1

Ιww

w.3

ds.c

om Ι

© D

assa

ult

Sys

tèm

es Ι

Con

fiden

tial

Info

rmat

ion

Ι08/

09/2

011

ref.:

201

0092

8MK

T03

8 Ι

Comparing ENOVIA - DMU Review 1 (DM1)

with

CATIA - 3D Insight (I3D)

2

Ιww

w.3

ds.c

om Ι

© D

assa

ult

Sys

tèm

es Ι

Con

fiden

tial

Info

rmat

ion

Ι08/

09/2

011

ref.:

201

0092

8MK

T03

8 Ι

I3D Configuration Overview

The 3D Insight product has been developed to comply with FAA (Federal Aviation Administration) certification policies which require there be only one model and one modifier, a primary engineer, during the entire development, deployment, manufacturing and management lifecycle.

3D Insight is especially dedicated to collaborators who need to access and use the 3D product definition. It provides review capabilities (including 3D tolerancing and annotations) and allows users to perform a precise analysis of the geometric product definition. 3D Insight does not allow users to save or export the created/modified data in order to prevent any changes of the 3D product definition.

3D Insight allows exact sectioning, exact measurement, sketch examination, construction and additional geometry creation for analysis, 3D Functional Tolerancing & Annotation (FTA) and 2D Layout for 3D Design (LO1) data review mark-up. It disallows the user to save the created data or to export it. Users can perform geometric analysis of the product within the manufacturing/assembly/inspection tooling context.

For more information: CATIA I3D configuration

3

Ιww

w.3

ds.c

om Ι

© D

assa

ult

Sys

tèm

es Ι

Con

fiden

tial

Info

rmat

ion

Ι08/

09/2

011

ref.:

201

0092

8MK

T03

8 Ι

DM1 Configuration Overview

This configuration provides in one seat all the tools necessary for technical data and

digital product visualization.

DM1 includes the ability to save modifications to parts and assemblies. It does not

include tools to edit geometry.

For more information: ENOVIA DM1 configuration

4

Ιww

w.3

ds.c

om Ι

© D

assa

ult

Sys

tèm

es Ι

Con

fiden

tial

Info

rmat

ion

Ι08/

09/2

011

ref.:

201

0092

8MK

T03

8 Ι

Infrastructure Workbenches

I3D

DM1

5

Ιww

w.3

ds.c

om Ι

© D

assa

ult

Sys

tèm

es Ι

Con

fiden

tial

Info

rmat

ion

Ι08/

09/2

011

ref.:

201

0092

8MK

T03

8 Ι

Product Structure Workbench

Workbenches are the same except:

I3D includes “Insert new part” New parts can be created but not saved

Included in I3D and DM1

DM1 I3D

6

Ιww

w.3

ds.c

om Ι

© D

assa

ult

Sys

tèm

es Ι

Con

fiden

tial

Info

rmat

ion

Ι08/

09/2

011

ref.:

201

0092

8MK

T03

8 Ι

Material Library Workbench

Workbenches are the same

Included in I3D and DM1

DM1 I3D

7

Ιww

w.3

ds.c

om Ι

© D

assa

ult

Sys

tèm

es Ι

Con

fiden

tial

Info

rmat

ion

Ι08/

09/2

011

ref.:

201

0092

8MK

T03

8 Ι

Catalog Editor Workbench

Workbenches are the same except:

I3D includes “Specifications Catalog Toolbar”

Catalogs can be created but not saved in I3D

Included in I3D and DM1

DM1 I3D

8

Ιww

w.3

ds.c

om Ι

© D

assa

ult

Sys

tèm

es Ι

Con

fiden

tial

Info

rmat

ion

Ι08/

09/2

011

ref.:

201

0092

8MK

T03

8 Ι

V4 Integration Workbench

The V4 Integration Workbench allows you to use Version 5

applications and to get advantage of CATIA Version 4

legacy data

DM1 has the ability to include CATIA V4 data in Digital

Mock-ups

Included in I3D only

I3D

9

Ιww

w.3

ds.c

om Ι

© D

assa

ult

Sys

tèm

es Ι

Con

fiden

tial

Info

rmat

ion

Ι08/

09/2

011

ref.:

201

0092

8MK

T03

8 Ι

DELMIA D5 Integration Workbench

DELMIA D5 Integration allows users to retrieve native DELMIA D5-based products

Imported DELMIA data can be saved in a V5 product structure

Included in DM1only

DM1

Import DELMIA D5 Component

Load a Recording File

Update DELMIA V5 Component

Replay A Loaded Recording

Convert D5 Library to V5 Catalog

10

Ιww

w.3

ds.c

om Ι

© D

assa

ult

Sys

tèm

es Ι

Con

fiden

tial

Info

rmat

ion

Ι08/

09/2

011

ref.:

201

0092

8MK

T03

8 Ι

Digital Mock-up Workbenches

I3D

DM1

11

Ιww

w.3

ds.c

om Ι

© D

assa

ult

Sys

tèm

es Ι

Con

fiden

tial

Info

rmat

ion

Ι08/

09/2

011

ref.:

201

0092

8MK

T03

8 Ι

DMU Navigator Workbench

Workbenches are the same

Included in I3D and DM1

DM1 I3D

12

Ιww

w.3

ds.c

om Ι

© D

assa

ult

Sys

tèm

es Ι

Con

fiden

tial

Info

rmat

ion

Ι08/

09/2

011

ref.:

201

0092

8MK

T03

8 Ι

DMU 2D Workbench

Workbenches are the same

Included in I3D and DM1

DM1 I3D

13

Ιww

w.3

ds.c

om Ι

© D

assa

ult

Sys

tèm

es Ι

Con

fiden

tial

Info

rmat

ion

Ι08/

09/2

011

ref.:

201

0092

8MK

T03

8 Ι

DMU Tolerancing Review Workbench

Workbenches are the same

Included in I3D and DM1

DM1 I3D

14

Ιww

w.3

ds.c

om Ι

© D

assa

ult

Sys

tèm

es Ι

Con

fiden

tial

Info

rmat

ion

Ι08/

09/2

011

ref.:

201

0092

8MK

T03

8 Ι

Mechanical Design WorkbenchesMechanical design workbenches are included in I3D only

I3D

DM1

15

Ιww

w.3

ds.c

om Ι

© D

assa

ult

Sys

tèm

es Ι

Con

fiden

tial

Info

rmat

ion

Ι08/

09/2

011

ref.:

201

0092

8MK

T03

8 Ι

Assembly Design Workbench

3D Insight offers assembly design capabilities without

the ability to save the created data. It defines

mechanical assembly constraints, automatically

positions parts, and checks assembly consistency.

Included in I3D only

I3D

Insert Existing Component with PositioningClash

16

Ιww

w.3

ds.c

om Ι

© D

assa

ult

Sys

tèm

es Ι

Con

fiden

tial

Info

rmat

ion

Ι08/

09/2

011

ref.:

201

0092

8MK

T03

8 Ι

Sketcher WorkbenchIncluded in I3D only

I3D

Create and modify 2D profiles

Created and modified data cannot be saved or exported

17

Ιww

w.3

ds.c

om Ι

© D

assa

ult

Sys

tèm

es Ι

Con

fiden

tial

Info

rmat

ion

Ι08/

09/2

011

ref.:

201

0092

8MK

T03

8 Ι

Drafting WorkbenchIncluded in I3D only

I3D

View create and modify 2D drawings

Created and modified drawings cannot be saved or

exported

18

Ιww

w.3

ds.c

om Ι

© D

assa

ult

Sys

tèm

es Ι

Con

fiden

tial

Info

rmat

ion

Ι08/

09/2

011

ref.:

201

0092

8MK

T03

8 Ι

Wireframe and Surface WorkbenchIncluded in I3D only

I3D

Create and modify CATIA surface data

Created and modified data cannot be saved or exported

19

Ιww

w.3

ds.c

om Ι

© D

assa

ult

Sys

tèm

es Ι

Con

fiden

tial

Info

rmat

ion

Ι08/

09/2

011

ref.:

201

0092

8MK

T03

8 Ι

DMU SectioningIncluded in I3D and DM1

Approximate measure

20

Ιww

w.3

ds.c

om Ι

© D

assa

ult

Sys

tèm

es Ι

Con

fiden

tial

Info

rmat

ion

Ι08/

09/2

011

ref.:

201

0092

8MK

T03

8 Ι

IntersectionIncluded in I3D only

Exact measure

21

Ιww

w.3

ds.c

om Ι

© D

assa

ult

Sys

tèm

es Ι

Con

fiden

tial

Info

rmat

ion

Ι08/

09/2

011

ref.:

201

0092

8MK

T03

8 Ι

Comparing ENOVIA - DMU Review 1 (DM1)

with

CATIA - 3D Insight (I3D)

Thank you