Fission and more with HFB-Gogny · Much more accurate and fast than Schmidt orthogonalisation !...

25
Fission and more with HFB Fission and more with HFB - - Gogny Gogny Beginnings and recent Beginnings and recent

Transcript of Fission and more with HFB-Gogny · Much more accurate and fast than Schmidt orthogonalisation !...

Page 1: Fission and more with HFB-Gogny · Much more accurate and fast than Schmidt orthogonalisation ! More important: “le développement de Gogny” can be employed. d Axial symmetry

Fission and more with HFBFission and more with HFB--GognyGogny

Beginnings and recentBeginnings and recent

Page 2: Fission and more with HFB-Gogny · Much more accurate and fast than Schmidt orthogonalisation ! More important: “le développement de Gogny” can be employed. d Axial symmetry

TwoTwo--centercenter bases for HFBbases for HFB

Usual HO bases very efficient for HFB with D1 interaction :

)2()1(ˆ)2,1( ][v

Nfv µ

µµϕ∑

≅ “Développementde Gogny”

However HO bases with reasonable

size are not adapted to two-nucleus

configurations

Page 3: Fission and more with HFB-Gogny · Much more accurate and fast than Schmidt orthogonalisation ! More important: “le développement de Gogny” can be employed. d Axial symmetry

Eigenfunctions of two-center HO potential not convenient for HFB :

they are hyper-geometric functions

“développement de Gogny” not applicable

{ } { })2()1( ϕϕ ⊕Another way : { })1(ϕ { })2(ϕ

d

Non-orthogonal (overcomplete) basis Orthogonalisation and elimination of

redundant vectors from diagonalisation

of T+T and TT+ with ),( )2()1(jiijT ϕϕ=

Much more accurate and fast than Schmidt orthogonalisation !

More important: “le développement de Gogny” can be employed

Page 4: Fission and more with HFB-Gogny · Much more accurate and fast than Schmidt orthogonalisation ! More important: “le développement de Gogny” can be employed. d Axial symmetry

d

Axial symmetry

Single part. energies

in two-center HO pot

Twice 10 HO shells

~ 1900 nucleon states

Page 5: Fission and more with HFB-Gogny · Much more accurate and fast than Schmidt orthogonalisation ! More important: “le développement de Gogny” can be employed. d Axial symmetry
Page 6: Fission and more with HFB-Gogny · Much more accurate and fast than Schmidt orthogonalisation ! More important: “le développement de Gogny” can be employed. d Axial symmetry

With this method, two-center bases are competitive

not only for two-nucleus configurations

but also for one-nucleus very deformed states

despite one additional parameter to be optimised : d

Page 7: Fission and more with HFB-Gogny · Much more accurate and fast than Schmidt orthogonalisation ! More important: “le développement de Gogny” can be employed. d Axial symmetry

1212C + C + 1212C and molecular statesC and molecular states

Sharp closeSharp close resonancesresonances in in 1212C + C + 1212C excitation functionsC excitation functionsnear Coulomb barriernear Coulomb barrierLongLong--lived “molecule” ?lived “molecule” ?

Also in a couple of other systems (Also in a couple of other systems (1212C + C + 1616O, O, 1414N+ N+ 1414N)N)Various interpretations not successfulVarious interpretations not successful

Description with HFB Description with HFB One problemOne problem: spurious center of mass energy and : spurious center of mass energy and potential energy of asymptotic statespotential energy of asymptotic states

Page 8: Fission and more with HFB-Gogny · Much more accurate and fast than Schmidt orthogonalisation ! More important: “le développement de Gogny” can be employed. d Axial symmetry

Removal of spurious center of mass (CM) energy in HFB:Removal of spurious center of mass (CM) energy in HFB:minimisationminimisation of of

AMPHH

2

ˆˆ'ˆ 2−=

OneOne--body and Twobody and Two--body corrections body corrections

AMPVHHH coul 2

ˆˆˆ'ˆ 2

21 −++=At large distance R At large distance R

coulVMA

PHMA

PHH +−+−≠ )2

ˆˆ()2

ˆˆ('ˆ2

22

21

21

1

>>=<−−<M

PMA

PMA

PMA

P R

µ2

ˆ

2

ˆ

2

ˆ

2

ˆ 2

2

22

1

21

2

Energy difference:Energy difference:

~11 ~11 MeVMeV in in 1212C + C + 1212C C

Page 9: Fission and more with HFB-Gogny · Much more accurate and fast than Schmidt orthogonalisation ! More important: “le développement de Gogny” can be employed. d Axial symmetry

Q =<QQ =<Q2020> mass > mass quadrupolequadrupole deformationdeformation

Page 10: Fission and more with HFB-Gogny · Much more accurate and fast than Schmidt orthogonalisation ! More important: “le développement de Gogny” can be employed. d Axial symmetry

)()()( 0 QQEQV ε−=Potential for dynamics Potential for dynamics

=)(0 Qε “zero“zero--point energy correction” point energy correction”

)2()1(22 QQRQ ++→ µAt large distance R At large distance R

Hence :Hence : ><→>∂∂

<≈M

PQMQiQ R

µε

2

ˆ

)(2)/()(

22

0

So removing everywhere the “zeroSo removing everywhere the “zero--point energy correction” point energy correction” should correct for the spurious CM energy should correct for the spurious CM energy

Actually, this does not work very well Actually, this does not work very well

Page 11: Fission and more with HFB-Gogny · Much more accurate and fast than Schmidt orthogonalisation ! More important: “le développement de Gogny” can be employed. d Axial symmetry

)(0 Qε

><M

PR

µ2

ˆ 2

Page 12: Fission and more with HFB-Gogny · Much more accurate and fast than Schmidt orthogonalisation ! More important: “le développement de Gogny” can be employed. d Axial symmetry

InglisInglis--BelyaevBelyaev formulaformula

Page 13: Fission and more with HFB-Gogny · Much more accurate and fast than Schmidt orthogonalisation ! More important: “le développement de Gogny” can be employed. d Axial symmetry
Page 14: Fission and more with HFB-Gogny · Much more accurate and fast than Schmidt orthogonalisation ! More important: “le développement de Gogny” can be employed. d Axial symmetry

FissionFissionJülich 1979

Page 15: Fission and more with HFB-Gogny · Much more accurate and fast than Schmidt orthogonalisation ! More important: “le développement de Gogny” can be employed. d Axial symmetry

Jülich 1979

Page 16: Fission and more with HFB-Gogny · Much more accurate and fast than Schmidt orthogonalisation ! More important: “le développement de Gogny” can be employed. d Axial symmetry

Fission barrier of Fission barrier of 240240Pu and D1SPu and D1S

Page 17: Fission and more with HFB-Gogny · Much more accurate and fast than Schmidt orthogonalisation ! More important: “le développement de Gogny” can be employed. d Axial symmetry

ScissionScission

Page 18: Fission and more with HFB-Gogny · Much more accurate and fast than Schmidt orthogonalisation ! More important: “le développement de Gogny” can be employed. d Axial symmetry
Page 19: Fission and more with HFB-Gogny · Much more accurate and fast than Schmidt orthogonalisation ! More important: “le développement de Gogny” can be employed. d Axial symmetry

Scission dynamicsScission dynamics

Page 20: Fission and more with HFB-Gogny · Much more accurate and fast than Schmidt orthogonalisation ! More important: “le développement de Gogny” can be employed. d Axial symmetry

Cold fissionCold fission

Page 21: Fission and more with HFB-Gogny · Much more accurate and fast than Schmidt orthogonalisation ! More important: “le développement de Gogny” can be employed. d Axial symmetry

SHESHE

Page 22: Fission and more with HFB-Gogny · Much more accurate and fast than Schmidt orthogonalisation ! More important: “le développement de Gogny” can be employed. d Axial symmetry

Fission 21st centuryFission 21st century

Page 23: Fission and more with HFB-Gogny · Much more accurate and fast than Schmidt orthogonalisation ! More important: “le développement de Gogny” can be employed. d Axial symmetry

H.H.GoutteGoutte, JFB, P., JFB, P.CasoliCasoli and D. and D. GognyGogny, Phys. Rev. C71 (2005) 024316, Phys. Rev. C71 (2005) 024316

Page 24: Fission and more with HFB-Gogny · Much more accurate and fast than Schmidt orthogonalisation ! More important: “le développement de Gogny” can be employed. d Axial symmetry

256Fm226Th

q 20(b)q3

0(b3/2)

E (M

eV)

238U

Page 25: Fission and more with HFB-Gogny · Much more accurate and fast than Schmidt orthogonalisation ! More important: “le développement de Gogny” can be employed. d Axial symmetry

Outlook (Daniel Outlook (Daniel Gogny’sGogny’s expertise needed)expertise needed)

Theory and Evaluation : how Theory and Evaluation : how to relate multito relate multi--dimensional PES dimensional PES with the onewith the one--D barriers which D barriers which are so successful in data are so successful in data evaluation ?evaluation ?

PhotofissionPhotofission

NucleusNucleus--nucleus reactions at nucleus reactions at low energy : SHE production / low energy : SHE production / structurestructure