Dynamics of the Earth System and the Ice-Core Record (DESIRE) Project submitted to the joint...

21
Dynamics of the Earth System and the Ice- Core Record (DESIRE) Project submitted to the joint QUEST-INSU AO

Transcript of Dynamics of the Earth System and the Ice-Core Record (DESIRE) Project submitted to the joint...

Page 1: Dynamics of the Earth System and the Ice-Core Record (DESIRE) Project submitted to the joint QUEST-INSU AO.

Dynamics of the Earth System and the Ice-Core Record

(DESIRE)

Project submitted to the joint QUEST-INSU AO

Page 2: Dynamics of the Earth System and the Ice-Core Record (DESIRE) Project submitted to the joint QUEST-INSU AO.

650 kyr of clues from EPICA and Vostok!

180

210

240

270

300Vostok + Dome C data

CO

2 /

pp

mv

-450

-420

-390

EPICA Dome C data

COLD

WARM

D ic

e /

300

400

500

600

700

0 200 400 600 800

Vostok + Dome C data

Age / kyr BP

CH

4 /

pp

bv

Siegenthaler et al., 2005; Spahni et al., 2005; Petit et al., 1999

Page 3: Dynamics of the Earth System and the Ice-Core Record (DESIRE) Project submitted to the joint QUEST-INSU AO.

180

240

300

0 200 400 600

CO

2 p

redic

ted (M

udels

ee)

180

240

300

0 200 400 600

CO

2 p

redic

ted (M

udels

ee)

Mudelsee (based only on Vostok data): pCO2 = 922 + 1.646 * δDt-2000

The success of approaches using correlations with Antarctic proxies

alone implies the dominance of Southern Ocean mechanisms?

The correlative approach can only take us so far, and a mechanistic, model-

based approach is now needed

Page 4: Dynamics of the Earth System and the Ice-Core Record (DESIRE) Project submitted to the joint QUEST-INSU AO.

State of the art: CH4

• G-IG jumps, 350-700 ppbv

• Very fast changes (200 ppbv) at DO scales

• Various sources (terrestrial except marine hydrates) could be involved– Distinguishable through isotopes

• Changing sinks also implicated– Little constraint on source/sink balance

Page 5: Dynamics of the Earth System and the Ice-Core Record (DESIRE) Project submitted to the joint QUEST-INSU AO.

300

400

500

600

700

0 200 400 600

Vostok + Dome C data

Age / kyr BP

CH

4 /

pp

bv

• new coupled models that cover the CH4 domain• different G-IG transitions with different climate changes• millennial events encompassing much of the G-IG range

QUEST-Deglaciation will look at G-IG change, but in DESIRE we will have the advantage of:

300

400

500

600

700

0 10000 20000 30000 40000

GRIP/NGRIP

Age / GICC05 yrs BP

CH

4 /

pp

bv

Page 6: Dynamics of the Earth System and the Ice-Core Record (DESIRE) Project submitted to the joint QUEST-INSU AO.

State of the art: CO2

• G-IG ramps, ~180-280 ppmv in last 450 kyr

• Lower CO2 in early IG (450-800 kyr)

• Very close link to Antarctic temperature– implies concentration on S. Ocean

• Physical and biogeochemical processes– Data and models provide some constraints– But error bars remain very large

Page 7: Dynamics of the Earth System and the Ice-Core Record (DESIRE) Project submitted to the joint QUEST-INSU AO.

Quaternary QUEST is also working on the CO2 issue, focussed on 1 climate cycle, but we will use the constraints of multiple cycles:

• In “weak” interglacials, did each mechanism scale with temperature, or were some inactive?

• Is the phasing at each termination and inception of diagnostic significance?

Page 8: Dynamics of the Earth System and the Ice-Core Record (DESIRE) Project submitted to the joint QUEST-INSU AO.

Dynamics of the Earth System and the Ice-core Record (DESIRE)

• Response to the NERC-INSU joint UK-Fra call “to develop a quantitative and predictive understanding of the ice-core record of changing atmospheric composition”

• Note that this is a huge question, and we have to balance ambition with reality

• 0.8 Myrs, CO2 and CH4

• 3 years, starting in ??? 07

Page 9: Dynamics of the Earth System and the Ice-Core Record (DESIRE) Project submitted to the joint QUEST-INSU AO.

Underlying principles• Use the new data• Use the best modelling tools, people and datasets

available to UK and French researchers• Use models of appropriate complexity for each

question being addressed• Tackle achievable aspects of the overall

“understanding everything” call• WPs arranged around hypotheses relating to (a)

CH4 change, (b) CO2 change, (c) the links between these changes and climate change in the coupled system

Page 10: Dynamics of the Earth System and the Ice-Core Record (DESIRE) Project submitted to the joint QUEST-INSU AO.

Strategy

Simulationsof appropriate

periods

Data constraints

Explore particular processes

Develop/test somenew modelling

tools

Prepare/compilenew diagnostic

datasets

Assess contributionof different mechanisms

to GHG changeover 800 kyr

Propose futureconstraints

Page 11: Dynamics of the Earth System and the Ice-Core Record (DESIRE) Project submitted to the joint QUEST-INSU AO.

Current partners• BAS (Eric Wolff)• IPSL/LSCE (Pierre Friedlingstein, Pascale Braconnot,

Gilles Ramstein, Laurent Bopp, Frank Bassinot and others)• Bristol (Sandy Harrison, Paul Valdes, Andy Ridgwell)• LGGE (Jerôme Chappellaz and several others)• OU (Neil Edwards)• Reading (David Marshall)• UEA (Corinne Le Quéré )• Cambridge (Harry Elderfield)• Exeter (Peter Cox)• Plus some unfunded partners (Steve Barker, Maria

Sanchez-Goni, Oliver Wild,….)

Expertise• Palaeodata - ice (Jerôme Chappellaz, Eric Wolff and others)

• Palaeodata - land (Sandy Harrison, Maria Sanchez-Goni)

• Palaeodata – oceans (Frank Bassinot, Harry Elderfield, Elisabeth Michel, Steve Barker)

• Ocean dynamics (David Marshall and others)

• Atmospheric chemistry (Oliver Wild, Dudley Shallcross)

• Ocean biogeochemistry (Corinne Le Quéré, Laurent Bopp)

• C cycle modelling (Pierre Friedlingstein, Peter Cox)

• Ocean modelling (Neil Edwards)

• Coupled climate models (Pascale Braconnot, Paul Valdes, Gilles Ramstein)

• EMICs (Neil Edwards, Andy Ridgwell)

Page 12: Dynamics of the Earth System and the Ice-Core Record (DESIRE) Project submitted to the joint QUEST-INSU AO.

Strand 1: CH4 and atmos chem

1.1 Fire modules and integration of methane-related components into IPSL-ESM

1.2 13C into FAMOUS1.3 Prospects for constraints on source and

sink for methane (atmos chem)1.4 Wetlands/veg data synthesis at MIS

13/15; DO8 and DO 19/20 synthesis by collaboration with QQ

Page 13: Dynamics of the Earth System and the Ice-Core Record (DESIRE) Project submitted to the joint QUEST-INSU AO.

Strand 2: CO2 and C cycle

2.1 13CO2 in ice

2.2 Marine sediment constraints on C cycle (including CaCO3 and dissolution in sediments, Chatham Rise, and MIS16/15 and 12/11)

2.3 SO physics and biogeochemistry (effect of eddies, winds and overturning)

2.4 Dust parameterisation (shape, composition)

2.5 MGV development

Page 14: Dynamics of the Earth System and the Ice-Core Record (DESIRE) Project submitted to the joint QUEST-INSU AO.

Strands 3 (models and zoos) & 4

3.1 Time slices MH, EH, LGM (Q-ESM and IPSL-ESM)

3.2 Other interglacials as time slices (FAMOUS/IPSL-ESM)

3.3 Short transients DO8 and DO19/20 (FAMOUS, IPSL-ESM, MGV)

3.4 Data/model: Compile zoo of ig and g (includes workshops about proxies)

3.5 Transient simulations of transitions and igs (GENIE, MGV) to explore parameters leading to zoo

4 Coordination

Page 15: Dynamics of the Earth System and the Ice-Core Record (DESIRE) Project submitted to the joint QUEST-INSU AO.

Resources

• 23 years of new PDRA time

• Redirected efforts of numerous French researchers and research time of UK Co-Is

• Bilateral visits and exchanges in most areas

• Workshops for major data synthesis and proxy interpretation efforts

Page 16: Dynamics of the Earth System and the Ice-Core Record (DESIRE) Project submitted to the joint QUEST-INSU AO.

Management• Wolff and Friedlingstein responsible to QUEST,

NERC and INSU• Co-Is responsible for each WP• Management board providing direction, dealing

with problems, organising synthesis• Project coordinator assists PI, communications,

workshops• Project meetings: 2 per year, plus management

board interim meetings and virtual meetings• Year 3 project meeting will have goal of outlining

synthesis paper

Page 17: Dynamics of the Earth System and the Ice-Core Record (DESIRE) Project submitted to the joint QUEST-INSU AO.

International linkages

• Most participants are already strongly linked to external collaborators (through e.g. EPICA, PMIP, etc.)

• PIs/Co-Is are strongly involved in all the major international projects (AIMES, PAGES, IGAC, ILEAPS, GCP, …..

• Potential fast-track initiative (PAGES/AIMES) around EPICA challenge has recently been discussed; DESIRE could make natural leaders for this

Page 18: Dynamics of the Earth System and the Ice-Core Record (DESIRE) Project submitted to the joint QUEST-INSU AO.

A testbed for understanding of the Earth System

180

210

240

270

300Vostok + Dome C data

CO

2 /

pp

mv

-450

-420

-390

EPICA Dome C data

COLD

WARM

D ic

e /

300

400

500

600

700

0 200 400 600 800

Vostok + Dome C data

Age / kyr BP

CH

4 /

pp

bv

DESIRE should be a significant step towards understanding the Earth’s behaviour in response to external (or artificial) forcing

Page 19: Dynamics of the Earth System and the Ice-Core Record (DESIRE) Project submitted to the joint QUEST-INSU AO.

Key deliverables• Improvements in modelling tools available to

UK/Fra researchers• New constraining datasets (e.g. 13C), and

recommendations for future data needs• Improved understanding of some key processes• Flagship simulations of critical time periods• Synthesis assessment (with uncertainties) of

contribution of different mechanisms to the observed records of CO2 and CH4

• Enduring partnership of top UK and French researchers

Page 20: Dynamics of the Earth System and the Ice-Core Record (DESIRE) Project submitted to the joint QUEST-INSU AO.

End

Page 21: Dynamics of the Earth System and the Ice-Core Record (DESIRE) Project submitted to the joint QUEST-INSU AO.

Hypotheses• CH4 changes (g-ig, DO, ig-ig) can only be

explained by a combination of chnages in both source and sink– Constrain solutions that fit all the data; suggest new

tests

• CO2 and insolation are enough to explain the ig-ig and g-g variability observed– Effectively test climate sensitivity using warm periods

only

• CO2 changes result from a combination of (mainly SO) mechanisms– Improve the mechanisms in models and narrow the

error bars for the effect of each