Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm … · 2017. 1. 3. · Exploiting the...

29
Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm dark matter Isabella Paola Carucci (SISSA) Meudon, June 16 th 2016 based on JCAP07(2015)047 work done with Francisco Villaescusa-Navarro, Matteo Viel, Andrea Lapi

Transcript of Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm … · 2017. 1. 3. · Exploiting the...

Page 1: Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm … · 2017. 1. 3. · Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm dark matter Isabella Paola Carucci

Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum:

forecasts for SKA on warm dark matter

Isabella Paola Carucci (SISSA) Meudon, June 16th 2016

based on JCAP07(2015)047 work done with Francisco Villaescusa-Navarro, Matteo Viel, Andrea Lapi

Page 2: Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm … · 2017. 1. 3. · Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm dark matter Isabella Paola Carucci

what does LLS tell us about the warmness of DM ?

Page 3: Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm … · 2017. 1. 3. · Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm dark matter Isabella Paola Carucci

constrained up to k ~ 3 Mpc-1 (Ly-α)

Power suppression

what does LLS tell us about the warmness of DM ?

Page 4: Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm … · 2017. 1. 3. · Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm dark matter Isabella Paola Carucci

Lyman-α forest flux power spectrum

Viel+ 2013

current constrain: mWDM >3.3 keV (2σ) [Viel+2013]

Page 5: Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm … · 2017. 1. 3. · Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm dark matter Isabella Paola Carucci

Viel+ 2013

looking after the cut-offPower

suppression at small scales

Page 6: Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm … · 2017. 1. 3. · Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm dark matter Isabella Paola Carucci

Viel+ 2013

looking after the cut-off

The 21cm power spectrum gets boosted at all scales!

Power suppression at small scales

Page 7: Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm … · 2017. 1. 3. · Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm dark matter Isabella Paola Carucci

neutral hydrogen in the universeGalaxies (DLAs)Dense, self-shielded HI

• observation perspective (SKA) • intensity mapping: mapping the

collective HI 21cm radiation background without resolving the individual sources

21cm radiation signal !

Lyman-α forest fluxmostly ionised H

Page 8: Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm … · 2017. 1. 3. · Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm dark matter Isabella Paola Carucci

SKA1-MID • 0<z<3 • 200 dishes; 15m • South Africa

SKA1-LOW • 3<z<27 • 911 antennae • Australia

Very isolated places to avoid RIF

Phase I

Page 9: Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm … · 2017. 1. 3. · Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm dark matter Isabella Paola Carucci

SKA1-MID • 0<z<3 • 200 dishes; 15m • South Africa

SKA1-LOW • 3<z<27 • 911 antennae • Australia

Very isolated places to avoid RIF

Phase I

Page 10: Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm … · 2017. 1. 3. · Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm dark matter Isabella Paola Carucci

simulation suite• Gadget3, w/ radiative cooling+ SF

• box size = 30 Mpc/h

• 5123 DM + 5123 baryons particles

• 5 cosmologies: CDM and 1, 2, 3 and 4 keV WDM

• from z=99 to z=3 (snapshot at 3, 4 and 5)

Page 11: Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm … · 2017. 1. 3. · Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm dark matter Isabella Paola Carucci

impact of WDM on the matter distribution

Page 12: Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm … · 2017. 1. 3. · Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm dark matter Isabella Paola Carucci

impact of WDM on the matter distribution

Overall, for WDM masses between 3 and 4 keV we observe a suppression in power up to

∼10% on small scales ...

... and a reduction in the number of 109 h−1M

⊙ halos of the order of ∼ 20 − 40% compared to the CDM case.

Page 13: Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm … · 2017. 1. 3. · Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm dark matter Isabella Paola Carucci

modelling the HI distribution

• f3 such that ΩHI = 10-3

• Mmin and Mmax corresponding to halo circular velocities of 30 and 200 km/s

halo based method particle based method

• assuming photo-ionization equilibrium, setting the HI/H fraction in order to reproduce the Lyman-α mean transmission flux

• mimicking HI self-shielding for high enough density regions

• letting H2 forming for even denser regions

HI resides only in DM halos HI assigned to all gas particles, according to their properties

(Bagla 2010) (Dave 2013)

Page 14: Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm … · 2017. 1. 3. · Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm dark matter Isabella Paola Carucci

modelling the HI distribution

• f3 such that ΩHI = 10-3

• Mmin and Mmax corresponding to halo circular velocities of 30 and 200 km/s

halo based method particle based method

• assuming photo-ionization equilibrium, setting the HI/H fraction in order to reproduce the Lyman-α mean transmission flux

• mimicking HI self-shielding for high enough density regions

• letting H2 forming for even denser regions

HI resides only in DM halos HI assigned to all gas particles, according to their properties

(Bagla 2010) (Dave 2013)

Both methods were tested with LLS and DLAs HI column density distribution

function !

Page 15: Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm … · 2017. 1. 3. · Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm dark matter Isabella Paola Carucci

modelling the HI distribution

Page 16: Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm … · 2017. 1. 3. · Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm dark matter Isabella Paola Carucci

modelling the HI distributionhalo based method particle based method

Page 17: Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm … · 2017. 1. 3. · Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm dark matter Isabella Paola Carucci

modelling the HI distributionhalo based method particle based method

HI bias is higher in WDM because there is a deficit of low-mass halos

Page 18: Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm … · 2017. 1. 3. · Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm dark matter Isabella Paola Carucci

modelling the HI distributionhalo based method particle based method

brightness temperature δTb 21cm signal(Furlanetto+ 2006)

ρHI —> RSD —> δTb —> P21cm(k)

HI bias is higher in WDM because there is a deficit of low-mass halos

Page 19: Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm … · 2017. 1. 3. · Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm dark matter Isabella Paola Carucci

21cm P(k) and SKA1-low forecasts

Page 20: Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm … · 2017. 1. 3. · Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm dark matter Isabella Paola Carucci

21cm P(k) and SKA1-low forecastswe can rule out:

• 4kev, with 5000 hour

observation, at z >3, with 3σ

• 3keV (today’s constraint) with

1000 hours, at z>3, with > 2σ

Page 21: Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm … · 2017. 1. 3. · Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm dark matter Isabella Paola Carucci

the ΩHI - mWDM degeneracy

Page 22: Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm … · 2017. 1. 3. · Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm dark matter Isabella Paola Carucci

the ΩHI - mWDM degeneracy

fisher matrix analysis

reference model • ΩHI = 10-3

• mDM = ��(CDM)

Page 23: Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm … · 2017. 1. 3. · Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm dark matter Isabella Paola Carucci

summarywe investigated the impact of WDM on the 21cm

intensity mapping in the post-reionization era (z = 3 - 5)

• hydro sims for 5 different models,

CDM + WDM (1, 2, 3, 4keV)

• assignment of HI a-posteriori

(halo + particle based methods)

The suppression on power in the matter power spectra results in an increase of power in the terms of the HI and hence the 21cm power spectra

(SKA forecasts).

Page 24: Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm … · 2017. 1. 3. · Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm dark matter Isabella Paola Carucci

thanks!

Page 25: Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm … · 2017. 1. 3. · Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm dark matter Isabella Paola Carucci

simulation ICs

Page 26: Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm … · 2017. 1. 3. · Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm dark matter Isabella Paola Carucci

Halo mass function Number of massive halos Do we have spurious

fragmentation?

Page 27: Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm … · 2017. 1. 3. · Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm dark matter Isabella Paola Carucci

testing the HI modellingHI column density distribution function

Page 28: Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm … · 2017. 1. 3. · Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm dark matter Isabella Paola Carucci

the HI bias: b2HI(k) = PHI(k)/Pm(k)

Page 29: Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm … · 2017. 1. 3. · Exploiting the 21cm power spectrum: forecasts for SKA on warm dark matter Isabella Paola Carucci

matter clustering properties reflected by HI?