Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert,...

240
Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3 ε = 1.1 minPts= 2 ε = 1.1 minPts= 3 ε = 1.1 minPts= 4 ε = 2.1 minPts= 4 ε = 4.1 minPts= 5 ε = 4.1 minPts= 4 DBSCAN and Single-Link Data Mining Tutorial Session 5: Clustering Erich Schubert, Eirini Ntoutsi Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München 2012-06-21 — KDD class tutorial

Transcript of Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert,...

Page 1: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

Data Mining TutorialSession 5: Clustering

Erich Schubert, Eirini Ntoutsi

Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München

2012-06-21 — KDD class tutorial

Page 2: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

Convergence of PAM

Let:

I Mi = model (= set of medoids) after the ith iteration.I TD(Mi) = cost of model Mi.

PAM when

There are(n

k

)possible models, but N iterations.

⇒ ∃t1<t2Mt1 = Mt2

⇒ TD(Mt1) = TD(Mt2) contradiction!

Page 3: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

Convergence of PAM

Let:

I Mi = model (= set of medoids) after the ith iteration.I TD(Mi) = cost of model Mi.

PAM converges when

TD(Mi) = TD(Mi+1)

There are(n

k

)possible models, but N iterations.

⇒ ∃t1<t2Mt1 = Mt2

⇒ TD(Mt1) = TD(Mt2) contradiction!

Page 4: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

Convergence of PAM

Let:

I Mi = model (= set of medoids) after the ith iteration.I TD(Mi) = cost of model Mi.

PAM does not converge when

∀i ∈ N : TD(Mi) > TD(Mi+1)

There are(n

k

)possible models, but N iterations.

⇒ ∃t1<t2Mt1 = Mt2

⇒ TD(Mt1) = TD(Mt2) contradiction!

Page 5: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

Convergence of PAM

Let:

I Mi = model (= set of medoids) after the ith iteration.I TD(Mi) = cost of model Mi.

PAM does not converge when

∀i ∈ N : TD(Mi) > TD(Mi+1)

There are(n

k

)possible models,

but N iterations.

⇒ ∃t1<t2Mt1 = Mt2

⇒ TD(Mt1) = TD(Mt2) contradiction!

Page 6: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

Convergence of PAM

Let:

I Mi = model (= set of medoids) after the ith iteration.I TD(Mi) = cost of model Mi.

PAM does not converge when

∀i ∈ N : TD(Mi) > TD(Mi+1)

There are(n

k

)possible models, but N iterations.

⇒ ∃t1<t2Mt1 = Mt2

⇒ TD(Mt1) = TD(Mt2) contradiction!

Page 7: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

Convergence of PAM

Let:

I Mi = model (= set of medoids) after the ith iteration.I TD(Mi) = cost of model Mi.

PAM does not converge when

∀i ∈ N : TD(Mi) > TD(Mi+1)

There are(n

k

)possible models, but N iterations.

⇒ ∃t1<t2Mt1 = Mt2

⇒ TD(Mt1) = TD(Mt2) contradiction!

Page 8: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

Convergence of PAM

Let:

I Mi = model (= set of medoids) after the ith iteration.I TD(Mi) = cost of model Mi.

PAM does not converge when

∀i ∈ N : TD(Mi) > TD(Mi+1)

There are(n

k

)possible models, but N iterations.

⇒ ∃t1<t2Mt1 = Mt2

⇒ TD(Mt1) = TD(Mt2)

contradiction!

Page 9: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

Convergence of PAM

Let:

I Mi = model (= set of medoids) after the ith iteration.I TD(Mi) = cost of model Mi.

PAM does not converge when

∀i ∈ N : TD(Mi) > TD(Mi+1)

There are(n

k

)possible models, but N iterations.

⇒ ∃t1<t2Mt1 = Mt2

⇒ TD(Mt1) = TD(Mt2) contradiction!

Page 10: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:

No borderpoints!

Page 11: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:

No borderpoints!

Page 12: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:BC

No borderpoints!

Page 13: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:B

No borderpoints!

Page 14: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C D

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:BD

No borderpoints!

Page 15: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C D

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:D

No borderpoints!

Page 16: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C D

B

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:D

No borderpoints!

Page 17: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C D

B

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:

No borderpoints!

Page 18: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:

No borderpoints!

Page 19: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:

No borderpoints!

Page 20: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:

No borderpoints!

Page 21: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:

No borderpoints!

Page 22: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

G K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:G

No borderpoints!

Page 23: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

G K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:

No borderpoints!

Page 24: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

G H K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:H

No borderpoints!

Page 25: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

G H K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:

No borderpoints!

Page 26: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

G H J

I

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:IJ

No borderpoints!

Page 27: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

G H J

I

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:I

No borderpoints!

Page 28: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:I

No borderpoints!

Page 29: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:

No borderpoints!

Page 30: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

G H J

I

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:

No borderpoints!

Page 31: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

G H J

I

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:

No borderpoints!

Page 32: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

G H J

I

K

L

K

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:

No borderpoints!

Page 33: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

G H J

I

K

L

K

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:

No borderpoints!

Page 34: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

G H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:

No borderpoints!

Page 35: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

G H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:

No borderpoints!

Page 36: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

G H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

O

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:O

No borderpoints!

Page 37: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

G H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

O

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:

No borderpoints!

Page 38: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

G H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

O P

R

N

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:NPR

No borderpoints!

Page 39: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

G H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

O P

R

N

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:NP

No borderpoints!

Page 40: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

G H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

O PN

R S

T

Q

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:NPQST

No borderpoints!

Page 41: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

G H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

O PN

R S

T

Q

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:NPQS

No borderpoints!

Page 42: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

G H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

O PN

R SQ

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:NPQS

No borderpoints!

Page 43: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

G H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

O PN

R SQ

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:NPS

No borderpoints!

Page 44: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

G H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

O PN

R S

T

Q

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:NPS

No borderpoints!

Page 45: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

G H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

O PN

R S

T

Q

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:PS

No borderpoints!

Page 46: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

G H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

O P

R S

T

Q

N

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:PS

No borderpoints!

Page 47: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

G H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

O P

R S

T

Q

N

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:S

No borderpoints!

Page 48: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

G H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

O

R S

T

Q

N P

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:S

No borderpoints!

Page 49: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

G H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

O

R S

T

Q

N P

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:

No borderpoints!

Page 50: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

G H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

O

R

T

Q

N P

S

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:

No borderpoints!

Page 51: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

G H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

O

R

T

Q

N P

S

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:

No borderpoints!

Page 52: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

G H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

O

R

T

Q

N P

S

ε = 1.1

minPts = 2

Seed list:

No borderpoints!

Page 53: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:

Page 54: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:

Page 55: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:BC

Page 56: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:B

Page 57: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C D

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:BD

Page 58: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C D

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:D

Page 59: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C D

B

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:D

Page 60: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C D

B

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:

Page 61: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:

Page 62: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:

Page 63: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:

Page 64: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:

Page 65: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:

Page 66: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:

Page 67: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:H

Page 68: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:

Page 69: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:IJ

Page 70: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:I

Page 71: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:I

Page 72: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:

Page 73: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:

Page 74: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:

Page 75: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:

Page 76: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:

Page 77: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:

Page 78: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:

Page 79: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:

Page 80: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:

Page 81: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

O

M

P

R

N

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:NPR

Page 82: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

O

M

P

R

N

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:NP

Page 83: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

O

M

PN

R S

T

Q

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:NPQST

Page 84: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

O

M

PN

R S

T

Q

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:NPQS

Page 85: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

O

M

PN

R SQ

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:NPQS

Page 86: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

O

M

PN

R SQ

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:NPS

Page 87: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

O

M

PN

R S

T

Q

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:NPS

Page 88: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

O

M

PN

R S

T

Q

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:PS

Page 89: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

O

M

P

R S

T

Q

N

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:PS

Page 90: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

O

M

P

R S

T

Q

N

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:S

Page 91: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

O

M

R S

T

Q

N P

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:S

Page 92: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

O

M

R S

T

Q

N P

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:

Page 93: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

O

M

R

T

Q

N P

S

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:

Page 94: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

O

M

R

T

Q

N P

S

ε = 1.1

minPts = 3

Seed list:

Page 95: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 96: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 97: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 98: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 99: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 100: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 101: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 102: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 103: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C D

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 104: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C D

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 105: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C D

EE

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 106: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C D

EE

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 107: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 108: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 109: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

G K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 110: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

G K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 111: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

HG

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:IJ

Page 112: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

HG

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:I

Page 113: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

HG

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:I

Page 114: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

HG

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 115: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

HG J

I

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 116: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

HG J

I

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 117: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

HG J

I

K

L

K

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 118: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

HG J

I

K

L

K

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 119: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

HG J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 120: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

HG J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 121: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

HG J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 122: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

HG J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 123: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

HG J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

O

M

P

R

N

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:NPR

Page 124: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

HG J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

O

M

P

R

N

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:NP

Page 125: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

HG J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

O

M

PN

R S

T

Q

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:NPQST

Page 126: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

HG J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

O

M

PN

R S

T

Q

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:NPQS

Page 127: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

HG J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

O

M

PN

R SQ

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:NPQS

Page 128: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

HG J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

O

M

PN

R SQ

T

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:NPS

Page 129: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

HG J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

O

M

PN

R S

T

Q

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:NPS

Page 130: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

HG J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

O

M

PN

R S

T

Q

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:PS

Page 131: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

HG J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

O

M

P

R S

T

Q

N

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:PS

Page 132: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

HG J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

O

M

P

R S

T

Q

N

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:S

Page 133: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

HG J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

O

M

R S

T

Q

N P

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:S

Page 134: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

HG J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

O

M

R S

T

Q

N P

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 135: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

HG J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

O

M

R

T

Q

N P

S

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 136: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

HG J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

O

M

R

T

Q

N P

S

ε = 1.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 137: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 138: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 139: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C D

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:BCD

Page 140: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

C D

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:BD

Page 141: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

DC

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:BD

Page 142: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A B

DC

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:D

Page 143: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

DC

B

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:D

Page 144: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

DC

B

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 145: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 146: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 147: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 148: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 149: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 150: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 151: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:HIJ

Page 152: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:IJ

Page 153: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

J

I

H K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:IJ

Page 154: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

J

I

H K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:I

Page 155: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

I

H J K

L

K

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:IK

Page 156: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

I

H J K

L

K

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:K

Page 157: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:K

Page 158: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 159: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 160: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 161: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 162: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 163: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

O P

R

N

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:ONPR

Page 164: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

O P

R

N

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:NPR

Page 165: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

P

R

N O

S

T

Q

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:NPRQST

Page 166: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

P

R

N O

S

T

Q

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:NPQST

Page 167: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

PN O

S

T

Q R

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:NPQST

Page 168: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

PN O

S

T

Q R

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:NPQS

Page 169: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

PN O

SQ R

T

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:NPQS

Page 170: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

PN O

SQ R

T

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:NPS

Page 171: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

PN O

SR

T

Q

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:NPS

Page 172: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

PN O

SR

T

Q

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:PS

Page 173: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

PO

SR

T

Q

N

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:PS

Page 174: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

PO

SR

T

Q

N

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:S

Page 175: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

O

SR

T

Q

N P

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:S

Page 176: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

O

SR

T

Q

N P

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 177: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

O

R

T

Q

N P

S

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 178: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

JG

F

H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

O

R

T

Q

N P

S

ε = 2.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

Page 179: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:

Page 180: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:

Page 181: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:

Page 182: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:

Page 183: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:

Page 184: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:

Page 185: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:

Page 186: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:

Page 187: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C DD

A B

C

EE

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:E

Page 188: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C DD

A B

C

EE

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:

Page 189: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C DD

A B

C

EE

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:

Page 190: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C DD

A B

C

EE

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:

Page 191: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C DD

A B

C

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

E

G H J

I

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:GHIJ

Page 192: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C DD

A B

C

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

E

H J

I

G K

L

K

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:HIJ

Page 193: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C DD

A B

C

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

E

H J

I

G K

L

K

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:HIJK

Page 194: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C DD

A B

C

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

E

H J

I

G K

L

K

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:IJK

Page 195: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C DD

A B

C

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

E

J

I

G H K

L

K

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:IJK

Page 196: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C DD

A B

C

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

E

J

I

G H K

L

K

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:IK

Page 197: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C DD

A B

C

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

E

I

G H J K

L

K

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:IK

Page 198: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C DD

A B

C

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

E

I

G H J K

L

K

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:K

Page 199: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C DD

A B

C

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

E

G H J

I

K

L

K

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:K

Page 200: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C DD

A B

C

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

E

G H J

I

K

L

K

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:

Page 201: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C DD

A B

C

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

E

G H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:L

Page 202: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C DD

A B

C

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

E

G H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:

Page 203: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C DD

A B

C

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

E

G H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:

Page 204: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C DD

A B

C

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

E

G H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:

Page 205: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C DD

A B

C

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

E

G H J

I

K

L

K

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

L

O P

R

N

S

T

Q

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:ONPRQST

Page 206: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C DD

A B

C

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

E

G H J

I

K

L

K

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

L

O P

R

N

S

T

Q

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:NPQST

Page 207: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C DD

A B

C

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

E

G H J

I

K

L

K

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

L

P

R

N

S

T

Q

O

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:NPQST

Page 208: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C DD

A B

C

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

E

G H J

I

K

L

K

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

L

P

R

N

S

T

Q

O

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:NPQST

Page 209: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C DD

A B

C

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

E

G H J

I

K

L

K

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

L

PN

S

T

Q

O

R

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:NPQST

Page 210: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C DD

A B

C

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

E

G H J

I

K

L

K

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

L

PN

S

T

Q

O

R

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:NPQS

Page 211: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C DD

A B

C

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

E

G H J

I

K

L

K

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

L

PN

SQ

O

R

T

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:NPQS

Page 212: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C DD

A B

C

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

E

G H J

I

K

L

K

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

L

PN

SQ

O

R

T

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:NPS

Page 213: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C DD

A B

C

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

E

G H J

I

K

L

K

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

L

PN

S

O

R

T

Q

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:NPS

Page 214: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C DD

A B

C

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

E

G H J

I

K

L

K

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

L

PN

S

O

R

T

Q

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:PS

Page 215: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C DD

A B

C

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

E

G H J

I

K

L

K

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

L

P

S

O

R

T

Q

N

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:PS

Page 216: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C DD

A B

C

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

E

G H J

I

K

L

K

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

L

P

S

O

R

T

Q

N

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:S

Page 217: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C DD

A B

C

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

E

G H J

I

K

L

K

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

L

S

O

R

T

Q

N P

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:S

Page 218: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C DD

A B

C

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

E

G H J

I

K

L

K

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

L

S

O

R

T

Q

N P

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:

Page 219: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C DD

A B

C

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

E

G H J

I

K

L

K

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

L

O

R

T

Q

N P

S

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:

Page 220: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C DD

A B

C

EE

F

G H

I

J

F

E

G H J

I

K

L

K

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

L

O

R

T

Q

N P

S

ε = 4.1

minPts = 5

Seed list:

Page 221: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 4.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

single-linklike effect!

Page 222: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 4.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

single-linklike effect!

Page 223: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 4.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:D

single-linklike effect!

Page 224: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

E

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 4.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

single-linklike effect!

Page 225: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 4.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:E

single-linklike effect!

Page 226: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 4.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

single-linklike effect!

Page 227: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

EE

F

G H

I

J K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 4.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

single-linklike effect!

Page 228: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

E

F

G H

I

J

F

E

G H J

I

K

L

K

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 4.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:K

single-linklike effect!

Page 229: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

E

F

G H

I

J

F

E

G H J

I

K

L

K

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 4.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

single-linklike effect!

Page 230: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

E

F

G H

I

J

F

E

G H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 4.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:L

single-linklike effect!

Page 231: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

E

F

G H

I

J

F

E

G H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

ε = 4.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

single-linklike effect!

Page 232: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

E

F

G H

I

J

F

E

G H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

O

ε = 4.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:MO

single-linklike effect!

Page 233: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

E

F

G H

I

J

F

E

G H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

O

R

T

Q

N P

S

ε = 4.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

single-linklike effect!

Page 234: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

E

F

G H

I

J

F

E

G H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

O

R

T

Q

N P

S

ε = 4.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

single-linklike effect!

Page 235: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

123456789

101112

A B

C D

A

C

B

D

E

F

G H

I

J

F

E

G H J

I

K

L

K

L

M

N O P

Q R S

T

M

O

R

T

Q

N P

S

ε = 4.1

minPts = 4

Seed list:

single-linklike effect!

Page 236: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN and Single-Linkage Clustering

DBSCAN with minPts = 2⇔ single-linkage dendrogram cut at distance ε.

DBSCAN is O(n2) (with index: O(n log n) only)but this is for a single ε only.

OPTICS (next week) with minPts = 2 is similar to SLINK(efficient algorithm for single-linkage clustering in O(n2))

However, results are generally better with larger minPts!

Page 237: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN and Single-Linkage Clustering

DBSCAN with minPts = 2⇔ single-linkage dendrogram cut at distance ε.

DBSCAN is O(n2) (with index: O(n log n) only)

but this is for a single ε only.

OPTICS (next week) with minPts = 2 is similar to SLINK(efficient algorithm for single-linkage clustering in O(n2))

However, results are generally better with larger minPts!

Page 238: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN and Single-Linkage Clustering

DBSCAN with minPts = 2⇔ single-linkage dendrogram cut at distance ε.

DBSCAN is O(n2) (with index: O(n log n) only)but this is for a single ε only.

OPTICS (next week) with minPts = 2 is similar to SLINK(efficient algorithm for single-linkage clustering in O(n2))

However, results are generally better with larger minPts!

Page 239: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN and Single-Linkage Clustering

DBSCAN with minPts = 2⇔ single-linkage dendrogram cut at distance ε.

DBSCAN is O(n2) (with index: O(n log n) only)but this is for a single ε only.

OPTICS (next week) with minPts = 2 is similar to SLINK(efficient algorithm for single-linkage clustering in O(n2))

However, results are generally better with larger minPts!

Page 240: Data Mining Tutorial - Session 5: Clustering · 2012. 6. 21. · Data Mining Tutorial E. Schubert, E. Ntoutsi Aufgabe 7-1 Aufgabe 7-3" = 1: minPts= 2" = 1:1 minPts= 3" = 1: minPts=

Data MiningTutorial

E. Schubert,E. Ntoutsi

Aufgabe 7-1

Aufgabe 7-3ε = 1.1minPts= 2

ε = 1.1minPts= 3

ε = 1.1minPts= 4

ε = 2.1minPts= 4

ε = 4.1minPts= 5

ε = 4.1minPts= 4

DBSCAN andSingle-Link

DBSCAN and Single-Linkage Clustering

DBSCAN with minPts = 2⇔ single-linkage dendrogram cut at distance ε.

DBSCAN is O(n2) (with index: O(n log n) only)but this is for a single ε only.

OPTICS (next week) with minPts = 2 is similar to SLINK(efficient algorithm for single-linkage clustering in O(n2))

However, results are generally better with larger minPts!