Office hours Wednesday 3-4pm 304A Stanley...

12
1 Office hours Wednesday 3-4pm 304A Stanley Hall Fig. 11.26 Association mapping (qualitative) Association scan, qualitative 433 47 G’s 797 141 C’s controls osteoarthritis χ 2 test Association scan, quantitative Association vs. linkage Association vs. linkage Unrelated individuals (usually) Related individuals

Transcript of Office hours Wednesday 3-4pm 304A Stanley...

Page 1: Office hours Wednesday 3-4pm 304A Stanley Hallmcb.berkeley.edu/courses/mcb140/brem_fall_08/association...1 Office hours Wednesday 3-4pm 304A Stanley Hall Fig.11.26 Association mapping

1

Office hoursWednesday 3-4pm304A Stanley Hall

Fig. 11.26

Association mapping (qualitative)

Association scan, qualitative

43347G’s797141C’s

controlsosteoarthritisχ2 test

Association scan, quantitative

Association vs. linkage Association vs. linkage

Unrelatedindividuals (usually)

Relatedindividuals

Page 2: Office hours Wednesday 3-4pm 304A Stanley Hallmcb.berkeley.edu/courses/mcb140/brem_fall_08/association...1 Office hours Wednesday 3-4pm 304A Stanley Hall Fig.11.26 Association mapping

2

Association vs. linkage

Unrelatedindividuals (usually)

Relatedindividuals

Extreme of linkage study is one large family; lesslikely that phenotype has multiple genetic causes

(locus heterogeneity).

Association vs. linkage

Strong, easy to detect

Unrelatedindividuals

Relatedindividuals

Association vs. linkage

Strong, easy to detect,but rare in population

Unrelatedindividuals

Relatedindividuals

Association vs. linkage

Strong, easy to detect,but rare in population

Unrelatedindividuals

Relatedindividuals

(e.g. BRCA1)

Association vs. linkage

Strong, easy to detect,but rare in population;may not be reflective ofcommon disease.

Unrelatedindividuals

Relatedindividuals

Association vs. linkage

Strong, easy to detect,but rare in population;may not be reflective ofcommon disease.Also, hard to collect familydata.

Unrelatedindividuals

Relatedindividuals

Page 3: Office hours Wednesday 3-4pm 304A Stanley Hallmcb.berkeley.edu/courses/mcb140/brem_fall_08/association...1 Office hours Wednesday 3-4pm 304A Stanley Hall Fig.11.26 Association mapping

3

Association vs. linkage

Strong, easy to detect,but rare in population;may not be reflective ofcommon disease.Also, hard to collect familydata.

Common but weakeffects

Unrelatedindividuals

Relatedindividuals

Association vs. linkage

Strong, easy to detect,but rare in population;may not be reflective ofcommon disease.Also, hard to collect familydata.

Common but weakeffects; need 1000’sof samples to detect

Unrelatedindividuals

Relatedindividuals

Association vs. linkage

Strong, easy to detect,but rare in population;may not be reflective ofcommon disease.Also, hard to collect familydata.

Common but weakeffects; need 1000’sof samples to detect.If no common cause,can fail.

Unrelatedindividuals

Relatedindividuals

Another key feature ofassociation mapping:

resolution

Association vs. linkage

manyrecombinationshave happenedsince commonancestor;shared regionis small; no co-inheritancebetweendistant markers

Association vs. linkagesmallnumber ofgenerations;individualsshare bigchunks ofgenome;can get co-inheritancebetweendistantmarkers

manyrecombinationshave happenedsince commonancestor;shared regionis small; no co-inheritancebetweendistant markers

Page 4: Office hours Wednesday 3-4pm 304A Stanley Hallmcb.berkeley.edu/courses/mcb140/brem_fall_08/association...1 Office hours Wednesday 3-4pm 304A Stanley Hall Fig.11.26 Association mapping

4

Association vs. linkagesmallnumber ofgenerations;individualsshare bigchunks ofgenome;can get co-inheritancebetweendistantmarkers

manyrecombinationshave happenedsince commonancestor;shared regionis small; no co-inheritancebetweendistant markers

So you need very high densityof markers to get signal in anassociation study, but you getvery high spatial resolution.

Association vs. linkagesmallnumber ofgenerations;individualsshare bigchunks ofgenome;can get co-inheritancebetweendistantmarkers

manyrecombinationshave happenedsince commonancestor;shared regionis small; no co-inheritancebetweendistant markers

In the “old days” of sparsemarkers, linkage analysis was

the best strategy.

Causative variant very close

-log(χ

2 p-

valu

e)

rs377472

But there is a pitfall ofassociation tests: “population

structure”

Diabetes in Native Americans

(1971)

Diabetes in Native Americans

Page 5: Office hours Wednesday 3-4pm 304A Stanley Hallmcb.berkeley.edu/courses/mcb140/brem_fall_08/association...1 Office hours Wednesday 3-4pm 304A Stanley Hall Fig.11.26 Association mapping

5

(1971)

Family studiesindicate it is atleast partlygenetic, notenvironmental.

Diabetes in Native Americans Association mapping causal loci

Typed IgG heavy chains with protein assay.Phenotypes can serve as markers too…

Association mapping causal loci

Typed IgG heavy chains with protein assay.Phenotypes can serve as markers too…

(Multiple proteins from chr 14 region: haplotype)

Association mapping causal loci

32841343no Gm27023Gmcontroldiabetes

Association mapping causal loci

32841343no Gm27023Gmcontroldiabetes

Association mapping causal loci

Page 6: Office hours Wednesday 3-4pm 304A Stanley Hallmcb.berkeley.edu/courses/mcb140/brem_fall_08/association...1 Office hours Wednesday 3-4pm 304A Stanley Hall Fig.11.26 Association mapping

6

32841343no Gm27023Gmcontroldiabetes

Association mapping causal loci

“Gm is protective against diabetes?”

Association mapping causal loci

Self-identified heritage Self-identified heritageMost “full heritage”members don’t havethe haplotype

Self-identified heritageMost “full heritage”members don’t havethe haplotype

The few without N.A.heritage are muchmore likely to havethe haplotype

Gm haplotype is very rare inself-identified 100% Pima

members.

Page 7: Office hours Wednesday 3-4pm 304A Stanley Hallmcb.berkeley.edu/courses/mcb140/brem_fall_08/association...1 Office hours Wednesday 3-4pm 304A Stanley Hall Fig.11.26 Association mapping

7

Gm haplotype is very rare inself-identified 100% Pima

members.

Gm is a marker for Caucasian ancestry.

Association and admixture

Association and admixture Association and admixture

hugealmost negligible

Association and admixture

these are all theCaucasians…

Association and admixtureGm doesn’t look like it hasmuch additional protective

effect if you stratify byfamilial origin first!

Page 8: Office hours Wednesday 3-4pm 304A Stanley Hallmcb.berkeley.edu/courses/mcb140/brem_fall_08/association...1 Office hours Wednesday 3-4pm 304A Stanley Hall Fig.11.26 Association mapping

8

Association and admixture

Caucasian ancestry isassociated with Gm haplotype.

Association and admixture

Caucasian ancestry isassociated with Gm haplotype.Caucasian ancestry isassociated with lower diabetesrisk.

Association and admixture

Caucasian ancestry isassociated with Gm haplotype.Caucasian ancestry isassociated with lower diabetesrisk.But Gm is not associated withlower diabetes risk!

Association and admixture

Cases

Controls

Controls are enriched for Caucasians

Association and admixture

Cases

Controls

=

=

N.A. and Caucasians aredifferent at many loci

http

://w

ww

.ucl

.ac.

uk/~

ucbh

jow

/med

icin

e/im

ages

/hum

an_k

aryo

type

.gif

Association and admixture

Cases

Controls

=

=

At any one of these loci, Caucasian-like allele will beenriched in control samples.

Page 9: Office hours Wednesday 3-4pm 304A Stanley Hallmcb.berkeley.edu/courses/mcb140/brem_fall_08/association...1 Office hours Wednesday 3-4pm 304A Stanley Hall Fig.11.26 Association mapping

9

Association and admixture

Cases

Controls

=

=

Don’t believe any one locus is causative!

Microarrays and genotyping

DNA microarrays

Fig. 10.21

DNA microarrays

Fig. 10.21

Post-genome era:the sequence andlocation of theoligos are known

DNA microarrays

Fig. 1.13

Genotyping by array

Fig. 11.8

Page 10: Office hours Wednesday 3-4pm 304A Stanley Hallmcb.berkeley.edu/courses/mcb140/brem_fall_08/association...1 Office hours Wednesday 3-4pm 304A Stanley Hall Fig.11.26 Association mapping

10

Genotyping by array

Fig. 11.10

Genotyping by array

Fig. 11.10

oligo (human genome fragment) index

Genotyping by array

Fig. 11.10

oligo (human genome fragment) index

Genotyping by array

Fig. 11.10

oligo (human genome fragment) index

Genotyping by array

Fig. 11.10

oligo (human genome fragment) index

Genotyping by array

Fig. 11.10

middle nucleotide onchip oligo

oligo (human genome fragment) index

Page 11: Office hours Wednesday 3-4pm 304A Stanley Hallmcb.berkeley.edu/courses/mcb140/brem_fall_08/association...1 Office hours Wednesday 3-4pm 304A Stanley Hall Fig.11.26 Association mapping

11

Genotyping by array

Fig. 11.10

middle nucleotide onchip oligo

Sample DNA is labeled, allowed to hybridize

Genotyping by array

Fig. 11.10

readout of sample

middle nucleotide onchip oligo

Genotyping by array

Fig. 11.10

readout of sample

middle nucleotide onchip oligo

Genotyping by array

Fabrication technology allows millions of oligos (eachpresent in millions of copies) on a single slide

Genotyping by single-baseextension

Fig. 11.11

Genotyping by single-baseextension

http://www.illumina.com/downloads/InfiniumIIWorkflow.pdf

Page 12: Office hours Wednesday 3-4pm 304A Stanley Hallmcb.berkeley.edu/courses/mcb140/brem_fall_08/association...1 Office hours Wednesday 3-4pm 304A Stanley Hall Fig.11.26 Association mapping

12

High density of markersnecessary for association