Letters
Transcript of Letters
Newscripts by Κ. Μ. Reese
New way to restore serial numbers Stanley G. Young of the National Aeronautics and Space Administration has worked out a new means of restoring serial numbers when criminals have removed them from stolen metal goods by grinding or filing. Young is at NASA's Lewis Research Center, Cleveland, Ohio. His method is based on cavitation, the formation of teeny vacuumlike cavities as a result of uneven pressure gradients in a liquid. The NASA scientist described the technique at a recent seminar of the California Association of Criminalists, in Palo Alto.
In practice, the surface to be restored is immersed in water. An ultrasonic generator creates the pressure gradients in the liquid and, in consequence, millions of microscopic cavitation bubbles. The bubbles strike the surface of the metal at thousands of pounds per square inch. They scour away the metal smeared into the grooves of the serial number, which becomes visible again. The method has been shown clearly to be a feasible, low-cost tool for crime laboratories, Young believes. The necessary ultrasonic generator costs less than $1500.
The new technique grew out of an ultrasonic etching procedure developed by Young for metallo-graphic studies of alloys. A NASA technology transfer team at Stanford Research Institute, Menlo Park, Calif., suggested its use in restoring serial numbers. Young tried it, and it worked. In the course of the effort, he found that numbers restored on a sample of brass appeared as a ghost image, rather than a cleaned-out groove. Young believes that the cavitation attack may be sensitive to the microstructural changes that result when the serial number is first stamped into the metal.
Mangrove in trouble in southwest Florida The nature lover's dilemma can be discerned in the discovery that a wood-boring crustacean, Sphaeroma terebrans, is undermining the red mangroves along the southwestern coast of Florida (1). The problem was uncovered by two scientists from the University of South Florida: Andrew Rehm of the department of biology, Tampa, and Harold Humm of the department of marine science, St. Petersburg. The attack is centered in the Ten Thousand Islands region, site of the greatest stand of mangroves in North America and one of the greatest in the world. Sphaeroma, in essence, is gradually cutting away the shoreline of the mainland and of the mangrove islands.
Rehm and Humm were
studying algae that grow underwater on the prop roots of the red mangrove. Then they discovered that on "a major portion" of the trees in the area there were no such algae because the prop roots had been cut off at about the level of mean high water. Further investigation tied the depredations directly to Sphaeroma. With their prop roots cut off, the trees are left standing on their main axes or oldest prop roots. Waves and current cut away the soil, mainly peat, and summer squalls and hurricanes topple trees on the margin into the water.
The shrinkage has been under way for a long time. An aerial photograph taken in 1953, for example, shows an isthmus and several islands that were gone by 1964. The visible evidence diverges sharply from a prediction of 1914 that a bay in the area would be filled in by proliferating mangrove islands. A second scientist predicted, in 1940, that the Ten Thousand Islands might coalesce one day because of the mangroves.
One gets the impression that the mangrove was the pest then. Sphaeroma appears to have been on the scene in 1940, but nothing as so destructive as today. Rehm and Humm say that "An ecocatastrophe of serious magnitude . . . appears to be in progress, " and one can draw the conclusion that they or somebody else will want to do something to save the mangroves. Therein lies the dilemma mentioned earlier. Previous pre
dictions haven't held up, so why should any made now. The Ten Thousand Islands are in big trouble, but Sphaeroma seems never to have had it so good. Which one to zap? (1) Science, 182,173(1973).
Other voices, same glooms " T h e position of the United States in regard to oil can best be characterized as precarious . . it is not a minute too early to take counsel with ourselves and call the attention of . . . geologists, engineers, capitalists, and legislators to the need of an oil supply for the future. '
"[The speaker] concludes by recommending that American capital be encouraged to assist in the development of foreign oil fields, thus assuring the additional supply of oil required to cover our needs for a long time to come." The Nautical Gazette, Jan. 20, 1920.
Department of obscure information
• The sheep population of the U.S. declined from 30 million in 1950 to 17.7 million at the start of 1973.
• The width of truck trailers may not exceed 96 inches in the state of Alaska.
• Terrorist bombings in the U.S. are occurring currently at an average rate of about 163 monthly.
Letters A Bas les Traites Theoretiques SIR: A great many so-called scientists (of which I happen to be one)/ Wouldn't know a genuine phenomenon if they should happen to see one./ So versed are they in computerized electron perturbations/ That they are quite inept at ordinary laboratory manipulations./ Now it's not that I can't hack theoretical chemistry myself;/ After all, I've got Cotton and Coulson and Co. sitting on my shelf;/ It's just that all these massive tomes with their surfeit of theory/ Don't do the least to help me answer my client's query./ Never has anyone asked me what ligand field theory is good for:/ Instead they ask how much copper is in their ore./ So, down with Schrodinger and Dirac, and down with Hartree and Fock;/ What I need is someone to help me analyze a rock./
Jerry F. O'Donnell, Ph.D. Del Mar College, Corpus Christi, Tex.
On with achievement SIR: A week before the ACS national convention, I picked up my copy of C&EN and read the editorial comment. Did I find an article praising chemistry for achievements? Did I find an article acclaiming the wonders of science and the benefits that
science has given the people of the U.S.; and is in fact, the sole reason that the people of the U.S. enjoy the best standard of living in the world? No indeed. In fact, what I found was a nicely worded, carefully phrased statement about giving in to the "antiscience" voices in the country; an article which might as well have been titled ''Retreat from reason. ''
I have no argument with the author; he has felt pressures, and feels appeasement may offer a solution. I say not. How does one appease the reactionary? What those who oppose scientific advances want science to say is that facts are theory, and theories are fabrications. Can we scientists afford this? We cannot. And for the sake of the country, we must not retreat from our position that strong scientific research is vitally necessary to the maintenance of the country as a world power. Do we need an- * other great Soviet advance, such as in 1957, to spur interest in scientific research? Our people have been too spoiled by the fact that no matter what the crisis, no matter what the trouble, no matter what the circumstances, American science has been able to make the necessary strives and achievements to end threats. This is not always going to be the case. Where would we have been in World War II if some of the scientific achievements had been two or three years later? Perhaps we would be speaking German, and only when told we could speak.
I disagree that people with strong religious convictions oppose science. I have
strong convictions, and am even a "creationist"; but I certainly do not deny science and the evidences of discoveries. I say the two go hand in hand. If one wants to know where the greatest reserves of oil and natural gas are, I say, look for the Garden of Eden. And what do you find—a map of the Arab oil fields!
It may be true that war is too important to be left to the generals, and law too important to be left to the lawyers, and many others. However, science is too important NOT to be left to the scientists. It is the nonscientists in government who have cut budgets and eliminated programs. Let these same people confine themselves to their own areas. In fact, with all the budget cuts science administrators have been forced to live with, I would be willing to bet they could produce a national budget that would be $5 billion in the black. So forget the economists, forget the lawyers, forget the whiners and criers, forget the dropouts, and let us concentrate on maintaining our record of achievements. And I say, hooray for the technocrats.
Larry R. Camp
Federal R&D funding SIR: I have read a series of articles in C&EN with a rapidly increasing sense of disbelief. The latest of these epistles was titled "New funding highs for academic R&D" (C&EN, Sept. 10, page 3) based on a National Science Foundation report.
Continued on page 34
36 C&EN Nov. 5, 1973
Organic/Analytical: Ph.D. 71. Post Doctoral experience with F19 aromatic and natural product (azabicy-clic) synthesis. Specialist in application of instrumental techniques to synthetic and analytical problems. Expert in Varian NMR instrumentation: A-60 series, T-60 and XL-100. Box 405-A-10, ACS, 1155 16th St., Washington, D.C. 20036
Organic/Polymer Chemist: M.Sc, Ph.D., D.Sc. (Venia Legendi, Germany). Formerly MIT staff member. Three languages. Diversified industrial· and academic research experience. Novel reactions, industrial products. Flame retardants, organophosphorus, organohal-ogen and organosulfur chemistry. Vinylics, polycarbonates, polyurethanes, graft polymers. Several patents, publications. Seeks challenging position in industry, Government, academia. Location: open. Box 406-A-10, ACS, 1155 16th St., N.W., Washington, D.C. 20036
Organic Polymer Chemist: Ph.D. 1960. Desires R&D industrial position. Diversified polymer experiences. Polymer syntheses and evaluation. Property-Structure Relationships. Fluorocarbon and Aromatic-Het-erocyclic polymers, modified silicones and chlorine containing polymers. UV and RF Plasma polymerizations. Supervisory experiences. Patents and publications. No agencies. Box 407-A-10, ACS, 1155 16th St., N.W., Washington, D.C. 20036
Physical-Analytical Chemist: Ph.D. 1968. Extensive research experience in molecular spectroscopy (UV, VIS, IR, NMR, AA, CD, and ORD), various chromatographic separation techniques, and methods development. Flexible with many publications. Seek industrial R&D position. Available now. (412) 793-2835, C. Ke, 159 Lansdowne Dr., Pittsburgh, Pa. 15147
Aerosol Food Chemist: M.S., physical chemistry 1950; M.S. Food Technology 1973. Six year's aerosol formulation and supervisory experience as Chief Aerosol Chemist. Can assume full responsibility in aerosol laboratory. Wide instrumentation experience. Available immediately. From $11,000. Box 410-A-10, ACS, 1155 16th St., N.W., Washington, D.C. 20036
Chemist-Biologist: 31, MS 1971 in Resource Chemistry. Experience in pesticide analysis, organic matter in soil and water, organic synthesis, and teaching. Familiar with instrumental analysis, especially gas chromatography. Actively interested in environmental as-, pects of chemicals and organisms. Prefer New England or Northwest location. Harold R. Day, 50 Forest Park Drive, North Kingstown, Rhode Island 02852
Idle Test Tube Jockey: Ph.D. 1970 (organic), age 29, three years postdoctoral research. Experience includes main group and transition metal organics, homogeneous catalysis, and classical and innovative organic syntheses. Desires intellectually challenging academic, industrial, or governmental position. Box 412-A-10, ACS, 1155 16th St., N.W., Washington, D.C. 20036
Marketing/Sales. Laboratory Instrumentation. Two years Sales Management, four years Product Management, six years field sales, all in instrumentation. ΑΜΑ courses; Leaders Course in Principles of Professional Salesmanship, Field Management of Salesmen, Product and Brand Management. Age 42. Available as result of divisional restructuring. M. A. Sweet, 1888 Brandy-wine Drive, Allison Park, Pa. 15101 (412) 364-2036.
Product Development Manager: Ph.D. Internationally oriented. Extensive experience in supervising, staffing, planning, organizing, decision making, etc. Worked closely with production and marketing department. Unusual record in product and processs development, coatings, industrial textiles, elastomers, films, foams, corrosion prevention, lamination, acoustical and vibration damping materials. Enrolled in M.B.A. program. No agencies. Box 414-A-10, ACS, 1155 16th St., N.W., Washington, D.C. 20036
Surfactants and Detergents specialist seeking research management position with industry involved in. production and development of surface active agents. Profitable accomplishments with many years of diversified experience. Publications. Box 415-A-10, ACS, 1155 16th St., N.W., Washington, D.C. 20036
Theoretical Surface Chemist: Ph.D. Four years postdoctoral. Background in chemical engineering (B.S.). Experience in surface chemistry, statistical mechanics, thermodynamics, mixtures, rheology, polymers, capillary condensation, computer programming, applied mathematics and air pollution. Desires industrial position. Will start from any level or be re-trained. Box 416-A-10, ACS, 1155 16th St., N.W., Washington, D.C. 20036
Air Pollution Engineer: Member NSPE, AlChE, EEIB, APCA committees. Familiar with industry operations and control methods. Extensive survey experience— source, industrial hygiene, ambient, permitting, inventories, measurements, expert witness, etc. Prefer inter-discipline opportunity South or East. Box 417-A-10, ACS, 1155 16th St., N.W., Washington, D.C. 20036
Analytical-Environmental and Food Chemistry, Ph.D. 1971. Two years experience with contract research organization analyzing environmental samples for pesticides and hydrocarbons of petroleum origin. Flavor chemistry of dairy and meat products. Familiar with GC, GC-MS, UV and IR. Publications. Seek academic, government, or industrial position. Box 418-A-10, ACS, 1155 16th St., N.W., Washington, D.C. 20036
Business, Product or Marketing Manager: Experienced Ρ and L, budgets, forecasts, planning and market research. Fifteen years experience specialty chemicals
in the textile, paper, leather metals, plastics and chemical industries. B.S. Chemistry plus MBA. Age 39. Will relocate. Box 419-A-10, ACS, 1155 16th St., N.W., Washington, D.C. 20036
Experienced Chemist M.S. Product and Process development. Experience in leading industries for fourteen years. Profit making contributions in industrial catalytic processes, catalysts, oxidation and hydrogénation in petrochemical and catalyst manufacturing industries. Background in chemical engineering. Capable of undertaking difficult assignments and leadership. Box 421-A-10, ACS, 1155 16th St., N.W., Washington, D.C.20036
Organic Chemist: Ph.D. 1970. Three years college teaching, two years postdoctoral experience, consultant experience. Familiar with spectral, analytical techniques. Research in organometallic, organosilicon synthesis transition and precious metal catalysts. Desire teaching four or two year college, or industrial research. Available immediately. Box 422-A-10, ACS, 1155 16th St., N.W., Washington, D.C. 20036
Production Management and Sales experience includes paint plant management and sales of raw materials and industrial chemicals. Desire opportunity in either management or sales. Will travel and relocate. Write for resume. Box 423-A-10, ACS, 1155 16th St., N.W., Washington, D.C. 20036
Marketing/Sales Management: Professional seeking participation in profits arrangement in New York area chemical specialties business. Prime account contacts in food and pharmaceutical houses. Solid specialty sales management background includes pharmaceuticals, fine organics, essential oils, dairy cultures, enzymes, terpene and tall oil derivatives. Box 413-D-9, ACS, 1155 16th Street, N.W., Washington, D.C. 20036
Analytical Chemist: B.S. in Ch.E.; graduate chem courses. Varied experience. N.Y. Consulting Lab; supervisor plastics physical testing; edible oils; rubber p.s. adhesives; N.Y. City area. Phone: 212-733-0682. Box 400-D-8, ACS, 1155 16th St., N.W., Washington, D.C. 20036
SITUATIONS WANTED (Retired Chemists and Ch.E.'s)
Retired Biochemist: Age 60, with patents and CIBS-award papers in chemistry, and broad experience with creative problem solving, seeks consulting or literary work in area of creativity and innovation. Established reputation in this field, book and journal publications, university teaching, seminars, lectures, synectics training. Box 425-A-11, ACS, 1155 16th St., Washington, D.C. 20036
Chemical Engineer: Thirty eight years engineering, production and management experience in lengthy inorganic process involving many unit operations plus experience in environmental problems; economic evaluations; literature searches; report writing. Full or part time work desired in -similar fields. Northern New Jersey. Box 426-A-11, ACS, 1155 16th St., N.W., Washington, D.C. 20036
Consultant: M.I.T. graduate, recently retired, thirty five years broad experience, industrial operation, R&D, production, management, sales development, process improvement, new product development and evaluation in wide range of specialty chemicals. Full knowledge EPA and FDA requirements. Technical and business problems invited. References. Phone (301) 367-3992 or write William Schulman, 1810 Tanbark Drive, Baltimore, Md. 21209
R&D Management and Liaison position sought by Ph.D. Chemist with graduate business degree and record of productive leadership in major industry R&D and contract research. Outstanding skills and results in product and process innovation, technical and business planning, multi-institutional liaison and technology transfer involving industry, government, research institutes, and universities. Box 428-A-11, ACS, 1155 16th St., N.W., Washington, D.C. 20036
HUNTING? "Courtesy is the true alchemy, turning to gold all it touches . . ."—Meredith. Answer all ad inquiries. Ignoring replies to your ads is unfair to the company and other applicants. With your cooperation C&EN can fulfill its obligations to readers and advertisers
Letters Continued from page 36
Somehow I felt that, on the basis of this article, my colleagues should be in a jovial frame of mind. I find instead a great deal of gloom.
I do not question the amount expended for R&D, but I strongly question the statement that ". . . fully $2.5 billion was allocated for basic research." I have sat on research evaluation panels and I can tell you that what is now called basic research by many of the government agencies bears little resemblance to definitions used in 1967.
As a practical measure of the support of basic research, it would be interesting to know relative allocations to science departments during the period 1968-72. I would not be surprised if there was a 30% decrease. Surely there is some reason for the mood of despair which is so prevalent today in chemistry departments. In addition there has been a catastrophic drop in the number of graduate students in the major departments which you can easily see in the ACS survey of graduate work.
C. R. Mueller Prof, of Chemistry, Purdue University, La
fayette, Ind.
Editor's Note: C&EN feels that over the years it has presented as accurate a picture of the R&D funding situation as is possible in such a complex area. We're sorry Dr. Mueller apparently feels otherwise.
ACS elections SIR: It was with considerable distaste that I returned my ballot in the ACS elections. A crude attempt is being made, in the name of majority balloting, to assure the election of a Tory. The power struggle between the popularly elected President and the Council and Board is also reflected in many other developments summarized by one of the candidates. Perhaps the time has come for a nationwide campaign to affect two reforms: 1. Direct popular election, by mail ballot, of ALL local and national officers except for administrative staff. 2. Initiative and referendum in all society affairs.
The ACS seems to have reacted against the election of two populist Presidents in a row by attempting to insure that no such aberration occur again. We are constantly reminded of the scholarly activities of the ACS and its sacred-cow tax position. I suspect that we, as chemists, would lose nothing if the Journals and CA were donated to the NSF and the National Meetings abolished. A healthier local section structure, better regional meetings, and a good dose of participatory democracy would do wonders for the old organization. I fear continued erosion of support, especially if the election ploy is successful. My own feeling of ambivalence extends to indecision as to whether staying and fighting is worthwhile, or whether I would simply drop out. As its stands, my best reason for staying is the group insurance! That realization really saddens me, since I was once a gung-ho member, frequent committee chairman, local section officer,, and even tried to organize a new section where I used to live. Sic transit gloria Societatis!
Marvin J. Albinak Baltimore, Md.
34 C&EN Nov. 5, 1973
JOB