HR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Constellation Orionis...

21

Transcript of HR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Constellation Orionis...

Page 1: HR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Constellation Orionis ...binaries.physics.muni.cz/download/talks/an_improved_model_of_delta_ori.pdfHR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Member of δ Orionis (Mintaka,
Page 2: HR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Constellation Orionis ...binaries.physics.muni.cz/download/talks/an_improved_model_of_delta_ori.pdfHR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Member of δ Orionis (Mintaka,

HR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930

Member of δ Orionis (Mintaka, ADS 4134)

Orion

Constellation

-2-

Page 3: HR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Constellation Orionis ...binaries.physics.muni.cz/download/talks/an_improved_model_of_delta_ori.pdfHR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Member of δ Orionis (Mintaka,

Harvin et al. 2002 Unexpectly low masses

Mayer et al. 2010 Confusion of secondary and tertiary in Harvin‘s study The spectral lines of the primary and tertiary dominate the optical spectra Normal masses, q ≈ 0.4

Harmanec et al. 2013 Detection of the secondary in the red spectral region

Corcoran et al. 2015

Nichols et al. 2015

Pablo et al. 2015

Shenar et al. 2015

Series of four consecutive

detailed studies

-3-

Page 4: HR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Constellation Orionis ...binaries.physics.muni.cz/download/talks/an_improved_model_of_delta_ori.pdfHR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Member of δ Orionis (Mintaka,

-4-

Spectroscopic data

Page 5: HR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Constellation Orionis ...binaries.physics.muni.cz/download/talks/an_improved_model_of_delta_ori.pdfHR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Member of δ Orionis (Mintaka,

-5-

SMEI MOST BRITE

Photometric data

Page 6: HR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Constellation Orionis ...binaries.physics.muni.cz/download/talks/an_improved_model_of_delta_ori.pdfHR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Member of δ Orionis (Mintaka,

Reduction of spect. spectra

SPEFO1

Disentangling

KOREL3

Photometric data + RV curves*

PHOEBE 15

Fitting observed and model spectra

PYTERPOL4

Rebinning to a scale linear in RV

HEC35D2

Homogenized phot. data

-6-

Page 7: HR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Constellation Orionis ...binaries.physics.muni.cz/download/talks/an_improved_model_of_delta_ori.pdfHR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Member of δ Orionis (Mintaka,

Variable quality of individual spectra

Signal to noise ratio

Problems in solution of this system

Lines of the primary and tertiary are blended

The primary and tertiary dominate

Faint secondary spectrum

The dependence of sum of squares on q is flat

-7-

Page 8: HR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Constellation Orionis ...binaries.physics.muni.cz/download/talks/an_improved_model_of_delta_ori.pdfHR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Member of δ Orionis (Mintaka,

The first step The second step

-8-

Residua for all

individual spectra

after disentangling

+ 1

The spectra of

primary and

tertiary were

disentangled

The spectrum

of secondary

was

disentangled

Page 9: HR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Constellation Orionis ...binaries.physics.muni.cz/download/talks/an_improved_model_of_delta_ori.pdfHR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Member of δ Orionis (Mintaka,

Python program

KORELMAP1

-9-

1 Written by J. A. Nemravová

χ2

Page 10: HR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Constellation Orionis ...binaries.physics.muni.cz/download/talks/an_improved_model_of_delta_ori.pdfHR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Member of δ Orionis (Mintaka,

Disentangled:

primary and

tertiary with

variable intensities

Convergence of:

T01, e, ω, K1

(orbit of close pair)

T02, K2

(outer orbit)

-10-

Disentangled:

primary and

tertiary with

variable intensities

Convergence of:

T01, e, ω, K1

(orbit of close pair)

T02, K2

(outer orbit)

Disentangled:

primary and tertiary

with constant

intensities and the

secondary with

variable intensity

Convergence of:

T01, q

(orbit of close pair)

Disentangled:

all three

components with

constant intensities

Convergence of:

T01, e, ω, q, K1

(orbit of close pair)

T02, K2

(outer orbit)

Disentangled:

primary and tertiary

with constant

intensities and the

secondary with

variable intensity

Convergence of:

T01, q

(orbit of close pair)

Disentangled:

all three

components with

constant intensities

Convergence of:

T01, e, ω, q, K1

(orbit of close pair)

T02, K2

(outer orbit)

Page 11: HR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Constellation Orionis ...binaries.physics.muni.cz/download/talks/an_improved_model_of_delta_ori.pdfHR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Member of δ Orionis (Mintaka,

For instance: Teff, log g , v sin i, LR

Finds fit between observed spectra and interpolated model

Simplex minimization technique

-11-

Page 12: HR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Constellation Orionis ...binaries.physics.muni.cz/download/talks/an_improved_model_of_delta_ori.pdfHR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Member of δ Orionis (Mintaka,

-12-

Page 13: HR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Constellation Orionis ...binaries.physics.muni.cz/download/talks/an_improved_model_of_delta_ori.pdfHR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Member of δ Orionis (Mintaka,

Homogenization of photometric data

Normal points

Interpolating maxima by Hermite polynomial

13 -13-

Page 14: HR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Constellation Orionis ...binaries.physics.muni.cz/download/talks/an_improved_model_of_delta_ori.pdfHR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Member of δ Orionis (Mintaka,

Homogenization of photometric data

Normal points

Interpolating maxima by Hermite polynomial

14 -14-

Page 15: HR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Constellation Orionis ...binaries.physics.muni.cz/download/talks/an_improved_model_of_delta_ori.pdfHR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Member of δ Orionis (Mintaka,

Homogenization of photometric data

Normal points

Interpolating maxima by Hermite polynomial

15 -15-

Page 16: HR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Constellation Orionis ...binaries.physics.muni.cz/download/talks/an_improved_model_of_delta_ori.pdfHR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Member of δ Orionis (Mintaka,

Homogenization of photometric data

Normal points

Interpolating maxima by Hermite polynomial

16 -16-

Page 17: HR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Constellation Orionis ...binaries.physics.muni.cz/download/talks/an_improved_model_of_delta_ori.pdfHR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Member of δ Orionis (Mintaka,

-17-

Page 18: HR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Constellation Orionis ...binaries.physics.muni.cz/download/talks/an_improved_model_of_delta_ori.pdfHR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Member of δ Orionis (Mintaka,

-18-

Page 19: HR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Constellation Orionis ...binaries.physics.muni.cz/download/talks/an_improved_model_of_delta_ori.pdfHR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Member of δ Orionis (Mintaka,

-19-

Aa2

Aa1

Page 20: HR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Constellation Orionis ...binaries.physics.muni.cz/download/talks/an_improved_model_of_delta_ori.pdfHR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Member of δ Orionis (Mintaka,

-20-

Page 21: HR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Constellation Orionis ...binaries.physics.muni.cz/download/talks/an_improved_model_of_delta_ori.pdfHR 1852, HD 36486, HIP 25930 Member of δ Orionis (Mintaka,

Analysis of a triple star delta Orionis A

Multiple star system delta Orionis

An eclipsing binary and a distant tertiary

Spectroscopic data

Disentangling the spectral lines of the secondary

Mass ratio: q = 0.415

Photometric data – satellites SMEI, MOST, BRITE

Light-curve solution

Improved physical elements

-21-