Lobateness of Martian Ejecta Craters Using Thermal Imaging Nicholas Kutsop Dr. Nadine G. Barlow NASA...

32
Lobateness of Martian Ejecta Craters Using Thermal Imaging Nicholas Kutsop Dr. Nadine G. Barlow NASA Space Grant Northern Arizona University Department of Physics and Astronomy

Transcript of Lobateness of Martian Ejecta Craters Using Thermal Imaging Nicholas Kutsop Dr. Nadine G. Barlow NASA...

Page 1: Lobateness of Martian Ejecta Craters Using Thermal Imaging Nicholas Kutsop Dr. Nadine G. Barlow NASA Space Grant Northern Arizona University Department.

Lobateness of Martian Ejecta Craters Using Thermal Imaging

Nicholas KutsopDr. Nadine G. Barlow

NASA Space GrantNorthern Arizona University Department of Physics and

Astronomy

Page 2: Lobateness of Martian Ejecta Craters Using Thermal Imaging Nicholas Kutsop Dr. Nadine G. Barlow NASA Space Grant Northern Arizona University Department.

Some info

• Lobateness Sinuosity How Flowery vs Circular the Ejecta Blanket Looks

• Γ=P/(4πA)1/2 • THEMIS - Thermal Emission Imaging System

Page 3: Lobateness of Martian Ejecta Craters Using Thermal Imaging Nicholas Kutsop Dr. Nadine G. Barlow NASA Space Grant Northern Arizona University Department.

AS ONE INCREASES IN LATITUDE, ONE WOULD EXPECT AN INCREASE IN WATER ICE CONTENT IN THE NEAR SURFACE REGION, LEADING ONE TO EXPECT TO OBSERVE A PROPORTIONAL INCREASE IN LOBATENESS OF THE EJECTA.

Original Proposition

Page 4: Lobateness of Martian Ejecta Craters Using Thermal Imaging Nicholas Kutsop Dr. Nadine G. Barlow NASA Space Grant Northern Arizona University Department.

MLER,DLER,SLER

Page 5: Lobateness of Martian Ejecta Craters Using Thermal Imaging Nicholas Kutsop Dr. Nadine G. Barlow NASA Space Grant Northern Arizona University Department.

Ok well why?• Martian craters differ significantly from those on the Moon or

Mercury

Lunar Ballistic

Martian Rampart

• Could be due to atmospheric turbulence following impact, or could be due to volatiles in the regolith

• Atmospheric theory falls short following investigation of icy satellites

Page 6: Lobateness of Martian Ejecta Craters Using Thermal Imaging Nicholas Kutsop Dr. Nadine G. Barlow NASA Space Grant Northern Arizona University Department.

What does it mean?

• Water ice on Mars? (Snapshots in Time)

• Water deep below the surface? (Mother Natures Tunnel Boring Machine)

Page 7: Lobateness of Martian Ejecta Craters Using Thermal Imaging Nicholas Kutsop Dr. Nadine G. Barlow NASA Space Grant Northern Arizona University Department.

A new look for old data• THEMIS resolution

(100m/p) vs. Viking resolution

(300m/p)• Layer types

lobateness consistent with previous studies

• Multiple differences between 1994 and 2010 data

Layer Type Lobateness

MLER AVG 1.56

MLER MIN 1.15

MLER MAX 2.18

SLER AVG 1.35

SLER MIN 1.10

SLER MAX 2.24

Page 8: Lobateness of Martian Ejecta Craters Using Thermal Imaging Nicholas Kutsop Dr. Nadine G. Barlow NASA Space Grant Northern Arizona University Department.

Significant Differences• 382 SLER, 137 MLER, 519

Total from 0-30°• 2008 SLER, 937 MLER, 2945

Total from 0-30°

Layer TypeMedian Values as of

2012

MLER Median 0-10 N 1.54

MLER Median 10-20 N 1.48

MLER Median 20-30 N 1.42

SLER Median 0-10 N 1.54

SLER Median 10-20 N 1.48

SLER Median 20-30 N 1.42

Layer TypeMedian Values as of

1994

MLER Median 0-10 N 1.19

MLER Median 10-20 N 1.19

MLER Median 20-30 N 1.19

SLER Median 0-10 N 1.10

SLER Median 10-20 N 1.10

SLER Median 20-30 N 1.11

Average % Difference = 77.446

Page 9: Lobateness of Martian Ejecta Craters Using Thermal Imaging Nicholas Kutsop Dr. Nadine G. Barlow NASA Space Grant Northern Arizona University Department.

The data thus far…

0 60 120 180 240 300 360

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Lon

Lat

Plot of All Craters

1.2

1.3

1.4

1.5

1.6

1.7

1.8

1.9

2

2.1

2.2

Page 10: Lobateness of Martian Ejecta Craters Using Thermal Imaging Nicholas Kutsop Dr. Nadine G. Barlow NASA Space Grant Northern Arizona University Department.

10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 1001

1.5

2

2.5

Diameter

Loba

tene

ss

Lobateness vs Diameter

y = 0.002*x + 1.5

vs. Dia

linear

Page 11: Lobateness of Martian Ejecta Craters Using Thermal Imaging Nicholas Kutsop Dr. Nadine G. Barlow NASA Space Grant Northern Arizona University Department.

0 5 10 15 20 25 30-1

-0.5

0

0.5

1residuals

Linear: norm of residuals = 8.3625

0 5 10 15 20 25 301

1.5

2

2.5

Latitude

Loba

tene

ss

Lobateness vs Latitude

y = - 0.0057*x + 1.6

vs Lat.

linear

Page 12: Lobateness of Martian Ejecta Craters Using Thermal Imaging Nicholas Kutsop Dr. Nadine G. Barlow NASA Space Grant Northern Arizona University Department.
Page 13: Lobateness of Martian Ejecta Craters Using Thermal Imaging Nicholas Kutsop Dr. Nadine G. Barlow NASA Space Grant Northern Arizona University Department.

0 5 10 15 20 25 30

1.4

1.45

1.5

1.55

1.6

Latitude

Lobate

ness

SLER Lobateness vs Latitude (5 Avg)

y = - 0.0058*x + 1.6

vs Lat

linear

0 5 10 15 20 25 30

1.4

1.45

1.5

1.55

1.6

Latitude

Lobate

ness

MLER Lobateness vs Latitude (5 Avg)

y = - 0.0047*x + 1.6

vs Lat

linear

Page 14: Lobateness of Martian Ejecta Craters Using Thermal Imaging Nicholas Kutsop Dr. Nadine G. Barlow NASA Space Grant Northern Arizona University Department.

Γ=NEGATIVE(≈.0055)Lat+1.6?

0 5 10 15 20 25 301.42

1.44

1.46

1.48

1.5

1.52

1.54

1.56

1.58

Latitude

Lobate

ness

Lobateness vs Latitude (5 Avg)

y = - 0.0055*x + 1.6

vs Lat

linear

Page 15: Lobateness of Martian Ejecta Craters Using Thermal Imaging Nicholas Kutsop Dr. Nadine G. Barlow NASA Space Grant Northern Arizona University Department.

Where are we and what next?

• Is the previously put forth model for lobateness accurate?

• What new hypothesis can we generate from this data?

• Lobateness at higher latitudes• The southern hemisphere• Compare to older data• Correlation between age and lobateness

Page 16: Lobateness of Martian Ejecta Craters Using Thermal Imaging Nicholas Kutsop Dr. Nadine G. Barlow NASA Space Grant Northern Arizona University Department.

And thank you…

• Dr. Nadine G Barlow• NAU Department of Physics and Astronomy• NASA Space Grant• Wikipedia for the pictures• MatLab for the graphs• The team of JMars

Page 17: Lobateness of Martian Ejecta Craters Using Thermal Imaging Nicholas Kutsop Dr. Nadine G. Barlow NASA Space Grant Northern Arizona University Department.

Quick Info

• Total Craters = 3029• DLER=3%• SLER=66%• MLER=31%• Residual = Goodness of Fit

n

1i

2id)2/1()^2).^d(abs(sum)2,d(norm

Page 18: Lobateness of Martian Ejecta Craters Using Thermal Imaging Nicholas Kutsop Dr. Nadine G. Barlow NASA Space Grant Northern Arizona University Department.

Bonus Pictures

Page 19: Lobateness of Martian Ejecta Craters Using Thermal Imaging Nicholas Kutsop Dr. Nadine G. Barlow NASA Space Grant Northern Arizona University Department.
Page 20: Lobateness of Martian Ejecta Craters Using Thermal Imaging Nicholas Kutsop Dr. Nadine G. Barlow NASA Space Grant Northern Arizona University Department.
Page 21: Lobateness of Martian Ejecta Craters Using Thermal Imaging Nicholas Kutsop Dr. Nadine G. Barlow NASA Space Grant Northern Arizona University Department.
Page 22: Lobateness of Martian Ejecta Craters Using Thermal Imaging Nicholas Kutsop Dr. Nadine G. Barlow NASA Space Grant Northern Arizona University Department.
Page 23: Lobateness of Martian Ejecta Craters Using Thermal Imaging Nicholas Kutsop Dr. Nadine G. Barlow NASA Space Grant Northern Arizona University Department.
Page 24: Lobateness of Martian Ejecta Craters Using Thermal Imaging Nicholas Kutsop Dr. Nadine G. Barlow NASA Space Grant Northern Arizona University Department.
Page 25: Lobateness of Martian Ejecta Craters Using Thermal Imaging Nicholas Kutsop Dr. Nadine G. Barlow NASA Space Grant Northern Arizona University Department.
Page 26: Lobateness of Martian Ejecta Craters Using Thermal Imaging Nicholas Kutsop Dr. Nadine G. Barlow NASA Space Grant Northern Arizona University Department.
Page 27: Lobateness of Martian Ejecta Craters Using Thermal Imaging Nicholas Kutsop Dr. Nadine G. Barlow NASA Space Grant Northern Arizona University Department.

MLER Avg

Page 28: Lobateness of Martian Ejecta Craters Using Thermal Imaging Nicholas Kutsop Dr. Nadine G. Barlow NASA Space Grant Northern Arizona University Department.

MLER Max

Page 29: Lobateness of Martian Ejecta Craters Using Thermal Imaging Nicholas Kutsop Dr. Nadine G. Barlow NASA Space Grant Northern Arizona University Department.

MLER Min

Page 30: Lobateness of Martian Ejecta Craters Using Thermal Imaging Nicholas Kutsop Dr. Nadine G. Barlow NASA Space Grant Northern Arizona University Department.

SLER Avg

Page 31: Lobateness of Martian Ejecta Craters Using Thermal Imaging Nicholas Kutsop Dr. Nadine G. Barlow NASA Space Grant Northern Arizona University Department.

SLER Max

Page 32: Lobateness of Martian Ejecta Craters Using Thermal Imaging Nicholas Kutsop Dr. Nadine G. Barlow NASA Space Grant Northern Arizona University Department.

SLER Min