White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey...

46
White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey: Exploring the Tail of the Distributions Pierre Bergeron Université de Montréal Sirius B

Transcript of White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey...

Page 1: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main

White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey:Exploring the Tail of the Distributions

Pierre BergeronUniversité de Montréal

Sirius B

Page 2: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main

Some WD properties :

Enpoint of stellar evolutionfor ~ 95 % of all stars

M ~ 0.6 M⊙

R ~ 0.01 R ⊙

ρ ~ 106 ρ⊙

log g ~ 8 ( ʘ = 4.4)

Hot (Teff ~200,000 K) and young

Cool (4000 K) and old

Page 3: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main
Page 4: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main

A brief history of SDSS WDs

#WDs Area• EDR: Harris et al. 2003 269 190º

2

• DR1: Kleinman et al. 2004 2551 2100º2

• DR3: Harris et al. 2006 6000 RPM LF• DR4: Eisenstein et al. 2006 9316 4783º

2

• DR6: Kleinman et al. 13000 (+ counting…) 6860º2

McCook & Sion (1999) : 2249 WDs i SDSS (2008) : 15300 WDs

Page 5: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main
Page 6: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main

SDSS Early Data Release

Spectra dominatedby H Balmer lines

Page 7: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main

SDSS Early Data Release

Spectra dominated by He I (DB) and He II (DO) lines

Page 8: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main

SDSS Early Data Release

Spectra dominated by C Ilines or C2 Swan bands

Page 9: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main
Page 10: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main

DA starTeff=25,700 K log g=7.98

DB starTeff=19,500 K log g=8.22

Page 11: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main

7167 DA stars 507 DB stars

Page 12: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main
Page 13: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main

~ 6000 stars

43 stars

348 stars

UV color excess Proper motion

Finite ageof the Galaxy

Page 14: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main

White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey:Exploring the Tail of the Distributions

Pierre BergeronUniversité de Montréal

Sirius B

Page 15: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main

White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey:

Pierre BergeronUniversité de Montréal

Sirius B

Exploring the Tail of the Distributions

• Ultracool white dwarfs

• DB white dwarfs in the «DB gap»

• DQ white dwarfs

Page 16: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main

Ultracool White Dwarfs

Page 17: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main

Data from Bergeron, Leggett, & Ruiz

(2001, ApJS)

Page 18: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main

H– b-f / f-f

H2– f-f

H2 collisioninduced absorption

Main opacity sources at the photosphere of a cool white dwarf

Page 19: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main
Page 20: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main

Ultracool (old) white dwarfs become

increasingly bluer !!!

Data from Bergeron, Leggett, & Ruiz

(2001, ApJS)

Page 21: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main
Page 22: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main
Page 23: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main
Page 24: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main

Gates et al. (2004) Harris et al. (2008)

Page 25: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main
Page 26: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main

DB white dwarfs in the «DB gap»

Page 27: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main

He

H

DO DA

Photosphere

Requires only10-16

Mi ofhydrogen

DB?

Page 28: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main

PhotosphereHe II conv

He I conv

Hydrogen atmosphere

DA DB

«convective dilution»

Page 29: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main
Page 30: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main

SDSS MMT

Page 31: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main

There are DB stars in the gap !

Page 32: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main

He

H

Photosphere

No hydrogen left after the post-AGB phase !

Page 33: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main

Werner & Herwig (2006)“Born-Again scenario”

Page 34: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main

DQ white dwarfs

Page 35: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main

Helium convection zone

Carbon core (diffusion tail)

Carbon in DQ stars is being dredged up from the core

The origin of carbon in DQ stars

Page 36: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main

Spectroscopicallyinvisible

Page 37: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main
Page 38: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main
Page 39: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main

Pure Helium log C/He = 0 log C/He = 1 Pure Carbon

Teff = 22,000 K log g = 8

He I λ4471

Courtesy of Patrick Dufour (Steward Observatory)

Page 40: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main
Page 41: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main
Page 42: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main
Page 43: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main

Werner & Herwig (2006)“Born-Again scenario”

Page 44: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main

A new chapter in white dwarf asteroseismology

Page 45: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main
Page 46: White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey ...sdss2008.uchicago.edu/depot/bergeron-pierre.pdf · Teff=25,700 K log g=7.98 DB star Teff=19,500 K log g=8.22. 7167 DA ... Main