Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith...

46
Scintillation Detectors Introduction Components Scintillator Light Guides Photomultiplier Tubes Formalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series

Transcript of Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith...

Page 1: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Scintillation Detectors

IntroductionComponents

ScintillatorLight GuidesPhotomultiplier Tubes

Formalism/ElectronicsTiming Resolution

Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series

Page 2: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

B field ~ 5/3 T

R = 3m

L = ½ π R = 4.71 m

p = 0.3 B R = 1.5 GeV/c

tπ = L/βπc = 15.77 ns

tΚ = L/βΚc = 16.53 ns

∆tπK = 0.76 ns

Experiment basics

βπ = p/√p2+mπ2 = 0.9957

βΚ = p/√p2+mΚ2 = 0.9496

Particle Identification by time-of-flight (TOF) requiresMeasurements with accuracies of ~ 0.1 ns

Page 3: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Measure the Flight Time between two Scintillators

400 cm

100 cm

300 cm

20 cmDisc

DiscTD

CStart

Stop

Particle Trajectory450 ns

Page 4: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Measure the Flight Time between two Scintillators

400 cm

100 cm

300 cm

20 cmDisc

DiscTD

CStart

Stop

Particle Trajectory450 ns

Page 5: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Propagation velocities

c = 30 cm/ns

vscint = c/n = 20 cm/ns

veff = 16 cm/ns

vpmt = 0.6 cm/ns

vcable = 20 cm/ns

∆t ~ 0.1 ns∆x ~ 3 cm

Page 6: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

TOF scintillators stacked for shipment

Page 7: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

CLAS detector open for repairs

Page 8: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

CLAS detector with FC pulled apart

Page 9: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Start counter assembly

Page 10: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Scintillator types

Organic

LiquidEconomicalmessy

SolidFast decay timelong attenuation lengthEmission spectra

Inorganic

AnthraceneUnused standard

NaI, CsIExcellent γ resolutionSlow decay time

BGOHigh density, compact

Page 11: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Photocathode spectral response

Page 12: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Scintillator thickness

Minimizing material vs. signal/background

CLAS TOF: 5 cm thickPenetrating particles (e.g. pions) loose 10 MeV

Start counter: 0.3 cm thickPenetrating particles loose 0.6 MeVPhotons, e+e− backgrounds ~ 1MeV contribute substantially to count rate

Thresholds may eliminate these in TOF

Page 13: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Light guides

GoalsMatch (rectangular) scintillator to (circular) pmtOptimize light collection for applications

TypesPlasticAirNone“Winston” shapes

Page 14: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Reflective/Refractive boundaries

acrylicScintillatorn = 1.58

PMT glassn = 1.5

Page 15: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Reflective/Refractive boundaries

Air withreflectiveboundary

Scintillatorn = 1.58

PMT glassn = 1.5

%5411 2

−≈⎟⎠⎞

⎜⎝⎛+−

=nnRair

(reflectance at normal incidence)

Page 16: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Reflective/Refractive boundaries

Scintillatorn = 1.58

PMT glassn = 1.5

air

Page 17: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Reflective/Refractive boundaries

acrylicScintillatorn = 1.58

PMT glassn = 1.5

Large-angle ray lost

Acceptance of incident rays at fixed angle depends on position at the exit face of the scintillator

Page 18: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Winston Cones - geometry

Page 19: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Winston Cone - acceptance

Page 20: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Photomultiplier tube, sensitive light meter Gain ~ 106 - 107

Electrodes

Photocathode Dynodes

Anode

γe−

56 AVP pmt

Page 21: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Window Transmittance

Page 22: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Voltage dividers

Equal voltage stepsMaximum gain

Progressive, higher voltage near anodeExcellent linearity, limited gain

Time optimized, higher voltage at cathodeGood gain, fast response

ZenersStabilize voltages independent of gain

Decoupling capacitors“reservoirs” of charge during pulsed operation

Page 23: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Voltage Dividersd1 d2 d3 dNdN-1dN-2

akg

4 2.5 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

16.5

RL

+HV−HV

Equal Steps – Max Gain

4 2.5 1 1 1 1 1 1 1.4 1.6 3 2.5

21

RL

Intermediate

6 2.5 1 1.25 1.5 1.5 1.75 2.5 3.5 4.5 8 10

44

RL

Progressive

Timing Linearity

Page 24: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

VoltageDivider

Active componentsto minimize changesto timing and rate capability with HV

Capacitors for increasedlinearity in pulsed applications

Page 25: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

High voltage

Positive (cathode at ground)low noise, capacitative coupling

NegativeAnode at ground (no HV on signal)

No (high) voltageCockcroft-Walton bases

Page 26: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Effect of magnetic field on pmt

Page 27: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Housing

Page 28: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Compact UNH divider design

Page 29: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Electrostatics near cathode at −HV

Stable performance with negative high voltage is achieved byEliminating potential gradients in the vicinity of the photocathode.The electrostatic shielding and the can of the crystal are bothMaintained at cathode potential by this arrangement.

Page 30: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Dark counts

Solid : Sea level

Dashed: 30 m underground

Thermal Noise

After-pulsing andGlass radioactivity

Cosmic rays

Page 31: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Signal for passing tracks

Page 32: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Single photoelectron signal

Page 33: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Pulse distortion in cable

Page 34: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Electronics

trigger

dynode

Measure timeMeasure pulse height

anode

Page 35: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Time-walk corrections

Page 36: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Formalism: Measure time and position

PL PR

TL TRX=0 XX=−L/2 X=+L/2

effLL vxTT /0 += effRR vxTT /0 −=

)()( 0021

21

RLRLave TTTTT +=+= Mean is independent of x!

[ ] )(2

)()(2

00RL

effRLRL

eff TTv

TTTTv

x −→−−−=

Page 37: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

From single-photoelectron timing to counter resolutionThe uncertainty in determining the passage of a particlethrough a scintillator has a statistical component, dependingon the number of photoelectrons Npe that create the pulse.

)2/exp()2/()(

2212

0 λσσ

σσLNLns

pe

PTOF −⋅

⋅++= 1000≈peN

ns062.00 =σ Intrinsic timing of electronic circuits

ns1.21 =σ

cmnsP /0118.0=σ

)15(36.0134 counterscmLcm ⋅+=λ)22(430 counterscmcm=λ

Combined scintillator and pmt response

Average path length variations in scintillator

SinglePhotoelectronResponse }

Note: Parameters for CLAS

Page 38: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Average time resolution

CLAS in Hall B

Page 39: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Formalism: Measure energy loss

PL PR

TL TRX=0 XX=−L/2 X=+L/2

λ/0 xLL ePP −= λ/0 x

RR ePP =

00RLRL PPPPEnergy ⋅=⋅=

Geometric mean is independent of x!

Page 40: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Energy deposited in scintillator

Page 41: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

UncertaintiesTiming

Assume that one pmt measures a time with uncertainty δt

Mass Resolution

2~

21 22 tttt RLave

δδδδ +=

2~)

21( 22 tvttvx effRLeff

δδδδ ⋅+⋅=

γEm = 2

2

2222 1)1( pEm ⎟

⎟⎠

⎞⎜⎜⎝

⎛ −=−=→

βββ

224

2

⎟⎟⎠

⎞⎜⎜⎝

⎛+⎟⎟

⎞⎜⎜⎝

⎛=⎟

⎠⎞

⎜⎝⎛

pp

mm δ

βδβγδ

Page 42: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Integral magnetic shield

Page 43: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Example: Kaon mass resolution by TOF

cGeVPK /1= GeVEK 116.11495.0 2 =+=

896.0=⎟⎟⎠

⎞⎜⎜⎝

⎛=

K

KK E

Pβ 26.2=⎟⎟

⎞⎜⎜⎝

⎛=

K

KK m

For a flight path of d = 500 cm, nsnscm

cmt 6.18/30896.0

500=⎟⎟

⎞⎜⎜⎝

⎛⋅

=

nst 15.0=δ 01.0=⎟⎟⎠

⎞⎜⎜⎝

⎛ppδ

Assume

( ) 222

42

042.001.06.18

15.026.2 =+⎟⎠⎞

⎜⎝⎛=⎟

⎠⎞

⎜⎝⎛

mmδ MeVmK 21~δ→

⎟⎟⎠

⎞⎜⎜⎝

⎛∞⎯⎯⎯ →⎯⎟

⎠⎞

⎜⎝⎛

∞→ βδβδ

γfixedfor

mm

2Note:

Page 44: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Velocity vs. momentum

π+

K+

p

Page 45: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Summary

Scintillator counters have a few simple components

Systems are built out of these countersFast response allows for accurate timing

The time resolution required for particle identification is the result of the time response of individual components scaled by √Npe

Page 46: Scintillation Detectors - Home | Jefferson LabFormalism/Electronics Timing Resolution Elton Smith JLab 2006 Detector/Computer Summer Lecture Series Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Elton Smith / Scintillation Detectors

Magnetic fields