Download - Architecture of planetary systems: HR8799 and Eridani · two dust rings gas giants in between" Eridani gap in the sub-mm indicates an outer planet inner planetesimal belt unstable

Transcript
Page 1: Architecture of planetary systems: HR8799 and Eridani · two dust rings gas giants in between" Eridani gap in the sub-mm indicates an outer planet inner planetesimal belt unstable

Architecture of planetary systems:HR 8799 and ε Eridani

Martin ReidemeisterA. V. Krivov1, T. Lohne1, S. Muller1, T. O. B. Schmidt1, S. Fiedler1,

C. C. Stark2 and J.-C. Augereau3

1 Astrophysikalisches Institut und Universitats-Sternwarte JenaSchillergaßchen 2-3, 07745 Jena

2 Department of Physics, University of MarylandBox 197, 082 Regents Drive, College Park, MD 20742-4111

3 Laboratoire d’Astrophysique de Grenoble, CNRS UMR 5571Universite Joseph Fourier, Grenoble, France

15.11.2010

M. Reidemeister et al. (AIU Jena) Architecture of planetary systems 15.11.2010 1 / 13

Page 2: Architecture of planetary systems: HR8799 and Eridani · two dust rings gas giants in between" Eridani gap in the sub-mm indicates an outer planet inner planetesimal belt unstable

Content

1 Introduction

2 HR 8799

3 ε Eridani

4 Summary

M. Reidemeister et al. (AIU Jena) Architecture of planetary systems 15.11.2010 2 / 13

Page 3: Architecture of planetary systems: HR8799 and Eridani · two dust rings gas giants in between" Eridani gap in the sub-mm indicates an outer planet inner planetesimal belt unstable

Introduction

DefinitionArchitecture of planetary system:

starplanet(s)dustplanetesimal belts(source of dust)

Motivationmultiple interactions betweendust, planetesimals and planetsconstrain planet masses,eccentricity, inclinationplanetesimals are remnants ofplanet formation

M. Reidemeister et al. (AIU Jena) Architecture of planetary systems 15.11.2010 3 / 13

Page 4: Architecture of planetary systems: HR8799 and Eridani · two dust rings gas giants in between" Eridani gap in the sub-mm indicates an outer planet inner planetesimal belt unstable

Introduction

DefinitionArchitecture of planetary system:

starplanet(s)dustplanetesimal belts(source of dust)

Motivationmultiple interactions betweendust, planetesimals and planetsconstrain planet masses,eccentricity, inclinationplanetesimals are remnants ofplanet formation

M. Reidemeister et al. (AIU Jena) Architecture of planetary systems 15.11.2010 3 / 13

Page 5: Architecture of planetary systems: HR8799 and Eridani · two dust rings gas giants in between" Eridani gap in the sub-mm indicates an outer planet inner planetesimal belt unstable

Content

1 Introduction

2 HR 8799

3 ε Eridani

4 Summary

M. Reidemeister et al. (AIU Jena) Architecture of planetary systems 15.11.2010 4 / 13

Page 6: Architecture of planetary systems: HR8799 and Eridani · two dust rings gas giants in between" Eridani gap in the sub-mm indicates an outer planet inner planetesimal belt unstable

HR 8799 – Introduction

ParametersA5 V star with d = 39.4 pcage of . 50 Myr Reidemeister et al. (2009)

(20 Myr up to 1 Gyr)γ Doradus (variable star)λ Bootis (metalpoor Pop. I)

Observationsstrong IR excess (IRAS, ISO)Sadakane&Nishida (1986), Zuckerman&Song (2004),

Moor et al. (2006), Rhee et al. (2007)

Spitzer/IRS spectrumJura et al. (2004), Chen et al. (2006)

3 directly imaged planetsat 68, 38 & 24 AUwith MP =5–13MJup

100

101

102

10310

−4

10−2

100

wavelength [µm]

flux

[Jy]

Marois et al. (2008)

M. Reidemeister et al. (AIU Jena) Architecture of planetary systems 15.11.2010 5 / 13

Page 7: Architecture of planetary systems: HR8799 and Eridani · two dust rings gas giants in between" Eridani gap in the sub-mm indicates an outer planet inner planetesimal belt unstable

HR 8799 – The planets

toE

arth

System' sangularmomentum

System' s

symmetry plane

Sky planeLine of nodes

N

E

W

i

Resultsinclination of 20–30◦

(rotational period: 13–30◦)rotation angle of 0–50◦

slipping in 1:2:4 resonance

2:1 b-c

2:1 c-d

duration of stability in years

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180

rotation angle [deg]

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

incl

inat

ion

angl

e [d

eg]

103

104

105

106

107

108

2:1 b-c

2:1 c-d

duration of stability in years

M. Reidemeister et al. (AIU Jena) Architecture of planetary systems 15.11.2010 6 / 13

Page 8: Architecture of planetary systems: HR8799 and Eridani · two dust rings gas giants in between" Eridani gap in the sub-mm indicates an outer planet inner planetesimal belt unstable

HR 8799 – The dust

100AU

d

cb

outer dust disk

outer ring ofplanetesimals

planetesimals

inner ring of

and dust

dust ringsouter ring & 100 AUMdust ≈ 4× 10−2M⊕

inner ring 2–10 AUMdust ≈ 10−5M⊕

101

102

10 100 1000

[mJy

]

λ [µm]

101

102

10 100 1000

[mJy

]

λ [µm]

ring dring cdring bcring bbest fit

101

102

10 100 1000

[mJy

]

λ [µm]

M. Reidemeister et al. (AIU Jena) Architecture of planetary systems 15.11.2010 7 / 13

Page 9: Architecture of planetary systems: HR8799 and Eridani · two dust rings gas giants in between" Eridani gap in the sub-mm indicates an outer planet inner planetesimal belt unstable

HR 8799

Stability

Dust mass

Ring position

Planetary mass

Inclination

Rotational period

Age

M. Reidemeister et al. (AIU Jena) Architecture of planetary systems 15.11.2010 8 / 13

Page 10: Architecture of planetary systems: HR8799 and Eridani · two dust rings gas giants in between" Eridani gap in the sub-mm indicates an outer planet inner planetesimal belt unstable

Content

1 Introduction

2 HR 8799

3 ε Eridani

4 Summary

M. Reidemeister et al. (AIU Jena) Architecture of planetary systems 15.11.2010 9 / 13

Page 11: Architecture of planetary systems: HR8799 and Eridani · two dust rings gas giants in between" Eridani gap in the sub-mm indicates an outer planet inner planetesimal belt unstable

ε Eridani

ParameterK2 V star at d = 3.2 pcage . 1 Gyr DiFolco et al. (2004)

SW: 30M� Wood et al. (2002)

“Kuiper belt” analog in sub-mmaround 65 AU Greaves et al. (1998, 2005)

assumed outer planetRV planet at 3.4 AU Hatzes et al. (2000)

A: e = 0.70 Benedict et al. (2006)

B: e = 0.25 Butler et al. (2006)

Spitzer/IRS spectrum indicateswarm dust at a few AU Backman et al. (2009)

“The cold origin of the warm dust”

M. Reidemeister et al. (AIU Jena) Architecture of planetary systems 15.11.2010 10 / 13

Page 12: Architecture of planetary systems: HR8799 and Eridani · two dust rings gas giants in between" Eridani gap in the sub-mm indicates an outer planet inner planetesimal belt unstable

ε Eridani

ParameterK2 V star at d = 3.2 pcage . 1 Gyr DiFolco et al. (2004)

SW: 30M� Wood et al. (2002)

“Kuiper belt” analog in sub-mmaround 65 AU Greaves et al. (1998, 2005)

assumed outer planetRV planet at 3.4 AU Hatzes et al. (2000)

A: e = 0.70 Benedict et al. (2006)

B: e = 0.25 Butler et al. (2006)

Spitzer/IRS spectrum indicateswarm dust at a few AU Backman et al. (2009)

outer ring (55-90AU)

oute

r planet

intermediate (10-55AU)

inner (<10AU)

planet 'A'planet 'B'

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

10 100 1000

exce

ss fl

ux [J

y]

wavelength [µm]

IRASMIPS

MIPS (SED)SHARC II

SCUBA

“The cold origin of the warm dust”

M. Reidemeister et al. (AIU Jena) Architecture of planetary systems 15.11.2010 10 / 13

Page 13: Architecture of planetary systems: HR8799 and Eridani · two dust rings gas giants in between" Eridani gap in the sub-mm indicates an outer planet inner planetesimal belt unstable

ε Eridani – ResultsSpectral energy distribution

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

10 100 1000

exce

ss f

lux [

Jy]

wavelength [µm]

Planet A: a=3.4AU, e=0.70

0-10AU, 0.05-1.42µm, q=3.010-90AU (ACE)

totalIRASMIPS

MIPS (SED)SHARC II

SCUBA

M. Reidemeister et al. (AIU Jena) Architecture of planetary systems 15.11.2010 11 / 13

Page 14: Architecture of planetary systems: HR8799 and Eridani · two dust rings gas giants in between" Eridani gap in the sub-mm indicates an outer planet inner planetesimal belt unstable

ε Eridani – ResultsSurface brightness profile

10-3

10-2

10-1

100

101

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40

su

rfa

ce

brig

htn

ess [

mJy/a

rcse

c2]

distance [arcsec]

24µm70µm

160µmSpitzer/MIPS

PSF

M. Reidemeister et al. (AIU Jena) Architecture of planetary systems 15.11.2010 12 / 13

Page 15: Architecture of planetary systems: HR8799 and Eridani · two dust rings gas giants in between" Eridani gap in the sub-mm indicates an outer planet inner planetesimal belt unstable

Summary

HR 8799young system (. 50 Myr)- planets with lower mass- high dust masssolar system like architecture:two dust ringsgas giants in between

ε Eridanigap in the sub-mm indicatesan outer planetinner planetesimal beltunstablemassive dust disk (10−3M⊕)but transport dominateddust can stem from outer ringand supply the inner system

M. Reidemeister et al. (AIU Jena) Architecture of planetary systems 15.11.2010 13 / 13