Greece On the road to recovery - Eurobank Ergasias · Greece On the road to recovery Adjustment...

of 33 /33
Greece On the road to recovery Adjustment program success stories, investment opportunities & challenges lying ahead Dr. Platon Monokroussos Chief Market Economist Eurobank July 2014

Embed Size (px)

Transcript of Greece On the road to recovery - Eurobank Ergasias · Greece On the road to recovery Adjustment...

  • Greece

    On the road to recovery

    Adjustment program success stories,

    investment opportunities

    & challenges lying ahead

    Dr. Platon Monokroussos

    Chief Market Economist

    Eurobank

    July 2014

  • 2

    Adjustment program success stories &

    socioeconomic costs

    Source: ELSTAT, BoG, Eurobank Global Markets Research

    Success stories 2009 2013Δ 2013/2009

    (improvement)

    General government balance (% GDP) -15.6 -3.2 12.4 ppts

    General government primary balance (% GDP) -10.5 0.8 11.3 ppts

    Interest expense (euro bn) 12.3 7.2 5.1 billion

    Current account balance (% GDP) -11.2 0.7 11.9 ppts

    Current account excl. oil, ships & net interest payment (% GDP) -2.6 7.1 9.7 ppts

    Socioeconomic costs 2009 2013Δ 2013/2009

    (deterioration)

    Nominal GDP (euro bn) 231.1 182.1 49 bn

    Unemployment rate (%, e.o.p) 10.5 27.1 16.6 ppts

    Total number of employeed of 15yrs of age and over (thousands) 4,461 3,573 888 thousands

    Gross public debt (% GDP) 129.7 175.1 45.4 ppts

    Rise in gross public debt due to snowball effect (ppts-of-GDP) 59ppts

  • 3

    Real sector developments

    Summary of views

    improvement in sentiment indicators increasingly reflected in hard economic data

    real GDP growth to shift into positive territory from Q3 2014 onwards

    upside risks to the troika forecasts for private consumption & imports growth

    tourism, energy, manufacturing (food processing), agriculture, retail & whole trade among the main

    growth drivers in the coming decade

    Risks

    negative carry over from last year’s recession (-0.6ppts)

    still negative savings rate of households & huge disinvestment in the domestic economy

    supply-side constraints to domestic credit

    reforms fatigue and resistance from vested interests

  • 4

    Tourism sector contribution

    16.5% in GDP (GVA); 18.5% of total employment

    10.7 11.4 11.3

    11.6

    10.4

    9.6

    10.5 10.4

    12.2

    13.0

    0.0

    2.0

    4.0

    6.0

    8.0

    10.0

    12.0

    14.0

    2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014f

    Travel receipts ( EUR bn)

    6.8% 1.7%

    4.7%

    6.3% 2.5%

    18.3%

    Albania Australia Switzerland USA Canada Russia

    Incoming passengers in 2013 by country of origin (% of total arrivals from non-EU countries)

    2014(f): 19mn visitors; >13bn direct revenue

    2021 target: 22-24mn visitors; €18-19bn in

    direct revenue 34.4

    15.2 12.0 8.6 11.3

    26.6

    9.1

    18.0

    1.6

    34.2

    -8.1

    53.3

    25.7

    16.2

    3.5

    -20

    -10

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    60

    Ath

    ens

    The

    ssal

    on

    iki

    Rh

    od

    es

    Ko

    s

    Her

    akle

    ion

    Ch

    ania

    Co

    rfu

    Zaky

    nth

    os

    Ke

    falo

    nia

    San

    tori

    ni

    Ara

    xos

    Kal

    amat

    a

    Sam

    os

    Skia

    tho

    s

    Kav

    ala

    Incoming passenger traffic: January-May 2014, YoY%

    Source: SETE, ELSTAT, BoG, Eurobank Global Markets Research

  • 5 Source: ELSTAT, Eurobank Global Markets Research

    Industrial sector contribution

    Industry (incl. construction) 16% in GDP (GVA);

    manufacturing 10% in GDP

    35

    40

    45

    50

    55

    60

    Mar

    -05

    Sep

    -05

    Mar

    -06

    Sep

    -06

    Mar

    -07

    Sep

    -07

    Mar

    -08

    Sep

    -08

    Mar

    -09

    Sep

    -09

    Mar

    -10

    Sep

    -10

    Mar

    -11

    Sep

    -11

    Mar

    -12

    Sep

    -12

    Mar

    -13

    Sep

    -13

    Mar

    -14

    Greek Manufacturing PMI (3mma)boom-bust threshold

    -15.0%

    -10.0%

    -5.0%

    0.0%

    5.0%

    10.0%

    Mar

    -01

    No

    v-0

    1

    Jul-

    02

    Mar

    -03

    No

    v-0

    3

    Jul-

    04

    Mar

    -05

    No

    v-0

    5

    Jul-

    06

    Mar

    -07

    No

    v-0

    7

    Jul-

    08

    Mar

    -09

    No

    v-0

    9

    Jul-

    10

    Mar

    -11

    No

    v-11

    Jul-

    12

    Mar

    -13

    No

    v-13

    Industrial & manufacturing output (YoY, %, 3mma)

    Total industry

    Manufacturing

    -50

    -40

    -30

    -20

    -10

    0

    10

    20

    Ap

    r-9

    7

    Fe

    b-9

    8

    Dec

    -98

    Oct

    -99

    Au

    g-0

    0

    Jun

    -01

    Ap

    r-0

    2

    Fe

    b-0

    3

    Dec

    -03

    Oct

    -04

    Au

    g-0

    5

    Jun

    -06

    Ap

    r-0

    7

    Fe

    b-0

    8

    Dec

    -08

    Oct

    -09

    Au

    g-1

    0

    Jun

    -11

    Ap

    r-12

    Fe

    b-1

    3

    Dec

    -13

    Industrial Confidence Indicator

    Greece Eurozone

  • 6 Source: ELSTAT, Eurobank Global Markets Research

    Trade contribution

    Retail & wholesale19% in GDP (GVA) &18% in total

    employment; retail 7% in GDP

    -50

    -40

    -30

    -20

    -10

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    -20

    -15

    -10

    -5

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    Jan

    -01

    Jan

    -02

    Jan

    -03

    Jan

    -04

    Jan

    -05

    Jan

    -06

    Jan

    -07

    Jan

    -08

    Jan

    -09

    Jan

    -10

    Jan

    -11

    Jan

    -12

    Jan

    -13

    Jan

    -14

    Retail trade indicators

    Turnover, YoY%, 3mma

    Volume, YoY%, 3mma

    Confidence index (r.s)

    -80

    -60

    -40

    -20

    0

    20

    40

    Jan

    -07

    May

    -07

    Sep

    -07

    Jan

    -08

    May

    -08

    Sep

    -08

    Jan

    -09

    May

    -09

    Sep

    -09

    Jan

    -10

    May

    -10

    Sep

    -10

    Jan

    -11

    May

    -11

    Sep

    -11

    Jan

    -12

    May

    -12

    Sep

    -12

    Jan

    -13

    May

    -13

    Sep

    -13

    Jan

    -14

    May

    -14

    Road Motor Vehicles (%, YoY)

    -60

    -50

    -40

    -30

    -20

    -10

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    Ap

    r-9

    3

    May

    -94

    Jun

    -95

    Jul-

    96

    Au

    g-9

    7

    Sep

    -98

    Oct

    -99

    No

    v-0

    0

    Dec

    -01

    Jan

    -03

    Fe

    b-0

    4

    Mar

    -05

    Ap

    r-0

    6

    May

    -07

    Jun

    -08

    Jul-

    09

    Au

    g-1

    0

    Sep

    -11

    Oct

    -12

    No

    v-13

    Retail Trade Confidence Indicator

    Greece Eurozone

  • 7

    Construction sector contribution

    GVA: 3.5% vs.16.3% in 2006

    0

    10,000

    20,000

    30,000

    40,000

    50,000

    60,000

    20

    00

    20

    01

    20

    02

    20

    03

    20

    04

    20

    05

    20

    06

    20

    07

    20

    08

    20

    09

    20

    10

    20

    11

    20

    12

    20

    13

    Gross investment components (EURmn, s.a., 2005=100)

    Other

    Other construction

    Dwellings

    Transportequipment

    Metal productsand machinery

    Source: BoG , Eurobank Global Markets Research

    -40

    -30

    -20

    -10

    0

    10

    20

    Jul-

    90

    Au

    g-9

    1

    Sep

    -92

    Oct

    -93

    No

    v-9

    4

    Dec

    -95

    Jan

    -97

    Fe

    b-9

    8

    Mar

    -99

    Ap

    r-0

    0

    May

    -01

    Jun

    -02

    Jul-

    03

    Au

    g-0

    4

    Sep

    -05

    Oct

    -06

    No

    v-0

    7

    Dec

    -08

    Jan

    -10

    Fe

    b-1

    1

    Mar

    -12

    Ap

    r-13

    May

    -14

    Construction Confidence Indicator

    Euro area Greece

    Baseline Adverse

    2008 0.3 0.3

    2009 -4.2 -4.2

    2010 -7.0 -7.0

    2011 -6.7 -6.7

    2012 -12.8 -12.8

    2013 -9.3 -9.3

    2014(f) -5.9 -9.0

    2015(f) 1.0 -3.9

    2016(f) 2.9 0.9

    Eurobank Research VECM model for explaining residential housing

    prices in Greece

    (realizations & forecasts, YoY %)

  • 8

    Eurobank GDP NOWcasting model

    Q2 2014 estimate & short-term forecasts

    Source: EL.STAT., Eurobank

    GDP Nowcasting Model estimates based on the following

    high-frequency indicators:

    "RS","AUTO","UNEMPL","NOFEMP","HIRES","CPI","BUILD","IP","MA

    NF","MANORDER","IPTURN","CREDIT","REERCPI",

    "REERULC","ECONSENT","ASEVOL"

    -6.0%

    -5.0%

    -4.0%

    -3.0%

    -2.0%

    -1.0%

    0.0%

    1.0%

    2.0%

    3.0%

    2Q

    20

    14

    4Q

    20

    13

    2Q

    20

    13

    4Q

    20

    12

    2Q

    20

    12

    4Q

    20

    11

    2Q

    20

    11

    4Q

    20

    10

    2Q

    20

    10

    4Q

    20

    09

    2Q

    20

    09

    4Q

    20

    08

    2Q

    20

    08

    4Q

    20

    07

    2Q

    20

    07

    Real GDP realised (QoQ %, s.a.)

    Nowcasting model fitted values

    -1.1

    %

    -2.5

    %

    -6.6

    %

    -9.2

    %

    -8.3

    %

    -8.0

    %

    -4.3

    %

    -8.0

    %

    -7.8

    %

    -7.4

    %

    -7.7

    %

    -4.9

    %

    -6.0

    % -

    4.0

    %

    -3.2

    %

    -2.3

    %

    -0.9

    %

    -0.3

    %

    1.1%

    -13.0%

    -11.0%

    -9.0%

    -7.0%

    -5.0%

    -3.0%

    -1.0%

    1.0%

    3.0%

    5.0%

    Q1

    20

    10

    Q2

    20

    10

    Q3

    20

    10

    Q4

    20

    10

    Q1

    20

    11

    Q2

    20

    11

    Q3

    20

    11

    Q4

    20

    11

    Q1

    20

    12

    Q2

    20

    12

    Q3

    20

    12

    Q4

    20

    12

    Q1

    20

    13

    Q2

    20

    13

    Q3

    20

    13

    Q4

    20

    13

    Q1

    20

    14

    Q2

    20

    14

    Q3

    20

    14

    Real GDP YoY growth (realizations & short-term forecasts)

    -35.0%

    -25.0%

    -15.0%

    -5.0%

    5.0%

    15.0%

    25.0%

    35.0%

    45.0%

    -15.0%

    -10.0%

    -5.0%

    0.0%

    5.0%

    10.0%

    15.0%

    20

    01

    Q1

    20

    01

    Q4

    20

    02

    Q3

    20

    03

    Q2

    20

    04

    Q1

    20

    04

    Q4

    20

    05

    Q3

    20

    06

    Q2

    20

    07

    Q1

    20

    07

    Q4

    20

    08

    Q3

    20

    09

    Q2

    20

    10 Q

    1

    20

    10 Q

    4

    20

    11 Q

    3

    20

    12 Q

    2

    20

    13 Q

    1

    20

    13 Q

    4

    Private Consumption YoY,% (left)

    Investments YoY,% (right)

  • 9

    Labor market conditions

    Unemployment still unacceptably high, but gradual

    improvement already underway

    Source: EL.STAT, Ministry of Labour , ERGANI, IMF (June 2014), Eurobank Global Markets Research

  • 10

    Greek GDP realizations and forecasts

    Components, contributions & risks

    Source: IMF , EC, ELSTAT, Eurobank Global Markets Research

    2.9

    -1.1

    -4.6 -5.6

    -6.7

    -4.2

    -0.9

    1.0 -0.5

    0.9

    -1.7 -1.0

    -1.3

    -0.8

    -0.8

    -0.3

    -2.8

    -6.0

    -1.5

    -3.0

    -2.9

    -1.0

    0.7

    1.5

    0.1

    3.0

    3.0 2.4 3.8

    2.0 1.6

    0.7

    -11.0

    -9.0

    -7.0

    -5.0

    -3.0

    -1.0

    1.0

    3.0

    5.0

    2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015

    Net exports GCF

    Public consumption Private consumption

    Contributors to real GDP growth

    (realizations & forecasts)

    YoY growth 2008-2012 2013 2014(f) 2015(f) Risks

    Private

    consumption -20.6% -6.0% -1.8% 1.7%

    Public

    consumption -18.4% -4.1% -1.7% -2.0%

    Investments -81.9% -12.8% 5.9% 9.7%

    Exports g&s -13.9% 1.8% 4.1% 5.2%

    Imports g&s -46.6% -5.3% -1.3% 2.2%

    GDP -22.5% -3.9% 0.6% 2.9%

    GDP components & risks

  • 11

    Potential sources of long-term economic growth

    18.0

    9.0

    6.5

    4.5

    4.3

    1.9

    1.4

    1.3

    1.0

    0.6

    0.45

    0.1

    0.027

    Tourism

    Energy

    Manufacturing - Food processing

    Agriculture - Crops agriculture

    Retail and wholesale

    Manufacturing of generics pharmaceuticals

    Aquaculture

    Regional Cargo & Logistics hub (tsansshipment and gateway)

    Long-term and Elderly care

    Waste Management

    Medical Tourism (mainly outpatient)

    Greek Specialty Foods

    Classics hub

    Additional annual GVA (in EURbn) over 10-year horizon

    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    Rising Stars

    Major Sectors

    Source: McKinsey & Co, 2012

  • 12

    Fiscal developments

    Summary of views

    fiscal adjustment unpredicted by historical standards

    State budget execution data support attainability of full-year fiscal target

    full coverage of projected financing gap achievable up to at least 2020

    public debt more sustainable now than in 2009

    new debt relief (OSI) expected upon completion of next troika review

    Risks

    recent court decisions to cancel certain wage cuts in 2012 (armed forces & emergency services personnel)

    may create the need for offsetting budgetary measures

    challenging medium-term primary surplus target (4.0%-4.5%-of-GDP)

  • 13

    Fiscal adjustment unprecedented by historical standards

    Adjustment mainly driven by the expenditure side

    Cumulative improvement in 2009-2013

    General gvnt balance: 12.4ppts-of-GDP

    General gvnt primary balance: 11.3ppts-of-GDP

    Cyclically adj. primary balance: 19.3ppts-of-GDP

    -13.6

    -6.3

    -1.3

    2.5

    5.7

    -20.0

    -15.0

    -10.0

    -5.0

    0.0

    5.0

    10.0

    2009 2010 2011 2012 2013

    Cyclically adj. primary balance (% potential GDP)

    Primary balance (% GDP)

    General gvnt balance (% GDP)

    -1

    0

    1

    2

    3

    4

    -1

    0

    1

    2

    3

    4

    Pro

    per

    ty in

    com

    e

    Oth

    er c

    urr

    ent

    tran

    sfer

    s

    So

    cial

    con

    trib

    uti

    on

    s

    Cap

    ital

    tra

    nsf

    ers

    Sal

    es

    Pro

    du

    ctio

    n&

    imp

    ort

    tax

    es

    Inco

    me&

    wea

    lth

    taxe

    s

    Fiscal Adjustment in Revenues, 2008-13 (percent of potential GDP)

    -1

    0

    1

    2

    3

    4

    -1

    0

    1

    2

    3

    4

    Su

    bsi

    die

    s

    Oth

    er c

    urr

    ent

    tran

    sfer

    s

    Cap

    ital

    tra

    nsf

    ers

    Gro

    ss c

    apit

    alfo

    rmat

    ion

    Inte

    rest

    Co

    mp

    ensa

    tio

    n o

    fem

    plo

    yees

    Inte

    rmed

    iate

    con

    sum

    pti

    on

    So

    cial

    ben

    efit

    s

    Fiscal Adjustment in Expenditures, 2008-13 (percent of potential GDP)

    Source: IMF , EC, Eurobank Global Markets Research

  • 14

    Public debt more sustainable now than in 2009

    That is, despite the rise in the debt ratio by

    ca 45.5ppts over the period 2009-2013

    Source: IMF , EC, Eurobank Global Markets Research

    Evolution of Greek public debt ratio

    Scenario analysis based on different assumptions regarding

    a) size & degree of persistence of fiscal multipliers; b) size

    & profile of fiscal adjustment; c) response of financial

    markets to fiscal consolidation

    125%

    145%

    165%

    185%

    205%

    225%

    245%

    265%

    20

    09

    20

    10

    20

    11

    20

    12

    20

    13

    20

    14

    20

    15

    20

    16

    20

    17

    20

    18

    20

    19

    No adjustment(nominal IR on debtfixed a 2009 level)

    No adjustment (debtrefinancing atconsesional rates)

    Full adjustment

    Partial adjustment

    Gradual adjustment 1

    Gradual adjustment 2

    Troika baseline DSA

    2.0 2.3

    2.7 2.8 3.1

    3.4 3.5 3.7 3.8 3.9

    4.4 4.7

    0.0

    1.0

    2.0

    3.0

    4.0

    5.0

    Net

    he

    rlan

    ds

    Ger

    man

    y

    Fran

    ce

    Au

    stri

    a

    Gre

    ece

    Bel

    giu

    m

    Po

    rtu

    gal

    Slo

    vak

    Rep

    .

    Sp

    ain

    Irel

    and

    Ital

    y

    Slo

    ven

    ia

    Nominal interest rate on debt 2013-2018 (%)

    1.5 1.7 2.0 2.0

    2.4 2.8 3.2

    3.3 3.6 4.1 4.3

    4.9 5.5

    0.0

    1.0

    2.0

    3.0

    4.0

    5.0

    6.0

    Net

    he

    rlan

    ds

    Ger

    man

    y

    Au

    stri

    a

    Slo

    vak

    Rep

    .

    Fra

    nce

    Eu

    roar

    ea

    avrg

    Slo

    ven

    ia

    Bel

    giu

    m

    Sp

    ain

    Po

    rtu

    gal

    Irel

    and

    Gre

    ece

    Ital

    y

    Interest payments on debt 2013-2018 (% of GDP)

  • 15 Source: IMF , EC, Eurobank Global Markets Research

    Interest expense with & without new debt relief (EURbn)

    69.8

    126.7

    63.2

    109.3

    0

    20

    40

    60

    80

    100

    120

    140

    2014-2020 2021-2030

    Current projection

    After debt relief

    Nominal effective interest rate on public debt with & without

    new debt relief (EURbn)

    175.1

    125.0

    83.0

    0

    20

    40

    60

    80

    100

    120

    140

    160

    180

    200

    20

    11

    20

    12

    20

    13

    20

    14

    20

    15

    20

    16

    20

    17

    20

    18

    20

    19

    20

    20

    20

    21

    20

    22

    20

    23

    20

    24

    20

    25

    20

    26

    20

    27

    20

    28

    20

    29

    20

    30

    troika baseline after new debt relief

    Evolution of Greek public debt ratio

    0.000.501.001.502.002.503.003.504.004.505.00

    20

    11

    20

    12

    20

    13

    20

    14

    20

    15

    20

    16

    20

    17

    20

    18

    20

    19

    20

    20

    20

    21

    20

    22

    20

    23

    20

    24

    20

    25

    After new debt relief

    Current projection

    Eurobank new debt relief proposal:

    GLF swap into 50yr amortizing bond with 10yr grace

    on interest payments and fixed interest of ca 0.6%

  • 16

    Full coverage of projected financing gap attainable

    up to at least 2020

    without recourse to a new aid package from official lenders

    Projected evolution of general government borrowing needs & funding sources

    (EURbn, cumulative amounts)

    Source: IMF (June 2014), Eurobank Global Markets Research

  • 17

    External sector developments & competiveness

    Summary of views

    Summary of views

    surplus CA for the first time on record

    improvement mainly driven by huge imports contraction, higher services exports and lower interest

    payment on public debt (PSI & DBB)

    cumulative losses in post EUR-entry wage cost competitiveness already eliminated

    Risks

    structural CA still at a deficit of ca 4%-of-GDP

    concerns remain as to the performance of merchandise exports excl. fuels

    CPI-based REER still overvalued by slightly over 10ppts

    improving environment for foreign direct investment, but FDI-to-GDP ratio still lower than EU average

  • 18

    -7.8% -7.2%

    -6.5% -6.5% -5.8%

    -7.6%

    -11.4%

    -14.6% -14.9%

    -11.2%

    -10.1% -9.9%

    -2.4%

    0.7%

    -16%

    -14%

    -12%

    -10%

    -8%

    -6%

    -4%

    -2%

    0%

    2%

    20

    00

    20

    01

    20

    02

    20

    03

    20

    04

    20

    05

    20

    06

    20

    07

    20

    08

    20

    09

    20

    10

    20

    11

    20

    12

    20

    13

    Source: BoG, AMECO, Eurobank Global Markets Research

    Greece’s current account (% GDP)

    Balance-of-payments definition

    -20%

    -18%

    -16%

    -14%

    -12%

    -10%

    -8%

    -6%

    -4%

    -2%

    0%

    0%

    5%

    10%

    15%

    20%

    25%

    30%

    35%

    40%

    45%

    196

    0

    196

    3

    196

    6

    196

    9

    1972

    1975

    1978

    198

    1

    198

    4

    198

    7

    199

    0

    199

    3

    199

    6

    199

    9

    20

    02

    20

    05

    20

    08

    20

    11

    Current account (right)

    Gross natinal saving (left)

    Total investment (left)

    Greece’s current account as a savings-investment

    imbalance (% GDP)

    A surplus CA in 2013 for the first time on record

    Improvement mainly driven by the sharp contraction of imports,

    higher services exports (tourism) and lower interest payments

    on public debt (PSI & DBB)

  • 19 Source: BoG, AMECO, Eurobank Global Markets Research

    Export & import trends

    Lingering concerns as to the performance of merchandise

    exports despite the rapid improvement in wage cost

    competitiveness

    -30.0%

    -20.0%

    -10.0%

    0.0%

    10.0%

    20.0%

    30.0%

    Dec

    -04

    Jul-

    05

    Feb

    -06

    Sep

    -06

    Ap

    r-0

    7

    No

    v-0

    7

    Jun

    -08

    Jan

    -09

    Au

    g-0

    9

    Mar

    -10

    Oct

    -10

    May

    -11

    Dec

    -11

    Jul-

    12

    Feb

    -13

    Sep

    -13

    Ap

    r-14

    Exports of goods & services

    Imports of goods & services

    Exports of goods & services (excluding tourism revenue)

    Annual growth of export s & imports

    (YoY %, 12mma)

    Merchandise exports and imports excluding

    fuel and ships purchases (% GDP)

    0.0%

    2.5%

    5.0%

    7.5%

    10.0%

    12.5%

    15.0%

    17.5%

    20.0%

    20

    01

    20

    02

    20

    03

    20

    04

    20

    05

    20

    06

    20

    07

    20

    08

    20

    09

    20

    10

    20

    11

    20

    12

    20

    13

    Imports Exports

  • 20

    Greece – REER cumulative growth

    (vs. 37 major trade partners)

    Minimum wage (euros per month)

    Source: Eurostat, AMECO, Eurobank Global Markets Research

    EUR 684

    EUR 877

    100250400550700850

    1,0001,1501,3001,4501,6001,7501,900

    Ro

    man

    iaB

    ulg

    aria

    Lat

    via

    Lit

    hu

    ania

    Cze

    ch…

    Est

    on

    iaS

    lova

    kia

    Hu

    ng

    ary

    Cro

    atia

    Po

    lan

    dT

    urk

    eyP

    ort

    ug

    alG

    reec

    e 1H

    …M

    alta

    Sp

    ain

    Slo

    ven

    iaG

    reec

    e 1H

    …U

    nit

    ed…

    Un

    ited

    …F

    ran

    ceIr

    elan

    dN

    eth

    erl

    an…

    Bel

    giu

    mL

    uxe

    mb

    o…

    Greece

    Now

    2011

    -10%

    -5%

    0%

    5%

    10%

    15%

    20%

    25%

    20

    01

    20

    02

    20

    03

    20

    04

    20

    05

    20

    06

    20

    07

    20

    08

    20

    09

    20

    10

    20

    11

    20

    12

    20

    13

    UCL-based

    CPI-based

    Wage adjustment has fully offset the wage cost-based

    competitiveness losses accumulated post the EUR entry

    However, Greece’s CPI-based REER remains overvalued by

    more than 10%

    Average annual earnings (YoY, %)

    -10.0

    -8.0

    -6.0

    -4.0

    -2.0

    0.0

    2.0

    4.0

    6.0

    8.0

    20

    01

    20

    02

    20

    03

    20

    04

    20

    05

    20

    06

    20

    07

    20

    08

    20

    09

    20

    10

    20

    11

    20

    12

    20

    13e

    20

    14f

    Greece Euro area

  • 21

    Estimate of the Greek sector

    competitiveness

    Greece competitiveness

    Performance vs. major trading partners (39 exporter EU &

    OECD countries as well as 56 others including emerging market

    economies)

    Estimate of the Greek competitiveness gap by year (%)

  • 22

    Financial sector developments

    Summary of views

    domestic financial conditions improving; deposit rates record significant decline since mid-2012 peak;

    loan rates ease, though to a lesser extent than deposit rates

    banking system reduces dependency on ECB liquidity measures; ELA funding close to zero

    domestic banking system fully-recapitalized, enjoying strong Core Tier 1 capital ratios and unique

    market structure (4 systemic banks controlling more than 95% of loans base)

    Risks

    initial bounce in deposit inflows post the June-2012 election discontinued (still down > 30% from peak)

    supply-side constrains risk credit-less recovery (EU-wide phenomenon)

    NPLs resolution remains a challenge for the domestic banking system

  • 23

    Bank recapitalization, gradual normalization of domestic

    liquidity conditions should allow switch to positive credit

    creation from 2015/16 onwards *,**

    Interest rates on new euro-denominated

    deposits with agreed maturity up to 1 year (ppts)

    Eurosystem funding to Greek banks

    (outstanding amounts in EURbn)

    (*) Eurobank’s Monetary Policy Transmission Mechanism Model (Panel Study): A 1ppt increase in domestic bank

    loan growth relative to the cross-section average of the PIIGS economies causes, after a quarter, a rise of between

    0.2ppts and 0.47ppts in Greece’s real GDP growth above the respective cross-sectional average.

    (**) Eurobank’s Greece SVAR model: A decline in the average Greek bank loan interest rate by 1ppt can lead to a

    cumulative boost in real GDP growth by around 0.3ppts over a 4-quarter period.

    Source: P. Monokroussos & Thomakos D. (2013a) “Monetary Policy Transmission Mechanism & Bank Lending Channel in the euro area –

    Greece Case Study”

    Source: BoG, Eurobank Global Markets Research Source: BoG, Eurobank Global Markets Research

    2.50

    3.00

    3.50

    4.00

    4.50

    5.00

    5.50

    Jun

    -10

    Au

    g-1

    0O

    ct-1

    0D

    ec-1

    0F

    eb

    -11

    Ap

    r-11

    Jun

    -11

    Au

    g-1

    1O

    ct-1

    1D

    ec-1

    1F

    eb

    -12

    Ap

    r-12

    Jun

    -12

    Au

    g-1

    2O

    ct-1

    2D

    ec-1

    2F

    eb

    -13

    Ap

    r-13

    Jun

    -13

    Au

    g-1

    3O

    ct-1

    3D

    ec-1

    3F

    eb

    -14

    Ap

    r-14

    Households Non financial corporations

  • 24 Sources: IMF, WB, BoG, Eurobank Global Markets Research

    Greece’s NPLs ratio

    12.3

    7.0

    31.9

    0.0

    5.0

    10.0

    15.0

    20.0

    25.0

    30.0

    35.0

    20

    00

    20

    01

    20

    02

    20

    03

    20

    04

    20

    05

    20

    06

    20

    07

    20

    08

    20

    09

    20

    10

    20

    11

    20

    12

    20

    13

    AT BE* CA

    CY*

    CZ

    DK EE

    FI FR DE

    GR

    HK

    IS

    IE*

    IT*

    JP LU

    MT

    NL NZ

    NO

    PT

    SK

    SI

    ES

    SE

    CH GB US

    BA

    BG*

    HR

    HU LV

    LT

    ME RO

    RS

    TR

    AM

    GE

    KG MD

    RU

    UA

    WS

    KW AE

    GA CR SV HN

    MX PW VE

    y = 0.8088x + 1.3347 R² = 0.3942

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    25

    30

    0 5 10 15 20 25 30

    Δ N

    PL

    RA

    TIO

    (T

    RO

    UG

    HT

    TO

    PE

    AK

    )

    CUM GDP CONTRACTION

    Cumulative real GDP contraction vs. change in

    NPL ratio

    from through to peak (2008-2013)

    Private sector credit % GDP (end-2008)

    0

    50

    100

    150

    200

    250

    300

    Slo

    vaki

    aR

    om

    ania

    Cze

    ch R

    ep.

    Po

    lan

    dU

    SH

    un

    gar

    yL

    ith

    uan

    iaB

    elg

    ium

    Bu

    lgar

    iaC

    anad

    aFi

    nla

    nd

    Ital

    yS

    love

    nia

    Lat

    via

    Ger

    man

    yF

    ran

    ceA

    ust

    ria

    Est

    on

    iaL

    uxe

    mb

    ou

    rgJa

    pan U

    KG

    reec

    eN

    eth

    erla

    nd

    sS

    wed

    enM

    alta

    Au

    stra

    liaN

    ew Z

    eala

    nd

    Po

    rtu

    gal

    Sp

    ain

    Irel

    and

    Den

    mar

    kC

    ypru

    s

    AVERAGE = 102.4

    Rise in Greek NPLs ratio due to recession, rather than

    bank lending practices

    Of total NPLs 60% corporate (SMEs); 16% consumer; 24%

    mortgages

  • 25

    Political environment, progress on

    structural reforms & upcoming troika review

    Summary of views

    coalition majority may rise further in the upcoming presidential vote

    a number of steps have been taken in fulfilling privatisation targets

    prior actions to the June 2014 EFSF loan disbursement fulfilled

    Negotiations in the context of next troika review unlikely to conclude before year-end

    Risks

    Lingering political jitters & reforms fatigue

  • 26

    Ruling coalition controlling slim parliamentary majority

    Majority of at least 180 in-favor votes needed for the

    upcoming election of the President of the Hellenic Republic

    Ruling coalition currently controls 2-seat majority in the

    300-seat Parliament.

    Constitution of Greece (Article 32, paragraphs 3 & 4)

    The vote for the election of the President of the

    Hellenic Republic should take place at least one

    month before the expiration of the tenure of the

    incumbent (i.e., 2 February 2015). The relevant

    procedure incorporates three separate ballots in

    Parliament.

    In the first two, a 2/3rd majority of the total 300 MPs is

    required (i.e., 200 in-favor votes). If both fail to

    produce a decisive outcome, a third ballot takes place

    where a majority of 3/5th is needed (i.e., 180 in-favor

    votes).

    125

    71

    27

    13 16

    13 12

    17 6

    Allocation of seats in the Hellenic Parliament

    N.D.SY.RIZ.A.PA.SO.K.Independent GreeksGolden DawnDemocratic LeftK.K.E.Independent Democratic ParliamentariansIndependent MPs

    Source: Ministry of Internal Affairs

  • 27

    Privatisation program

    Progress so far & issue on the agenda in the upcoming

    program review

    Even if with delays, a number of steps have been taken in

    fulfilling privatisation targets

    —16 privatisation projects already completed, e.g. sale of 33% of Emma Delta, sale of 66% of DESFA

    — 16 privatisation projects currently in progress, e.g. sale

    of 67% of Piraeus Port (country’s largest port complex) —16 privatisation projects currently under preparation, e.g.

    Public Power Corporation S.A, Hellenic Petroleum —out of a target of 1,000, ca 950 commercially-viable real

    estate assets have already been transferred to HRADF; more than 80,000 real estate assets have been initially

    assessed (currently, under the management of line ministries and the Public Properties Company)

    — relevant law amended to improve governance of HRADF

    Steps that need to be taken

    Strengthen governance regime of the privatization plan

    Bring forward privatisation revenues

    1.6 0.0

    1.0

    1.5

    2.2

    3.4

    2.9

    3.0 3.4

    3.6

    22.3

    0.5

    4.5

    8.5

    12.5

    16.5

    20.5

    24.5

    0.0

    0.5

    1.0

    1.5

    2.0

    2.5

    3.0

    3.5

    4.0

    20

    11

    20

    12

    20

    13

    20

    14 (f

    )

    20

    15 (f

    )

    20

    16 (

    f)

    20

    17 (

    f)

    20

    18 (f

    )

    20

    19 (

    f)

    20

    20

    (f)

    Greece: Privatization Proceeds (2011-2020)

    Yearly Proceeds (EUR bn)

    Cumulative Proceeds (EUR bn)

    Source: EU Commission, Occasional Papers 192/April 2014, “The

    Second Economic Adjustment Programme for Greece, Fourth

    Review”

  • 28

    Prior actions to the June & July 2014 EFSF tranches

    June 2014 EFSF tranche (€1bn) Completed Pending

    Adoption of outdoor trade law √

    Adoption of investment licensing & spatial planning laws √

    Issuance of ministerial decree for integration of debt collection to tax administration √

    Update of nuisance charges list √

    Adoption of code of conduct for members of Government √

    Adoption of legislation entailing reduction in the average profit margin of pharmacists (to 15.7% from 19%) √

    Adoption of legislation for non-insured citizens' access to diagnostics centers and use of medicines √

    July 2014 EFSF tranche (€1bn) Completed Pending

    Adoption of legislation on political parties' funding and on declaration (and monitoring) of their assets √

    Adoption of administrative burden legislation √

    Abolishment of third party taxes recorded as auxiliary funds revenue√

    Clearance of State arrears to PPC and adoption of law for the establishment of "Small PPC" √

    Adoption of forestry law√

    Adoption of legislation allowing merger of all supplementary pension funds into ETEA√

    Legislation for implementation of "No Deficit Clause" & sustainability formulas to all funds not currently in ETEA √

  • 29

    Next (5th) program review

    Key issues on the agenda

    Key issues on the agenda

    Measures for the coverage of projected fiscal gaps (1.0%-of-GDP in 2015 & 0.75%-of-GDP in 2016)

    Measures for the coverage of projected financing gap (H2 2015 & 2016)

    Labor market reform (collective dismissals, industrial actions)

    Public sector reform (8k-10k additional layoffs by end 2014, other)

    Assesment of the privatisation program

    (e.g.issuance of a list of pending actions required for the privatisation of key State entities; (ii) completion of an asessment

    of the management and board members of companies in the HRADF portfolio)

    Framework for strengthening/restructuring domestic banking system

    e.g., (i) BoG approval of the capital-raising plans addessing the adverse scenario already submitted by domestic banks;

    (ii) review of personal and corporate insolvency laws

    Regulatory framework of product and services markets

    (e.g.review of over-the-counter medicine prices & liberalisation of their retail channels)

    Review of medical/pharmaceutical spending

    (e.g. publication of list of medicine prices based on the lowest prices in three EU member States)

    Source: EU Commission (April 2014), IMF Country Report No. 14/151 (June 2014), MTFS (2015-2018), Eurobank Global Markets Research

  • 30

    www.eurobank.gr/research

    DISCLAIMER

    This report has been issued by Eurobank Ergasias S.A. and may not be reproduced in any manner or provided to any other person. Each person that receives a copy

    by acceptance thereof represents and agrees that it will not distribute or provide it to any other person. This report is not an offer to buy or sell or a solicitation of an

    offer to buy or sell the securities mentioned herein. Eurobank and others associated with it may have positions in, and may effect transactions in securities of

    companies mentioned herein and may also perform or seek to perform investment banking services for those companies. The investments discussed in this report

    may be unsuitable for investors, depending on the specific investment objectives and financial position. The information contained herein is for informative purposes

    only and has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable but it has not been verified by Eurobank. The opinions expressed herein may not necessarily

    coincide with those of any member of Eurobank. No representation or warranty (express or implied) is made as to the accuracy, completeness, correctness,

    timeliness or fairness of the information or opinions herein, all of which are subject to change without notice. No responsibility or liability whatsoever or howsoever

    arising is accepted in relation to the contents hereof by Eurobank or any of its directors, officers or employees.

    Any articles, studies, comments etc. reflect solely the views of their author. Any unsigned notes are deemed to have been produced by the editorial team. Any

    articles, studies, comments etc. that are signed by members of the editorial team express the personal views of their author.

    http://www.eurobank.gr/research

  • 31

    ANNEX 1

    Funding gap fully covered on a 12-month forward basis

    Strategies sought for the full coverage of the financing gap over the next 12 months

    re-access to international capital markets

    intra-general government borrowing through short-term repo operations (up to €3 bn )

    use of idle resources available in other parts of general government for liquidity purposes

    buyback by Pireaus Bank and Alpha Bank of preference shares from the State (€1.7bn )

    rollover of 5-yr government bonds owned by the National Fund for Entrepreneurship and Development (ETEAN) that mature

    in August 2014 (€1.5bn-€ 0.43bn )

    utilisation of the HFSF buffer (ca €11.3bn) after substracting from it any amounts needed to cover potential capital shortfalls

    in the domestic banking system identified by a new EU-wide stress test, scheduled to be completed by end- October 2014

  • 32

    ANNEX 2

    Greece – Disbursements under 2nd adjustment program (EURbn)

    Source: EU Commission “ The Second Economic Adjustment Programme for Greece, 4th Review,” (April 2014), Eurobank Global Markets Research

    Loan tranches disbursed so

    far under 2nd adjustment

    program

    Pending EFSF loan tranche

    following completion of 4th

    program review (subject to

    fullfilment of certain milestones )

    Future disbursements

    Total disbursements

    under 2nd adjustment

    program

    March 2012-mid-July 2014August 2014

    (initially scheduled for July 2014)September 2014-March 2016 March 2012-March 2016

    EFSF 140.9 1.0 2.9 144.8

    IMF 11.9 0.0 16.1 28.0

    Total 152.8 1.0 19.0 172.8

  • 33

    ANNEX 3

    Greece – Timeline of key data & events

    Source: EU Commission, local press, Eurobank Global Markets Research