On Fuzzball conjecture

30
On Fuzzball conjecture Seiji Terashima (YITP, Kyoto) based on the work (PRD78 064029(2008), arXiv:0805.1405) in collaboration with Noriaki Ogawa (YITP) 2009 Feb 19 at Kinosaki

description

On Fuzzball conjecture. Seiji Terashima (YITP, Kyoto) based on the work (PRD78 064029(2008), arXiv:0805.1405) in collaboration with Noriaki Ogawa (YITP). 2009 Feb 19 at Kinosaki. 1. Introduction. In general relativity (or classical gravity):. Black hole solutions exist - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Transcript of On Fuzzball conjecture

Page 1: On Fuzzball conjecture

On Fuzzball conjecture

Seiji Terashima (YITP, Kyoto)

based on the work (PRD78 064029(2008), arXiv:0805.1405)in collaboration with Noriaki Ogawa (YITP)

2009 Feb 19 at Kinosaki

Page 2: On Fuzzball conjecture

2

1. Introduction

Page 3: On Fuzzball conjecture

3

In general relativity (or classical gravity):

Black hole solutions exist and behave like blackbody:

Thermodynamics

d E = T d S

δS ≥ 0

Blackbody radiation

Black hole

d M = κd A

δA ≥ 0

Hawking radiationM: Mass of B.H.A: Area of horizonκ: surface gravity

Page 4: On Fuzzball conjecture

4

Irreversibility ↔ horizon.

No information inside the B.H.can escape outside the horizon.

Information loss problem(quantum theory should be unitary)

Page 5: On Fuzzball conjecture

5

Anyway, black hole is a classical solution,but thermodynamic object!

General relativity will be just an effective action,and there will be micro states for the black hole,perhaps quantum mechanically.

Page 6: On Fuzzball conjecture

6

String Theory- is well defined and understood perturbatively- is useful for Mathematics (ex. Mirror symmetry)- is applied to the QCD (ex. Holographic QCD)- can be applied to Particle Phenomenology and can be the Theory Of Everything.

- includes Quantum Gravity

Remember why String Theory is interesting:

Page 7: On Fuzzball conjecture

7

Indeed, in string theorywe can find the microstates of B.H.

and show:

log (# of microstates)= Area of B.H.

for some BPS B.H.Strominger-Vafa

using the Gauge/Gravity duality.

Page 8: On Fuzzball conjecture

8

a Puzzle remains:

Near the horizon, classical general relativity seems valid because curvature is small

andthe quantum effects would be confined within

the plank length near the singularity

Information loss? Inconsistency?

Page 9: On Fuzzball conjecture

9

Fuzzball conjecture:

“Black Hole” does not exist quantum mechanically (in string theory).

(There is no horizon in quantum gravity.)

Instead of black hole, somethings like fuzzball( 毛玉) exist.

Mathur and his collaborators

Page 10: On Fuzzball conjecture

10http://lillicat-kingdom.com/blog/archives/craft_addict/knitting/index.php?page=17

Fuzzball(has complicated topololgy)

Black hole

Corse graining(粗視化)

Page 11: On Fuzzball conjecture

11

B.H. is macroscopic object andhas very large number of degree of freedom, N.

Quantum effects will spread out by the large N effect.

→ 1. Macroscopic “hozizon” appear2. Quantum effect near horizon !

Key point:

Page 12: On Fuzzball conjecture

12

In supergravity, some classical solutions without horizon and singularity

which are approximately same as the B.H. outside “horizon”were found (fuzzball solution).

→ “horizon” appear as approximate notion

Note 1:the fuzzball in general are not represented as

classical solution. Only for special cases.

an evidence:

Page 13: On Fuzzball conjecture

13

Note 2:

BPS properties are essential to find the solutions.

BPS equations is linear → reduced to one like Laplace equation

→ infinite sum of the solutions are also solutions→Fuzzball solutions

No hair “theorem” is terribly violated

Page 14: On Fuzzball conjecture

14

2. Half BPS Fuzzball in AdS5xS5

Page 15: On Fuzzball conjecture

15

AdS5/CFT4

AdS5 x S5 ↔ N=4 SU(N) SYM

restrict to ½ BPS sector

Lin-Lunin-Maldacena ↔ N free fermions in (LLM)geometry harmonic oscillator potential

Page 16: On Fuzzball conjecture

16

Other parts

Page 17: On Fuzzball conjecture

17

AdS5x S5 solution

In the coordinate , the metric becomes

AdS5xS5 geometry within the global coordinate

Page 18: On Fuzzball conjecture

18

[Note] fermion distribution can be defined for special class of state in Hilbert space, i.e. semi-classical or

“coherent states” spanning the base of Hilbert space

Page 19: On Fuzzball conjecture

19

• Pauli’s exclusion principle means for CFT side.

• LLM geometry have Closed Time like Curve for outside this region. Thus these solutions will be unphysical in quantum theory.

• LLM geometry is smooth for

• This phase space us quantized by

Page 20: On Fuzzball conjecture

20

Thus, in this ½ BPS sectors of AdS5xS5 example, all microstates are represented by smooth supergravity solutions, which are the fuzzballs!

More presicely, all states

of a basis of microstates

are represented

by supergravity solutions.

Page 21: On Fuzzball conjecture

21

Smooth geometry ↔ pure states in CFT

Interpretation of the singular geometries in LLMis Mixed/coarse grained states in CFT.

Singular geom. = “gray droplets”

Superstar=simplest gray droplets=uniform disk

Balasbramnian et.al.

Page 22: On Fuzzball conjecture

22

Suparstar has naked singularity without horizon,

but we expect it will have horizon after including quatum effects

5d N=2 supergravity reduced form is

BPS “black hole”, but not extremal.If the horizon is at ζ ,

Page 23: On Fuzzball conjecture

23

Summary of our work:“Coarse-graining of bubbling geometries

and the fuzzball conjecture”

• Consider charged “B.H.” called “Superstar” in AdS space-time

• Estimate the entropy of superstar, as log(# of microstates)• Estimate the "horizon" size of the superstar, based on the

fuzzball conjecture, from gravity side.

• We find the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy computed from this "horizon" agrees with log(# of microstates)

• Thus, this result supports the fuzzball conjecture.

Page 24: On Fuzzball conjecture

24

Entropy = log of number of states which are not distinguishable

from one another by macroscopic observations.

So, what is “macroscopic observer”?We assume that

One can only measure physical quantities up to

If metric perturbation is bigger than We can detect two geometries are different

Page 25: On Fuzzball conjecture

25

Consider two similar LLM geometries with fermion distributions and

and their difference

Page 26: On Fuzzball conjecture

26

Then, we can compute the entropy of the superstar (and other non-smooth geometries) by

counting the number of possible microstates as

Page 27: On Fuzzball conjecture

27

Now we observe region very close to the fuzzballand see where is “horizon” .

Here the “horizon” is the surface of the region where the typical microstates are different each other.

After some computation, we find “horizon” is at

or in the coordinate for the superstar.

Therefore, according to previous formula, we have

We take with very small α

Page 28: On Fuzzball conjecture

28

Conclusions

Page 29: On Fuzzball conjecture

29

• Summary– For some BPS black holes we find there are fuzzball solutions in

super gravity, which are smooth and has no horizon.– These will correspond to the microstates of B.H.

• Future directions – Including higher derivative corrections– Non BPS, non extremal

Page 30: On Fuzzball conjecture

30

Fin.