Lecture 4: State sum models in 2d€¦ · June 4, 2014. State sum model I M manifold, triangulation...

15
Lecture 4: State sum models in 2d John Barrett School of Mathematical Sciences University of Nottingham June 4, 2014

Transcript of Lecture 4: State sum models in 2d€¦ · June 4, 2014. State sum model I M manifold, triangulation...

Page 1: Lecture 4: State sum models in 2d€¦ · June 4, 2014. State sum model I M manifold, triangulation . I A nite set S I A state is an assignment of an element of S to each k-simplex

Lecture 4: State sum models in 2d

John Barrett

School of Mathematical SciencesUniversity of Nottingham

June 4, 2014

pmzjwb
Pen
Page 2: Lecture 4: State sum models in 2d€¦ · June 4, 2014. State sum model I M manifold, triangulation . I A nite set S I A state is an assignment of an element of S to each k-simplex

State sum model

I M manifold, triangulation ∆.

I A finite set S

I A state is an assignment of an element of S to eachk-simplex (some fixed k < d)

I Weight Zσ ∈ C defined for each simplex σ, using thestates on the simplex

Z (M ,∆) =∑states

∏σ

Examples

I Lattice gauge theory

I Topological quantum field theory

I Spin foam models

Page 3: Lecture 4: State sum models in 2d€¦ · June 4, 2014. State sum model I M manifold, triangulation . I A nite set S I A state is an assignment of an element of S to each k-simplex

Example: 2d state sum model

[Fukuma, Hosono, Kawai 1994]

ZT = Cabc ∈ CZE = Bab

Z• = R

Cabc = Ccab Bab = Bba

pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
Page 4: Lecture 4: State sum models in 2d€¦ · June 4, 2014. State sum model I M manifold, triangulation . I A nite set S I A state is an assignment of an element of S to each k-simplex

Dual formalism

pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
Page 5: Lecture 4: State sum models in 2d€¦ · June 4, 2014. State sum model I M manifold, triangulation . I A nite set S I A state is an assignment of an element of S to each k-simplex

Planar model[Lauda, Pfeiffer 2007]

M ⊂ R2

pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
Page 6: Lecture 4: State sum models in 2d€¦ · June 4, 2014. State sum model I M manifold, triangulation . I A nite set S I A state is an assignment of an element of S to each k-simplex

Frobenius property

Replace cyclic symmetry of C and symmetry of B with

CabdBdc = BceCeab

Z is independent of the way the diagram is drawn in theinterior.

pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
Page 7: Lecture 4: State sum models in 2d€¦ · June 4, 2014. State sum model I M manifold, triangulation . I A nite set S I A state is an assignment of an element of S to each k-simplex

Topological QFT

Z depends on M but not on gµν .

Examples

I Chern-Simons QFT d = 3

I Quantum Gravity

I Topological phase in CM

Page 8: Lecture 4: State sum models in 2d€¦ · June 4, 2014. State sum model I M manifold, triangulation . I A nite set S I A state is an assignment of an element of S to each k-simplex

Topological State Sum Model

Z depends on M but not on triangulation.

Example: planar model

C eabC

dec = C d

af Cfbc

=⇒ structure constants of an associative algebra A.

pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
Page 9: Lecture 4: State sum models in 2d€¦ · June 4, 2014. State sum model I M manifold, triangulation . I A nite set S I A state is an assignment of an element of S to each k-simplex

3-1 move

A is a special Frobenius algebra.

pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
Page 10: Lecture 4: State sum models in 2d€¦ · June 4, 2014. State sum model I M manifold, triangulation . I A nite set S I A state is an assignment of an element of S to each k-simplex

Spin models[JWB, Sara Tavares 2013]

MΦ−→ R3 π−→ R2

I Φ is an immersionI π is a coordinate projectionI Planar model with additional data λ : A⊗A → A⊗A.

pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
Page 11: Lecture 4: State sum models in 2d€¦ · June 4, 2014. State sum model I M manifold, triangulation . I A nite set S I A state is an assignment of an element of S to each k-simplex

Axioms for crossing

pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
Page 12: Lecture 4: State sum models in 2d€¦ · June 4, 2014. State sum model I M manifold, triangulation . I A nite set S I A state is an assignment of an element of S to each k-simplex

Spin model: results

I Z is independent of the triangulation

I Z depends on Φ only via the spin structure induced fromR3.

I ψ2 = 1

I If ψ = 1 then Z is independent of the spin structure.

I There exist examples of Cabc ,Bab, λabcd that distinguish

spin structures.

pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
Page 13: Lecture 4: State sum models in 2d€¦ · June 4, 2014. State sum model I M manifold, triangulation . I A nite set S I A state is an assignment of an element of S to each k-simplex

Example: torusA torus has four spin structures.

pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
Page 14: Lecture 4: State sum models in 2d€¦ · June 4, 2014. State sum model I M manifold, triangulation . I A nite set S I A state is an assignment of an element of S to each k-simplex

Torus diagrams

pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
Page 15: Lecture 4: State sum models in 2d€¦ · June 4, 2014. State sum model I M manifold, triangulation . I A nite set S I A state is an assignment of an element of S to each k-simplex
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen
pmzjwb
Pen