Producons*and*decays*of* charmed*baryons...Charmed baryons Whatdo!we!expectfor!heavy!quarks? • Qqq...

31
λ ρ Produc’ons and decays of charmed baryons Nov.30 Dec.1, 2014 Progress on JPARC hadron 1 Atsushi Hosaka, RCNP, Osaka Progress on JPARC hadron physics in 2014, JPARC Contents 1. Introduction -- Exotics with heavy quarks 2. Charmed baryons: to probe ρλ modes diquark 3. Productions 4. Decays With Noumi, Shirotori, Kim, Sadato, Yoshida, Oka, Hiyama Prog. Theor. Exp. Phys. (2014) 103D01

Transcript of Producons*and*decays*of* charmed*baryons...Charmed baryons Whatdo!we!expectfor!heavy!quarks? • Qqq...

Page 1: Producons*and*decays*of* charmed*baryons...Charmed baryons Whatdo!we!expectfor!heavy!quarks? • Qqq distinguishes the two modes of λ and ρ! Diquark motions in the baryon mass spectrum!!

λ

ρ

Produc'ons  and  decays  of  charmed  baryons  

Nov.30  -­‐-­‐  Dec.1,  2014 Progress  on  J-­‐PARC  hadron 1

Atsushi  Hosaka,      RCNP,  Osaka    Progress  on  J-­‐PARC  hadron  physics  in  2014,  J-­‐PARC  

Contents 1. Introduction -- Exotics with heavy quarks 2. Charmed baryons: to probe ρλ modes diquark 3. Productions 4. Decays

With Noumi, Shirotori, Kim, Sadato, Yoshida, Oka, Hiyama Prog.  Theor.  Exp.  Phys.  (2014)  103D01  

Page 2: Producons*and*decays*of* charmed*baryons...Charmed baryons Whatdo!we!expectfor!heavy!quarks? • Qqq distinguishes the two modes of λ and ρ! Diquark motions in the baryon mass spectrum!!

1. Introduction

Nov.30  -­‐-­‐  Dec.1,  2014 Progress  on  J-­‐PARC  hadron 2

50 year of quarks

Page 3: Producons*and*decays*of* charmed*baryons...Charmed baryons Whatdo!we!expectfor!heavy!quarks? • Qqq distinguishes the two modes of λ and ρ! Diquark motions in the baryon mass spectrum!!

Nov.30  -­‐-­‐  Dec.1,  2014 Progress  on  J-­‐PARC  hadron 3

Already proposed by

12 year of quarks

Page 4: Producons*and*decays*of* charmed*baryons...Charmed baryons Whatdo!we!expectfor!heavy!quarks? • Qqq distinguishes the two modes of λ and ρ! Diquark motions in the baryon mass spectrum!!

Fermi Lab

SLAC

LHC

Nov.30  -­‐-­‐  Dec.1,  2014   Progress  on  J-­‐PARC  hadron   4  

Page 5: Producons*and*decays*of* charmed*baryons...Charmed baryons Whatdo!we!expectfor!heavy!quarks? • Qqq distinguishes the two modes of λ and ρ! Diquark motions in the baryon mass spectrum!!

Quarks bonding differently at LHCb

Nov.30  -­‐-­‐  Dec.1,  2014   Progress  on  J-­‐PARC  hadron   5  

hJp://www.theguardian.com/science/life-­‐and-­‐physics/2014/apr/13/quarks-­‐bonding-­‐differently-­‐at-­‐lhcb

So until last week there were two known types of hadron. ...... LHCb has just confirmed what data from other experiments had already led us to suspect. There is a third way.

Phys.  Rev.  LeJ.  112,  222002

Page 6: Producons*and*decays*of* charmed*baryons...Charmed baryons Whatdo!we!expectfor!heavy!quarks? • Qqq distinguishes the two modes of λ and ρ! Diquark motions in the baryon mass spectrum!!

Zb(10610, 10650)@KEK 2012 1/10

Nov.30  -­‐-­‐  Dec.1,  2014   Progress  on  J-­‐PARC  hadron   6  

Bファクトリー実験において、ボトム・クォークを含む新種のハドロン粒子を発見した。この新粒子は電荷を持ち、4個以上のクォークが結合してできたハドロン粒子と考えられる。...  今回の発見は、4個以上のクォークが結合したエキゾチックハドロンが、ボトム・クォークを含む粒子系にも存在することを明らかに示したものである。

Page 7: Producons*and*decays*of* charmed*baryons...Charmed baryons Whatdo!we!expectfor!heavy!quarks? • Qqq distinguishes the two modes of λ and ρ! Diquark motions in the baryon mass spectrum!!

Z(3900)

Z(4430)

7

X(3872)

qq qq

What we expect: Creation and rearrangement of multiquarks

ηc

′ηc

J ψ

′ψ

χc0χc1

χc2

N=0

N=1

N=2

N=3 qqqq

? ?

creation (constituent) Clustering Meson-like Diquarks

qq

What governs them ? 2.8

3.0

3.2

3.4

3.6

3.8

4.2

Nov.30  -­‐-­‐  Dec.1,  2014 Progress  on  J-­‐PARC  hadron

Page 8: Producons*and*decays*of* charmed*baryons...Charmed baryons Whatdo!we!expectfor!heavy!quarks? • Qqq distinguishes the two modes of λ and ρ! Diquark motions in the baryon mass spectrum!!

S=3/2

S=1/2

14c +1cc << 80uds (6excited)

1/2+

1/2  – 1/2+

3/2+

 1/2–

1/2+

3/2+

3/2  –

5/2+

?

ΞC

[GeV]

?

1/2+

3/2+

ΩC

cqq cqq

csq

css ΞC

Ξ’C

1hω

?

1 Ξ+cc

Nov.30  -­‐-­‐  Dec.1,  2014 Progress  on  J-­‐PARC  hadron 8

Ground states

More states at JPARC

2. Charmed baryons

Page 9: Producons*and*decays*of* charmed*baryons...Charmed baryons Whatdo!we!expectfor!heavy!quarks? • Qqq distinguishes the two modes of λ and ρ! Diquark motions in the baryon mass spectrum!!

What  do  we  expect  for  heavy  quarks?

• Qqq distinguishes the two modes of λ and ρ Diquark motions in the baryon mass spectrum • It could expose light flavor (chiral) dynamics

Nov.30  -­‐-­‐  Dec.1,  2014 Progress  on  J-­‐PARC  hadron 9

From hadron to diquark (spectroscopy)

λ

ρ

Page 10: Producons*and*decays*of* charmed*baryons...Charmed baryons Whatdo!we!expectfor!heavy!quarks? • Qqq distinguishes the two modes of λ and ρ! Diquark motions in the baryon mass spectrum!!

Nov.30  -­‐-­‐  Dec.1,  2014 Progress  on  J-­‐PARC  hadron 10

λ, ρ modes appear in the spectrum

λ

ρρ > λ

λ

ρ ρ = λ

HO and no ss λ

ρ

Degenerate ß Two diquark motions à Distinguished Isotope-shift

mQ = mu,d mQ →∞

Page 11: Producons*and*decays*of* charmed*baryons...Charmed baryons Whatdo!we!expectfor!heavy!quarks? • Qqq distinguishes the two modes of λ and ρ! Diquark motions in the baryon mass spectrum!!

qqQ  systems

Nov.30  -­‐-­‐  Dec.1,  2014 Progress  on  J-­‐PARC  hadron 11

Quark model calculation with spin-spin interaction: Yoshida, Sadato, Hiyama, Oka, Hosaka

Quark model hamiltonian

H = p12

2mq+ p2

2

2mq+ p3

2

2MQ− P2

2Mtot

+Vconf (HO)+Vspin−spin (Color −magnetic)+ ...Solved by the Gaussian expansion method

See how systems change as MQ is varied

Page 12: Producons*and*decays*of* charmed*baryons...Charmed baryons Whatdo!we!expectfor!heavy!quarks? • Qqq distinguishes the two modes of λ and ρ! Diquark motions in the baryon mass spectrum!!

Excitabon  spectrum

Σ(1/2+)  

Λ(1/2+)

Σ(3/2+)   Λ(1/2-,  3/2-)

Λ  Σ  Σ  

Σ Λ

Hyperons

Nov.30  -­‐-­‐  Dec.1,  2014 12

Charmed baryons

Σc(1/2+)  

Λc(1/2+)

Σc(3/2+)  

Λc(1/2-,  3/2-)

Λc

Σc  

Λc

Σc  

Σc  

L=1  excited  states:  spin-­‐spin  interacbon

Progress  on  J-­‐PARC  hadron

ß l = 0, ground states à

ß l = 1, excited states à

Page 13: Producons*and*decays*of* charmed*baryons...Charmed baryons Whatdo!we!expectfor!heavy!quarks? • Qqq distinguishes the two modes of λ and ρ! Diquark motions in the baryon mass spectrum!!

Excitabon  spectrum

Σ(1/2+)  

Λ(1/2+)

Σ(3/2+)   Λ(1/2-,  3/2-)

Λ  Σ  Σ  

Σ Λ

Hyperons

Nov.30  -­‐-­‐  Dec.1,  2014 13

Charmed baryons

Σc(1/2+)  

Λc(1/2+)

Σc(3/2+)  

Λc(1/2-,  3/2-)

Λc

Σc  

Λc

Σc  

Σc  

L=1  excited  states:  spin-­‐spin  interacbon

Progress  on  J-­‐PARC  hadron

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 5 MQ  [GeV/c2]

s c

Page 14: Producons*and*decays*of* charmed*baryons...Charmed baryons Whatdo!we!expectfor!heavy!quarks? • Qqq distinguishes the two modes of λ and ρ! Diquark motions in the baryon mass spectrum!!

Excitabon  spectrum

Σ(1/2+)  

Λ(1/2+)

Σ(3/2+)   Λ(1/2-,  3/2-)

Λ  Σ  Σ  

Σ Λ

Hyperons

Nov.30  -­‐-­‐  Dec.1,  2014 14

Charmed baryons

Σc(1/2+)  

Λc(1/2+)

Σc(3/2+)  

Λc(1/2-,  3/2-)

Λc

Σc  

Λc

Σc  

Σc  

L=1  excited  states:  spin-­‐spin  interacbon

Progress  on  J-­‐PARC  hadron

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 5 MQ  [GeV/c2]

s c SU(3) HQ

Page 15: Producons*and*decays*of* charmed*baryons...Charmed baryons Whatdo!we!expectfor!heavy!quarks? • Qqq distinguishes the two modes of λ and ρ! Diquark motions in the baryon mass spectrum!!

Wave  funcbon

Nov.30  -­‐-­‐  Dec.1,  2014 Progress  on  J-­‐PARC  hadron

15 mQ [GeV]

mud = 300 MeV

Prob

abili

ty |c

|2 Mixing of

e.g. λ-mode dominant state: How much the other mode mixes? Λ(phys) = cλΛ(

2λ)+ cρΛ(2 ρ)

| cλ (Λ(1 / 2− )) |2

| cλ (Σ(1 / 2− )) |2

| cρ (Λ(1 / 2− )) |2

| cρ (Σ(1 / 2− )) |2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

0 0.5 1 1.5 2

SU(3) limit

Λc* is almost

pure λ mode è Reflect more diquark nature

Page 16: Producons*and*decays*of* charmed*baryons...Charmed baryons Whatdo!we!expectfor!heavy!quarks? • Qqq distinguishes the two modes of λ and ρ! Diquark motions in the baryon mass spectrum!!

3.  Charmed baryon Productions

Nov.30  -­‐-­‐  Dec.1,  2014 Progress  on  J-­‐PARC  hadron 16

Production rate (Λc/Λ) and Ratios (Bc*/Bc)

π + N à D* + Λc reactions

Page 17: Producons*and*decays*of* charmed*baryons...Charmed baryons Whatdo!we!expectfor!heavy!quarks? • Qqq distinguishes the two modes of λ and ρ! Diquark motions in the baryon mass spectrum!!

Strategy: At high energies: Forward peak à t-channel dominant Theory: • Rates (Λc/Λ) by the Regge model, D* Reggeon • Relative ratios of (Bc

*(λ modes)/Bc) by a One step process of Qd picture

APS-­‐JPS  joint  meebng   17 d

q(pi ) c(p f )Pion-induced reaction π + p D* + Bc

*

π D*

Bc* p

D* Reggeon

Nov.30  -­‐-­‐  Dec.1,  2014 Progress  on  J-­‐PARC  hadron 17

Page 18: Producons*and*decays*of* charmed*baryons...Charmed baryons Whatdo!we!expectfor!heavy!quarks? • Qqq distinguishes the two modes of λ and ρ! Diquark motions in the baryon mass spectrum!!

pπ, Lab = 4.5 GeV

π − p→ΛK*0 π − p→ ΣK*0

cosθ cosθ

1

10

0.1 –1.0 0 +1.0 –1.0 0 +1.0

dσdΩ[µb / sr]

D.J. Krennel et al PRD6, 1220 (1972)

Nov.30  -­‐-­‐  Dec.1,  2014 Progress  on  J-­‐PARC  hadron 18

Page 19: Producons*and*decays*of* charmed*baryons...Charmed baryons Whatdo!we!expectfor!heavy!quarks? • Qqq distinguishes the two modes of λ and ρ! Diquark motions in the baryon mass spectrum!!

Absolute values

Nov.30  -­‐-­‐  Dec.1,  2014 Progress  on  J-­‐PARC  hadron 19

Regge model ~ Sang-Ho Kim's talk

strangeness

charm

10–2

10–5

Charm/strangeness productions: 10–2 ~ 10–5

Page 20: Producons*and*decays*of* charmed*baryons...Charmed baryons Whatdo!we!expectfor!heavy!quarks? • Qqq distinguishes the two modes of λ and ρ! Diquark motions in the baryon mass spectrum!!

Nov.30  -­‐-­‐  Dec.1,  2014 Progress  on  J-­‐PARC  hadron 20

Relative rates of (Bc*/Bc) ���

One step process of Qd pictire

t fi ~kπ × e ⋅

J fi

~ Bc* e⊥ ⋅

σ ei

qeff ⋅x N

Transverse = (Geometric) × (Dynamic) CG coefficients

d

q(pi ) c(p f )λ

V-exchanges

D*π

Bc*

Kim  et  al,  PTEP  (2014)  103D01  

Page 21: Producons*and*decays*of* charmed*baryons...Charmed baryons Whatdo!we!expectfor!heavy!quarks? • Qqq distinguishes the two modes of λ and ρ! Diquark motions in the baryon mass spectrum!!

Dynamical  part  ~  radial  integral

Nov.30  -­‐-­‐  Dec.1,  2014 Progress  on  J-­‐PARC  hadron 21

GS

Transitions to excited states are not suppressed

Bc(S-wave)

e⊥ ⋅σ ei

qeff ⋅x N (S-wave) radial ~1× exp −

qeff2

4A2⎛

⎝⎜

⎠⎟

Bc(P-wave)

e⊥ ⋅σ ei

qeff ⋅x N (S-wave) radial ~

qeffA

⎛⎝⎜

⎞⎠⎟

1

× exp −qeff2

4A2⎛

⎝⎜

⎠⎟

Bc(D-wave)

e⊥ ⋅σ ei

qeff ⋅x N (S-wave) radial ~

qeffA

⎛⎝⎜

⎞⎠⎟

2

× exp −qeff2

4A2⎛

⎝⎜

⎠⎟

Excited states

d

q(pi ) c(p f )qeff: the momentum transfer ~ Large

Page 22: Producons*and*decays*of* charmed*baryons...Charmed baryons Whatdo!we!expectfor!heavy!quarks? • Qqq distinguishes the two modes of λ and ρ! Diquark motions in the baryon mass spectrum!!

Results

Strange kπCM = 1.59 [GeV], kπLab = 5.8 [GeV]

Nov.30  -­‐-­‐  Dec.1,  2014 Progress  on  J-­‐PARC  hadron 22

1.00                0.02                0.16          0.90                1.70                0.02                0.03              0.04              0.19              0.18          0.50                0.88                0.02                0.02              0.01                0.03            0.07            0.07

Charm kπCM = 2.71 [GeV] , kπLab = 16 [GeV]

1.00                0.067                0.44                    0.11                  0.23              0.007          0.01              0.01            0.07            0.067                      0.13                0.20              0.007          0.01            0.004          0.02            0.038        0.04

Page 23: Producons*and*decays*of* charmed*baryons...Charmed baryons Whatdo!we!expectfor!heavy!quarks? • Qqq distinguishes the two modes of λ and ρ! Diquark motions in the baryon mass spectrum!!

Yasui's talk, wed à 1/ 2+ 1/ 2− 3 / 2− 3 / 2+ 5 / 2+

HQ doublet HQ doublet

l = 1 l = 2 l = 0

1 : 2 3 : 2

Nov.30  -­‐-­‐  Dec.1,  2014 Progress  on  J-­‐PARC  hadron 23

Page 24: Producons*and*decays*of* charmed*baryons...Charmed baryons Whatdo!we!expectfor!heavy!quarks? • Qqq distinguishes the two modes of λ and ρ! Diquark motions in the baryon mass spectrum!!

Nov.30  -­‐-­‐  Dec.1,  2014 Progress  on  J-­‐PARC  hadron 24

Meson analogue

d

q(pi ) c(p f )

D*π

Bc λ

r

How similar the λ baryon mode and r meson mode?

Page 25: Producons*and*decays*of* charmed*baryons...Charmed baryons Whatdo!we!expectfor!heavy!quarks? • Qqq distinguishes the two modes of λ and ρ! Diquark motions in the baryon mass spectrum!!

4.  Charmed  baryon  decays

Nov.30  -­‐-­‐  Dec.1,  2014 Progress  on  J-­‐PARC  hadron 25

ρ-mode λ-mode

Bc*

Mc

N π

Bc*

Bc

Page 26: Producons*and*decays*of* charmed*baryons...Charmed baryons Whatdo!we!expectfor!heavy!quarks? • Qqq distinguishes the two modes of λ and ρ! Diquark motions in the baryon mass spectrum!!

Chiral dynamics

Nov.30  -­‐-­‐  Dec.1,  2014 Progress  on  J-­‐PARC  hadron 26

Spontaneously broken = SU(2)L x SU(2)R à SU(2)V Non-linear realization with only ispsoin symmetry S. Weinberg, Phys.Rev.166, 1568 (1968)

U = exp ifπ

τ ⋅ π⎛⎝⎜

⎞⎠⎟, U→ gLUgR

ξ = exp i2 fπ

τ ⋅ π⎛⎝⎜

⎞⎠⎟, ξ → gLξh

† = hξg†L , h = h(gL ,gR ,π )

vµ , aµ = i2

ξ† ∂µξ ±ξ ∂µξ†( )

N→ξN , DµN ≡ (∂µ− ivµ )N→ξDµN• • • •

Page 27: Producons*and*decays*of* charmed*baryons...Charmed baryons Whatdo!we!expectfor!heavy!quarks? • Qqq distinguishes the two modes of λ and ρ! Diquark motions in the baryon mass spectrum!!

Linear  descripbon

Nov.30  -­‐-­‐  Dec.1,  2014 Progress  on  J-­‐PARC  hadron 27

Again by S. Weinberg, Algebraic realization, Phys.Rev.177, 2604 (1969) Mended symmetries, PRL65, 1177 (1990)

• Assign chiral representations to hadrons • Then write a chiral invariant Lagrangian terms

etc

N ~ 12 , 0( )⊕ 0, 12( ); NL,R → gL,RNL,R , NL,R = 1+ γ 5

2N

(σ , π ) ~ 12 ,

12( ), (ρ, a1) ~ 1, 0( )⊕ 0,1( )

NLUNR + NRU†NL = N σ + iτ ⋅ πγ 5( )N

Page 28: Producons*and*decays*of* charmed*baryons...Charmed baryons Whatdo!we!expectfor!heavy!quarks? • Qqq distinguishes the two modes of λ and ρ! Diquark motions in the baryon mass spectrum!!

Meson-­‐baryon  coupling

Nov.30  -­‐-­‐  Dec.1,  2014 Progress  on  J-­‐PARC  hadron 28

Light meson qq (½, ½) Nucleon qqq (½, 0), (1, ½) Heavy meson (quark) Qq (½, 0) Heavy baryon (diquark) Qqq (0, 0), (½, ½), (1, 0)

Diquark JP Chiral Isospin Baryons S 1S0 0+ (0, 0) 0 Λ, Λ*(λ) P 3P0 0– (0, 0) 0 Λ*(ρ) V 3P1 1– (½, ½) 0 Λ*(ρ) A 3S1 1+ (½, ½) 1 Σ, Σ*(λ) T 3D1, 1P1 1+, 1– (1, 0) 1 Σ, Σ*(ρ)

qqqγ 5qqγ µqqγ µγ 5

τ qqσ µνγ 5

τ q

q =T qiγ 0γ 2γ 5iτ 2

Page 29: Producons*and*decays*of* charmed*baryons...Charmed baryons Whatdo!we!expectfor!heavy!quarks? • Qqq distinguishes the two modes of λ and ρ! Diquark motions in the baryon mass spectrum!!

Nov.30  -­‐-­‐  Dec.1,  2014 Progress  on  J-­‐PARC  hadron 29

Bc* à π Bc

π Bc (½, ½)×(0, 0) (½, ½)×(½, ½) (½, ½)×(0, 1) [1] (0, 0) --- OK --- [2] (½, ½) OK --- OK [3] (1, 0) --- OK ---

Bc*

[1] Λ*(λ) à πΣ [2] Λ*(ρ), Σ*(λ) à πΛ, πΣ, these are related [3] Σ*(ρ) à πΛ, πΣ

Page 30: Producons*and*decays*of* charmed*baryons...Charmed baryons Whatdo!we!expectfor!heavy!quarks? • Qqq distinguishes the two modes of λ and ρ! Diquark motions in the baryon mass spectrum!!

Nov.30  -­‐-­‐  Dec.1,  2014 Progress  on  J-­‐PARC  hadron 30

Bc* à Mc N(½,0), (1,½)

Mc N (0, ½)×(0, ½) (0, ½)×(½, 1) [1] (0, 0) OK --- [2] (½, ½) --- OK [3] (1, 0) --- OK

Bc*

[1] Λ*(λ) à KN [2] Λ*(ρ), Σ*(λ) à KN [3] Σ*(ρ) à KN

• Chiral selection rules may explain small widths • explore more on the nucleon

Page 31: Producons*and*decays*of* charmed*baryons...Charmed baryons Whatdo!we!expectfor!heavy!quarks? • Qqq distinguishes the two modes of λ and ρ! Diquark motions in the baryon mass spectrum!!

Summary •  Evidences  of  new  mulbquark  configurabons                è  Molecule  +  ...  •  To  pin  down  the  dynamics,  J-­‐PARC  will  help  

•  ρ  and  λ  modes  are  disbnct  (Isotope  shin)        beJer  in  Λ  than  in  Σ    à  can  we  approach  di-­‐quark  ?  •  Systemabc  study  in  strangeness  is  important  

•  Higher  excited  (Λ)  states  may  be  produced        as  many  as  the  ground  states,  analogue  for  mesons  •  Chiral  selecbon  rules  may  be  relevant  to  small  width  

•  More  on  the  chiral  structure  of  the  nucleon  

Nov.30  -­‐-­‐  Dec.1,  2014 Progress  on  J-­‐PARC  hadron 31