TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection...

40
TeV Astrophysics with HAWC Gus Sinnis Los Alamos National Laboratory

Transcript of TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection...

Page 1: TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection Small Aperture/Low Duty Cycle Study known sources Deep surveys of limited regions Source

TeV Astrophysics with HAWCGus Sinnis

Los Alamos National Laboratory

Page 2: TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection Small Aperture/Low Duty Cycle Study known sources Deep surveys of limited regions Source

PACIFIC 2014G. Sinnis

The Electromagnetic Spectrum

103 10 10-1 10-3 10-5 10-7 10-9 10-11 10-13 10-15 10-17 10-19 10-21

Radio μWave IR Opt

ical

UV X-Ray

Gamma Ray

MeV GeV TeV

CMBPulsarsRadio Galaxies

Stars, galaxiesDark Energy

Compact objectsParticle

acceleration

Particle acceleration, Gamma Ray Bursts, Active Galaxies, Cosmic Ray Origins, Lorentz Invariance,

Dark Matter

2

Page 3: TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection Small Aperture/Low Duty Cycle Study known sources Deep surveys of limited regions Source

G. Sinnis PACIFIC 2014

Goals of TeV Astrophysics• Cosmic Particle Acceleration

- Origin of cosmic rays

- Understand astrophysical jets and extreme environments

• Cosmology

- Measure the extragalactic background light

- Sum of all UV, optical, and infrared radiation emitted since the Big Bang

• Search for new physics

- Dark matter (indirect detection of annihilation or decay products)

‣ Direct detection of Q-Balls

- Measure intergalactic magnetic fields (origins in primordial field)

- Search for violations of Lorentz invariance

3

Page 4: TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection Small Aperture/Low Duty Cycle Study known sources Deep surveys of limited regions Source

PACIFIC 2014G. Sinnis

Gamma Ray TelescopesAtmospheric Cherenkov Telescopes

H.E.S.S./VERITAS/MAGICEAS Arrays

Milagro/Tibet/ARGO

50 GeV - 100 TeVLarge Area

Excellent background rejectionSmall Aperture/Low Duty Cycle

Study known sourcesDeep surveys of limited regionsSource morphology (SNRs)Fast transients (AGN flares)

Sky survey & monitoringExtended SourcesTransients (GRBs, AGN flares)Highest Energies (>10 TeV)

100 GeV - 100 TeVLarge Area

Good background rejectionLarge Aperture & Duty Cycle

4

Page 5: TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection Small Aperture/Low Duty Cycle Study known sources Deep surveys of limited regions Source

PACIFIC 2014G. Sinnis

Extensive Air Showers

F. Schmidt, "CORSIKA Shower Images", http://www.ast.leeds.ac.uk/~fs/showerimages.html

• γ showers almost purely e-m and relatively compact• Hadronic showers

contain muons (~30/TeV) • Both have core of

energetic particles• Ground-based VHE

telescopes must distinguish protons from photons

5

1 TeVgamma ray

5 km4 km

4 km

1 TeVproton

5 km

Page 6: TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection Small Aperture/Low Duty Cycle Study known sources Deep surveys of limited regions Source

PACIFIC 2014G. Sinnis

Extensive Air Shower Arrays

Tibet ASγ

200m

200m

6

Page 7: TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection Small Aperture/Low Duty Cycle Study known sources Deep surveys of limited regions Source

PACIFIC 2014G. Sinnis

Extensive Air Shower Arrays

Tibet ASγ

200m

200m

6

Page 8: TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection Small Aperture/Low Duty Cycle Study known sources Deep surveys of limited regions Source

PACIFIC 2014G. Sinnis

Extensive Air Shower Arrays

Tibet ASγ

200m

200m

Milagro

6

Page 9: TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection Small Aperture/Low Duty Cycle Study known sources Deep surveys of limited regions Source

PACIFIC 2014G. Sinnis

Extensive Air Shower Arrays

Tibet ASγ

200m

200m

Milagro

6

Page 10: TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection Small Aperture/Low Duty Cycle Study known sources Deep surveys of limited regions Source

PACIFIC 2014G. Sinnis

Extensive Air Shower Arrays

Tibet ASγ

200m

200m

Milagro

6

• Detect particle that survive to ground level

• Scintillation detector arrays sparsely instrument the ground <2% coverage

• Water detectors (or RPC carpet) can densely sample the shower particles (~50% particles detected)

• Water will also convert gamma rays to electrons/positrons (gamma rays dominate the particles on ground ~6:1)

• Deep water detector (≳4m) can serve as muon detector

Page 11: TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection Small Aperture/Low Duty Cycle Study known sources Deep surveys of limited regions Source

PACIFIC 2014G. Sinnis

Angular and Energy Reconstruction

ARGO

ARGO

Primary energy via energy at ground(shower fluctuations dominate

resolution ~40%)

Direction via timing(~ns timing yields 0.2o-1o

resolution)

7

Page 12: TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection Small Aperture/Low Duty Cycle Study known sources Deep surveys of limited regions Source

PACIFIC 2014G. Sinnis

Background Rejectionpr

oton

sga

mm

a ra

ys 30 GeV 70 GeV 230 GeV

20 GeV 70 GeV 270 GeV

300m

300m

8

Page 13: TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection Small Aperture/Low Duty Cycle Study known sources Deep surveys of limited regions Source

G. Sinnis PACIFIC 2014

Galactic Gamma-Ray Sources38 PWN/PSR30 UNID13 SN Shell9 SNR/Mol. Cloud8 binaries4 massive star clusters2 Star Forming Regions1 Cataclysmic Variable1 Globular Cluster

9

PWN

SNR

X-Ray Binary

Globular Clusters

Terzan 5Crab Nebula

TychoSNR/Molecular Clouds

IC 443

Page 14: TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection Small Aperture/Low Duty Cycle Study known sources Deep surveys of limited regions Source

PACIFIC 2014G. Sinnis

Pulsar Wind Nebulae

10

Page 15: TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection Small Aperture/Low Duty Cycle Study known sources Deep surveys of limited regions Source

PACIFIC 2014G. Sinnis

Pulsar Wind Nebulae

• Most common Galactic source of TeV gamma rays• Inject e+e- into ISM- Potential background for dark matter searches

10

Page 16: TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection Small Aperture/Low Duty Cycle Study known sources Deep surveys of limited regions Source

PACIFIC 2014G. Sinnis

Pulsar Wind Nebulae

Gaensler & Slane 2006

• Rapidly spinning neutron star powers a cold relativistic electron-positron wind

•Wind termination shock accelerates e+e-

• Inverse Compton reactions lead to production of VHE gamma rays

•Over time nebula expands, magnetic field weakens, and e+e-

are released into the ISM

11

Page 17: TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection Small Aperture/Low Duty Cycle Study known sources Deep surveys of limited regions Source

PACIFIC 2014G. Sinnis

Indirect Dark Matter Detection• Neutralino annihilation to quarks,

leptons, and bosons (W, Z) yields gamma rays, neutrinos, and cosmic rays (positrons)

• Search for gamma ray signal with DM energy spectrum in regions with large M/L and no/low (or understood) astrophysical backgrounds

- Dwarf spheroidal galaxies, Galaxy Clusters, Galactic Center, Andromeda

from theastronomist

dφdEdΩ

= 〈σ v〉iM χ

2i∑ dNγ ,i

dEρ2 (r)dl(Ψ)

los∫

12

Page 18: TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection Small Aperture/Low Duty Cycle Study known sources Deep surveys of limited regions Source

PACIFIC 2014G. Sinnis

PWN: Positron Generators

• Geminga (~300,000 yrs at ~200 pc) and Monogem (100,000 yrs at ~300 pc) are good candidates• Milagro detected an extended gamma ray source (3o) coincident with the Geminga pulsar (~1032

ergs/sec) at ~20 TeV. Most likely seeing the PWN• HAWC will detect Geminga at ~50σ - measure energy spectrum and map the region to

understand electron diffusion

13

10 100 1000Energy [GeV]

0.01

0.1

Posi

tron

Frac

tion

PamelaFermiAMSMonogemGemingaBackground (Galprop)

Linden & Profumo arXiv:1304.1791

10 pc

Milagro ~20 TeV

Geminga

Page 19: TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection Small Aperture/Low Duty Cycle Study known sources Deep surveys of limited regions Source

PACIFIC 2014G. Sinnis

HAWC DM Sensitivity

14

HAWC has sensitivity to TeV mass DMWe can search for undiscovered high M/L satellites

w/Sommerfeld Enhancement

5σ 5-yr sensitivity

Page 20: TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection Small Aperture/Low Duty Cycle Study known sources Deep surveys of limited regions Source

PACIFIC 2014G. Sinnis

Extragalactic Gamma Rays

15

Page 21: TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection Small Aperture/Low Duty Cycle Study known sources Deep surveys of limited regions Source

PACIFIC 2014G. Sinnis

Extragalactic Gamma Rays

• Active Galaxies (57 detected in VHE band)

• Gamma Ray Bursts (not yet detected from ground)

- Extragalactic Background Light

- Primordial Magnetic Fields

- Axion-like Particle Searches

- Lorentz Invariance Violation

15

Page 22: TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection Small Aperture/Low Duty Cycle Study known sources Deep surveys of limited regions Source

G. Sinnis PACIFIC 2014

AGN Spectral Energy Distribution

16

eV MeV GeV TeV

X-Ray synchrotron

VHE inverse ComptonSynchrotron

Inverse Compton

keV GeV TeV

Page 23: TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection Small Aperture/Low Duty Cycle Study known sources Deep surveys of limited regions Source

PACIFIC 2014G. Sinnis

The EBL• The sum of all UV, optical, and IR

radiation emitted over the history of the universe

• Main contributions from stars and light re-radiated by dust

• Direct measurement difficult due to local backgrounds (zodiacal light)

• Gamma-ray absorption measurements are the best way to measure EBL

• EBL is useful tool for probing other physics

- Axion-like particles

- UHECR accelerators

- IGMFs

wavelength (microns)1 TeV 10 TeV 100 TeV

17

Page 24: TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection Small Aperture/Low Duty Cycle Study known sources Deep surveys of limited regions Source

PACIFIC 2014G. Sinnis

The EBL• The sum of all UV, optical, and IR

radiation emitted over the history of the universe

• Main contributions from stars and light re-radiated by dust

• Direct measurement difficult due to local backgrounds (zodiacal light)

• Gamma-ray absorption measurements are the best way to measure EBL

• EBL is useful tool for probing other physics

- Axion-like particles

- UHECR accelerators

- IGMFs

wavelength (microns)1 TeV 10 TeV 100 TeV

17

z=0.1

z=0.3

z=0.5

z=1.0

z=0.01

Dwek & Krennrich 2012

Page 25: TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection Small Aperture/Low Duty Cycle Study known sources Deep surveys of limited regions Source

PACIFIC 2014G. Sinnis

EBL Measurements

z~.05

z=0.11z~0.18

H.E.S.S. results

• H.E.S.S. has measured the EBL from 2~1-10 microns• Fermi has measured the EBL below 0.2 micron (3±1 nW m-2 sr-1 at z=1)• These values are close to the lower bounds set by Galaxy counts• Large star formation rates at the end of the cosmic dark ages excluded

18

Page 26: TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection Small Aperture/Low Duty Cycle Study known sources Deep surveys of limited regions Source

PACIFIC 2014G. Sinnis 19

Some Tension at High Opacity

Horns & Meyer 2012

• Possible explanations- Cascades from UHECR (if AGN are UHECR sources)- Evidence of photon/ALP mixing (~neV axion-like particle)• Need to increase AGN sample size• Need to search for VHE transients from distant sources (z>0.1)

Φint (E) = φobs (E)eτ (E, z )

• Fit spectra in optically thin regime (τ<1)• Test sample τ>2• Observe ~4σ hardening of

intrinsic spectra in optically thick regime

Page 27: TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection Small Aperture/Low Duty Cycle Study known sources Deep surveys of limited regions Source

PACIFIC 2014G. Sinnis

AGN Transients•HAWC will monitor all AGN in our field-

of-view every day (8 sr)

• Search for high redshift transient emission

- probe EBL absorption anomalies

•Alert other observatories of flaring activity

- search for inter galactic magnetic fields

20

3 min

5 hr

1992 1995 2000 2006

HAWC 1-day sensitivity

HAWC Horizon7236 Quasars

Hewitt & Burbidge 1993

Page 28: TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection Small Aperture/Low Duty Cycle Study known sources Deep surveys of limited regions Source

PACIFIC 2014G. Sinnis

• Sierra Negra, Mexico (19o north, 97o west)• High elevation (4100m)• ~22,000 m2 area (also muon detector)• ~10-15x more sensitive than Milagro

21

HAWC

Page 29: TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection Small Aperture/Low Duty Cycle Study known sources Deep surveys of limited regions Source

G. Sinnis PACIFIC 2014

HAWC Collaboration

Instituto Nacional de Astrofísica Óptica y Electrónica (INAOE)Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México (UNAM)Benemérita Universidad AutónomaUniversidad Autónoma de ChiapasUniversidad Autónoma del Estado de HidalgoUniversidad de GuadalajaraUniversidad Michoacana de San Nicolás de HidalgoCentro de Investigacion y de Estudios AvanzadosUniversidad de Guanajuato

Los Alamos National Laboratory University of Maryland University of Wisconsin University of Utah Univ. of California, Irvine Michigan State UniversityGeorge Mason University University of New Hampshire Penn State UniversityUniversity of New Mexico Michigan Technological University NASA/Goddard Georgia Institute of Technology University of Alabama Colorado State University UC Santa Cruz

22

Page 30: TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection Small Aperture/Low Duty Cycle Study known sources Deep surveys of limited regions Source

PACIFIC 2014G. Sinnis

HAWC Design

7.3

4.5

• 300 steel tanks

• 4 PMTs/tank

• No hardware trigger

- all hits (1/4 PE threshold)

- software trigger

- ~500 MBytes/sec

• Retain all data for 24 hrs (40 TB)

• Reconstructed data ~600 TB/yr

23

Page 31: TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection Small Aperture/Low Duty Cycle Study known sources Deep surveys of limited regions Source

PACIFIC 2014G. Sinnis

HAWC Design

7.3

4.5

• 300 steel tanks

• 4 PMTs/tank

• No hardware trigger

- all hits (1/4 PE threshold)

- software trigger

- ~500 MBytes/sec

• Retain all data for 24 hrs (40 TB)

• Reconstructed data ~600 TB/yr

8” PMTs (Milagro)10” HQE PMT

23

Page 32: TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection Small Aperture/Low Duty Cycle Study known sources Deep surveys of limited regions Source

PACIFIC 2014G. Sinnis

HAWC Event

24

Page 33: TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection Small Aperture/Low Duty Cycle Study known sources Deep surveys of limited regions Source

PACIFIC 2014G. Sinnis

HAWC Event

24

Page 34: TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection Small Aperture/Low Duty Cycle Study known sources Deep surveys of limited regions Source

PACIFIC 2014G. Sinnis

Moon Shadow

• Moon blocks cosmic rays

• Good calibration source

- angular resolution

- energy scale (earth as magnetic spectrometer)

- Simulation predicts Emed ~ 1.6 TeV (protons)

- Expect 1o deflection for 1.6 TeV protons

- Observe 1.04o ± 0.11o

25

Page 35: TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection Small Aperture/Low Duty Cycle Study known sources Deep surveys of limited regions Source

PACIFIC 2014G. Sinnis

HAWC-111 Sky

26

Mrk 421

Crab

Mrk 501

Page 36: TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection Small Aperture/Low Duty Cycle Study known sources Deep surveys of limited regions Source

PACIFIC 2014G. Sinnis

HAWC-111 Sky

26

Mrk 421

Crab

Mrk 501

Page 37: TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection Small Aperture/Low Duty Cycle Study known sources Deep surveys of limited regions Source

PACIFIC 2014G. Sinnis

HAWC-111 Sky

26

Mrk 421

Crab

Mrk 501

Cygnus Region Inner Galaxy

Page 38: TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection Small Aperture/Low Duty Cycle Study known sources Deep surveys of limited regions Source

G. Sinnis PACIFIC 2014

The Inner Galaxy

27

Page 39: TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection Small Aperture/Low Duty Cycle Study known sources Deep surveys of limited regions Source

G. Sinnis PACIFIC 2014

The Inner Galaxy

27

W41 (SNR) HESS J1834-087

G22.7 (SNR) HESS J1832-093

PWN HESS J1831-098

UNID HESS J1837-069UNID HESS J1841-055UNID HESS J1843-033PWN HESS J1846-029UNID HESS J1857+026 UNID HESS J1858+020

UNID MGRO J1908+06

A complex region supernova remnants, molecular clouds, diffuse emission, PWN, ...

Need to better understand instrument response to disentangle physics

Page 40: TeV Astrophysics with HAWC - UCLA · 50 GeV - 100 TeV Large Area Excellent background rejection Small Aperture/Low Duty Cycle Study known sources Deep surveys of limited regions Source

PACIFIC 2014G. Sinnis

Summary• Complementarity of all-sky and pointed instruments

• Now have ~150 sources in the TeV band

- Large diversity of source classes

- Have begun to probe fundamental physics: Dark Matter, EBL, IGMF, & Lorentz invariance violation

• HAWC is now operating with 111 tanks (~5x more sensitive than Milagro/ARGO)

• Already seeing objects undetected by Milagro

• Complete in March 2015 (300 tanks)

• Sky survey (~8 sr) in the TeV regime to 30 mCrab

28