Mungiu-Pippidi, . (2005). 'Deconstructing Balkan Particularism: The Am-biguous Social Capital of Southeastern Europe', Southest European andBlack Se Studies, 5: 49-68.

    Offe, C. (1999). 'How Can We Trust Our Fellow Citizens?' Warren .., ., Democrcy and Trust, Cambr.idge: Cambridge Vniversity Press.

    Ostrom, . (1994). 'Constituting Social Capital and Collective Action', Jour-nal ! Theoretical Politics, 6: 527-562.

    , . . (2001). ' , - ', -, 17: 141-173.

    Pollack, D., Jacobs, J., Mueller, . & Pickel, G. (2004). 'Democratic Values Central and Eastern ', . Insti-tute of Transformation Studies Frankfurt an der Oder. -: www.democraticaIues.eu.tf

  • 161

    Putnam, R. D. (1993). Making Democracy Work: Cvic Traditons Modern[. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

    Rose, R. (1994). 'Post-communism and the Problem of Trust', Joumal ofDemocracy, 5: 18-30.

    Skapska, G. (1997). 'Learning to be a Citizen: Cognitive and Ethical Aspectsof Post-Communist Society Transformation' Fine, R. & Raj, S., .,CI Society: Democrtic Perspectives, London: Frank Gass.

    Sotiropoulos, D. . (2002). 'From an Omnipresent and Strong to a Big andWeak State: Democratzation and State Reform Southeastern Europe', .Southest Europen nd Blck Sea Studies, 2: 63-74.

    Tempest, C. (1997). 'Myths from Eastern Europe and the Legend of theWest', Fine, R. & Raj, S., ., CI Society: Democrtic Perspectives,London: Frank Gass.

    Tismaneanu, V. (2002). 'Discomforts of Victory: Democracy, Liberal Valuesand Nationalism Post-Communist Europe', West Europen Politics, 25:81-100.

    Warren . . (1999). 'Introduction', Warren . ., ., Democrcy Trust, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.