GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in...

62
GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part 1 Dan Jaffe The University of Texas at Austin

Transcript of GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in...

Page 1: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part

GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part 1

Dan Jaffe The University of Texas at Austin

Page 2: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part
Page 3: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part
Page 4: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part
Page 5: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part

ν Δν Ω ε ν

Page 6: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part

2.2 5.7 9.2 13 16 20 23

OH Night sky in the H band (Chan Park et al.)

Page 7: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part
Page 8: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part

λ/Δλ Δλ Δμ

λ/

Page 9: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part

First-generation high resolution spectrographs for the IR Small wavelength coverage: CSHELL: λ/200 Phoenix: λ/100 CRIRES: λ/70 Small coverage means lots of moving parts. Many surfaces. Hard to get decent slit sizes at high resolution. Instruments already quite large and so not too stiff.

Page 10: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part
Page 11: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part

μ

Page 12: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part
Page 13: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part

β/λ

Page 14: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part
Page 15: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part
Page 16: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part
Page 17: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part

λ

Page 18: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part

Ω

Page 19: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part
Page 20: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part
Page 21: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part
Page 22: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part
Page 23: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part
Page 24: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part

μ μλ μ λ μ

     

Page 25: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part
Page 26: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part
Page 27: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part
Page 28: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part
Page 29: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part
Page 30: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part

• λ

θ θ λ θθ

Page 31: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part

μ

μ

λ

Page 32: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part

λ

λ

Page 33: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part

μ

λ δ

Page 34: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part

μ

λ μ

Page 35: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part

Δλ/λ

Page 36: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part

Δx⇔Δϕ2πλΔx

ϕ =ϕ0 +2πλΔx

ϕ =ϕ0

Δx⇔Δϕ2π (n−1)

λΔx

ϕ =ϕ0 +2π (n−1)

λΔx

ϕ =ϕ0

Δx⇔Δϕ2πn

λΔx

ϕ =ϕ0 +2πn

λΔx

ϕ =ϕ0

Page 37: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part

In immersion, the internal wavelength shrinks by a factor of n, the refractive index

max

(sin sin )2 sin

2 tan

G

G

G

m nn LR

ndd

λ σ α β

δλββ

λ λ

= +

=

=

Resolving power is equal to phase delay across the beam measured in wavelengths divided by the ratio of the angular size of the slit to the diffraction limited angular scale. R= λ/Δλ = (2Lsinδ)/λ • θdiff/θslit Where L is the grating length and δ is the grating angle.

Page 38: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part

The invention of the immersion grating by Dan Jaffe 1. The eureka moment - Spring 1992 If you illuminate a grating from inside a transparent medium, the density of the medium leads the light to see the grating as longer , that is, bigger by a factor of the refractive index, n, which is 3.4 for silicon

Page 39: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part

The invention of the immersion grating by Dan Jaffe 2.The oh moment – discovering a US patent from 1984

Page 40: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part

The invention of the immersion grating by Dan Jaffe 3.The hah moment- finding an article from Nature, 1954

Page 41: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part

The invention of the immersion grating by Dan Jaffe 4. The duh moment: Gegenseitige Einwirkung der im Wasser und anderen brechenden Mitteln gebeugten Strahlen Joseph Fraunhofer 1823

Fraunhofer immersed his gratings in water, linseed oil, and turpentine. We immerse ours in solid silicon but the physics is the same.

The interaction of diffracted radiation in water and other refractive media.

Page 42: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part

The thick substrates require a completely independent process chain from what wafers require.

Page 43: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part

Page 44: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part
Page 45: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part
Page 46: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part
Page 47: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part
Page 48: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part

Contact Lithography

Page 49: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part

• 

• 

• 

• 

Page 50: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part
Page 51: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part

• 

• 

• 

• 

Page 52: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part

Degree of difficulty: [(n-1) sinδ]/λ for grisms and with [2nsinδ]/λ for immersion gratings. Scales with length of grating divided by width of slit in units of diffraction limited width. Forcast grism 1: δ=11o λ= 30 μm, DD=1 Other Forcast grisms: DD=1-10 JWST grisms: DD= 9 IG for IGRINS: DD=120 IG for GMTNIRS: DD= 250

Page 53: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part
Page 54: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part

• • 

• 

• 

• 

Page 55: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part

JWST NIRCam Grisms λ/100 rms grating surface

105 dynamic range Flight Part

Page 56: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part

IGRINS Immersion Grating- Complete 2011

Surface is λ/6 peak to valley. Efficiency ~80%

Page 57: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part
Page 58: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part

IGRINS (UT and KASI) covers all of 1.4-2.45 μμm in one exposure at R=45,000 with no gaps!

Page 59: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part

IGRINS on McDonald 2.7m 2014-2016, no cold moving parts, warm calibration system with moving mirrors

IGRINS on 4.3m DCT 2016- and McDonald 2.7m 2017- No moving parts, sky emission and absorption lines, white spot

Page 60: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part

IGRINS Spectrum of a star, not corrected for telluric absorption

Region covered by the Phoenix spectrograph

Page 61: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part
Page 62: GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in ...eaa2018/Talks/Brazil_2018_Jaffe_L1.pdf · GMTNIRS and the Promise of High Resolution Spectroscopy in the Infrared: Part