1 · Web viewΟ Kelsen μάλιστα έφτασε σε ... η λεγόμενη...
Transcript of 1 · Web viewΟ Kelsen μάλιστα έφτασε σε ... η λεγόμενη...
1
1. :
20 1 6 1 . , . . . , . .
, , .
, , , , , , .
, 20 1 , , .
, - - . , .
201 :
2.
- . , (4 1950) ( 1966). , , . , , .
, , . , 7 2 . , , - , ( ), , .
, 20 1 . , minimum , , 1 , , , 60% 2 ( : ) 20 1 , 6 1.
, 103 3. , . , , .
, 4 6 - 2002 17 25 , 68%. , 20 1985 1 1988, , .1846/19895,
1. , (), , , , 11, 18 25 1997, .., -, 1998, .10
2. , .., .27
3. -, , , .., -, 1999, 20 1, . 65-66.
4. http://www.echr.coe.int/Eng/EDocs/SUBJECTMATTER2002TABLE.pdf
5. , , ., ( ), , , EUNOMIA Verlag, , 1998, . 131
, 6.
, , 6 : , . 20 1 , 7,8 , 28 1 . 6 1 .
, ( ) . , 9. , 20 , , 10 , . ( ), .
,
6. , , ., , 2 , . . , -, 2002, .417
7. , .., . 416
8. , , ., , , 2 , . . , -, 1993, . 465-466
, , ., ( ), .., -, 1993, . 91 (: 20 1 .)
9. -, .., . 68
10. , .., . 399
25 1. , , , / 20 1. , 11, , , Hans Kelsen . Kelsen , .
, , . , Kelsen , . Kelsen 12, - , . , (Grundnorm), , 13.
H.L. Hart, 14, , Kelsen 15. . Kelsen , - - ,
11. , , , , , , 1994, . 53-59
12. , , ., , , 11, . . , -, 1999, . 16-19
13. H.Kelsen . Reine Rechtslehre, 1934
14. , .., . 19-22
15. H.L.Hart . The Concept of Law, 1961
Grundnorm.
, , . , , Nietsche 16: , . , . - 1989, a posteriori .
, - . , , , . , , .
, , . justice delayed is justice denied. , ; , , , , .
16. , , ( ), , , , 1998, . 67
, , . , . , , . 2002 844 391 375 17 ( 95%). ( Bottazzi vs. Italy, No 43884/97) : the accumulation of breaches accordingly constitutes a practise that is incompatible with the Convention18, .
( 20 1 6 1 ) . 1975 , 48 1 , .
, 20 1 , , . , - Franz Kafka ( , ) , , , . . ,
17. http://www.echr.coe.int/Eng/EDocs/2002SURVEY.pdf
18. Reports of Judgements and Decisions of the European Court of Human Rights, Bottazzi v. Italy [GC], no. 34884/97, 22, ECHR 1999-V
19, ( ) .20.
, , , 21, , , .
, , , .
19. K, , , (: ), 2001, . 217
20. , , , (: ), 2001, . 218
21. , , ., , 2 , . . , -, 2002, . 417-418
3. 20 1 .
3.)
3..1)
3..1.1)
22. . . ( ): , , 23. ( ), , , .
. , . , , ( ) , . , , .
. . , , . -
22. , , ., , , , , 1991, . 313
23. , , , , , , 1994, . 51
- , , . , .
24 . , , , , , . , , - , , . , .
, , , , , .
24 , Hans Kelsen. Kelsen, , . , -, 25, , .
24. , .., . 53-59
25. , .., . 313
3..1.2)
, , 26. , , . , . , . , , .
- - , , , 26. , , - - , - , . .
, , - 25 1 . - - , , ( ) . ( ) () 27.
26. , .., . 46 .
27. , , ., , , 2 , . . , -, 1993, . 469
3..2)
, , 1827, 14 : , , , , .
- - , - 6 1 , , , , .
, 22 ( , ) , 16 ( .).
1864 : , , , . . , , 28, 1975, 20 1 .
2001 29 25 1 : .
28. , ., .37
29. , , ., , 2 , . . , -, 2002, . 330
3..3) 2001
1 1 , ( ) 30. , , . , , 31.
32. . . , , , 34, 20 1 .
, . , 2001 (.4-25), (.26), (.110), (.93 4 .100), (.94, 95), (.20), .
30. , .., . 311
31. , .., . 364
32. , , ., , .., -, 1995, . 180
33. , .., . 311-319
34. , , ., , , 11 , . . , -, 2002, . 99
- - 35. 1 3 ., , 110 , , 93 4 , 26 ( ) 43 95 1 . , . 20 1 .
- . , - 25 1 . , , : ..
, - . , . 36, .
35. , .., . 368-377
36. , .., . 121-123
3..4)
1978, , .. 410/1968. ( ) - , :
, . , . , , , , 1 . 720/2977, , , , .37.
585/1978 , , , . , , - . , .
1095/1987,., . , , , . , :
, 1
37. , .., . 145-146
95 , , 38. 1095/1987 ( ) , .
, , , 1990/1990. , , , 103 , ( ) . , , , , , (normativ) .39
, , 2829/2990, 789/1990 . 2112/1984 ( ), 1426/1989, 4024/1990( ), 412/1993, . .. 703/1990 , .. 494/1993 1441, 2493 3480/1992 .
( ), / , 40.
38. 1989, . 37
39. , .., . 148-149
40. , , ., 1992, . 39
3..5)
, , , , , 41. , .
3..5.1)
, . C. Schmitt . Montesquieu, - , , . . , - .
. , 178942. , 26. , , ,
41. . , .., . 123-137
42. 16: Toute socit dans laquelle la garantie des droits n est pas assure et la sparation des pouvoirs (n est determine) n a point de constitution
, , , .
3..5.2.
. . , ( , , ), 43 , , . , , . , .
stricto sensu . . ( 87 2 .), intra legem secundum legem contra legem ( , , ) praeter legem ultra legem. , , imperium fiscus ( ).
, ( ) , , , .
43. , .., . 127
3..5.3)
, , , ( 4-25 .). . 44, , , .
, ( 20 .) , .
3..5.4.
. , , . , - , ( , 45)
44. Beatty, David, M., Human Rights and Judicial Review, Dordrecht, Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, 1994, pages 242-243
45. , , ., , , , , 2004, . 21
, 20 1 .46.
, , , - , .
, : .
, 20 1 . - . , .
46. , .., . 138-139
3.)
3..1)
3..1.1)
, , 1975, . , 1927 , 14 22 , , 47, 16, :
, , . , .
, 134 :
.
, 1832 , 14, , , - - :
, , , , , , , , .
. , 1844, , 91 :
.
( 1864, 1911, 1925, 1927
47. , 3..2) , .12
1952), . 1844 86 :
,
, 20 1 ., 1975 ( 2 , 1968 1973, .). , , , (.8) .
, 1 1974, , 1952, , 20 :
.
48 20 . , , , - ( ). , , .
, , , , , , .
48. , .., . 106
3..1.2) 20 1 .
20 1 . :
, .
, - , . .
3..1.2.1)
2 , 49. , , , . .
(audiatur et altera pars) , ( ), ( , ). , , , 50 , neque enim inaudita causa quemquam damnari aequitatis ratio patitur.
49. , , ., , , 2 , . . , -, 1993, . 464
50. , .., ( ), , . . , -, 1986, . 190
, , , , , , 20 , , ( 8 .). , , :
, , , , , - , - , , , , .51
, . , , . , , , . , .52 , , , 53.
. ( ) - , , , , ,
51. , .., . 374-375
52. , .., . 326
53. , .., . 85 ( , )
.
3..1.2.1.1)
, , , . , - , . 20 1 . . in dubio pro libertate a fortiori .
. , 6 1 ( , 28 1 ., , ), 20 1 , , , . , , , 6 1 54.
, .
3..1.2.1.2)
. . , , 55.
, ,
54. , .., . 87-88
55. -, .., . 91-92
. , , , , , .
, , , , . , , .
, 20 1 . 56.
.
, .
, 57.
( ) , , , .
4 1 . , .
, - , .
56. , .., . 377-387
57. . 347
, , , .
3..1.2.1.3)
20 1 . . . , - . , , 58, , 25 3 . ( ). , 59.
- - ( ) 60. . , , , . , , . .
, , .
58. - , .., . 74
59. . 116 ( )
60. , , ., , , . . , -, 2002, . 224 .
( )
61. , 20 1 . 25 1 . , .
62 . (actio popularis) . , , . 63, , , ( ) 20 1 64.
, , 20 1 . .
3..1.2.2)
, . , ( ). , ( ), ( 62) - . ( ) 65 ( ) 66, , , , .
61. , .., . 88
62. , .., . 379-380
63. , .., . 403-404
64. , .., . 87-88
65. 79-93 112-114
66. 586-590 106-108
, , , , , 67. , ( . 2251/1994) . , 62 . . :
, , , .
, , , 68. , . , , ( ), , .
3..1.3) 20 1 . 6 1
6 1 , , 20 1 . , , . , 87 1, , , , - .
,
67. , .., . 424
68. , .., . 379
69. , , , , 28 1 . .
, ( 10 1948) 10 - ( 14 1), . , .
3..1.3.1) 6 1
6 1 :
: , , , , .
, 20 1 . , . , , , . , , , , . , 2001, 25 1 . , , . - 2001- .
69. , , ., , . . , -, 2000, . 119
3..1.3.2) 20 1 .
6 . . , 34, ( , ). , , (toute personne), (everyone)70.
, , , 6 1 , , , , de facto . , , 5 1 ., , .
3..1.3.3)
, , , , , , , . , - 71.
, 28 1 ., , , , ,
70. -, .., .96
71. : , .., . 142 .
. , , . , .
, , 20 1 ., , , , (87 .)- , . , , 20 1 . , , , , .
, 20 . , , . , , , 20 1 . , 6 1 , . , ( 52 1 . ), - - . 20 1 . .
, , , , ( ) , 72.
3..2)
, 20 1 . 6 1 . , , . , , , , . justice delayed is justice denied73. H .
, , , , . , 74.
, , . , , , , , , , .
72. , , , , , . . , -, 1997, . 58
73. Stavros, Stephanos, The Guarantees for Accused Persons under Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights, Dordrecht, Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, 1993, preface
74. , .., . 764. 14 .
3..2.1)
, . , 20 1 .75 . , . , .
- - , , , . , 76. , 20 1 . .
, . in abstracto77 ad hoc, . , 18 Laino v. Italy ( 33158/96)78, , :
75. , .., . 378
76. , .., . 91.
77. Stavros, Stephanos, The Guarantees for Accused Persons under Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights, .., . 89
78. Reports of Judgements and Decisions of the European Court of Human Rights, Laino v. Italy [GC], no. 33158/96, 18, ECHR 1999-I
the reasonableness of the length of proceedings has to be assessed, in particular, in the light of the complexity of the case and of the conduct of the applicant and of the relevant authorities.
, - - , . , , , , , , 79.
, , , . , 80. , . , - , , , - . 6 1 .
, . . .
3..2.2)
, .
79. Stavros, .., . 92-105
80. , .., . 94
, - 6 , . .
, 6 , . , , 81.
, 53 , e contrario :
.
3..2.2.1)
, , , , ,
81. Weissbrodt, David and Wolfrum, Rdiger, The Right to a Fair Trial, International Symposium, Heidelberg, Germany, January 31-February 3 1996,Max-Planck-Institut fr auslndisches ffentliches Recht und Vlkerrecht, Springer-Verlag, Berlin-Heidelberg-New York, 1998, pages 647-649
. ( , , ) ( ) .
, , . , ad hoc, (, , - , ), .
- 82. - , , - - - .
3..2.2.1)
, - , . , , , - 83.
- -
82. , .., . 29
83. Stavros, , Stephanos, The Guarantees for Accused Persons under Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights .., . 84
84. . - , ( ), . , 85.
, , 6 , , :
: . ()
, , .
3..3)
, - . - , 86. , . , 6 1 , 87.
84. , .., . 55
85. Stavros, .., . 85-86
86. ,
87. Weissbrodt, David and Wolfrum, Rdiger, The Right to a Fair Trial, ., . 651
. 88, , . - , , - , .
, , , , 89. , . , , , - ( ) 90. , .
, . ( ) , , , , , 91.
, , . , ,
88. , .., . , . 48
89. , , ., , , .., . 466
90. , , ., , . . , -, 1996, . 325 ( )
91. , .., ( ), . . , -, 1986, . 167-168
( ).
3..4)
3..4.1)
- - , ( - ) 6 1- . , . , 2002, 844 , 391 375 92 ( 95%).
, , ( - .1846/1989 - , ) . 2002 25 , 2.96% 93, , , , .
92. http://www.echr.coe.int/Eng/EDocs/2002SURVEY.pdf
93. http://www.echr.coe.int/Eng/EDocs/2002SURVEY.pdf
3..4.2)
20 1 ., , , , - . , , - - , , .
, ( , ) , 94. , , , - 20 1 . , , , , .
, , . , , , ,
94. , , , , .., -, 1994, . 710-711
- - .
, 366-368/199295, . 96. , prima facie , , , . , 97 .
, , . , , 20 1 . , , 1980. , 98 - , .
, , , , . , , , ,
95. 1992, . 137-142
96.
97. 803/1984 364/1983 ()
98. . ,
4 5 .-, , , .
3..4.3) 1/1999
1/1999 99, . , .
, , , . , .
- . : .
, , , , - ( ) . , , , .
99. 1999, . 318
3..4.4) 30/1991
30/1990 100. , , . , 24 , prima facie .
, . .1264/1982 , - , , 5 .
20 1 6 1 . , . . 21 .
, , 21
100. 30/1990 . ( ), .., . 622 .
( ), . 21 ( ) .
, . , ( ). : ( ) .
( ), - 5 1 .- . , .
, - .
3..4.5)
, , , , . , 6 1 expressis verbis , , -, .
, 6 , - - . , ( ) Smokovitis and others v. Greece (No. 46356/99)101, Spentzouris v. Greece (No. 47891/99)102 Angelopoulos v. Greece(. 49215/99)103 2002, Sakellaropoulos v. Greece (No. 46806/99)104 (.13427/87)105, , - .
101.http://hudoc.echr.coe.int/hudoc/ViewRoot.asp?Item=1027&Action=Html&X=1117183320&Notice=0&Noticemode=&RelatedMode=1
102.http://hudoc.echr.coe.int/hudoc/ViewRoot.asp?Item=1004&Action=Html&X=1117182831&Notice=0&Noticemode=&RelatedMode=1
103.http://hudoc.echr.coe.int/hudoc/ViewRoot.asp?Item=5&Action=Html&X=524005606&Notice=0&Noticemode=&RelatedMode=0
104.http://hudoc.echr.coe.int/hudoc/ViewRoot.asp?Item=1026&Action=Html&X=1117183320&Notice=0&Noticemode=&RelatedMode=1
105.http://hudoc.echr.coe.int/hudoc/ViewRoot.asp?Item=1026&Action=Html&X=1117183320&Notice=0&Noticemode=&RelatedMode=1
3..4.6) Smokovitis and others v. Greece (No. 46356/99)
24 / , , 2002 , . ( ), , .
, 1992. ( 1993) - , . , 1994, . 1994 .2233/1994 , 1995 , , 77 1 . . 1996 6 1 ( 1997) .
. , . . 2233/1994 , , , , 5 , .
6 1 , , . , . 2233/1994 , 6 106. , .
.
3.B.4.7) Sakellaropoulos vs. Greece
. Sakellaropoulos v. Greece (No 46806/99) 11 2002. 6 1 . . . 18 1 . , , , , , , ( 120 .). . . 28 1985, .
30 1986 , 1986, 1981 1983, , , . 1986 .
106. Case of Smokovitis and others v. Greece (pplication no.46356/99), 28 (http://hudoc.echr.coe.int/hudoc/ViewRoot.asp?Item=1027&Action=Html&X=1117183320&Notice=0&Noticemode=&RelatedMode=1)
. 1988 , 1990. 1991, , , . 1992. , , 1996, 1998.
6 . ( 21 107) , , . , , 8 9 - , 6 , .
3..4.8)
, 108.
107. Case of Sakellaropoulos v. Greece (No 46806/99), 21, (http://hudoc.echr.coe.int/hudoc/ViewRoot.asp?Item=1026&Action=Html&X=1117183320&Notice=0&Noticemode=&RelatedMode=1)
108. -, , : , , - Baden-Baden: .., Nomos Verlagsgesellschaft, 1996, . 27 .
. , , ( ) 22 1972 .
1973 . ( 1973) 141/1975109 ( 107 2 .) . , .
, . 141/1975 ( . 1701/1987) ( expressis verbis ), . - ex tunc , . , 1990, .
1987 ( 61 ) 1 ( ).
109. .. 2687/1953
1991. 1993 6 1 , 110. , 6 ( ). Smokovitis v. Greece. , 20 1985, - .
1990 ( 23 ) 4 4 . ( ) , 6 1 . , 50 .. . , .
3.)
3..1) 201 .;
, , 111 .
110. (. 13427/87), 28 (a), http://hudoc.echr.coe.int/hudoc/ViewRoot.asp?Item=1026&Action=Html&X=1117183320&Notice=0&Noticemode=&RelatedMode=1
111. , , ., ( ), , , EUNOMIA Verlag, , 1998, . 93
112 .
. 20 1 . , . , , . 113 , , , .
sine qua non . ( ) , 87 1 . ( , , 114).
.
3..2) :
, . , ,
112. , , ., , 2 , . . , -, 2002, . 412 .
113. 718/1993, 1993, . 1577
114. , .., . 93
, , / , . , , a posteriori.
, . , .
3..2.1)
( ) 115. , . , , .
. , , , . , .
115. , , ., ( ), .., -, 1993, . 173 ., .
.
, 116. , , , , . - , ( ).
, , - 20 1 . , 117. , , , .
3..3)
( ), . (.) 228/1992118 , (.) 18/1993 (.) 29/1993 (.) 8/1993119 (
116. -, , , .., -, 1999, . 85
117. -, .., . 130
118. 1992, (.) 228/1992, . 1312-1314
119. 1993, (.) 18/1993, (.) 29/1993 (.) 8/1993, . 1200-1202
, 1943/1991), . 2522/1997 .
3..3.1) (.) 228/1992
57 4 . 1943/1991 . , , . , .
120. , . 1943/1991. 57 4 :
.
, , . 1943/1991 . 1992121, - - .
, 20 1 ., , :
,
120. .. 18/1989, . 702/1977 4 2
121. . 2026/1992
, , .
, , , , , . , 18/1989 ( 52) . .
3..3.2) (.) 18/1993 (.) 29/1993 (.) 8/1993
, 1943/1991, , 8 18 1993. . (.) 18/1993 , 57 . 1943/1991 , ( ) .
(.) 8/1993 ( 122) . 1943/1991 1992. , 12 8 . 1400/1983, . 52 .. 18/1989 .
20 1 ,
122. . (.) 21/1993
. 57 . 1943/1991. 123 , , , 20 1, .
, (.) 29/1993. 16 4 . 2026/1992 , . , , .
(.) 62/1993124 . 1400/1983 .. 18/1989 ;
3..4) O v.2522/1997
. 2522/1997 . ,
123. , , ., , 2 , . . , -, 2002, . 413 59
124. 1993, (.) 62/1993, . , . 1204
. , , ( ).
, . . 2522/1997, .
125, . , . .2522/1997 . , .
, . 2522/1997 ( ) , , , . (
125. , , ., ( . 2522/1997 ), .., -, 1998, . 79 .
126 ) .
4. ( 21/2001)
, , , , 127. 20 1 . , , 6 1 .
( ) . , , , ( ) , 128.
2915/2001129 , ( 1 1 . 2915/2001). , , 130, 131 , , -
126. , , ., .., . 140-141
127. .
128. 270 1
129. http://www.parliament.gr/ergasies/nomosxedia/ValidNomosxedio/E-DIKASTH.pdf , 109, 29/5/2001
130. http://www.hcba.gr/ekdiloseis.php3
131. ( 165) . 3160 30/6/2003
, .
, . - , , . , , .
21/2001 132. . 2097/1952, ( 8) , 133. .
134 , .. 135, 50 . 20 1 136, . 2097/1952 .
, .
132. http://www.nchr.gr/category.php?category_id=75
133. , , ., , . . , -, 2000, . 7-8
134. , ( ), , , EUNOMIA Verlag, , 1998, . 690-695
135. -, , : , , - Baden-Baden: .., Nomos Verlagsgesellschaft, 1996, . 57
136. , .., . 103 .
137, . , , , - .
137. , -, ., 6 . 1 , , , .., -, 1996, . 185 .
5.
, sine qua non , . , , , , , , .
20 1 , , . 6 1 ( expressis verbis ) .
, , . , .
, .
, 20 1 . , . , , , . , . , .
HE RIGHT TO A SPEEDY TRIAL AND THE RULE OF LAW
Synopsis
In this project we deal with the primary aspect of the principal of the rule of law, which is the right to a fair trial as it is protected both from the Greek Constitution and the European Convention On Human Rights. In particular, we regard the fact that justice should be delivered on time as our main subject, and stress out that a fair trial presupposes that the proceedings are of a reasonable length. After a brief introduction and a mention to the theories developed in the past, we attempt to point out the matters to which the first paragraph of article 20 of the Greek Constitution extends to, its protective core, the individuals who have the right to judicial protection as well as its content, and we do the same with the first paragraph of article 6 of the European Convention On Human Rights. We focus mostly on the right to a speedy trial and comment on the situation in Greece, a country that, based on the jurisprudence of the European Court of Human Rights, has violated the aforementioned article on many instances. We analyze some of these decisions, as well as examples of the jurisprudence of Greek Courts. We also reffer to temporary judicial protection and, apart from that, certain measures taken by the Greek State in order to improve the delay noted on the Greec judicial system are underlined.
Beatty, David, M., Human Rights and Judicial Review, Dordrecht, Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, 1994
Hart, H., LA., The Concept of Law, 1961
Kelsen, Hans, Reine Rechtslehre, 1934, 19622
Reports of Judgements and Decisions of the European Court of Human Rights
Stavros, Stephanos, The Guarantees for Accused Persons under Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights, Dordrecht, Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, 1993
Weissbrodt, David and Wolfrum, Rdiger, The Right to a Fair Trial, International Symposium, Heidelberg, Germany, January 31-February 3 1996,Max-Planck-Institut fr auslndisches ffentliches Recht und Vlkerrecht, Springer-Verlag, Berlin-Heidelberg-New York, 1998
,
, , ., , , , , 1991
, , ., ( . 2522/1997 ), .., -, 1998
, , ., , , . . , -, 2002
, , ., , .., -, 1995
, , ., , , , , 2004
, , ., , . . , -, 1996
, -, ., 6 . 1 , , , .., -, 1996
-, , : , , - Baden-Baden: .., Nomos Verlagsgesellschaft, 1996
, , ( ), , , , 1998
-, , , .., -, 1999
, (), , , , 11, 18 25 1997, .., -, 1998
K, , , , 2001
, .., ( ), . . , -, 1986
, , , , , , 1994
, , ., , 2 , . . , -, 2002
, , ., ( ), , , EUNOMIA Verlag, , 1998
, , ., , , 11, . . , -, 1999
, , , , , . . , -, 1997
, , , , .., -, 1994
, , ., ( ), .., -, 1993
, , ., , , 11 , . . , -, 2002
, , ., , . . , -, 2000
, , ., , , 2 , . . , -, 1993
, , ., , 2 , . . , -, 2002
:
http://www.echr.coe.int
http://www.hcba.gr
http://www.nchr.gr
http://hudoc.echr.coe.int
http://www.parliament.gr
:
:
.. 585/1978
.. 703/1990
2112/1984
1095/1987 . 1989, . 37
1426/1989
789/1990, .
1990/1990 .
2829/1990
4024/1990
144/1992
2493/1992
3480/1992
412/1993, .
494/1993
366/1992*
367/1992*
368/1992 *
* 1992, . 137-142
803/1984
364/1983
1/1999, 1999, . 318
30/1990
:
718/1993, 1993, . 1577
(.) 228/1992, 1992, . 1312-1314
(.) 18/1993*
(.) 29/1993*
(.) 8/1993*
(.) 21/1993*
(.) 62/1993*
* 1993, . 1200-1204
:
Smokovitis and others v. Greece (No. 46356/99) (http://hudoc.echr.coe.int/hudoc/ViewRoot.asp?Item=1027&Action=Html&X=1117183320&Notice=0&Noticemode=&RelatedMode=1 )
Spentzouris v. Greece (No. 47891/99) (http://hudoc.echr.coe.int/hudoc/ViewRoot.asp?Item=1004&Action=Html&X=1117182831&Notice=0&Noticemode=&RelatedMode=1 )
Angelopoulos v. Greece (. 49215/99) (http://hudoc.echr.coe.int/hudoc/ViewRoot.asp?Item=5&Action=Html&X=524005606&Notice=0&Noticemode=&RelatedMode=0 )
Sakellaropoulos v. Greece (No. 46806/99) (http://hudoc.echr.coe.int/hudoc/ViewRoot.asp?Item=1026&Action=Html&X=1117183320&Notice=0&Noticemode=&RelatedMode=1 )
(.13427/87) (http://hudoc.echr.coe.int/hudoc/ViewRoot.asp?Item=1026&Action=Html&X=1117183320&Notice=0&Noticemode=&RelatedMode=1 )