M r O r’ R d ( ) q R -...

89
R r’ r O M R q d ( ) r 0

Transcript of M r O r’ R d ( ) q R -...

Page 1: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

Ω

Rr’

r

O

M

Rqd ( )

r0

! "# !$% &'%"$!# )(! *'#

+-,/.102.436587+-,/.:9<;=,>[email protected].:,$7=,JIK;%LNM:GHOQP=,7=,RMTSU3F08V,W.EGX36P=Y[Z\'58G^],/.:M2G^08V,`_a,/5=.EGbIcBGX589R3A.8V,DZ=d`36589eLf

Page 2: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

!" # $

%"$!# )(! *'#

%&(' ' )+*#,-

.0/21436587:9 ;<1>=?52/A@CBEDGF4;H36=JIK1"=J52/L7MDNFO1"PRQDG5S36=JDNFTI:P2UKF"=JV89MDGFWDH1X7 DZY?D[9M3\F3\D[Y?]^1"=J52/MF _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ `ba

c _\dfehgSijk(lnmpoqknr>sot ij u"jvsql+r gxw moyfz"jvu"zM|?~j#kj moj e sqj _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ c _ ix sz4o u"jm gSij ! oqj#mu"jm ehg l!knr>m\o j l e o m u>l!kj hl!sqjm _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ 4_ ix sz4o u"jm gSij ! oqj#mu w l!koqy0z"jm _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ c _\d0w mJjkjml l u " k ju"ju"j ijmu"jvsoj ij _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ c _\ z mz"mKz o j mohl!o j:j r gxw mpoqyfz"j __(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ c

PM]I=1"3\D @ 367 3\DGF7 D¡ S3\]/ 7MD[9M3¢7MDLV9 DGYpV9 DNF£I:PRQD[/M52¤¦¥DG/ DNFI:P2UKF"=JV89MDGF _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ c

c _"§ jm " k jmu"jvsql~r gxw moyfz"j _(_(_(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ c _"¨ l!s w mj:u"oqkj mpo " jssqj _(_(_(_(_(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ c a _ c _"© o u"j ojmmpj _(_(_(_(_(_(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ c a _ _ i j ojvu ijxl! ij#jr\l z jvj ªfr>s mo « z e s ij¬l!o j _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ c­

4_"®gij " kOj jmsqo ij#m~l+s¯l l ohl°o __(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ c±4_ c _"² omphl e jv³Gj j `?d sjoqs _(_(_(_(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ c±4_ _"© k~ ju´ ij# oqsjmu>l m8sqj#m8xl!s¯lª4oqjm _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ !

_<®gSij " kµj j#mMsqo ij#mnls´¶o j l e o ijsqj e oyfz"jj# e knr ij#oo l ohl°o ` o j l e o ijsj e oqyfz"j _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ _ c _"² okj mo j# ij j oj e l l e ij oqmpoyfz"jmu"jvs·´¸l° kjMu´ gw u "j j _(_(_(_(_(_(_ _ _"¹ l!z4jz klª"oqkl!sqjKu"jmk hl! jm _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ _¶4_"º l!mpmj»u"j:s¯ln³Nj j _(_(_(_(_(_(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_

_"®gij " kOj jmu"o j m _(_(_(_(_(_(_(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ _ c _ ³[l!oqssqj u"jm " w l!zfª _(_(_(_(_(_(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ _ _"¼ l w " jkj K mmpoqsqjl x½¾ _(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ _¶4_4¿ ojmpmjvu´Àj x sHu"jm oqmjl!zfª _(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ a _ _"® u"z e o u´ ij j oqjr\l sqj#m8l ok(l!zfª _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ ­

Page 3: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

$ $

_ _"§ om8u´ ij e g j#sqsqjj >o s oqj _(_(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_

PM]I=1"3\D @ 51"=J52/MF¦QDGY<QD[¤LDG/214]=?36DNF 74QD[Y?D[;<1"3\5SF014]^1"=pV89MD _(_(_(_ c _\2g l jmr e z"jssqjmj#u"oqmp o>z4o m8u"j ehg l j#mr e z"jsqsjm _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ c _ c _\ g l j#mr e z"jsqsjm _(_(_(_(_(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_

"!#$ &%'% ( &%')* +, &-.0/1$2, 03 _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ 546879 % &$2: <;=)> &%')*$ &? +A@ %B30CD3&)E &F +, G+ &-B0/1$2, 03 _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ a?HJI /1$2 ()K 03&)L6%') 7 NM5OPRQ cTS.U + 7 VW%=):%X+F;Y)K #%'): & 7 & &)*D3&):)**Z#= " &)[+

0/1\; 7 & &)*0$Z#' _(_(_(_(_(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ a^]_` 2%a 03b+, (0/1\;c &) 7 dZ#6e;=)> &%')*$ &? &3 _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ ­

c _ _\d0w mp¬j#kjmu"j ehg l jm8r e z"jssqjm _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ 46 =f;= &$;YD30)*$%g+, &3<;=)> &%')*$ &^3G #)J+ 03G0/1\;Y3 _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ 46546 =C 7 &)*0$ 03 &)<%'h&*%a0 03 __(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ 46?H 9 % &$2: 7 & &)*30):)*ZT' b+i@ %j30CD3&)E &F G+, (&/1$2 03k;=%a#)= &? 03 _(_(_(_(_ c 46^]_` (+e;ml 7 & &)*30):)*ZT' __(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ c

_"² oqmp o>z4o m e o z"jmu"j ehg l jm _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ _ c _\ knr ! jknj ml!m w knr" oqyfz"j#m _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ _ _ ³ gij ! jkjvu"j:mz4r<j r mpoo m e l!sql!o j r z sqj r j ojs _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ _¶4_ ª"j#knr>sqjm _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ ­

465H R&&6n 0/1:2 7 _(_(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ ­465H546o ?3TZ#= 0/p$2 7 _(_(_(_(_(_(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ ±465H?HFI \;=&)K &F &%')q+^;=n X+c;=)> &%')*$ && 7 7 rEs2t%_+, u+?30)K%a v;'w6%a

+?30)*0*!T)*$%B% &)* _(_(_(_(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ _ _ ³ gij ! jkjvu"j:mz4r<j r mpoo « j e ! oqjssqj r z sqj ehg l!knr ijsqj e oyfz"j _(_(_(_(_ fc _ _ ª"j#knr>sqjm _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_

46xy R&&6n 0/1:2 7 _(_(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ 46xy546 z &)* 2%a |%dVW%'<&/1$2 7 _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ 46xy?Ho &K3$;Y/<E & <;=&):%=)k6%a ~0/1:2, %a%j%'d0F _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_

4_ ³ gSij ! jkju"jb:l!z"mm _(_(_(_(_(_(_(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ 4_ c _ i" e6ij»j 8o ij fj# _(_(_(_(_(_(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ 4_ _"¨ r"r>sqo e l°o m _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ a

H 46I /1\;c &)z;=)> &%')*$ &GE@ t-) 7 #0$ &6b+A@ % G+?30)*0$!#)*$%.3:;Y/ 7 &&*Z#= bZ#' # %_Z#= aH 46546kI /1[;u &)i;=)> &%')*$ &GEF@ %') 7 &&$ &6b+i@ 6%a G+?30)*0*!#6)*$%.3$;Y/ 7 &0*ZT' GZT' & 0%_Z#= !±H 46?H ;Y/<E # 03|6%'f0 7 #" &%')0/1$2 7 f &3 _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ !±H 46^]_z n% &%30C 7 &)*0$ 3$;Y/ 7 #0*Z#= _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ H 46xykI C%_+ (0/1$2 7 _(_(_(_(_(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ H 46*` ()K &3XE"@ 6)*?3T)*$%+.)/ 7 DaE &F G+, "[33 _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ a

_ j oqju´¶z m w mp¬jknjmu"j ehg l jm ij#r\l ojm _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ a c _ c _"²Oij t oo _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ a c _ _ ª"j#knr>sqjm _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ a c _¶4_"² j mo iju´ ij j oqj ij#sqj e mphl°oyfz"j _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ a c

_\d z e z j» ! knjsqsj:u"js´ ijsqj e mphl°oqyfz"j _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ a

PM]I=1"3\D @ 9MD[YJV89MDGF ]I I:Yp=J;]^1"=J52/MF ¥] 7MDNF I 365kY¥D[¤LDNFI:P2UKF"=JV89MDGF _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ a

c _"¨ kj u´ gxw u "j j _(_(_(_(_(_(_(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ a _"º oqsoqjzfª e u"z e jz mKj#8oqm sql m~l+s´ ij#yfz"oqso j _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ a _ c _\d z e z j»j#r r o ij ijm ij#s ijkj hl!o jmu"jm e u"z e jz mMj 8om s¯l mls´ ijyfz"osqo j a _ _ | 1 z"j e j! e u"j ml°jz m# e l°r\l e o ij _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ a

46 46 %f<= &%a0 &)f 8&$ #%')<+, ~;'&) 7 _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ a

Page 4: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

· h :!" $·$ $

46 46546kI %_+ &%p3T)> &6|3:;Y/ 7 &&*Z#= __(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ aa46 46?HkI %_+ &%p3T)> &6 ;an% _(_(_(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ a ­

_¶4_\ u"z e jz u>l m8z e g l!kr ijsqj e oyfz"j:j ª4 ij oqjz _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ a ± _ _"² o ijsqj e oyfz"jvu>l mz ehg l!knr ij#sqj e oqy0z"jj ªf ij ojz _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ a

4_ \! k~z"s¯l°o s e l!sj:u"z gSij ! jknju"jbl!z"mm _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ ­!4_ c _ 6! k~z"sql°o z oqu"okj mo " jsqsj _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ ­!4_ _ ij ij l!sqoqml°o m _(_(_(_(_(_(_(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ ­fc4_¶4_ yfz>l°o u"j ® oqmm _(_(_(_(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ ­fc

_\ z l ijsqj e oyfz"j _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ ­ _ c _"º uHjsqju"j ² z"u"ju"jvs¯l e u"z e o o ij ij#sqj e oqy0z"j _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ ­ _ _"© o u"j ijmpoqmphl e j _(_(_(_(_(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ ­ _¶4_"¼ ijmomphl e jvu"jv z"oj _(_(_(_(_(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ ­ _ _"¼ ijokjm l oql°>sqjm _(_(_(_(_(_(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ ­

_ s ijkj mu"jvk(l! ij mphl°oyfz"j _(_(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ ­a4_ z"jsqy0z"jm " o mu´ ijsqj e e o ij#oyfz"j _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ ­­a4_ c _ | u"z e o _(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ ­­a4_ _"¼ ijokjm l mo o j#m _(_(_(_(_(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ ­!±a4_¶4_"¼ ijokjmmo z"m u>l!zfª« ! e6ij#m _(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ ­

5H %=)d+=&):% _(_(_(_(_(_(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ ­5H546kI &) 3 7 &&$ _(_(_(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ ±5H?H 7 &3d%_% _(_(_(_(_(_(_(__(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_(_ ±4c

Page 5: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

$

QT ( ) $ %!

§ j ehg l°r>o j o u"z e o r r mj z j¡r ijmj hl°o u"jm¢ gSij ! ojm¢r gxw mpoqyfz"j#m j# u"jsqj#z m j#s¯l°o m _ |?sWl!o r\l oqm£l°r"rjs l u"jm " o m yfz´Àz ij#z"u"o¯l £\l ehg jsoqj £ jk(l oqmpjZr\l!m#k(l!om lCr z Jj e oqOu"j z o z r\l "! l k(l·o e knr>sqj# y0z"ompjmp z e z j l(r jmmo jkj l!z e z mKu"z e z mz"mMz o j mohl!o j lnkjmz j»yfz"j»s·´ ij#z"u"o¯l mjl!koqso¯l omj l~l!zfª e e j#r"mKu"jvsql~r gxw moyfz"j _

§ j ehg l°r>o j c l r z Jj e oq(u"j u " j l£s·´ ij#z"u"oql z joqu ijj u"jm ! u j#m u"j l u"jz yfz"j¢s´ j e j j r gxw mpoqyfz"j°l!o moWyfz"j¢u"jm j ehg oqyfz"j#m u ijjm mz s´¶l l!s w mju"okj mo " jsqsjnr z l° ! u"j z r >sjkj _ § j#m ehg l°r>o j#m»mz"o l m»m » j#m l!u"oo " j#sqm _

! #"%$&"(') +* ,!'.-0/&*21('. 3*4156/1738($#*256/&948(1;:<3=41(')>294/1 ?!*4')"4@/1A BCDFEHGJIKG&LMON&PHQRPTSUM E MVUDCE MOWXN DY STM LM%Z[M%W GJY\IKBC M W]P C ZKP^Q`_ ab BCDFEHGJIKG&LMON&PHQRPTSUM E MVUDCE MOZKP E S C M C&Y QcUM GJY M Qd BCDFEHGJIKG&LMON&PHQRPTSUM E MVUDCE M`Q DFefe M g I ZKPTS YJD QQRM gHSh BCDFEHGJIKG&LMON&PHQRPTSUM E MVUDCE MOi CY&LMjM e M%W]P E iM ek BCDFEHGJIKG&LMON&PHQRPTSUM E MVUDCE M G M%QRl LM Y\DG\C&Y M G M(QRl LM Y\DG\C&Y M mn opjq dsrst]bur4vh2v A v w DY\D ixl DY QyUM GJY M z|Q rstn ~2pjq db A v N&M E&YJ l DTY QyUM GJY M `Q rtn q db4h r6v E Mj G P E n q dbv(hur4v P C Z[M nq db v h r4v A rst P^Z G n q db4h r6v A rt P^Z G l DY QcUM GJY M Q rtn &q b A W]P C ZKP^Q`_QyUM GfY M aQn Tq b r6 A W]P C ZKP^Q`_xl DTY QyUM GfY MW C _3M aQ r6n +q b r6v A W]P C ZKP^Q`_xl DTY QyUM GfY MW DYJY&LM aQ r6vnq b rst A W]P C ZKP^Q`_xl DTY QyUM GfY M aQ rstn (q b v h rst A D QRlUM Y Ml DTY QyUM GfY MW DYJY&LM `Q r4vn q h rst A D QRlUM Y M n 3q d rst b r4 h A v efI M%QM Ee l DTY QyUM GfY M 3Q rstnq d rst b r4v h v A v w DY\D i zn q db v h rt A r6v PFNQ ¡n¢q d rst b r4v h A v efI M%QM Ee n £¤q db v A v N&M E&YJ

Page 6: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

· h :!"

"%$&"(') +* 4')7+*6'^$&"(') +* Mjl LM YJD STMOiM e l3P eJI[G\I P Ee

Y\I S IKE M`i CEyY MjlUM Y M P I EHG i PF_ e M Y DG\I P E9 M%W G M C&Y CEIKGJDFI[Y M

D W W Y P I efe M%QM EHG I E3EIKG&LM eJI Q D Z2iMOZ D W]PHP Y iP EE|LM M8 M%W G M C&Y Y M l LM Y\DTEHG ZKMl3P I EHG i PT_ e M Y DTGJI P E8 P C 8 ! #" M%W G M C&Y Y M l LM Y\DTEHGZ[MOl#P IKEHG i PT_ e M Y DG\I P E i&Mjl CIKeCE MOWXN DTY SFMi I e W Y UM G M

$ M%W G M C&Y Y M l LM Y\DTEHG Z% LMjZ LM(QRM EHG e P CY W MOWXN DY S LM8'& 8)(*$ M%W G M C&Y e M l DY\DTEHG ZKMOl3P IKEHG i PT_ e M Y DTGJI P Ei&MOZ D WXN DY STM e P CY W M

,+-+/. W]PHP Y iP EE|LM M e W DYJG&LM eJI M EE M e l3P C&YY Mjl LM Y M Y CE l#P IKEHG0 +213+2. W]PHP Y iP EE|LM M e W Z IKE i Y\IKBC M e l#P C&YY Mjl LM Y M Y CE l#P IKEHG0 +245+/1 W]PHP Y iP EE|LM M e e lN LM Y\I BC M e l3P CY Y M l LM Y M Y CE l3P I EHGi 8 i LMjlZ D W M%QM EHGcLM%Z LM(QRM EHGJDFI[Y Mi 8 i5 9 76 i8- 99:6 i;. 9< W]PHP Y iP EE|LM M e W DYJG&LM eJI M EE M ei 8 i 0 9=>6 0 i81 9?@6 i8. 9< W]PHP Y iP EE|LM M e W Z IKE i Y\IKBC M ei 8 i 0 9=>6 0 i84 9AB6 0 eJIKE 4¤i81 9? W]PHP Y iP EE|LM M e e lN LM Y\I BC M eiC'D i8ED i 0 LMjZ LM(QRM EHG iMOZKP E S C M C&Yi LMjZ LM(QRM EHG iM eJC&Y w D W Mi8F LMjZ LM(QRM EHG iM PFZ C QRMG efCY w D W MH efCY w D W M w M Y Q LMjM

I Y\DTE iM CYJecLMjZKMjW GJYJI BC M e

J WXN DTY SFM LM%Z[M%W GJY\IKBC M¡ &efG UM(QRMWXN DY S LMop l3M Y Q IKGfG\I IKG&LM`i C I i&M~2p l3M Y Q LM D _ I Z I[G&LM`i C I iMK>LNM@LPO w P Y W MOW]P C ZKP^Q`_ I M EE MOMRQ&M Y W LMjMl DY J eJC&Y J & LNML O LM E M Y S I Ml3P G M EHGJI MjZ ZKM`i Cxef&efG UM(QRM J M G J &S L WXN D QRl LMjZKM%W GJYJI BC M`W Y&LM LMl DY JS:T WXN D QRl LMjZKM%W GJYJI BC M`W Y&LM LMl DY ¡ L l3P G M EHG\I M%Z LM%ZKMjW GfY\I BC MW Y&LM LMl DTY J T l3P G M EHG\I M%Z LM%ZKMjW GfY\I BC MW Y&LM LMl DTY ¡UBV S W C Qyi C WXN D QRl S UDGJY\D M YJe Z DeJC&Y w D W M H: QRP^QM EHG i I l3PFZ DTIKY M i&M EeJI[GLM PFZ C Q IKBC Mi&MOWXN DY STM e i&M EeJI[GLM eJC&Y w D W I BC MOiMOWXN DY STM e i&M EeJI[GLM`Z I E|LM IKBC MOi&MOW]N DY STM eX i&M EeJI[GLM`iMW]P C&Y\DTEHGYZ[\!]%^ _P\ I[G M efe M QRP M EE MiM e W]N DY STM e IKEHG M EeJI[G&LM`i C W]P C&Y\DTEHG` G M EeJI P ELM%Z[M%W GfY\IKBC Macb |P C ` %b IKEHG M EeJI[G&LMOM G G M EeJI P E M EyY&LM S I QRM DTYJI D _#Z[M W]P E i C W GJI I[GLM LM%Z[M%W GfY\IKBC M W D l D W IKG&LM Y&LM eJIKefGJDFE W M LM%Z[M%W GfY\IKBC M¢ W]P E i C W GJDFE W M£ DTCG Ped I E i C W GJDFE W M

Page 7: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

` %!

-,2**#& T-- &n,2*#-*O-- T- #-!O,",-!#)#*#&$

` 03 ))*t&):%p3s+, cn 2thf) 7 &%.+ f2% 7 &)30" &)B+, u@ 7 & &)*0$#) 7 '% 3p@ 7 &)> &%_+, #%')( 3TZ#W@ E.+, 03(+?30)K%a &3d0) 3d #%p30*!# &3)\'@ 03&)A;=6" &n.Z#W@ &? 03%=) 7 &) 7 "!&3d &&h 7 f 03;'+ 03|C, &-vhf6 2y 03 U ;= &6)kC h+A@6) 03)*),&)*$%p3Z#6 3p@ 7 &)K #%_+, &%')NEF+, 30_;= #))> 03+30):%a 03bZT @ #? 03G%') 7 D0/1;y; 7 ( ,3dZ# @ $&FE"%D3G!&3f &0h)$%p3

|?mll e© j* ,+ t) 7 (+i@;a)*ZT' c a ­

² l mµs¯l l°z j!8y0z>l° jXo j l e o mµ u>l!kj hl!sjmOmz.-nmj Or z u ij e o j£l s´ g j#z jl e z"j#sqsqjEs·´¶j mpjk>sqjEu"jmr gij " kµj jm r gw moqy0z"jm >mj l°>sqj#m r\l ko e jzfª y0z"oµm e knr oqm»>oj j j u"z0/»|Js j#mpj g jz jz"mj#kj j e ! j£u"j " k~ jzfª¡k w mp¬j jm j r gxw moyfz"j _ _ sqsqj#m rHj j µl«u"j#m ij ehg jsqsjm» jmvu"o j mpjmj# o j p j o u"j#myfz>l o ij#m u>l!kj hl!sjm sqjm e g l jmGy0z"o jm vr\l!m e s¯l!o jkj »u ij#t ojmNk(l!oqm u l!u"kj#s¯l rj o j e j j l!oqm u"j sjz m j z"m j ªfr>sqo e l°o j#m _21 u " j lEz ju"jm e or"o yfz>l!sohl°o jMu"j e jm8o j l e o m8u>l m e jvyfz"ompz"o _

354 %,6-' )7*¬' ¬*98:-0 X-:#);<=*O-: >@?A> B-' -*CB-D#-§ lFE6GHJILKNMPORQASPH © j9* c a ±x­ jmJGz j gSij ! oju"js¯lUTWVNXAY[Z $]\_^A` yfz"o ijo s´ ij x sqz4o jkr ! jssqjKu"j#mu"j# ijmu"jMsqo<j ij u ij e o l z m w mp¬jkj _J1 rj#z4j ! k~z"sj s´ Jj 2u"jk(l oj jl!mmjba ij ij l!sjvm z"ms¯l+ ! kjdc

8!6fe"" e"h ge04Tq"· ¯! h e"h ih>°2jke"<l· m on.phTrq##? he",j^6·84 rs

¨ j ee j#ju ij#t oo O j#mp o e o ju"jsqlk ij e l oyfz"j!6s¯lu " ijj~u"jm ehg l!knr>mMu"j ! e jmr oj u´¶z j l!z4 j gij ! oqj!j u"j g ! mu"z e j ª4j8mp o e u"j8s¯lvk ij e l oqy0z"j ·j ª4jknr>sjmtc l ohl°o z ! e j u"j z"s ks _N§ ´ ijyfz>l°o u´ ij x sz4o j#knr ! j#sqsqj(j#mp~sqjr o e or<j

c

Page 8: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

o 03d&&e;_)*$%g+, 03)/ 7 D0$ &3<;Y/,C30*Z#= 03

K ')7+948(/ efDFD W Mj G P E D dH P CYuD W W LMjiM Y UD iM e _ I PTS YJD lN I M e i&MlN &eJI W I M Ee DP E l3M CG W P EefC Z G M Y !#"$!%'&()*,+-%&)/.(0/1+2&#13#45 #&6(07$&/8 //97: /' :+'/13)

u>l!kj hl!sHu"jvsqlu w l!koqy0z"j8;=<?>uA@uCB QEDGF c

zH@ QEI jmp8z j»yfz>l o iju w l!koqy0z"ju ij t oqjvr\l s¯lKJ ORM GHMLtKCN_ORQASPHPO Q Z$QZ$R >j#r\l z jr r o ij# ijvu"jmr\l o e z"sqjm I 6sql+kl!mmj:o j oqjssqj _

§ ´ GSUT HJIVNXWZY[LFK]\ M GHN O-^3LFH º lªo*2jsqs· c± a jmJz j gij ! oqj u"jm`_8aAY[Zb@dc ·j# u"j:sqj#z ij x sz4o u>l m s·´¶jmJr\l e jSj# sjjkr>m e ij ijm[r\l u"jmecf ^[g _ ` cSl°r"r<js ijj#m e g l jm ijsqj e oyfz"jm _d µ 6Jj#rjz48m´¶j ª4r okj m z"m8sql ! knj8!6Ae"" n!6Fe0¬ih n4 e" h>°p4h9m Oj mPk· n°Wj^ 4mlg j m4p? hm j?m mN on.phh h>° j ?n[npo¡ ?nJnUqrnJnts hj eLn! \is

§ jm ijy0z>l°o m u>l!kj hl!sjmm e jsqsjm8u"j º lª.*2j#sqs;vu>,cu"o `o Q wxy F g fMz o Q|~: R Fu"o `q Q F g fMz q QE]3 : RVe

K ')7+948(/K D QRM e a|ZKM Y g D Q&|MjZ Z%DV#3PdM G M E i Y\I W]g EHG PHP E P Y M EHG D] d&;<2> 4D i &ED Q I BC M E Mj G P EI M EE MM efGcLM G\C i I LMjMM E l Y M%Q I UM Y M DFEE|LM M^;vu> M e;LM BCDG\I P Ee i&M D Q&|M%ZKZ+M G Z% LMjZKMjW GJY PHQ D S E|LM GJI e QM e P EHGD _#P Y i LM e M E iM C Q I UM(QRM DFEE|LMjM^

Page 9: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

S# Hh :!" # jm ijy0z>l°o mSj l q j z j ijyfz>l°o u"jKr r\l!xl°o u"jm ehg l!knr>ml»sql ojmmj Q

c s´ ijsqj e k(l! ij#oqmkjGjmpNu e l!z"mmpoz j^ gij ! oqju"jm u"jm ijsj e kl! ij#oqy0z"jm _® z e " l js´Àjj#u"jm ehg l!knr>mSmpz u"jmSm w mp¬jknjmu"j8r\l o e z"sjm ehg l ij#jm2j#Smpz"o f js´ ij x sqz4o jknr ! jsqsju"j e jmr\l o e z"sqj#mr\l sqlvk ij e l oqyfz"j°os6j#mp ij e jmml!o jMu´¶o u"z"o jz J YAS T K]\ H j j8sjmu"j#zfªn gij ! oqjm _0² l msj e l!mu"j8s·´ ijsj e kl! ij#oqmpkj!!sj e z4r>sql!jjmp8 z or\l s·´ ijy0z>l°o u"j § ! j a cfx!

D Q O o Kq 1 rjz4~u e r r mj z m ehgijklOl!mmjba ij ij l!su´¶z j gSij ! oqjr gw moqy0z"j! l!s¯l°>sj

u>l m«z e j ª4jXu " ij ·u ij#j ko ijWr\l sjm ij ehg jsqsjm«u"jTs z"jz r\l j ª"jknr>sj&nyfz"ou ij#r<j uOu"jvsql l°z jvu"z«r >sjkj ij#z"u"o ij=c

6 GHY[W_ORHWH^ J K LM^ e >"e"h cf ^[g _ ` c _:aAY[Zb@dc nJnts h2h # 6 s 6 h M_KtLORQASPH s p n4 ? j^ hq e"h T `Mg` cT ` $! `,g z `e"h jH°¬ n! h on°(µ=e"hK h>° je"Fl· hrs" µ Ce j h¬°rn° eh n[nns h!onbj h+he" n# h !jH° n!6%$ MXN_HW K_IVN_O-YWM m^hdl· #h !6,e >" !jH°¬De"h: h>° jMh jH°8 h8 on° hrs

& $')()/$#9 =+* E M`M eJBCI eJe MRi CE M G N LMjP Y\I MOWjZ DTeJefI BC MRi&M Z D i &ED Q IKBC M`iM e &efG UM%QRM e iMl DYJG\I W C ZKM e WXN DTY S LM M e M ExIKEHG M YJD W G\I P E º lªo*2jsqs § ! j a © j* i sqj e k(l! ij#oqmkj z4r>s¯l!j ºij e l oyfz"jOj#F['j D jAQ Oj o j q uA@ j

uCB QED j, ,

o F q -/. g j 2Bj F j 2Bj1 r z l!o >oqj j j u"z r r mj z m ehgijkl l l!s z"j j e g omoqmpml ¡sql

l ohl°o e kkj gSij ! oj2u"jm e g l!kr>m u ^sjm m z e j#mm ^sjm u"oqmp o>z4o m u"j2k(l!mmj#myfz"o e ijj Ksqj#m ehg l!knr>mu"jv ! e j#m8u"jv l ohl°o _

0 4 132 &r*#& T- - &n,2*#- T- O)+' 54 *r=^- ,) *#&6 & T)+' -! )d#- u ij#r>o u"jWs´Àj ª4 djkj e kr>sqj ª4o ijµu"j#mr gij " kOj jmr gw moqy0z"jm >mj l°>sqj#m2yfz>l° j$ XXz `g YM_5z $ fLX c87 fgX TAY[Z ` XXz Y ` c j# sqjmT gSij ! ojm u"jm ehg l!knr>mXyfz"o+sqjz m l!mm e o ij#jm

rj kj#j u´Àj ª4r>soqyfz"j sql+ l u"j:kl# ! o ijMu"jm r gij " kµj jmr gxw moyfz"jmmz u"jm ij ehg jsqsjmu"j s z"jz l!z"mpmo l o ijjmyfz"j c9:!; c9<:!= k hl!oqssqj e l l e ij ompoqy0z"jXu"z " w l!z lc?>@; c?>BA k hl!osqsj e l l e ij oqmpoyfz"j:u"jvs·´DC o j m _² l mvz ju"jm e or"o ijs ij#kj hl!o j°sqjm e e j#r"m `e s ijm»o j j l vu>l m e jm gSij ! oqj#mm

o § lm z e jFE<oo § jr j oqjs ehg l!knr m e l!s¯l!o j&j#sj ehg l!knr ehg l!knr j e ! oqjs ~y0z´¶jssqjm e ij#j

m oG)H4JI+Sj# o H6!I+ ooqo § j e z4r>sql!jl j e z j+ gij ! ojnu w l!koqy0z"jjmJr mmo>sjns ! myfz"js´ ml!ovu ij#t o

s·´ ij j oqjOr j ojsqsjWu´¶z j m z e jWjmpE u>l m z ehg l!knr u " ij e ij ijTr\l z m w mp¬jknju"jm z e jmLK:NM"OQPFH¤JI3 Q E)GNO JI3 _W1 ml!oj j<j#»y0z"jnsqlu w l!knoqyfz"jk jy0z´¶z jr\l o e z"sj«mju ij#r>s¯l e j j m+sqjko ok~z"k u"j«s·´ ij j oqjr j ojsqsjm z"m:s´Àjj u´¶z jn ! e j D OQPFH JI+ Q ZRSUTV

ZXW ^ W z ^ W jmJ ! oj ij~u>l msj+mpj mu"jmYI e oqmpml m _

Page 10: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

o 03d&&e;_)*$%g+, 03)/ 7 D0$ &3<;Y/,C30*Z#= 03

0 10 20 30 40 50r

−100

−50

0

50

100

Ug,

Ω(r

)

sens de la force

K ')7+948(/ zP Y QRMl3P efeJI _#Z[MRl3P CY Z% LM E M Y S I Ml3P G M EHG\I MjZ Z[M`M Ge M Ee iMOZ D w P Y W M DTeJe PW I LMjM^

o C j e mJhl j e l l e ij oqml +s´¶o j mo ij(u"j(s´¶o j l e o _ d l l!sjz jmp+lJz"mp ijjr z N j u j e knr"ju"jm ijmz"shl°m j ª4r ij oqkj hl!zfªj#Nu ij#r<j uu"z ehg oªvu"z»m w mp¬jkju´Àz o ijm ehg oqmo _

C r\l l!kOj# j r z kj j j ij ou"j e jEs¯l kl oq jmpl°o u"j#m u"o ij j jmo j l e o mvjmp e j#sqz"ou"j(s´ ij e g j#sqsqjnu"js z"jz e l l e ij oqmpoqyfz"ju"z r gSij " kµj j ij z"u"o ijcehg l!yfz"jZo j l e o mjZk(l om jmpjr>sqz"m r\l o e z"sqoj jkj u>l m z j e j hl!o j xl!kkju´ ij e g j#sqsqj#m«u"jWs z"jz m ; > _2® l j ª4jknr>sqjl s´ ij ehg jsqsjTu"jTs´¶l° kj z u"jWs¯l k s ij e z"sqj!s´Ào j l e o ijsj e oqyfz"j u ko j jmµsql jkj Os·´¶o j l e o l ohl°o " jssqj y0z"ovjmJl!s ! m ij#sqoqjl°>sqj _¨ s´ ij ehg jsqsju"zm w mJjkj m sql!o j j + j l e g j°sjm Jj m^k(l e m e r>oqyfz"j#mij#hl jz4 jm ijsj e oyfz"jknj Rs·´¶o j l e o ijsqj e oqy0z"jAjmJ ijsqoj¬l°>sqj u"j l sql l ohl°o yfz"jKu"j#m2jj#m e z"k~z"s¯l°o m j u"j r ij#r u ij l j _4¨ zfª ij ehg jsqsjm2u"jKs z"jz oj j"xsqjm^u"jzfªno j l e o m^u o j j# jr omjmj e kr"j2r z j ª4r>soqy0z"j e j hl!o mr gij " kµj jm _4§ l g l!z4jz w r>oyfz"ju´¶z jMk hl! j8mpz z jKr>s¯l j#j ijmz"sjKr\l j ª4jknr>sqju"jµsql e knr ij oo j j«o j l e o m ijsj e oqyfz"jj# l ohl°o " jsqsjmpz s¯lTr>s¯l j#jj yfz"j#mpo _® sqz"mHz jr>sql j#jj#mpGs ij"j j°r>sqz"mGz jk hl! j rjz4 j# j ijsj ijj e l ml g l!z4jz k(lª4oqk(l!sjj#mpl°jo jSs ! mpyfz"jSsqlK l ohl°o r\l oqj 8l e krj mj s¯l e gijmpo u"z~m sqou"jjmmpj oqjssqjkj 8u"o e ij#jr\l u"jm8j<j#m ijsqj e oqy0z"jm _

K ')7+948(/ M e lZ Ce l3M G\I[G M eVLMjW]N&M%ZKZKM e i&MOZKP E S C M C&Y W]P EEC M e

; > a|MjZ D E M eJI S EI# M l DTe;E|LM%W]M efeJDTIKY M%QRM EHGBC M%ZKZKM E MNQ IKefG Mcl DTe M E i&M%N&P YJe iM!W]M!iP^Q DFIKE MDuQ DTI e lZ C&GP GBC M%ZKZKM M efG Q DFefBC|LM Ml3P C&Y i I M YJe M e YJDFIKe P Ee

Page 11: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

S# Hh :!" #

K ')7+948(/ Ml#N&P G PFS Y\D lN I M`i&MZ D P E MZ D lZ Ce S YJDFE i&M D Q DFIKe PF_ e M Y LM M^a|N D W CE i&M exl3P I EHG\e M e G CE M;S D Z D Q I M DTED ZKPTS C M0UD Z DE P GfY M BCI W P EHG\I M EHGOBC MjZ BC M e W M EHG\DTI E M e P CQ I Z Z I M YJe iMQ I Z Z I DY i e i LM G P I Z[M e W]PHQQRMZKM e P^Z[M I Z G\I[YLMi C;e M Y M CYseJC&Y Z[M e l CIKeJefDFE W M e iM DTC a !(/" %!4 : //(&&19/.(!/"$#%!)&/1'! 1$) | j l e o l ohl°o " jsqsj§ jWk z jkj (u"jWs¯l ehg z4jWu"jm e ! r>m z4 ij#z"u"o ijWj ªfr ij okj hl!sqjknj u"jTkl oj j l°o " jsqsj r\l l!sqos ijj u>l m sj o 8") 2thf6 +uHjmsql¢t u"zL ¿ | jkj moj e sqj!

k(l!om s¯l " o u"j e l!z"ml!sqo ij ´¶l°r"r\l l y0z"j¢r mp ij ojz jknj _ c a ±x­ (u>l m sqj#m 0%a#e;_*c")/' &)*$ © j* ijs¯l° ! j sjmO u"jkj mWu"j s¯lu w l!koqy0z"j j#Ou"j sql l ohl°o _ ³ z"m sqjm e ! r>m r mpm¬ju"j Rz j e l l e ij oqmpoqyfz"j u>l!kj hl!sqjl°r"rjs ijjk(l!mmpj( l ohl°o " jssqj8; > _^ ´Àjmp~z jyfz>l o ijr moo j(j ~j ª4j mo jyfz"om´¶j ªfr oqknjj ! _

K ')7+948(/ " I D Z I ZKM P I D Z I Z[M I D, 'd

K ')7+948(/ $# EHG M YJD W G\I P E S Y\D IKGJDTGJI P EE M%ZKZKM`M EHGJY MOZ D&% M YfY MM G Z D 4CE MFC e ! r>m~u"jk(l!mmj I e ijj j z4r o u"j(s·´¶jmJr\l e jz r j oqjs2 l ohl°o " js

G('JI32l°r"rjs ijr j oqjs j* oqj cG ' JI+ Q *)

II

; > LMjS D Z IKG&LM M EHGJY M Z D Q DFefe M S Y\D I[G\DG\I P EE MjZ ZKMM G Z D Q DTeJe M I E M YJGJI MjZ ZKMD YLM efC Z G\DGuBCI i LM%W P C ZKM i&M Z% PT_ e M Y DTGJI P EMNQ&l LM YJI QRM EHGJD Z[MQ DTI eE D iQRM G l DFe i I EHG M Y l Y&LM G\DG\I P EeJI QlZKMDHW]P EefGJIKG\C MZKM l YJI E W I l#Mi LM BCI D ZKM E W]M BCI w P E iMZ DG N LM P YJI MOiMOZ DY M%Z DTGJI IKG&LM`S LM E|LM YJD Z[M^

Page 12: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

o 03d&&e;_)*$%g+, 03)/ 7 D0$ &3<;Y/,C30*Z#= 03

|?sjmp so ijnl»s·´ ij j oqjM l ohl°o " j#sqsqj8yfz"jKr mpm¬ju"j:z j r\l o e z"sjKjmp u"jMkl!mmj IvP moz ijju>l m8sj x omo l!j:u"j I c

M ' P ' O !I+ Q I P G ' JI3 Q *)IKINPI

j e jmu"jzfª k(l!mmjm I j# INP m´Àj ª"j e j«z j ! e j l ol°o " jssqjyfz"o2j#mp z z ml° l e o j _ sqsju ij o ju"jSs·´ ij j oqjr j ojsqsjS l ol°o " jssqj _¬¨ o mos¯l ! e j2m´Àj ª"j e l mz I P l!z4!c

D ' P ' O !I+ Q uUM ' P ' O JI+u)I ^ W Q *)

I I PI > ^ W F a

z ^ W jmJKu"o oq ij:u"j I j m INP _>§ l e mphl jvz o j mjssqju"jsql l ohl°o l!z4) Q a a ­ ±x c 9:@: k ! 9<: m 9 > ­

§ l l ohl°o jmp:z j+o j l e o u"j+l!o>sqj~o j mpo ij!kl!oqmMyfz"oGu ko j«ls´ ij ehg jsqsju"zµm w mp¬jknjm sql!o j j#8u"js·´¶z o j m ·l!mp " koj! e mpk s oj&;> _

| j l e o ijsj e oqyfz"j|?svj ª"oqmJj u>l mOs¯l l°z j u"jm e ! r>mOyfz"o r mmj#u"j Tz j r r o ij# ij l°r"r<js ij#j ehg l jijsj e oyfz"j! " ijj O 0j# j ªfr oqk ij#jKj e z"s k>m _0§ jm ehg l j#m ij#sqj e oqy0z"jmSrjz j j# j

r mpoo jm z ij#xl°o jm _ ssqjm e ijj z r j oqjs ijsj e mphl°oyfz"jFG3JI+l°r"r<js ijMr j oqjse z"s k~>oj cG+JI3 Q O

I

jsqz"o `e oHu ij#j ko j:s´ ij j ojr j oqjssqj:u´¶z j e g l jjmJ OP l!z x oqmo l!ju"j O c

M P O JI3 Q O P G JI+ Q OOP I c

j sqjmµu"j#zfª ehg l jm ijsj e oyfz"jm O j# OP m´Àj ª"j e j z j ! e j u ij o l Wu"j s´ ij j ojr j oqjssqj!>u ij e z j jvj c­!±x r\l z"s kH

D P O JI3 Q uUM P O JI3u)I ^ W Q OOP

I > ^ W cc

l° l e o j mo O j# OP m Ku"j:moq jm r"r m ij#mKj# ij#r>z"sqmpo jvu>l msqj e l!m e l!o j _

§ l e mpl j jmpKl°r"rjs ijjr<j koo o ijMu"z ou"j ± ±x c±x­!±4c­ c 9:!> k 9: F c

3 c 9: k c

;> E W DY\D W G&LM Y\IKe MsZ% IKEHG M EeJI[G&LMuiM e2IKEHG M YJD W G\I P Ee l DTY i&M e W P Ee G\DTEHG M e i&M e GJY\C W GJCY M D BCDTEHG\I[G&LM e2efDFEe i I QRM EeJI P E i&P EHG Z D D ZKM C&Y;EC Q LM Y\I BC M Y M efG M!iP E W IKE WXN DFE S LMjM BC M%Z BC M e P IKG ZKM e &efG UM%QRM!i CEIKG&LM e WXNP I efI X P C&Y Z DS Y\D IKGJDTGJI P E D#W M efG

¢ v r v +

D MjWuZ D Q DFefe M i C l Y P G P E $ e r4v! gHS8DZ D W]P EefGJDFEHG M i&M Z DFE WXg / " r4# e M G Z D IKG M efe MOiMOZ D Z C Q I UM Y M %$ // & ('Qx e rst

Page 13: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

S# Hh :!" #

K ')7+948(/ a|N DY Z[M e d C S Ce G\I E iMyauP C ZKP^Q`_DZ/ d M G DFEe a|N Y\IKefG\IKDFE M YJefG MjiD d'T

K ')7+948(/ EHG M YJD W G\I P ELM%Z[M%W GJY P^Q D S E|LM G\IKBC MVUD Zc LM%WXN&M%Z Z[MOiMOZ% DTG PHQRM^

§ lW ! kjr\l o e z"sqoj j ·l e j#z vu"j e j#j e mpl j(r oj u"z ehg oª u"zRm w mp¬jkju´¶z o ijm _G§ ´Ào j l e o ijsj e oyfz"j(u ko j z"msjm»r gij " kµj jm»r gw moqy0z"jm~u"j(s´ ij ehg jsqsju"jEs´¶l° kj l e jssqju"js·´ g kknj r gxw mpoqyfz"jCl° koqy0z"j!r gw moqy0z"ju"z m sqou"j! ehg oqknoqj!>o s oqj '' ; > _^§ l e j#r\l oqjk(l! ij#oyfz"ju"j e j#j o j l e o l ij# ij z4u´¸l° ! uij#z"u"o ijjr\l 1 j mpju«j c±x! _

| j l e o ! j® z sqlu"jm e or"o u"jmr gij " kOj jmSmpz4\l° koqy0z"jmxr gw moqy0z"j z e s ij¬l!o jKj#r gw moqy0z"ju"jm:r\l o e z"sqjm ¹ joqmj <j µj#z ! lr* l o oo ij j m cf sql gSij ! oqj+u"jns·´¶o j l e o ! j _"1 r mpz"sqj r z e js¯lTs´Àj ª"ompj e j u´¶z j«yfz>l o ij u>l!kj hl!sj«l°r"r<js ijj ehg l j ! j z ehg l j g l!u oqyfz"j " ijjE<fy0z"o e ijj z r j oqj#s<r gSij " k ij " s oqy0z"j l°r"rjs ijr j oqjsHu"jz ! l * l c

G H JI+ Q Efj 9 WI c

z Q I c c9:!= k ;i>kjmpz j sqlZr ! ijjRu"jRs´¶o j l e o ! j!:l j eI ± c9 > ! sqlk(l!mmju"jmKr\l o e z"sqjmKl°r"rjs ijjmMk ijm m _ C mj e u z e s ij u"j ehg l j ! jE P "r>s¯l e6ijl+r ª"oko ijMu"z«r jkoj "r mpm¬ju"j»z j ij j ojr j oqjssqj

M H PFH O JI3 Q E P G H JI+ Q EQE P j 9 WI c

; > E W DTYJD W G&LM Y\I e M e P EIKEHG M EefIKG&LMOl DTY Z D W]P EefGJDFEHG M i&M efGfY\C W G\C&Y M #E M

J v op v # + P UC J ( '/ % r! a M efG Z D WXN DY STMOiMZc LM%Z[M%W GfY P E ;"> E l#M C&G LM Y\I M YBC M nq £ v#Or6v$# rt £ rst# £

Page 14: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

o 03d&&e;_)*$%g+, 03)/ 7 D0$ &3<;Y/,C30*Z#= 03

u Ku ij o jz j ! e jl w l Kl°r"r ª"ok(l°o jkj »l e z ju"omphl e js¯l+ ! kj

D H PFH O JI3 Q uUM H PFH O JI3u)I ^ W E > j 9 WI

c cI ^ W c a

§ l l!sqj#z l°r"r ª4oqk(l°o j«u"j Er z sqjm z e s ij mjmJu"j E c 9<: C _ d<_ | _ ; > _§ ´¶o j l e o ! jjmpSj r\l o e z"sqoj jmpr ml°>sqjKu"js¯l e gSijmo u"jm " w l!zfª(l° koqy0z"jm _ ssqjl!oj l!o8u ijXlTls·´ ij ehg jssqj:u"jm8y0z>l ! mls·´¶o j oqjz u"jm z e s ij m _

K ')7+948(/ ' M YJE M Y M IKe M E _#M Y S8D#3Pd;M G I iMjg IsC g D D D di#$F

K ')7+948(/ 8 EHG M Y\D W G\I P E w P YJG MVUD Z% LM%WXNMjZ Z[MiM e BCDY g e | j l e o l!o>sqj§ ´¶o j l e o l!o>sqjjmp~r>sqz"m+mz4"osqj _ sqsj z"j mpz z j(r ! ijj(r>sqz"m e z jj e ! j

yfz"js´Ào j l e o ! jµj# jr u"z"onr\l!mnu´ ij#hl°mnsqo ijm+j j«r\l o e z"sqj#m·jssqj ´¶jmpnr\l!m jmJr ml°>sj»u"jvr gij " kµj jmKu"j e gSijmo 6k(l!omo j oj Ku>l m8sql l!u"o l e o o ij >r\l j ª4jknr>sqj:u>l m8sql+u ij#mo ij l°o u"z j#z4 ; > c . 9

sqsqj»l ij ij ijsql° ! ijj j m cf r\l j ko2;=< y > _<§ l l!sjz u"jE2<sql ehg l j~l!o>sj!<jmJu"js·´ ! u ju"j Tc9<:!; C d | _G j#jo j l e o ij#hl «l jm e z jnr ! ijjnj u"jn j#m; > 4D W]P EefGJDFEHG M iM efGJYJC W G\C&Y M i&M0Z% I EHG M Y\D W GJI P E w P YfG MM efGxDTeJe M Q D ZW]P EEC M^ uZKZKMM efG i&M Z% P Y i Y M iM u i P UC Z D D ZKM CY D ll Y P Q I Q DG\I M`iMl3P CY ZKM eEC WjZ LMjP Ee ; > a) M e G DTC Z I|BCIuD LM(Q I e Z%N l3P G N UM e Myi&MyZc MNQ IKefG M E W]Mci CE M;l DTYfG\I W C Z[M E M C&GJY MD6Z[M E M C&GJY\IKE P8Di&MxQ DTeJe MGJY UM e w DTI _ZKMDl3P CY IKEHG M Y l YLM G M Y ZKMW DY\D W G UM Y MW P EHG\I EC i&M eue l3M%W GJY M e i LM(Q IKeJeJI P E! D GJY UM e i I#"LM Y M EHG\e i&M ese l3MjW GfY M ei I e W Y M G\e PT_ e M Y LM e i DTEe ZKM e i LM eJIKEHGLMjS Y\DG\I P Ee MRQ I efG M E W M;i&M e l3M%W GJY MVW P EHG\IKECE M;l3P C DTEHGRe MNQ&lZ I BC M Yi DFEe Z[MW P EHG MRQ G Mi CE l Y PT_#Z.UM(QRM UD i&M C QW]P Y l eVD M%W!W]P Ee M Y DG\I P E i&M Z% LM E M Y S I MM G iM Z D BCDTEHG\I[G&LM iMQRP C M%QRM EHG D I Z w D Z Z DFI[GVefC ll3P e M YBC CEGfY P I efI UM(QRMxW]P Y l e l#M Y QRM GJG\DTIKG CE M Y M%i I efGfY\I _ C&G\I P E i&MxZ% LM E M Y S I MciMQ DFEI UM Y MOW P EHG\IKEC MM EHGJY MZ[M e iM C QVl DTYfG\I W C Z[M e PF_ e M Y D _#Z[M e ;< y > E Z D W DY\D W G&LM Y\IKe Ml DYCE MOW P Ee G\DTEHG MOiM e GJY\C W GJCY MOiMOzM Y Q I

%$ v$ r'& +

Q DFIKe P E!E Ml3M CG l DFeyLM%W Y\I[Y MOiMl#P G M EHG\I M%Z P C i&M w P Y W]Ml3P C&Y W M GfG M IKEHG M YJD W G\I P E

Page 15: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

S# Hh :!" #

K ')7+948(/ $ P^Z[S DTE S DTC Z I D, dVM G E&Y\I W]PzM Y Q I D#$Rdi#

K ')7+948(/ LM efI EHG&LM S YJDTGJI P E i C ' p & Y

l!o>sjvo j mo ij°<jssqjvj#mpKu"o - e osqj lkj# jvj ij oqu"j e j»j# ´Ào j oqj Ky0z´ lns·´ ij ehg jssqju"jmr e jmmz"m8j jr\l o e z"sjm ijs ijkj hl!o jm _

§ jmr r o ij# ijmjmpmj oqjssqjmu"jmyfz>l° jo j l e o mm ijmz"k ijj#mu>l msqj hl°>sqj¬l!z e o `u"jmm z"m8j# sjm ij e g j#sqsqj#mu"j s z"j#z l!zfª4yfz"jssqjm sqj#mo j l e o m u ko j m osqsz"mp ijj#mmz s¯l+t>z jvmz"o l j _

& $')()/$#9K M e BCDGJY M IKEHG M YJD W G\I P Ee w P E i D QM EHG\D ZKM e *3"%/8($8F"%'. +*21

738($ Y ' "%$&"(') +*6*4/X( (./ @/X()/F"%8')>294/ 38%"j/ $' ' (./$c/:/8(/1 M G P E auP C Z[PHQO_/ sC g D D zM Y Q I #

M Y\efG M%i M I e M E _3M Y SG# D Q&uM%Z ZA 2 +928 ^/ Q DFefe M WXN DTY SFM LMjZKMjW GJYJI BC M WXN DY STM w P YJG M WXN DY STM w DFI _#Z[M J $ #"j/&*3"(')/X( 0 ( ¢ = t y L= ( = M r =@S*2/8(7+'./ :s "%/&*3"(')/X( ()/ 1% +948 F/1;: +*,T"(94/X( ()/1 ( ¢ O= t y LPL

O= ( O= M r =

+*41j"j$#*3"j/ ? M ¢ U rst]t t y p rst $ U rst@S <2/X( ()/ 56/() +*47+92/&948 - ! p rst p ( p rst & ( rt " rt & a|M e W]P EefGJDFEHG M e;E P EHG l DFeG P CG M e Z D Q M(QRM efI S EI W DTGJI P E P CY W P^QRl DY M Y ZKM e;I EHG M YJD W G\I P Ee D I Z w DTCGC&G\I Z I e M Y Z[M e W P Ee G\DTEHG M e i&M efGfY\C W G\C&Y MOi&P EE|LMjM e M ExE P G M e i&M_ DTe i&Ml D STM e

Page 16: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

o 03d&&e;_)*$%g+, 03)/ 7 D0$ &3<;Y/,C30*Z#= 03

proton

noyauatome molécule

100

physicien

montagne

103

galaxie1020

amas galactique 1023

1026

univers

système solaire

1012

cristal

-310

ForteFaible Electrique

<10

1010 10-9

-10

-15

Gravitationnelle

?

?

-14

"!$#&%('*) = +-,/.102*35476-298 02 ,:. 29;<;<2=8>6-2?;<@BADCBED2=EDFG8IHJ29AK3ML2=NOFG2=8QPR2=NS6-298UTVAWNO2=FG4 , NXT<@BAD8Y @BAZ6D4B352=AWNX4[;<2=8\35T<8O298"29A^]_2=E`L4 , 298 02 ,:. 29;<;<2=8ba

Page 17: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

!"# $% &132('*),+.-0/1'32 465!78-:9 &5!'<;=/15!784?>@2?ACB /1DE+?5F7GIHJKHLM#HNONPHJRQ#HSNPTVU#WVX#HXZY[WVTVXZ\]H1YU#HU^EKHW]_"NOH`(HU^aNOH1Ja^bMcKHT"YdOHJaQZeZUf_"`*dPghX#HJifj[dPJk^bT"YbdPghX#H l

`*HU]^,m#NO_<`nKHL_"U#dOghX#HFLNO_"JJdOgoX#HH1Jk^pNO_Cq#YbH1`*drH1YHF^bMcKH1T"YbdOHFQZeZUf_"`*dPghX#H"i#s:NONPHS_CLTVU#UoXEQ#H^Y,rH1JW"Y_"U#Q#J[JX#L1LVrHJmt_uq#qfNPdOghXcKH1HvU#T"^_"`*`*H1U^R_"X6JweZJk^,rH1`*HSJTVNO_"dPYbHSH1^*r_*Nxy_"Jk^YbTVU#TV`*dPHH1U6WzKH1UKH1Y_"Ni Xh|^Y,rHJIW"Y_"U#Q#HJKHLM#HNPNOHJzQ#HcNOTVU#WVX#H1XZY,muHNPNOHq~HXZ^=H1^YbHc_uq#qfNOdOgoXKHHFr_aNxyX#U#d\]H1YbJIH1^LTVU]^bdPHU^zHULHJHU#J[N_CLTVJ`*TVNPTVWVdOH<U#H1^bTVU#dPHU#U#HagoX#dz_q~TVXZYRfXZ^pQxKH1^_ufNPdPYaQ#HJR`*ToQtrHNOH1JpQxKH \]TVNOXZ^bdPTVUQ#HSNxyX#U#d\]H1YbJi

Xh|?^kYrHJRq~H ^bdP^bH1J.KHLM#HNONPHJ!Q#HCNPTVU#WVX#HXZY!HU@YbH1\u_"U#LM#H"mHNONPHvHJk^FdPU#L,_uq_ufNOHQ#HQcKHL YbdPYbHNPHLTV`(qT"Y^bH`(HU^H1^SN_EJk^kYbX#L1^bXZYbH(Q#HJ_u^bTV`*H1JH1^SQ#HJv`*TVNKHLX#NPHJq_uYH|#H`(qfNPH"i X[rH`*HJdrHLNOHum:NxKH`*H YbWVHU#LHQ#H.N_ E6GHJILKNMNORQWSPHdS_KWMXN_ORQWSPH ;<<2> =TVMZYEZZm0Q#HEYbTVWVNOdPH]"Zm LMZYTVQ#dOU#WVH Y3]Vhmt=T"YbUmj[HdOJkHUH1YbW#m_"X#NOd]Vhm '' !_JkXZYb`*TVU]^ZKH<L1H1^^bH<Q#dP*L1X#NP^hKH"itGI_`nKHL_"U#dOghX#H0ghXf_"U]^bdPghX#H0HJk^IX#U#H:^bMcKHT"YdOH0QZeZUf_"`*dPghX#H0_"XSJH1U#JzTVXSH1NONOHYbH1qTVJHcJkXZYX#U#HCKH1ghXf_u^bdPTVUQxKH \]TVNOXZ^bdPTVU._uq#q~H1NKHH6KHghXf_u^bdPTVUEQ#H LMZYTVQ#dOU#WVH1Yi

"!$#&%('*) = T<2=;V8 @ . Fw '#¡, @ EDTV8 6-2 FG@[CB;VT<2 $#¡ F¢ TVA +-,/. Fb£@B6ZT<ADC[2=Fw k¡$^2bN >4b¤ @[FXA] ¡Da LHJ@^Y,rHJ@q~H ^bdP^bH1J¥KHLM#HNPNOHJ6Q#H¦NOTVU#WVX#HXZY,m[NPHJ@q_uY^bdOL1X#NOHJ6H |#M#d~HU]^6Qf_"U#JL1H1Y^_"dPU#HJ

LdYbLTVU#Jk^_"U#L1HJ(X#U§L1TV`(q~T"Y^H`*HU]^TVU#Q#X#N_u^bTVdYbHN_@U#T"^bdPTVU¨LNO_"JJdOgoX#HQ#H^Y_©wHL ^bTVdPYbH3qH1YbQ_"NOT"YJ?JTVU¥JHU#J@L,_uY@dONSUxyHJk^?qfNPX#J?q~TVJJdfNOHªQ#H«JX#d\hYbHªdPU#Q#dP\ZdPQ#X#HNONPH`*HU]^?X#U#Hªq_uY^bdPLX#NOH,ghX#dqHXZ^<Q#TVU#U#H1Y*NPdOHX¥r_6Q#HJCqfMKHU#TV`.rHU#H1J(QxydPU^H1Yb¬1KH1YbH1U#LHJ*LTV`(`*H_\]H1LNPHJ<TVU#Q#H1Ji:­HNO__®q~TVXZY¯H H1^¯Q#H¥`*ToQ#dP°fH1Y§Yb_"Q#dOL,_"NPH`*HU]^±NOH1J±NOTVdOJ¨Q#H²N_®qfM]eZJdPghX#H²ghX#dm(JdEHNONPHJ±JTVU]^\u_"N_ufNOH1J³r_´NxKHLM#HNPNOH¨`*_"L1YbTVJLT"qfdPghX#H"mFQ#TVdP\]H1U^§H1^YbHnLT"YYbdPWKHHJµr_´NxKHLM#HNPNOHnQ#HJ¶JkehJk^,rH`*H1J`nKHJkTVJLT"qfdOgoX#HJ@TVXUf_"U#TV`nKH1^YbdPghX#HJ ;<2u> i!­=HJ?YbHN_u^dOTVU#J?U#TVXZ\]HNPNOHJ@¬TVU]^NPHªqfNOX#J@JTVXZ\]HU]^_uq#q_uY_ ·^YbHªX#U#H«ghXf_"U]^bdP°fL_u^bdOTVU¥Q#HJ@W"Y_"U#Q#HXZYJ@qfM]eZJkdOghX#H1J§goXf_"U^dP°fL,_u^bdPTVU²Q#HJ@U#dP\]H,_"Xh|QxKH1U#H1YbWVdOHCQ#HCNx¸_u^TV`*H"mgoXf_"U^dP°fL,_u^bdPTVUQ#HCN_*YhKH1JdOJk^b_"U#LH(QxKHNKH`(HU^JFQ#HCLdYbLX#dP^Jr_NxKHLM#HNONPHQ#HSgoX#HNOgoX#HJRUf_"U#TV`.rH ^YbHJm '' i:NOX#JaWKHUKH1Y_"NPH`*HU]^,mTVUEq_uYbNOHQ#H¹ ^ ORQASPH¦dS_KNMXN_ORQASPHNOT"YJghX#H¶NxyTVUºdPU#LNOXZ^nr_¨LHªL,_"QZYbHQZeZUf_"`*dPghX#HNPHJEq#YbToLHJJkX#J?QxydOU]^bH1Yb_"L1^bdOTVUmq_uY?H |ZH`(qfNOHKHNPHL1^YbTV`*_"WVUKH1^bdOgoX#H"iGz_`¨KHL,_"U#dPghX#H³ghXf_"U]^bdOgoX#H´HJk^¨L,_uY_"L1^hKH1YbdOJoKHH´q_uY§NO_®LTVU#Jk^b_"U^bHµQ#HcNO_"U#L ! m (» ¸¼ u½V¾V"¿V¿f¿V] ¼ 9 pÀ iyJm#H ^YHQ#TVU#U#HSNO_C`nKH1L,_"U#dOgoX#HFL1N_"JJdPghX#H*r_N_NOdO`(dP^bH . ¼ is:NONPHHJw^aqfNPX#JpWzKHUcKH1Yb_"NOHSgoX#HNO_<`nKH1L,_"U#dOgoX#HLNO_"JJdPghX#HFghXxyH1NONOHFdOU#L1NOXZ^,i

Á!H6`?H`*H@_"Xh|±^kYrHJÂW"Y_"U#Q#HJ\ZdP^HJJHJ1m=N_«`¨KHL,_"U#dPghX#H@LN_"JkJdOgoX#H¨ÃTVXµgoXf_"U^bdPghX#H*HJw^dOU#L_uq_ufNOH!Q#HRYbHU#QZYbHFLTV`(q#^HRQ#HJ=qfMKHU#TV`.rHU#H1JqfM]eZJkdOghX#H1Ji C UU#TVXZ\]H,_"XL_"QZYbH!LTVU#LH1q#^bX#H1N_«KH ^ZKH@KH1N_u~T"YhKH!q_uYascdPU#Jk^bHdPUªw ¼ VihÄNJx¸_"WVd^aQ#HFN_<Å H T KCN_OOÆWO N GH Å HM^'NXW_HJORMXN_H ghX#dt_"`.rH1U#HX#U#HU#TVXZ\]HNONPHL1TVU#LH1q#^bdPTVU<Q#HNxÇHJkq_"LHH1^0Q#X^bH`(qfJa¬T"Yb`X#NKHHU#T"^_"`*`*HU]^q_uY0È@dOU ! TpJ ! dH1^`*ThQ#d°fH¦L1TV`(qfNrH1^H`*HU]^NO_µQZehUf_"`*dOgoX#H ;=< > iFGz_¯YbHN_u^dP\Zd^hKHªYbH1qTVJH§JXZYN_µL1TVU#Jk^_"U]^bH V]¾"]u½"É ¼ `.iÇJ 9: H1^RYbHQ#TVU#U#HNO_(qfMehJdOgoX#HLN_"JJkdOghX#HEr_*NO_*NOdP`*dP^bH . Ê´is:NONOHLTVU]^bdOH1U^0Q#TVU#LN_pqfM]eZJdPghX#HLNO_"JJdOgoX#H"m"`3_"dPJzYbHJw^bHdOU#QcKH1qHU#Qf_"U^HaQ#HN_RqfM]eZJdPghX#H=goXf_"U^bdPghX#H"i

C U#HWzKHUcKH1Yb_"NOdOJ_u^bdOTVUm~L1TVU#Jk^YbX#d^bHHUnZ<q_uYFs:dOU#Jk^bH1dOUm~LTV`fdPU#HNOHJ[q#YbHJkL1YbdPq#^dOTVU#J!Q#HN_!YbHNO_u^bdP\hdP^hKHvr_L1HNONPHJcQ#HaN_!W"Y_\hdP^_u^dOTVUi"ÄNfJx¸_"WVd^:Q#HaN_SÅ H T KCN OOÆAO N GH@Ë GHJM GHMW K T H goX#dfdOU#LNPXZ^;<<2> 4 3 02 , 4BADTyÌ E-2Ì EZ4[AWNXTÇÌ ED2 2=8ON"29AD8O2=T<CBA 02b2 2=AM8O2 , @BAZ6 ,wÍ-, ;<2Ba;<2u>~Î A*ÏZ4[FG;<2S6-2U8 Í 8ONbL2*3 298 AD4BA-@B8 , @ÏZTyÌ E-298 ;<@[FX8Ì E-2>;PÐ @BA7298_N L4 ;Ð 02 ,/. 29;<;<2U6DE AZ4[AD@ 3ML2=NOFG2`HÑ 3RP 2bN 6D28 Í 8_NbL29352=8 3 02=8O@B8 , @ ÏZTyÌ E-298 L456D2=8 02 ,/. 2=;V; 298 TVAWNG2bFQ3 0296DTV4[T<FO298 ÏZ4[F"2¤-2*3Ï ; 2 ;<2^35T , FO@W3 L2bNGFG2 H2Ñ 3 P/a;< > 4`FG2=;V4 NXTÇÒ-T N 02 FO298_NGFG2=TVAWNO2Ï 2=EDN 2=NOFG2 4Ó @[FX6 02=2>29AÏZFO2*35T<2bF ,wÍ-, ;<2 354BT<8M8O@BA 02=NXED6-2 298_N C 029A 02=FG4B; 2*3 29AWN, @ 3Ï ; 02=N 02=2 4[ES8_2 , @ AD6 ,wÍ-, ;<2 a

Page 18: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

A ! "

"!$#&%('*)="$# ; Ó 2=FON TVAD8ONO29T<A A/b¡ &%\2bFQ354BADA STVA'B@b¢ 8' T A# ¡i#2bN)( ED;<2=8% 29A-FXT* @ T<A , 4[F 021 l#/ ¡i#$ a

"!$#&%('*) #+# ; Ó 2=FON TVAD8ONG2=TVA2=N S4[FONXTVA + ,/. ¢ 4[F 8 ,:. TV;<6 l/b¡3Da

N_@YbHNO_u^bdP\hdP^hKHYbHJk^kYbHdOU]^bHH1^*goX#daHJw^*dOU#Q#dPJkq~H1U#Jb_ufNOHEqTVXZY3_uT"YbQ#H1Y3NPHJ<q#YbT"fNrH`*HJ<NOdKHJ(_"Xh|LMf_"`(qfJ=Q#H[W"Y_,\Zd^_u^bdOTVU<dOU]^bHU#JH1Ji­H ^^bHp^bMcKH1T"YbdOH[HJw^=HU3q_uY^bdPLX#NOdPH1YL KHNrH1#YbHRq_uYN_JTVNOXZ^bdPTVUQ#H LM]_uY a JkLM#dPNOQ@LTVU#Q#X#dPJb_"U^Cr_<NxyH |ZdOJk^bH1U#LHQ#HF^YbTVX#JaU#TVdPYbJa_"Xh|`3_"JJHJ^Y,rH1JÂKHNPH1\:KHH1Ji

C U#H ^bMcKHT"YdOH QcKHL1YdP\u_"U^ r_ N_ ¬TVdPJ NOHJ qfMcKH1U#TV`?rHU#HJ _"Xh| qH1^bdP^HJ KHLM#HNONPHJ Q#HNOTVU#WVX#H1XZY H1^ _"Xh| W"Y_"U#Q#H1J8\Zd^bHJJH1J HJk^8¬TVXZYbU#dOH q_uY8N_ ¹ ^ ORQWSNH dS_KNMXN_ORQASPHÅ H T KCN_OOÆWO-^'N_H Á!dPYb_"L<]"É]H1^pLTVU#Jk^bd^bX#HSJTVX#JaJHJa¬T"Yb`*HJaNOHJqfNOX#JÂKH1N_u~T"YhKHHJ GHY[W_ORH^dS_KNMXN_ORQASPH^ Å H T KCN OOÆAO-^'N_H^ NH^ J KtL ^ KHNO_u~T"YhKHH1J®U#T"^_"`*`(HU^¥q_uY+, H eZU#`3_"Um LMadOU#WVH Y,m.-zTV`*TVUf_"W]_*H1^FÁ[eZJTVURNPHCL_"QZYbH^bMKHT"YbdPghX#HNOHqfNOX#JF_"LM#H1\:KH@r_NxÇM#HXZYbHC_"L1^bX#HNPNOH"m`3_"NPW"YZKH!JTVUEdPU#L,_uq_"LdP^hKHÂr_<QcKH1L1YbdPYHSLT"YYHL1^bH`(HU^pNOHJqfMcKHU#TV`.rH1U#HJRNOdKHJr_<N_CW"Y_,\ZdP^b_u^bdOTVUi

"!$#&%('*) * 4BED; # 6DFGT<2=AG>4[EDFGT , 2 T FX4 , #¡ Da

Page 19: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

!"#

"!$#&%('*) T ,:. 4 FX6 * . TV;<;VT Ï 8Z2 Í A 354[A e3¡i# ( ED;VTV4[A + 2 Í 3 @ E-F +-,/. ¢ TVA-C[2=Fk $#b¡ +-. TVA]Ð T ,:. T<FO@ % @W3 @BAZ4 C 4 ,b¡/R2bNZFG2b2*354[A(Za Í 8O@BA #¡Ga TVXZYR_u~T"YbQ#H1YaLTVU]\]HUf_ufNOH1`*HU]^[X#UEqfMcKHU#TV`.rH1U#HqfM]eZJdPghX#HSQ#TVU#UcKHum TVUÂq~HXZ^pXZ^bdONPdOJH1YaNOH1J

°fWVXZYbHJ ¼ iO,½!H1^ ¼ i¸ ¼ ;=< > i dOU#JkdmuqTVXZY:X#U#HQ#HJL YbdPq#^bdPTVU(LT"YkYbHL1^bHQ#HNx¸_u^TV`*H!w ¼ 9: ` mdON#HJw^

dOU#Q#dPJkq~H1U#Jb_ufNOHQ#HSQ#dPqTVJH1YaQ#HNxKHNPHL1^YTV`3_"WVUKH1^bdPJ`*H[H1^Q#HSNO_C`nKHL,_"U#dOgoX#H!ghXf_"U]^bdOgoX#H"i dtQ#HJH H1^bJNOdKH1J=r_Q#HJt\Zd^bHJJH1J!KHNPH1\:KH1HJIdPU^H1Y\ZdPHU#U#HU]^,mdON"¬ _"XZ^IQcKH1q_"JJkH1YzNO_`nKHL,_"U#dOgoX#HghXf_"U]^bdOgoX#H0H ^^Y_,\u_"dONONPH1Y=HU`nKH1L,_"U#dOgoX#H[ghXf_"U]^bdOgoX#HpYbHNO_u^bdP\hdOJk^bHuih TVXZY*KH1^bX#Q#dPH1YNOH[JweZJk^,rH1`*HRJTVNO_"dPYbHCw ¼ :!> ` mN_!W"Y_,\Zd^_u^bdOTVUH1^:N_!`nKHL_"U#dOghX#HLNO_"JJdPghX#HJXZ*JH1U^,mo_"NOT"YJ0goX#HqTVXZY:^kY_\u_"dONPNOH1Y0JXZY:NOH1J0^YTVX#JU#TVdPYJmfW"Y_\hdP^_u^dOTVUÂH1^aYHN_u^bd\Zd^ZKH[JTVU]^RdOU#Q#dPJkq~H1U#Jb_ufNOHJpH1^pNO_CYbH1N_u^bd\ZdP^hKHFWzKH1UKH1Y_"NOHFJxÇdO`(qTVJH"i

C U#H=¬TVdPJ QKH1^bH1Yb`(dOUcKHHJ NPHJ^bMcKHT"YdOHJ UcKHL1HJJb_"dYbHJmVTVUdPQ#HU^dP°fHNOHJIq_uY_"`.rH1^YHJzq~H Y^bdOU#H1U^bJ1mdOU#Q#dPJkq~H1U#Jb_ufNOHJFr_SN_FQ#HJL1Ybdq#^bdOTVU(Q#HJcqfMcKHU#TV`.rH1U#HJcqfM]eZJdPghX#HJL1TVU#JdOQcKH1YhKHJH1^cQ#HJ_uYbWVX#`(HU^JQ#dO`(HU#JdOTVU#U#H1NOJ¥TVU q_uYbNOHµJTVXZ\]HU]^±Qx¸_uYbWVX#`(HU^J¨QxKH1LM#H1NONOH,¦q~H1Y`*H1^^bH1U^¨Q#HºghXf_"U]^bdP°fH YghX#H1NOghX#H1JpT"YbQZYbH1JpQ#HFW"Y_"U#Q#HXZY,i

vitesses (c)

1

0.1

10 10 10 1012-15 -10 20

Mécaniquequantique

Mécanique classique Cosmologie(newtonienne)

Cosmologie relativisteDynamique relativisteMécaniquequantiquerelativiste

cordes ?

100 distances (m) "!$#&%('*) 8 + ,/.1029354?6-298 T 3:ÓDFXT , 4 NXT<@BAD86D2=8 N .102=@[FXT 298M6 Í AZ4B35TyÌ E-298 2=A Y @BA , NXT<@BA 6-29802 ,/. 2=;V; 298 6D2 ;<@BA-C E-29E-FX8 H 2=AU3ML2bNGFO298QP 2bN 6D2Ò-T<NO298O8O298 H 2=AEZADT<N 0298 PQa

?% >E7z- B5SB 5!7 BA (;:AC2@4 2?'3B ;:5 45 465(; &5!7 45 ),/¦5!;0- &5GT"YbJgoXxyX#UJkehJk^,rH`*H0HJk^LTVU#Jk^bd^bXKHQxyX#Uv^kYrHJW"Y_"U#QSU#TV`#YHQ#HLTVU#Jk^dP^bXf_"U]^bJKHNKH`*HU]^_"dYbHJm

JX#JL1H1q#^bdPfNPHJQxydOU]^bH1Yb_"WVdPYFw[`(TVNOHRQ#H[W]_ a q_uY=H|#H`(qfNPH[LTVU]^bdOHU]^¿ ¼ > _u^bTV`*HJmhdON Q#H1\ZdPHU]^dONPNOX#JTVdYbHCQ#H(q#YhKH1^bH1U#QZYbHr_X#U#H*Q#H1JL1Ybdq#^bdOTVUªQcKH1^b_"dONONKHH(Q#H<NxKH1\]TVNOXZ^bdPTVUQ#HJSQ#HW"YhKHJvQ#H<NOd~H1Y^hKHdOU#Q#d\ZdPQ#X#HNOJ§Q#H´LMf_"goX#H²LTVU#Jk^bd^bXf_"U]^,i[U _ _"NOT"YbJ¦YbHLTVXZYJ®r_®Q#HJ¯_uq#q#YbToLM#H1J±WVNOT"_"NOH1J¬TVXZYbU#dPJJb_"U]^Q#HJdOU#¬T"Yb`*_u^bdOTVU#JvJkXZYNOHJW"Yb_"U#Q#HXZYbJ`*Te]HU#U#HJ q#YbHJJdPTVUmz^bH`<q=KH1Y_u^bXZYbH<q_uYH |ZH`(qfNOH, i~GI_ HMWXLpY M_K LFORQASPH TVXm~Qf_"U#JFX#U#H\]H1YbJdPTVU6qfNPX#J@KHNO_u~T"YhKH1H"m~N_¹ ^ ORQASPH N K,N_O-^'N_ORQASPHPO HJk^?NPHL,_"QZYbHLTVU#LH1q#^bX#H1NSq~H1Y`*H1^^_"U]^LH1^^bH¶_uq#q#YbThLM#H¶WVNPT"_"NOH"ia­=H¶JTVU]^Q#HJ3^bMcKHT"YdOHJghX#dRqTVJJrHQ#H1U^NOHXZYJÂTVXZ^dONOJ3Jwq=KHLdP°fgoX#HJm`3_"dPJ*ghX#dpYH1q~TVJH1U^ÂfdOHU³HU]^bHU#Q#X

;< > T<CBE-FG2 TVAD8ÏZT<F 02=2 6-2 a FGEÓ 2bFk 3 02 , 4[ADTyÌ E-2 029A 02=FX4[;<2 * FG2=8G8_298 * @ ; Í NG2 ,:. ADTyÌ E-298 @ 3 4[AD6D2=8w 4[EZ8O4BADA-2Da

Page 20: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

&

JXZYµNOHJ±^bMcKH1T"YbdOHJ¯QZehUf_"`*dOgoX#HJ KH1\]ThgoXKHHJ±q#YhKHL KH1Q#H`*`*HU]^,i [U8L,_"NPLX#NOH Y_ q_uYµH |ZH`(qfNOHNxKHU#H1YbWVdPH`(Te]HU#U#H6QxyX#UµJkeZJw^rH`*H6HU´JkTV`*`3_"U]^3^bTVXZ^bHJÂNOHJÂ\"_"NPHXZYbJq~TVJJkdPfNOH1JEghX#H@q~H1XZ^q#YbHU#QZYHnNxKHU#H1YWVdOHªQ#X JkeZJk^,rH`*H"mRLMf_"goX#H«\u_"NOH1XZY¥KH ^_"U^?qTVU#QKH1YhKHH«q_uY6N_¨q#YbT"_ufdPNOd^ZKHªQ#HN_.YbH1U#LTVU^kYbH1Y,i GHJ\"_"NPHXZYbJq#YbdPJHJq_uYCNxKH1U#H1YbWVdOH3JkHÂQcKH1Q#X#dOJHU]^<Q#HJ^bMKHT"YbdPHJq#YZKHL KHQ#H1U^bH1Jm_"NOT"YJgoX#H<NO_ÂqfM]eZJdPghX#H(Jw^_u^bdOJw^bdOgoX#HCQ#TVU#U#H(N_¬ _ LTVU¶Q#H(QcKH ^bH1Yb`*dPU#H1YNOHJFq#YbT"_ufdONPdP^hKHJ1i dNPHJkehJk^,rH`*H3L1TVU#JdOQcKH1YhKHHJw^<X#U¦W]_ a dOTVU#dPJoKH3YbHNO_u^bdP\hdOJk^bHumIdPN¬ _"X#QZY_?fdOHUnJ]XZYCXZ^bdONPdOJH1YNPHJNOTVdPJvQ#HNxKHNOH1L1^YbTV`3_"WVUcKH ^bdOJ`(H H1^zQ#H0N_YbHNO_u^bdP\hdP^hKHqTVXZYzH |hq#YbdO`(H1YNOHJ\"_"NPHXZYbJtq~TVJJdfNOHJq~TVXZYINxKHU#H1YbWVdPHQ#X.JkehJk^,rH`(H"i

Â% +@;:70+@7 +62/ 2<5!;c70/-AC/1;:5 52 ¶9(>E70/1D.+?5Gz_¶qfM]eZJdPghX#H²KH1^bX#Q#dKHH@HU³q#YH`*dOH Y3L1eZL1NOH@X#U#dP\]H1YJdP^_"dYbH.YbH1qTVJH?HJJkHU^dOHNPNOH`*H1U^ÂJXZYÂNOH1J

^bMcKHT"YdOHJaLN_"JJkdOghX#H1J c ÄU]^bH1Y_"L1^dOTVU¶W"Y_,\Zd^_u^bdPTVU#U#HNONPH<H1^vdOU]^bH1Y_"L1^dOTVUKHNPHL1^YdOghX#HumILTVXZqfNKHHJEr_ENO_`nKH1L,_"U#dOgoX#H

LNO_"JJdOgoX#H§ÃQZeZUf_"`*dPghX#H@U#H1^bTVU#dOHU#U#H, maL1HghX#dRqH1Yb`*H ^ENxKH1^bX#Q#H6Q#XºJkehJk^,rH`(HJTVNO_"dPYbHum=Q#HJJkehJk^,rH`*H1JLMf_uYbWzKHJTVXºQ#HJLTVXZY_"U]^bJ³KHNPHL1^YdOghX#H1Jq_uYH |#H`<qfNOH"mQ#H6`?H`*H@ghX#HLHNPNOH6Q#HJTVU#Q#HJm

^bM#H Yb`*ThQZehUf_"`*dOgoX#H`3_"L1YTVJLT"qfdOgoX#Hp_uq#qfNPdOgoXKHHr_!NxKH1^bX#Q#HQ#HaJweZJk^,rH1`*HJ0JdO`(qfNPHJaW]_ a m`*T"^bH1XZYbJ iGHJ ^bMKHT"YbdPHJ KHN_uT"YZKHHJ _"X LTVXZYbJ Q#X [rH1`*H JdrH1LNOH"m¶YHN_u^bd\Zd^ZKH H1^ `nKH1L,_"U#dOgoX#H

ghXf_"U]^bdPghX#H"mtJTVU]^KH1\]H1U^bX#H1NONOH1`*HU]^Sq#YhKHJkHU^hKHHJHU°fUQ#H<q#YbH`(dOH1YL1eZL1NOH"mt`3_"dPJLTVU#Jw^bdP^bX#H1U^,m_"LLTV`<q_"WVUKHHJ±QxyX#U _uq#q#YbTV¬TVU#Q#dPJJH`*H1U^³Q#HJ±^bMcKHT"YdOHJ¯LNO_"JJdOgoX#HJ T"q#^bdPghX#HºqfM]eZJdPghX#H"m`*dPNOdOH1Xh|8`*_"WVUKH1^bdOgoX#HJ³TVX Q#dKHNPHL1^YbdPghX#HJ1m^bM#H1Y`*ThQZehUf_"`*dOgoX#H Q#H1Jº`*dONPdOHXh| Q#HU#JkHJm '' NxÇHJJH1U^bdPHNQ#HJ!HU#JkHdOWVU#H`(HU^JQ#HQ#HXh|ZdrH`(HL1eZLNPH"i~ÁF_"U#J!NOH`.H1`*H^bH1`(qfJm~NxydOU]^YbToQ#X#L1^bdPTVUQ#HSNO_CqfM]eZJdPghX#HJk^_u^bdPJk^bdOgoX#HFqH1Yb`*H ^pQxy_u~T"YbQ#H1YpNxKH1^bX#Q#HSQ#HJkeZJw^rH`*HJaLTV`(qfNPH |#HJSKHNPHL1^YTVU#JQf_"U#JpNPHJ`¨KH1^_"Xh|ÂTVX.JkH`*dlLTVU#Q#X#L1^bH1XZYbJmf\ZdP#Yb_u^bdOTVU#JQ#HJpJkTVNOdOQ#H1Jm '' i

Page 21: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

!"#

;:4;:5F7¦465 (;:AC2@465+@;§465 DE+@5)1DE+@5!7 ¶9 &52@'*B B52@5!79*>E70/1D.+?5!7

<% 5F7 2?'3B ;:5!7 45 )1A 9*>E70/1DE+@5G:xy_"Uf_"NPehJHQ#dP`*HU#JdPTVU#U#HNONPHL1TVU#Jk^bdP^X#HSX#UETVXZ^dONtH |Z^kYH`*H`(HU^qH1Yb¬T"Yb`3_"U]^q~TVXZYaNx¸_"Uf_"NeZJH

ghXf_"NPdP^_u^dP\]HÂHU±qfMehJdOgoX#H"i [U±q~TVXZYY_"d^3Q#dPYH.ghXxÇdONJx¸_"WVd^*Q#H?Nxy_uY^*Q#HEQKHQ#X#dPYbH?H,_"X#LTVXZqQxydPU#¬T"Yb`3_u^bdPTVU#JJXZYcX#UCqfMKHU#TV`.rHU#HqfMehJdOgoX#HaNPT"YbJgoX#HaNxyTVUCUxyHU<LTVU#Uf_"dP^:_Fq#YdOT"Ybdf_"JJkH a qHXQ#HLM#TVJHJi0­[xyHJw^Q#TVU#LX#U#H¬ _ L1TVUnJdP`(qfNOH<q~TVXZY¬ _"dPYH3Q#HÂNO_E~TVU#U#H3qfM]eZJdPghX#H3HU«YbHU#Qf_"U]^LTV`(q#YhKHM#HU#JdfNOHJRQ#H1Jp`nKHL_"U#dOJ`*H1Jq_uY¬TVdOJpL1TV`(qfNOH |ZHJi

GI_vqfMehJdOgoX#H.KH1^bX#Q#dOHpQ#HJ=T"Z©wH1^bJ=ghX#dLTVXZ\oYbHU]^Q#HJ*KHLM#HNONPHJQ#HRNOTVU#WVX#H1XZYbJ=H |Z^kYH`*H`(HU^Q#dP\]H YbJHJmFJTVXZ\]HU]^ªdP`(q~TVJJkdPfNOH1J¯r_´dP`3_"WVdOU#H Y,iRÄNCH1Jk^TVU QxKHL YbdPYbHnghX#HNPghX#HJX#U#J¶Q#H¨L1HJU#TV`#YbHJi NPT"YbJagoXxyHUÂqfMehJdOgoX#HSQ#HJq_uY^bdPLX#NOHJaTVU^Yb_\u_"dONPNOHFJXZYRQ#HJaJkeZJw^rH`*HJQ#H

¼Cy¼V¼V¼<¼V¼V¼C¼V¼V¼(¼V¼V¼<¼V¼ `TVX ¼ 9:!= `.mJTVdP^EX#U²`*dONPNOdOTVU#drH`*H@Q#H¶`*dPNONPd_uYbQ#drH`*H@Q#H¶`.rH1^kYbH"mN_§LTVJk`*TVNOTVWVdPH6^Yb_"dP^bH6Q#HU#TV`#YbHJ^bHNOJghX#H

¼V¼C¼V¼V¼(¼V¼V¼<¼V¼V¼<¼V¼V¼<¼V¼V¼(¼V¼V¼C¼V¼V¼(¼V¼V¼ `TVX ¼ >@; `.mZJTVd^aL1HU^a`*dPNONOdPTVU#J=Q#H`(dONONPd_uYbQ#J=Q#HF`*dPNONOdO_uYbQ#JQ#HF`.rH1^YHJi#GI_qfM]eZJdPghX#HHJk^Q#TVU#LX#U#HCJLdOH1U#LH(_"Xh|6`X#N^bdPqfNPHJ[¬ _"LH1^^HJmq#YbT"_ufNOH1`*HU]^NO_3JHX#NOHCJLdPHU#LH?r_ÂJ1xydOU]^hKH1YHJJH1Yr_Q#HJQ#TV`3_"dPU#HJ_"X#JJdZ\u_uYbdKH1Ji"scNPNOH*KH1\hdP^bH=HUYbH1\u_"U#LM#HaJkTVdOWVU#HX#JH1`*HU]^:Q#H=^Yb_"dP^bH1YQ#HNO_!L1TV`(qfNOH |ZdP^hKHH1^INxKH1^bX#Q#HcQ#H:NxÇM#TV`*`*H H1^zQ#HcN_=\ZdPH0q_uYzH |#H1`(qfNOHYbHNrH1\]H:Qf_,\u_"U^_"WVH:Q#HcNO_aLM#dO`*dPH"mN_=fdOTVNPTVWVdOH"mN_ªqfJkehLM#TVNPTVWVdOH"mNO_¦JToLdOTVNPTVWVdOH"m '' LH1Y^_"dPU#HJEQ#H6LHJJLdPHU#LHJ¶NOHJq#YbH`(drH1YbH1J*Jx¸_uq#qfXZe_"U]^Qx¸_"dPNONPHXZYbJ^Y,rHJaN_uYbWVH`(HU^JXZYpN_qfMehJdOgoX#H"i

GT"YbJgoX#HNxyTVU JxydPU^hKH YbHJJH®_"Xh| T"YbQZYbHJ³Q#H W"Y_"U#Q#HXZY _uq#q#YbThLM#H ghXf_"NOd^_u^bd\]H²Q#HNO_qfM]eZJdPghX#H m:TVU±LM#H1YbLM#HQ#H1J(\"_"NPHXZYbJ3L,_uYb_"L1^hKH1YbdPJk^bdPghX#HJ3_uq#q#YT|ZdO`3_u^bd\]HJiÁF_"U#J3LH.L,_"J1mcX#U¬ _"L1^bH1XZY ¼ w ¼ ¬TVdOJqfNOX#JpTVX ¼ ¬TVdOJa`*TVdOU#JUxÇHJk^pq_"J^Y,rHJadO`(qT"Y^_"U]^ ;< > iGIT"YJghX#HNxyTVUE_T"#^bHUX3NOH~TVU3T"YbQZYHpQ#HRW"Y_"U#Q#H1XZY,moNPHJLT, ·PU#LdOQ#H1U#LHJ(KH1^_"U]^cYb_uYbHJmL"xyH1Jk^c\oY_"dOJH1`fNO_ufNOH`(HU^q_uYbLH?goX#H?NxÇTVU¯_ ! " Q#X³qfMcKHU#TV`.rHU#H²KH1^bX#Q#dKHuic_uYH |ZH`(qfNOH

;< > zÐ 2=8ON ;Ð @ Ó-]_2=N 6-2 ;Ð 029;<4Ó @[FX4 NXT @ A 6-298 N .102b@BFGT<298ZÏ .Í 8GTÇÌ ED2=8#Ì ED216Ð 4B3 029;<T<@[FG2=F ;V4ÏDF 02 , TV8OT<@BA 8GE-F NG2=;V;<2 C[FX4[AD6D2=EDFba

Page 22: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

&

NOT"YJghX#HFNxÇTVUEJXZq#qTVJHvghX#HFN_CJk^YbX#L ^bXZYbH_u^bTV`(dOghX#H[H1Jk^R¬TVU#QcKHHSJXZYRNxydOU]^bH1Yb_"L1^bdOTVU³KHNOH1L1^YbdPghX#H"mTVU@T"#^bdOH1U^RqTVXZY!N_(^_"dPNONPHvL,_uY_"L1^hKH1YbdOJw^bdOgoX#HvQ#HNxy_u^bTV`*HSNO_(\"_"NPHXZY » > I > ¼ 9:@: `.m_"NOT"YJ=ghXx¸_,\]HL[NxyM]ehq~T"^MtrHJH[ghX#H[LuxyHJk^NxydOU]^bH1Yb_"L1^bdOTVU3W"Yb_\hdP^_u^bdPTVU#U#HNONPHRghX#d LTV`(q#^bH[TVU3^YTVXZ\]H » > ) II > ¼ > ` ÃqfNOX#J<W"Y_"U#Q§ghX#HNxÇX#U#dP\]H1YbJ i0G0xyT"fJkH1Y\u_u^bdOTVU§H|ZqKH1YbdP`*HU]^_"NOH¬TVXZYbU#d^FqTVXZYSNPHJ!Q#dP\]H1YJ_u^TV`*HJ[Q#HJ!Y_,e]TVU#JFQ#H ¼C . ¼ 9:

r_@ ¼ 9<: `Ei ÄN HJk^FLNO_"dPY!ghXxy_"X

YbHW]_uYQ¨Q#HENO_Q#d KH1YbH1U#LHEHU]^YbHNOHJCQ#HXh|¨U#TV`#YbHJ¦KH \]ThghXcKH1JCqfNPX#J<Mf_"XZ^(dON=HJk^<NKH1WVdP^bdP`*H3Q#HLTVU#LNPXZYbH=ghX#H=LuxyHJk^zfdOHUNxÇdOU]^bH1Y_"L ^bdOTVUKHNPHL1^YdOghX#H=goX#d,©wTVX#HX#UYuTVNPHL1YbX#LdO_"NhQf_"U#J NO_RJk^YbX#L1^XZYbHQ#HJ:_u^bTV`*HJ1i]­!xÇHJk^0Qf_"U#J0LHaJkHU#JcgoX#HNxyTVUCLM#H1YbLM#H1Y_Âr_!QcKH1^bH Yb`*dOU#H Y:Q#H1JcT"YbQZYbH1J:Q#HW"Y_"U#Q#HXZYm^bTVXZ^SHU«W]_uYbQf_"U^Âr_.NxÇHJkq#Ybd^vN_UKHLHJJkdP^hKHQ#H(^bMcKH1T"YbdOHJKHN_uT"YZKHHJSqTVXZYvYbHU#QZYH3LTV`(q#^bH<Q#HJQcKH1^_"dPNOJSdO`<q~T"Y^_"U]^bJQ#XÂqfMKHU#TV`.rHU#H"i

GHp^_ufNPH,_"X*Ld l Q#HJJkTVX#JY_"JJH`fNPHpghX#H1NOghX#H1JcT"YbQZYbH1JQ#HpW"Y_"U#Q#H1XZY^Y,rHJ_uq#q#YbT|ZdO`3_u^dO¬JQ#HQ#dO`(HU#JdOTVU#JH1^pQ#H`3_"JkJHJi

& ')($) % 5 Î FX6-FG298 6-2 C[FX4[AZ6-29E-F , 4[FG4 , N 02=FGTV8_NXTyÌ E-298 FG2=A , @ AWNOF 0298"29A[Ï .Í 8GTÇÌ ED2:Ï @ E-F 6-298Ï .1029A-@W3ML29A-298 L4 6-298 02 ,/. 29;<;<298 NOF=L298"6DTÇÒB2=FX8_298:a ) ) ! ) ! ) F' '*) ) ! ) ) * ADTÇÒB2=FG8 3 ! &#" 'WC # Ñ $ Ñ ' 'WCDa 3 Ñ&% 4B;<4¤DT 2 (' 3 ' 'WC ' Ñ & 'WCZa 3 Ñ%+ @ ; 29TV; ' 3 % " 'WC U &! % 'WCDa 3 Ñ&%% 2bFGFG2 3 'WC & ' p)%'WCDa 3[Ñ&%%\@ 3 3 2 " 3 )'WC ) ' % 'WCZa 3 Ñ%* FO@BN 029T<AD2 Ñ 3 Ñ # Ñ (' 'WC % S@B; 02 , ED;<2 8GTV3Ï ; 2 Ñ' 3 Ñ % 'WC # NG@ 3 2 ; @ E-FX6 Ñ ' " 3 Ñ & 'WC & 'WCZa 3[Ñ%# NG@ 3 2+* Ñ ' " 3 Ñ 'WC 'WCZa 3[Ñ% @ Í 4BE; @ E-FX6 Ñ ' 3 Ñ & 'WC ' 'WCDa 3[Ñ&%* FO@BNO@ A Ñ ' & 3 Ñ 'WC ' ' 'WCDa 3 Ñ&% ; 2 , NGFG@BA " Ñ ' 3 Ñ&% " 'WC, EZ4 F' " Ñ ' 3 Ñ 'WC \E a 4Da H EDAZT N 02 4B8_NGFG@BA-@W35TyÌ E-2 P.- '/' 3R 8\4Da ; a H 4BADA 02=2w¡ ;VEZ35T L2=FO2 P0- ' & 3R :ÏZ4 FX8O2 , - 4-a ;Ja

0Â%21 2?AC)>E7 5 4/,B 52?70/1'3262@5),)15

35467498;:=<?>/:A@CBED;FG>H<IDKJ&J&DGHJ`nKH1^bM#ThQ#H1JQxy_"Uf_"NPeZJkHCQ#dP`*HU#JdPTVU#U#HNONPHHUqfM]eZJdPghX#Hq~H1Y`*H1^^bH1U^QxyT"#^bH1U#dPY_"dOJoKH1`*HU]^

Q#HJIT"YbQZYbHJQ#H:W"Y_"U#Q#HXZYzQ#H:qfMcKHU#TV`.rH1U#HJzqfM]eZJdPghX#HJmq_uYb¬TVdPJz`.H`(H0J_"U#JLTVU#Uf_ ·P^kYbHcNO_a¬T"Yb`*Hq#YhKHL1dOJHQ#HSN_CNOTVd~qfM]eZJdPghX#H`*dOJHFHU©wHXi

­=TVU#JdOQcKH YbTVU#Jzq_uYH|#H`(qfNPH:NO_\hdP^bHJkJH:QcKH °fU#dOHcq_uY$L » I B i !UvqHXZ^`(HJXZYbH1YIN_Q#dOJk^b_"U#LHI HUv`.rH ^YbHJc` m,NO_aQ#XZYhKH1H B HUvJkHLTVU#Q#HJÃJtH ^N_=\Zd^bHJJkH7L[HUv`.rH1^YbHJtq_uYJkHLTVU#Q#H!`EiyJ 9: i[U KH1L1YbdP^vghX#H*NPHJvQ#dO`(HU#JdOTVU#JSQ#H I JTVU]^Q#HJNPTVU#WVX#HXZYbJmAM ION »QP mILHNPNOHJvQ#H B Q#HJv^H`(qfJmM BHN »SR H1^=LHNPNOHJcQ#HEL<Q#HJ=NPTVU#WVX#HXZYbJq_uY=X#U#d^hKH[Q#Hp^bH1`(qfJmMTL N »UPR 9<: i !U3q~H1XZ^3KHW]_"NOH`(HU^`*HJkXZYbH1YNO_FNPTVU#WVX#HXZY IOV HU ! dPNOTV`.rH ^YbHJ ! `H1^:N_Q#XZYhKHH B#V HU*M#HXZYHJ!M m]`3_"dPJQxyX#U#Haq_uYk^NOH1J\u_"NOHXZYbJSUoX#`nKH YbdOgoX#HJSq#YbdPJHJSq_uYSNOHJNOTVU#WVX#HXZYbJSH1^NOH1JSQ#XZYhKHH1JU#H(JTVU]^vqfNOX#JSNOHJ`?H`*HJH1^SQx¸_"XZ^YbHCq_uYvNO_YbHNO_u^bdOTVUWL V » I V B V dO`(qTVJH<goX#H*N_\"_"NPHXZYvUX#`nKH1YdOghX#H<LT"YYbH1Jkq~TVU#Qf_"U]^bHq~TVXZYcN_!\ZdP^HJJHaJTVdP^cH |Zq#YbdP`nKHHHU ! dONOTV`.rH1^YbHJq_uYM#H1XZYbH ! `.iyM 9: i [U*q~HXZ^c¬T"Yb`*HNPNOH`(HU^KHL1YdPYbHNOH!q_"JJb_"WVHSQxÇX#U.JkehJk^,rH`*H!QxÇX#U#dP^hKHJr_<Nx¸_"XZ^YbHFJTVX#JaN_<¬T"Y`*H

IOV » W IX X XY ! ` ¼V¼V¼ Y `

H1^ B/V » R BX X XZ M V¿ ¼V¼ Z J

Page 23: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

!"# ­=TV`*`*H L V » I V B/V mTVU§HUnQKHQ#X#dP^ L » W I R B m JTVd^ » W 9<:R TVUnYH`3_uYbgoX#HNO_`.H`(HF¬T"Y`*HgoX#H MTL N » M ION M BHN 9<: mffdPHU.goX#HNPHJ JTVdPHU^pQ#HSJdP`(qfNOH1JU#TV`#YbH1JH1^

L V » LX X X

! ` M 9: : ; ` J 9:

354H354 @ED >/D B D D$D @ED D/:AJI>#: @ @ D7>.DC U#Hv_"U#HLQ#T"^HvM#dOJk^T"YbdOgoX#HFqH1Yb`*H1^aQxydPNONPX#Jk^YbH1YpNxÇH1*L,_"L1dP^hKHFQ#HJR_uYWVX#`*HU]^bJpQ#dP`*HU#JdPTVU#U#HNOJm

ghX#dcTVU^qH1Yb`*dPJvQf_"U#JNOHJ_"U#UcKHH1J<½ ¼ r_ -_,eZNPT"YQ#HQKH1^bH1Yb`(dOU#H1YNxKHU#H1YWVdOH3QcKHW]_"WzKHHNPT"YbJvQ#Xq#YbH`(dOH1Y H1JJb_"dhQ#HTV`~H _"X[TVXZ\]H,_"XhlÈ@H |#dPghX#Hr_pq_uY^dPY QxÇX#U°fNP`®Q#H=NxyH |hqfNOTVJdPTVUvQ#d X#JhKHq_uY=Nx¸_uYb`nKH1H_"NPT"YbJcgoX#H[Q#HJYbHU#JH1dOWVU#H`*H1U^bJ^HNOJgoX#HRNxKHU#H1YbWVdPH[QKHW]_"WzKHHRH ^_"dOHU]^I©wX#Jk^H`*HU]^LNO_"JJoKHJJkHL1YbH1^Jm"NOH:JX#LL"rH1J0Q#H-_ehNOT"Yz_aqfNOTVU#WzKHcNOHJ`(dONOd^_"dPYHJ_"`¨KH1YbdPL,_"dOU#JIQf_"U#JNOHJkLH1q#^bdPLdOJ`(HH1^SNxydPU#L1YhKHQ#X#NPdP^hKH, ;=< > iIG0xydPQKHH*Q#H -z_ehNOT"YKH ^_"dP^JdO`<qfNOH`*H1U^Q#H*LTVU#JdPQKH1YbH1YvghX#H*NxyH |hqfNOTVJdPTVUq#YbToQ#X#dOJb_"d^X#U#HCTVU#Q#HCQ#H<LM#ThLumt\hdOJdfNOHJXZYFNOH°fNO`Em~H1^FghX#HNOHY_,e]TVU Q#H<NxyTVU#Q#HCQ#HLM#ToLUxKH ^_"dP^=¬TVU#L ^bdOTVUghX#HpQ#H[NxKH1U#H1YbWVdOH[QcKH1W]_"WKHH! 3moQ#X3^bH1`(qfJ B KHLTVX#NKH[Q#H qfX#dOJ=NxÇH |ZqfNPTVJdOTVU3H ^=Q#HN_CQ#HU#Jd^ZKHSQ#HNx¸_"dY" c »$# % F B F "h i

E ρ

R(t)

"!$#&%('*) 5= Î AD6D2M6D2 ,/. @ , L4>8 Í 3 02=NOFXT<2M8Ï .102bFXTyÌ E-2M@Ó 8_2=FÒ 4ÓZ;<2U8OEDF ; 2'& ;V3 2bN58 ,/.102*354N Í ÏZTyÌ E-2 6D2 ;Ð 4B;<;VE-FG2 6D2 ;Ð @ AD6-2^6-2 ,:. @ , &¤D4BAWN"; 298tÏ 4 FX4B3ML2=NGFO298"6DE!ÏDFG@ÓZ; L2*3 2Ba[U´LM#H1YbLM#HX#U#HLTV`fdPUf_"dOJTVU³Q#H?qfX#dOJJb_"U#L1HJ( » LTVU#Jw^ *) B,+ ".-fi=_uY^_"U]^Q#HJ

KHgoXf_u^bdOTVU#Jp_"Xh|.Q#dP`*HU#JdPTVU#J M/ N »0P > R 9 > m!M BHN » R H1^ M1" N »20P 9 TVU?LM#H1YbLM#HEr_¦KH1L1YbdPYHvX#U#HghXf_"U]^bd^ZKHM#TV`*TVWfrHU#H.r_X#U#HCNOTVU#WVX#HXZYi [U KH1NOdO`(dOU#HN_`3_"JJkH"mghX#d Uxy_uq#q_uY_ ·P^FghX#HCQf_"U#J H1^"fmhq_uYN_LTV`fdOUf_"dPJTVU M3 " N »UP = R 9 > i [U_"NOT"YbJT"#^bdPHU^dP`*`nKHQ#dO_u^bH`*HU]^X#U#HFNOTVU#WVH1XZYHU.¬T"Y`3_"U^9MO4 B > "h : = N »SP mL1HSghX#dLTVU#Q#X#d^[_"XEY_,e]TVUEQ#HSNxyTVU#Q#HFQ#HvLM#ThLFq#YbT"q~T"Yk^bdOTVU#U#HNr_.4 *" 9: B > : = m

» LTVU#Jk^ % *" 9: B > : = wViO­=TVU#Uf_"dOJJ_"U^!NO_*Q#HU#JdP^hKHCQ#HNx¸_"dYRH1^[H1U6JkXZq#q~TVJb_"U]^FghX#HN_<LTVU#Jk^_"U]^bHHJk^[Q#HNxyT"YbQZYHvQ#H

VmZLH[goX#d~JxÇHJk^YhKH1\:KHNKH[LT"YkYbHL1^q_uYX#U#HF_"Uf_"NPehJH[X#NP^hKH YbdOHXZYH!qfNPX#J=q~TVX#JJoKH1H"m#dON~JkXZ(^Q#H[^Y_"LH Y

;< > ^a a 4 FG29AÓZ;V4 NGNw T 3 29AD8GT @ AD4[; 4[AD4B; Í 8GTV8 @[FX6-@ AM4[AD6 FG2=4 ,/.+ , T 29A , 2)* EÓZ;VT<8 . 2=FG8w # 358ONO2=FG6Z4B3 Wa

Page 24: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

' &

NOU%" = aHU@¬TVU#L1^dOTVU@Q#HNOU B % H ^ B JkTVU^F_"LL1HJJdfNOHJ*r_*q_uY^bdY[Q#X?°fNO`=q~TVXZY!QcKH1^bH Yb`*dOU#H YN_\"_"NPHXZYaQ#H 3i [U.T"#^bdOH1U^pHUEH H1^

NPU " = » NOULTVU#Jk^ NOU NOU B F wVi VJTVd^.X#U#H¶QZYbTVd^bHQ#Hq~HU]^bH¦ngoX#ddPU^bH YbLH1q#^bHNx¸_|ZHQ#HJET"YbQ#TVU#UKHHJ¨r_¨NO_n\u_"NOHXZYENOU JdNOULTVU#Jk^ ¼ i

"!$#&%('*)H5 FG@BT<NG2R29A , @W@ 6-@ ADA 02b2M; @BCB4[FGT<N . 35TyÌ E-298Ï 2=FQ3 2bNGNX4[AWN 6Ð 4 ,b, 0296-2=FRL4U;PÐ 029A-2=FGCBT<26 02=CB4 C 02b2 a A 2 " 2bNk ;PÐ 2¤ÏZFO298O8GT<@BA 6-2 Ï 29E-NU4BED8G8OT 8_2 3 2bNGNGFO2 8O@BED8S;<4 Y @BFX352 & -H P ' D6]Ð @ LE>;Ð 2w¤ÏDFG2=8G8OT<@BAU2=A;<@[CZa

$% 9 &52?'3B B52?5F7 ),/ &5!7 BA )1A (;:A 2?/-AS-0/1'32

4674 >/J< +@D D 0D : /D$> GIH1Jq_uY_"`.rH ^YbHJ@¬TVU#Qf_"`*HU]^_"Xh|®dOU]^bH1Y\]H1Uf_"U^Qf_"U#JNO_µQ#dOJw^_"U#LH -zH1YYbHl TVNOH1dON* JTVU]^

LNO_"dPYbH`(HU^vNOHJ`3_"JkJHJvYbHJwq~HL1^dP\]HJ H1^ Q#X TVNPHdONH ^Q#H3N_ -zH1YkYbH"mNO_Eq=KH1YbdOToQ#H3Q#HYhKH1\]TVNPXZ^bdOTVUQ#HN_ -IH1YYbHH1^RNO_(LTVU#Jk^_"U]^bHQ#HvW"Y_,\ZdP^b_u^bdOTVU ) goX#dL_uY_"L1^hKH1YdOJHvNxydPU^bH Y_"L1^bdPTVUW"Y_,\Zd^_u^bdOTVU#U#H1NONOHui !U´KH1L1YbdP^

»2# F F F) wVi¸]

ghX#HNxyTVU.LM#H1YLM#HCJTVX#J[NO_*¬T"Yb`*HSq_uY^dOLX#NPdrH1YbHQxÇX#U#HLTV`fdOUf_"dPJTVU?Q#HvqfX#dOJJ_"U#LHJi­=TV`*`*H) IKI V I HJk^:X#U#HEKHU#H1YbWVdPH"m]TVU*_ M ) IKI V ION » 0P > R 9 > m]JTVd^ M ) N » 0 9<: P R 9 > i !U(HU(QcKHQ#X#d^NxÇH |Zq#YHJJdPTVU

» ) > : # wViy½

scUµJXZq#q~TVJ_"U^EghX#H6N_n¬TVU#L ^bdOTVU # HJw^EQxÇT"YbQZYbH¨H1^ÂHUºXZ^bdPNOdPJb_"U^ÂNPHJQ#TVU#UcKH1HJEq~TVXZY ) m ª» ¼ ! WH1^ » F_"UmZTVUT"#^dOHU]^NxÇT"YbQZYbH[Q#H!W"Y_"U#Q#HXZYQ#H!N_vQ#dPJk^_"U#LH -zH1YkYbH l TVNPHdON ¼ :@: ` ;< > i;< > # E;VT 29EU6-2 U '#' 3 29AMF 0294[;VT<N 021 Z;PÐ @[FX6-FG2 6-2 C[FX4[AD6D2=EDF"298_N 6D@BA , NGFbL298 , @[FGFO2 , N=a

Page 25: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

!"# GHµYhKH1JX#NP^_u^ » ) > : # ¶UxyH1Jk^¨YbdPHU Qxy_"XZ^YbH³ghX#H³N_#rH`*H¯NOTVd

Q#HH qfNOH1Y¦Mf_ufdP^X#HNONPH`*HU]^ KHL1Ybd^bH±JTVX#J«N_²¬T"Yb`*H > » ) ½ > ivGz_¥¬TVU#L1^bdPTVU# <\u_"XZ^Q#TVU#L¨Ã½ > 9<: ¼C ¼ H ^HJk^ÂdOU#QcKH1qHU#Qf_"U]^bHQ#X¯Y_uq#qT"Y^ iG0x¸_ufJHU#L1HEQ#H Qf_"U#J<LH1^^HÂH|Zq#YbHJkJdOTVU§H1Jk^CNOH¬ _"dP^CQ#HNxKHgoX#dP\u_"NOHU#L1HÂ`*_"JJHdOU#H1Yk^bdOHNPNOH l`3_"JJkHW"Y_,\Zd^_u^bdPTVU#U#HNONPHÂgoX#d=q~H1Yb`(H1^(Q#HÂJdP`(qfNOd°fH1Y(NO_`3_"JkJHQ#HNxÇT"#©wH ^(W"Y_,\Zd^_"U]^,m dOLdNO_-zH1YkYbH"mfQf_"U#JpNPHFq#YbdPU#LdPqHS¬TVU#Qf_"`*H1U^_"NtQ#HN_<QZehUf_"`*dOgoX#H

Q > gQ B > » )

I > ^ W

­=H1^^bH3JdP`(qfNOd°fL,_u^bdPTVUªHJk^^Y,rH1JdO`(qT"Y^_"U]^bH"mz`*_"dOJvU#H*qHXZ^q_"JH1^YbH3QcKHQ#X#d^bHQ#HNx¸_"Uf_"NeZJHQ#dO`(HU#JdOTVU#U#H1NONOHui

& ')($) %5 @ ADA 02b298 A EZ3 02=FGTyÌ E-298^FO29;V4 NXT Ò 2=854BE,¤CÏ ;<4BA L2=NO29856DE 8 Í 8_NbL29352M8O@B;V4[T<FG2Ba 298354[8G8_298H P58_@ AWN T<AZ6DTyÌ E 02=2=8529A 'WC ;<2=8 6DTV8_NX4[A , 298UH 4Ï .102=;VT<2 fÏ 02bFXT .1029;<T<22bN5FX4 Í @BA 3 @ Í 2=A6-2 ;PÐ @[FÓZT<NO2 P 29A`35TV;<;VT @ AD8 6-2 '-3R ;V4[Ï 02=FXT @ 6-2 6-2RF 02kÒB@ ;<EDNGT<@BA H # P 2=A`4BADA 02b298 NGFO@ ÏZTyÌ E-298 2=N;Ð TVA , ;<TVAD4BT<8O@BA 6D2 ;PÐ @[FÓZT<NO2 H P 298ON FG2kÏ 02=F 02=2FÏ 4 FMFG4ÏÏ @[FGNU4[EÏZ;V4[A 6-2 ;PÐ 02 , ;<TÇÏDNXTyÌ E-21 298ON;Ð 2w¤ , 29AWNOFXT , T<N 02 a* ;V4[A L2bNG2 # U2=F , E-FG2 % / 029A ED8 % $ ' % 2=FGFO2 % ' & $p S4[FG8 : % (BEÏZT<NO2=F & 3# / ` + 4 NXE-FXA-2 & e ` * FX4[A EZ8 & & / 3 2kÏDNXEDAD2 & ` / * ;VE-NG@BA # / '

"!$#&%('*)5 298tÏZ;V4[A L2bNG298"6DEU8 Í 8ONbL2*3 2 8O@B;V4[T<FO2 a­=TVU#Uf_"dOJJ_"U^=NPHaY_,e]TVU*Q#HaNxyT"YkfdP^bHaQ#HpN_ -zH1YYbHumJ_Sq=KH1YbdOToQ#HpQ#HpYhKH1\]TVNOXZ^bdPTVU(H1^cLHNPNOHpQxÇX#U#H

_"XZ^YbH:qfN_"UrH1^bHum _u^bXZYbU#Hq_uY H|#H`(qfNPH!"R_"U#Jb muTVUq~H1XZ^ Jx¸_ Y_"U#LM#dPYQ#X¬ _"L1^bH1XZYUoX#`nKH YbdOgoX#H½ > 9: q~TVXZYvT"#^bHU#dPYNPH<Y_,e]TVUªQ#H3NxÇT"YfdP^H(Q#H3LH1^k^bH(qfN_"UrH ^bH(q_uYX#U#H*Y,rH1WVNOH*JdP`(qfNOH<Q#Hq#YbT"qT"Y^bdOTVU#Uf_"NPdP^hKH c

>ª» > FJTVd^ » > >: : ,½ ¼V¼C ¼ ; ! `

Page 26: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

&

"!$#&%('*) 8 * A-2nÒ-E-2 6D2 + 4 NXE-FXA-2 H T 354 CB2 6ZE ]_@ E-Fb 3 4 FX8 NGT<F 02=2 6ZE8OT<NO2 / #%%% 0#$&* 6!&1'0#" "'!/.(/1:)0( !$ 35T<FO@ T F 6DE 8OT<NG2 6D2 ;V4 # +## 8ONOFG@BAD@ 3 Í ÏZT , NXE-FG2 @ Y N . 2 6D4 Í 0"%( 6$.' "'0'0 6&0#$&* PQa

4H35498;:0D B D <I: > /DKJUB!+@EJ #D$J >#D$J_uYzNxÇT"fJH1Y\u_u^bdOTVUv_"Jk^YbTVU#TV`*dPghX#H"m,TVUvqHXZ^QcKH ^bH1Yb`*dPU#H1YNxyT"YbQZYHcQ#HW"Y_"U#Q#H1XZY Q#HN_Q#dOJk^b_"U#LH

Q#X TVNPHdON_"XLH1U^YH<Q#HN_W]_"N_|ZdOH"m ¼V¼V¼V¼ _ N É? ¼ > ` U#T"^YbHJkTVNOHdPN HJk^FJdP^XKH

Qf_"U#JÂNOH@^bdOH1YJqKH YbdPqfMcKH1YdOghX#HQ#HNO_ªW]_"N_|#dPH(H1^Q#HNO_«\hdP^bH1JJH@Q#H6YhKHLHJJkdOTVU L ¼V¼ r_ ¼V¼ ! ` J 9<: Q#X TVNPHdON:_"XZ^bTVXZYQ#XªL1HU^kYbH*Q#H*NO_EW]_"N_|ZdOH"itGHJvQ#TVU#UcKHHJvYHN_u^bd\]HJÂr_.NO_\]TVdOHN_"L ^ZKHH!q~HXZ\]HU]^H1^kYbHL1TVU#JdOQcKH1YhKHHJRLTV`(`*H!L,_uY_"L1^hKH YbdOJk^dOghX#H1JaQ#HNxyH1U#JH`fNOHFQ#HJRW]_"NO_|#dOH1Ji

"!$#&%('*)5$ +-,/.102*35456D2 ;Ð 2*3ÏZ;V4 , 29352=AWN"6ZE8 Í 8ONbL2*3 2 8O@B;V4[T<FG2^6Z4[AD8\;<4 CB4[;V4b¤DT<2 as:U?JXZq~TVJb_"U]^!ghX#HN_*W]_"NO_|#dOHFHJk^RX#U?T"#©wH ^(r_(NxKHghX#dPNOd#YbHSW"Y_,\Zd^_u^bdPTVU#U#HNtT"=KHdOJJ_"U^!_"Xh|

NOTVdPJ:Q#HaN_FQZeZUf_"`*dPghX#H"mVTVU(qHXZ^H|Zq#YbdP`*H1Y:N_`*_"JJH H Q#HaN_W]_"NO_|#dPHL1TV`*`*HX#U#HR¬TVU#L1^bdPTVU

Page 27: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

!"# 1

"!$#&%('*)~5 " * AD2:Ò-ED2 6-2^;<4aÒ @BT<2^;V4 , N 02=20Ò 2=FG8 ; 2 , 2=AWNGFO2 6-2 ;<4 CB4[;V4b¤DT<2HGL4RCB4BE ,/. 2 T 354 CB26DEM]_@ E-F^6DE 5]O4BAÒ-T 2=F 1H / 0#"%(/ 6$#. "$0/0 6& 0'&* PGP 2=N 6D2R;V4UCB4B;<4¤DT 2 3 HGL4 6DFO@ T NG2 PQa

Q#H H m?L =m ¨H1^ ) c H »2# % H F L F F)

» LTVU#Jk^ )H L + - ) wVi V

scU*YH1q#YbHUf_"U]^NOHJQ#dP`*HU#JdPTVU#JQ#H ) H ^=LHNPNOHJQ#HEL moTVU3`*TVU]^YbHRgoX#H M N » M/L > ) 9: N i [UHU.QcKH1Q#X#dP^

H » H L > ) 9: # H F wVi¸¿]

H1^aq~TVXZY[NPHJR`.H`(HJYb_"dOJTVU#JRgoX#Hq#YhKH1LKHQ#H`*`(HU^pq~TVXZY[NO_ -zH1YYH"m TVU.qHXZ^!_uYbWVX#`(HU^H1YRgoX#HNOH!YhKHJkX#NP^_u^aHJk^pHUE¬ _"d^pdPU#QKH1q~HU#Qf_"U]^[Q#HN_<`*_"JJHFQ#HSNxÇT"Z©wH1^W"Y_\hdP^_"U]^,m#JTVd^pdPLdi [U?__"dOU#JkdINxyT"YbQZYbHFQ#HvW"Y_"U#Q#H1XZY H ¾?r_* É ¼ : ! WmfJTVd^,m_\]H1L ª» ¼ ! W3X#U#HS\u_"NOH1XZYHU@X#U#dP^hKHJ[Q#H`3_"JJHJkTVN_"dPYH H ¼ :@: L1HghX#dzL1T"YYbHJkqTVU#Q¯r_*NxyT"YbQZYHQ#HW"Y_"U#Q#HXZY!Q#XU#TV`#YbHFQxKH1^bTVdPNOHJQ#HSU#T"^kYbHSW]_"NO_|#dOHC ¼V¼ `*dPNONOdO_uYbQ#J=QxKH ^bTVdONPHJaQf_"U#JaX#U#HSX#U#dPghX#HSW]_"NO_|#dPH ¸ i

[U@U#T"^bH1Y_3ghX#HSLH1^^bHH|Zq#YbHJkJdOTVU@LTVU#Q#X#d^[HU?q#YbdOU#L1dPq~HEr_*X#U#HH1Jk^bdO`*_u^bdOTVU.Q#HNO_(`3_"JJkHLT"YYHJkq~TVU#Qf_"U]^@r_6NO_?q_uYk^bdOHdOU]^bH1YU#HÂQ#HÂN_?W]_"NO_|#dOH?Q#X¨LH1U^YH«r_?N_?Q#dPJk^_"U#LH ¼V¼V¼V¼ _ N iÄNzUxÇHJk^[q_"J[LH1Yk^_"dOU@ghX#HNxyHJkJHU]^bdOHNzQ#HCNO_*`3_u^bdrH1YbHSQf_"U#J!X#U#HW]_"NO_|#dOHSJTVdP^[L1TVU#LHU]^YhKHQf_"U#JNOH1JYhKHWVdPTVU#JL1HU^kY_"NOHJ1mIL,_uYSNOHJFW]_"N_|ZdOHJ!JTVU]^vH1U^bTVXZYhKHHJvQxÇX#U¶Mf_"NOTÂq=KH1YbdPqfMcKH YbdOgoX#H*ghX#d q~H1XZ^LTVU]^YbdfX#H1YQ#Ha¬ _ LTVU*U#T"^_ufNPHCr_NO_`3_"JkJH^T"^_"NOH"i [T"^kYbHaH1Jk^bdO`*_u^bdOTVUCHJk^:LH1qHU#Qf_"U^LT"YYbHL ^bHL,_uYNO_.`3_"JJH<^bT"^_"NOH(Q#HJW]_"N_|ZdOHJHJk^Q#H3NxÇT"YbQZYbH*Q#H? ¼ :@: r_¶ ¼ :!> `*_"JJHJvJkTVN_"dPYHJÂ ¼ :!>HU]\ZdYbTVUEq~TVXZYaN_CU#T"^YbH"i¸ i

[U¨q~H1XZ^¦KHW]_"NPH`*HU]^CU#T"^bH1Y<ghX#HNxÇH |Zq#YHJJdPTVUnq#YhKHL KHQ#HU]^bH.HJk^<X#U#H._"XZ^kYbH¬T"Yb`*HQ#HENO_ZrH`*HCNOTVdQ#H FH1qfNPH1Y_uq#qfNPdOghXcKH1H*LH1^^H(¬TVdOJS_"X¶`*TVXZ\]H`(HU^FQ#X TVNPHdONQf_"U#JvNO_W]_"N_|ZdOH"is:UU#T"^_"U]^pgoX#H L ª» mfTVU?_CfdPHU >ª» ) H ½ > i

ÄNHJk^Cq_uY*_"dPNONPHXZYbJdOU]^hKH1YbH1JJb_"U]^*Q#HÂJHEQ#H`*_"U#Q#H1Y(L1TV`fdPHU¨Q#HYhKH1\]TVNPXZ^bdOTVU#JLTV`<qfNrH1^bH1JQf_"U#JN_[W]_"N_|ZdOHNPH=JkeZJw^rH`*HJkTVN_"dPYHFTVXN_ -zH1YYH_[H HL ^bXKHaQ#H qfX#dOJJb_[L1YhKH,_u^dOTVUi"GI_!qKH YbdOToQ#H\u_"N_"U]^ ¼C "É«r_ É ¼ _"U#J,mLHNO_ELT"YYbH1Jkq~TVU#QªQ#H1qfX#dPJ½ `*dONPNOd_uYQ#JQxy_"U#UKHHJmr_EX#U#H\ZdPU#W"^_"dOU#HQ#H^bTVXZYbJ(w¿¶r_.u½^bTVXZYbJFHU\hdPYbTVUiÈ«H`(HCNPHJFLM#d YbH1Jv_"Xh|#goX#HNOJFU#TVX#JFJTV`*`*HJMf_ufdP^XKHJmuL1TV`*`*HcNxÃ_"WVH:Q#HN_ -zH YYbH"mJTVU]^Q#dP*L1dONOH1Jar_pJHYbH q#YZKHJHU]^bH1YiV TVXZY Q#TVU#U#H1YghX#H1NOghX#H1JdO`*_"WVHJmLTVU#JkdOQcKH1YbTVU#JX#U´^Y,rH1JÂ\hdOHXh|³¬TVJJkdONOH6Q#H6NxOrH YbH?q#YbdO`3_"dYbH"m=LTV`(`*H?X#Uµ^YdONOT"fd^bH?Q#XL,_"`#YbdPHU@TVXQ#X6L,_uYTVU#dO¬ rH1YbHum~\ZdOH1Xh|@Q#H< ¼V¼ `(dONONPdOTVU#JaQx¸_"U#UcKHHJ1iÁ!XZY_"U]^FLH1^^HQ#XZYZKHH"mtdONz_H HL1^bXcKH3HU]\ZdYbTVU¦^bTVXZYbJSQ#H3N_EW]_"NO_|#dOH.NxÇHJJH1U^bdPHNFr_.NxKH1^b_u^vQ#H*¬TVJJkdONOH3dPN:H1Jk^v\hYb_"d m_"NOT"YJghXxÇHUÂX#UEJdrHLNOHFTVUÂUxyHUH HL ^bX#HgoXxyX#U#HF¬Y_"L1^bdPTVUQ#HF`*dPNONOdPTVU#drH`(H [TVX#JJTV`*`*H1Jq~HXÂQ#HLM#TVJHJ ''

Page 28: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

M &

?% 9 &52?'3B B52?5!7 ),/ &5F7 BA )/,2*-5!;:A-:/1'*2 &5)15-;/1D.+?5 5R-p'*B &5[-0/-:/1'32 (;:A 2?/- AS-:/1'32~/,2*- 5F;:A-:/1'*2 &5)15-;=/1DE+?5

G4674 > QD$@EJI>/: @ D < D$@ED >/D2 < D>#J<?>'ED$J BED2 % <&: QD B EB!0: D$@ D

G:xy_u^bTV`*HQxyM]eZQZYbTVW#rH1U#H.HJk^<L,_uY_"L1^hKH1YbdOJoKHq_uY*NPHJ(`*_"JJHJ I H1^ I Q#HNxKH1NOHL1^kYbTVU¨H1^<Q#Xq#YbT"^bTVUmVNPHXZYbJ0LMf_uYbWVHJ H1^ mVNO_FLTVU#Jw^_"U^H L_uY_"L1^hKH1YdOJk^bdPghX#HQ#HNxydPU^H1Y_"L1^bdPTVU«KH1NOHL1^kYbdOgoX#HNPHJH H1^JCW"Yb_\hdP^_u^bdPTVU#U#HNOJSJTVU^CUcKHWVNPdOWVH,_ufNPHJvH1^CN_?LTVU#Jw^_"U^HÂQ#HÂcNO_"U#L ! mqfX#dPJghX#HNPH^Y_"d^bH`*H1U^Q#TVdP^H1^YHgoXf_"U^bdPghX#HHUY_"dPJTVU.Q#HFN_q~H1^bd^bH!^_"dONPNOH!Q#HSNx¸_u^bTV`*Hui

­=TV`*`*H!NxKHU#H1YbWVdPHH1Jk^RL,_uYb_"L1^hKH1YbdPJoKHHFq_uYRNOH!^bH1Y`*HQxÇdOU]^bH1Y_"L ^bdOTVU > ½ m#TVUEq~TVJH Y_ghX#HFN_^_"dONPNOH!L,_uY_"L ^ZKH1^bdPJk^bdOgoX#HQ#HNxy_u^bTV`*H"mIm#HJk^pQ#HSN_¬T"Yb`*H

»2# > F ½ F/I F/I F F JTVdP^ » > ) ½ + I - I wVi ¾V

­=TV`*`*H M > ½ ION » 0P > R 9 > mTVU_ M ½ N » M > 9 I 9: N R > i"­=TV`fdOUcKH[r_9M N » 0P > R 9<: mLH1^k^bH¶H |hq#YbHJJdPTVUºq~H1Y`*H1^QxKHNPdO`*dPU#H1Y R H1^EdON!\ZdOH1U^2M N » M ½ 3 > > 9: I 9<: N mJTVd^,mHULM#TVdOJdPJJb_"U]^=_!q#YbdOT"Ybd_uYfd^Y_"dYbH`*HU]^0N_!`3_"JJHQ#HpNxKHNPHL1^YTVU?L"xÇHJk^©wX#Jk^bd°=KHpJdfNxÇTVU<YbH1`3_uYbghX#HghX#H[NPHpq#YbT"^bTVULT, ·PU#LdOQ#H[H1UÂTVU#U#H!_uq#q#YbT|ZdO`3_u^dOTVU3_,\]HL[NOHpLHU]^YbH!Q#H[W"Y_,\ZdP^hKHRQ#H[Nxy_u^bTV`*HpH ^YbHJw^bHSQ#TVU#Lr_Cq~H1XEq#Y,rHJadO`*`*T"fdPNOHm

» ½ > > 9: I 9: # I I LHghX#dfLTVU#Q#X#d^,m]Qf_"U#JcNxÇMeoq~T"^bMrH1JHaTtrX<N_!¬TVU#L1^bdPTVU*HJk^:QxyT"YbQZYH ;< > r_!NxÇH |Zq#YbH1JJdOTVU<Q#X(Y_,e]TVUQ#Hv=TVMZYaQ#HSNx¸_u^bTV`*H[QxÇMehQZYbTVW#rHU#H

» ½ >I > » ¼C V"Â ¼ 9:

` wVi¸É]

[U T"#^bdOH1U#QZY_8Q#H `*_"U#drH1YbH JdP`*dONO_"dPYbH NxKHU#H1YWVdOH L_uY_"L1^hKH1YdOJk^bdPghX#H q_uY NxyH |hq#YbHJJdPTVU > ½ goX#dLTVU#Q#X#dP^Cr_ ;=< > » I

½ > > » V¾ ¿ ¼ 9<: À wVi¸]

s:U´YbH1q#YbH1Uf_"U^YbdOWVTVXZYbH1X#JH`*HU]^.NPH`.H`*H?Y_"dOJkTVU#U#H`*HU]^,mTVUµqHXZ^.L,_"NPLX#NOH Y.N_ª^_"dPNONOHL,_uY_"L ^ZKH1YbdPJk^bdOgoX#H8Q#X JkehJk^,rH`(H q#YbT"^bTVUhluKHNOH1L1^YbTVU HU NOH JXZq#qTVJb_"U]^ NOdKH q_uY NPHJ ¬T"YbL1HJW"Y_,\Zd^_u^bdOTVU#U#H1NONOH1JX#U#dPghX#H`(HU^i [UE^YTVXZ\]HS_"NPT"YbJ

» >) IlI > ¼ > ` F wViO ¼

L"xÇHJk^kl r_l Q#dPYHaX#U*U#TV`#YbHJb_"U#Jc_"X#LX#U#Hp`(HJXZYbHa_\]H1LaNO_!YhKH_"NOdP^hKHH ^:`.H`*HJXZqKH1YbdPHXZYr_!N_[^_"dPNONOHQ#HNxÇX#U#dP\]H1YbJ ÄwNhHJk^Q#TVU#LLN_"dYghX#H=NO_!Jw^YbX#L1^bXZYHQ#HNx¸_u^bTV`*H:HJk^ ^Y,rHJ fdOHUCQKHL1Ybd^bH_"XC`*Te]H1UQ#H!N_`nKHL,_"U#dPghX#H[goXf_"U^bdPghX#H< cH1^Q#HNxydPU^bH Y_"L1^bdPTVU±KH1NOHL1^kYbdOgoX#H( iZG:xy_ufJHU#LHFQ#H H1^Q#H) `*TVU]^YbH3ghX#HÂW"Y_,\Zd^_u^bdOTVUªH ^<YbH1N_u^bd\ZdP^hKH*U#H©wTVX#H1U^*_"X#LX#UnYuTVNPHTVX¨HU¦^bTVXZ^CL,_"JX#UnYuTVNPHUcKHWVNPdOWVH,_ufNPHHUq#YbH`*drH1YbH_uq#q#YbT|ZdO`3_u^dOTVUi;< > * A , 4[; , EZ; 2w¤D4 , N\3 @BAWNGFG2Ì E-2(H P?- [a;< > 4Ò 4[;<29E-F 2w¤D4 , NG2 2=8ON ;V4 3 @BT<NXT 02^6-2 , 2bNGNG2 Ò 4[;<2=EDFw " - # 2 D@ LE 2 - Ñ ' (Za

Page 29: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

!"# G4H354 <ID E> /D BED$J Q: @A< @ED$J Xh| KHLM#HNONPHJSQ#H<NOTVU#WVX#HXZYdOU]^bH1Yb`nKHQ#d_"dYbHJmtNOH1JFqfMcKHU#TV`.rHU#HJSqfM]eZJdPghX#HJJTVU]^SWVTVXZ\]H1YUKHJ

q_uYN_ªLTV`<q=KH1^bdP^dOTVU±HU]^YbH@Q#HXh|¯dPU^H1Y_"L1^bdPTVU#Ji­=TV`*`*H.H|#H`(qfNPH.TVU¯q~HXZ^LTVU#JkdOQcKH1YbH YENO_Mf_"XZ^bHXZY!`*_|#dO`*_"NOH QxÇX#U#H`*TVU]^_"WVU#HSJXZYRX#U#HvqfN_"UrH1^bHTtrX?NPHSLMf_"`(q@Q#HvqHJb_"U]^bHXZY[\u_"XZ^E i­=H1^^bHMf_"XZ^bH1XZY`*_|#dO`*_"NOHFHJk^F_u^^bH1dOU]^bHNOT"YbJkghX#HN_(q#YHJJdPTVUH |ZH1YbL KH1HCq_uY!NPHvq~TVdOQ#J[Q#HNO_`*TVU]^_"WVU#HHJk^JXZ(Jb_"U^HCqTVXZYFq#YT\]ToghX#H1YFN_3¬X#JdPTVUQ#HCJb_3_"JH"iGI_ÂLTVMcKH1JdOTVUQ#HJJkTVNOdOQ#H1JHJk^RWVTVXZ\]H1YbUcKHHvqTVXZY!Jb_(q_uY^Rq_uY[NxKHU#H YbWVdOHKH1NOHL1^kYbTVJk^_u^bdPghX#HvH ^[TVU.q~HXZ^RHU@HJk^bdP`*H1YRNxyT"YbQZYHQ#HRW"Y_"U#Q#H1XZYr_( Q#HpNxKHU#H1YWVdOHpQxÇdOTVU#dPJb_u^bdOTVU(Q#HJ_u^bTV`(HJm]L,_"NOL1X#NKHHpq#YhKHLHQ#H`(`*HU]^ ;u y > i [Uq~H1XZ^ Q#TVU#L=U#T"^bH1YzN_RQ#HU#Jd^hKHQxKHU#H1YbWVdPHUKHLHJkJb_"dPYbHvr_pNO_p¬X#JdPTVUCQxÇX#UJTVNOdPQ#H 9 j » TrXW ¼ 9<: `8HJk^FNxÇT"YbQZYbHQ#HW"Y_"U#Q#HXZYQ#HCNO_3Q#dOJk^_"U#L1HCH1U^YH(_u^bTV`(HJ[Qf_"U#J!X#UJTVNPdOQ#H"m ¼ H H ^ ¼C¸¼ ViGHJcq_uY_"`.rH1^YbHJ0q~H1Yk^bdOU#HU]^bJcqTVXZYNxyHJk^dO`3_u^bdPTVU<Q#H JkTVU^cQ#TVU#LRNOHaLMf_"`<q3Q#Hpq~H1Jb_"U^HXZYE m0NO_Q#HU#JkdP^hKH " ¼ ! W ` 9 Q#X§`3_u^hKH Ybd_"XnH1^ 9 j c ¯» # F E F "o !U±`*TVU]^YbH¬ _"LdPNOH`*H1U^aghX#H M N » M E 9: " 9<: N m#JTVdP^ (» LTVU#Jk^ " 9: E 9: H1^p°fUf_"NPH`*HU]^aqTVXZYpNO_ -zH YYbH

" E V ¼ ` wViOVLHghX#d#LTVU#Jw^bdP^bX#HX#U(T"YQZYbHaQ#HW"Y_"U#Q#HXZY0^Y,rH1J:LT"YkYbHL1^,iVG0xys0\]H1YbHJw^cLX#NP`*dOU#HHU<H H ^Fr_[q#Y,rHJ0Q#H ¼V¼V¼ ` H1^RNPHJa\]TVNPL,_"U#JpQ#H1J·ONPHJpj!_,_, ·TVU^pX#U#HvMf_"XZ^bHXZY[Q#H ¼V¼V¼ `8_"XEQ#HJJX#J[Q#X?U#d\]H,_"XQ#HvNO_<`*H1YaH1^aYbH1q~TVJkHU^RJXZY[N_qfN_"goX#HSThL KH,_"U#dOgoX#Hq_"Ld°fghX#Hr_(½ ¼V¼V¼ TVX@ ¼V¼V¼ ` _"Xhl Q#H1JJTVX#JQ#X¨U#d\]H,_"X¦Q#HÂNO_6`(H1Y,i [U¨L1TV`(q#YbHU#Q KHW]_"NOH`(HU^goX#HJXZYCÈ_uYJ.`(TVdOU#Jv`3_"JkJdP\]HghX#HNO_-zH1YkYbHvH1^!Q#TVU#L_,\]HLX#U#H_"LL KHNKH1Yb_u^bdOTVU?Q#HNO_(q~HJb_"U]^bHXZY!`(TVdOU#QZYbHdONH |#dPJk^bHvQ#HJ[¬ _"NO_"dOJH1JRQ#H ¼ ! ` Q#HMf_"XZ^bH1XZY,i

"!$#&%('*) 5# * . @BNO@ 8 6]Ð EDA , 4[A Í @BA?H ]OEZT<;V;<2bN #BP\2=N 6Ð EDA-253 @ AWNG4[CBA-258GE-F >4 FX8 H2#]OEDTV;<;<2=N P TV3 4 C[298 6ZE^]_@BEDF H /0#"%(/ 6$#. "$00 6&0'&* P/a­=HJY_"dPJTVU#U#H`*HU]^bJ=Q#TVU#U#HU]^NxÇT"YbQZYbHRQ#H[W"Yb_"U#Q#HXZYQ#H[N_vMf_"XZ^bH1XZYQ#HJ=`*TVU]^_"WVU#HJcqTVXZY

Q#HJ_"Jk^YbH1J_,e_"U]^X#U#H<_"L1^bd\Zd^ZKHv^bHL1^TVU#dOghX#Hui­HUxyH1Jk^!q_"JNO_L_"JFQ#HCN_3GX#U#H<q_uYFH |ZH`(qfNOHghX#dqTVJJrHQ#H1Yb_"dP^[_"XZ^kYbH`*HU]^aQ#HJp`*TVU]^_"WVU#HJ^Y,rH1JÂKHNPH1\:KHH1JiG4 4 +JJ&D BED D0D

G:xÇHJk^bdP`3_u^bdPTVU Q#H²N_ `3_"JkJHºQ#H²N_ -IH1YYbH´qHXZ^¥H1^YH²¬ _"dP^bHºH1U L1TV`(q_uY_"U]^±NxKHU#H1YbWVdPHW"Y_,\Zd^_u^bdOTVU#U#H1NONOH±r_¨NxKHU#H1YWVdOH KH1NOHL1^kYbdOgoX#H"iaGI_ -zH YYbHH1Jk^?HUºH H1^?X#U²T"Z©wH1^EHU8KHgoX#dONOd#YbH"iG0xyH H1^Q#H!N_vW"Y_,\Zd^_u^bdOTVUmghX#d^bHU#Qªr_H TVU#QZYbH YaNPH[JkeZJw^rH`*H"moHJk^LTV`<q~HU#JoKHRq_uYNO_Jk^_ufdONPdP^hKH_u^bTV`*dPghX#H"iG0xKHU#H1YWVdOH3W"Y_,\Zd^_u^bdOTVU#U#H1NONOHC^bT"^_"NPH(HJk^Q#HNO_.¬T"Yb`*H M » ) > izÄNcHJw^_"JJH a Q#d*LdPNOHªQxÇHJk^bdP`*H1Y?NxKHU#H1YWVdOH®KHNPHL1^YbdPghX#HªL,_uY.N_±L1YbTtXZ^bH¶^H1YYbHJw^YbH«HJk^@JTVNPdOQ#H"ma`3_"dOJNxÇdOU]^hKH1YbdPHXZYIQ#H:NO_ -zH YYbH0HJk^INOdOgoX#dOQ#H"i [USqHXZ^I^TVXZ^bH¬TVdOJLTVU#JdPQKH1YbH1YzghX#H0N_Jk^_ufdPNOdP^hKHKH1NOHL1^kYbdOgoX#HHJk^ _"JJXZYhKHHq_uYNxKH1U#H1YbWVdOHcQxydOTVU#dPJb_u^bdPTVU^ ehqfdPghX#H"mQ#HNxÇT"YbQZYbHcQ#H » r_v ¼ H¯q_uY_u^TV`*H"m

;vu y > * @ E-F Y @BAZ6-FG2 EZAS8O@B;VT<6D2 T<; Y 4BE-N 4ÏÏ @[FGNO2=F EDA-2 029A-2=FOC T 2Ì EDT AD2cÏ 29E-N 2bNGFG2Ì EÐ EDA-2 Y FX4 , NGT<@BA 6-2 ;PÐ 029A-2=FGCBT<26]Ð T<@BAZT<8G4 NXT @ A±Ì EDT , @BFOFG298ÃÏ @BAZ6 L4 ;V4 6ZT<8G8_@ , T<4[NGT<@BA 6-2 ;Ð 4 NG@ 352Ba Î A¦Ï 29E-N7A-@BNO2=F3Ì E-2 ;<4Ò 4[;<2=EDF ,/. @ T<8GT 2 " 2 , @[FGFO298ÃÏ @ AD67L4REZA-2^NO2*3Ï 02=FX4 NXE-FG2 6-2p"!= , 2Ì EDT298_N NG@BE-N5L4 Y 4[T<N FG4BT<8O@BAZAD4Ó ; 2=Ï @ E-F EDAD2NG293Ï 02bFX4 NXE-FG2\6D2 Y ED8GT @ A a 4 , @[FGFG2=8Ï @BAD6Z4[A , 2 029A-2=FOC T 2$# NG293Ï 02bFX4 NXE-FG2ÏZFO@bÒ-T<29AWN16D2 ;V4:Ï .Í 8GTÇÌ ED2 8ONX4 NXT<8ONGTyÌ E-2ÏZ4[F\;<20Ó T<4BT<8 6-2 ;V4 , @BAZ8_NX4[AWNG2 6D2 @B;<N 354BADA&%'EÌ EZT 3 298OEDFO2 ;Ð 029A-2=FOC T 2 , TVA 02=NGTyÌ E-2^3 @ Í 29ADAD2 L45NO2*3Ï 02bFX4 NXE-FG26-@ ADA 02b2 %' # H(%' - Ñ % ( ! Ñ '=P/a

Page 30: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

&

LH*goX#d¬ _"dP^vX#U^bT"^_"N q~TVXZYSNOH<\]TVNPX#`*HCQ#H*N_ -zH1YYbH<Q#H M » ½ TtrX2 » HJk^N_SQ#dPJk^_"U#LHp^ eoqfdOghX#HpHU^kYbH[_u^bTV`*H1JcQf_"U#JX#U3JTVNPdOQ#HRTVX3X#U3NPdOgoX#dOQ#H"iscU¨KHW]_"NO_"U^cLHJ=Q#HXh|LTVU]^YbdfXZ^bdOTVU#JmdON~\hdOHU]^aX#U#HSH |hq#YbHJJdPTVU?HU]^YbHYb_e]TVUH1^p`*_"JJH c

> » ½

)

F wViOV

JTVd^,mZ_,\]HL ¶» ¿ ¼ ; ` X#U#H!`3_"JkJH[Q#H ª» * ¼ > ! Wfmh^Y,rHJq#YbThLM#H!Q#H!N_v\u_"NOHXZY=YhKH1HNONPH ¿ ¼ > ! Wfi

"!$#&%('*) 5" 4 % 2bFGFG2 =TV354[C[2 6DE1]_@ E-F(6DE 4Ò FXT<; H /0#"%(/ 6$#. "$00 6&0'&* P/a­=HY_"dPJTVU#U#H`*H1U^´U#H®q~HXZ^µq_"JºJxy_uq#qfNOdOgoX#H1Y´_"Xh| WzKH,_"U]^bHJ´W]_ a HX#JHJ À XZqfdP^bH1Y´TVX

_u^bXZYbU#H, m U#dI_"X?JTVNPHdONtghX#dtY_,e]TVU#U#HKHU#T"Yb`nKH`*HU]^pQxKHU#H1YbWVdPHvH1^pUxyHJk^pQ#TVU#LSq_"JpX#U?T"Z©wH1^Cr_NxKHghX#dPNOd#YbH!Qf_"U#JpJTVUµKH ^_u^pQxKHU#H1YbWVdPHS`*dPU#dO`3_"NPH"i

Â% 9 &52?'3B B52?5F7 4/ 2<5F;:7

54674 +> #D BED$J @E: 'G0xyHJw^bdO`3_u^dOTVUªQ#HÂN_?^_"dONPNOH*Q#XnU#Te_"X¦q~HXZ^CJH¬ _"dPYbHQ#HN_@`.H`(H3`3_"U#drH1YH3ghX#HLHNPNOHQ#H

Nxy_u^bTV`*H"iIGIH1JCq_uY^dOLX#NPHJLTVU#Jk^bd^bXZ^bdP\]H1Jmq#YbT"^bTVU#JCH1^CU#HXZ^YbTVU#JCJTVU]^6r_?q~H1Xnq#Y,rHJCQ#HÂ`?H`*H`3_"JJkHJ I ¿]¾º ¼ 9 >BA ! W´H1^6JTVU]^NPdKHH1J@q_uYdOU]^bH1Yb_"L1^bdOTVU ¬T"Y^bH¦L,_uY_"L ^ZKH1YbdPJhKHH«q_uYNO_LTVU#Jk^b_"U^bH E m E > ¼ 9 >BA ! W ` J 9 > izGH*^Y_"d^bH`*H1U^SU#H*q~HXZ^JkH3¬ _"dPYbH3goXxyHUª`nKH1L,_"U#dOgoX#HghXf_"U]^bdPghX#H"mfQxyTtrXNxÇdOU]^bH1Y\]HU]^bdPTVUEQ#H c »2# IAF E > F i [U.T"#^bdPHU]^R_"dPU#Jd

> I E > ¼C ¿ ¼ 9<:!= `

JdNxÇdOU]^bH1Y_"L ^bdOTVUnKH1NOHL1^kYbdOgoX#HpUxydPU^H1Y\ZdPHU]^=ghX#H^Y,rHJ¬ _"dfNOH`(HU^cQf_"U#J=N_SJw^YbX#L1^bXZYHRQ#X3U#Te_"XmLHghX#dtHJk^aH H1L1^bdP\]H1`*HU]^pLT"YkYbHL1^i

Page 31: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

!"#

54H354 : @ @ED QD$@ <:AJ&JI> /D

ÁF_"U#JvNPHJv`*ToQtrHNOHJQxyH |hq_"U#JdOTVUªQ#H(NxyX#U#d\]H1YbJmIN_EQcKH ^bH1Yb`*dPUf_u^bdOTVUQ#H3N_E`*_"JJH<^T"^_"NOHCQ#HNxÇX#U#dP\]H1YJH1Jk^a^kYrHJdO`(qT"Y^_"U]^bHRq~TVXZYaQcKHLdPQ#H1YaHU^kYbHNPHJJL KHUf_uYdOTVJQ#dP\]H1YbJSH |hq_"U#JdOTVUÂdOUZ°fU#dPHJd N_S`3_"JkJHa^bT"^b_"NOHpUxÇH |#L"rHQ#HRq_"JX#U#HRLH Y^_"dOU#HR\u_"NOH1XZYL1Ybd^bdOgoX#H"modPW­YbX#U#LMÂH ^=LTVU]^Y_"L1^bdPTVUJTVX#J!NxÇH H ^!Q#HN_3W"Y_,\ZdP^b_u^bdOTVU.Jkd N_*`3_"JJkHHJk^!JXZqKH1YdOHXZYbH?r_3N_*\u_"NOHXZY!L1YdP^bdPghX#H"m '' i TVXZYLHNO_Zm^TVXZ^bHJvNPHJv¬T"Yb`*H1JvQ#H*`3_"JJkH?TVXªQxKHU#H1YbWVdPHFq#YhKHJkHU^HJQf_"U#JvNxÇX#U#dP\]H1YbJSQ#TVdP\]HU]^3H1^YHq#YbdPJHJ0HU(LTV`<q#^bH"i [U(LTVU#Uf_ ·^c_uq#q#YT|ZdO`3_u^bd\]H`*HU]^ NO_FQ#HU#JkdP^hKHQ#Ha`*_"JJH`3_"JJkHq_uY:X#U#dP^hKHQ#H\]TVNOX#`*H_"JkJThLdKHHr_N_!Q#dOJw^YbdPfXZ^dOTVUCQ#HaNO_F`3_u^drH1YbHW]_"NO_"L1^bdOgoX#H " H ¼ 9 > ! W ` 9 ÃÄNJxy_"WVdP^[dPLdzQ#HNO_`*_"JJHS^bT"^b_"NOHvQ#HJ!W]_"NO_|#dOH1JpQ#dP\hdOJoKH1Hvq_uY!NOHv\]TVNOX#`(HSQ#HNxÇX#U#dP\]H1YbJ1iG0xyX#U#dP\]H YbJLTV`(q#YHUf_"U^QxydP`*`*HU#JkHJ[YZKHWVdOTVU#J[\hdOQ#HJmtLH ^^bH`3_"JJH\]TVNOX#`(dOghX#HH1Jk^^kYrHJ!dOU#¬1KH1YdOHXZYbH@r_NO_Q#HU#Jd^hKHÂQ#HJ<W]_"NO_|#dPHJÂ`3_"JJkH3QxyX#U#HÂW]_"N_|#dPH3Q#dP\hdOJoKHH3q_uY<JTVU«q#YbT"q#YbH\]TVNOX#`*H"mzQ#HÂNxyT"YbQZYHQ#H¦ ¼ 9 >@= ! W ` 9 ia­H1JU#TV`#YbHJÂJTVU]^E`*_"NOW"YhKH.^bTVXZ^ÂH |h^Y,H`(H`*HU]^3q~H1^dP^bJÂLTV`(q_uYhKH1J_"Xh|Q#HU#Jd^hKHJMf_ufdP^bX#HNPNOHJ c H,_"Xm ¼ ! W ` 9 mtTVX¶_"dYQf_"U#JNxy_u^b`*TVJkqfMrH1YH^H1YYbHJw^YbH"mQ#H<NxyT"YbQZYHQ#H( ! W ` 9 i i

"!$#&%('*)5 Ò @B;VE-NXT @ AU6-2 ;PÐ * AZT Ò 2=FG8ba

"!$#&%('*)5' 14[FONG@[CBFG4Ï . T 2 6DE Y @ AD6U6D2 FX4 Í @ ADA-2*3 29AWN , @ 8G35TyÌ E-2RH 8G4 NG2=;V;VT NG2 Î 1P/aÄNcH|#dOJw^bHnKHW]_"NPH`*HU]^Qf_"U#JNxÇX#U#dP\]H1YJvX#U#H_"XZ^YbH3¬T"Yb`(H(QxKH1U#H1YbWVdOH_"JkJThLdKHH_"Xª¬TVU#Q«Q#H

Y_,e]TVU#U#H`*HU]^*L1TVJ`*dOgoX#H¦r_¶ Cm\]HJk^bdPWVHEQ#X¯=dOW_"U#W#mH1^*LHNONPH l L1daQ#TVd^*LTVU]^YbdfX#H1Yr_NO_

Page 32: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

&

Q#HU#Jd^hKHSQ#H`3_"JJH!^bT"^_"NPH[q_uYRNxÇdOU]^bH1Yb`nKHQ#d_"dYbH!Q#HNO_<L KHNrH1#YbHFYbHN_u^dOTVUEQxÇscdPU#Jk^bHdPUKH1U#H1YbWVdOH » `3_"JJH >

[UvJH:q#YT"q~TVJH:Q#HcQcKH1^bH Yb`*dOU#H YNxÇT"YbQZYbH0Q#HcW"Y_"U#Q#H1XZYQ#HcNO_a`3_"JkJH0\]TVNPX#`*dOgoX#H0_"JJThL1dKHH " W R iGHY_e]TVU#U#H1`*HU]^ LTVJ`*dPghX#H:HJk^X#UH |#H1`(qfNOH:Q#H=LHghXxÇTVU_uq#q~HNPNOH=X#UvY_,e]TVU#U#H`*H1U^Q#HL1T"YqfJU#TVdPYRH1^RNO_<qfX#dOJJ_"U#LHQKHW]_"WKHHSq_uY[X#U#d^hKHvQ#HvJkXZYb¬ _"LHvq_uY[X#U@LT"YqfJpU#TVdPY[HJw^[Q#TVU#UKHHvq_uY[NO_NOTVdQ#H ^bH¬ _"U TrX6NO_*LTVU#Jk^_"U]^bHQ#H ^bH1¬ _"U@\u_"XZ^ » ¿ ¿]" ¼ 9 ! W J 9 9 i [U²KHL1Ybd^Q#TVU#L!" W R » # F F Nx¸_"dPQ#HaQ#H M N » 0R 9 9 m.M N » m M N »SPR 9: H1^EM1" N » 0P 9 mTVUET"#^dOHU]^ M/" N » M 9 N m#JTVdP^

" W R ¼ 9 : ! W ` 9 wViO]LH?goX#daYbH1q#YhKHJHU]^bH@X#U#H?¬Y_"L1^bdPTVU±Q#H?NxÇT"YbQZYbH.Q#X¯`*dPNONOdrH`*HQ#H?N_¶Q#H1U#JdP^hKH?Q#H?`*_"JJH.Q#H?NO_`3_u^bdrH1YbHW]_"N_"L ^bdOgoX#H"iGz_6`3_"JJHÂ^bT"^_"NOHÂ_"JJkThLdKHH._"X§¬TVU#Q±Q#HÂY_,e]TVU#U#H`*HU]^*LTVJk`*dOgoX#HHJw^Q#TVU#LSL1TVU#JdOQcKH1Yb_ufNOH"mQ#HSNxyT"YbQZYbHFQ#H( ¼ A ! Wfi54 4 > <ID$JJ&D B D!@ F : B DKJ : >/J&D 'G0x¸_uq#q~H1N#Qx¸_"dPY0HJw^cX#U#HQKH1q#YbHJkJdOTVU*L_"X#JhKHHq_uYcNO_!\hdP^bHJkJHQxKHLTVX#NPH`*HU]^:QxyX#UfX#dPQ#Hp_"XZ^TVXZY

QxyX#ULT"YkqfJJTVNOdPQ#H"i dPU#JdmNOT"YJghXxÇX#UL,_"`*dOTVUq_"JJHSr_pW"Y_"U#Q#H\hdP^bH1JJHH1^QKH1q_"JJH=X#UL1ehLNOdPJk^bH"mdONHU]^Y_ ·PU#H=_\]H1LNOX#dNxy_"dPYz_"`fdO_"U^zH1^NO_pQcKH1q#YbH1JJdOTVUHU]^YbHcNOHL,_"`(dOTVUSH ^ NOH:L1eZLNPdOJk^H:q#YbToQ#X#dP^ NO_¬T"YbLHpQx¸_"JkqfdY_u^bdOTVU<fdOHU*L1TVU#UoX#H"i#­!xÇHJk^cqTVXZYNPHJc`.H1`*HJY_"dOJTVU#JcghX#HpNO_¬X#`nKH1HRQ#HpLdPW]_uYbH1^^HJT"Y^<JkqTVU^_"UcKH1`*HU]^(q_uY*NO_¬HUH ^YbH.QxÇX#U#H\]TVdP^XZYbHEHU¨`*TVXZ\]H`*HU]^,i0­=HJ<qfMcKH1U#TV`?rHU#HJ*JkHLTV`(qfNPdOgoX#HU^pq_uYb¬TVdOJRq_uY!NO_3q#YhKHJHU#LHCQ#Hv^bXZYfX#NPHU#LHJ1i[TVX#J!_"NPNOTVU#JR¬ _"dYbHX#U6`*ThQrHNPHS^Y,rH1JJdP`(qfNOd°=KH3Qx¸_"dONPH3QxyTVdPJH,_"X«q~TVXZYCQKH1^bH1Y`*dOU#H1YCNO_?\hdP^bH1JJHQxyHU]\]TVN=TVXmzqfNPX#J<WzKHUcKH Y_"NOH`(HU^CNO_\Zd^bHJJkH<`*dPU#dO`3_"NPHr_NO_"ghX#HNPNOHX#UTVdPJH,_"X6q~HXZ^FqfN_"U#H1Yi [U¶U#Hq#YbHU#QZY_Âq_"JHULTV`(q#^bHNOH1JLTV`(qfNPdOL,_u^dOTVU#JJXZq#qfNKH1`*HU]^_"dPYbH1JpNOdKHHJp_"X_u^^bH1`*HU]^pQ#HJp_"dONPHJaH1UEq_uY^bdPLX#NOdPH1Y,i

"!$#&%('*)5=5 , @ ED;<29352=AWN 6-2";PÐ 4[T<F 4[EDNO@ E-F 6Ð EDA-2 4BT<;<2 H 2=A . 4BE-N 29A 02 , @BEZ; 2*3 29AWN ;<4 35T<AZ4[T<FO2H AD@[FQ354[; P>2bN 29AÓZ4B8 2=A 02 , @ ED;<293 29AWN NGEDFÓ ED;<2=AWN/P/a + E-F`;V4(&ZC E-FG2 6DE . 4BE-Nk ;V4.Ò-T NG2=8G8O26]Ð 02 , @BEZ; 2*3 29AWN 2=8ON 8GEÏ 02=FXT 29E-FG2 4[E¡ 6D2=8G8OEZ8 6D2 ;Ð 4BT<;<2aÌ EÐ 4BE 6-298O8O@BEZ8:a + EDF ;<4!&ZCBEDFO2R6DEvÓZ4B8 ; 298"NXE-FÓZEZ; 29A , 2=8tÏ 2=FGNGEDFÓ 29AWN , @ AD8GT<6 02bFX4Ó ; 2*3 29AWN ;PÐ 02 , @BED;<2*3 2=AWN=a­=TVU#JdOQcKH YbTVU#JQ#TVU#LpX#U#HR_"dONOH=q_uYb¬ _"d^bHpQ#HaJXZYb¬ _"LH ghX#d#q~H1Y`*H1^:X#U¨KHLTVX#NPH`*HU]^Q#HaNx¸_"dY,m

Q#H@`3_"JJH?\]TVNPX#`*dOgoX#H " ! W ` 9 m_"Xhl Q#HJJkX#J¦r_«N_¶\Zd^bHJJH Ln`3_"dOJ*q_"JÂ_"Xhl Q#H1JJTVX#JQ#HENx¸_"dPNOHdON¬ _"X#QZY_"d^*HU¨^TVXZ^bHYbdPWVX#HXZY*¬ _"dYbHEdPU^H1Y\]HU#dY*N_Q#d KH YbHU#LH.H1U^YH.NOHJC\Zd^bHJJH1JQxKH1LTVX#NOH`(HU^_"XhlQ#HJJX#JH1^_"XhlQ#HJJTVX#JH1^dPNJxy_"WVdP^fdPHUHU^HU#Q#XEQ#H[NO_\hdP^bH1JJHpYbH1N_u^bd\]HRQ#H

Page 33: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

!"# Nxy_"dONPHvH1^!Q#X fX#dOQ#H"i¸ i~GI_QcKH q#YbHJJdPTVU _"Xhl Q#HJkJX#JQ#HNx¸_"dONPHvHJk^!Q#HNO_*¬T"Yb`*H » " L >TVU_ M N » 0P 9<: R 9 > [H1^H |#H YbLH(X#U#H<¬T"YbLH goX#d Q#TVdP^LTV`(qHU#JH1YSNOHq~TVdOQ#J " GFE TrX" ¼V¼ ! W ` 9 w Q#HNOHFQ#HU#Jd^ZKHSQ#HNxyH_"XEHU]\ZdYbTVU i !U._<Q#TVU#L

L > » " GFE " ­=H1^^bH.YbH1N_u^bdPTVU³H1Jk^ÂLT"YYbHL ^bH@Q#X³qTVdOU]^Q#H?\hX#H?Q#dO`*HU#JkdOTVU#U#HNm`3_"dOJ3dPNpHJw^¯KH \ZdOQ#H1U^ÂghXxÇdON¬ _"X#QZY_"d^pX#U.L1ThH1(LdOHU]^RL_uY_"L1^hKH1YdOJb_"U]^RNPHJagoXf_"NOd^ZKHJa_zKH1YbThQZehUf_"`*dOgoX#HJQ#HSNxyTVdOJkH,_"Xi

dNxÇTVUS`*ToQKHNOdPJH`3_"dOU]^bHUf_"U]^zX#USTVdOJH,_"Xq_uYzX#U#H qfNO_"U#LM#H QxyH1U\]H1YWVXZYbHpmQxKH1q_"dOJJkHXZY ¼ H1^FQ#HCN_uYbWVHXZY LuxyHJk^_"JJkH a W"YTVJJdOH YSQxy_"JJdO`(dONOH Y!X#UTVdOJkH,_"X¯r_X#U#H<qfNO_"U#LM#H '' mNOH*\]TVNPX#`*H*Q#H3NO_@¬T"Y`*H G » ¼ qH1Yb`*H ^Q#HJdO`(qfNPdP°fH1YvNxyH|Zq#YbHJkJdOTVU«Q#HN_E\hdP^bHJkJH3HU¬TVU#L1^bdPTVU.Q#HSNxyHU]\]H1YbWVXZYHQ#HNxyTVdPJH,_"XJHX#NOH1`*HU]^ c

L » " E ¼ " ¼V¼ ±`yJ 9: wViO,½

TVXZYX#U#H(`nKHJ_"U#WVH"m ÂL`.mJkTVdP^FX#U#H(`3_"JkJHQ#HEW#mTVUT"#^bdOH1U^ L y½Â`yJ 9<: » ¼ ! `yM 9: i TVXZYX#U_"NP_u^kYbTVJmQxyHU]\]H1YbWVXZYbHZiya`.mTVUT"#^bdPHU]^!L Va`ÇJ 9: » ] ! `yM 9<: i­=HJ!U#TV`#YHJ!U#HCJkTVU^!q_"J*r_*q#YbHU#QZYbHCQ#H`3_"U#drH1YHH |f_"L1^H"m~`3_"dPJ[Q#TVU#U#HU^Q#HJ!dOU#Q#dPL,_u^bdPTVU#JYbHNO_u^bdP\]H1JicNPX#JX#UnTVdPJH,_"X¦HJk^CW"Y_"U#QmzqfNPX#J<dPNcNPX#d=¬ _"XZ^C_"LghXcKH1YdPYCX#U#H3\ZdP^HJJH§KHNPH1\:KHH3qTVXZYQcKHLTVNPNOH1YTVX*qTVXZYqfN_"U#H Y,i dNxyTVdPJH,_"X*q~TVJkJ,rHQ#H[X#ULThH *LdPHU^_IKH YbThQZehUf_"`*dOgoX#HpQ#H[`3_"XZ\u_"dOJHghXf_"NPdP^hKHumdONIHJk^FdOU#L_uq_ufNOHQ#HvqfN_"U#H1YFH1^!dPNNOX#dI¬ _"XZ^FLTVU#Jk^_"`*`(HU^p_u^^YbHQ#HJF_"dPNOHJRqTVXZYJkH`3_"dPU^bH1U#dPY[HU@Nx¸_"dPYNxÇTVdOHSq_uYRH |#H`<qfNOH iÄNIq~H1XZ^!`?H`*H*H ^YbHS^bTVXZ^RJdO`(qfNPH`*HU]^[dP`(q~TVJJkdPfNOHghX#H(NxyTVdPJH,_"X\]TVNPH"mtLTV`*`*HCQf_"U#JvNPH(L,_"JvQ#H(Nx¸_"XZ^kYbX#LM#H*ghX#d0Q#H1\hYb_"dP^_u^k^bHdOU#QZYH*X#U#H(\Zd^bHJJkHfdOH1U.JXZqKH1YbdPHXZYbHr_CJb_C\hdP^bH1JJHSQ#H!q~TVdPU^HSHU.L1TVXZYbJHv_,\u_"U^aQxyHJwq=KH1YbH1Y[J1xyHU]\]TVNOH1Y

L

v 2

pigeon

martinet

aigle

albatros

oie

mésange

fou de bassan

goéland

autruche

poule

vautour

"!$#&%('*) @BT56Ð 02 ,/. 2=;V; 2*Ò-T<NO298G8_2 6]Ð 29AÒB@ ; ¡ 29AÒB2=FOC E-FG2 H 8 ,/.102*354 NXTyÌ E-2 P[Ï @BEDF`6DTÇÒB2=FX8@BTV8_294[E¤ 4 6-FG@BT<NO2(ÏZ4B8O8G4[AWNvÏZ4[F ;PÐ @[FXT C T<AD2 , @BFOFG2=8Ï @BAZ6 4[E 3 @ 6 L29; 2 , T ¡ 6-298O8GED8SÏ @BEDF ;<298@BTV8_294[E¤O4 02bFG@ 6 Í AD4 35TyÌ E-298 2=N @ AÏ 2=EDN5TV354[CBTVA-2=F5EDA-2pÏZ4[FG4B;<; L29; 2U4BE,¡ 6-298O8GED856D2 ;V4Ì ED2=;V; 2; 298"@ T<8O2=4BE,¤U8O@BAWN TVA , 4Ï 4ÓZ;<298\6D2ÒB@ ; 2=F=a[UµqHXZ^3^Y_"LH YX#U#H NPTVdpQxKH1LM#H1NONOH goX#dpY_"JJH1`fNPH@NOHJ3LTV`<q~T"Y^bH1`*HU]^bJ*Q#HJÂQ#dP\]H1YJ

TVdOJkH,_"Xh|m=LH1Xh|ºgoX#dFJkTVU^L,_uq_ufNOH1JEQ#H\]TVNPH1Y¯KH1^_"U]^EJkdP^bXcKHJQf_"U#JEX#U#H6_"U#Q#HH1^LHXh|µghX#dq~H1XZ\]HU^aqfN_"U#H1YKH1^_"U]^a^kYrHJaq#YThLM#HJRQ#HFN_CQZYbTVdP^bHFLT"YYHJkq~TVU#Qf_"U]^(r_CU#T"^YbHF`*ThQrHNPH"i54 G4 0:GB<?>/:A@CB D$@ED >/D #D$J 7@ > '

ÄNoH1Jk^q~TVJkJdPfNPH=QxKH1^_ufNPdPYzX#U#H=NOTVdQxKHLM#HNPNOH=HU]^YbH=NO_p`3_"JJH:Q#HJ_"U#dO`*_"Xh|vH1^zNOHXZY q#YThQ#X#L1^bdPTVUghX#T"^dOQ#dOH1U#U#HvQ#HvLMf_"NOHXZY<r_<q_uY^bdYRQx¸_uYWVX#`*HU]^bJpH |h^Y,H`(H`*HU]^RJdP`(qfNOH1JpdOJkJX#JRQ#HvNxKH1^bX#Q#HQ#HN_vYhKH1JdOJk^b_"U#LHQ#H1Ja`3_u^hKH1Ybd_"Xh|~i dNxyTVUÂLTVU#JdOQrH YbHX#U#HFLTVNPTVU#U#HFL eZNOdPU#QZYbdOgoX#H!Q#HMf_"XZ^bH1XZYH ^Q#H3Y_,e]TVU! omI\]H1Yk^bdOL,_"NPH"mzL1HNONPH l LdqHXZ^JHLTVXZYH1YCJTVX#JNxÇH#"~H1^vQxyX#U#HLTVU]^Y_"dOU]^bHTVUªq_uYbNPHQ#H_"`_"WVH mZLTV`(`*Hpq_uYH |#H1`(qfNOH!NOH1J^kYbTVU#LJQx¸_uY#YHJaJkTVX#JNxyH#"H1^Q#XÂ\]H1U^,i -z_"U^ghX#H!NO_

Page 34: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

&

LTVU]^Y_"dPU^bH<YbHJk^bH_"JkJH3¬ _"dPfNPH"mzTVUªH1Jk^Qf_"U#JNOH(Q#TV`3_"dOU#H¦KHN_"Jk^dOghX#H(H1^N_LTVNOTVU#U#H(YH1q#YbHU#QJb_.¬T"Yb`(H(dOU#d^bd_"NPH*_uq#Y,rH1JvJXZq#q#YbHJkJdOTVU¦Q#H*N_LTVU^kY_"dOU]^bH"i Xhl Q#HN r_.QxyX#U#H3LTVU]^Y_"dPU^bH(NOdO`(dP^bHHU¦YbH1\u_"U#LM#Hum:dPNce¦_@YXZq#^bXZYbH"i [U¨`*TVU]^YbHHU¦^bMKHT"YbdPHQ#HÂNxKHN_"Jk^dOLd^ZKH3ghX#H3q~TVXZY«KH1\hdP^bH1YCNO_YbXZq#^bXZYH.JTVX#J(NxyH#"H1^<Q#X§JdO`<qfNOHq~TVdOQ#J<Q#HENO_LTVNPTVU#U#HEHU§JkdP^bXf_u^bdPTVU¨Q#H _"`_"WVHum0dPN¬ _"XZ^ghX#HNOHJaQ#dO`*H1U#JdOTVU#JaQ#HSN_CLTVNOTVU#U#HT"=KHdOJkJHU]^(r_(X#U#HSNPTVdtQxKHLM#HNPNOH » LTVU#Jk^ pTrX.NO_LTVU#Jk^b_"U^bHQcKH1qHU#Q¶Q#HN_3W"Y_,\Zd^hKH"m Q#HCNO_3Q#HU#JdP^hKH<Q#HN_3LTVNPTVU#U#HH1^!Q#H<JkHJ!L,_uY_"L1^hKH YbdOJk^dOghX#H1JKHNO_"Jk^bdOgoX#HJmL1TV`*`*H.NPH6`(ThQ#X#NOHEQxcTVX#U#W#i­H ^^bH?YbHNO_u^bdOTVU¯HJk^3YH`3_uYbgoXf_ufNOH`*H1U^3\:KH1YbdP°KH1HQf_"U#JpNO_<Uf_u^bXZYH"m#q_uYRH |ZH`(qfNOH[q_uYpN_¬T"Yb`*HFQ#HJR_uY#YHJ=i

"!$#&%('*) @BT 6Ð 02 ,/. 2=;V; 2 . 4[EDNO29E-F¡ 6DTV4B3ML2=NOFG2cÏ @ E-F 6-298 4 FÓDFG2=8 6]Ð # 3 02=FGTyÌ E-2^6DE @[FX6 a 298 02 ,/. 29;<;<298"8_@ AWN ;<@[CB4[FGT<N . 35TyÌ E-298 8OEDF ; 298 6D2=E¤M4¤-2=8"2bN ;V4=Ï 29AWNO2 298_NIÓZT<2=A6D2-a

G0x¸_uq#qfNPdOL,_u^bdPTVU r_ NO_ q#YbThQ#X#L1^dOTVU QxKHU#H YbWVdOH q_uY NOHJ¥_"U#dP`3_"Xh| YH1q~TVJH QxÇX#U#H q_uYk^JXZY6NxÇT"fJH1Y\u_u^bdPTVUQf_"U#J6NOHªL,_"J6Q#HJ@`3_"`*`(dO¬ rH1YbH1J.ghXxÇdONOJ?JkTVU^6W"YbTVJJkdrH1YbH1`*HU]^L1TVU#Jk^bdP^XKHJQxKH1NKH`*H1U^bJCL1ehNOdOU#QZYdOghX#H1J<goX#d=Q#TVdP\]HU]^(J_u^bdOJ¬ _"dYbHÂN_NPTVd <H1^<Qx¸_"XZ^kYbHÂq_uYk^(goX#HNO_qfX#dOJkJb_"U#LHÂQKH1\]HNOT"q#qKH1Hq_uYCX#Un`X#JL1NOHQ#H`*_"`*`*dO¬ rH YbH(HJw^<dPU#QKH1q~H1U#Qf_"U^bHQ#HNx¸_"U#dP`3_"N:H ^\u_uYbdOH!q#YbT"q~T"Yk^bdOTVU#U#HNPNOH`(HU^p_,\]HLJ_(JHL1^dOTVU =i

s:U¯_"JJdO`(dON_"U]^<X#U±`CX#JkLNOHnr_X#U³L eZNOdPU#QZYbHEQ#H?NPTVU#WVX#HXZY"!!H1^3Q#HY_e]TVU hm0TVU¯_Q#TVU#L # $%!&,ifGI_(`3_"JJkHQ#X?`X#JLNPHSHJw^pq#YbT"qT"Y^bdOTVU#U#H1NONOH3r_(JTVU\]TVNOX#`*H(') *!+%!,,mQxyTtrX¯NO_qfX#dOJJb_"U#L1H6QcKH1W]_"WKHH.q_uY3X#U¯`X#JLNOH &!-, ./,01'2/,ics:U¯JXZq#q~TVJb_"U]^ÂLH1^^HYbHNO_u^bdOTVU<\"_"NO_ufNOHaqTVXZY=NxÇHU#JH`fNPHRQ#HRNxÇT"YbW]_"U#dOJk`*HaTVU*qHXZ^^Yb_"LH1Y=LH ^^bHpNPTVd JkXZY=X#U#H.KHLM#HNONPHNOTVWulNOTVW43

NPU 65 » LTVU#Jk^87 ½ NOU9' 65

dONPNOX#Jk^kYZKHHFJXZYRNO_C°fWVXZYbHJX#dP\u_"U^H"i

(Za ! 4[A-2 2bN;:?a + NO2=FGA . 29TV3[ * .Í 8GTyÌ E-21 :S4B8O8O@BA * 4 FXT<8=<.>?>@ uÏ aAB-a

Page 35: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

!"#

P

m10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10

10

10

10

10

10

10

-3 -2 -1 20 1 3 4

0

1

2

3

4

5

souris

rat

chat

lapinmouton

vache

éléphant

kcal/j

kg "!$#&%('*) @BT 6Ð 02 ,/. 2=;V; 2 ÏDFG@ 6DE , NXT @ A ]O@BE-FXAD4B;<T L2=FO2"6D2 ,/. 4[;<2=EDFá 354B8O8O2Ï @BE-F ;<2=8hÒ 2bFGN 02wÓZF 0298L4U8O4BA-C ,/. 4BED6 H 354B3 3 T Y L2=FG2=8w @ T<8O2=4BE,¤ P/a 298 02 ,:. 29;<;<2=8 8_@ AWN ;<@[C 4 FXT N . 35TyÌ E-298 8OEDF ;<2=8^6-29E,¤4b¤-298 2bN\;<4=Ï 29AWNO2 Ò 4BE-N ZaÄNc¬ _"XZ^vU#T"^bH1YghX#H(JdcNxyTVU¶JXZq#qTVJb_"dP^JkdO`(qfNPH`*HU]^vgoX#H*NOH(\]TVNPX#`*H?ÃH1^vQ#TVU#L3NO_.`3_"JJH

\u_uYbdOHHU#! LTV`*`(H(q~TVXZY<X#UnL1XZ~HÂTVXnX#U#HÂJkqfMrH1YbHum0TVUnT"#^bdOH1U#QZY_"dP^X#U#HÂNOTVdQ#HÂN_@¬T"Yb`*H %'2 :LHagoX#dfUxyHJk^:LNO_"dPYbH`(HU^q_"J0\:KH1Ybd°=KHaH|ZqKH1YbdP`*HU]^_"NOH1`*HU]^,iVGz_F¬T"Yb`*Ha_"NONPTVU#WKHHQ#HJKHNKH`*HU]^bJpL1TVU#Jk^bdP^XZ^bdO¬JaQ#HJRLT"YqfJaQx¸_"U#dP`3_"Xh|ÂYZKH1q~TVU#QfdOHU¨r_CQ#HJRLTVU]^Y_"dPU^bH1JaqfM]eZJdPghX#HJRH ^NOH1J:Q#dP`*HU#JdPTVU#J0L_uY_"L1^hKH1YdOJk^bdPghX#HJ0JTVU]^:^kYrHJ0¬T"Y^bH`*H1U^:NOdKHHJ0_"Xh|<LTVU#Jk^_"U]^bHJ0Q#HpNO_!qfM]eZJdPghX#H"i dN_W"Y_,\ZdP^b_u^bdOTVUºKH1^_"d^!qfNOX#JF¬ _"dPfNOHq_uYH |#H`<qfNOHÃq_uYFH |#H1`(qfNOHJd KH1^_"d^FqfNPX#J¬ _"dfNOHCTVXJdNxÇTVU KH1^_"d^CJXZY3X#U#HqfNO_"UtrH1^bH`*TVdOU#JC`3_"JJd\]H m NO_NOTVdQxKHLM#HNONPH JH1Y_"d^(HU#L1T"YbH\u_"N_ufNOHumo`3_"dPJ:NO_SLTVU#Jk^b_"U^bHpHU*q#YhKH¬ _"L1^HXZYJH1Y_"d^cH,_"X#LTVXZqqfNOX#JW"Yb_"U#Q#HRH1^=NPHJcLTVU]^Y_"dPU^HJ`nKHL_"U#dOghX#H1J_"XZ^bT"YbdOJkH1Y_"dOH1U^ÂQ#HJT"YbW]_"U#dPJ`*HJ*H,_"X#LTVXZq´qfNPX#JW"Y_"U#Q#JH1^°fNOdO¬T"Y`*HJ6Ã^bTVXZ^LTV`*`(HFNPHJMf_"XZ^bHXZYbJaQ#HJR`*TVU]^_"WVU#HJghX#d~qTVXZYY_"dOH1U^vH1^YbH!~H,_"X#L1TVXZq?qfNOX#JpdP`(q~T"Yk^_"U^HJ i

2m

"!$#&%('*) A . @ 3 3 2\2bN18O@BA ,/. T<2=A 8OEDF (2=FOFG2 HXL4 C 4[E ,/. 2 P , @ 3=ÏZ4 F 0298 L4 EDA . @ 3 352\2=N8_@ A ,/. T 29AS4BT<;V;<2=EDFG8 6Z4[AD8 ;PÐ AZT Ò 2bFX8 HGL4R6-FG@BT<NO2 P 8OEDF EZA-2cÏZ;V4[A L2bNG2 35@BTVAD8 354[8G8GT Ò 2 354BT<8 6D2, @W3Ï @B8GT NXT @ A 02Ì EDTÇÒ 4[;<2=AWNG2Ï @BEDF0Ì E-2 ;V48_NGFXE , NGEDFO2 6D2ÓZ4B8_2 , 4 FÓ @BAD2¡ .Í 6-FG@[CDL2=AD2¡ @¤ Í CDL29A-2w¡4=@[NG2 8_@ T NIÏDF 02=8O2=FÒ 02=2Ba54 54 :A>/J B D ED /D D$@ >/:/: >#DGz_CNOTVdQxKHLM#HNONPHk`nKH1^b_u~TVNOdPJ`*H ®`*_"JJH /, HJk^aX#U#dP\]H1YbJkHNONPHSHUÂfdOTVNOTVWVdPH cmfLHFghX#d¬ _"d^

Q#dPYHÂr_ À iÇjif=YTaUmCi¸[iªH1Jk^RH1^p[i À i#scU#goX#dOJk^aghX#H ! & "! #" %$ ! ) ! & ! %'( & ! *)

H1^a°fUf_"NOH`(HU^aghX#H ! ! ! " + & ! " "

(Da % a,1FG@b¢ A 4[AZ6 ^a-, a/. 298_Nk +-, 4B;<TVA-C T<A0, T<@B;<@[C Í + 4BAWNG4 Z2%1 AZ8_NXT NXE-NG2 + NGEZ6DT<2=8RT<A7N . 2 + , T 29A , 2=8 @ Y @W3ÏZ;<2¤DT<N Í Î ¤ Y @BFG6 AZT Ò 2bFX8GT N Í * FO298O8w Î ¤ Y @[FX6] ?B?BB-a

Page 36: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

&

[UnL1TV`(q#YbHU#Q¦N_?NOTVd:QxKHLM#HNPNOH¯KH1\]ThgoXKHH*qfNOX#JMf_"XZ^q_uYQ#HJC_uYbWVX#`(HU^JCQ#H*YMKHTVNOTVWVdPHH1^µQ#HYhKH1JdOJk^b_"U#LH Q#HJµ`3_u^hKH1YbdO_"Xh| r_ q_uY^dPYµQ#H®N_ NOTVd ! q~TVXZYµNOHJ KHNKH`(HU^JL1ehNOdOU#QZYdOghX#H1JmqfX#dPJghX#HNOHJTVJm`CX#JkLNOHJ1m°##YbH1J.`X#JLX#N_"dYbHJmU#H1Yk\]HX#JHJmpH1^bL ÂJTVU]^.NOH1JKHNKH`*HU]^bJLTVU#Jk^bd^bXZ^bdO¬JHJkJHU]^bdOHNPNOH`(HU^aL1ehNOdOU#QZYdOghX#H1JaQ#HJT"YbW]_"U#dPJ`*HJ=\Zd\"_"U]^bJi­=H1qHU#Qf_"U^mLH1^k^bH:NPTVd k`nKH1^_uTVNOdPJ`*H=¨`3_"JJkH/, \u_"XZ^FKH1W]_"NOH`*H1U^tq~TVXZYINOH1JIT"YbW]_"U#dPJ`*HJt`*dPL1YbTVJL1T"qfdOghX#H1J ©wX#JgoXxÃr_@N_?`*d^bThLM#TVU#QZYbdPH"mX#U#dP^hKH±KH1NKH`*H1U^_"dYbH3Q#H3q#YbThQ#X#L ^bdOTVU¦QxKHU#H YbWVdOHÂQf_"U#JN_?LHNPNOX#NOH,TVX¶q~TVXZYNPHJ_"U#dP`3_"Xh|ª_"goXf_u^bdOgoX#HJiÁF_"U#JLHJQ#HXh|«JkdP^bXf_u^bdPTVU#JvH |h^Y,H`*H1JmINPHJvLTVU]^Y_"dPU^HJYbMcKHTVNPTVWVdOgoX#HJpUxÇTVU^aqfNOX#JRNPdOHX.Q#H©wTVX#H1Y[X#U.YuTVNPHq#YhKH1qTVU#QKH1Y_"U]^!HU.Y_"dPJTVU.Q#HJR¬ _"dfNOHJaH#"~H ^bJNOdKHJr_<N_CW"Y_,\ZdP^b_u^bdOTVU¶r_<NxKHLM#HNPNOHQ#HJp`*dPL1YbTulT"YbW]_"U#dOJ`(HJTVXEHU.`(dONOdPHX_"ghXf_u^bdPghX#H"i

"!$#&%('*) @ T 6]Ð 02 ,/. 29;<;<2`3 02=NG4Ó @ ;<TV8X3 2¡ 354B8O8O2CÏ @BEDFS;<2=8@BFOC 4[AZT<8X3 298!Ò-TÇÒ 4[AWNX8:a 29802 ,/. 2=;V; 29858O@BAWN ;<@[CB4[FGT<N . 35TyÌ E-298 8GE-F ;<2=856D2=E¤I4b¤-298^2bN5;V4Ï 29AWNO2RÒ 4BE-N9*Da 298^6 02 , 4[;V4 CB2=86]Ð @[FX6-@ ADA 02=298 L4\;Ð @[FXT<CBTVA-2 8_@ AWN 6DED81L4 6-298Ò 4B; 29E-FX86ZT 02=FO29AWNG2=8(6DE0ÏDF 02 Y 4 , NG29E-FÏ @ E-F 6DT 02bFG2=AWNG298, 4[N 02=C[@BFGT<2=8\6]Ð @[FGCB4BADTV8G352=8 H T<CBEDFO2 2¤-NGFG4BT NG2 6D2 ;Ð @ EÒ FX4 C[2^6-2,1FG@b¢ AM2=N . 298_N/PQaÄNQ#TVdP^*Q#TVU#LEH |#dPJk^bH1Y(X#U#HEY_"dOJkTVU¨qfNOX#J(q#YTV¬TVU#Q#Hnr_LH1^k^bH.X#U#dP\]H YbJb_"NOd^hKH"i !U¨N_^YTVXZ\]H

Qf_"U#JNx¸_"Jwq~HL1^¬Y_"L ^_"NQ#HJYZKHJH,_"Xh|ÂUcKH1LHJJb_"dYbHJr_CNxydPYkYbdOW]_u^bdPTVU3Q#HJT"YbW]_"U#dOJ`(HJ 3ZLdPYLX#N_u^bdPTVUJb_"U#WVX#dPU#H"m*JkehJk^,rH`*HµYbHJkqfdY_u^bTVdPYH"m(LdYbLX#NO_u^bdOTVU Q#H²NO_ J,rH1\]H²Qf_"U#J¯NOHJn\:KHWzKH1^b_"Xh|m i[UY_"dPJTVU#U#H1Y_(JkXZYpNxyH |ZH`(qfNOH!Q#XEYhKHJH,_"X.J_"U#WVX#dOU.Qf_"U#JaN_JX#dP^bHui­=HJYZKHJH,_"Xh|EJTVU]^pL1TVU#Jk^bdP^XKHJQxyH1`#Yb_"U#LM#H1`*HU]^bJ3Q#HEqfNOX#J(HU§qfNOX#J(qH1^bd^bJmq_uY^_"U]^*Q#H.Nx¸_"T"Y^bHÂq~TVXZY*_uYYbdP\]H Y,mc_uq#Y,rHJ

WzKHUcKH1Yb_u^bdOTVU#Jm_"Xh|L,_uqfdPNON_"dYbHJi

"!$#&%('*) 2=8O2=4BEÒ 4[8 , EZ;<4BT FG2 NOFXTV6DT 3 2=AZ8OT<@BAZA-29; 6]Ð EZA @BFOC 4[ADTV8X3 2Ò-TÇÒ 4[AWN H T<CBEDFO22¤-NGFG4BT NG2 6D2 ;Ð @ EÒ FX4 C[2 6-2,1FG@b¢ A2=N . 2=8ON/PQa

Page 37: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

!"# LMf_"ghX#HEWKHUKH1Y_u^bdPTVUm:X#U KHNKH`*HU]^*L eZNOdPU#QZYbdOgoX#H.Q#H.NPTVU#WVX#HXZY"!hm0Q#H.Y_,e]TVU hmcJkH

JoKH1q_uYHHUKHNKH`*HU]^bJr_RN_pWzKHUcKH Y_u^bdOTVUSJX#dP\u_"U^H"i [UT"fJH1Y\]H=Qf_"U#JzNOHJzYhKHJH,_"Xh|SfdOTVNOTVWVdPghX#HJghX#HHJk^r_Âq~H1Xq#Y,rHJLTVU#Jk^_"U]^r_3^bTVX#JSNPHJFU#dP\]H,_"Xh|Q#HCWKHUKH1Y_u^bdPTVUm » iz­=H1^^HYbHNO_u^bdOTVUmt_"L1LTV`(q_"WVUcKHHCQ#H(goX#HNOgoX#HJM]ehqT"^bMrHJH1JvUf_u^bXZYbHNPNOHJ1mJkXZ(^SqTVXZYYH1^YbTVXZ\]H1YN_ÂNOTVdQxKH1LM#H1NONOH`nKH1^_uTVNOdPJ`*H l`3_"JJHCH ^afdPHU.Qx¸_"XZ^kYbHJ i

GI_³`*_"JJH^bT"^b_"NOHªQ#X fX#dOQ#Hª^Y_"U#Jwq~T"Y^hKH«HJw^?q#YbT"q~T"Y^dOTVU#U#HNPNOH´r_±N_±`3_"JJkH^bT"^_"NPH¶Q#HNxÇT"YbW]_"U#dOJk`*H=H1^:HNONPHH1Jk^cQ#TVU#UcKH1Haq_uY:N_!Q#HU#JdP^hKHaQ#X fX#dOQ#Hp`X#N^bdPqfNPdKHHq_uY:NOH\]TVNOX#`*H^T"^_"NZQ#XYhKHJkH,_"XiGHv`nKH1^b_u~TVNOdPJ`*H!HJk^pq~TVXZY[Jb_(q_uYk^RQcKH1^bH Yb`*dOUcKHq_uYRNOHSU#TV`#YH^bT"^_"NtQ#HL,_uqfdPNONO_"dPYbHJ_"NOdP`*HU]^_"U]^NOHJL1HNONPX#NOHJQ#H3NxyT"YbW]_"U#dPJ`*H6r_?NO_.WKHUKH1Y_u^bdPTVUª^bH1Yb`*dPUf_"NOH ¦mzL,_uYL"xÇHJk^.r_?LH1^^HKHLM#HNPNOHghXxÇTVU^NPdOHXªNPHJKHLMf_"U#WVHJ¶KHU#H1YWKH1^bdOgoX#HJHU]^YbH3NxÇT"YbW]_"U#dOJk`*H(H1^vNOH3`*dPNOdOH1X¶H |Z^hKH1YbdOH1XZYQf_"U#JNOH1Jvq~TVX#`*TVU#Jvq_uYCH |ZH`(qfNOH, i ­=TV`*`*H<NOHJv^bdPJJX#JfdOTVNPTVWVdOgoX#HJJTVU]^HJJHU]^bdPHNONPH`*HU]^^bTVX#J6Q#H¨`.H1`*HªUf_u^bXZYbH"m!NPHJL_uY_"L1^hKH1YdOJk^bdPghX#HJ6Q#HJL,_uqfdONPN_"dPYHJm !m JTVU]^NPHJ6`?H`*HJq~TVXZYÂ^bTVX#JÂNOHJÂT"YbW]_"U#dPJ`*HJmcJHX#NFNOHXZYÂU#TV`#YbH¨H1^Q#TVU#LNPH`nKH ^_u~TVNPdOJ`*H,C\"_«QcKH1qHU#QZYbHQ#HSNxyT"YbW]_"U#dPJ`*H.KH1^bX#Q#dKH"i

GHSU#TV`#YbH!^bT"^_"NQ#HF\"_"dPJJH,_"Xh|¦r_<NO_CWzKHUcKH Y_u^bdOTVUm "!$#&% (' *) +-, .

/ *) '103245(6879579:;#< =>#&?@AB9:DCE FG '

H #&%I#J9BABA:7K%>AB#CL#JMD"7 79B"M%N#JM!@J%MKOI"AQPRJ%DK%>"

< #JDM 'SD9T8 U 'D9:8 VW ) G&X ! 'D9:8 YX

VW )

!

H 7K%Z5[#JA:57AB4% \+7KD9BAB9:DOAB#\5D4%D]J#&D9B^YAB#\D7K%>_#J5`=I]J#J9:DD[#J78ab;#\Ac#edfg=%N#&>9: 3X (' &X h , D9Tji ' / h ,Mk 2 ' fl , 7Gi' fl , *[mon ^#e5

'i l , 'pi l ' 'i ) ' / l , 2 ) q #r]&#JAB7K%s ! tJ?D7`;# !$#&%D>9T%suAB#Z_#@v5\wABg%8M[#J7e_c%>#J5=N#JA / 9:DJD%>J!x2y%>Ce!AB9:AQPzM!$#J5 m Ac#"d-=g=%N#&>9: \!@=7K >9BCE4% 67IAB= ]J#J9:DD[#J78ae!@=%DCE=D>=|tAQPz9:%D%>9:d#&>9B*PR7.]AB7CE ! m

ll

l

k

k+1

k-1

~8> [1yDg&zRQgw: M4s&N-D*NRQDezD@MQQz 4(¡¢

Page 38: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

q ]A:7CE^>JN#JA %>Ce!AB9ZM.dABJ?$#JA:CE 9B]J#&%D9c#J ! ' h , !&h ,D9: '

/ ! h , k ! 2 ' k h , ' fl , G' fl , mon ^#e#JABJ%>! ' ! l , ' ! l ' ' ! ) ' / l , 2 ! )

e5=O78a 4a8!%>DM9By !x7KO =79:%>EAB# MCECE`d-Cb4D%>9B6768799B>=%M]K9B=|"#JAQPz4aK!%DDD9:GOAB#eCL#JMDVW )

! ' ) ! )V=W ) / l , * 2 l , *

' )! )V=W ) / l

, 2

' ) ! ) 0 / l, 2

0 l ,

CECE 0j= "! 0 / $#8!9:687CE=|[ MtIAQPzJ%>K%>uI67AB67t9 #J9B=N24\!@=7K dA:9Bd=%jAB / l , * 2 =]&#J|O0Y#J7+|7Cb=%>#&>7K%j=I9:A*]K9B=|

< #JDM 'SD9T8 GX ) ! ) / 0 l , 2 l , n # !AB7 ' i ) = ! '% ! ) 679579BD=| ;# ) ! ) ' i l l ! ' , ! y;7 A:+!%>879T ! =M 5[#&%N#J5=84%>9BMD9B687^= D9BDD7L?9:ABd9B67 ;# AQP5&ABA:5[#&!9:ABAc#J9T%>=5 ;#^!@7 !%[;5MN#J!@7K%>7`A:J%>d#J9BDC\ msn b=b 79TAQPz4aK!%DDD9: < #JDMY' =D9:8 , * ! / 0' l , 2l , @D9T'(#JAB=CErAB =78aAB9B"!79:D>#J5

< #JDM S , = < =N#&?@A:9BDC\

*PR;7.Ac#AB9**P=5&=ABAB< =>#&?@AB9:DCE S< #JDD /,

YCE;AB"4aKD%*)CECE=|jD9BCe!AB9+(g"579:;#\>7K>"7Y=%>9:YO%>=Ac#&>9:I*P=5&=ABAB&!$#&%j4aCe!AB ) 4 ! ) 5[#&%N#J5=8=%>9BM|jAQPR#JJ%D>r=jAQPz D%D7K](67"A:(%>#,#.=uAc#ABd77K%jAQPR#JJ%D>Z]&#&%>9B 5=CECE [) 'pi l ' * < #JDD - ! ) S< #JMD , /,

rC.)CE&AB#`]89:>=DDZZ>#Jd!7AB !$#&%uA:Z50/"7K%j#J7 9:]#J7 rAP #JJ%D>.=N#JJK21 ) A:ABO=M 9:g=!@#J>YOAc#eCE#JDD(OAQPzJ%>d#J9BMCE m3 "%8M7A:N#& #!%>9:J%>9*D%[;jD7K%D!%>#JDg79:(AQPz4aK!%>=DD9BAc#LCL#JDD`>J>#JAB`>#Jd. 4!Ac#J5o6879f9T4)=D%>Ac# C.)C\.;#>7uABj9:][#J78a."dfg=%N#&>9: 35=MN#J> '=D9:8 eG&X 1 'M9:8 + l X 1 |

D9T51 '5N#J|D .!$#&%D>9B5=7AB9B4%1 ) < #JDD )

Page 39: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

!"#

$ %KD7ATN#& =5J%>b!A:7 =D#J|!@7K&% )=D%DF554%> AB %# &CE 5[#&%>9B#J687 m q #]K9T>DMG7 >#Jd #JeAQP #JJ%M>GPz4aK!%D9BCE _ 5=>9: +AB# _c%8675^5[#&%>9B#J687J 1 ) '' ! ) k ')( '+*-,/.102 ! ) $M9:

* ,/.102;< #JDD l , /, C?9:g ;#Ac#AB9**P=5&=ABAB"D7K% AB#eA:df=]K9TK

q d-=]89:8 < #JDD , /, +^ =79:Z67OAB"50/(7K%r">7 A:IJ%Dd#J9BDCE=u]89:]&#J|>u!%>879T 7^C`?%>"5MN#JOAPRJ%>K%D"e0 m43 CE9BA:AB9c#&%Dur?$#&D>=CE> m

5-7KD 5=-A:9B*P5&A:ABtD| ?9B">7#JDD #&!!%>5& =3CL#J9BA:AByD ]t=%>9+(g=4a8! =%>9BC\|>#JABCE=|j#[]5O7(?@"!%859BM9B m678#9 7 ;:rMQ=<&MN z 43s* R M zM3Mfz 4Rw|D?>3MRA@CB : QDFEHGIKJL&M?NDOz 4z 4z=¢

PRQTSVUXWY/WTZ[]\V^`_[bac Z[b[ [dfeg\h_ SVUXWjikQml \ in[poq[ [bdfer\s_ SVUXWtl [p_ Q a Z[< =N#&?xAB9BMCE u kwv 'yx1z4 3 x m 3| #*#^#JJ%DD u k" 'yx1z~u 3 x m u 9:DDD(7+>#Jd / #JJ%D>2 x1z x m xx AB7CEZ>JN#JA*">#Jd 0 m 0 m xx %K687=5O5[#&%D9c#J687 (0 kwv ' x1z4 3 x1z~ 3 D9TKO"5[#&!9BA:Ac#J9:%D (0 k 0O' x1z~x u x1zx 3q df=]K9TK 0 kwv 'yx1z4 3 x m 3

Page 40: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

$

Page 41: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

!"#

!#"$% '&)(# +* #%,-.#" /10

2-35476 "8%,9 :;! * 0 < =>.#%?@>01 = * 6 "8%9 :' * 0 <

A,BCA,BEDGFIHKJMLONQPSR8T?U+VXWZYIN\[][]N.P

^_`^X_`^_bacedgfihjfkcelQmnceo)pgqrhtsusOhvhtsKwxdkhjyhtlz|fg.~edMhn 5MN#&>r4a8! =%>9:CEN#JABC\|67rAc#`_ J%>5 4a=%D5xr!$#&%j7r5&#&%>dr!@5=D7ABA: D7K% 7"5&#&%>d"!x5=>7A:AB k 9BMN#J>" #eA:u!%DJ!%>9=8ID79T]J#J> 9c2 A:AB(g5=%> ) TI5=CECE0 k g

9:9 2pA:AB(Mu!%>J!@J%M>9BA:ABO#J7.!%>79:jI5&#&%>d gg 9:9B9 2 A:ABL\#&MD%N#J5=>9T] / %84!7ABD9T]2OD9 kg x / kg x2O=5A:9B [#J9T%> ;# AB#+9BM>#J5D%>"ABu5&#&%>d m

q

q’

r

charge ‘‘test’’

r

uF

q q’

~8> w =3z =gOzD3tM MfNQ Q.B?>34M3t>gz43 ¢

¡ ' k v X£¢3) Q.¤ z / m 032

Page 42: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

$ q # 5&#&%>d AB54D%>9B67 =PR4a8!%>9BCE 57ABC`? / 2 4p # A: =687#&>9:p#J78a9BC\D9B ' lX ' / 5&#&%>d[2

¢) ' lX lX' l , l

=jAc#]J#JA:7K%I"Ac#5MN#J>O=MI =O!$#&%0

v X£¢ ) 'y1zB0 x8dCE lM lM z^_`^X_Q_ sOhgd qrh c whgsKwxqrhm mnh y lQs ! w#"hto)h yXh yhtlz ft.~ed Xh$ 9:"=78a5&#&%Dd 4 g m q r!$#&%N#JC+;4D%> !x=%D>9:|D(!x7K%r4aK!%>9:CE=%rA:r687#J>9:8=! & #KD9:687 / |IAQP=%>d9:2M| ZAB#e9:MN#J5"|M%>OA:j5&#&%>d= = v X¢ ) D9T%K¡ ''& / v X£¢ ))( ( ( 2 (

' / v X£¢ ) 2* ,+ .- ( !/z CECE % '0 lX +J?>9:

% ¡ o' v X£¢ ) & / k 2z / m 2

%8D7A:>#& t5=J%D%>5=!79:D687uAQPz4aK!%DDD9:e4a#J5=>Dug79:tuAQPRaK!%>MD9BejAB#r_ J%D5 7ABC`?v ¡ ' %K¡ e Q.¤( D9: k

v X£¢ ) ' %K¡ e (

1 % ¡ x' kgv X¢ )

1 e (

%K¡ ' k v X£¢ ) 32 % ) z

q # 5MN#J>.ML#&%M?9:D%N#J9T%> mtn 7K>9BA:9BD Ac#5|]=|>9: *PR7p==%>d9B !@J>=|>9:ABA:G|7ABA:ABJ%DD687(Ac#9BMN#J5=OD%>"ABu5&#&%>d I9:(9BJ$D9: %s) ' xe4)46587:9%K¡ ' k

v X£¢3) z / m u2q PR4a8!%>DM9B ¡ ' <;>= ?A@B? ; ¤ Q.¤ *PR# %>9B C #KK=%>9:78a mDC ABA: 57A:

AQPz4aK!%DDD9: 7SD%N#[]J#J9:A^=ACE=|N#J9T%> Ac#F_ J%>5= 57ABC`?9: !@7K%G7 g=!Ac#J5=CEe Q.¤ E!F' b¡ HGye Q ¤ ' ¡ 3e

6879uMbd#JAB=CE\ ^#J7FD9BdG!%[;e!$#&%LAB#]&#&%>9c#&D9BF*P=%>d9:.!xJ>>9BA:ABEF

'+ %K¡ D9: % ¡@' 2 ¡ 3e / m v 2 (

*PR;7.AQPz4aK!%>=DD9BG5&4%>5&g mq P4%>d9B !@J>=|>9:ABA:LM!@M9:>9T]Lg5=%>9:D>#J>.4P #J|7AB ;#^AQPR9:(9 D9gA:5&#&%DdD C.)CELD9:d / ABA:`D %>=!@7MD24A:AB M d#&>9T]L=5=%>9:D>#J>.#JA: 5#J5D%N#J9T%> / #&DD%N#J5=D9B$2 m4I5J7:9,K Z gz>gMML ON #P1 QN [¢

Page 43: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

!"# ^_`^X_ _ .~ dXh w hw+lQsuqxw h '10 y h +suqxwxqrces yel QcZwhtsKw qrhm hmnhif w dgcZw ~ wxqglKhh w-y l ftQ~eo hmnhif w dqtl#h

n 5[#&%>#J5=8=%>9:DEAB#.5&#&%>d D7A:\!$#&%YAPRx="687*PR=ABAB\#J7K%N#J9:"D7K%O7E5&#&%>d\>Y79:8g '10 rmon +g (9: #JABJ%>uAB Shl e Z[poq[ W a YQ [ / 7p=AB5=M%>MN#&>9:6872 ¡ , '

v X£¢3) Q ¤ ( ¡ ' z / m43 2

PRMA: 5&#JC\! A:5=D%>9:687 57A:C?9: 6879gJ?g9T^;#AP67#&>9B #J78a 9:CED9: ' $lX l , mEn (9: SC.)CE ABp!xJ>>9B=A A:5=D%>N#&>9B67 ;# !$#&%M>9:%FSAQP=%>d9:!@JD|D9BA:AB(OAc#5&#&%>d">=M U %K¡ , '

v X£¢ ) ( %K¡ ' U z / m 2

q "!@JD|D9BAJ?g9T;#AQP=687#&>9:G#J78a.9BC\D9B U '0 lX l , ' mn G#&!!xABA:Z]A: / 2wAQPR79T8ZZ!@J>=|>9:AQ5A:ABr7 5&#JCe! A:5=D%D9B687Z=M5rAB ]A:

!$#&%C+;=M%> / m C l , 2 m AxM 7K>9:AB ZJD=%687 U =M 7^=%>d9:Z= M7r_ J%>5 mq #Z%DAc#&>9:b¡x' <;>= ?A@B? ; ¤ Q ¤ DgM%N#J79:f!$#&%s74a8!%>DM9Be#J#JABd7 D%>g!xJ>>9BA=j5&#JC\! 465 :9

' / 2 QQ¤ ' U e Q.¤ z / m 2n G%>=D%D7K]"?9B=GAc#%>AB#&>9B

e

! v X£¢ ) #" '

v X£¢ ) z

q # 5=|]>9: D7K% AQP=%>d9: !@J>=|>9:ABA: ;# AQPR9:(9 D d- =%>#JAB9BM #J7 !xJ>>9BAA:5=D%>N#&>9B67>s5A:79% 59j=P #J|7ABb;# APR9:(9jD7e%KD=%M]G687*Pz9BA*P #F#J9:!$#J\G5&#&%Dd;#eAPR9:(9 m^_`^X_%$K_'&?q sOhvyh>ft.~eo h w h(glQq c whgsKwxqrhtmxmnht

q GA:9Bd 5&#JC\!= AB 6879T!@J>=|>9:ABA: DG.57K%D?xG= .D7K%>_#J5=G6879!@4%>CE=DD|YE%>=!%8M|D=%\AB#G>J!@dJ%>#&! &9BE7 5&#JC\! =7 !@JD|D9BAAB54D%>MN#&D9B687=*PR7(9BD%>9:?7KD9BG(5&#&%>d m $ (AB9:d((5&#JC\!.Mj7O57K%D?x"J%D9B8r>A:ABr687*Pz5&#J687\!x9B[yAB\5&#JC\! =AB5=M%>9B67\AB79wMON#Jd mM$ J%D9BN#&>9: MYgE!$#&%YA:D\7 5&#JC\! m q \5&#&%Dde!xD9:>9T]\54%KLe5&#JCe!\9:]4%>d> / A:\A:9BdeDJ%>9:|8 "Ac#e5&#&%>d(]=%>jAQPRaK8=%D9B7K%2#JABJ%Dj67OAB=IAB9:du5|]4%>d ]=%>jABj5&#&%Dd d#&>9T] m q AB9:d 5&#JC\! !%>=|\#J9BDD#J5.4CE7K%>D9:D7K%5&#&%>d=D9T;#AQPR9:(9 m$ 687>9B 6879 # =b56875= 9BCe!@J%DN#J> #JbAc# D79:> Mb5A:AB 7 C`?%>C\|A:9Bdp15&#JC\! m.n !@7K =]K9:CECE=| DM9B=% 7 C?%D#&%D?9TD%N#J9:%D ZAB9:dgZ5&#JC\!8!79:D687*Pz 5&#J67 !@9:|ZAPRM!$#J5=Z9BA!$#JDDr7ZAB9:d

4I5) :9K \M@ RzrQIQMRN =L 4Q)*[ R +Y43M3Z+3eM &NQQRz:MY: 3QDQ =-,,B P. J 70/21 : J 70/ Du3\ * NQD3*[*D@MQ4zR"R`@MQzo=¢54 = Q ==: DQz 4 3rM * NQDK 4 zRRyRf@&<& =g*z-36 QDQzMRz#:4 M7 7 3zQ@R-NN zQz 4eD DgD z@ 3398T 43 =g&zzM3QsNN zOzMsz "@&z4>gD-FO&QQ4Q+;:gLP J 70/ L<x¢=oO3DzMDfDg& =Y OQzML L ?>(@AB@)CBPEDGFDIH >JKDFDIL MANJODFDIP QC P J 70/ L'<ic H >3J. L QANJ P MC ¢M=x>@M R*[3MS:[ 4IY L @UTV@)W P DFDYX J DFDIZ GT9J DFD[ W P.J 70/ L\<]c X JY Z T]JY [ Qz^T8GW ¢V_zM D[IM Dy = & =4Dy3s Dy MZ@M3RD¢

Page 44: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

$ 5&#JC\!w9BA # # 5^7G9B(9:8+9B C`?%N#&?A: m $ 7K!!xD 687.AQPR =59B+*Pz%>=!%8D>=% m q 7K%9:%>=5=>9B 4 D^7 9B AP #JABA:7K%> d- 4%N#JAB AB#>J!xABd9BI7.5&#JC\! m q 7K%uD9T8r =d#JABCE=| APR9:|>=D9:8Z7 5&#JC\! m D9B 4%>AB5[#J(*PR7E5&#&%>d79B67 m C N#JO e7\D7K%D_#J5bACEN#J9:%D67AB5=687 s!$#&%Z5C`?9:^`AB9:d Y5&#JC\! % A:ABYD%>#]=%D8YD9 AQPz #\g59:g*Pz+%>=!%8D>=%#J7.DJN#JA

q

−qq

E~8> Rz3OD zz43Mj(K>34 \| r?>NQr3 *[rMr3M\?>NQD 3J =[MM¢

dS

dS

dS

~8> _(M3 =gO3Q>gM@DR=DsK>34 IQ D4MQQsQ)8TOD >gDQ4Q*[Dz 4 *[=¢ x =$MRD *[3 D4M DzQ)8T*3Q `QDM@D zQM4z¢q # 67#J|D9:8^5&=%>5& M 4a#J5=>CE=| A:C`?%>^ A:9Bd 5&#JC\! 6879 D ;#AQPz9B8=%>9:7K% 7 5 ) 9BDD7 = =P #&!!7#|#J.M7K% B4I5 9g7 D7K% Ac# D7K%>_#J5^!%>=8!@4%D!@9:57Ac#J9T%>CE=| ;#.AP #a`7 5 )J m =D>D7K%>_#J5= =N#J ;# AB# 9:MN#J5$L\AB#5&#&%>dJA:ZC?%D+ rAB9:dgD%N#[]=%>>#J b=MD9BCe!ABCE=| A:ZC`?%> >JN#JA 67

C7A:>9T!AB9:YABO%>#&!!@J%D kwv X `AB#LD7K%>_#J5`!%>=8=^;#EAB#LD7K%>_#J5`>JN#JA:Y`Ac#LM! &*;4%> "%N#*# m $ "D7K%>_#J5Y=M J%>9:KJoAB(C?%DO5&=%>5& MI5C\!8r!@D9T>9:]=CEID9AB= AB9Bd= Z5&#JCe! M%N#]4%>D#J ABZD=uZAPRJ%>9:N#&>9BLZAB#YD7K%>_#J5r5C\CEID7K%uAB#(d7K%>J$ d#&>9T]CEu#JIA:"5[#Jj5D%N#J9:%D mon ^#5O9:59

+' v X ( / m 2

6879e%> !$#&%b9:|8dJ%N#&>9:"!$# % ' / AB #8C?xAB&!$# D9Bd9 ( 67 AQPR9:|8dJ%N#JABM 4>7 ;# Ac# D7K%>_#J5=_ 4%>Cb = 7^D7K%>_#J5_ =%>Cb^ML>7'7K%DLJ%>9B8^]=%DAQPz4aK8=%>9B=7K%2 m q C`?%> k ( ]J#&%>9: #]=5 AB#^9BMN#J5= =p0 k k`5CECEEA:L5&#JC\!57A:C?9: 4I5*):9 mn G!@=7KZ#J9BM9Z=5=%>9:%D

' ¢ ) z

4I5 9$+ =MDQ)8T4sD DsJQJM3Rz4QD Mg zQ)8T4=¢4I5*):9 K gNJMR-34zy =zRZM >gM zQ3g =R *[34Qz-,/.10X 5 ¢32 = z3M zy3$Rsw>M = TQN34 5YM 3 gM M 3RBrDgf QQ\*[szMy=DS:&4 M*3N*[3 zwQ3 gD3Q =:z)*[ DzzwDy@&<&s&N-3 N3J 4-wQ)8TD ¢

Page 45: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

!"# H 7K%`*Pz9BC\!xJ%D>687A:AB\M7K%>_#J5L_ =%>Cb |D7K%N#J|YAc#G5&#&%>dJ #GABeC.)CE%8D7ATN#&[! # '" y %>=]&#J5&LD9wAc#.5&#&%>d *PzMO!$#J">7K%8E!$#&%OAc#.M7K%>_#J5 #J7K%N#! # ^'yx`5[#&%9:A # #`#J7KN#JrAB9:d 6879o|M%>I#J / 5C\!8= gd#&>9T]CE2t67OA:9Bdu6879GDJ%D> / 5C\!8=u!xD9:D9:]CE=|2 m

q

~8> 2)8T 8M *[3MR 40*[3MQ 43Q4yR?>34sJ 4 Dzz¢n (9: &#&?9:>7=ABAB=CE AB Q d 7 5&#JC\! A:5=D%>9:6871;#SD%N#[]=%> 7 D7K%D_#J5ACEN#J9:%D(!$#&%

' Gy ^' z / m 2$ +9:|8=dJ%N#JABL;#D%>#]=%Dj7"D7K%>_#J5Y_ 4%>Cb" # / (2s' # Gy ^' ¢3) # v X '

¢) # z / m 0 x2$ A:+687(Ac#D7K%>_#J5 5=|>9: 7G*$+# # / (2s' ¢ ) D9

# / (2s'yx D9 k z PRMj7G%8=D7A:N#&uD%[;=I9BCe!@J%DN#J6879D4%N#\7K>9:AB9B(!$#&%jAc#D79:> mq D7K%>_#J5=`6879T!@J>>9:ABA:fD>A:ABf67*PRYD7Kf!@9:|A: !@JD|D9BAwAB54D%>MN#&D9B687#^C.)CEe]J#JA:7K% mMC ABAB=`D|!x=%D!@=9B57AB#J9:%>#J78a A:9Bd 5&#JC\! m #J`ABL5#J*Pz75&#&%>dO!x5=>7A:ABY79:687JoAB 6879T!@J>>9:ABA:IJ?g9:DDE;#\AP67#&>9B kwv X£¢ ) Y' 5M z=j5OM|IIM! &*;4%> 5=|D%8 D7K%IAc#`!@D9T>9B.OAB#e5&#&%>d mA,B BP WN NQP+N VMFIHKJMLONQPSR8T?U+VXWZYIN\[][]N.P

^_ _`^_.lQhgd QcZgqxw qrces yh c whgsKwxqrhtm>h w$yht>ft.~ o un 5=D9B*;=%D7 #8M[;C\ ' ! W , #""#" %$ ^5&#&%>d=E!@5=>7=ABAB= !%8M57687=AIF!AB#J5+7+5&#&%>d+>=M 7 !x9B'& m q E_ J%>5=L4a4%>5o\D7K% D#J9:D9:].4aK!%>9:CE(5OAc#_ J%>5(>JN#JA: / MCECE ]5=DJ%>9BA:AB2 Pz4a=%Jv5[#J|jD7K%

( ¡ ' *)]¡ 2 5 ¡ 2 z z z 2 ,+Q¡ '$V W , .- ¡

'$V W , k

v X¢ ) 0/ Q %/'

$V W ,

v X£¢ ) 0/ Q 0/'

$V W , +1-f' (

Page 46: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

$ P P & ! "# & $&%' " ( $ )$ #" ] " #

(+* $V W, +.- *

$V W(,

v X£¢.- 0/ Q 0/ z / m100.2

q1

q1

r

r

r

q’

q

q

2

M

E

1,M

N,M

2,M EqN

~8>43 2+M>g65G87S?>NQD*J 4 DzzD !9 ¢ .) : % d ) " 1 & d $ ; < " $ # #" ] 4I5>= 9m q % d ? $ $ & d $ $ "" @ $ #A$ B$% & "# $

% ( ¡ * % *)]¡ 2 % 5 ¡ 2 z z z 2 % ,+Q¡ * $V W(, % .- ¡

*$V W(, nk

v X£¢.- 0/*

$V W(,

v X£¢.- 0/*

$V W(,DC .- * C (

%E % F G " ! !1 & $%H' " ( $ )$ #" $ #

C ( *$V W(, C 1- *

$V W(,

v X£¢I- 0/ z / m10 2

^_ _Q_ Zo hwxdqrh>hw q`sKJM~edqr~ sOfkhtq L & & ! "# M N G ! ' $!$ $O " $ $ #A P " ! $ A!1 $< $ " A " $ ! < $K$ #A P " $ $ $K$P + $ $!$ ] $ Q 1 $ $ $ $ m q $ $ $F$! R S $ $ ! " ' A! $ T & d $ U % a $ & % & % VG " $ "" W $ $ m $X " $ $ # ! " $! Y! $ A"1 $Z) A [ X # " & ! !1 \ $]] " ]' $ ^ $Id A $_ & #A$ # $ m$ % 1 a $ ` $ # ! " % $ ! ! ' A" a & d $N( a ]:A AG R : F & ! !1 R $ $ m $ % # $%bJd % ca $ # ! " : + &V$ A X %ba $ G ! ( X %a # %> ) m $ $ + $

4I5>= 9d 4zfQM z 4::M3Q4z | zQ =rQ zg| 3r+M>gI:B*[g: =(@K<J3zQjR3- N : D R gw3MIM3Q4zM RMQ4 z 4ZD?>NQDy 4 z4D¢

Page 47: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

!"# P & d $ "1< $ $ " $ aZ$!+ $ % ! m q %b] 1 " $K d $ $+ ! < $ A %ba # ! : O &W $ ) ! ( 8 %a : $ < % A G ! : a & $ $ & m3 + ^ 1 # Z< %b ! ! U & $ L# A ($4) P _ $ $ 1 % m # $ : $ < % $ ! " ' A" ? & d $ $ + ] " ( + " ! $ " % ] ! ]' / ! $ " " ( 1 Ea " " A A % a 2 : + & $ A A! d A & #A$ # Z $ @ [ a ! ]] " ]' m

^_ _ _ sOhgd qrh htmnhkfwxdgcZtw~ w qtl#h y l s ! w#"hto)hvyhjftQ~edXht Qc sOf wxl#hm mnht$ a & d $ $! $ , . $ $ ], m q % d $!$" # G A ]G ! O 8 & d , % ( ) a , : $ ] $ ] : $ 1 ]: $ % 1 % # d $K & : + $ S$ ]: & $ [ & ( K @ G a : d G " 1 C ,&/ a 2 4I5:9 m q ' $ #A ! "# :

% , * C ,&/ a 2 * , C / a , 2 * 0 / C ,&/ a 2 2 , C / a , 2!2 (

C / a 2 $ ^ G ! ( S & d ) $ P ] & d m A $ \' L & d $ $ $ : Q A % ( * V

2% * 0

V V

W v X¢.- z / m10 u 2

! < !# % $ ($ a $ ] ]:I % $ % % % 1 ]] " ($ G P" # \' L & d $ m^_ _%$K_'&,h>yeq cZmnh htmnhkfwxdgcew~ w qtl#hn $ A %]'G a & d $ , $ $ m n & &

" $ R ) " F Q & < % # $ G $ $ ! ( N ]) ! %a $ & d $ 465 9 m

q

ϕ2

1

M

r

r

r1

2

~8> 2+M>gws3M K>3NQD*J 4 DRDQ! fQ#"¢4I5:9 K j3QMY4wD` g3Qu:M3Q4zjR <J3zI3u3DN =DwK>3NQDsJ =3Q3MRD¢xMQEDMQ4zR <&YJDMQ^N4z@OM 3QM zez z%$&('| 3O3RQ =O& =GFO&Q z:4 =z& R*[3" =Q)8TMR*[3 | QMz 4EQRz(RR zZ&N)$B:$ *[3* =33 * 5+-,/.021 &43.¢- M 8D>gDg3Q O&T>g)5&zQ3Qzt3ZR8zCM3)*[ 4766tD w:Dz4¢4I5:9 _w: DO(Q 4R 3 gMz 4 :R]8T3tD[44zDNTZMNW+Mwjz 3 & = M*MQwJ 4RsDO =3@MDsw>@MQ *[D?BT z4RuDszM?>3 4RzQ4z 4+3Q zRDYDsD[?>NQD ¢/^+=4@K> 4RQ|3 N CV:3: =NTtQM|M: R3MRzR =(sR 3zQMQz 4ZwQ3J Qt CIB=8 M>34 oT 34z WOQ|QyRsQ N =j4Q 43o Cw3&3R$3j> >jJQJM3Rz4Q,B34z- 8 ¢+ *[3szzQQ O3Qz 4r3s?>34MM gRRNN RQs 4QQz 4(Q 43y C0:3RDR[ zzw3*D=<My: N >rMyzMy 33M3Qy>G+QR*[3My = R3@MJM34DNW@¢

Page 48: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

$ q ) " Z & $ _ " $_( ! $ud P "1< $ $ & d $

C *)r 5 * &K/ , ( ( ( ( (Hv X£¢.- 2 zC A"#1 $" S $ $ $ X $ ] $S( P $X/ * 0 M $Md $S$! $"$ $ 2 ?' ! S _

C *)r 5 * ,v X£¢.- &K/ k , ( k ( 2 z / m10 v 2

% $ D [ a $!$ a 8 # ! $y]] " ]' $ $!$ $ mn R A _ # _ ^ a $ ^ $ d ] ! ( O< Y_ _ " 1 Z % $P$ $ $ ! & Z A"#1 $! , * / $ 2 k 2 2 / $ 2 * 0 $ 2

v * / $ 2 k 2 2 / $ 2 * 0 2 $ 2

v $! ?$!+ ,Mk ,x0/ k 0/

C *)r 5 / ( 2 * ,v X£¢ -r 0 0 ¤ $ 2 5 ¤ 5 2 , 0 0 2 ¤ $ 2 5 ¤ 5

$ ! & $ $ $ c _ ! & mn ) A ! 6 _ &W & ! "# m + N $ d " _ % $!$ $OM % ) "# : $@ 1 $N $ [ S ) & ! $ "1< mn ?( " ) & ! $ "1< $ $ " $_$ ]] $@$P _ $ 2 * , / & $ K , * * : $ < + ] " # " %bd $ & d G$ " ] 2 :# 2 ! / ] [a + " d $ 2m

r

r r

O- +

+

-

θ

d

M

θu u r

~8>! _z =EMzMQ = N R*[34¢ + =DQM3f X Dsz=MQM3f3zQ4QuD4MN 33j3=gD N =R <&3D zZIz" =3@ g Z Mt3I>gM@N 3tgDQQz 4rR <J3zDQR 4gtz =3@MNT3¢ + ]G ! $ & d $ $ $ : _ _ " 1 & & \ $

C ; "1/ ( 2 * v X£¢.- &K/ k ( 2

_ $ )$" $ &W $ ! .) $! $ e_ ; " - / ( 2 * ; " G Q - * v X£¢ - - / k ( 2 ( * ( 1z

Page 49: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

!"# $ %] a ! d $ &: k $ M < !# "# :) < % ! N ] & # M aA $!$ F' ` # $;$ W < _ X a m n d # d $ $ $ / k 2 ]] a a @1 ]

C ; " / ( 2 v X£¢.-

! 0 $ " l, 2 ! 0 2 $ " l

, C A"1# $" _ [ ] S# / 0 2 2 * 0 2 4.7 0 9 : 1 ] ! 0 $ " l

, 0 g $

( C ; " / ( 2

v X£¢ - ! 0 2 g $ " 2 ! 0

g $ "* $

v X¢.- (/ m1032

< $ "_ _ & & ] & &K/ k ( 2 * ¤ $ m q ) " Od $ ) P $ "# ) # $ ] X< G " \' / 0 k k 1 0 k 2m % $ ) $! " ( !" 1 $ a & d $W)$ $ m 1 $ %bd ^ $ ! ! ' A" Y & d $^ G$P$ ($ W$ #A ! " $P & !1 m q < " * e * Q $ ] G # mq ` $ )$" $ & P "1< R $ 1 $ [ 1 $ ) " / # %H ! + d & _ $ G " [ # $ A $"]] " ]' $ 24myn d 1 $ % a $!$ C ( / 2 * ( / 2

" ] " 1 C ( / ( ( 2 * 3 ( / ( ( 2 a / m10 2

a $ T < < $ & $ a * Q ¤ 2 Q $F) 1 $ : ( * ( ¤ / ( 2 Q ¤ 2 ( / ( 2 Q mn

C ( / ( 2 * ( ¤ / ( 2 2 ( / ( 2 1z ! " $ ]] ]' M A ) m C R( !! # $ %F$ * $ z * x : $U$ * $ z * x : `' " a aA $!$ $ $>4.7 ) 9

( ¤ / ( 2 * C ( ( ( / ( 2 * 0 C ( ( / m10 24.7 0 9

αε

ε

1

1

+ 8 4 = L ?> P > eJM3?QQ@M4D 43* 8T4RzDgDs4 =zQzN4j>"!P$#4¢54 4 4 > P%# J'& : 4e> )*[3'*[3I: MQ 4R>gMgDg =3@I&N&u 3z &z ruzZ&DQZM >(! P)#I:$ D7 7 3zrR`@MQzxML *# P,+]:$ -# J.&` 0/ #5J1+2&M¢xMQf3QMQz 4 D*NROzsJ 433+`J 4QzQR8 4 @M4QR8¢0=xRDy| yR3 3MMz\*[354 &64[MJ z¢4.7 ) 9,K o <& *[ DzzM =y QDQD3 J 4R 3st3 gMz 4DT¢

Page 50: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

( $ S

; " ¤ / ( 2 * $ v X£¢ -r ( ; " / ( 2 * $

v X£¢ - z / m10 2

q $ G$! $ &R$! d # $ ] $!$! $ < $ $ \' mHC 1 $N$! ! & $ G ] $ $ mq %] 1 " $c & #A$ 1 $ $ aA $!$ $ G $ $ 1 $+ $ m $ $ P " "A # : a "A $ $ 1 $a( Z 1 $! & 1< ] ( a $! $!$ 1 ]' $ ) m q ) $ ( Y +_ ! & d ! # E? $!$ #A P " $ # $P / [ ( % P $@$ A @ % 1 $ & ! )$ #" _ a $@$ A S 1 $ & ! d ! _ 2 4I7:5J9 m

3 .#%O@ 01 * !!< 0 = * 6 "8%,9

BCA,BEDjT R8T,JZW N N\UOWePSHKP RIW TW YIN.Pn $ $ ! " ' A! Z & d $ < mon Q & d - % a $ V$P( ! ! $ "# $ ! " ' A" / ( a $ +,# N P a & d $6 *# #< 1 $ ! " ' A" 2m d $ ! - : $ < $ [ 1 $ $ P " ' A" c$! $"$ ' A : E P ) ! A X' `) A @ ) " _ a &

C ( v X£¢.- ( (

v X£¢I- Q ¤ ( ! -

ur

r

Ωr0

~8>R @ =gJ QQDgD x4+3 3Q R*[3M*jJ 4DQzDJ*3 ?>4g Mo333RQQ O3Qz 4"?>3N*[Dz 4 *[u 4Q43 3R =¢ A $ $!$ $ # $ : ` A " A $

C ( / ( ( 2 * v X£¢.- & ( / -k ( ( 2 ( / m10 2

4.7:5 9 2[-T =L4DEN4z3ITDM=O 3EQM M <J:$ = 4 NQ*[| `:M3Q4z(J 4DQzDzzO 3z = P . * 5+-,/. 0 B R3 4 *[3)& '*3 4z- =Q 3 = O z 4r3M3RQ=bB =3\*[|@M ggD3 *[-z 3R gDt =Qf3R O:MzQ =uDQ-[3N4MgMzDQ =3 *[D :[| 4Qz4R = MzMQ N=@MQ *[@sR 8 4 gNJ # @s QQ *[s:DMQ4zs 4Q4w3MMQ3r R3 R3RQ43 !g *[zR O3QI:

! 4 4"! . "

435$# ! " 0 P 'V@ 4z% ! Pv 435$#6! 4 4 N " '&)( !+* -, ¢ + DM=I MQNzD% ! QQQtR >@Dz 4"wRug = DM3z4¢

Page 51: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

!"# ( - / ( ( 2 * ( G Q - *

v X£¢I- ( - / - k ( ( 2 z / m "x 2

q $`_ " $ & ( ( [ ' +_ $ ! ! ' A" m C 1 $ ] $ 0 $ m $ F $ P " ' A" $ $ #A P " $P & !1 ( a :\ $b_ " $ ($ $@d $ m $ F & d $ 1 ]: + $ % # # ' $ & d $ $/ $ ! " ' A" d '( A! 2 : $!$" & $ 1 $ ] / 0 k RG A X G ! 0 k ) A @ Z & 2 : M % $ @ L $NG A @ ) mn P! " ) ! G ! & ! $ "1< % $ ` _ " " N A ) / $" _' $ ] d $ A N & d G " 1 ( a 2mq % d $ ! " ' A" RG A $"U( ! $ $P$" # e_

% ( * $

v X£¢I- - T $ X $ L "1< $!$ $ : < [ L_ $ W _ & d ! "# L $ N ( !" $ $ #A$ m B BGFN.TOJN N +N PeYIR8N.J R8TOP W ]T?U PeV£H,[xH xJMN R8T?YIJ[]N R8TWeN.U?W ]N\[q " T & d $ #$ $ $ ! ! ' A" $ & d $G " 1 $K d " ] $N/ ! $ 2 G$ " ] $;/ $ 2m q $ %\$ & 1 d A K G ! ]] D $ & d $ ] 1 $ : Z AD W D N$ ! " !A $ # ( $ O " N & d $ m $ ; & d # / 2

`G & $ * a `G " # 4.7 7:9 C / a 2 *

/ 2v X£¢.- *

/ 2v X£¢.- a

z

Ω

Rr’

r

O

M

Rqd ( )

r0

~8>$ _zQQ O3Qz 4Yg?>NQD FO&QQ4QN5f¢ + 4Qz4RgD <3@MwD(rJ 4R*[Dz 4 *[KBzMKw: R Dx 5 ;::D DgD$3y= 4RgIuM*M M3RxT z4Rf =QzD 33w?>NQk I ¢ + sJ 4R-| OQNN z 4rDM*MwMz-T 4Qz4R wMyR3R DQ`i @ DQzQ 4 . 14 ¢

q & $ G$ " ) " ]] A G A ` $ ! " ' A" ! " ' ! # 4I7) :9 : $ $ & d $L$! Z ( P" $ " ) $ & 4.7 7:9 K 4 43Q zMI 4=M =3jN4DuD Q:MO( += 437c4DQD f ( 4Qz4RNOzQQ4QbB ==MK> 4RQ 3R3RQ =O& =(sK>3NQ: 4z DR g3M3ZMN Q O&zz4 =Q : Q|QJ 4Ry 43Q rQ 434R ?>34(M D M z=¢ O&Rzw: D3>rO&3sz z O z 4a5 :z *[ tQM|M t& =zf OQNN =¢ 8Mf<x4¢=o(4 3rOJM 4R" 4rJD-zQ [3zgzI3RQ43QMRN =tK>3NQS7c& =z| OQNN z 4: P+ . "¢ - z3M N ="QK5+z4 <& *[t: 4" 4z gMQ zDJ 4RQ = D"¢ =x QN43?>3s3Y *[N =ZDR *[ , BP . J 70/21 BxD-33sDRN =DQs?>3=gZM*& 4D D|4ZJ 4R OQNN =ZMyz4 <& *[3wzsJ 4R MyQ3QM3 OztwNN M¢4.7U :9 B8T3@M8Tz *[f: QMz 4 N Rzszgz O z 4 QMT<J3z-J = *[: DQz 4Iz4Q4 4=Q=¢

Page 52: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

$ $!+ $ ( Z d $ A Z ] # \ & d ( ( L ) " $&% !#

C ( / a 2 * 1 ( / 2v X£¢.- a

z / m 0.2

$ X !1 $ " d 1 $ A $ #< $ $ ! " ' A" $ " $ L & d $ m 2 $ ! " ' A! ] # 1< $ & d $Z$! $ G$ & $ ( P" $ $ ] 1 $ m@n ( S $ ] # 1< a & d $/ 2 # / 2 * / 2

$ ] # # $ #! ( Q ]) ! % ! d 4I7 J9 mq % a $!$ d G ! _ ( P" #

C ( / a 2 * 1 ( / 2 v X¢.- a

z / m 2

$ V ] A u )$" $ m ) ] $ : * l m q % d \ $ a d P " :) # ) ! $ A a $ G$! $ % ] 1 ? $ m# 2 $ ! " ' A! $ A _ # [$ S % ( $!$ A $ ! " ' A" / ( a 2

$ Y! $L " ] \ $\ A! $ $ $ : A $ X )/ 2 ]] " ($ $ d ( ! ] $ % ( $!$ A U %H [ ( #U $ $ A _ 1< / 2 ( / 2 * / ( 2 ^ * / ( 2 ^ ([] / ( 2 * / 2

z

n !# $ L $

C ( / a 2 * 1 ( / 2 v X¢ - a

( / m "u 2

$ % ! d _ $ ' & $ : $ [ E] A G$" $ ; % d @ $ ' : 1 $ * lM m

O

R

Σ M

r’

r

d ( )q R

~8> _RQ =O& =(Q)8TMR*[3t3w?>34MyNOz z-¢4.7 9 =x 4Q3 43@D-MQzMD* 4rE P 0> Ax CV:MZ>@ R*[3My 4rE P " OR T T0W@¢

Page 53: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

!"# #1 2 $ ! " ' A! # # ($ $ ! " ' A! $ ( 1 _ : $ \ / ( a 2 ] mon (

/ 2 * / 2 ^[ * / 2 ([] / 2 * / 2

(

C ( / a 2 * 1 ( / 2 v X¢.- a

( / m v 2

O

M

R r

r’

d ( )q R

~8>g _RQ =O& =(Rz@M *[ w?>NQDNOzQQ4Q-¢$ _ % ! d R $ ' & $ : $ + ] A 0 WG$" ? + % d ? $ $ ]: * xl , m

BBIN R[]N.P

Q__`^_babq mftq`dgfgl.mn~eq`dkhjft.~ed hn $ ( # *# j - : & P : ) ! \ F & d

( !" _ $ A $" _ mwn & & [ Y ) " ) S < %a $ + ) mxn T ! _

C ,q2, / 2 *

v X£¢ - &K/ - k 2 ^ \ ) ! &K/ - k 2 0 $ G A S ! ] M % a $!$ \' ed $ m

Or’

z

dθr

r0

0

~8> _RQ =O& =(Rz@M *[ w?>NQDQ ZM z4¢q & d @ $ 6 ( !" $ A 6 1 d m A [ _ %d % ] !!A / ,# - ) Q*# & $ %H " d ! 2 ?

Page 54: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

$ * ¤ 0 ; * ; : $! 4I7*):9

C ,/2 , * X

v X¢.- / 2 - 2 , ( x m X

C , /2, / 2 *1 - C ,/2 , *

v X£¢.- / 0 2 - k 2 l , z

q $ x : &K/ - k 2 k - C ,/2 , /x 2 * 0 ¤ 0 $ $ < :&K/ - k 2 0 O % ! ] ' G ! A \' `d $

C ,q2, / ! - 2 * v X£¢ - z

-3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3z/r

0

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

V(z

)/V

(0)

~8>1 4 QM zMs&N-3 <JM M3Rz 33R8 4 e>gDy?>NQ=¢ + 3QDQ =t 43Q-z 3: 1 D D CP +#,/.0 X 0 -#(J C " N "! * & " / 1 'x-# . " P 5X 50 J oR3R*[33tJMQr> 4Q 8 4 z jT z4R:&&3R =OQw&N OJ 4R *[ @M4Qz4 TJ =z zR M =QQ`*DN4 tQ4 MtjT 3QMQz 4( =3z =gOzM 3R TJ =z zR M =4` ¢

A $ &: ` A ' S % aA $!$ & P "1< $ A @ %a ( ,/2 , * / 2 Q( / 2 * C ,/2 , *

v X¢.- / 0 2 - k 2 l z $ d X' $ 1 # ! - mn A ; % a $!$ &F A $ [ # % " < %H $!$ ) " $ ! ] $ Jd A A % ) m a $!$! G ! a 1 $ ] ! : C /x 2 * kwv X£¢ -r - : !P # ($ [ # Z & .) G :( @1 % #`+ ( Q ! ]] " ]' $ C /x 2 ( N ]) ! < ? $P$ ! ] m

Q__Q_ q Qtl#h fg.~ed hq O $ % $ O & d N $ 8 X 1 $ #1 ; 6 $ ! ! ' A" $ $ A _ 1< P _ $ m $ : $ A _ # " F & d 4.7):9,K &D 3QQ3QRzRfzuD3QwRz@M *[ P]@ N 5 ! Mri P !0T¢

Page 55: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

!"# * ; ; ¤ 50 & $ A 4.7 = 9 $ $ G %'$ " x$ A @ %b / 2 2 , : $P #

C ; &0 * - v ¢.- / 2 2 , ( x - ( x m

C ; K0 / 2 * 1 ¤ 0-

1 - C ,/2,

* v ¢.- - 1

¤ 0-

/ 2 2 ,

* v ¢ -r - / 2 - 2 ,

* v ¢.-

- / 0 2 - 2 , 0 z

r’O

θdρ

zE_! #"$&%(') $&*,+-#')")8/.10R* '32543260873.1":9;2<:'3"='3+>4?)* ')2,@[ ' 1 # + \' 0 BADC RFE P "1< $%H' " ( "/ ! >

; HG# * / 2HI ( / 2 * CKJ ML J * N ¢ - -PO 0O / 2 - 2FQ , O 0 * N ¢.- O -SR 0 / 0 2 - 2 Q , UT

Q__ _ ceo Qc dwhto;htsKw!yeq QcZm#V q`dghGyel QcZwhtsKw qrhm+ftd h h "V' d(V sOyhjyeq wVesOfkh <Vedl sOh yeq w dqrptl.wxqrces sOhtl.wxdghW $ YX[Z;\Y]^ $P E )_ $ - G ! 8 _FE ` ( P" 6 # A W \ $! & P %b $_A ! " A C $ # 1 # \FE ` A *ba (N - A W T$% $!$ QG %b : $ + ! AKC $H_A !1 ) " ` $ Y $ X' Z WFE $ G ! ( A=C % 1 X $ * $ AC $\'G $ " ! $ ! $ < $X$P E !1 $ / ) A !# Q$! A FE ` $ 2 $P dc - :ec O c O AKC $ $&% " " : W +)_ * / $ 2 2 $ A4.7 = 9,K +gf(2h') gi2H9,.1j?2hkl2h+ #"#.hmF.;?jj?2H"D.hm;2h0j?.n4)2h+3#& )i25#')")8/.10 * ')2oPqp N 5 "! 2 r4i Psoutv4)tv40T)@

Page 56: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

Z :]KZ Z Z;\ Z(]Z

!

"

$#

#!

3 _ 2kU7 :f7&%2H"#26087.F"#9 i22;@W $% $!$ G ! ` $ & G " : $S FE FE # ^ %] + " X' AKC W G " # a ( $ (

C / 2 *0N ¢.- '

O - 0! 0 O $ 2

" Q,

0N ¢ - '

O - 0! 0 2

$ " T( : % $!$ G " $ A O % ` $ ( O ^$P E A

C) / 2 ' N ¢.- - 0 ! 0' - 1

- $ * +, -,

2 0N - 1 - $ $

* +, -, "* N ¢ - 2 / ' /. 2 -N ¢ - T

C ZFE P "1< L P $P) g A)/ 2 * N ¢.- 2 / ' (N 2 -N ¢.- T

W ] 1E + + ^ $ E W : $FE ` 0 Z1&#]32 Z;\ Z4 : $! ! %HF' " $P E L / 65 `A a ^ ] $+ ! W + L ?$ & ^ $P E A Z ` : Z % 1 $ $P 2 A

Page 57: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

!"#

$%

&'

(

)+*

),

/.-=.Ff3f":* 08732hkU2+ <432<4)2h'0/>4)2kU7 :f7&%2"#2H@C ) " 21 ) ( N U$ & ^ $P E $ [ # : 1 $ ! " $ $ ` $W ` ! " ' : $ $ # $_ & $ :

C Q / 2 * N ¢ - 2 / ' /. 2 -N ¢ - ( $P ! ) " $ ) :

C / 2 * C ) / 2 2 C Q / 2 * / ' (N 2 -N ¢ - ( G # < * - AKC ZFE ! "1< v A $

/ 2 * O N ¢.- T436573 98:<;>= : : : ?A@!BC:D=EBC;>? GF ;IH JI:LK F ;= :LMNMN: BC;@!= MO: K 8!P B:LMO:LK F = @Q:W $P LR1 < G A ; ) " : + $ ! $[+$P+ $ " $ ! # $ ATS WFE ` # / 2 U ) & $ * U FE

U/ U 2 * / 2N ¢.- U I ¤( ? A S # / $P A ;^ '$ h " 2 A $% & "# $! $

I ¤ * U *U U

T

Page 58: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

Z :]KZ Z Z;\ Z(]ZC E $ G$ #" $ 1E W$ ! "# $ $>4.7:9

( / U 2 * 1 ( / 2N ¢.- U U T / O A O 2

W ] $ # P A $P$ ! $ _ $ $ ! ! ' A" $ " $ FE ` $ $ ! " ' A" # 1< ( / U 2 * 1 ( )/ 2 N ¢.- U

U ( $ ! " ' A" $ A 1< ( / U 2 * 1 ( / 2 N ¢ - U

U ( $ ! " ' A" # # ( / U 2 * 1 ( / 2 N ¢.- U

U T/ O A O a 2

4343 : B MN:<?

#VtDV C % $!$ ` 1E W P "1< ^ ( O #P " ' A" " T$!+ " 1 A U A $! ` $ U $ ` $ $_ ! ! G A [ : ? A : # & " FE A 11 $ ! $ ! _$ ( _ % 5

Or’

z

α

dE

uz

r

r

0

0

v _! #"#?%'3 #?*;+qj?+vi2 * ')2 432 087.F"#912h #')">'3+ 0 2"$0Hj?2 4 ./)2C3@ + 2 m;2h0 #2h')"'3+3? $.1?":25f(2"#f(2h+34?0'3j.1?"#2 %.Uj .+/)22h! =+)*1 3i2 @C ZFE M $

J ML J * / 2N ¢ - U U (

1 WG ! c )$" $ A % * J !L J G I c )$" * J ML J G I A S ` A $_A ! "# ( _ ]G P ! #\ FE # X G$! $ A X % + $ "# $ % 1 $ G$ $ # & " V AC % $ \' A 1 ! _ $ ! "# $!$! $ $ ` A $ FE $ N $ )$" $; $@$ a $ N A $ $! ! < J ML J J !L J G I * cW _1 $ 1E W G 4I7 9 J ML J / 2 * / 2HI ( / 2 * 1

J ML J J !L J G I 4.7:93+ + )i291"$.1j?20 *,+m;2"#912D :*,' !*,')"$ 0H2 : #2^8/*; :k2hkl2D:j 2O/) #2h+3#&*,+ :f.1 #.1j?264)2j.l43! #"#?%'3 #?*;+g2h: v+"! +3?2;@4.7:9 K +lf *;'3":"$.1? P.FffjR* '32H"ej&2hK.F"#9;'(kl2h+ # 432+3k i2 #"#?2 f *;')"e.F% *;'3 #?"Pf(j?' "#.1f4)2kl2h+ .;' k2kl2v")i2h:'j& $.F j ./)2643'>0H2"#0j&2 i2 $.1+ <./)264)26+3k i2 :"$?264)26j. 4?: :"$?%') $?*;+:j?26087.;klfr#')"<j .+/)22h: =4)25j?. 8/*1" kl2?+43 * 'vi22;@

Page 59: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

!"# #

* 0N ¢ - - O - U G I (

U G I * $ T + $! $ $ $ < %HZ( A ! " ! : % ` " $ @ + ^

/ 2 * N ¢ - 1 - - O -

$ * N ¢ - $

%H A"1# $ * $ G A " $ " 1< A W ? A ` "# / 2 * N ¢.-

/ - 2 2 TW $ ?FE $ :8 < % W ) + $ )$" $ $P 1 $ $ $ $ '$ $ F $ G$" $W # $ S X$!+ a $ "/ # A

5 tDV $ Q $ % $ ! ! ' A" # # TFE ` $ ( !" $ A F

5 O "#1` 5 / %b 2 : $+ ` $ $_ ! " 1# < `FE $ # G & : $ 5 : $! * / 2I ¤ A W W ` A 5 FE & G P ( ? ` ) $! A G & / 1 % ` + 5 `A 2 AlC ! " ' A" ]: U$!+ : $ ¤ * G I ¤ * $ : * 0N ¢.- T

z

O

zd

r

r’

α

Ed

dE ur

M

λ _! #"$&%(') $&*,+-j?+vi2 * ')2 4)26087.F"#912h#')"='+ !(j[":2h0 $j??9;+325+"!(+/@

Page 60: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

Z :]KZ Z Z;\ Z(]ZW P $ " ]' $ # $ : : : 6 " X $ < ) $! A & $ ` 5 A W 1E $ # $ A " ! % $ ) A G # " S % ` "

/ 2 * 1

0N ¢ - $ $" FE S $ $ 5 A W `( !" 1 N` * g $ * g :(& ! #1 " %b ` 1< : h` * $ * g :$! * $r A # $ * $ _1v

$ * N ¢ - $ * +, -;

$ * +, -, ¤ 5 $ T

A [ " 5 : % ` " L ! O O :A& / 2 * N ¢ -r 1

Q $ *

O ¢ -r TW + A % $!$ ` G " # ` / $! U $ ZFE ` $X % 5 2 A C :

C / 2 *N ¢.- $

* N ¢.- ` O 2 N $!$ ` Q * O / c 2 * O / 2 A A ' # G ! : # A ($!$ ( S % A $!$ FE ! "1< :

C / 2 * / 2 *

O - $ % $ 5 G ! : ( \ TG $ 5 (: G A A " N $ :

C / 2 *

O - TW U % $!$ C / 2 * / 2 $ S $ $ % " #"/ A $% `# # $ ! $ % ` $ A O Y$! A & / 5 %H A P 2 : $ % $ " ! $ FE Q A A ) %H'$ h " A

Page 61: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

!"#

V DV W! #"%$'&()(+* ( $ (, " ^ .- E &()( $0/21 ( $ ( ( 43 )#( 5( 36$ (7) 1 _ 989: -; ) 3<1=3 * ( E 1 ) ` ( *>) 1"%? *!( ! * !" ),A@(,( =3 )>@( -B1 ) 3" ( : , 1"% )( .- ( 3143DCE1F _ ,A@( 3 ) " ( _ CG"%!$ ) "G? *!(3 * 3 ( "G : IHKJ=LM 8 J : '&*NJO( P3QCK/21 ` C (7RS@( !"T3 E 1C ,( *>)@( $ ( - * "% C ( # ,,( 3U$ ( CG1$ (, " ^ P- E &()( ADC 1+ (* C ( $!" * CT3 @( * -!-VC @(,( 43<1" )(( .3$ ( 1" )( 1W3P3 ( =3"GN&1X ( -B1 P ) 3" )$ ( C/2"%43 @( ` ) 1C ( CE1Y$ ( ! #"T3 @( $ ( E 1 ) ` ( $ ( *>) 1 ( : IHKJ=L : 1 ) "G1WZVC ( A'[ 1 ) _ ,A@( 3 ) " ( : C ( E 1 , -1 * ( 43 )#(( P3\-; ) 3 @( -B1 ) C/]1 ( ( 3^$!" ) " ` @( () _C ( ZB1 _ P" 8^` caH( 3\ #"bC ( _ P39&(,(c( P3CG1$ (, " ^ P- E &()( * - @() " (*>)(dL AS @( C @(,e( 43^$ ( *>) 1 ( $gf M 8 $ J 8 P"G J $ghi )>@((F* j E 1 , -$ (k, $ * C ($ M lN 8 IHKJ=L $Bfnm8$!=3QCE1O43 ) "%Z * 3"% (o 1 (a( P3eCE1p- ) Wq ( 3"G $ J &1r"G=3 @( ` )() *>) hs$ ( c &1 O H =3 ) "TZ * 3"G O Lt( 3^ *>)^J $ ( c &1 O : #"T3 H:c=LuM lN 8 O 8 4v m8 m J P"G J $ J

* +, -)w\xnyBzdx

M 8a 8 TW!3 () 1A? * /|"GC^0/ ( P37-B1 7-g # #"TZVC ( &1-B1 ) 3" ) $ ( CG1$!! @(( $ ( ( 3#3 ( (* C (p( - )( # P"G$ ( $ @( $ * " )( C ( -;3 ( 43#" ( C ( A C 1 * $ ) 1"%3 ( (~;( 3!V1 1 3 )( CG1e :] X6H U L $V1! * "G P"GV1 ` ( $ ( -; *>) 1( 3 )( 91W-B1WZVC ( $0/ (~g( 3 (*>) CK/|"G=3 @( ` ) 1W3"% A+ec 6ju 3P>3 HQ;IH!K : : F H F :<=u: FC ( 3 E @( ) &(,( $ (Y¡ 1 * # k$!! (* ((¢ - )( # #"%$ *r£V*¢ $ * E 1 , - @( C ( 3 ) "G? *!( ( )@(g@(-B1 )t* ( $!"% P3 ) "TZ * 3"GQ1 ) ZV"%3 ) 1" )( &13 ) 1d¤ () * ( *>)¥ 1 (¥¦(),A@((§N( ¥ !3"GY$ ( CG1k E 1 ) ` (33<1C (( ¥¦(),A@(( -B1 ) CG1U *>)#¥ 1 ( A¨"T3©«ª H ( L C (c£V*¢+( X? *!( P3#"G A W¬16-B1 ) $ @( 5 !"%3"%

© ª H ( L­M¯® ª $B© H ( L $B© H° ( LIM (U± $g² T H O A O³ Lt ,,( -B1 ) 1"GC%C (*>) eC ( E 1 , - ( .3 * ( # ,,( $ ( E 1 , -V * C% , ZV" ( ! H ? *!( C/2¤W1 E "G #" ) P * eCE1 ¥ ),( $ ( CK/ (¢ - )( # #"GA"G=3 @( ` ) 1C ( : , 1"G FCG1 , 1(,( $ @(, 1 ) E!( -; *>)#) 1 1( 3 )#()( - ) $ * "%3 ( -; *>)\* ( $!"% P3 ) "TZ * 3"G+$ ( E 1 ) ` ( \$!"G # ) &( 3 ( L :

$ Jµ´ G#¶ ´¸·V¹#º¼»µ½ M $!¾ HK¿7LNÀ 8 U_Á ¿Â U_Á ¿  Ã+- (* 3 ( ! )(p@( ) " )(ÅÄ|Æ w¸Ç ( M ( $ Jµ´ G#¶ ´¸·V¹#º¼»µ½ © ª H ( L­M ( © ª H $ Jµ´ G#¶ ´¸·V¹#º¼»µ½ L

Ä|Æ w¸ÇdÈ j4É/.1'3 f *;'3"=0H2j.Uf 2H" k ') #2H"j?2h<+ )i291"$.1j?2IÊ0H*;+m,2":9;2+ #2¸ËP2H gi20H"#?"#2ÌbÍ ÊGÎÐÏgËVÑ ® Í Ï 4nÎÐÒÓPÔÕÖÓ×;ØÙÖÚÜÛ­Ñ Ï ® Í 4nÎÐÒÓPÔÕÖÓ×;ØÙÖÚÜÛÞÝ

Page 62: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

Z :]KZ Z Z;\ Z(]Z * : -; *>)_* ( $!"G .3 ) "%Z * 3#"GX$!"% # ) &( 3 ( :

( M ( ¾ NÀ 8 U Á ¿Â U Á ¿  ©«ª H ( L M ( ©«ª H Jµ´ G#¶ ´¸·V¹#º¼»µ½ L / ( P3 ^ &1 ^ $!" )#( ? *!( C (Å£V*¢ $ * E 1 , -O331Cu (U) 1 , &( ( $V1! 3 * C ( c91 7&1 * ( # ,e,( $ (£V*¢ $ ( E 1 , -V c * CG , ZV" ( ! c-g *>) C ( #? *!( CG cr17$ @( qd&1 , =3 )@( ? *!( C (Å£V*¢)( ¤" ( =37&1 * $ @( ! , Z )(,e( 43_$ ( C%" ` ( \$ ( E 1 , - ( 3\¤W1 * 3

© ª H $ J°´ GP¶ ´¸·B¹Pº¼»°½ L­M $!¾ HK¿7L 8 #" $!¾ HK¿7Lj§© ª H $ J°´ GP¶ ´¸·B¹Pº¼»°½ L­M c #" $!¾ H¿+Lj§

-; *>) $ ( _$!"% P3 ) "TZ * 3"G! D=3"G *!( ^$ ( E 1 ) ` ( ( 3©«ª H Jµ´ G#¶ ´¸·V¹#º¼»µ½ L M ¾

8 #" ¾ j§©«ª H Jµ´ G#¶ ´¸·V¹#º¼»µ½ L M c #" ¾ §

-; *>) $ ( F E 1 ) ` ( F$!"G P ) &( 3 ( A C /2"G=3 @( ` ) 1C ( *>) C ( ¤=C *!,e( $ ( CE1X$!"% P3 ) "TZ * 3"G Ä|Æ ) Ç $!! (1CG ) * ( 43 ) "%Z * 3"% @( ` 1C ( &16CE1Å E 1 ) ` ( 33<1C ( ª ( ¥¦()#,@(( $V1! \CE16 *>)¥ 1 (ŧ©«ª H ( L M l 8 z ª $!¾ HK¿7L M

ª 8©«ª H ( L M l 8

- ª¾ M ª 8 T

(\)@( * C%3<1W3 ( P3 5 V1C (,( =3 @( ¤"G$ ( =3C% ) #? *!( CK/| ( # * ¤>" ( 43$ ( CK/ (¢ - )#( # #"%Q$ *e£V*¢ -g *>)* ( E 1 ) ` ( -;!3 *!( CGC ( A E 1? *!( E 1 ) ` ( -g!3 *!( C%C ( $9¾ H * ¾ -; *>) $ ( E 1 ) ` ( $!"G # ) &( 3 ( L &1CK/|"G=3 @() " (*>) $ ( CE1^ *>)¥ 1 («¥¦(),A@(( 43 ) "%Z *!( 19¤ ( * F-;"G$! _$n¾ 8d: ( 3 C ( u E 1 ) ` ( (¢ 3 @() " (*>)#( &1FCE1F *>)¥ 1 ( ( =3 ) "TZ *!( 43«-B1 «91 ) C ( tCG" ` ( D$ ( E 1 , -+? * / ( CGC ( t )@(( 43«3 ) 1d¤ () ( =3_$ (*¢¥ "G H( =3 )@((( 3\ # ) 3" (dL ( 3#3 ( *>)¥ 1 ( AC /2"%43 @() 1( 3 , 1nq (*>) $ * 3 E@( ) &(,( $ («¡ 1 * # ( P3 $ ( - ()#,( 3#3 )#( C ( 91CG * C $ *F£V*¢ $ * E 1 , -@( C ( 3 ) "%? *!( 1CG ) «? * /27" ` ! )( CE1 ¥ ),((¢ 13 ( $ ( ( E 1 , - A 1! * +- ) ZVCK&(,( &1 E 1 * 3 ( _ ,@( 3 ) " ( : F1 ( (~;( 3Ð *>o 1 ,,( =3Ð$ ( =3 ) 1"G=3 ( H CG" @(( t&1_CE1D _ ,A@( 3 ) " (­( 3Ð1 *¢ - ) - ) " @( 3 @( $0/2"%4¤W1 ) "G1! (dL -; *>) " , -g ()D* ( $!" )( 3#"G¬1 * E 1 , - ( 3 * ( $ @( - ( !$V1! ( $ *X, $ * C ( $ * E 1 , - ( ¥ !3#"Gi$ ( () 3<1"G ( e¤1 ) "E1WZVC ( A ( 43 ) 1"G=3 ( e- (* ¤ ( =3Y *>oe)( 1 * 91CG * C$ *a£V*¢ &1e3 ) 19¤ () * ( *>)¥ 1 (Å¥¦(),A@((F( CGC (;^¸, 1(,( E "% #" (( ¥ !3"Gj$ ( CE1 _ ,A@( 3 ) " ( APC ( E " ¢ $ ( CG1 *>)#¥ 1 (^( P3­3 * q. *>) ­3 ( CV? *!( CE1? * 1=3"%3 @( ª ( ± $²X #"T3 ¥ 1"%C (,e( 43I91C% * CE1WZVC ( ,,e( ¤==3\C (c, 43 )() C ( \1W-!-VCG"%91W3"G! D? * "' * "T¤ ( =3 AÄ|Æ ) Ç f "!$#&%'!(*) j,+.-vi+m+hj,1f3f/+k0+ )1-$+6j32 )'+6f#)i+54i+5-+ )6+"7$2Ff# %+8%12hm"(*#=f/+9# k:!$))i+j*+8%;( ))i+5<=#&21j,+8%>7

ÌbÍ ÊGÎÐÏgËVÑ ® Í Ï -nÎÐÒÓPÔÕÖÓ×;ØÙÖÚÜÛ­Ñ Ï ® Í -nÎÐÒÓPÔÕÖÓ×;ØÙÖÚÜÛ­Ñ Ï -?dÊA@^ËBDC Ý

Page 63: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

!"# 343 B!B M P FV ;IHQ?

° \!¬ b # Þ j1$ @( qd&1 (¢ - ) " ,A@( C ( -;3 ( 43#" ( C * CG , ZV" ( A&1 ) 1!$ ( $!"% P3<1! ( -g *>)* ( $!"G P3 ) "%Z * 3"%1 ) ZV"T3 ) 1" )#( V1 ) @(( 5 !" ( $0/ (¢ 3 ( ! #"%3-V"%? *!( 8 : ( ? * "«43 ) 1"G=3eCG1 ¥ ),e( * "%¤W143 ( &13 * 3 ( $!"G .3<1! (

( H U LIM !À 8 #" ( H 98 J h L #" sM (%$ HK¿7L $'&)(M+*-, (\, 1(,( -; *>) C ( I , -g 143 ( I$ * .V1 , - @( C ( 3 ) "%? *!( : CG1 ¥ ),e(\, 1W3 @(, 1W3"%? *!( &1/ ) 1!$ ($!"G .3<1! ( " , -; ( &1Å3 * 3 ( $!"G P3<1! ( CE1 ¥ ),(

('0 1 - H J h LuM (U±321 - M !À 8 m54 ('0 1 - H 98 J h L6,¨"tCE1j$!"G .3 ) "%Z * 3#"G$ ( V1 ) ( ( P3U P-7 @() "G? *!(OH / ( P398&1:8¸$!" )( $ HK¿7LFM $ H<;L( !"G #"% # 1=3CK/| ) "="% ( 1 * ( 43 )#( $ ( CE1O P-70&()(dL : 3# * 3 (X) 3<1W3#"G $0/21'C ( J * h 1 ) ZV"%3 ) 1" )( Q1 * 3# *>)$ * ( =3 )( $ ( CE1¯ P-70&()#( CG1"G # ( C ( - ) ZVCK&(,( -7>> #"%? *!( "G!V1' @(@?Ab( 1'C ( J ( 3Ah0/2"%43 () ¤>" ( ! ( =3X$!!j$V1! +1 * * ((¢ - )( # #"G -7B #"G? *!(@?Ab( 71 ) *!,( =3 Y$ ( 9 ,A@( 3 ) " ($ @( ¤ ( C%-!- @( F$V1! kC ( 91 $ ( CE17 P-V" )( " ) * CE1" )#( - (),( 3#3 ( 43k$ (, 1(,e( $ (U, 43 )() ? *!( C (V1 , - @( C ( 3 ) "G? *!(k( P3 ) 1$!"G1C H / ( .398&1:8Ü$!" )( -; ) 3 @( -B1 ) C ( ¤ ( 3 (*>)_* !"%3<1" )( 2C L

r20

r

ϕ

R

DFEHG5IKJMLONBPRQ3SUT(3%)6#&(WV !$)&(* %YX:Z\[+5#&(^] !+-$+4Z2=#'<+5%_

( H U L M ( H L M !À 8 #" ( H 98 L ( H U L M ( H L 2C M !À 8 m 4 ( H 98 L 2C ,

( CG1 ( !$ (_)( CG1W3"G : e$ @( $ * "%3t? *!( C (\£V*¢ $ * V1 , - @( C ( 3 ) "%? *!( &1c3 ) 1d¤ () * ( *>)#¥ 1 ( P-7 @() "G? *!( $ () 13= ( 43 )@(( *>) CK/2 ) "="G ( / @( ) "T3 Ä|Æ y Ç©`=a9bdc»fe%» H ( L­M ( H LV® `=ab6c»<eT» $Bf M !À m ( H L

Ä|Æ y Ç hg +9) %2iX#' !) (,45(- ! +jX2=#')Ok,2 -(,#'+849)6(, #62-(32.k,+-! 4Z2 g Xh] !(lX/+5# g +9)- <[+549#&(*#6+mX/!#! [+kn[+ g + ) -$+%6!$#KÉ 2=49+%YX:Z\[+9#&(^] !+ -porÑrqs%'( #t - t -uvI-wO] !+Î Ïx -poÑzy Ï -p +5) - 2=!)'#6+/X 2D#6)%k,+É 2(*)|] !+/k*+ g -!k,+-! 4~Z2 g Xy Ï Ê=q Ë + -\[+9X + -] !+ -$+/k32 -(3%)&2 4>+q %2k =#&(*<"( +7 4>+/] !(14> -!(,) %2 `=ab6c»feT» ÎuÏ x -@oÑy Ï'Ê=q Ëfq spC %'( #t - t s C -uFÑ6Bq s yÏbÊRq Ë_

Page 64: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

!"# $( 3D$ * 3M @( ) &(,e( $ (¡ 1 * # \7$ @( $ * "T3\? *!( #"0CK/|7 ( -VCG1 ( &1ÅC/ (¢ 3 @() " (*>) $ ( CE1F$!"G P3 ) "%Z * 3"%H ` 8 L : X1U #" , -VC (,e( 43 Ä|Æ% Ç

!À m ( H L M l 8 C w8 $ H<;L !À ; m $ ; M 8 #"T3 * ¬V1 , -X$ ( CG1 ¥ ),e(

( H L M !À 8 m 2 C ,Ab( -;3 ( 43#" ( C&1UC/ (¢ 3 @() " (*>)\( ¬$ @( * C ( -B1 ) "G=3 @( ) 1W3#"G

( H L M Á ( H L $ M !À 8 ( 7!"G #"% # 1=3\CG1F! P3<1=3 ( $0/2"%43 @( ) 1W3"GY * CGC ( -; *>) 1 # *>)() ? *!( C ( -;3 ( 43#" ( C; /]1! * C ( &1CK/|"G'&V!" ?Ab( ¥ !3"%! " ( H 98 L'( 3 4 ( H 98 L P43u$!!t P" , -VC (,( =3 @( =1C ( \&1 l &1CK/ (¢ 3 @() " (*>)( 3uC ( -;3 ( 43" ( C ( 3 C ( V1 , -Å- )( ! ( 43­CE1 ¥ )#,( * C% , ZV" ( ! ( )#)#( P-;!$V1=3&1 * ( V1 ) (-;!3 *!( CGC ( -VCE1 @(( &1UC/2 ) "R"G (@?

)(°)(°*( \!¬ +-,!,$+/.0,12+4353 61".0,+7412+/8)7 68).9+1 4,:7418;,1#. +/74180+/8<+43>=Þ.80+¨"CK/2Å ( -VCG1 ( ( 3#3 (D¥ "% ^&1C/2"%43 @() " (*>) $0/ * ( $!"G P3 ) "%Z * 3"%UV1 ) @(( &1 9 ,@( 3 ) " ( P-7 @() "G? *!( :C ( U1 ) *!,( =3 F$ ( 9 ,A@( 3 ) " (Q( 3Å"G=¤1 ) "G1! (N@( ¤=? *@( - )@( @( $ (,,( =3 )( P3 ( 43ŤW1CE1WZVC ( ?Ab()( *>) e1 * 3M @( ) &(,( $ (¬¡ 1 * # (¢ "R (Q* ( (* C (7, $!"?&V91W3"G P"tC (Q£V*¢ $ * V1 , - &13 ) 19¤ () * ( *>)#¥ 1 ( P-7 @() "%? *!( =1 ) $ ( CG1 ¥ )#,( !À m ( H L : CK/|"G=3 @( ) 1C ( $ ( CE1¬V1 ) (Y( .3 ( 3P3 (k¥ "% \C%" , "T3 @(( &1 * ( P-7'&()( $ () 13= A@ 98 ( 3_"%C'¤" ( =3!À m ( H L M l 8

CBC w8 $ HY;kL !À ; m $ ; ( H L M Á ( H L $ ,

A 1 ¥ ),((¢ 13 ( $ @( - ( !$ , 1"G=3 ( V1=3^$ ( CG1 ¥ ),e( - )@( "G ( $ ( CE1e$!"% P3 ) "TZ * 3"G¬$ ( .V1 ) ( ( 3\C ( ¥ !3"%! " ( H 8 Lt( 3 4 ( H 8 L«( X$ @( - ( !$ ( 43 @( =1C (,( =3 ?)(°)()(DCgÐk+/7+E8*.F1'7 +G+.0,H= 7 +I+J 1! DC ( 91 «-B1 ) 3"% * CG" () CG1 # #"G? *!( $ ( $!"% P3 ) "TZ * 3"G! «$ ( V1 ) ( * !" ¥ ),( ( 7¤=C *!,( *( + *>)¥ 1 ( : C ( ( ¢ - )( P #"G+Z!3 ( *!( 6&1ÅCK/ (¢ 3 @() " (*>) #=3D¤1CG1WZVC ( H( 3D #=3\C ( ,LK(,e( t$V1! C ( \$ (*¢ 91 DZV" ( ( 43 ( !$ *BL : , 1"G &1UC/2"G=3 @() " (*>) : 7- ) &( $ ( ,,( * "%3 M $!"% P3 ) "TZ * 3"G+$ ( V1 ) ( * !" ¥ ),(c( X¤=C *!,( $ 8 !À m ON w H L MQPR w CC w à #"T3 N w H L M !À 8 m S 98UT à M !À 8 Ã8 AV 98 ON w H L M !À 8 m AW 8 Ä|Æ% Ç )'+5#62Ok32 -(YX[+5#'+ 49++ )6#6+ k32[ZD2D#&(,2.V:k,+/q/] !( -\[+549#6(,)k,2 %6!$#KÉ 2=49+ -$+]\ 2=!%'%0+5)k,2^ZD2D#&(32V:k,+]_ ] !(X2=#649!#')k,2 %"!$#&4>+.4~Z2D#6<'[+5+d_

Page 65: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

!" $#[ *>) C ( -;3 ( =3" ( CV1 N w H L M Á N w H L $ M Á&%m P')( R w C yC %w ! P3<1=3 ( : b&* CG1c! P3<1=3 (( P3­$ @( 3 (), "% @(( -B1 ) CE1!$!"%3#"G6$ ( 43"% * "T3 @( $ * -g3 ( =3" ( C&1cCG1 *>)¥ 1 ( $ (t) 1 ) $ (,( =3 8 P')( R w %C w M ! P3<1=3 ( Á %m P')( R w %C w : $0/|b&*

N w H L M l* !À 8 8+-, Á S.. 8 T m0/21 . V . 8 1

N w H . L M !À 8 . 1 . W . 8 ,M $!"% P3 ) "TZ * 3"G+$ ( V1 ) ( * !" ¥ ),e( ( + *>)¥ 1 (43 8 !À . m 65 w H . L Mz* #"T3 N w H . L M! P3143 ( : b&* CE1! .3<143 (( P3«$ @( 3 (), "G @(( -B1 ) CE1!$!"T3"GQ$ ( 43"% * "T3 @( $ * -;3 ( 43" ( C P')( R w C w M ! P3<1=3 ( : $0/2b&*

65 w H . L Mz* 1 5 w H . L M !À 8 . 8 1 . V . 8 1 5 w H . L M !À 8 . m 1 5 w H . L M !À 8 . 1 . W . 8 1

Ab( (¢ - )( # #"G! 6 #=36$!! @(( 6"G" ( ¥ !3#"G$ ( CG1a.V1 ) ( 331C ( : , 1"G ( CGC ( Å- (* ¤ ( =3@( =1C (,( =3 K( 3 )((¢ - ) " ,A@(( ( ¥ !3"G $ ( $ ( ! #"T3 @( ( * ZV P3"T3 * 1=3 )#( P- ( 3"%¤ (,( =3 M ' Ã À . Ã8 $ 8 * sM !À . m8 3 8 ?

0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3

r/r0

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

4πε 0 r

02 E(r

)/Q

0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3

r/r0

0

0.5

1

1.5

4πε 0 r

0V(r

)/Q

DFEHG5IKJMLONBP N798\Z2 g X+9) X/=)6+ )6(,+9k -;: ! +.%YX:Z&%+5#6+.! ( É # g [+ g + )14Z2D#6<'[+5+6_)(°)(=<0(?> 13 . +/. A@V +4,:7412+ +/74180+

Ab( 91C% * C ( P3H&VV1C (,( =363 ) &( 6 #" , -VC ( &1pC/ (¢ 3 @() " (*>) $ ( 3# * 3 ( $!"% P3 ) "TZ * 3"G¯&1j 9 ,A@( 3 ) " ( P-7 @() "G? *!(? ¨" CE1Y$!"G P3 ) "%Z * 3"%p1 * ) 1 = &V!" . 89: ) 1 # (, ZVC ( $V1! C ( 31WZVC ( 1 * * "%¤W1=3C ( )@( * C%3<1W3# _$V1! _C ( D$ (*¢¬R ( _$ ( CK/ ( P-B1 (@?BCD"E L C INBP QrT(3%)6#&(WV !$)&(* % %2 %GF g [+9)6#6(,+.%YX:Z\[+9#&(^] !+6_HJILKKLNM-L EPO LRQS CT L UWV CX S YZIA[9L\K![MEHL E Y JMLRQ T JE]S^[EILK6 q s y«Ê=q ËBÑ`_ Í$a BDC b ÊRq ËSÑdc y«ÊRq Ë-q _ Í ÊRq ËSÑ wC 6I_ s -_eWÊ_ Ë

qgf q C ÎhÊ=J ËVÑ i"jlkmjn Ro w w y I-w b hÊ=J ËBÑpi"jlkjn Ro w w _Zq Ó q;+5%');! +.49 %')&2 )6+qgr q C ÎsÊ=J ËVÑ iut$v w0wn Ro w w y I-w b sÊ=J ËBÑxc yn Ro w izt$v www y -q _ Í ÊRq Ë 2 X#&(*#6( ZD2D#&(,2.V:k,+

Page 66: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

!"# $)(°)( (j @!3 1".7+ =W7 + ! #"G$0&()(i* d>C%"G!$ )( $ (A) 1 = : $ ( C%' *!(*>) "%'&V!" ( -; ) 3<143 * ( $ ( ! #"T3 @(¤=C *!, "G? *!(+* !" ¥ ),e( $ 8 ? ¨"%3 C/]1 ¢>( $ * d>C%"G!$ )( : ( 3Y #" ( 43 . 1 h 1 C ( Q ) $!! @(( dCG"G!$ ) "G? *!( ?A 1e$!"% P3 ) "TZ * 3"G ( .3^"G=¤W1 ) "E1=3 ( -B1 ) 3 ) 1! #CE1W3#"G+-B1 ) 1CGCK&( C (,( 436&1 ( 3\-B1 )) 3<1W3#"G1 * 3 *>) $ (6 $!!  ¶ º¼½ z eT» H . 1 h 1 =L  ¶ º¼½ z e%» H . L6? * 3-VCE1=3 ( V1=3 :1"G! P"b? *!( 3# * 3\-VCG1+- () - ( !$!"% * CE1" )(k( P3\-VCG1¬$ ( 9 ,A@( 3 ) " (? * 7-;"%43 & ? *!( C%!? *!( :C ( V1 , - ( .3$!!\-g ) 3 @( -B1 ) CE1c$ ) "%3 ( q."RV143I- () - ( !$!"G * CE1" )#(,( =3 & &1C/]1 ¢!(\ : #"%3 ¶ º¼½ z e%» H & L ¶ º¼½ z eT» H . L 2C ?t()@( * C%3<1W3 ( P3D¤1CG1WZVC (c( X3 * 3D-;"%43\$ ( C/ ( .-B1 (@?

E

z

r

DFEHG5IKJMLONBP N>Q+T(3%)6#&(WV !$)&(* 4F k,( -#6( ] !$+:-$+.4Z2D#6<=+8%~_ C« *>o 3U$ ( () . ()Q* ( *>)#¥ 1 ( $ (X¡ 1 * # e1$V1W-!3 @((@?lAb(+£V*¢ © ª H ¶ º¼½ z e%» H . L 2C LeM ª ¶ º¼½ z eT» H . L 2 C ± $g²O / @( ¤W1C *!( #" , -VC (,( 43D$V1! _$ (*¢ 91 M #"T3_$g² 2C 1 * ? *!( C91 DCE16=3 ) "%Z * 3#"G¬$ ( $g² 1 *7£V*¢ 3#3<1C ( P3_ * C%C ( :M #"T3$g² M $Bf 2C 1 * ? *!( Cu91 ¶ º¼½ z eT» H . L 2C ( .3k! .3<143 ( , $ * C ( *>) $g² ( 3 ( 3 * 3 -;"%43 - () - ( !$!"G * CG1" )( &1cC/ @( C @(,( =3 $ ( *>)¥ 1 (kH C ( - ) $ * "%3­ #91CG1" )( $ ( ¤" ( =3 * e #" , -VC (- ) $ * "%3_1C= @( Z ) "%? *!(dL^Ä|ÆÜÆ Ç ?t( 3#3 ( $ () !"K&()( #"%3 * 1W3"G ( - ) $ * "T3t #"BCK/|Q! #"G$0&()( -; *>)t§ CG1k *>)¥ 1 ( CG1W3 @() 1C (§ ¶$0/ * dCG"%!$ )( $ (Q) 1 = . $0/]1 ¢!(a( 3Å$ ( V1 * 3 (*>)p? [ *>)Å¥¦(),e()U§ : * 3"GC%"G ( $ (*¢$!"G P? *!( § % ( 3 § m $ (c) 13= . - () - ( !$!"% * CE1" )( U&1 -?

ª ) ¶ º¼½ z e%» H . L 2Ct± $g² % M ª y ¶ º¼½ z e%» H . L 2 Ct± $g² m Mz* 1

ª j ¶ º¼½ z e%» H . L 2 C ± $g² ¶ M * À . ¶ º¼½ z e%» H . L.,A / @( ¤W1C * 1W3"%¬$ ( CG1eV1 ) ( =3 ( *!( $V1! § $!! ( $ 8#À m P" . ` Y( 3 $ 8#À . m #" . @ ? ( ¬$ @( $ * "T3 Ä|Æ! Ç

" ¶ º¼½ z eT» H . L M # $ 8 m * 8 . #" . ` $ 8 . * 8 #" . @

Ab( -;3 ( =3" ( CÐ ( $ @( $ * "T3$0/ * ( "G=3 @( ) 1W3"% H . LDM Á%$'&$ C * H . L«M Á H . L $ . ( " , -; 1=3 @( =1C (,( 43DCE16=3"G * "%3 @( $ * -g3 ( =3" ( C ( . M ?Ä|ÆÜÆ Ç #62.XX/+9k k,+ ] !$+ -@o +8%) =#&(*+ ) [+X +5# X + -(,45!k32=(,#6+ g + ) %2|k,2 %6!$#KÉ 24>+d_Ä|Æ! Ç + X/+8!$)pX2=% +)( X#&( g +9#\k*+ 4Z2 g X + É 4>)&(* -+k32:4Z2=#'<+ )6=)&2.k,+-! 4F k3( -$#6+ 452D# 4>+k k*+)* 45(/-( Z+5#6<=+d_ !)6( k,(3%'+:- 4 k,2 -+ %'(,) [+0Z"6k3! g ( ] !$+.-+.4Z2D#6<=+8%e C _

Page 67: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

!" )(°)( (1¸ 1:,$+ 3 68 ,:13 1 ,:1#. 8 , i+'7t+G+ +8

Ab( 3M @( ) &(,( $ (¡ 1 * # ( P3 ZV" ( ( =3 ( !$ * 3 * q. *>) ¤ ) 1" ? t( - ( !$V1=3 "GC=0/ ( P3Ð-B1 * 3#"GCG"% 1WZVC ($V1! 3 * 3 ( QC ( Q #"T3 * 1W3"%! ? ¨"^C/2i ( $!"% P-; ( $0/21 * * 1 ) *!,( =3Q$ ( 9 ,A@( 3 ) " ( : "%C ( .3" , -; # #"TZVC ( $ ( 19¤=" ) &1QCK/21d¤W1! ( ? *!( CGC ( ¤W1 K( 3 )( CE1 ¥ ),e( $ * V1 , - ( 3c"GC ( P3c$!! (¢ C *$0/ ( Q91CG * C () C (\£V*¢ &13 ) 19¤ () * ( *>)¥ 1 ( $!! @((@? J (_, 1!"K&()#( @( @() 1C ( : CG ) #? *!( CK/2U ( 1"T3 ¥ 1" )( 1W-!- ( C&1U$ ( ) 1"G P! (,( =3 _$ ( 9 ,A@( 3 ) " ( ? * / ( * ¬! , Z )( CG" , "%3 @( $ ( -;"G=3 D$ (CK/ ( P-B1 (7H -B1 )(¢!(, -VC ( $V1! C ( 91 $0/ * ( V1 ) ()@( -B1 ) 3" (F* !" ¥ ),A@(,( 43 *>)* j$!"% #? *!( :Y- (* 3 , =3 )() ? * / ( * +-;"%43D$ ( CK/21 ¢!( C ( V1 , - ( P3«-; ) 3 @( -B1 ) CK/21 ¢!( $ * $!"G #? *!( : , 1"G r ( 1"%3c-B1 ( O$!" )( ) 1!$r! (e( r$ ( ! ) $ ( ( 31 ¢!(dL r ( - (* 3k-B1 @( @() 1C%"G () *>o 1 ,,( =3D-; *>) 3 ) * ¤ ()\* ( *>)¥ 1 (k¥¦(),A@(( - (),( 3P3<143 * ¬1CG * Cb$ (c£V*¢\?a < ¬^ p F e5 pFP! "$#&% '!)( % @( @() 1C%"G ( C/ (¢ - )( # P"Ga$ ( CK/ @( () " ( $0/ * > P39&(,( $ ( V1 ) ( $!"G # ) &( 3 ( 1 * 91 _$ ( $!"G .3 ) "%Z * 3#"G! _43"% *!( _$V1! * +¤=C *!,( ¾+*

!À 8 . *-,/. $ HK¿7L $'&!À 8 ; #"T3 *102

¾ *!À 8 . *3,4. ( $ HK¿7L $'&!À 8 ; M ( HK¿7L 1

b&* ( HK¿7L( P3^&1^! * ¤ ( 1 * C ( -g3 ( =3" ( C$ K* &1CG1^$!"G P3 ) "%Z * 3"% ? Å"G=3 ) $ * "G 1=3 CE1_- )(, "K&()#( # ,,e( *>)5 : "GC;¤" ( =3 &VV1C (,( 43l* ¾ * ¾6*

!À 8 . * Á . 7 ( M l* ( $ HK¿7L ( HK¿7L $'& , H * ? *98 Lt( 3#3 (U(¢ - )( # #"G ( P3 * ( "%43 @( ) 1C (@( 3 ( !$ *!( 1 * ¤=C *!,( V1 ) @(@? C%C ( 17CE1+Zg! (¥ ),($!" ,e( ! #"G! ( CGC (?: <; "=?>A@)"B C ( P3 ¥ 1"GC ( $ ( 1CG * C () CK/ @( () " (r@( C ( 3 ) P3<1W3#"G? *!( $0/ * ( P-70&()#( V1 ) @((6* !" ¥ ),A@(,e( 43( ¬ *>)¥ 1 ( -B1 )\(¢!(, -VC (@? [ 1 ) 1W-!-VCG"%91W3"%X$ ( C/ (¢ - )( # P"G

7 ( M5l* ( 3 H¿+L ( HK¿7L $Bf19¤ ( * ( "%43 @( ) 1C ( C%" , "T3 @(( 1 * $! , 1"G ( V1 ) @( : / ( .398&1:8Ü$!" )( CE1Y *>)¥ 1 ( $ ( CE1Q P-70&()( : b&* ( H . 8 L­M P')( R w C w ( 3 3IH . 8 LIM 3 8 M P')( C yw : "GC0¤" ( =3C 5 w M l* `Rabdc»fe%» 3 8 5 w H . 8 L $Bf M l* m!À 8 . 8 ,J 1! kC ( 91 c$ ( CG17 .-7'&()(* !" ¥ ),A@(,( 43V1 ) @((e( O¤=C *!,( : C ( 91CG * C ( P3 * O- (* -VC * $ @( C%"G91W3\91 ) C ( $! , 1"G ( $0/2"%43 @( ) 1W3"G+ / @( 3 ( !$A&1Å3 * 3_C/2"%43 @() " (*>) $ ( CG1U P-70&()( 7 N w M5l* ( $ HK¿7L ( HK¿7L $'&

M l* C w8, !À . Ã8D EGF HN w

l* !À 8 . 8 S , Á ; m. m8 TD EGF H&JI w LK

!À ; m $ ;D EGF HzJMM,N

m!À 8 . 8 ,

Page 68: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

!"# $¸ ! " % B ' " "% " " "@)" ' ( B ' 'V "

- (* 3 , =3 )() ? * /|"GC ( P3 -; # P"%ZVC ( $ ( 3 ) 1! ¥ ),() CK/ ( ¢ - )( P #"G 7 N w M%m $ HK¿7L H¿+L $'& ( * ( "G=3 @( ) 1C ( -g ) 3<1=3_ *>) C ( V1 , - @( C ( 3 ) "%? *!( -VC * 3 K3D? *!( C ( -;83 ( =3" ( C ? «( 3#3 ( "%43 @( ) 1C (_( P3«1C% ) @( 3 ( !$ *!( &13 * 3 CK/ ( P-B1 ( '&*) &( (^* QV1 , - @( C ( 3 ) "%? *!( :? *!( ( #"%3^$V1! C ( ¤=C *!,( V1 ) @( *a( j$ ( ! ) ? 1$ ,( 3#3 ) 1e"G" 1! $ @(, ! .3 ) 1W3"% (c)>@( * CT3<1W3 :7 M » `=a » l* 8 m HL $'& 1? * " ¥ 1"T3^1W-!-B1 ) 1 K 3 )( CE1Å? * 1=3"%3 @(l* 8 m HL ,,e(c* ( $ ( ! #"T3 @( ¤=C *!, "G? *!( $0/ @( () " (@?p- (* 3c ( 4¤W1"G! )( 1"G @(,e( 43c$ ( CE1¤ ) 1"G (, ZVCG1! ( $ ( (F)@( * CT3<1W3 ( )( 3 ) * ¤W1=3CK/ @( () " (j@( C ( 3 ) P3<1W3"%? *!( $ ( _$ (*¢¬(¢>(, -VC ( D- )@( @( $ ( =3 ?

7 :IjI e : U ! XjJ 1! * ( 3 @( ) " ( -7>> #"%? *!( : C ( p$!" ~\@()( 43 O! ( -!3 ( 3 )( CE1W3#"G! "G=3 ) $ * "T3 0/2=3-B1 e3 * eC (X,LK(,( P3<1W3 * 3 ? N-B1 ) 3$ ( - ) "%!"%- ( Q * CG"% ¥ !$V1 ,( 43<1C ( ? «( #43$ ( @( !! @( e"G!$ @(, 43 ) 1WZVC ( : , 1"G Å$!43UCE1a¤W1CG"G$!"T3 @(7( P3e1$ , "G (Y( ) 1"G PA-B1 )U(¢!(, -VC ( $ (¤ @() " &V91W3#"G! (¢ - @() " ,( 43<1C ( t$ ( C (*>) «! @( ? (* ! ( ? @( @() 1C0C ( - ) "G!"T- (c¥ 1"%3D1W-!- ( C &1$ ( I! ( -!3 #".- ) " , "%3" ¥ %$ H°, 1 # ( : V1 ) ( -B1 )I(¢!(, -VC (dL ? * /|"GC!$ @( &V!"T3 ( ,LK(,( 3 (, -V ?5Ab( (¢ - @() " ( ! ( 6? * "I¤W1CG"%$ ( =3UC (=H L - ) "G!"T- (=H L ( ¤ @() "?& ( 43F-B1 Å @( ( # 1" )(,( =36C ( - ) "%!"%- ($!" )#( 3 (,e( 43 : , 1"G -VC * r @( @() 1C (,( 43¯ ( ! @( ? *!( ! ( ? * 3 ( ¯C ( ¯! @( ? *!( ! ( $ @( $ * "T3 ( cCG5"G? *!(,( =3! .3"%3 *!( 431 * 3<1=3c$ ( 3 @( ) &(,( ?& CÐ0/^a1Y-B1 * ( - )@( ( 43<1W3#"G* !"G? *!( : 1 ) - (* 3 @() "= ()a( - ) "%!"%- ( $ ( @( !! @( $!" ~\@()#( 43# ¬-; *>) ! .3 )* " )#(r* (3M @( ) " (@? O!"G P"%3 ( ) @( @() 1Cu$ ( -B1 ) 3" ) $ ( @( !! @( cC ( -VC * - ) . ( k$ ( CK/ ( ¢ - @() " ( ! ( : ( ? * "' )#)( P-;!$¬C ( -VC * _ # * ¤ ( 436&1UCE16$ @(, 1 ) ( !"G P3 ) "G? *!(?BCD"E L C INBP N(' )62=)6!)6% -$+8% <=#&2 -$+8!$#&%FX:ZF$%6( ] !$+8% + [+k,+549)'#6%')&2D)&(^] !+6_)+*-, /.10243655 ,7*8:9<;=4>@?3 9<;=4,A 2 3 ² =B;= 2 =C ,82DE, 0F3HG *-82I;9 3 8J=B;KA "b$ ( * C% , Z L NM NO M O')( R w C y 2 C - ) "G!"T- ( QP"R ;82I 3 2 S5 IT?3U ,V?3W365 () " ( -;3 ( 43" ( CGC ( C NM NO M O')( R w C 3M @( ) &(,e( YX V1 , - @( C ( 3 ) "G? *!( M L NMNO ¾[Z $ @( &V!"%3"%[ 3 ( =3" ( C @( C ( 3 ) "G? *!( M C NM NO ¾SZ $ @( &V!"%3"% V1 , -¬ * C% , ZV" ( M ')( R w C y 2 C 3M @( ) &(,e([ 3 ( =3" ( C' * CG , ZV" ( M ')( R w C 3M @( ) &(,e(\], 5 = ,7^ 2 =4,7*8 5 I 3 DS>; S_365 V1 , - M` ba * $ 3M @( ) &(,e( Yc [ 3 ( =3" ( C M` ba * $ 3M @( ) &(,e( Yc d C *¢ ©Dª H° L M ª $g² $ @( &fe!"%3"hgie @( g ) &( e ( $ (k¡ 1 *j j ©Dª H° L M ª 8 3M @k g )lk,mkvon w 8 +9)6)'+ #6+k,2=)6(, -\[+qp (,) + g/r+ g +)6+ g X% k32 4Z2=#'<+[+9k,+84>)6#6( ] !$++9)sp ($+/k,2AZD26k*+8!$# +9) k,+5% ! (*) [+5% -$+/k3249 %')&2 )6+ BDC _v Ø w 8 : +5%') ! ) Z\[+9# %+ g + (,%6%'!-+k=: + ( X#'+8%'%6(, -$+ k,2 É #649+ +9) -$+ k32:49 %+5#>ZD2D)&(* -+k=:<[+ +9#6<(,+ + g [+8492 ( ] !$+d_v Ò w 8 : +5%');! ) Z\[+9# %+ g + (3%'%6! -$+8%1) Z\[+5=# %+ g +5% -+.%6! X/+9# X/%6(*)&(, + /g [+8452 ( ] !$+d_

Page 69: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

!" eJg %g j%j Z k eMk g lk k k ¡ j j g k he k¥ gie k e "!# @e kA¥ $ g j j #%& k k ' k( k k¥ *) gie,+ j k¢6k khe k £ ¢ g- hg ¥ gie k e. k £ ¢/.? k 012k &fe 3 k£ ¢ k e LKk4 k k j ? e k e5k 6 hg j k7 g hg Z k e89e8M2k g lkmk@?'A % k¢ k j%j hgie: k ; ¥ g kL NM O=< ¾ Z k ¤ k e e.9e k k &fe gie,+ 0 ¥ g k k g g Z: k ¤ k e >e5Mk g lk k@? % k j >e k ?k j%k ehgie:e5 k 5 ; j\¥ g k k7 j g l ¥ > k Ä|ÆA@ Ç ?& k!j - e?k k j%j eB k<j%k k e k j B 0 j k¥ g k k ,%Ce k Mk g k$ Hgie k D lk jY¥ k k e.iEk ek ; j%k D8 e g5 k@? [ k ¢k k +FG e.H k #% k¢ k j%j hgiee k4I gie k ee k k 0 ¥ g !k k 9¤ gie g k e k¥ gie k e. k 0 d¤? gie,+

LKJ M J O*< Á>L:M"M Z. m 2 C 1k eg eFNO,% k k P ; LKk kt¥ g kK 2k N? k N? k 0 ¥ g k k g hg RQ +igie gie j kN?,%S; j o 6 k¥ k k jj Qfj hgie j

¾ . Mk l!À UT . Á>L

Jg6d¤Eg k e:e j%k V Q k 5e k Mk g k k 0m d¤? gie BCD"E L C INBPCW' )62=)6!)6% -$+8% <=#&2 -$+8!$#&%FX:ZF$%6( ] !$+8% X/!$# k32<=#&22Z$(*)&2D)&(, )+*-, /.102S3U55 ,*-8:9<;f=4>T?3 9<;=4, A 2 3 ² =B;= 2 =C ,82DE, 0 3HG *-82I;9 3 8J=B;KA gV kPX k4I gie LYJ M J O*< Á>L JKJ OC y 2 C he k QP"R ;-8I 3 2 S5 I@?3U ,V?3W365 e k M k Jg k e. k ; k C J M J O,< Á>L J OC Mk g lk k QX : k d¤? gie R J

<LKJ M J O M Z k &fe gieZ g k e k F d¤? giee k J

<C J M J O M Z k &fe gie e k4I gie k e R8J

<Á>L JC y 2 C Mk g lk kZ g k e k 1e k4I %gie k e J

<Á>L J C Mk g lk k\ , 5 = ,7^ 2 =4,7*8 5 I 3 9<; 55 3U5 R

< ` R J a g R Mk g lk k Qc Z g k e k < ` J a g Mk g lk k Qc d ; ¢ © ª ! R / < ª R Yg² k &fe gie 2k g lk e k kk¡ j j ©Dª[! R / < Á !À L7\ ª Mk g lk kvon w 8 +5)6)'+ #6+9k32D)&(* -\[+bp (*) + g/r+ g + )6+ g X % k,2 g 2%'%'+<=#&22Z$(,)62=)6(, +k^k,+.+5)p ($+k,29ZD26k*+8!$# +5) k*+8%1! (,) [+8% -$+k3249 %')&2 )6+] _v Ø w 8 : +5%') ! ) Z\[+9# %+ g + (,%6%'!-+k=: + ( X#'+8%'%6(, -$+ k,2 É #649+ +9) -$+ k32:49 %+5#>ZD2D)&(* -+k=:<[+ +9#6<(,+ + g [+8492 ( ] !$+d_v Ò w 8 : +5%');! ) Z\[+9# %+ g + (3%'%6! -$+8%1) Z\[+5=# %+ g +5% -+.%6! X/+9# X/%6(*)&(, + /g [+8452 ( ] !$+d_

Ä|ÆA@ Ç ' (k=: %"!Z2=(,)'+ X 2D# + ($+ g Xk*+ 4> %')'#&!(,#6+ ! + ) Z\[+5=#&(*+ -+vk=:<[+9k,+84>)6#'"%)&2D)&( ] !$+ -2 % ! +8%<X 2=49+V(3-( g + %6(* +9k 7(^k +5%') X# [+PÉ[+5#62.V:k,+ -$+%X2=#')&(*#0-$+ 4>+5)')6+ %'+549 -$+«É =# g !:k,2=)6(, _^ +`_/! ( -;: ! 4Z2 g X #62-(32.k-2 % k*+lXk,2 %'+9#&2=(,) 2( %'( -$ [+lX 2D#baBqMyDÊRq Ë +9)1+ Z+5#6)6!-!) Z\[+5=# %+ g + -$+ \2=!%6%97 ( k -+ Z #&2=(,) ZD2.k,(,# ? a BDC8 +k,24> -!(*) %2 ! 4Z2 g X [+9k,+84>)6#6( ] !$+ + Dc a q 49+9)6)6+tÉ (3%>7'y«Ê=q Ë Ñ ds Ro w w +5).! X/)'+ )6(,+kk,=<"2D#&(*) Z g ( ] !$+b ÊRq Ë Ñ c ds Ro w k q _$8 : +5%').! + %6(*)&!2=)6(, )6# %+8% -( X [+9#6+ )'+ -+%k=:<[+9k,+549)6#'"%)&2D)&(^] !+ -2 % k: +8%<X 2=49+ #6-( 2=(,#'+6%2)6#'"(,% -( g + %'(, %~_

Page 70: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

A $> e k " k¢6k k k k k j k j j k % k k g j ;N? k #% k¢ k j%j hgie

k d¤?hgie ?k kTk e e g e kTj gie' ¢6k e k ; ¢ k k j%j%k \ ܶ º¼» + j%j ; k k l1e: j N? k k 3Egie . T k > k k e j ?k e ¥ g k R ܶ º¼» ! / < Á * L7\ ܶ º¼».T

+ Á S . T T % v / 1g k e g k #% k e k M k Jg k e. k ; k ,%Se k9 j j%k M l j e k . k e k@l7 %S ek k ,%Se kek4Q k j%k#j 7k ;NO k k k e j ?k e ¥ g k k > k 3Egie . T

C ½»µ¹ ¶ » ` » M J ! . / < Á LP\ ½»µ¹ ¶ » ` »* . T+-, Á S .. T T

/ , e k k k4 k eTeg k RN? kD g k k M2k g lkmk kX¡ j%jTk j j k4 k e e k

gie j k N? k e k k ; ¥ g k k e . :!# e j % k j k k e j giee k / + k¢ j k eMk g lk k kY¡ j%j JgR #%Che. k hgiev 9¤ giee k k1 g k JgR #% k k g j ;NO k@? k ;H8 k k 2 k g>¤ k 2G lk j+j k k e2 ; ¥ g k D k 9¤ gie ?k k %¤ k j%k j j Q hgie j k j%j%k jl j k k j 7k N? k k¢6k k?

Page 71: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

!"

! < G ! "4 !

#%$'& ( )" <4 e k j %Che. k g5 k j k j* k j k 'g k e k k k j e %g k@?Z g k 0mgie j%k giee k e k j Q hgie: k M k j6 gO2k ; j e6 %C g k k /gieB ;NO k k!j k e;N? k!j k Q k j hg j G k ?k k k e ? A %C g k ,%^B? g5 lk e k e jj gie k + gie k e k j > k ?k!j%k ek !,M k g gie ! gie j e k eg. / j%j k l e k M k Jgie k ; k .- /102- l % g =he k43 H k lk k ! . 1)5 176 / + k ` gO j eYeHg k e k = k k e. g hg RQ k e 98 ! . / +M e k k e j ?k k M k k k4 gieN? k $ 0 ! . / <;:=<

C)> P@? +9A T < *-, NL*CBEDF ?A gie j e. k : k j 6k k he2k k k e- j%j e.9 0 e k ;?k k k ;NO kHGJILKNM ,O - / 0 - <

T!QP . . $ 0 ! . / < P ASRT :

1 k N?[ g j%k 0 * k : < O - / 0 -UT P A RT ?Z g k k` k k G;NO k` ?k k %C g k +4gieR; j%k k Mk g lk4 k kWV j%jd?A M k g k2 gie k e. kl #%Che.?k k ,%Se kj 7 lk kYX k 3Egie . ! k e?k!kj #% g R e k /*

Z=[< - /\02- Z 0 ! . / < - /102- C

T!QP . . $ 0 ! . /

GJILKNM ^u:^]J_a`[bdc7eNf k bhgibkjlf k jdm k b X f)e ]n_a` [bdc7eNf `N]Jo@_/X f)e X f)e `p] bqg _2rs_to.Vu`p] b _a` k fwv o@_ j `N]Jo@_xzy:^ m k bde y\[b pH_u] b X f)ex|~W cq9 baS y 9 ~ y baS y 9 ~2x|~

f Z bdj x| c c7 g o]`x|~W cq ~ g ]S~ bqg ` b _a`N] bde _

Page 72: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

A $> g lZ 0 ! . /k!j 0 gie. Q hgie e. k k k gie;NO kk - / 0 - k ; k eg. A %S ek k gie l GJILM ,

Z [< - / 0 - S * . A T * .A T

T k C)> P7? e5 k eg k >N? k

0 ! . / < QP . 0 ! . / < O - / 0 -A RT. k C)> P@? < Z 0

. k ?k j%k e k 0 k k k gie;NO k9 g j%k k e.G k k!jsj lk k!j k Egie j . k . . ; k?k j k e. k e he k e A T N?giee k ;P j e k k j + g k g Q Q ;k k ?k j k e k k % k k4 gie A k : k k G;NO kHGnILM l *Ek j X + QP . ! . / + gie + l #%& ; k5 k g lk k k V j%j + l1 % k k j%j hgie

! . / < - /102-* P T SA T

A T .

* . T k C)> P@?

k > k Jg k e. k g k j Jgie e j % g Q k e9> e?k gie G ? M ! . / < - /\02-

QP TS A T

. T k C)> P7?

A % k e k k k 0 j gie k %&%g k ,% g lk e kmk j Pk k ek!k k e k* ; e k * ; ek k!j%j k g k k Jg k e. k 8 ! . /V ?k k k eg. j%k e k k4 gie k` kO - / 0 - k 9 #% k k e k Y k ; j e k . < A T l %S e'&fe k k k e k k k ;; j gie * 9 g j!#"

< P@? L 8 M 0 .%$ C

< O - / 0 - P7? & 8 .'$ C

< .- /102- P7? 8

< O - /102- 8 !pA T / e g Q k e 0 * k e. k N? k ! "

< O *( * k*) ! k+) <

-,/.

0 %21 3 / k ?k j k j 2 k g Q k k 0 * k k k g Q k e. k k e k eN? k NO e.;N? k + gie e,%C j k e. g k [ k #% k e k k ek N? k ! Jg j *Ek / k % k k4 gie G 54 M

GJILM r(_76b ` f 8:9 ]J` v f@j ] 9Jb; b _a`< f7e ]n_a`6bdc7eNf `N]Jo@_=< f)e < f)e `p] bqg>9nfweb9nf `N]o_x@?H|~W cq ?

b y A c b CB ? ~ ? y b y ~2x?C|~ cED b

?

b ` x@?H| cq c c b ?F _G< f7e `N] jdm9 ] ble x@H5IJ ? ? |LK a c a | c a M a D a M H a D H b H5IJ ? ? FGJILM ^ f y ] g ` e ] 8Hm `N]o_!y bhjONuf)epc7b(bqg ` g < N 6bde ]QP m1b 9JbkjONuf*; < bqg `y1o@_ j(eNf y ] f9 R |LS T |LM VU I FG ? M r(_ jON1bdepj5N1b <Co m1ej b9nfwm _ bkg o 9Jm `p]Jo@_=y bW9nfwv o e;wb |XD ZY a M b H[IJ ? ? FG 54iM 8 b `` b 6b _ blepc ] b <Co g ]J`p] Z b%bdg ` y b%9 : o e y eb y b]\^ H a a_`M H g o]` f7m eNf F@o_y b%a o N1e \^ H a a _`D H y1o_a` 9nfj o@_a` e ] 8um `p]Jo@_ bqg ` 9Jfb; o@]J`N]c6b y bhjlb9Q9b y bW9 :26b _ blepc ] b <Co7` b _a`N] b9Q9b | b _OZ f9Jbqm1e f8ug o 9nm1b F

Page 73: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

!" $ ! : ! : ' 'f " " ' > ( > " ' "B "@"=?" % ' b "B "B ( % ' " B " ')B ( @ % ' B @ " )@ " e j e gie k 6 j g k l % k N? ; Q k + k7 k k G;NO k g k j eO V e kJk + k ; k gie k gie k e e2 k!j k j Q k!j + g j NO k>!k ; k j j g j l7e k ?k k +; [ ! j 6 k j k k gie j ; Q k j e k + g k N?, k j 2k 0 k *Ek j k j j q+ k j gie k " k 0 gie g?Ee e2g Jg j k k ?k k k #% k NO; ; Q k#k j 3k ; j k g j N? k ; + g k ?k j e kTj k j g k j Q k!j j %& ee. k + !kN? g G k j gie l7 %C eeO ; gie D e k e k g V! k eDe1 k j lk j Q k +, k #% g k k

0 $# j/ k k g k ?k ,% k e. k g k ??k k e,% k j 7Jg j j Q k NO k k N? k kP ; k g g k k j9 k!j ; Q k j kj%k 2k 0 !k " %Che.?k k 9,%Ce gie k >+ l1 #% k NO; ; Q k k j >gie ?k j k &&%(' < +

)%(' < j 7!# kY* g kk!j k NOJg k e. k /Fk ` e j e * g ; kj * j k e eD k@* e k!j hgie k j g jG g ;NO k j + < ,+ <

0 ,-? k> gie k k!j Ek +. k j k jj%k j Q k e k e j + k#k j *Ekmk e. e j e ; k k k4 N? k !g j g ; e. / +K k j: k!j j gie: ; k k j]k : #%& ; hgie,%Ce k k e k %g * gON? kTj%k k k e7e k g k e gieB k .g k j e j * j e. k g gO k e(k e k g V e gie j k N? k e k +? k> lP #%C e?k k F k k G;NO kk j egie e. k 9 k g k e k 6k k %g j N? k e,% k j Y j9 gie j e:/:10 %32 " % "54 ( % " % B ' " B4 > 6 ' "

798:7$8<;8>=@?)A1BDCE?GFHCICKJLF MNCPOQF@RPCE?DJTSCFHU@V9UFERJXWCY gie j ;k gie j e gie k j k ;NO k k EgieTZ T Jg Gk#l7e Jg k e k T Jg GlH 0D k k ! gie Bk k4 k ePNO k ;8 k k e k k Jg k e. k g k e j hgie k j Pgieek k [<

T O )\^]:_`_`]<

T / 6" k: gie k DJg k g j e k: k g k Z k e j + k +?k G k e+ g k4 k e j 0 j + k k e j gie' k 0 j k kTj k ;NO k %g j k!jJghe. jj gie'k NO * k e jj 0 j + k ,%Se k j lk k X" k g k e k k e j q+ k k j gie gieek T <

!aZ T / <Z

QP T Z T e 2k^b eE 0 ?k : gie k + g k * k e. Ek g k N? k N? k ? k 0YN? e?k k k N? k k >Jg k 9 kP gie k j g jl1 ; k e j gie [ 6 ; k 0hgie

Z<;: [ !dc@ /

Y k k k ; gie k j Ek ek k k e j kK j gie k j k ;NO k + 0 k k j gie gieek k : <QP T Z T 5g e9 k * k k e j giee k #+fgie-

e :gf< e(h T f e Z T f=<ji $#/k ml onqp e [ f< e T f<ji k ml on r# k N?[giee kPQ k e e : [ f< n

e k eg k N?,%C k!j + ; k ,% g Q k e e k NO e.?k g g lk e k]lDe k k e k k %S e k k 0 k g k * k e.9 k ?k ,e : [ fts e [ f< n s e f<ui k l < e k e k k f

,% g l ;9 k ; gie giee e % k e k k gie k Ek ,vwyx 'Pz w| ] _ < gie j e. k sY: [ e:eg k N?,%S; e k + D jD gie+ gie k 0<eg giev~w:x 'z w| ] _ Jg % k e k k *Ek ;

Page 74: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

eg hgie [ g ;B k k e k k Jg k e. k e( k gie.G k RN? k 0 gie j e. k * T + j g=,

v wyx 'Pz w| ] _ < : [

<

Z [

<

Z :

p !dc@ / k N? k!j gie+ g k l % k k j j gie giee e. k k k % k e k k k ; j lk ke+ g k k e bk kk e j + k -?g j gie j e k e e NO k % gie g k ,%Se gie k Ek e j k gie gie k he; k k e.Te k G k +F k ek k j %S e b e Z he k e k + ; K ! j % k k4 k e3 kj + k j%k gie gie k k eB k *Ek4 k k k gie k 7e k j Q gie j + ;NO k k9 k!j k@lP % k j k e k ,%Ce ?k k k> gie k Ek NO`g k k8 g k e j k e j k" gie k ] hg Q k k e.@e k k Jg j%j k % k e k g l7 #%Che.?k k F k9!k ; V," kj 2 kj k gie gie k k j " k k kB k ,%Che k e k >" k k eg Hlk e k ,%C e k e k j%k HH k j ;Lie k!j k 'N?b k e. ,%Ce k k jj q+ k j g *Ek j %& G k t" g j N? k g k j k!j ;Xie k j kK j%j k j ,%Ce gie k * k ee k e l7 ; j + k k %& G kK gie k + %S e k e !k k j 2 g k k ` 0 k he k k!j k k k e.+g Jg j k kml ; k e k e. k

0

0 V

V

U S W! "$# _ _ m b _ j b b _a` eb y bdm&%tj o@_uy m j ` bdm epg F" k jD(') +*,-* ) )@ * ) *- ' .*8/*4 *4* ) D ; ?* ., ') * ') * ) ,*+,+ *4,?*(,H5 * ?* + (' *^* .* ) b* ' *4G;NO*-N? *(,G*B %C )@ * ) * ' .* ;5N? ) ?** *(, ; Q .*(,,G .*(, *,+ ' * ) , .* 0, ,%C )(') +*9, ' *+1* ) + ') ') *7 ; *4* ) *7*6 ' +* ) .* , ;NO2*(* (') * ) ,*4!,

Z<;: ! # O / <;: [ p

'32: #% ') ' ., [54 0 !# .* 6*,G6LE*7* #%& * * *4,Y %C +* / *4tZ ;

*P ' ?*(* 6 #%& * ' , * *

798:7$8:79887gM ?GSCE?:9!; JoCEB=<>9V@? WC0< R+AEBDC )CB *(DFEHGJI0KG(DK.*L B ILH**F*(M B K.*NKOIPGJI B I0GQE1R*TSDCG ') S* ) ,IE*(DFLU, B R*L+Q.V1D*4,WS*(DXIL+MYIEDFL*(,MZR*EI0K.K.QV1D*(,[, B R*L+Q.V1D*,\G ') G(* ) E+LQV1D*(,S*8L]I ') ,_^ # *E^ (` ^ #\a ^ (` ,1R* B IL1R*(*, B IL\D )MbQK.Q.*DXQ, ' KOI ) EUS* B *LMcQE+EQ * QdEFR* hWegf K.* * QS*&h@G ') ,iEQdED* ) END ) G ') S* ) ,IE*DFLT, B R*L+Q.V1D* F * *GK.*8G ' Q jSlkmD ) *bG IL*Z Bn' L+E1R*(* B IL\KkmILMYIEDFL+*XQ ) E+*L ) * ` K.*8G I0M B R*(K.*GE+LQV1D*X* ) EiL*bK.*,ILMYIE+DFL*(, * I0DFEo,+Q.M B K.*(Mb* ) E GmpqNM

&$r ZQP hWe Zs $ut r O S

S Z $=t p ^ # a Z a ^ s

GmpqNM _\v ble ` m y m ` N 6b o exwb; b y bgysf7mugg 9nfjONuf)epc7b <Co e `6blb < f)e 9dz^f7e;wf ` m ebWb% ` ble _ b _ z ]n_a` ble v1] b _a` < f@g y f _ g9z bx% < epbqgg ]o_ y mzjON f+; < y f _ g 9nf jdf v1]`6b v1]ny bWb _a` eb 9Jbqgkf7e;wf ` m ebqgkb ` 9JbtjON f+; < bdg ` 9Jb`;P|b;wb y f _ gkjlb `` be 6blc ]o_=P m1bhg ] gbqm9 9Jbhj o@_uy m j ` bdm e ]J_a` bde _ b(b% ] g ` f ]J` F

Page 75: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

"! ) * ) SNR*(SDQdEgK.I8SQ R*L* ) G*_S* Bn' E* ) EQ.*K3* ) E+L+*_K.*,PS*(D G ') SDGE*DFL, ,

[ r f ^ # h O f ^ s h r O # #s

f Zh S Z r ZQP hWe%$'&^ # O &^ s)( p

, ' QdE

: r Z [ r QP h e ^ # ^ s^ s O ^ # Y ' MbMb* e hWe f r+* M%, # ` K.IXGJI B I0GQE1R* ,(km** B LQ.Mc*[* ) + IL]I0S,

R

Q

R12

-Q

U S.-! 0/ 1o@_ y b _ gf ` bqm1eg < N 6ble ]QP m1b32 9Jbzj o_ y muj ` bqm1e ]J_a` bde _ b=bqg ` ;wf ]n_a` b _ m wfm _<Ho@` b _a`N] b954687:9!b ` 9Jbj o_ y muj ` bqm1e b% ` bde _ bwf m _'<Co@` b _a`p] b9;4 H=< 9 9nf ` b _ g ]o_bv f7m `> 46@?A4 H F798:7$8CB$887gM ?GSCE?:9!; JoCEB=< VED; ?F ) GJI0, E+L 2*(, DFEQK.*\* ) B L]IE+Q.V1D*_SI ) ,[K*(, G(QdLG(DQE+,6R*(K.*(GE+LQ.V!D*(, *(,iE[G(*K.DQ@SD>G ') S* ) ,+IE*(DFL

B KOI ) HGKl,(kmIQE SI ) , KOIM ' STR*(K.Q,IEQ ') QSTR*JI0K.*[S* S*(D ILMYIEDFL+*(, B KOI ) *(, Q )b) Q*(, * ) L*+ ILSKk D ) * S* K k I0DFE+L+*1"Uk B/' E 2*(,+* Slk ILMYIE+DFL*(, Q )b) Q*(, *(,iE ) R*(G(*,+,I0QL+* Bn' DFLZV!DlkmQK I0QEQ )@ D* ) G(*\E ' E]I0K* I ) ,PKOI B L]IEQV1D* R* * Q.S*MbMb* ) E ` K.*,gILMYIE+DFL*(, ') EPD ) *\**1E* ) ,+Q ') b) Q.* )X)' E+*G ') * * ) EQ ')) *(K.K*(Mb* ) EJI>K*(DFL:,+DFL+ I0G* *E < K.IgSQ.,iE]I ) G* V!DQ1K*(,H,!R* B IL* @" k B/' E l2*,+*G(Q S*(,+,iD,XL* * Q.* ) E 2I ) R* K.QX*LCK.*,X* *E,CS*LK ' LS, ` L*(, B/') ,IMKK*(,8S*-K.I + DQE*-S*-K.QX ) *(,S*G I0M B Q.K.KD,iE+L1R** GQ` S*,+, ' D,ONKk I BB L ' FQ.MYIEQ ') *(,iE Slk I0DFEI ) EUMb*(QK.K*(DFL*V1D* < TP I *(,iE B *E+QE

U S=-! Q-R1o@_uy b _ gpf ` bdm e < 9nf _ 2 ] 9 9nm g ` eNf `N]Jo@_y m < N 6b _ o ;gwb _ b y b v m ]` b y bqg 9 ] c _ bqg y bjON f+; < F 1 bdg bTSQb ` g y b 8 o e y gg o_a` `o@` f*9b; b _a` _ 6bdc*9 ] c 6bqg y f _ g 9bkjlf*9Jjdm9 F

Page 76: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

/ ' DFLHG(I0K.G(DK*LHKOIoGJI B I0G(QE1R*TSDG ') S* ) ,IE+*(DFL B KOI ) ` ')_B *([email protected].,+*L@K.*(,3LFR*(,+DKdE]IE,uL*KOIEQ+ ,I0D G ') S* ) ,IE*(DFL>, B R*LQ.V!D* *E B I0,+,+*L 2IZK.I KQ.MbQdE*>^ ) E+L+*jK*(,6ILMbIEDFL*(,-SD

G ') S* ) ,+IE*(DFL , B R*LQ.V!D* ` * ) D ) B/' Q ) E Z ') )' E* Z r ^ # )"3*_G I0M B R*K.*(GEiLQ.V!D* * I0DFE f Zh r Z

QP hWe Zs r ZQP hWe ^ s # $ & ^ # ( ,

s

) Q ) E+L ' SDQ,I ) E\KOI S* ) ,+QdEFR*b,+DFL+ I0GQ.V1D*8,+DFLK k ILMYIE+DFL*CQ ) E*L ) *Z r QP ^ s # ` ') ' KEQ* ) EK.*XG I0M B R*K.*(GEiLQ.V!D*8* ) E+L*XK.*,_ILMbIEDFL*(,[SD G ') S* ) ,IE*(DFL B K.I ) * ) B I0,+,I ) E 2I KOI-K.Q.McQE*^ # , r h e $ & ^ # ( ,

s 4h e

Y*[L1R*,+DKE]IEP,(k ' KE+Q.* ) E R*+ I0K.*(Mb* ) E B ILgI BB KQ.GJIE+Q ') SD E R* ' L 2*(Mc* S* V I0D,+, G pNM "3* Bn' E* ) EQ.*(K* ) E+L*oK.*(, ILMYIE+DFL*(,:SDbG ') S* ) ,+IE*(DFL B K.I ) ,(kR*(GLQdENS ') G f ')c)' E+*-K k I:*B *L B * ) SQG(DKOI0QdL*\I0D ILMbIEDFL*(,]h

f lh r O # S r O he G ') ,iE]I ) E*

Slk '2D Kk ') SNR*(SDQdEgKOIXSQ R*L* ) G(*_S* Bn' E* ) EQ.*(K[ r # O s r O hWe f # O s h r <hWe r Z <hWe I

) * ) STR*(SDQECK.I GJI B I0G(QdEFR* : r h e I T < ` L1R*,+DKE]IE\G ' R*L* ) EXI * *(GbKOI6KQ.MbQdE*C^ S*YK.IGJI B I0G(QdE1R*[SD6G ') S* ) ,IE+*(DFL , B R*L+Q.V1D* "!$#&%&')(+*,'.-/%.01#.23'&# 54.01687 *:9;*.)(- ;< '.*=*?>@( *A- *,'.-F ) B L ' KK 2*(Mb*'+OL1R*V1D* ) E V!DQ_L*(K 2* * * R* I0K.*Mb* ) E SD B R* )' M 2* ) * SlkmQ )@ D* ) G(*Z*,iE G(*(K.DQSlkmD ) G ') SDGE*(DFL B K.I0G R*PSI ) , D ) G I0M B R*(K*(GE+LQV1D* **FE1R*LQ.*DFLY*(KDQ` GQ Q ) SDQENKk I BB IL+QEQ ')S* G IL*, 2I KOI ,+DFL+ I0G(* SD G ') SDGE*(DFL6V1DQ[,+* SQ,iE+LQKD* ) E6S* MYI ) Q 2*L* 2IZI )) DK*L K*G I0M B E ' E]I0KUQ ) E*L ) *~Y ') ,+Q.SNR*L ') ,K.*bG(I0,,+Q.M B KQ b R*8SlkmD ) *Y, B l2*L+*YG ') SDGE+LQG(*-S*cL]I ')Z e ` MYI0Q ) E* ) D* 2IjD ) B/' E* ) EQ*(K ) DK ` B K.I0GnR*(* 2IjKk ' L+QLQ ) * SI ) , & e D ) Q+ ' LMb* *(,8G IL*(,B/' ,iQEQ * *(,o*E ) R* IE+Q * *(,oI BB IL]I0Q.,i,+* ) E 2I8K.IX,iDFL+ I0G(*\S* KOIC, B 2*L* ` GL1R*(I ) EPD ) G I0M B &CBEDGFIH]y_ ] `S*T, ' LiE*NV!D*TK.* G I0M B E ' E]I0KL1R*(,iDKE]I ) E & x r & e &CBJDGFKH]y_`] *E@K* B/' E+* ) E+Q.*(K!I0,+, ' G(Q R* ` x f Z p 5 hf 5 *(,iE Mb*,+DFL1R* B IL L]I BB/' L+E 2ICKOISQdL*(GEQ ') SD G I0M B I BB K.Q.V!DTR*&h ' KTR*(Q,+,+* ) EgI0D G ') SQEQ ') ,I0D K.QMbQE*, ,iDQ * I ) E*,=,

ZL p & x & eZ r Z e p x f Z e p 5 h r 0NM 5

GmpLM rs_ jlf*9Jjdm9Jb `po m `y z^f 8 o e y 9Jb jONuf*; < j e 6b 6b < f)em _ < 9Jf _ j5N f)epc 6b ]n_POC_ ] FQ f)e gSR; 6b ` e ] b 9JbjON f+; < bqg `< bde < b _ yu] jdm9nf ] ebf7m < 9nf _ b `Syu] e ] c 6b y b ;wf _ ] wblepb yu] v bdec@b _a` bg ] 9Jb < 9nf _ bdg ` jON f7ec 6b <Ho g ]J`N] v b;wb _a` FT b)UCmJ%gwf ` epf v bleNg m _ bgpm1epv f@j b v bdec; 6blb j o ; <Co e ` f _a`9y bdm&%gbdj `N]o_ g ]ny b _a`p]QP m1bqg y b< f)e ` b `y z^f@m ` eb y m < 9nf _Nv f@m `V TXW b ` 9JfsjONuf)epc7bb _ v bde; 6bdbbqg `9y1o_ _ 6bdb < f)eY W y z o wm T Y[Z V\ FKQ f)e9gpm < bde <Co g ]J`p]Jo@_y bdg4j5N f*; < gjle 6b 6bqg < f)e y bqmJ% < 9Jf _ g ]J_]OH_ ] g y b jONuf)epc7bqgo*<<Co g 6bdbdg o@_o 8 `N] b _a` 9bjON f+; < b _a` epb 9Jbdgf)ec;wf ` m ebqg y mj o@_uy b _ gpf ` bdm e < 9nf _ T wyx 'Pz_^ DG`ba ' Y[Z \

F+Q

E

S

-Q

Page 77: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

*YKOI B L*MbQ 2*L+*bG ') SQE+Q ') ` QM B/' ,!R** B ILCK.* + I0QdEV1D*YK.I6, B l2*L* R*E]I ) E b) Q* ` *(KK.* ) * B *DFEQ ) SDQdL*V1Dlk D ) * B *LiEDFLK IEQ ') K ' GJI0KQ.,!R**\S ') E K kmQ )@ D* ) G(*CSQ., B ILI !E 2IZ0L]I ) S*SQ,iE]I ) G(* ` ')B *DFEK R* QdEQ.Mc*(Mb* ) EN,iD BB/' ,+*L Bn' DFL K.* B/' E* ) EQ*(KnGL1R*nR* B ILKOI , B 2*L* D ) *4+ ' LMb*oSTR*(GL ' Q,+,I ) E* ) B DQ,+,I ) G(*_S*_KOICSQ.,xE]I ) G(* ` x r O e Z@G ' , 5

QP h e f5 hZ 8

"=I8,+*(G ') S*\G ') SQE+Q ') ` e Z e G ' , 5 r

QP h e f5 hZ 8e p

Q.M B/' ,+* I0K ' L,HKOI4+ ' LMb*S* K.I+ ') GEQ ') I ) DKOI0QdL**E:D ) * G ') EiL]I0Q ) E* V1DQ1L+*(K.Q*K.*(,:G ' *^*bG(Q* ) E, *E ` , ' QE f 5 h r G ' ,

5 *E r QP hWe e Z 8 + #e F B LQ ' LQ ` ) kmQM B/' L+E+*5V1D*K B/' E+* ) E+Q.*(K ,+IEQ.,q+ I0Q,I ) E G(*(, G ') E+L]I0Q ) E+*(, G ')2* Q.* ) E 2I )' E+L+*B L ' KK 2*(Mb*1 ) + I0QE )' D,-I0KK ') ,YQG(QPQ ) * ' V1D*LYD ) L1R*(,iDKE]IEbEiL 2*(,YQ.M B/' L+E]I ) EbV!D* )' D, ) *SNR*(M ') E+L*L ') , B I0, ` K* E R* ' L 2*(Mc*[Slk D ) Q.G(QdE1R*[V1DQl,iEQ B DK.*[V1D* E ' DFE* , ' KDFEQ ') SlkmD ) B L ' KK 2*(Mc*SlkR*K.*(GEiL ' ,iE]IEQV1D*>,IEQ,q+ I0Q.,+I ) E S*(, G ') SQEQ ') , I0D KQ.MbQdE*(,YS ')) R*(*(, *(,iE D ) Q.V!D* ILMbQK.*, B/' E* ) EQ*(K.,bGKOI0,+,+QV1D*(,-G ')) D, ` LI BB *(K ') , K.I+ ' LMb*6SD Bn' E* ) EQ.*(KoGL1R* R* B ILYK* SQ B ' K*R*(K*(GE+L ' ,xE]IEQ.V!D* `

zP% Dx ` ] f Z p 5 h r G ' ,5

QP he Z s GK*(,iEoMYI ) Q+ *(,xE*(Mb* ) EoS*_KOI + ' LMb* G *LG R*(* ` 2I8G ') SQdEQ ') S* B/' ,i*L r p *E r p

, ' QdE b) I0K*(Mb* ) E BJDGFKH]:_`] f Z p 5 h r e Z Re G ' , 5Zs

' D,\I * ') ,\* ) + I0QdE_Q ) EiL ' DSDQEQG(QUD ) SQ B ' K.* R*(K.*GE+L ' ,iEIEQ.V!D* B/' DFL L*(M B K.I0G(*L_KOI , B l2*L*G ') SDGEiLQ.G(* ." kR*(V1DQ * I0K* ) G(*Y* ) E+L*-K*(,\S*(D B L ' KK 2*(Mb*,*(,iECG ' M B K 2*E* 2I>K km**1E1R*LQ*(DFLS*YK.I, B l2*L+* ) SQdEPV!D*_K.*[SQ B ' K* *,iEgK kmQ.MbI*6R*(K.*(GE+LQ.V!D* S* KOIX, B 2*L*C *:9;*X (- ;< '.* %.0X#.2 '&# 4.0X687 *,9*.)(+- < '.* *?> ( *:- *:'&- I ) , K.*jGJI0, '2D G0km*(,xE6D ) MbQK.Q*(D Q, ' KOI ) E V1D* K k ') B KOI0G(*jSI ) , D ) G I0M B *FE1R*L+Q.*(DFL `KOI-,+QdEDIEQ ') *(,iE K/*(I0DG ' D B B K.D,[G ' M B K***CGJIL 2I K kR*(V!DQ.KQ KL*CK.*XG I0M B Q ) E+*L ) *bI0D MbQK.Q.*D

SQ R*K.*(GEiLQ.V!D* *(,xE )')\) DK ` G(* V1DQ2+ I0QE=SQ., B ILI !E+L*UKOI G ') SQE+Q ') S*UL]I0G(G ' L+S*(Mb* ) Eu* ) Z e ' D,I0K.K ') ,uE ' DFE*+ ' Q.,HS ')) *LUV1D*K.V1D*,R*K R*(Mb* ) E, Bn' DFLUIMK ' LS*L:D ) E+*(K B L ' KK 2*(Mb*T* ) G ') ,+QSTR*L]I ) ES* )' D * *(I0D6K.*[GJI0,P, B R*LQ.V!D*F ) R*K R*(Mb* ) E=S* * ' KDMb*gS_S* MYIEQ 2*L* B/' KOIL+Q.,!R*(*U*(,iE R*(V1DQ * I0K* ) E 2IPD ) M ' Mb* ) E3SQ B/' K.I0QL*S r f # h&S '32D *(,iEHK* * *(GE+*(DFL B/' K.ILQ.,+IEQ ') f M ' Mb* ) E3SQ B/' K.I0QL* B ILHD ) QE1R*TS* * ' K.DMc*&h* )C)' E]I ) E # K.IgSQ.,iEI ) G(* SD Bn' Q ) E & 2IgD ) * ' L+QLQ ) * IL KQE+L]I0QdL* ` *E s Bn' DFL:L* B R*L*L D )Bn' Q ) ESlk ' K,i*L * IEQ ') ` K.* B/' E+* ) E+Q.*(KGL1R* R* 2I'0LI ) S*_SQ.,xE]I ) G(* B IL6SZ,(kR*(GLQdE

S D x `Fr S . $ # sQP h e Z s # s

Page 78: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

! / I ) ,NK*PGJI0, '32DbKOI B/' KOIL+Q.,IEQ ') *,iETD ) Q+ ' LMb* ` Q.K I BB IL]I !dEND ) *g,iQ.M B KQ b GJIEQ ') EiL 2*(,NDFE+Q.K.* V1DQB *LMb*E[S*XGJI0K.G(DK*L[K.* B/' E* ) EQ*(KHS* B/' KOIL+Q.,IEQ ') B IL DFE+Q.K.Q,IEQ ') SD E R* ' L 2*Mb*CS* V I0D,+,SI ) ,TK*(,NGJI0,NS*G@R* ' MZR*EiLQ.*(,UG(K.I0,+,+Q.V!D*(, )bB *(DFE* *(GEQ * *(Mb* ) ET, ' L+EQL f # hUS*PKkmQ ) E1R* 0L]I0K.*,+DFLPK.*[SQ R*(K*(GE+LQV1D*[*E R*GLQL+* SQdL*(GE*Mb* ) E

D x ` r f # h .#

$ # sQP hWe Z s # sS r f # h . & # p

'32D K k ') L*(G ')) I !dE K*jG I0M B I0DQ.KQOI0QdL* & # ` K*jG I0M B R*(K.*(GE+L ' ,iE]IE+Q.V1D*>GL1R*nR* B IL D ) *SQ.,xE+LQ KDFE+Q ') S* G IL*(, D ) QdE1R* S* M*Mb* ,1MZR*E+L+Q.* V1D* K* MbQ.KQ.*(D SQ R*(K*(GE+LQV1D* R*EDSQ R*Y ') ,+Q.SNR*L ') , B ILc**(M B K* D ) * , B l2*L* D ) Q+ ' LMZR*Mb* ) E Bn' KOILQ,1R*(* *EbGJI0KG(DK ') ,8K.* G I0M BS* Bn' KOILQ,IEQ ') * ) E ' DFE B/' Q ) E ` Q ) E1R*LQ.*(DFL ' D **1E1R*LQ*(DFL~"3* G I0M B R*(K.*(GE+L ' ,iE]IE+Q.V1D*-GL1R*nR*B ILoD ) *\, B l2*L* B/' L+EI ) EoD ) *\G IL* Z D ) Q+ ' L+M R*(Mb* ) E L1R* B IL+E+Q.*_* ) * ' K.DMb* * I0DFE

# rZ

QP hWe ZZ Re r Zc hWe p # rZ

QP hWe Zs r Z Rec he ZsI * *(G_D ) * S* ) ,+QE1R*_D ) QE1R* Z r R P Z Re s & ) * ) SNR*(SDQdEgK* Bn' E* ) EQ.*(K

D x ` f Z p 5 h r # f Zh $ . $ t wyx Bp

, ' QdE

D x ` f Z p 5 h r Z@G ' , 5c h e p D x ` f Z p 5 h r Z Re G ' , 5c hWe Zs

F KkmQ ) E1R*LQ.*DFL S* KOI , B l2*L+* ` K.* B/' E* ) EQ*(KG ' L+L+*(, B/') S 2I[D ) G I0M B S* B/' K.ILQ.,IE+Q ') D ) Q+ ' LMc*& D x ` r OR ? ` I0K ' L+,UV!Dlk 2I Kk **FE1R*LQ.*DFL QKI D ) *o** B L*(,+,iQ ') SQ B/' K.I0QL*cR*(V!DQI0K.* ) E* 2I G(*(K.K* SlkmD )SQ B ' K* G ' L+L*(, Bn') SI ) E I0D M ' Mb* ) E SQ Bn' KOI0QdL*[E ' E]I0K r R P Z Re

! #"%$ &(')+*-, . ' /0)1'2 34& *-5 26 #"6728$ 2 392 : )1&<;=;

X?>&! -56 '&90 ( !$# '&# % 68*:#&2 !$#&#.*,9;9;*@ ) G ') ,+QS 2*L*YD ) MbQK.Q.*D SI ) ,\K*(V1D*(KUQ.KBA I Q ) 0IL+QOI ) G(* B IL E+L]I ) ,+K.IEQ ')jB IL]I0K.K 2*(K.*(Mc* ) E

2I S*(DDC$SQL*(GEQ ') ,6SI ) , K km*(, B I0G(* ` S* , ' L+E* V!D* K.*(, B L '0B LQ R*EFR*(, BFE AF,+QV1D*(, ) * B *(D * ) ESNR* B * ) SFL* V1D* SlkmD ) *>,+*DK.* G '!' LS ')) R*(* ` )' E1R** ` B IL-*C*(M B K*6KOI S* ) ,+QE1R*>S* G E ILHG*(, `I f lhJN-1Q Kk ') I BB KQ.V1D*PI0K ' L, K.* E E R* ' L 2*(Mc*PS*K[I0D,+, 2I_D ) R*K R*(Mb* ) ENS*L ' K.DMc*oQ )b) QE1R*(,iQ.MYI0K* ) G '!' LS ')) R*(*(, GJIL+E1R*,+Q.* )) *, ` ') ' KEQ.* ) E-D ) * R*(V1DIE+Q ') SQ R*L* ) EQ*(K.K*6E+L 2*(,YQM B/' L+EI ) E*G ')) D*\, ' D,oK.* )' M S* B L*(MbQ 2*L* R*(V1DIEQ ') S*8M INCO*(KKPJ@ ) G E' Q.,+QdE=KQ.* ) R*FQS*(MbMb* ) EXS* L*(, B *(GE+*LYKOIj,QAFMZR*E+LQ.* SD B L ' KK 2*(Mb* *E Bn' DFLbG(*(K.I

') G ') ,+Q.S 2*L+* D ) R*(K R*(Mb* ) E S*R ' K.DMb* S*ZK ') GD*(DFL S. KQ.MbQdEFR* B IL S*DDC ,+DFLTS I0G(*(, IB *L B * ) SQG(DKOI0QdL*(, 2IVUL ` S r I8SWJ"3*8XDDC R*(K R*Mb* ) E]I0QL*[SD G E I0M B R*(K*(GE+L+Q.V1D* 2I8E+LIY *L+,K.*,oS*(DDC!S I0G(*(,P* ) EiL]I ) E+*_*Eo, ' L+E]I ) E*60I0DFE

S[Z r Z f Slh\]Z f /h r f_^ f S/h=\ ^ f lhihI`

Page 79: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

! ) DFEQ.KQ.,I ) EoK.*[STR* *(K '0BB *(Mb* ) EgS*@I AFK ' LoI0D B L*(MbQ*L ' L+S*L

f Slh r f /h S S S U f S s h p

') IXS ') G S[Z r I zz S r # I f lh ICS ` Slk '32D K kR*(V!DIEQ ') SQ R*L* ) EQ.*K.K.* G E *LG E R*(* `S ^ f /hS r I f /hh e p

V1DQ G ') ,iEQdED*gK.I B L*(MbQ 2*L* R*(V!DIEQ ') S*MjINCDO*(KKPJ NK.K*PG ') ,xEQED* K.I+S ' LMCDKOIE+Q ') K ' GJI0K*PSDE E R* ' L 2*(Mb*[S* K I0D,i,P*E ' D*_D ) LH' K.* E+L 2*(,oQ.M Bn' L+E]I ) E * ) R*(K.*GE+L ' MYI G ) R*EQ.,+Mc* J@ ) B *(DFEgI BB KQ.V!D*L G(*E+E*[*C B L*(,+,+Q ') I0D GJI0K.G(DKlSD G E I0M B R*K.*(GEiLQ.V!D* I0D ' Q.,+Q ) I G* S*KOI>,+DFLHS I0G* SlkmD ) G ') SDGE*DFL J ' D,8I ') ,11D V1D*-SI ) ,8D ) G ') SDGE+*(DFL 2I KkR*V1DQ.KQ KL*-K.IS* ) ,+QdE1R* ' K.DMbQV1D*\S*CG E ILHG*(,[*(,iE ) DK.K.*C*E[V!D*XK*(, G E ILHG*(,[,+*LFR* B IL+EQ,+,+* ) E D ) Q.V1D*Mb* ) E* ) ,+DFLHS I0G(* J5Y*(KOI G ') ,iEQdED* D ) * FQ,+Q ') MYI0GL ' ,iG '0B Q.V!D* V!DQ ) * B *(DFEc* ) I0DG(D ) GJI0, *E+L+*LQG ' DFL*(D,+*(Mc* ) ETG ' L+L*(GE*PK ' L,+V1D*oKk ') ,(kmQ ) E1R*L*(,+,i* 2I_S*(,8R*G E *K.K.*, B K.D, B *EQdE*(, ` )' E]I0MbMb* ) E2I KkR*(G E *(K.K* MbQ.GL ' ,+G '0B QV1D* '2D K*(,YSQ.,iEiLQ KDFEQ ') ,YS* G E ILHG*(,YSNR* B * ) S* ) E S* K.I ,iE+LDGE+DFL*IE ' MbQV1D* J D ) *-R*(G E *(K.K*oQ ) E+*LMZR*(SQ.I0QL* f Gkm*(,iE 2IH SQdL* E ' DFEUS*PM*(Mc*,+D*b,I0McMb* ) EBG0L]I ) S*B/' DFLc* I0G*LYKOIj,iE+LDGE+DFL* IE ' MbQV1D*&h ') M ' SNR*(KQ.,+* KOI SQ.,iE+L+Q KDFEQ ') S*6G E ILHG*(, B ILcD ) *S* ) ,+QdE1R*8 ' KDMbQ.V!D* V1DQlE* ) S LI B Q.S*(Mb* ) E *L, 2I8K kmQ ) E1R*LQ.*(DFLoSD! ' KDMb* SD G ') SDGE*(DFL J@ )cB ILK.*oS*PK.I G E ILHG*PSlk *(, B I0G(*PSDbG ') SDGE*DFL J I ) ,NK*oG(I0,NSlkmD ) G ') SDGE*(DFLT,+*(MbQ Q )b) Qf V!DQ ' G(GD B *CE ' DFE[K.*CS*(MbQ *(, B I0G* a B IL[*CF*(M B K.*Jh ` ')>B *(DFE DFEQ.KQ.,+*L D ) *8S* ) ,iQE1R*XS*KOI1S ' LMb*

I f /h r I e * 4 "Uk I BB K.QGJIEQ ') S* KOI B L*(MbQ 2*L* R*(V!DIEQ ') S* M INCDO*(K.K G ') SDQE Q.MbMZR*(SQOIE*Mb* ) E 2IKk *C B L+*(,+,+Q ') SD6G E I0M B f r ^ f /h h

^ f lh r * G ') ,iE G ') ,iE 4

"3*NG E I0M B S*I ) E>*E+L* ) DK!K ' Q ) SI ) ,=K.*- ' KDMb*:SD\G ') SDGE+*(DFL f \C h ` ') I G ') ,iE r *EHK.IPG ') EQ ) DQE1R** ) f Q.K ) k A_I B I0,HS*TS* ) ,+QdE1R*,+DFLHS I0GQ.V1D*S*G E ILHG*,]huQ.M Bn' ,+*NG ') ,iE r J"!$# *:# *:-0X9 20 ( !$#.2 I ) ,TD )YB L ' KK 2*(Mb* '2DYK kmQ ) ILQOI ) G* B ILTE+LI ) ,+KOIEQ ')b) *g,+*L]I0QE B I0,I0,+,+DFL1R** ` ') GuR* ) R*LI0K.Q.,i*G(*[LFR*(,+DKdE]IE Bn' DFL ' KE+* ) QL

S ^ f hS

S ^&%f hS('

S ^ f hS*) + SQ Xf h r I f hh e `

"Uk '0B R*L]IE+*(DFL SQ *(,iE D ) '0B R*L]IE*DFL *GE ' LQ*(KgI GQ,+,I ) E ,iDFL D ) G E I0M B S*< *(GE*(DFL Bn' DFLS ')) *L D ) G E I0M B ,+GJI0K.I0QL* JG-FIS ' LMb*6SNR* B * ) S:KQ.* ) * ) E* ) SD SD G E' Q C S* ,QA1,iE 2*(Mb* S*G '!' LS ')) R*(*(, J IL *C*(M B K.*jIY *(G D ) ,QA1,iE 2*(Mc* S*jG '1' L+S ')) R*(*(, , BFE R*LQ.V!D*(,6*E B/' DFL D )B L ' KK 2*(Mb* 2I8,QA1M R*E+LQ* , BFE R*LQV1D* ` ') I

SQ ^ f Zh t r &Z s SS Z f Z s ^ f Z0h+h r I f hh e p

V1D*YK k ') B/' DFLiL]I0QE )' E]I0McMb* ) EI BB K.QV1D*L8I0D GJI0KG(DKTSD G E I0M B R*(K*(GE+L+Q.V1D*YGLFR* R* B ILCD ) *, BFEl2*L+*\D ) Q S ' LMZR*(Mb* ) EPG E ILHGuR**_* ) ' KDMb* J

Page 80: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

! / < '.0 ( !$# %.* ! 22!$#"uI B L+*(MbQ 2*L* R*(V!DIEQ ') S*<M INCOT*(K.K ` SQ Xf h r

` G ' D B K R** 2I KOI L*(K.IEQ ') G E I0M B B/' E+* ) E+Q.*(K ` Xf h r \ f h ` G ') SDQE 2I\D ) * *C B L*(,i,+Q ') K.Q.I ) EK* B/' E+* ) E+Q.*(K 2I\K.I\S* ) ,+QdEFR*S*_G E ILHG*, ` G ')) D*\, ' D,PK.* )' M SlkR*(V!DIEQ ') S* ' Q,+, ')

SQ -f h + Yf h r \ I f hhWe `

"Uk '0B R*L]IE+*(DFL ,(kmI BB *(KK.*[KOI B KOI0GQ.* ) *EP* ) G '1' LS ')) R**(,PGJILiEFR*(,+Q* )) *(,gQK3,kR*(GL+QE

Yf p ' p ) h r s s

s ' s

s ) s p

I0K ' L+,oV!Dlkm* ) ,QAFMZR*E+LQ.* , BFE R*LQ.V!D*\Q.Kl,(kR*(GLQdE

Yf Zh r &Z s SS Z $ Z s S -f ZhS Z ( `

Y*E '0B R*L]IE*(DFL ' D*_D ) LE' K*[EiL 2*(,PQM B/' LiE]I ) E * ) BFE A1,+Q.V!D* J< &<" )1.V* 2+'2 / *B"%,!& 2

CX !C%! *,9*=%.* /-5'&%&* %.* 90#" !$#&%&'$" (&%(')%($** **:9;*+")(-,% < '.* I ) ,-K.* GJI0,-SlkmD ) G ') SDGE*(DFL )') Q., ' K R* ` G0k *(,iE 2IH SQdL*j* ) G ') E]I0GE IY *G K*(, R*(K R*(Mc* ) E+,SlkmD ) G(QdLG(DQdE R*(K.*(GE+LQ.V!D* G ' M Bn' L+E]I ) EYI0D M ' Q ) ,cD ) GuR* ) R*L]IE*(DFL ` Q.K ) * B *(DFE B I0,A I ' QLSlk I0GG(DMCDKOIEQ ') S*TG E ILHG*(,u,+DFLHK.*,u,+DFLHS I0G*(,HSD\G ') SDGE+*(DFL:GJIL@G*(K.K*(, GQ1, ') E_R*I0G(DNR*(*(, B ILK.*[G(QdLG(DQE J GKlL 2* G ) *\I0K ' L, D ) G E I0M B R*K.*(GEiLQ.V!D* )') ) DK3SI ) ,gK.*[G ') SDGE*DFL ` L*, B/') ,IMKK*SD6M ' D *Mb* ) EoS*,PG E ILHG*(,oK.Q KL+*(, J ' E ') ,.-jK.IjG E ILHG*6S*, B/' L+E+*(DFL,cKQ KL*, f ,+D BBn' ,1R*(*(, Bn' ,+QE+Q *(, ` GJILcK.*(,8G ') * ) EQ ') ,L*(K.IEQ *,I0DYG ' DFL]I ) EYR*(K.*GE+LQV1D* ') EYR*E1R* R*KOIMK ' L1R*(*(, I 0I ) EKOI\SNR*G ' D *L+E* S* K kR*(K*(GE+L ') hJ )

B L1R*(,i* ) G(*\Slk D ) G E I0M B ` KkR*(V1DIEQ ') S ') SI0Mc* ) EI0K.*[S*_KOIXSA ) I0MbQV1D* ,(kR*(GLQdE/ r -

*EU,(k Q ) E 2* G0L* * ) f ') G E' Q.,iQEUD ) *PG ') SQdEQ ') Q ) QdEQOI0K*TE*(KK.* V1D* KOI FQdE*(,+,i*o, ' QdE ) DKK.* 2I K kmQ ) ,xE]I ) E0 r '32D Kk ') KL]I ) G E *\K* G E I0M B R*(K.*GE+LQV1D*&h

1 f 0 h r - / 0 `

Y*E+E* , ' K.DFE+Q ') G ') SDQL]I0QdE 2I[D ) I0G(GL ' Q.,+,i*(Mb* ) ETQK.K.QMbQE1R* f * ) Kk IMK,i* ) G(*PSlk *2/*E,UL+*(KOIEQ FQ,iE*(,]hS*cK.I 1QE*,+,+* ` MYI0Q,[* ) I0DG(D ) GJI0, 2I K.I ,IE+DFL]IEQ ') ' K,+*LQ R*(*8*C B R*L+Q.Mb* ) E]I0K*(Mb* ) E J"GKBS I0DFES ') GQ ) E+L ' SDQL*D ) * S ' LG*S* SOL ' E+E*(Mc* ) E *32/*(GE+Q *54 B/' DFL L* ) SFL*CG ' M B E*\S*,[G ' K.K.Q,+Q ') ,S*(,oG E ILTG*(,PKQ KL*(,o,+DFLgK*(, Q.M B DFL*EFR*(, SD L1R*(,+*(I0D GLQ.,xE]I0K.KQ )

4 r \ / 1 `

Page 81: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

!

q

vdt

dS

8- z !#"$% &' (*),+.- /0%"+ /+ 1324.,"5 ' 6dz7,+.05.0528 z79:;249'+< 5 ;.+.0=>9' ? @.*) &' @;24505.0528Nw&z ;)' 55 AB05+ 24 2$05=>9 8C2 0 ,+/9' #DE2+<; &' FDE+.2.. G U$905 8HI * B IL]I0M 2*E+L* ` Q ) E+L ' SDQdE QG(Q B/' DFLZS*(, L]I0Q, ') , SQMb* ) ,+Q ')) *(K.K*(, ` *(,iE KOI SDFL1R*(*

GJIL]I0GEFR*LQ,iEQ.V!D*>,1R* B IL]I ) E S*(DDC G E' G(, G ') ,!R*(G(DFE+Q S , J I kR*(V!DIEQ ') SD M ' D *(Mb* ) E-S*FQ* ) EG(*EiE*+S ' Q,S 1S 0 & 1 r -

/p

*EoKOIX, ' K.DFEQ ') ,(kR*(GLQdEJ p.KML1 f 0 h r -

/N & \ * ,PO MRQ `

Y*E+E* *C B L*(,+,+Q ') G ') SDQdE 2ICD ) *_,+IEDFL]IEQ ') E+L 2*(,L]I B Q.S* ` I0DK ' DFE SlkmD ) * SDFL1R*(*[S* K k ' LSFL+*S*gV!D*(K.V!D*(, S ' Q,TKOI 0I0K*(DFLS* ` *(KK.*8SMUT*(Mb* Q ) SR*L+Q.*(DFL* 2I KOI B QG ' ,+*(G ') S* ` S*g, ' LiE*PV!D*gKk ')B *DFE G ') ,+Q.SNR*L*L[SI ) , KOI B KD B IL+E S*(, ,+QdEDIEQ ') , G ') GL 2*E*,[V!DlkmD ) L1R*GQ.Mb* B *LMYI ) * ) E *(,xEQ.McM R*(SQOIE+*(Mb* ) E IE+E*(Q ) E '2D6K*(, B/' L+E*DFL, ') EPD ) *8FQE+*(,+,+* f S*_SNR*LQ * ' D6Slkm* ) E+LITV ) *(Mb* ) E h1 z$W]:_YX Z/]:r -

/ ` f cJ c hI I V!DI ) EQdE1R*\[ z$W]y_YX Z/] L* B LFR*(,+* ) E* S ') G K.I SQ,iE]I ) G(* M ' A * )) * * ) EiL* S*DDC G ' K.K.Q,+Q ') ,,+DG(G*(,+,+Q *(, f * ) G ' L*PI BB *(K R**PK.QKL* B ILG ' DFL,UM ' A * ) hJ,Y*E+E* SQ.,iEI ) G(* ` S*PK k ' LSFL* S*:] _^ `*(,iE@KOILHG*(Mc* ) Eu,+D B R*LQ*(DFL* 2IgKOIoSQ.,iE]I ) G** ) EiL*S*(DDCCQ ') ,@SD\L1R*(,+*(I0DXGLQ.,iEI0K.K.Q ) f S*K k ' LSFL* S*c`^[h ` G*PV1DQ B L ' D *oV1D*oK.*(, G ' K.KQ.,+Q ') , S*(, B/' L+E+*(DFL,NS*oG E ILHG*(, ') ETKQ.*(D8,+DFLTK*(,NQM B DFL*E1R*,SDZL+*(,+*JI0D *E B I0,X,+DFL8K.*(,XQ ') ,J @ ) * ) SNR*(SDQdEc* )ZB IL+EQG(DK.Q*LXV1D* KOI>G ') SDGEQ FQdEFR*-SlkmD )MZR*EI0Kl,(k I0MZR*K.Q ' L+* IY *(G ,I B DFL+*E1R* JI km* ) ,i*(M8KK.* S*(, G E ILTG*(, I ) Q.MZR*(*, SlkmD ) M ' D *(Mb* ) E S* FQdE*(,+,i* Slk * ) E+L]ITV ) *Mb* ) EM ' A * )) * 1 z3W]y_aX Z/] S ')) * ) I0Q.,+,I ) G* 2I8D ) G ' DFL]I ) E R*(K*(GE+LQV1D* J @ )6)' E*

b r I 1 z$W]:_YX Z/] f cJ] hKOI S* ) ,+QE1R*bS*cG ' DFLI ) E fe c f r k , s l ,d n ` I r - R*E]I ) E\K.I S* ) ,+QdE1R*V ' KDMbQ.V!D*XS*cG E ILTG*(,K.QKL*(, ,+Q *(,iE[K.* )' M8KL*XS* Bn' L+E*(DFL+, S*XG E ILHG*(, B IL_D ) QdEFR*CS*1 ' KDMb*&hJ @ ) SNR*SDQE[S*J p.KML Q 289'+e+ 1249'+. &9' =>9.05280 S +. <0% % #0 05+ G v f 28gG &"+ 4C>28h+ 2> w #24BG F.905 2ij28k+ 289lf9k+. !0% +f. G$Adz =>9,<0528l.#1 ;24lG !&"+. 8Cnmom4pq 6rtsgu 9'Cwvax uys z$| 2805m4oo u ?Um8pr 2 s 68va~ | u ;24 .8 &h 4 p r Cij905(28h*) +<*)' f9' # 289'<0%24g$,+..0950w + 6' #z =>9,<0%24g;2Gw 4C'050R$,+ x%' !G5 F9 #12459.05280 3 8 #9h. G$;C sFu_ r Ci5? 289'<0%24624dw . P*) +<*) 152+<( 24BG @' s 68va~ | ' s t2805.,<01DY80%+. 5 ;240%<0%249&%00%. /9+.2"w !G 8CFw v 2805+ s va~ u 9 | u 989nG24 e2 w9ndz 28n"+<*) F5 &*)8GhH

Page 82: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

! / G(*EiE* *C B L*(,i,+Q ') D ) *[L*(K.IEQ ') * ) E+L*[S* ) ,+QE1R*_S*[G ' DFL]I ) Eg*EoG E I0M B R*(K*(GE+L+Q.V1D*[I BB *(K R*(* K ' QSlk @ E M K ' G(I0K.* `

b r p r - s / ` f cJh

I kmQ ) E* ) ,+QE1R* SD G ' DFL]I ) E-R*K.*(GEiLQ.V!D*gE+L]I *L,I ) E D ) * ,+DFLTS I0G(* I S ')) R*(*[*(,iE Mb*(,+DFL1R*(* B ILK.* )' M8KL* S* KQ G ) *(, S* G ' DFLI ) E E+L]I *L,+I ) E I ` ' D-* ) G ' L+* B IL K.I\G E ILTG* E ' E]I0K.*PEiL]IY *L,I ) EI B ILoD ) QE1R* S* E*(M B ,4J pp<L J M IE E R*(MYIEQV1D*(Mc* ) E ') K km*C B LQ.Mc* B ILgKOIL*(K.IEQ ')

r S&-S 0 r

#bSB` f cJ h

,(k *C B LQMb* * ) I0M B2*L*(, f [h *EPK k ') I e f r l ,d n J @ ) *C B LQ.Mc*>R* G I0K*(Mb* ) E c * ) J M , s JI *PM ' S 2*(K.* S* LDS* R* ' V!DTR* B KD, E I0DFEN*(,iEUE+L 2*(,ULDSQ.Mb* ) E]I0QdL* ` MYI0Q,UQK,(k I BB KQ.V!D*oE+L 2*,KQ.* ) I0DDC G ') SDGE*DFL, ` * ) B IL+EQG(DK.Q*L-I0DDC M R*E]I0DDC J * MYI ) Q 2*L* EiL 2*(,GuR* ) R*L]I0K.* ` MUT*(Mb*,+Q Kk ') ) * SQ, B/' ,i* B I0, SlkmD ) M ' S 2*K.* McQ.GL ' ,iG '0B Q.V!D* S* G ') SDGEQ ') R*(K.*(GE+LQ.V!D* ` K.I K ' QSlk @ E M K ' GJI0K.*Y*(,xEXEiL 2*(, ) IEDFL*(KK.* J ) *2/*E ` B K.D,XKOI6E* ) ,+Q ') QM B/' ,!R*(* B ILXK.* G@R* ) R*L]IE+*(DFL*(,iE\Q.M Bn' L+E]I ) E* ` B K.D,\K*bG E I0M B SI ) ,\K*bG ') SDGE*DFLC*(,iE R*(K* R*c*E\S ') G B KD,\K.*(,_G E ILTG*(,K.QKL*(, ,+* SNR* B K.I0G(* ) EoL]I B QS*(Mb* ) E J I IXS* ) ,+QE1R*[S* G ' DFL]I ) E(b_I0D GMb* ) E* S ') G[I *(G K.* G E I0M B J D*(K.K*CV1D*, ' QdE KOIbL*(K.IEQ ') f R*GLQE+*XQG(Qu* ) E+L+*XK*(, M ' SDK*(, S*(, *(GE+*(DFL, , ' D, KOI S ' LMb*c r f ^ h+h * ) EiL* G(*(, S*(DDC V1DI ) EQE1R*, ` ') B *(DFE KOI$KQ ) R*JIL+Q.,+*L I0DDC G E I0M B ,4S I0QKK.*(, c r f h ^ f h ` ` ` J$Y ' MbMb*_K*CG ' DFL]I ) E *,iE ) DKH* ) KkmIMK,+* ) G(*XS*CG E I0M B ` f h r *E8Kk ') Q ) E+L ' SDQE8D ) * G ') ,iE]I ) E* ` KOI>G ') SDGEQ FQdEFR* R*(K*(GE+L+Q.V1D* $r f ^ h_V!DQ G ') SDQE 2I)' D *JI0D 2I\K.I_K ' Q Slk @ E M K ' GJI0K* ` R*LQ b R*(* I *(GgD ) * G0L]I ) S* B L1R*(G(Q.,iQ ') SI ) ,TK*(,I BB K.QGJIEQ ') ,G ' DFL]I ) E*(, b r J I I G ') SDGEQ FQdEFR*-I B/' DFLXSQ.Mb* ) ,+Q ') , f * ) DFE+Q.K.Q,I ) ECK.*(,SQMb* ) ,+Q ') ,e ^ f r i k l , s n ,(d *E e c f r k , s l ,(d n h e f r i ,d k , lNn s ` *(K.K*_,(k *C B LQMb*_* ) JmM ,d f ,iQ.*(Mb* ) ,B ILoM 2*E+L*JhJ[I ) ,gK*(,gMZR*EI0DDC ` KOIcG ') SDGEQ1QE1R*_*(,iEgS*_Kk ' SFL*\S* 6r & 2I & J M ,(d ` K.IcS* ) ,+QdEFR*S* Bn' L+E*(DFL,S*cG E ILTG*(, f R*(K*(GE+L ') ,]h S*YKk ' LSFL*8S*bS* r ' DJ & s iM , ` K.*XE*(M B , S*G ' KK.Q.,iQ ') r 2I cJ & ,(d , *EoK.*[K.QKL* B ILG ' DFL,PM ' A * ) S* K k ' LSFL*[S*k] ^ JC"! ! ( %;! # %.*=- **:2&%2 (+01#$" *Y ') ,+QSTR*L ') ,XD ) G ') SDGE*(DFLXGA1K.Q ) SFL+Q.V1D*YS*-,+*GEQ ') I ` S*-K ') GD*(DFL ` , ' DMbQ, 2I D ) *E* ) ,iQ ') [ r d \ s J @ ) )' E* U KkmINC*>SD G ') SDGE*(DFL ` K.*>G E I0M B R*(K*(GE+L+Q.V1D* I0DFE r ^ *EoK* B/' E* ) EQ*(KgR*(K.*GE+L ' ,iEIEQ.V!D* 2IXK kmQ ) E1R*L+Q.*(DFL I0DFE f lh r \"! ^ S[ r d \ ^ ,+QTK k ') Q.M B/' ,+* Yf h r d J I I SS B *(,xEL*(K.Q R*(* 2I Kk I0M B K.QE+DS*bSDZG E I0M B GJIL Yf h r sQ.M B/' ,+* [ r ^ JI kmQ ) E* ) ,+QE1R*\EiL]IY *L,I ) E K.* G(QLGDQE I0DFE r z$#z O r c I r% ^ I%J ) G ' M B IL]I ) E [ *E `') SNR* b) QdEHD ) G ' *'&bG(Q* ) E=G@R* ' MZR*EiLQ.V!D* GJILI0GE1R*LQ,iEQV1D*NSD_G ') SDGE*(DFL:*EHI BB *K R*NL1R*,+Q.,iEI ) G(*R*(K*(GE+LQV1D*

^ r [ r

I ` f cJ(hY*PL1R*(,+DKdE]IE ) k *(,iEG ' LiL*(GEV!D* SI ) ,TKOI?GuR* ' M R*E+LQ*oGAFK.Q ) SFLQ.V!D* J @ ) I BB *K.K.* R*G I0K.*(Mb* ) E ,dKOICL1R*(,+Q,iEQ FQE1R*$J p*)ML *E + r ^ ,d K.I8G ') SDGEI ) G(* JJ pp<L Q 249'+A9+.2"w !G gw 9 0G 0528 C283 9A2. +-, u m m4p C#. u/ 0 0 u W s z$W]y_YX Z/] $~*C1240%, u1/s z$W]y_YX Z/] W u32 W HJ p4)ML65 5 6 ?DY+ =>9' !BG ('28 / C 805A289fz v 05. +.28?00t +.805 28 9+<05.=>9' ' G28'Da9.0%24k v #' .05 v 289B05=>9 8H Q 289'+&% #g| !G A+.805 28;C'249# z G$%240% +.28F&5n'2<,<0528 289+.8 Y 3289+#289.0 v 05 ow 89 #' #B 05 6 9+ Da05=>9 #' #;),+.- H

Page 83: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

!C **A2&%;2 (+01# " * %.*K'$%(+*[I ) ,HK.*TGJI0,HS*,HMbQ.KQ.*(DDC_Q., ' K.I ) E+, ` QK1*CFQ.,iE* E ' D ' DFL,:D ) *%S I0Q KK*G ') SDGEQ FQE1R* ` L*, B/') ,IMKK*B IL\*C*(M B K*cSD MZR*(GJI ) Q.,iMb*8S*cSTR*(G E ILHG*bS*(,\G ') S* ) ,IE*(DFL+,GJIL\K*cMbQK.Q.*D SQ R*K.*(GEiLQ.V!D** ) E+L* K.*(,ZILMYIEDFL+*(, ) k *(,iE iI0MYI0Q., B ILHS I0QdE*(Mb* ) EZQ., ' K.I ) E J GK-*(,iEZGJIL]I0GEFR*LQ,1R* B ILZD ) *S I0Q KK* G ') SDGEQ1QE1R* V!DQ B *LMc*E D ) G ' DFL]I ) E S*4S DQE+* SNR*(G E ILHG*JI ) E K* G ') S* ) ,+IE*(DFLf M ' STR*(K.Q,!R*c* ) R*K.*(GEiL ' G(Q ) R*EQV1D* B ILK k I0,+, ' G(Q.IEQ ') B ILI0K.K 2*K.*cSlk D ) *YGJI B I0G(QdEFR* B ILHS I0QE+*YIY *GD ) *TL1R*(,iQ.,iE]I ) G*TS*%S DQE*N^0hJ I *TGJI0K.GDK1S*TK.IPLFR*(,+Q,iE]I ) G(*TS* S DQE*,+*NSTR*(SDQEHS*K.IPK ' Q Slk @ E M J[I ) ,PK km*CF*(M B K.* SD6G ') S* ) ,IE*(DFLg, BFE R*LQV1D* ` ') I

r b3S r S r h e r [h e, ' QdE

^ r [ r hWe r &] ^ s \ ^ d^ d ^ s `

A I ) EQ ) E+L ' SDQES*DDC D ) QE1R*,,+D BB K R*(Mc* ) EI0QL*(, ` K.*(, ' E Mc, f h ` D ) QdE1R*(,S*bL1R*,+Q.,iEI ) G(*R*(K*(GE+LQV1D* f ^\h ` & r i k s l ,d n , s ` *E K.*,4S IL]I0S, ` D ) QE1R*(, S* G(I B I0G(QE1R* f h ` & * ri ,(d k , s l s n s ` ') I8* ) B ILiEQ.G(DKQ.*L e ^ f r e(hWe f r l JCC ** % 68*A2 ' 0 -,%0 9;*A2 D BB/' , ') ,YV!D* KOI>E* ) ,+Q ') I BB K.QV1DNR*(* 2I D ) R*(K R*(Mb* ) EcS* G(QL+G(DQEc, ' QE10IL+QOIMKK.* SI ) ,cK*E*(M B , f B IL *C*M B K.*\,iQ ) D, ' V.SI0K* ` [ f 0 h+hJ Q@K.*, ILQ.IEQ ') ,PE+*(M B/' L+*(K.K*(, ) *C, ') E B I0,gEiL '0BL]I B QS*(, ` ')ZB *(DFEXDFEQ.KQ.,+*L8KkmI BB L ' CQ.MbIEQ ') S*(,CL1R* GQMb*(,CV1DI0,iQYS B *LMYI ) * ) E,X* ) *L+ED S*

KOI0V!D*(K.K*_K*(,oL*KOIEQ ') , R*E]IMKKQ.*(, B L1R*(G R*S*(MbMb* ) E * ) E+L* E* ) ,+Q ') ` G ' DFLI ) E ' D G E ILTG* ` L*,iE* ) EI0KOIMKK.*,_* ) E+L*G0LI ) S*(DFL,Q ) ,xE]I ) EI ) R*(*(, J Q K*c,+QG ) I0KNI BB KQ.V1DNR* f E* ) ,iQ ') h[*,iE B R*L+Q ' SQV1D* `') B *DFE-STR* b) QL-,I4SOL1R*(V1D* ) G* *EYG ' M B IL*LYG(*(KK.*8SG(Q 2I D ) BFE R* )' M 2* ) * B R*LQ ' SQ.V!D*6S*L1R* SR*L* ) G(*8* ) R*(K*(GE+L ' MYI G ) R*EQ,+Mb* ` G0km*(,xES 2ISSQL*XKOI-K.DMbQ 2*L* J K.I-M T*(Mb* SOL1R*(V!D* ) G(* Bn' DFLKOI KDMbQ 2*L* ` G ' L+L*(, Bn') S D ) * K ') GD*(DFL Slk ') S* r 5V!DQ\GJIL]I0GEFR*LQ,+* KkR*(G E *(K.K* S*(,ILQOIEQ ') ,C, B IEQOI0K*(,XS*(, BFE R* )' M 2* ) *(,cKDMbQ ) *DDC J Q K.* G(QL+G(DQE8*(,iE8S* SQMb* ) ,+Q ') B *EQE+*B ILPLI BB/' L+E 2I ` ') B *DFE G ') ,+QSTR*L*L V!D*\K.*,LI0K.*(DFL,PSD6G E I0M B ` SD Bn' E* ) EQ.*K ` *EG ` , ') ED ) Q S ' L+Mb*(, 2I D ) Q ) ,iEI ) E S ')) R*8,iDFL_K*XGQLG(DQdE[*E[S ') G8V!D*8K k I BB L ' CQMYIEQ ') S*,[L1R*GQ.Mb*(,V1DI0,iQYS B *LMYI ) * ) E, *(,iE I0KOIMKK* J Y k *(,iE K.* GJI0, B/' DFL S*(, SOL1R*(V!D* ) G(*(, xD,+V1Dlk 2IXV!D*(K.V!D*(,LM! JI km*C B L*(,+,iQ ') r" [ B/' DFL8D ) G ') S* ) ,IE*(DFL ` GuR* ) R*LI0K.Q.,!R*(* I0DDC L1R*GQ.Mb*(,?ILQ.IMKK.*(, `S ')) *\I0Q ) ,+Q

f 0 h r# [ f 0 h`Y ' M KQ ) R*(* 2I8KOIXSTR* b) QE+Q ') S*[Kk Q ) E* ) ,+QdEFR*

f 0 h r S f 0 hS 0 p

') ' KE+Q.* ) EgK.ICL*KOIEQ ') S ') GEQ ')) *(K.K*_Slk D ) G ') S* ) ,IE+*(DFL * ) L1R* GQ.Mb*ILQOIMKK* f 0 h r# S [ f 0 h

S 0 ` f cJ h *PM T*Mb* B/' DFLND ) G ') SDGE+*(DFLGA1K.Q ) SFL+Q.V1D* ` K*(,:L*(KOIE+Q ') , [ f 0 h r ^ f 0 h /*E f 0 h r c f 0 hI r ^ f 0 h I * ) E+L]ITV ) * ) EPKOICL*(KOIE+Q ') S ') GEQ ')) *K.K.* S*(,PL1R*,+Q.,iE ' L,

[ f 0 h r ^ f 0 h` f cJ h

Page 84: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

! / ' 2+$ 28.*B; 392 $ ). 2 *B #; *B)+*-,!& 2

@ ) L]I0,+,+*(M8KK* SI ) ,=G(*E+E*U,+*(GEQ ') V!D*(K.V!D*(,LFR*(,+DKdE]IE,3*(,+,+* ) EQ*(K.,@SlkR*(K.*GE+L ' ,iEIEQ.V!D*CR*E+* ) SD,,I ) ,>SNR*(M ') ,xE+L]IEQ ') 2I KOI MYI G ) R*E ' ,xE]IEQ.V!D* J GK\,(k I GQdE ,+*(DK*(Mb* ) E>Slk I ) I0K ' GQ.*(, V!D* Kk ')I0SMb*EiE+L]IC,I ) ,PSNR*(M ') ,iE+L]IEQ ') J ) R*K.*(GEiL ' ,iE]IEQV1D* ` K.*(, , ' DFLG(*(,]S ') SI0Mb* ) E]I0K*(, , ') E K.*(, G E ILHG*, R*K.*(GEiLQ.V!D*(, J )MYI G ) R*E ' ,iE]IEQV1D*G(* , ') ENK*(, G ' DFL]I ) E+,XR*(K*(GE+LQV1D*(,8J p.L ` ' D ` B K.D, B LFR*(G(Q,1R*(Mb* ) E ` K.* XDDCZZSD

G E I0M B MYI G ) R*EQV1D*$J pML J I I G ') ,xE]I ) E+*1S ') SI0Mc* ) EI0K.*CV1DQ@Q ) E+*LTFQ* ) E *,iE[KOI B *L+M R*JIMKQ.KQE1R*MYI G ) R*E+Q.V1D* e ` E*(K.K*_V!D* e e f r i k n s ` e r ] & , ` M ,d ` '2D K* E * ) LQA f [h,+*L]IbSNR* b) QD ) B *(D B K.D,oK ' Q ) JI kR*(K R*(Mb* ) E *,+,+* ) EQ.*K * ) R*(K*(GE+L ' ,xE]IEQ.V!D* Bn' DFL K k I BB K.QGJIEQ ') I0DDC G(QLGDQE, *,iE K*G ') S* ) ,+IE*(DFL JOGxK *,iE G(IL]I0GE1R*L+Q.,!R* B IL K.I GJI B I0GQE1R* J ) MYI G ) R*E ' ,iE]IEQV1D*>K.* G ' M Bn' ,I ) ES* K I0,+* *(,iEbK.I K ' KQ ) *$J pML J GK ,(k I GQdEcSlk D ) b KoG ') SDGE*(DFL B ILG ' DFLD B ILbD ) G ' DFLI ) EY*E* ) L ' DK R*CV1DQ@GL1R*(*cI0D MbQK.Q.*D S*XK km* ) L ' DK.*(Mb* ) E D ) G E I0M B MbI G ) R*EQ.V!D* J*CG E I0M B *,iE K.Q R*I0D G ' DFLI ) EjR*(K.*(GE+LQ.V!D* f QKH*(,iE_Slk I0DFE]I ) E B KD,+S ' L+E V1D*8KkmQ ) E+* ) ,+QE1R*c*(,iEjR*(K.* R*(*&h *E_Q.K:* ) *(,xES* M T*(Mb*YSD XDDCZS* G* G E I0M B J ' MbMb*Y* ) R*K.*(GEiL ' ,iE]IEQV1D* ` ') STR* ) QEcD ) G ' *'&bGQ.* ) ES* B L '0B/' L+E+Q ')) I0K.QdE1R* ` G(*E+E* S ' Q., * ) EiL* XDDC *EZQ ) E* ) ,iQE1R* J* G ' *'&cG(Q.* ) E G@R* ' MZR*E+L+Q.V1D*GJIL]I0GEFR*LQ,iEQ.V!D* *(,xE Kk Q ) SDGE]I ) G* ' D I0DFE ' S Q ) SDGE]I ) G(* ` )' E1R*(*LJ I kmQ ) SDGE]I ) G(* B *LMb*ESlkR*E]IMKK.QdL D ) *CL+*(KOIEQ ') * ) EiL*E* ) ,+Q ') I BB KQ.V!DTR*(*XI0DDC K ' L ) *,[S*CK.I3K ' KQ ) *C*E Q ) E* ) ,+QE1R*CK.IB ILG ' DFLI ) E J *CM T*(Mb*V!Dlkm* ) R*(K*(GE+L ' ,xE]IEQ.V!D*KOIYGJI B I0G(QdE1R*CSlkmD ) G ') S* ) ,IE+*(DFL B *LMb*E Slk *C B L+Q.Mb*L,+QM B K.*(Mc* ) E KkR* ) *LHGQ* R*(K*(GE+L+Q.V1D* *(MbMbI G I0,+Q ) R*(* B IL K.*PG ') S* ) ,IE*(DFL ` * ) MYI G ) R*E ' ,iE]IEQV1D*Kk Q ) SDGEI ) G(* SlkmD ) * K ' KQ ) * B *LMc*E Slk *C B LQMb*L ,+Q.M B K.*(Mb* ) E KkR* ) *LHGQ* MYI G ) R*E+Q.V1D**(MbMbI G I0,+Q ) R*(* B ILoKOI K ' KQ ) * JI *(,\SQ *L,+*(,\I ) I0K ' GQ.*,_, ') E_L]I0,i,+*(M8KK R*(*,\SI ) ,_K*8E]IMKK*JI0D ,+DQ 0I ) E J @ ) L*EQ.* ) SFLI * )

B IL+EQG(DK.Q*LoKOIXL+*(KOIEQ ') S ') GEQ ')) *(KK.* B/' DFLgK* K ' KQ ) * * ) L1R* GQMb*0IL+QOIMKK.* f 0 h r S f 0 h

S 0 f J & h'32DbK kmQ ) SDGE]I ) G(* ` Mb*(,+DFL1R**g* ) E * ) LTA1, f [h ` I0DFE ` SI ) ,TKkmI BB L ' CFQ.MYIE+Q ')X'32DYKk ')c) R* GK.QG*PK.*,*2n*E,PS* K ' LS, `

r e s I

R*E]I ) EK.* )' M KL+*gS* , B QL+*(,TE ' E]I0K ` 3KOI K ') GD*(DFL S* K.IK ' KQ ) * *EOI ,I,+*(GE+Q ') J D Bn' Q ) ES*81D* SQMb* ) ,+Q ')) *(K ` ') I "! r$#&% s(' s J

)*,+- * %-! d"/. 8%28-805 5 ;.+ 241<,<0=>9' 10 -8 .28 ..0=>9' J p<L # wDa9'G'28 +&=>9 z705 z x%05 :99 =>90 v 8% 6B,-8 <0=>9' : 6*),+.- % ;.+<05=>9 H 1 . :," ' ; n=>9 nz 24 ,3 % k% :28'281|24% B,-8 <0=>9' B 1 w dz 2+<05-80' z79 n; +..805 n0 R +<05 n +. % ;.+<050% F /-8 <05<G 4HJ pML 5 % ;.+.28 ..0=>9' 4Ck5 *),+.- 28 -88% !G +. 0 9/U$9J% 9 *)4G 5 ;.+.0=>9' +z 0. +M 005+ #9h<) 2+xw G F NyA89.;HJ pML32 G$%240% &1249 v (5 F. +MG F8'-8054 5D76 3289'+? 05-8 +?9 f"$28"0' 4H

Page 85: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

! ! E ILHG* B/') GE+D*(K.K* * Q.KlQ ) ) Q

q

Er

I r

B

r # t q t r"! $#s t &%' e r d)( d e * ` M ,d e r ] & , `mM ,(d

') S* ) ,IE+*(DFL * ' KQ ) *e

+ -

U

S N

I S

,iDFLHS I0G(*8I ` R* B I0Q.,i,+*(DFL+ ,+*(GEQ ') I ` )' M KL+* S* , B QL*, ^ r , ` r - r ./ ` Z r r 0,0 O ` r 010 O r 0 .0 O ` r 0 #0 O2hW3 ` 34576 X98;: 3 r ds s 2=< a?>)@ W3A5 X98: 3 r ds s

BDC & 28'!& 2 ; .< 1*-, . ; 3FE 2+'2 / *B" /, . 2 *-,!&<2

GXIH #$(-5! % '$")( %!$#@JLKNMPO7QSRTQVU$M&Q7WXQZY[]\ J M_^ `aMXKNMXJbU [ U$Q7cdJIK \ WXWQSJbU$MPe MfOkaMOSMXWUg`$chWXQ7JiaMU$Q7j \ M=MXJL`haM GdQSRTM=O7QSJPaM [ QV`$M J I MXKKNM \ O7KkWXcdRl^cdK [ JUNKkWXcdJ KNQSePaMm`aMXKKNcdJbUe MXKe Q7^ATcdOSMKnaMXOSMXWmUN`$chWQSJPaMU$Q7j \ MXKko - f J MI^ [ KkWXcdJ SAcdJ e`$M[ bMXWpe MXKne QV^ATcdOSMXKqaMXOSMXWmUN`$QSj \ MXK]hrOSQSJPaM [ Q7`$MXKstW0kuMXKgUSmY[ S)e QV`$Mv^Zc \ `nOSMXKNj \ MXOSO7MXKnO [ `$MXO [ U$QScdJqMXJUg`$MQSJbU$MXJ KgQ7UhaM f 0 hwY[ UN` [ bM`NKkOSMIe QV^ATcdOSMwMUkO [ U$MXJ KNQ7cdJ =xzy| 0 hwY[ KNMXK KZc`NJ MXKkMXKgU \ J MwMCh^ `$MXKNKgQScdJe MO [ SAc`$RlM

~ aMXKNQ7KgU [ J WXM xzy 0 h r Z 0 h

cdJ e MXJ K [ U$M \ ` xzy 0 h r & # 0 hhe 0 *cKQSJ M xzy| 0 h r e Z 0 h

e 0 `

M [ U E aMXR [ UNQSj \ MRTMXJbUcdJ^Zc \ `g` [ Q7UWXcdJ KNQ7eiaM`$M`e MXKeiaM`$QfaMXMXKelkc`$e`NM^O \ KaMXO7MfaMszR [ QSKkWXMXO [Jlk [ ^ ^c`NU$M`NQSMXJ^ E AKNQ7j \ MXRlMXJU J GO]MXKgUQ7Rl^Zc`NU [ JUMXJ`$M [ J W E Me MnJlk [ bcdQ7` [\ W \ JU$M`$RTMWXcdJ KgU [ JUJ Q [\ W \ J M^ \ QSKNK [ J WXM e M 0 hms e M Z 0 hc \ e MLOSM \ `$KteiaM`$Q faMXMXKhe Q 2taM`$MJU$Me M & J@kJ \ UNQSOSQ7KNM` [ ^c \ `O [ U$MXJ KNQ7cdJ [\ C KZc`$J MXKelk \ JDe QV^ATcdOSMrO [ J cU [ UNQScdJ xzy 0 hc \ KQ7MXJ 0 hs 0 hkc \ = 0g KNMOScdJpO [ J [ U \ `$Me \ e Q7^ATcdO7M J c \ `OuQSJbU$MXJ KNQVUaMcdJvWXcdJ KNM`TbMm` [ Z 0N

Page 86: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

W [ ` O QSJbU$MXJ KgQ7UhaMpMKgU O [ R TMXRlMvMXJ U$c \ Un^cdQSJbU e \ WXQ7`$W \ Q7U MXJbUN`$M e M \ C ePaMm`$Q [ U$QScdJ K e [ J KO [ ^ ^ `$c C QSR [ U$QScdJ e MXK`aM GdQSRlMXKj \[ KNQYS^ZM`NR [ J MXJbU$KXsWMKgUSY[ S?e Q7`$MDU [ JUj \ MDOSMXKOScdJ G \ M \ `$KezcdJ e MKNcdJU0G` [ J e MXKke M [ JbU|O [ U [ QSO7OSMe \ WXQ7`$W \ Q7U s WXMj \ Q MKgUU$c \ ;c \ `NK0h` [ Q K [\ SKNQVU \[ U$Q7cdJMCWXM^ U$Q7cdJ J MXOSO7M J [ J K OSMXK `$MXO [ U$QScdJ K j \ Q^ `haMXWYMXe MXJbU scdJ [\ U$QSO7QSK aM=O [ WXcdJ bMXJbU$QScdJLe Q7U$M=WXcdJ bMXJbU$QScdJL`aMXWXM^ UNM \ `WXcdJ SAc`$RDaMXRTMXJbUY[ O [ j \ MXOSO7MO Q7JU$MJ KNQ7UhaM e cdJ WOSMW E[ Rl^qaMXOSMWUN`$Q7j \ M WXQ7`NW \ OSMLe [ J KOSMKNMXJ Kte MO [ U$MXJ KNQ7cdJ c \ e Q 2taMm`$MXJ WXMLe ML^ZcUNMXJUNQSMXO ePaMXWm`$cdQSKNK [ JU$M J_U [ JUe cdJ JPaM \ J WXQ7`$W \ Q7U s&O7M^ `$cKOYMXRlMMXKgUezaMU [ KOSQ7`w^ \ Q7Ke Mr`haMXKNc \ e`$M OSMXKvaMj \[ U$Q7cdJ Ke Q 2taM`$MXJbU$Q7MXOSO7MXKj \ Q`haM GdQ7KNKNMXJbU OSMXK [ O7M \ `$Ke MpO Q7JU$MJ KNQ7UhaMve [ J KnOSMXKe QbM`$KgMXK K ` [ J W E MXKe \WXQV`$W \ Q7UIMUwOSMKU$MXJ KNQ7cdJ K [\ C Kc`$J MXKwe MXKwe Q bM`$KIe QV^ATcdOSMXK J@J [ `$MWXc \ `$KI^Zc \ `WMXO [ Y[ e M \ COScdQ7K+SAcdJ e [ RTMJU [ O7MXK [ ^ ^MXOaMXMKwOScdQSKLe MQ7`$W E E c 2 s&O [ OScdQ_e MXKwJ \ e Kj \ Qf^ `haMWXQSKNMj \ MTOSMKQSJbU$MXJ KgQ7UhaMXKre M e M \ C K ` [ J W E MK j \ Q|WXcdJ bM`HGdMXJbU KX [ e e QVU$QScdJ J MXJbU MUrO [ O7cdQe MXKrR [ Q7OSOSMKlj \ QMCh^ `$QSRTM=O7M S [ QVU j \ M_O [ KNcdRTRTMe MXK U$MXJ KgQScdJ K K \ ` \ J M_R [ QSO7OSM O7M=OScdJ G]ez \ J M Kc \ WXOSM_WXcdRl^OYMU$M MXKgU_J \ OSO7M J MXK=OScdQSKePaMWXc \ OSMXJbUfe M S [ WcdJ aMhQSe MXJbU$Me MXK=J cU$QScdJ Ke M K [ KNMezaMOSMXWUg`$cdR [ GdJPaMU$Q7KNRTMj \ MlJ c \ K [ bcdJ KvaMU \ e QaMXMXKJ GO-S [\ UJ cU$Mm`wj \ [\ eiaM^ [ `NUcdJp^ZM \ Uc`$QSMXJbU$M` [ `KQ7UN` [ Q7`$MXRlMXJUOSMK QSJbU$MXJ KNQVUaMXK e MXK e QbM`$KgMXK K ` [ J W E MXKDMmUDO7MW [ OSW \ Ol^ZM`NRTMU MXJ K \ QVU$M e M WXcdJ `$RTM` WMXKc`$Q7MXJU [ U$QScdJ K KNQOSMXK]QSJbU$MXJ KNQVUhaMXK]cK U$MXJ \ MXK]KNcdJU]^ZcdKgQ7U$Q bMXK c \ e MLO7MXKQSJ `$RTMm` KNQZOSMK [ OSM \ `NKKNcdJbU|JPaM G [ UNQbMXK JG"! ** % 68*A2 (+-01#&2 %(+! %;-*:2

I c`$K e M OaMmU [ KOSQ7KNKNMXRTMJU c \ e M OMCU$Q7J WU$QScdJ e \ WXc \ ` [ JbUe [ J K \ J WXQ7`NW \ Q7U st^ZMXJ e [ JbU\ J Me \ `aMXM [ KNKNM K `YMbMszO7MXK G` [ J e M \ `$K^ E AhKNQSj \ MXKLWcdJ J [ QSKNKNMJU \ J M aMbcdO \ U$QScdJU$MRl^Zc`$MOSOSM `haMGdQSRTMkUN` [ J KgQ7U$cdQV`$M [ [ JbU|ez [ UgU$MXQSJ e`NMLO7M \ `$KL [ OSM \ `$KePaMJ QVU$QbMKMXJ`haM GdQSRTMk^M`$R [ J MXJbU JcdJ KNQSePaMm`$cdJ KIY[ UNQ7UN`$MezMCMXRl^OSMkO7M^ `$cKOYMXRTMke MkO [ W E[ `HGdMkez \ J WXcdJ e MJ K [ U$M \ ` WXQV`$W \ QVU J F J Mr`haMXKNQ7KgU [ J WXM MXKgU^O [ W aMXMMXJDK aM`$Q7M [ bMXW \ JWXcdJ e MXJ K [ U$M \ ` J I M WXcdJ e MXJ K [ U$M \ `MXK;UQSJ QVU$Q [ O7MXRTMXJbUJ cdJpW E[ `HG aMs 0 J 0 cdJ K ` [ J W E M \ J4G aMXJPaM` [ U$M \ `IePaMOSQ ` [ JbU\ J MLUNMXJ KNQScdJ "! WcdJ KgU [ JbU$M J @J [ e cdJ W c \ ` 0# 0g 0g$ !

KNcdQVU s [ bMW 0g% 0, O 0 O & 0g s& 0g ,d 0g$ ! `

I [ KNcdO \ U$QScdJG&aMXJiaM` [ O7Me MO aMXj \[ U$QScdJ K [ J KtKNMXWXcdJ enRlMXR8K `$MLMKgUe MLO [ SAc`$RTM d 0g' - M , O )(

c Y\ -wMXKgU \ J MLWcdJ KgU [ JbU$MLezuQSJbUhaM G` [ UNQScdJ J F J MKNcdO \ U$QScdJr^ [ `NU$Q7W \ OSQYM`$Me MLO aMXj \[ U$QScdJrWXcdR^OYMU$MMXKgUe cdJ JiaMXML^ [ `O [ KNcdO \ UNQScdJWcdJ KgU [ JbU$M+* ! ! `

I [ KgcdO \ U$Q7cdJ WcdRl^OYMUNM 0g, d 0g * e cdQVUK [ U$Q7KTS [ Q7`$M Y[ O [ WXcdJ e Q7U$Q7cdJ"QSJ Q7UNQ [ OSM $ - ! s KgcdQ7U 0g% "! & \ M ,PO ( `

@kJ^ZM \ UMXJ K \ QVU$MW [ O7W \ OSMm`O QSJbU$MXJ KgQ7UhaMsO [ U$MXJ KgQScdJ [\ C%KZc`NJ MXKe M MU [\ CKc`$J MXK|e M s 0g$ ! ,(d M ,PO ( !N ,d M ,PO )(

0g% 0g" ! M ,PO )( 0g% 0g ! & \ M ,PO )( `

Page 87: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

-1 0 1 2 3 4 5

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

Q(t

)/C

U0

-1 0 1 2 3 4 5t/τ

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

RI(

t)/U

0

!#"%$'& -)(+* 1 ),+.- 6-,79h28' .,. 9+( 289?9 F. 0528g281<. 4HGO=MXKgUaM G [ OSMRTMXJbULQ7J KgUN` \ WmU$Q SfezM2MXWU \ M` \ J KQSO [ J aMXJ Mm`HG&aMU$Q7j \ M J c \ `LWXMXO [ cdJ`NM^ `$MXJ eOaMXj \[ UNQScdJ QSJ Q7UNQ [ OSMj \ MOucdJ R \ OVU$Q7^O7QSMk^ [ ` 0g e 0 s

Z 0N & 0g" ! ` ` `/. Z 0N e 0 * 0N e 0 & 0N e ! 0g e 0

021! * 0g e 03 465 78 !:9 1 8 ; 3=< ;?>A@CB#D

E 0 1 ! 0N e 3 465 7F; 1 ;$

! 0G1! 0g e 03 465 7

1 !9 1 8 3=< >A@CBEH *!D

EH *! *! `

@kJ WXcdJ K;U [ U$Mkj \ MkO aMXJ Mm`HGdQSMSAc \ `$J Q7Mk^ [ `OSMG aMXJPaM` [ U$M \ `]MXKgUTaMXj \ Q7U [JI O7MXRTMXJbUe Q7KgUN`$Q I\ aMXMMXJUg`$M\ J ML^ [ `gU$QSM \ U$QSO7MTY[ O [ W E[ `HGdMe \ WXcdJ e MXJ K [ U$M \ `kMU \ J ML^ [ `NUNQSMe QSKNKNQV^aMXMe [ J KtO [ `haMXKNQ7KgU [ J WXM J Q OucdJTKXQ7JUhaM`$MXKNKgMY[L\ JWXQV`$W \ QVU K aM`$Q7MsOaMj \[ U$Q7cdJle Q 2taM`$MXJbU$Q7MXOSO7MY[ `haMKNc \ e`$M|MXK;Uie \KNMXWcdJ ee M G`haMsR [ Q7K]O [ RDaMmU E che MezaMU \ e MJzMKgUt^ [ KLSAcdJ e [ RTMXJbU [ OSMRTMXJbUe Q 2taM`$MJU$M J

GLK?MLK *N %PO NRQ2Q %TSVU QXWRY ZT[\ U^] W:_ "*N`Qacbed#b?fgbihjlk=mJn)o prq-k=snXjI M^ [ ` [ G` [ ^ E M^ `haMXW aMe MXJUUN` [ Q7U [ Q7Ue MXK`aM GdQSRlMXKUg` [ J KNQ7UNcdQ7`$MXKj \ Q_KgM^ `$c e \ QSKNMJUwO7c`$Ke MOaMU [JI O7QSKNKNMRTMXJbUlc \ e MOMCU$Q7J WU$QScdJDe \ WXc \ ` [ JbUT^MXJ e [ JU \ J Mne \ `haMXM I ` YM6tbM J \ S)e MXOY[ e Mj \ MOSj \ MK SAcdQSKtO [ t [ OSM \ `e \ U$MXRl^Kte M`$MXO [ C [ U$Q7cdJ U A ^QSj \ MRTMXJbU svu E . E /w K QSOfKXaMmU [JI OSQVU \ J `haM GdQ7RTMl^ZMm`$R [ J MXJbU J I MT`haM GdQ7RTM^M`$R [ J MJUJzuMXKgUI^ [ KwJPaMXWMXKNK [ QV`$MXRTMXJbU \ J`haM GdQ7RTMQSJ ePaMm^ZMXJ e [ JbUne \ U$MXRl^KrWXcdRTRlMnWMKgU OSM W [ K e [ J K O MCMXRl^OSMe \ WXcdJ e MXJ K [ U$M \ `W E[ `HG aMKNc \ K UNMXJ KNQScdJqWXcdJ KgU [ JbU$M JyxO|^ZM \ UKX [ GdQ7` ez \ J `haM GdQ7RTMc Y\ O [ `haMm^ZcdJ KNMe \ WXQV`$W \ QVU Q7JU$MJ KNQ7UhaMI^ [ `MC MXRl^O7M t [ `$QSMIe [ J KO7MIU$MXRl^KkWXcdRlRTMO MCWXQ7U [ UNQScdJ UNMXJ KNQScdJ Q7Rl^ZcdK aMMI^ [ `\ J G aMXJPaMm` [ U$M \ `eiaMXOSQth` [ JbU \ J MU$MXJ KNQ7cdJzt [ `$Q [JI O7M^ [ `tMC MRl^OSM J J W [ KI^ [ `gU$QSW \ O7QYM`NMXRTMXJbUIQ7Rl^Zc`NU [ JUMXKgUwWXMO \ QPe MKI`aM GdQSRlMXKKNQ7J \ Kgc VSe [\ C J I c`$Kgj \ MTO7MWXQV`$W \ Q7UlMXKgUO7QSJPaM [ QV`$Ms [ ^ ` YMXKTO7M`haM GdQ7RTMrUN` [ J KNQVU$cdQ7`$M sfcdJ [ UNUNMXQSJbU \ J`haMGdQSRTMr^ZM`NR [ J MXJbUc Y\OuQSJbU$MXJ KNQVUhaMMU=O [ UNMXJ KNQScdJ [\ C I c`$J MXK=e MXK=e Q 2taM`$MXJbU$K=e Q7^ATcdO7MXK=e [ J K=OSMWXQV`$W \ Q7U|t [ `$Q7MTaM G [ OSMXRlMXJUKNQ7J \ KNc V7e [ OSMXRlMXJUXsfY[ O [ R TMXRlM+S `haMXj \ MXJ WXMj \ MwWXMOSOSMQSRl^cdKhaMXMI^ [ `O [ Kgc \ `$WXM e MIU$MXJ KgQScdJ c \e MWc \ ` [ JU J I uQSJbUaM`>TMUfR [ ;M \ `_e \ `haMGdQSRTMKNQ7J \ KNc V7e [ Osbc \ UN`$MtK [ ^ `haM8S aMXRlQSJ MXJ WXMtQSJ e \ KgUg`$QSMXO7OSMs^ `$ctQ7MXJU=e \ S [ QVUj \ MiU$c \ U&KNQ GdJ [ O^aM`$QSc e QSj \ Mi^ZM \ UBTMUg`$MeiaM6tbMXO7c^ ^aMK \ ` \ J M I [ KNMe MKNQ GdJ [\ CKNQ7J \ KNc V7e [\ C^ [ ` [ J [ OAhKNMe M~ c \ `$QSM` J

Page 88: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

MW E J Q7j \ MXRlMXJUXs|cdJ e cdQ7U`aMXKNc \ e`$M \ J M aMj \[ U$Q7cdJ e Q 2taM`$MXJbU$QSMOSOSM e \ ^ `NMXRTQSMm`nc \ e \KNMXWcdJ ec`$e`$MWcdRl^ `$MXJ [ JbU \ JU$Mm`$RTM cdKNWXQSO7O [ JbUY[ O [ S `haMXj \ MXJ WMe M!SAc` W [ GdMQSRl^cdKhaMXMr^ [ `O [ Kgc \ `$WXM J I [ `haMXKNcdO \ U$QScdJ MXK;U]G` [ J e MXRTMXJbU]S [ WXQ7OSQ7UhaMXMF^ [ ` O [ `NMXW E M`$W E Mez \ J MKNcdO \ U$Q7cdJKNQ7J \ KNc V7e [ OSMe MR TMRTM<S `haMXj \ MXJ WXM JPO \ KgQSM \ `$KrU$MXW E J Q7j \ MXK KNcdJUS `haMXj \ MXRTRTMJU MXRl^O7c AfaMXMXKXsJ cU [ RTRlMXJU \ J MfRDaMU E c e M-G` [ ^ E QSj \ M=`$M^cdK [ JbU K \ ` O [ WXcdJ KgUN` \ WU$QScdJe M ~`$MXKNJ MO j \ QdWXcdJ KNQSK;U$MY[n[ KNKgchWXQ7M` Y[\ J MVSAcdJ WU$QScdJvKNQSJ \ KNc VSe [ O7M 0g WXcdK 0

D \ J tbMXWU$M \ `we MlO7cdJ G \ M \ `CPaMM^ [ `kO [ Rl^OSQVU \ e Mws UNc \ `$J [ JU|e [ J K|OSM^O [ JFY[ O [ tQVU$MXKNKNM [ J G \ O [ Q7`NM MUkePaMm^ E[ KhaMY[Ouc`$Q GdQ7J M 0 r^ [ `` [ ^ ^c`NUY[ O [ CMwe Mw`aM SaM`$MJ WXM ^ [ `MCMXRl^O7MwO [ CM tbM`NU$Q7W [ O e M J I [WXcdJ KgUg` \ WU$Q7cdJKgM S [ Q7UY[t\ JQ7J KgU [ JbU [ ` I QVUN` [ Q7`NMs^ [ `&MC MXR^OSMLY[ 0$ J I Q7JUhaMm`'TMU`haMXKgQSe Mie [ J KO7MS [ Q7Uj \ Me MXKKNcdRTRTMXKMmUe MXKte Q 2taM`NMXJ WXMXK]e M SAcdJ WU$QScdJ KKNQ7J \ Kgc VSe [ OSMKte MR TMXRlM S `haMXj \ MXJ WXMKgM`haMXe \ Q7KNMXJbUY[ e MXK]KNcdRTRTMXKc \ e MXK]e Q 2taMm`$MXJ WXMXKte M tbMWU$M \ `$KJ J M [\ UN`$M [ ^ ^ `$c W E MWXcdJ KNQ7KgU$MY[\ U$Q7OSQSKgM`OSMK&J cdR I `$MXKWXcdRl^O7MC MK J O [ SAcdJ WU$Q7cdJ 0N cdJ [ KNKNchWQSM [ OSc`NK O [ SAcdJ WmU$QScdJWXcdRl^O7MC M 0g$ M % M O J[@kJ `haMXKgc \ eOaMXj \[ UNQScdJre Q 2taM`$MXJbU$QSMOSOSMK [ U$Q7KTS [ Q7UNM^ [ ` 0g shj \ QzKNM`haMXe \ QVUY[\ J MaMXj \[ UNQScdJ [ OG&aM I `$Q7j \ Ms ^ \ QSKgj \ M

e 0ge 0 0g

0 0g e 0% E 0g ^ \ QSKtcdJc I U$Q7MXJbU 0g$ ~ M 0g J

acbed#bRbVs?mJqp s=k m s JDMCMXRl^O7MTUN` YMXKwWXcdJ J \ MKgUWXMXO \ Qez \ J WXQ7`$W \ Q7U K aMm`$QSM [ OSQ7RTMXJbUhaMl^ [ ` \ J MrU$MXJ KNQ7cdJKNQ7J \ KNc V7e [ OSM 0g$ WXcdK 0g J I aMXj \[ UNQScdJ `haM GdQSKNK [ JUtOSMWXQ7`NW \ Q7UMXKgUtO [ K \ Q t [ JU$M s Z 0N3 465 71! O D

e 0ge 03 465 7

1#" O DE 0 Z 0N e 03 465 7

1#$ O 0g `

I [ KNcdO \ U$QScdJ Z 0g MXKgULW E M`$W E aMXMTKgc \ KO [ SAc`$RTM 0g WXcdK % 0 \ J I MXKt [ OSM \ `NKe M ss MU e cdQtbMXJUIeiaMU$M`$RlQSJ M`MXJUNQYM`$MRTMXJbUIOuQSRl^iaMe [ J WXM& MUIOSMlePaMm^ E[ K [ GdMU$MXJ KgQScdJS)Wc \ ` [ JU J3cdRTRlMQSOdKX [ GdQ7U QSWQez \ JWXQV`$W \ QVU K aMm`$QSMsWuMXKgU OuQSJbU$MXJ KNQVUaMfj \ QdMXKgU O [ RUTMXRTMMXJpU$c \ UL^ZcdQ7JU e [ J KIW E[ W \ J e MXKwe Q7^ATcdO7MXK MmUwcdJv^ `haM S)YMm`$MrMXJG&aMXJPaM` [ O"C M` \ J MT`haM SaM`NMXJ WXMe M ^ E[ KgM WXcdRlR \ J M Y[ U$c \ UlO7M WQ7`$W \ QVUlMJD^ZcdK [ JU Z 0N WcdK 0g J @JDW E M`$W E M [ OSc`NKO [ U$MJ KNQScdJDKNc \ KO [ SAc`$RTM 0g WXcdK 0D J'c \ `WXMXO [ scdJ ePaMJ QVUlO7MXKj \[ JbU$Q7UhaMKWXcdRl^O7MC MK 0g kM( O MU 0g M % M( O j \ Qf^M`$RTMmUNU$MXJbUwezaMW`$Q7`NMTOaMXj \[ U$Q7cdJpe \WXQV`$W \ Q7UtWXcdRTRlM

0gD 0g

DE 0g$ 0g `

[ J KW E[ j \ MU$M`$RlMQ7O [ ^ ^ [ ` [ T V7UtM ( O j \ MOucdJ ^M \ U|KgQSRl^O7Q M`tMUtQSOgtQ7MXJbU *)

D

DE ,+ M %

WXMLj \ Q eiaMJ Q7UOuQSRl^iaMXe [ J WMWcdRl^OSMCM

& % $ M % )

D

DE + & % M % `

Page 89: M r O r’ R d ( ) q R - gps.ijl.univ-lorraine.frgps.ijl.univ-lorraine.fr/webpro/berche.b/ElmDeug1.pdf · Q T ( ) $ % ! § j ehg l°r>o o u"z e o r m j z j¡r i jm j hl° o u"jm¢

@kJnMXJnePaMXe \ QVU|J cU [ RlRTMXJbU

& $ *

D) \ E + *

U [ J $ E ) \ E + `

I MXKWXcdR^Zc`NU$MRTMXJbU$K [ KQARl^ UNcU$QSj \ MXKIY[ I [ KNKNM8S `haMXj \ MXJ WXMIKNcdJbU|O7MXK]K \ Q t [ JUNKXs& w d E

D * d * E D

EH * D` ` `

U [ J \ w d \$ \ H ` E[\ UNM+S `haMXj \ MXJ WXMIcdJ [

& ED * d *

DEH *

D` ` `

U [ J $ D H `

acbed#bed b n j jq JUg`$MO7MXKP`haM GdQ7RTMXK_e M I [ KNKgM|MU E[\ UNM S `haMXj \ MXJ WXMkKNM]^ `$che \ QVU \ JT^ E aMXJ cdRnYMJ M|e M`haMXKgcdJ [ J WXMc Y\ & ! ^ `$MXJ e \ J M t [ O7M \ `RTQSJ Q7R [ OSM J MXO [ MJUN` [ T VSJ Mj \ MT^c \ ` \ J M t [ O7M \ `e cdJ JiaMXMre MO [ U$MXJ KgQScdJpM'&lW [ WXMQSRl^cdK aMXM [\ C I c`$J MKe \ WQ7`$W \ QVU s OuQSJbU$MXJ KNQVUaMj \ Q=OSMUN` [ tbM`$KNM^ `$MXJ evK [t [ OSM \ `R [ CQSR [ O7M ezc Y\ O7M|U$M`$RTMte Mk`aMXKNcdJ [ J WXM JF@kJ WcdJ KgU [ U$M [ Q7KhaMXRTMXJbUj \ MkO [ `haMXKgcdJ [ J WXMKNM^ `$che \ QVUO7c`$KNj \ M

! \ E !KX [ J J \ O7Ms KgcdQ7U]^Zc \ `

*! E `