Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main...

43
Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University STARRY Final conference, June 2019

Transcript of Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main...

Page 1: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

Magneticfieldsofpre-mainsequencelow-andintermediate-massstars

E.AlecianIPAG,Grenoble-AlpesUniversity

STARRYFinalconference,June2019

Page 2: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

MAGNETICFIELDMEASUREMENTS

Page 3: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

Zeemaneffect•  ifBl≠0

→ linesplitting→ linecircularpolarisation

•  Intheweakfieldapprox.: Δλ=Cgλ2|B|

V=-Cgλ2(dI/dλ)Bl

J ~ 0

J > 0

I/Ic

I/Ic

Q P

V/Ic = Q - P V/Ic = 0 Longitudinal

magneticfield

Δλ

Modulusofmagneticfield

Page 4: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

Zeemanbroadening

Johns-Krull2009

TiIlinesBsensitive

COlinesBsensitive

Page 5: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

ZeemanbroadeningWhatdowemeasure?

I(λ)

Δλê f|B|

ê <|B|>

f:fillingfactor

Page 6: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

ZeemanbroadeningWhatdowemeasure?

I(λ)

Δλê

Σfi|Bi|

ê <|B|>

f:fillingfactor

Page 7: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

Disk-lockingprediction

Johns-Krull2009

|B|ImportantforunderstandingdynamosprocessesNOTformagnetosphericaccretionprocesses

Page 8: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

Zeemaneffect•  ifBl≠0

→ linesplitting→ linecircularpolarisation

•  Intheweakfieldapprox.: Δλ=Cgλ2|B|

V=-Cgλ2(dI/dλ)Bl

J ~ 0

J > 0

I/Ic

I/Ic

Q P

V/Ic = Q - P V/Ic = 0 Longitudinal

magneticfield

Δλ

Modulusofmagneticfield

Page 9: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

StokesVObservations*High-resolution spectropolarimeter:

ESPaDOnS @ CFHTNARVAL @ TBLHARPSpol @ ESO3.6mSPIRou @ CFHT => Require multi-line analysis

Multi-lineanalysismethods:-  PCA(Semeletal.2006)-  SVD(Carrolletal.2012)-  LSD(Donatietal.1997)

noise noise

I(λ)

V(λ)

Page 10: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

VI

LSDmeanprofiles

ZeemanVsignature

VèBl èLargescalefield

Page 11: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

©O.Kochukhov

ZeemanDopplerImaging

Page 12: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

ZDIofTWA8A 1. MonitoringoverfewProt2.  Sphericalharmonicdecomposition3.  PotentialfieldextrapolationHill+2019

Page 13: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

Photospheric+CaIRTlinesLkCa15,Donati+2019

Page 14: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

MagneticpropertiesinTTauristarsMAPPandMaTYSSEprojects(PI:J.-FDonati)ESPaDOnS,HARPSpol,Narval

Hilletal.(2019,2017),Donatietal.(2019…2011)

Page 15: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

TheHerbigAe/Besurvey

Convective-Radiativelimit

Alecianetal.(2013)

ESPaDOnS,Narvalobservations

Page 16: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

BasicMagneticpropertiesHerbigAe/Bestars

•  300G–3kG•  Dipolar•  Stable

•  Fossilfield(noncontinuouslysustainedbydynamo)

TTauristars

•  1to5kG•  Topologystrongly

dependentontheinternalstructure

•  Highlyvariable

•  Dynamofields

Page 17: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

THEORIGINOFMAGNETICFIELDSINRADIATIVESTARS

Page 18: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

0.5M¤

4M¤

Rad.Core+

Conv.Env.

FullyRadiative

Conv.Core+Rad.Env.

FullyConvective

PMSevolutionofthenakedstar

Alecian+2013,Villebrun+2019

Page 19: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

PMSevolutionofthenakedstar

low-massprotostar

3M¤PMS

=>3M¤ZAMS

Page 20: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

PMSevolutionofthenakedstar

low-massprotostar

3M¤PMS

=>3M¤ZAMS

Allstarsgothroughafullyconvectivephase

Page 21: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

FieldrelaxationduringthePMSphase

Norotation§  Numericalandanalyticalwork:

⇒ Mixedstableconfigurations(Braithwaite&Nordlund2006;Duezetal.2010;Duez&Mathis2010)

Withrotation§  Lowestenergystate:dipolarfields§  Initialhelicityandangularmomentum

impactthefinalstate(Emeriau&Mathis2015)

Page 22: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

Backin2014

Page 23: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

Backin2014Herbigstars Low-massstars

Page 24: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

Backin2013

?

Intermediate-massTTauristars(IMTTS)

Page 25: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

IMTTSSurveyESPaDOnS+HARPSpolsnapshotobservations38targets(PIs:Alecian,Hussain)

Page 26: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

IMTTSSurveyResultsVillebrunetal.(2019)

©Villebrunetal.2019

Page 27: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

IMTTSSurveyResultsVillebrunetal.(2019)

©Villebrunetal.2019

Magnetic

NotMagnetic

2%M★

25%R★

Page 28: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

IMTTSSurveyResultsVillebrunetal.(2019)

©Villebrunetal.2019

Magnetic

NotMagnetic

2%M★

25%R★

Page 29: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

HOWNON-MAGNETICARENON-MAGNETICSTARS?

Page 30: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

Blimitdetermination•  Hypothesis:adipolarfieldmaybehiddenintheVsignal•  MCsimulations

–  i,β,φrotrandomtrials–  Bdfixed–  ComputenoisysyntheticVprofiles

–  Computethe#ofdetection

Alecianetal.(2016),Alecianetal.inprep.

Page 31: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

Blimitdetermination•  Hypothesis:adipolarfieldmaybehiddenintheVsignal•  MCsimulations

–  i,β,φrotrandomtrials–  Bdfixed–  ComputenoisysyntheticVprofiles

–  Computethe#ofdetection

Alecianetal.(2016),Alecianetal.inprep.

90%

300G

HD142666

Page 32: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

Magnetismatintermediate-masses

AdaptedfromVillebrunetal.2019

Page 33: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

Magnetismatintermediate-masses

AdaptedfromVillebrunetal.2019

Page 34: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

Magnetismatintermediate-masses

Blim<500G

Alecian,Lebretonetal.inprep.

Page 35: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

Accretionsignaturesinpoorly-magneticstars

Blim<500G

Alecian,Lebretonetal.inprep.

HD142666

HeID3

PAR1394HeID3

Page 36: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

Accretionsignaturesinpoorly-magneticstars

Blim<500G

Alecian,Lebretonetal.inprep.

HD142666

HeID3

PAR1394HeID3

Page 37: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

Accretionsignaturesinpoorly-magneticstars

Blim<500G

Alecian,Lebretonetal.inprep.

HD142666

HeID3

PAR1394HeID3

Page 38: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

TakeHomeMessages•  B-fieldofTTSbecomemorecomplexastheconvectiveenvelopebecomethiner

•  WTTSandCTTSshowsimilarfieldproperties

•  OnceMCE<2M★ magneticfielddisappears,withinfew0.1Myr(forM★<3M¤)

•  SomeHAeshavelowB-fieldbutshowstrongaccretionsignatures

Page 39: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

What’snext?

Page 40: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

MonitoringIMTTS

©Villebrunetal.2019

HavebeenmonitoredwithESPaDOnSandHARPSpol

What’snext?

Page 41: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

MonitoringIMTTS

©Villebrunetal.2019

HavebeenmonitoredwithESPaDOnSandHARPSpol

What’snext?

Workinprogress=>Bfieldpropertiesandevolutionbeforedisappearing

Page 42: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

TheClassI/Flat-spectrumobjectswithSPIRou

Addressmagnetism,rotationandaccretionprocessesduringtheembeddedphase

What’snext?

Page 43: Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate ... · Magnetic fields of pre-main sequence low- and intermediate-mass stars E. Alecian IPAG, Grenoble-Alpes University

THANKYOU!