How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today...

61
How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS Andrei Gritsan Johns Hopkins University May 29, 2014 LBNL Research Progress Meeting

Transcript of How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today...

Page 1: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

How Wide is the Higgs Boson:off-shell constraints from CMS

Andrei Gritsan

Johns Hopkins University

May 29, 2014

LBNL Research Progress Meeting

Page 2: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

Overview

• Introduction

• The Higgs boson

• How we see it

• Off-shell production

• Data analysis

– H → Z∗Z∗ → 4ℓ

– H∗ → ZZ → 4ℓ

– H∗ → ZZ → 2ℓ2ν

• Theoretical considerations

• Summary and outlook

Andrei Gritsan, JHU II May 29, 2014

Page 3: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

A FEW SLIDES OF HISTORY

Page 4: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

July 2012: Observation of a New Boson

• Observation of a New Boson on CMS: 5σ excess

X → Z(∗)Z(∗) X → γγ

• Probability of background

∼ 0.2× 10−6

Higgs boson mass (GeV)116 118 120 122 124 126 128 130

Loca

l p-v

alue

-1210

-1110

-1010

-910

-810

-710

-610

-510

-410

-310

-210

-110

1σ1σ2

σ3

σ4

σ5

σ6

σ7

Combined obs.

Exp. for SM H

γγ →H

ZZ→H

WW→H

CMS Preliminaryγγ ZZ + WW + →H

-1 = 7 TeV, L = 5.1 fbs-1 = 8 TeV, L = 5.3 fbs

Andrei Gritsan, JHU IV May 29, 2014

Page 5: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

July 2012: Observation of a New Boson

• Observation of a New Boson on ATLAS: 5σ excess

X → Z(∗)Z(∗) X → γγ

[GeV]4lm100 150 200 250

Even

ts/5

GeV

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

-1Ldt = 4.8 fb∫ = 7 TeV: s-1Ldt = 5.8 fb∫ = 8 TeV: s

4l→(*)ZZ→H

Data(*)Background ZZ

tBackground Z+jets, t=125 GeV)

HSignal (m

=150 GeV)H

Signal (m=190 GeV)

HSignal (mSyst.Unc.

Preliminary ATLAS

100 110 120 130 140 150 160

Eve

nts

/ GeV

0

200

400

600

800

1000

1200

1400

1600

1800

2000

2200

2400

Data 2011 and 2012 = 126.5 GeV)

HSig + Bkg inclusive fit (m

4th order polynomial

Selected diphoton sample

-1 Ldt = 4.8 fb∫ = 7 TeV, s

-1 Ldt = 5.9 fb∫ = 8 TeV, s

ATLAS Preliminary

[GeV]γγm

100 110 120 130 140 150 160

Dat

a - B

kg

-100

0

100

• Probability of background

∼ 0.2× 10−6

[GeV]Hm

110 115 120 125 130 135 140 145 150

0Lo

cal p

-710

-410

-110

210

510

810

Exp. Comb.

Obs. Comb.γγ →Exp. H

γγ →Obs. H

llll→ ZZ* →Exp. H

llll→ ZZ* →Obs. H

νlν l→ WW* →Exp. H

νlν l→ WW* →Obs. H

bb→Exp. H

bb→Obs. H

ττ →Exp. H

ττ →Obs. H

ATLAS Preliminary 2011 + 2012 Data = 7 TeVs, -1 L dt ~ 4.6-4.8 fb∫ = 8 TeVs, -1 L dt ~ 5.8-5.9 fb∫

σ0 σ1 σ2

σ3

σ4

σ5

Andrei Gritsan, JHU V May 29, 2014

Page 6: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

The Higgs Boson Signal on CMS

• Excellent signal H → ZZ,WW, γγ, τ+τ−, bb̄

6.8, 4.3, 3.2, 3.2, 2.1σ

(6.7, 5.8, 3.9, 3.7, 2.1σ expected)

Andrei Gritsan, JHU VI May 29, 2014

Page 7: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

Discovery of a Higgs Boson

• Discovery of a Higgs Boson

– absolutely new form of matter-energy

– consistent with fundamental JP = 0+

scalar excitation of a vacuum field

• It would be foolish to stop here

– mass (is Universe stable, are EW data consistent?..)

– width / lifetime (are there missing final states?)

– quantum numbers (is there CP violation?..)

– coupling strength in production and decay (is it the right Higgs?..)

• It is also a triumph of predictive power of scientific knowledge

– we knew where to look

– but a discovery was not guaranteed, also true for the next steps

Andrei Gritsan, JHU VII May 29, 2014

Page 8: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

The Higgs→ ZZ → 4ℓ Signal on CMS

Andrei Gritsan, JHU VIII May 29, 2014

Page 9: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

The Higgs→ ZZ → 4ℓ Signal on CMS

Andrei Gritsan, JHU IX May 29, 2014

Page 10: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

The Higgs→ ZZ → 4ℓ Signal on CMS

Andrei Gritsan, JHU X May 29, 2014

Page 11: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

TOPIC FOR TODAY

Page 12: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

References for Today Presentation

• ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width

from off-shell production and decay to Z-boson pairs”

CMS-HIG-14-002 (Moriond - 2014), arXiv:1405.3455 [hep-ex]

submitted to PLB on May 14, 2014

• ”Measurement of the properties of a Higgs boson

in the four-lepton final state” (CMS H → ZZ Run1 ”legacy”)

CMS-HIG-13-002 (Moriond - 2013), arXiv:1312.5353 [hep-ex]

published in PRD,89,092007 on May 14, 2014

• ”Higgs Working Group Report

of the Snowmass 2013 Community Planning Study”

arXiv:1310.8361 [hep-ex]

Andrei Gritsan, JHU XII May 29, 2014

Page 13: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

The Large Hadron Collider

Andrei Gritsan, JHU XIII May 29, 2014

Page 14: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

The CMS Detector

• Complex detector

to sort collision debris out

Andrei Gritsan, JHU XIV May 29, 2014

Page 15: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

The CMS Detector

Total weight 12500 t

Diameter 15 m

Length 22 m

Magnetic field 4 T

Andrei Gritsan, JHU XV May 29, 2014

Page 16: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

The Experiment

Andrei Gritsan, JHU XVI May 29, 2014

Page 17: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

Detection of Major Objects

• Leptons: ℓ± in Si Tracker: e± (EM Calorimeter), µ± (Muon System)

• Photons: γ (EM Calorimeter)

• Quark q & gluon g jets → ”Particle Flow” thru Hadronic Calorimer

• Neutrinos ν ⇒ missing energy (”MET”)

ZZ → (µ+µ−)(νν̄)

Andrei Gritsan, JHU XVII May 29, 2014

Page 18: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

Production and Decay of a Higgs Boson

• Excite vacuum: gg, VBF,.. → H → ZZ(∗), WW (∗), γγ, τ+τ−, bb̄,..

[GeV] HM80 100 200 300 400 1000

H+

X)

[pb

]

→(p

p

σ

-210

-110

1

10

210= 8 TeVs

LH

C H

IGG

S X

S W

G 2

01

2

H (NNLO+NNLL QCD + NLO EW)

→pp

qqH (NNLO QCD + NLO EW)

→pp

WH (NNLO QCD + NLO EW)

→pp

ZH (NNLO QCD +NLO EW)

→pp

ttH (NLO QCD)

→pp

[GeV]HM80 100 120 140 160 180 200

Hig

gs B

R +

Tot

al U

ncer

t

-410

-310

-210

-110

1

LH

C H

IGG

S X

S W

G 2

013

bb

ττ

µµ

cc

gg

γγ γZ

WW

ZZ

gg→Hqq→qqH

V→V H

Andrei Gritsan, JHU XVIII May 29, 2014

Page 19: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

Signal and Background

• At LHC might have produced > 200000 Higgs bosons / experiment

gluon fusion weak boson fusion associated production

• The challenge is to distinguish signal from backgrounds, examples:

qq̄ → ZZ(∗)(γ(∗)) qq̄ → Z(γ)+jets gg→ tt̄

Andrei Gritsan, JHU XIX May 29, 2014

Page 20: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

Track / Mass Resolution

• H → ZZ → (ℓ+ℓ−)(ℓ+ℓ−)

– excellent mass resolution ∼ 1%

– good control with Z, J/ψ → ℓ+ℓ−

– measure mass mH and width ΓH

Andrei Gritsan, JHU XX May 29, 2014

Page 21: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

Fit mass and width of Higgs→ ZZ → 4ℓ

• Employ a 3D fit

m4ℓ – invariant mass

Dkinbkg – MELA (matrix element likelihood) to suppress background

δm4ℓ – per-event error estimate on invariant mass

(GeV)l4m

120 130 140 150 160 170 180

bkg

kin

D

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

0.254e

µ4

µ2e2

CMS-1

= 8 TeV, L = 19.7 fbs ; -1

= 7 TeV, L = 5.1 fbs

Andrei Gritsan, JHU XXI May 29, 2014

Page 22: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

Test with Z → 4ℓ

• Excellent candle Z → ℓ+ℓ−γ∗ → ℓ+ℓ−ℓ+ℓ−

mZ = 91.12± 0.37 GeV (compare PDG 91.19 GeV)

ΓZ = 3.6+1.0−0.8 GeV (compare PDG 2.50 GeV)

Andrei Gritsan, JHU XXII May 29, 2014

Page 23: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

Mass H(126)

• Employ a 3D fit

mH = 125.6± 0.4 (stat.)± 0.2 (syst.) GeV

Andrei Gritsan, JHU XXIII May 29, 2014

Page 24: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

Width H(126)

• Employ a 3D fit

ΓH = 0.0+1.3−0.0 GeV < 3.4 GeV at 95% CL

expect ΓSMH = 0.00415 GeV at mH = 125.6 GeV

Andrei Gritsan, JHU XXIV May 29, 2014

Page 25: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

CAN WE DO BETTER?

Page 26: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

Off-shell effects

• mH = 125.6 GeV < 2mZ = 182.4 GeV

⇒ H → Z(∗)Z∗ with off-shell Z∗ ⇒ suppression

• Higgs boson remains on shell dσgg→H→ZZ

dm2ZZ

∼g2ggHg

2HZZ

(m2ZZ −m2

H)2 +m2

HΓ2H

Andrei Gritsan, JHU XXVI May 29, 2014

Page 27: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

Higgs off-shell effects

100

2 MW

2 MZ 2 Mt 1000

10−6

10−5

10−4

10−3

10−2

10−1

WW

ZZ

HTO powered by complex - pole - scheme

8 TeV

MV V [ GeV]

M2 VV

dM

2 VV

[pb]

• Sizeable off shell H

gg → H → Z(∗)Z∗

on shell H, suppressed Z∗

gg → H∗ → ZZ

suppressed H∗, on shell Z

N. Kauer, G. Passarino

arXiv:1206.4803 [hep-ph]

MC: gg2VV, LO in QCD

Tot [pb] mZZ > 2mZ [pb] R[%]

gg → H → all 19.146 0.1525 0.8

gg → H → ZZ 0.5462 0.0416 7.6

Andrei Gritsan, JHU XXVII May 29, 2014

Page 28: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

Higgs boson width from off-shell production

dσgg→H→ZZ

dm2ZZ

∼g2ggHg

2HZZ

(m2ZZ −m2

H)2 +m2

HΓH2

• On peak (mZZ ∼ mH) and off peak (mZZ −mH ≫ ΓH)

F. Caola, K. Melnikov: arXiv:1307.4935 [hep-ph]

σonpeakgg→H→ZZ = constg2ggHg

2HZZ

ΓH

σoffpeakgg→H→ZZ = const′ g2ggHg2HZZ

⇒ measurement of ΓH

• Complication: signal - background destructive interference

Andrei Gritsan, JHU XXVIII May 29, 2014

Page 29: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

Higgs boson width from off-shell production

σonpeakgg→H→ZZ = constg2ggHg

2HZZ

ΓH

σoffpeakgg→H→ZZ = const′ g2ggHg2HZZ

• Given the signal strength at the peak µ = σ/σSM

⇒ off-shell signal ∝ ΓH , interference ∝√ΓH

Andrei Gritsan, JHU XXIX May 29, 2014

Page 30: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

Monte Carlo Simulation (off shell)

100100100 200200200 300300300 400400400 500500500 600600600 700700700 800800800 900900900 100010001000

000

0.20.20.2

0.40.40.4

0.60.60.6

0.80.80.8

1.01.01.0

1.21.21.2

NNLO

LO

HHH virtuality [ GeV]

Lin

eshape

by Giampiero

arXiv:1312.2397

• gg → ZZ(∗)/Zγ∗ gg2VV and

MCFM: J. Campbell, K. Ellis, C. Williams

arXiv:1311.3589 [hep-ph]

– LO in QCD, Pythia shower

– running QCD scale µR,F = mZZ/2

– uncertainties µR,F ∈ [mZZ ,mZZ/4]

– signal K-factor ∼ 2

– bkg K-factor = signal K ±10%

(soft-collinear approximation arXiv:1304.3053 for gg → WW )

• No references for width studies in VBF: V ∗V ∗ → ZZ(∗)

use Phantom: A. Ballestrero et al., arXiv:0801.3359 [hep-ph]

• Generate sig, bkg, sig+bkg+interference ⇒ extract interference

match signal on-peak cross-section to best knownAndrei Gritsan, JHU XXX May 29, 2014

Page 31: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

Monte Carlo Simulation

[GeV]T

p0 50 100 150 200 250

0

0.05

0.1

• On-shell signal MC arXiv:1309.4819

– NLO QCD production POWHEG

– H → V V → 4f decay JHUGen

– anomalous couplings with JHUGen

spin-0, 1, 2, qq̄, gg, VBF, V H, H2j

• Dominant qq̄ → ZZ background

– NLO QCD POWHEG

NLO EW re-weighting

follow arXiv:1307.4331, arXiv:1305.5402

−(5− 10)% in 220− 500 GeV range

∼ 40% uncertainty on the correction

Andrei Gritsan, JHU XXXI May 29, 2014

Page 32: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

Use Kinematics to Suppress Background

• One challenge is the dominant qq̄ → ZZ background

• Follow the same approach as at the Higgs discovery

MELA technique

(Matrix Element Likelihood Approach)

to suppress qq̄ → ZZ

vs gg → ...→ ZZ

MELA > 0.5

Andrei Gritsan, JHU XXXII May 29, 2014

Page 33: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

Matrix Element Likelihood Approach

Andrei Gritsan, JHU XXXIII May 29, 2014

Page 34: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

Matrix Element Likelihood Approach

Andrei Gritsan, JHU XXXIV May 29, 2014

Page 35: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

Matrix Element Likelihood Approach

vs.

• Optimal discriminant to separate gg → ZZ vs qq̄ → ZZ

Dgg =Pgg

tot

Pggtot + Pqq̄

bkg

=

1 +Pqq̄

bkg

10×Pggsig +

√10× Pgg

int + Pggbkg

−1

MCFM - continuum, JHUGen - onpeak signal, analytical

• Higgs discovery:

Dkinbkg =

P0+

P0+ + Pqq̄bkg

• Higgs spin-parity:

DJP =P0+

P0+ + PJP

Andrei Gritsan, JHU XXXV May 29, 2014

Page 36: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

Kinematics

• MELA Dgg(mZZ ,mZ1,mZ2, cos θ1, cos θ2, cos θ∗,Φ,Φ1)

Andrei Gritsan, JHU XXXVI May 29, 2014

Page 37: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

H∗ → ZZ → 4ℓ Mass after Kinematic Selection

• Optimal use of kinematic information

before after Dgg > 0.65

Andrei Gritsan, JHU XXXVII May 29, 2014

Page 38: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

Semileptonic Channel H → ZZ → 2ℓ2ν

• Partial reco, but ×5.5 higher branching

⇒ comparable to 4ℓ sensitivity at high mass

but no hope at low mass (overwhelmed with Z+jets background)

m2T =

[

pT,2ℓ2 +m2ℓ2 +

EmissT

2+m2ℓ

2

]2

−[

~pT,2ℓ + ~EmissT

]2

Andrei Gritsan, JHU XXXVIII May 29, 2014

Page 39: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

Semileptonic Channel H → ZZ → 2ℓ2ν

• Partial reco, but ×5.5 higher branching

⇒ comparable to 4ℓ sensitivity at high mass

but no hope at low mass (overwhelmed with Z+jets background)

m2T =

[

pT,2ℓ2 +m2ℓ2 +

EmissT

2+m2ℓ

2

]2

−[

~pT,2ℓ + ~EmissT

]2

Andrei Gritsan, JHU XXXIX May 29, 2014

Page 40: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

Look at enhanced signal region

• For illustration purpose define the enhanced signal regions

H → ZZ → 4ℓ H → ZZ → 2ℓ2ν

m4ℓ > 330 GeV, Dgg > 0.65 mT > 350 GeV, EmissT > 100 GeV

Andrei Gritsan, JHU XL May 29, 2014

Page 41: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

Enhanced signal H → ZZ → 4ℓ and 2ℓ2ν

4ℓ 2ℓ2ν

(a) total gg (ΓH = ΓSM

H) 1.8±0.3 9.6±1.5

gg signal component (ΓH = ΓSM

H) 1.3±0.2 4.7±0.6

gg background component 2.3±0.4 10.8±1.7

(b) total gg (ΓH = 10× ΓSM

H) 9.9±1.2 39.8±5.2

(c) total VBF (ΓH = ΓSM

H) 0.23±0.01 0.90±0.05

VBF signal component (ΓH = ΓSM

H) 0.11±0.01 0.32±0.02

VBF background component 0.35±0.02 1.22±0.07

(d) total VBF (ΓH = 10× ΓSM

H) 0.77±0.04 2.40±0.14

(e) qq̄ background 9.3±0.7 47.6±4.0

(f) other backgrounds 0.05±0.02 35.1±4.2

(a+c+e+f) total expected (ΓH = ΓSM

H) 11.4±0.8 93.2±6.0

(b+d+e+f) total expected (ΓH = 10× ΓSM

H) 20.1±1.4 124.9±7.8

observed 11 91

Andrei Gritsan, JHU XLI May 29, 2014

Page 42: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

How to Extract the Width• Relative size of low and high mass Higgs signal

– analysis at high mass ⇒ gggH gHZZ (gg→ H) or gHVV gHZZ (VBF)

– must relate to on-peak to measure Γ

• Composition of production: gg→ H vs VBF

– need to know to describe the shape

• Is the coupling gHVV(mZZ) running (anomalous)?

Andrei Gritsan, JHU XLII May 29, 2014

Page 43: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

Extracting the Width

• Determine strength and production composition from the peak

– µggH and µVBF provide both (ratio to SM µ = σ/σSM)

Ponshelltot (~x) = µggH × [Pgg

sig(~x) + P tt̄Hsig (~x)] + µVBF × [PVBF

sig (~x) + PVHsig (~x)]

+ Pqq̄bkg(~x) + Pgg

bkg(~x) + . . .

• Relate to high mass

– ΓH is the only free parameter remaining

Poffshelltot (~x) =

µggH × ΓH

Γ0× Pgg

sig(~x) +

√µggH × ΓH

Γ0×Pgg

int(~x) + Pggbkg(~x)

+

µVBF ×ΓH

Γ0× PVBF

sig (~x) +

√µVBF ×ΓH

Γ0×PVBF

int (~x) + PVBFbkg (~x)

+ Pqq̄bkg(~x) + . . .

Andrei Gritsan, JHU XLIII May 29, 2014

Page 44: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

CONSTRAINTS FROM THE LOW MASS

Page 45: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

Constraints from the low mass

• Employ a 3D fit and 2 jet tagging catetories

m4ℓ – invariant mass

Dkinbkg – MELA (matrix element likelihood) to suppress background

if at least 2 jets: Djet – to identify VBF or VH (mjj, ηjj)

if <2 jets: pT (4ℓ) – to identify VBF or VH

Andrei Gritsan, JHU XLV May 29, 2014

Page 46: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

Constraints from the low mass

• Employ a 3D fit and 2 jet tagging catetories

m4ℓ – invariant mass

Dkinbkg – MELA (matrix element likelihood) to suppress background

if at least 2 jets: Djet – to identify VBF or VH (mjj, ηjj)

if <2 jets: pT (4ℓ) – to identify VBF or VH

(GeV)l4m

120 130 140 150 160 170 180

bkg

kin

D

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

0.254e

µ4

µ2e2

CMS-1

= 8 TeV, L = 19.7 fbs ; -1

= 7 TeV, L = 5.1 fbs

Andrei Gritsan, JHU XLVI May 29, 2014

Page 47: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

Production Mechanism Results

Ponshelltot (~x) = µggH × [Pgg

sig(~x) + P tt̄Hsig (~x)] + µVBF × [PVBF

sig (~x) + PVHsig (~x)]

+ Pqq̄bkg(~x) + Pgg

bkg(~x) + . . .

µggH = 0.80+0.46−0.36 σSM(ggH + tt̄H) = 14.99 pb + 0.085 pb

µVBF = 1.7+2.2−2.1 σSM(VBF+ V H) = 1.214 pb + 0.896 pb

µ = σ/σSM = 0.93+0.26+0.13−0.23−0.09

Andrei Gritsan, JHU XLVII May 29, 2014

Page 48: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

CONSTRAINTS FROM THE HIGH MASS

Page 49: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

High Mass: H → ZZ → 4ℓ

Poffshelltot (~x) =

µggH × ΓH

Γ0× Pgg

sig(~x) +

√µggH × ΓH

Γ0×Pgg

int(~x) + Pggbkg(~x)

+

µVBF ×ΓH

Γ0×PVBF

sig (~x) +

√µVBF ×ΓH

Γ0× PVBF

int (~x) + PVBFbkg (~x)

ΓH = 1.9+11.7−1.9 MeV < 33 MeV at 95% CL

expected: 4.2+17.3−4.2 MeV < 42 MeV at 95% CL

Andrei Gritsan, JHU XLIX May 29, 2014

Page 50: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

1D Fit in H → ZZ → 4ℓ

Andrei Gritsan, JHU L May 29, 2014

Page 51: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

High Mass: H → ZZ → 2ℓ2ν

• Combine H → ZZ → 2ℓ2ν at high mass and 4ℓ at low mass

ΓH = 1.8+12.4−1.8 MeV < 33 MeV at 95% CL

expected: 4.2+19.3−4.2 MeV < 44 MeV at 95% CL

Andrei Gritsan, JHU LI May 29, 2014

Page 52: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

Combined Result

ΓH = 1.8+7.7−1.8 MeV < 22 MeV = 5.4× ΓSM

H at 95% CL

expected: 4.2+13.5−4.2 MeV < 33 MeV = 8× ΓSM

H at 95% CL

Andrei Gritsan, JHU LII May 29, 2014

Page 53: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

Model (in)dependence

σonpeakgg→H→ZZ = constg2ggHg

2HZZ

Γσoffpeakgg→H→ZZ = const′ g2ggHg

2HZZ

• Higgs boson coupling HV V (gHV V )

– experimental limits prefer tree-level SM HV V coupling

– anomalous HV V couplings enhance off-shell production

⇒ conservative limit

• Higgs boson production in gluon fusion (gggH)

– top quark dominance, no new particles in the loop

• Higgs boson production mechanism

– very mild dependence (e.g. VH vs VBF), fit directly in the data

• Background model

– no BSM in background; benefit from improved SM calculations

Andrei Gritsan, JHU LIII May 29, 2014

Page 54: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

CP Results in H → ZZ → 4ℓ

• Assumed tree-level HV V coupling either in decay or VBF production

A(HV V ) =1

v

(

a1m2V ǫ

∗1ǫ

∗2 + a2f

∗(1)µν f ∗(2),µν + a3f

∗(1)µν f̃ ∗(2),µν

)

SM Higgs 0+: (a1) CP ∼few% (a2) CP ∼10−10 ? (a3) CP6

(or beyond SM) (or beyond SM)

• Test with optimal MELA observables for many JP models, e.g. 0−

Andrei Gritsan, JHU LIV May 29, 2014

Page 55: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

CP Results in H → ZZ → 4ℓ

• Exclude pure pseudo-scalar 0− at 99.95% CL

fa3 =σ(a3)

σ(a1) + σ(a3)= 0.00+0.17

−0.00 < 0.51 at 95%CL

• and many other models:

spin-0, 1, 2

consistent with JP = 0+

Andrei Gritsan, JHU LV May 29, 2014

Page 56: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

Anomalous HV V Couplings and Off-shell Effects

A(HV V ) =1

v

(

g1m2V ǫ

∗1ǫ

∗2 + g2f

∗(1)µν f ∗(2),µν + g4f

∗(1)µν f̃ ∗(2),µν

)

• Higher-dimensional non-renormalizable operators lead to

σ4/σ1 blowing up at higher q2 (for pseudoscalar 0−)

same effect for 0+h , spin-2, spin-1; example of f f̄ → V ∗(q2) → V H

[GeV] s200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000

[fb]

σ

1

10

210

310

410

[GeV] s200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000

[fb]

σ

1

10

210

310

410

0−

0+h

0+m (SM) 0+m (SM)

arXiv:1309.4819 Analytic MELA calc.

Andrei Gritsan, JHU LVI May 29, 2014

Page 57: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

Anomalous HV V Couplings and Off-shell Effects

• Same enhancement σi/σ1 with higher-dim. operators H∗(q2 = m2ZZ)

[GeV] ZZm200 400 600 800 1000 1200

1σ/ 4σ

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

[GeV] ZZm200 400 600 800 1000 1200

1σ/ 2σ

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

JHUGenMELA calc.

AnalyticMELA calc.

similar study also in arXiv:1403.4951 [hep-ph]

• Conclusion on anomalous HV V couplings:

– experimental data consistent with SM coupling a1

– there is still room for small anomalous contributions

– width constraint would be only tighter if those are present

Andrei Gritsan, JHU LVII May 29, 2014

Page 58: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

Anomalous ggH Couplings

• In gg → H rely on the dominance of t-quark in the loop

– assume no new particles in the loop

– otherwise some modification to offshell / onshell ratio

Andrei Gritsan, JHU LVIII May 29, 2014

Page 59: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

WHAT IS THE HIGGS BOSON LIFETIME

Page 60: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

Higgs Boson Lifetime

• How long does the Higgs boson live?

τH =h̄

ΓH, expect 1.6× 10−22 s

we know it is not stable (H → ZZ, ...)

observe 0.3× 10−22 s < τH <∞

• Can we set a better upper bound?

– expect σv ∼ 50µm vertex resolution, p ∼ 50 GeV

– flight distance ∼ pmccτH ∼ 2 · 10−14 m = 20 fm ∼ 4× 10−10 × σv

could reach 0.3× 10−22 s < τH < (?) 0.4× 10−12 s <∞

Andrei Gritsan, JHU LX May 29, 2014

Page 61: How Wide is the Higgs Boson: off-shell constraints from CMS · 2014-07-24 · References for Today Presentation • ”Constraints on the Higgs boson width from off-shell production

Summary: How Wide is the Higgs Boson?

0 < ΓH < 22 MeV = 5.4× ΓSMH at 95% CL

(0.3× 10−22 s < τH <∞)

mild assumptions (no new particles in ggH loop)

• Rich physics with the Higgs boson

– mass

– width and lifetime

– quantum numbers / CP

– production and decay couplings

• So far consistent picture

reduced room to decay to new states...

Andrei Gritsan, JHU LXI May 29, 2014