Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization

41
Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization Xinmin Zhang Institute of high energy physics 1) Brief review on the models of dark energy, especially on Quintom model; 2) Current constraints on the equation of state of dark energy; 3) Interacting dark energy: Testing CPT symmetry with CMB polarization; 4)Summary Outline Workshop on Frontiers of Cosmology at Dome A, Antarctica July 18-23, Beijing/Suzhou

Transcript of Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization

Page 1: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization

Dark Energy and

CPT Test with CMB PolarizationXinmin Zhang

Institute of high energy physics

1) Brief review on the models of dark energy, especially on Quintom model;2) Current constraints on the equation of state of dark energy;3) Interacting dark energy:

Testing CPT symmetry with CMB polarization;4)Summary

Outline

Workshop on Frontiers of Cosmology at Dome A, Antarctica July 18-23, Beijing/Suzhou

Page 2: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization

Dark Energy:Negative pressure:

)3(3

4/ pGaa +−= ρπ&&

0>a&& → 3/1/ 03 −<=<+ ρρ pwp* Smoothly distributed, (almost ) not clusteringdates:mological constant (or vacuum Energy)

μνμν πg

GT

=

1/ −== ρpw eV10~m

)102(8

3-

43

ν

πρ

×≈Λ

=−= − eVG

p

12010~/ obth ρρ cosmological constant problem!

ynamical Field: Quintessence

)(21 QVQQL −∂∂= μ

μ VQpVQ QQ −=+= 22

21,

21 &&ρ

11 ≤≤− Qw

Page 3: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization

Parameterization of equation of state:

A) w=w_0+w_1 z (for small z)B) w=w_0+w_1 z / (1+z) (used mostly in the literature)C) w=w_0+w_1 sin(w_2 ln(a)+w_3)

Equation of state w=p/ρ: characterize the properties of the dark energy models

* Vacuum : w=-1* Quintessence:

Important determining the equation of state of dark energy with cosmological observations

1w ≥ −

* Phantom:* Quintom: w crosses -1

For example:

single scalar:

1 ( )2

L Q Q V Qμμ= − ∂ ∂ − 2 21 1,

2 2Q QQ V p Q Vρ = − + = − −& & 1w ≤ −

No-Go Theorem!!

Page 4: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization

No-Go Theorem:For theory of dark energy (DE) in the 4D Friedmann-Robertson-Walker (FRW) universe described by a single perfect fluid or a single scalar field with a lagrangian of , which minimally couples to Einstein Gravity, its equation of state w cannot cross over the cosmological constant boundary.

Examples of Quintom models:

1) Two scalar fields:

2) Single scalar with high derivatives:

3) Modified Born-Infeld action:

Page 5: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization

Comments on Quintom model: 1) Quintom Bounce

The expanding of the universe is transited from a contracting phase; during the transition the scale factor of the universe a is at its minimum but non-vanishing, thus the singularity problem can be avoided.

.0>•

H0=H

Contracting phase:

;0<H ExpandingPhase:

.0>H

At the boun-cing point:

1)(4 −<⇒+−=•

wpGH ρπ

-10 -8 -6 -4 -2 0 2 4 6 8 100

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

20

t

a

a=1

Around it:

Transition to the observable universe (radiation dominant, matter dominant,…) So w needs to cross -1, and Quintom matter is required!

.1−>w

Yifu Cai et al., JCAP 0803:013(2008).Yifu Cai et al., JHEP 0710:071(2007).

Page 6: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization

Examples:1) Two Field Quintom

Page 7: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization

Examples:1) A single scalar with high-derivative term

Page 8: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization

2) Oscillating universe with Quintom matterXiong et al., arXiv:0805.0413

Solution:

Page 9: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization

Large field model:the resulted power spectrum is far from scale-invariant

Bounce + inflationBounce + inflation[R.Brandenberger, and X.M. Zhang, arXiv:0903.2065]

Small field model:For example, Phys.Rev.D79:021303,2009Phys.Rev.D79:021303,2009

Page 10: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization

Testing Oscillating Primordial Spectrum and Oscillating Dark Energy with Astronomical ObservationsJ.Liu, H.Li, J.-Q. Xia & X.Zhang, e-Print: arXiv:0901.2033

JCAP07(2009)017

This can be motivated by:

Natural inflation, Planck scale physics and oscillating primordial spectrumX.L. Wang, et al. Int.J.Mod.Phys.D14:1347,2005

Page 11: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization

The effects on the TT power spectrum and matter power spectrum

Page 12: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization
Page 13: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization

tance of perturbation: Constraint on dark energy by WMAP3

Relative error: ~9%

Relative error > 50% !!

3) on dark energy perturbation

Page 14: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization

∞→⇒≠→+ θδθδ ,,, 0 ,01 &&&ww

Difficulty with dark energy perturbationwhen w crosses -1

Page 15: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization

Perturbation of DE is continuous during crossing!

Here δ and θ are the density perturbation and the divergence of the fluid velocity respectively

Zhao et.al Phys.Rev.D 72,123515,2005

Perturbation with Quintom dark energy

Page 16: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization

I.

Quintessence –

like perturbation

I.

Phantom –

like perturbation

I.

Quintom-based perturbation

ε+−≥ 1)(zw

ε−−≤ 1)(zw

εε +−≤≤−− 1)(1 zw

0 ,0 == θδ &&

Our strategy to handle perturbations when w crosses -1

Page 17: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization

Global fitting procedure

Cosmological parameters:

)1()( 10 awwaw −+=

)lnsin()( 210 awwwaw +=

Method : modified CosmoMC, Perturbation includedG.-B. Zhao, et al., PRD 72 123515 (2005)

Calculated at ShangHai Supercomputer Center (SSC)

Data: CMB LSS SNe

1. w = constant

2. Perturbation divergent when w across -1 , new method

3.

Page 18: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization

Constrains on dark energy with SN Ia + SDSS + WMAP-1

Observing dark energy dynamics with supernova, microwave background and galaxy clustering

Jun-Qing Xia, Gong-Bo Zhao, Bo Feng, Hong Li and Xinmin Zhang Phys.Rev.D73, 063521, 2006

Page 19: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization

Quintessece

Quintom A

Quintom BPhantom

Current constraint on the equation of state of dark energy

WMAP5 resultE. Komatsu et al., arXiv:0803.0547 Xia, Li, Zhao, Zhang,

Phys. Rev. D78, 083524 (2008)

Status: 1) Cosmological constant fits data well;2) Dynamical model not ruled out;3) Best fit value of equation of state:

slightly w across -1 Quintom model

Difference:

Data: SN (SNLS+ESSENCE+Riess et al.)vs SN (307,Kowalski et al., arXiv:0804.4142)

Method: WMAP distance prior vs Full CMB data.However, results similar (Li et al., arXiv: 0805.1118)

Page 20: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization

APJ Lett. 683, L1, 2008

Page 21: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization
Page 22: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization

or the published version :

WMAP5 result E. Komatsu et al.,Astrophys.J.Suppl.180:330-376,2009

Xia, Li, Zhao, Zhang, PRD. 78, 083524

Page 23: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization

New results with Data: WMAP5 + small-scale CMB + SDSS LRG + ”constitution” sample (SN: CFA+UNION)

23

Page 24: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization

Results (WMAP5+Contitution SN+SDSS)

24SFU Group Meeting

Page 25: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization

25SFU Group Meeting

Page 26: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization

26SFU Group Meeting

Page 27: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization

Interacting Quintessence* If Quintessence –like scalar field responsible for the current acceleration of the Universe ,expected also to interact with thematter directly. Open new possibilities for the detection.

* Direct coupling with ordinary matterConstraint from the limits on the long-range force

* Interaction with derivativeGoldstone theorem: Spin-dependent force a unified model of DE and Baryo(Lepto)genesisQuintessino as DM

* Interacting with DM (Peebles et al )

* Interacting with neutrinos: mass varying neutrino

Page 28: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization

μνμνFQF Variation of the Fine Structure Constant

Example of Interacting Dark Energy

Page 29: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization

MllQ φφ

Λ

RcRNNQ

mass varying

Gu, Wang, Zhang,PRD68, 087301 (2003)Fardon, Nelson, Weiner, JCAP 0410:005(2004)

νm

Neutrino can decayXiao-Jun Bi, Bo Feng, Hong Li, Xinmin Zhang, PRD72:123523,2005

Neutrino oscillations as a probe of dark energyD. Kaplan, A. Nelson, N. Weiner, Phys.Rev.Lett.93:091801,2004

GRB: Delay of flight time?Li, Dai, Zhang, PRD71:113003,2005

Relaxing the cosmological limit on the Neutrino massGong-Bo Zhao, Jun-Qing Xia, Xin-Min Zhang, JCAP 0707:010,2007

Connection with Neutrino:1. ΛCDM:2. QCDM:

443 )()10( νλρ mev ∝∝ −

plQ M

meVm2

3310 ν∝∝ −

Neutrino Dark Energy

Page 30: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization

Interacting Dark Energy CPT Violation, Baryo-/Leptogenesis

and CMB Polarization

couplings:nified model of dark energy, dark matter

and baryon matter

model of baryogenesis and dark energy----Quintessential baryo/leptogenesis

SYing, Quintessino is dark matter particleed model of dark matter and dark energy

PT violation with WMAP and Boomerang

Page 31: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization

M.Li, X.Wang, B.Feng, X. Zhang PRD65,103511 (2002)De Felice, Nasri, Trodden, PRD67:043509(2003)

M.Li & X. Zhang, PLB573,20 (2003)

μμBJ

MQ

cL∂

=intIn thermo equilibrium⇒⇒

Quintessential Baryo(Lepto)genesis

MTQgc

TO

TTg

dEmEEgnn

bbbb

TETEmb

bbB bb

6])([

6

][)(2

 n

23

3

]/)exp[(11

]/)exp[(11

2/122

2

&≈+=

−×−=−= ++−+

∫μμπ μμ

32

452 Tgs ∗≈π

MTgQgcsn b

B∗

≈=&

2415/π

η

Cohen & Kaplan

The value of depends on the model of QuintessenceCosmological CPT violation!

Page 32: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization

Leptogenesis Anomaly for CMB

Page 33: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization

Cosmological CPT violation: predicting <TB> and <EB>

Bo Feng, Hong Li, Mingzhe Li and Xinmin ZhangPhys. Lett. B 620, 27 (2005);

Bo Feng, Mingzhe Li , Jun-Qing Xia, Xuelei Chen and Xinmin ZhangPhys. Rev. Lett. 96, 221302 (2006)

( )Q f Rμ μ∂ → ∂Hong Li et al

Page 34: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization
Page 35: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization
Page 36: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization
Page 37: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization
Page 38: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization
Page 39: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization

P.Cabella, Natoli & Silk, PRD76, 123014 (2007)

Wavelet Analysis:

WMAP3(TT,TG,GG,CC,TC,GC)

: 0.057 degPLANCK σ =

deg 0.40.6 ±−=Δα

deg 8.32.6 ±−=Δα

1)

2)

3)

6)

Bo Feng et al., PRL 96, 221302 (2006)

J.Q.Xia et al., arXiv:0710.3325

5) 2.6 1.9 degαΔ = − ±J.Q.Xia et al., arXiv:0803.2350

4) 1.7 2.1 degαΔ = − ±Komatsu et al., arXiv:0803.0547

Page 40: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization

Spatial dependent Δα

• Cosmological CPT violating effect on CMB polarization. Mingzhe Li , Xinmin Zhang. Published in Phys.Rev.D78:103516,2008. e-Print: arXiv:0810.0403

• De-Rotation of the Cosmic Microwave Background Polarization: Full-Sky Formalism. Vera Gluscevic, Marc Kamionkowski, Asantha Cooray . May 2009. 11pp.

• e-Print: arXiv:0905.1687 [astro-ph.CO]• A Constraint on Planck-scale Modifications to Electrodynamics with CMB polarization data.

Giulia Gubitosi, Luca Pagano, Giovanni Amelino-Camelia, Alessandro Melchiorri, Asantha

Cooray. Apr 2009.e-Print: arXiv:0904.3201 [astro-ph.CO]• Constraining a spatially dependent rotation of the Cosmic Microwave

Background Polarization. Amit P.S. Yadav, Rahul Biswas , Meng Su, Matias Zaldarriaga . Feb 2009. e-Print: arXiv:0902.4466 [astro-ph.CO]

• How to De-Rotate the Cosmic Microwave Background Polarization. Marc Kamionkowski (Caltech) . Oct 2008. Published in Phys.Rev.Lett.102:111302,2009. e-Print: arXiv:0810.1286 [astro-ph]

Page 41: Dark Energy and CPT Test with CMB Polarization

Summary

1) Current status on constraints on dark energy:

a) Cosmological constant fits data well;b) Dynamical model not ruled out;

2) B-Mode: Tensor Perturbation; CPT violation effects