Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from...

54
Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 1 Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed?

Transcript of Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from...

Page 1: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 1

Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy

Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources

Q: why is this needed?

Page 2: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2

The Galactic Plane in gamma rays

almost all sources extended

R. ChavesICRC 2009

L = 60o

L = -85o

Werner Hofmann, TeV PA 2009

Page 3: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 3

SNR models

RX J1713.7-3946Berezhko & Völkastro-ph/0602177

Shock speed 1840 m/se/p ~ 10-4

B = 126 µGasymptotically ε ≅ 50%

Synchrotronradiation ππππo

decay

Slide from W. HofmannTeV PA 2009

Page 4: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 4

MILAGRO surveyCygnus region J1908+06

Geminga CrabEnergy range ~5 … 100 TeV

B. DingusWerner Hofmann, TeV PA 2009

Page 5: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 5

Future γ-ray telescope arrray: CTA / AGIS from Stefan Funk’s talk

on future detectors atTeV PA 2009

Page 6: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 6

Blazars

PKS 2155-304

Page 7: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 7

HAWC(High Altitude Water Cherenkov) TeV

Particle Astrophysics Observatory

Brenda DingjusTeV PA 2009

Page 8: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 8

Paschal CoyleICRC 2009

Page 9: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 9

Atmospheric vs astrophysical ν

• Atmospheric– νµ : νe : ντ ~ 2:1:0– Steady flux

– sec(θ) distribution– Steep spectrum

– νe very steep– “prompt” neutrinos

• νµ : νe = 1:1• normalization uncertain• harder spectrum

• Astrophysical– νµ : νe : ντ ~ 1:1:1– Flux may be variable– Point sources expected– Harder spectrum– All flavors similar spectra– Charm decay is important

background for search for astrophysical neutrinos

Page 10: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 10

Lake Baikal

372 νννν candidates

cos(zenith angle)

Eve

nts

1

10

102

103

104

105

106

10 102

103

σSI σSIlim

(CDMS+XENON10)

Ethµ = 1 GeV

Neutralino Mass (GeV)

Muo

n flu

x fr

om th

e S

un (

km−

2 yr−

1 )

> BAIKAL 1998−02AMANDA−II 2003IceCube−22 2007

SUPER−K 1996−01

MACRO 1989−98BAKSAN 1978−95

IceCube-22

Limits on muon fluxfrom WIMP annihilationin the Sun

skymapNT200

NT200+

Page 11: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 11

V. B

ertin

-C

PP

M -

AR

EN

A'0

8 @

Ro

ma

70 m70 m

4450 m50 m

JunctionJunctionBoxBox

Interlink cablesInterlink cables

40 km to40 km toshoreshore

2500m2500m

• 900 PMTs • 12 lines• 25 storeys / line• 3 PMTs / storey

The ANTARES Detector

Page 12: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 12

Water vs Ice

• Water– Scattering length >= absorption length

• More direct hits, easier reconstruction

– Noisy environment

• Ice– Scattering length < absorption length

• More scattered light, complicates reconstruction

– Very quiet environment• <~ 500 Hz

Page 13: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

M. Spurio- ANTARES Extra-galactic Sources -Heidelberg '09

1313

Example of a reconstructed down-going muon, detected in all 12

detector lines:

Atmospheric muons

z

time

Page 14: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

M. Spurio- ANTARES Extra-galactic Sources -Heidelberg '09

1414

Example of a reconstructed up-going muon (i.e. a neutrino candidate) detected in 6/12 detector lines:

Neutrino-induced muon

time

z

Page 15: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 15

Antares sky map

750 neutrino events from below, combined 2007-2008 data

( Paschal Coyle, ICRC 2009)

Page 16: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 16

AMANDA 2000-2006

AMANDA integrated intoIceCube 2007 – 2008.

Coincident analysis in progress

AMANDA turned off onMay 11, 2009

To be replaced by Deep Core sub-detector

Page 17: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 17

IceCube timeline

In the ice:2005: 1 string

2006: 9 strings

2007: 22 strings (publishing)2008: 40 strings (analyzing)

2009: 59 strings (running)

(includes 1 deep core)

Planned:

2010: 77 strings

(includes 6 deep core)2011: 86 strings

(includes 6 deep core)

15-year design lifetime

Page 18: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 18

Drilling

Drill with hot water under high pressure5000 gallons of fuel per hole

Page 19: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 19

Page 20: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 20

Digital Optical Module (DOM)

LED Flasher board HV board

Main board for digitizing & time stamping

Page 21: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 21

Photo: James Roth, Dec 8, 2007

IceTop

Photo: Jim Haugen

Nov 23, 2007

• Two tanks per station for calibration• High-gain, low-gain DOMs for dynamic range• Waveforms give some µµµµ/e discrimination

at the surface

Page 22: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 22

anim_07

IC-22: Nearly horizontal atmospheric muon across top of detector

Page 23: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 23

IC-22: Nearly horizontal atmospheric muon across bottom

Page 24: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 24

IC-22: Horizontal event in bottom of detector – neutrino candidate?

Page 25: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 25

ICj-22: Two unrelated atmospheric muons

Page 26: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 26anim_co_01.mpg

IC-22 / IT-26 coincident event

Page 27: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 27anim_co_02.mpg

IC-22 / IT-26 coincident event

Page 28: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 28anim_co_03.mpg

IC-22 / IT-26 coincident event

Page 29: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 29

IC-40: EeV coincident event (~2000 muons at 2 km o f ice)

Page 30: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 30

IC22 point source searchAp.J.Letters (arXiv:0905.2253)

• 5114 neutrinos in 276 days live time with 95% on-time during operation.• Unbinned maximum likelihood search (resolution-weighted direction + n-channel)

with likelihood sampled every 0.25 r.a. x 0.25 dec.

Hottest spot: Cluster of 7-8 bright eventsPost-trials probability of chance occurrence is 1.3 4%

Page 31: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 31

IceCube 40 Juan Antonio Aguilarparallel session today

Page 32: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 32

IC40 Moon shadow (slide from Teresa Montaruli, 15/7/09)

Page 33: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 33

Jon Dumm, IceCube, ICRC2009Juan Antonio Aguilar, parallel session today

Page 34: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 34

Looking for diffuse fluxes above the background of atmospheric neutrinos

Sean GrullonParallel session

Page 35: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 35

Monitoring the Universe

• Look for correlation with variable sources– e.g. AGN flares

• Externally triggered searches (GRB)• Neutrino alerts (e.g. optical follow-up)

– 2 or more ν from same direction in ∆t• Alerts to ROTSE-III from IceCube since Oct. 2008• Alerts to TAROT from Antares since May 2009

– Sudden excess in counting rate (IceCube)• Send SN alert to SNEWS

• Monitoring rates in surface detectors– IceTop, Auger– Solar particle events, modulation of galactic cosmic rays

Page 36: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

GRB searches

GRB search with IceCube 22 (arXiv:0907.2227) • 41 bursts in 2007/08• Realistic modeling of each burst

according to Guetta et al. 2004• Lowers expectation relative to WB

AMANDA 400 bursts 1997-2003Ap.J 674 (2008) 357

Limits

Page 37: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 37

AMANDA/IceCube as MeV νdetector

…first proposed by Halzen, Jacobsen & Zas, astro-ph/9512080

� PMT noise low (~ 300 Hz)� ice uniformly illuminated

� detect correlated rate increase on top of PMT noise

Page 38: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 38

Events in monitoring stream

IceCube using IceTopAp. J. (Letters) 689 (2008) L65-L68

Counting rate in IceCube:Sum of 4800 DOMsfor SN at Galactic center ( 34 σ )

Thomas Kowarik , ICRC 2009

Page 39: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 39

SN @ Galactic center in full IceCube

Page 40: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 40

IceCube Deep Core replaces

AMANDA

Page 41: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 41

IceCube deep core motivation• Open Southern hemisphere by using

surrounding IceCube as a veto• Increased sensitivity at low energy

– Measure atmospheric neutrinos in region where oscillations are important

• Irina Mocioiu, parallel session today

– Improves search for WIMPs from Sun

Page 42: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 42

Plan for completion of IceCubeCurrently 59 strings

18 strings in 09/10

9 strings in 10/11

Deep core:7 normal strings8 with 50 DOMs

below dust layer

Page 43: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 43

neutrinos

from

GZK

interactions

galactic

extragalactic

Slide byFrancis Halzen

Page 44: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 44

GZK neutrino limits

Angela Olinto, TeV PA 2009

Page 45: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 45

TeV PA 2009

Page 46: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 46

EeV ντ detection with Auger et al.

D. Gora<~ 1 GZK ντ / year in Auger

Γcτ ~ 100 km for Eτ ~ 2 x 1018 eV followed by τ-decay showerT. Weiler, D. Fargion

Page 47: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 47

Km3 telescopes can also do ντ

G. Miele--talk describeshow to unfoldneutrino

Cross section

Page 48: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 48

Detector was tested in pulsed electron beamat SLAC – Jeff Kowalski

Page 49: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 49

Page 50: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 50

Page 51: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 51

Proposed detectors

ARIANNASteve Barwick

AURA at South Poledigitize signal at antenna cluster

--Hagar Landsman

Page 52: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 52

SPATS Geometry

400

320

250

190

140

100

80 m

Horizontal

Vertical

Testing acousticdetection at the

South Pole--Justin Vandenbroucke

Page 53: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 53

IceCube as a test facility

• Radio antennas/transmitters to study future Askaryan radio array

• Acoustic pingers/receivers to measure speed of sound, attenuation length in ice

• Ultimate goal is 1000 X IceCube sensitivity for cosmogenic neutrinos

• Proposal for radio array is in preparation

Acoustic pinger,photo by Justin Vandenbroucke

Page 54: Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy€¦ · Neutrino & γ-ray astronomy Looking for signals directly from cosmic-ray sources Q: why is this needed? Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 2 The Galactic

Berlin, 2 Oct 2009 Tom Gaisser 54

Proposed Askaryan Radio Array

David Besson, TeV PA 2009