Science and nonsense in the martial arts NYC Skeptics SkeptiCamp 2010 John Rennie NYC Skeptics...

10
Science and nonsense Science and nonsense in the martial arts in the martial arts NYC Skeptics SkeptiCamp 2010 John Rennie

Transcript of Science and nonsense in the martial arts NYC Skeptics SkeptiCamp 2010 John Rennie NYC Skeptics...

Page 1: Science and nonsense in the martial arts NYC Skeptics SkeptiCamp 2010 John Rennie NYC Skeptics SkeptiCamp 2010 John Rennie.

Science and nonsense in Science and nonsense in the martial artsthe martial arts

Science and nonsense in Science and nonsense in the martial artsthe martial artsNYC Skeptics SkeptiCamp 2010

John Rennie

NYC Skeptics SkeptiCamp 2010John Rennie

Page 2: Science and nonsense in the martial arts NYC Skeptics SkeptiCamp 2010 John Rennie NYC Skeptics SkeptiCamp 2010 John Rennie.
Page 3: Science and nonsense in the martial arts NYC Skeptics SkeptiCamp 2010 John Rennie NYC Skeptics SkeptiCamp 2010 John Rennie.
Page 4: Science and nonsense in the martial arts NYC Skeptics SkeptiCamp 2010 John Rennie NYC Skeptics SkeptiCamp 2010 John Rennie.
Page 5: Science and nonsense in the martial arts NYC Skeptics SkeptiCamp 2010 John Rennie NYC Skeptics SkeptiCamp 2010 John Rennie.

V = volume of block

δ= modulus of rupture ≈ stress material can handle

E = modulus of elasticity ≈ stiffness

V = volume of block

δ= modulus of rupture ≈ stress material can handle

E = modulus of elasticity ≈ stiffness

Critical energy to break a block = Vδ2/2ECritical energy to break a block = Vδ2/2E

Page 6: Science and nonsense in the martial arts NYC Skeptics SkeptiCamp 2010 John Rennie NYC Skeptics SkeptiCamp 2010 John Rennie.
Page 7: Science and nonsense in the martial arts NYC Skeptics SkeptiCamp 2010 John Rennie NYC Skeptics SkeptiCamp 2010 John Rennie.
Page 8: Science and nonsense in the martial arts NYC Skeptics SkeptiCamp 2010 John Rennie NYC Skeptics SkeptiCamp 2010 John Rennie.

F = ∆mv/∆t = (45 kg-m/s)/0.004 s ≈ 104 N F = ∆mv/∆t = (45 kg-m/s)/0.004 s ≈ 104 N

= 2,250 lbs.= 2,250 lbs.

Page 9: Science and nonsense in the martial arts NYC Skeptics SkeptiCamp 2010 John Rennie NYC Skeptics SkeptiCamp 2010 John Rennie.

Dim mak: death touch techniques?Dim mak: death touch techniques?

Page 10: Science and nonsense in the martial arts NYC Skeptics SkeptiCamp 2010 John Rennie NYC Skeptics SkeptiCamp 2010 John Rennie.