Παναγιώτης Φάκλαρης Προβλήματα Στον Τάφο ΙΙ Της...

345

K O O TO II B: TO MO O K O1

O , 1977 2, , , 336 .X.3,

1. - Cambridge Faculty of Classics . O - . . 1995 , . , -. , . -, .

2. : Colloquium 2008 AA The Chronology of the RoyalMacedonian Tombs at Vergina, 109th AnnualMeeting. Abstracts, Archaeological Institute ofAmerica, 31, January 3-6, 2008, 128-130. , - , Gill D.W.J., Inscribed Silver Plate fromTomb II at Vergina: Chronological Implications,Hesperia 77 (2008) 335-58. , Borza E.N.-PalagiaO., The Chronology of the Macedonian RoyalTombs at Vergina, JdI 122 (2007) 81-125. BartsiokasA.-Carney E., The Royal Skeletal Remains fromTomb I at Vergina, , 2007-2008, 15-19.

3. . ., . O - , 1984, 232( 1984). - Hammond Musgrave. .Hammond N.G.L., Philips Tomb in HistoricalContext, GRBS 19 (1978) 331-50 The Evidence forthe Identity of the Royal Tombs at Vergina, Adams W.L. Borza .. (.), Philip II,Alexander the Great and the Macedonian Heritage,Lanham-N.York-London 1982, 111-27. The RoyalTombs at Vergina: Evolution and Identities, BSA 86(1991) 69-82. . Miller S.G., The Tomb of Lysonand Kallikles: A Painted Macedonian Tomb (Mainz amRhein 1993) 3 . 8 ( Miller). PragA.J.N.W.-Musgrave J.H.-Neave R.A.H., The Skullfrom Tomb II at Vergina: King Philip II of Macedon,JHS 104 (1984), 60. Musgrave J.H., The HumanRemains from Vergina Tombs I, II and III: AnOverview, AncW 22 (1991) 6. , - . . -., . O . , 2004. ., . , 2005, 28-61.

4, 316 .., - 5, - 6, 7.

, , , 8.

346

ANAITH AKAPH

4. . , 1984, 231-32.5. Adams W.L., The Royal Macedonian Tomb at

Vergina: An Historical Interpretation, AncW 3(1980) 67-72. Cassander, Alexander IV and theTombs at Vergina, AncW 22 (1991) 27-33. Lehmann,P.W., The So-Called Tomb of Philip II: A DifferentInterpretation, AJA 84 (1980) 229-30. Once Againthe Royal Tomb at Vergina, AAA 14 (1981) 138-40.The So-Called Tomb of Philip II. An Addendum,AJA 86 (1982) 437-38. Prestianni Giallombardo.., La tomba e il tesoro di Filippo II di Mace-donia: Una nuova proposa di attribuzione, MagnaGrecia 16 (1981) 14-17. Riflessioni storiografichesulla cronologia del Grande Tumulo e delle tombereali di Vergina, - , 4-10 -

1983, 1 ( 1985) 237-41. Il diadema diVergina e l iconografia di Philippo II, - IV, 1986, 497-509. Recenti testi-monianze iconografiche sulla kausia in Macedonia ela datazione del fregio della caccia della II tombareale di Vergina, DHA 17 (1991) 257-304. PrestianniGiallombardo .M.-Tripodi B., Le tombe regali diVergina: Quale Filippo? , AnnPisa Sezione di lettere,ser. III, vol. X, 3 (1980) 989-1001 Robertson .,Early Greek Mosaic Barr-Sharrar B. BorzaE.N. (.), Studies in the History of Art, 10, Macedoniaand Greece in Late Classical and Early Hellenistic

Times, Symposium 1979, Washington 1982, 246. BorzaE., Those Vergina Tombs Again, ArchNews 11(1982) 8-10. The Royal Macedonian Tombs and theParaphernalia of Alexander the Great, Phoenix 41(1987) 105-21. The Macedonian Royal Tombs atVergina: Some Cautionary Notes, ArchNews 10(1981) 73-87 In the Shadow of Olympus the Emergenceof Macedon, 1990, 256-66. Pfrommer ., Studien zur alexandrinischer und grossgriechischer Toreutik

frhhellenistischer Zeit, 1987, 183 (FK 59).

Untersuchungen zur Chronologie frh-und hochhelleni-

stischen Goldschmucks, Tbingen 1990, 259 (FK 111).Carney E., The Female Burial in the Antechamberof Tomb II at Vergina, AncW 22 (1991) 17-26.Tomb I at Vergina, ArchNews 17 (1992) 1-10. Olym-pias, mother of Alexander the Great, -.2006, 157. Bartsiokas A., The Eye Injury of KingPhilip II and the Skeletal Evidence from the RoyalTomb II at Vergina, Science 288 (2000) 514. Bartsio-kas Carney .. 17-18. Borza Palagia, (.)118. O Gill (.. 354) .

6. Pfrommer ., .. 259 (FK 111). O Pfrommer , - (297..).

7. . , . 10.8. ,

- ( 1984, 189) - [ . (.), , 1979, 49, . 95], , .. .., , 40(1985): ., 10. - - ( 1984, 119, 165, . 31, 73) 1997 - , , , -, -

KAI AA POBHMATA TOY TAOY II TH BEPINA

347

- , , 317 ..9. - -10 -11. .

- , ... -

. . .., ; , . , 1994, 137-48. , (. Drougou St., Vergina. On the tracks of theMacedonian kings, Valavanis P. (.), GreatMoments in Greek Archaeology, 2007, 266. O , , - , . . K- ., , , VI, 1, 1996 (1999),632. O - O [ M., . O - , 10 (1977) 25-26] ( 1984, . 75) , , . - , - . . - .,. O .

, 2004, 176. 9.

4 . .. (

., . , 2005, 28-61 Saatsoglou-Paliadeli Chr., Lapeinture de la Chasse de Vergina Descamps-Lequime S. (.), Peinture et couleur dans le mondeantique, 2007, 52, . - - 4 . . Rotroff S.I., AJA 111 (2007) 809 ..(review 2005). , Eadem, WhosePottery? The Ceramics from the Vergina Tombs,Colloquium , .. 129-30, Royal SaltCellars from the Athenian Agora, AJA 86 (1982) 283 Spool Saltcellars in the Athenian Agora,Hesperia 53 (1984) 343-54. - , Gill (.. 354), - , . , , . . . . ..-- .., O , 1997, 173( -).

10. Faklaris P.B., Aegae: Determining the Site ofthe First Capital of the Macedonians, AJA 98 (1994)609-16. ., , 2006. - [Papazoglou F., Les Villes de Macdoine lpoque Romaine, BCH Suppl. 16 (1988) 134, .63], , - .

11. . . 5.

...12, , , 13. - .

.

O , ( , )14, 9.50, 5.56, 5.3015 6,08 .16. , . - , -17; , 1984, - , , ( ) .

(. 1), , 1910 , 9.50, 7.83 4.75 .18. O

348

ANAITH AKAPH

12. 1984, 96.13. 1984, 96-97, 220, 228-29, 233. -

, O - , 13 (1980) 158-59 ( ). Hammond, Hammond N.G.L Walbank F.W., A History of Macedonia, III, 336-167B.C., O 1988, 6-7. , Philip of Macedon, 1994, 179, . O Fedak, , . B. Fedak J., Monumental Tombs of theHellenistic Age: A Study of Selected Tombs from the Pre-

Classical to the Early Imperial Era, Toronto 1990, 106.14. O . :

:

,

-

, , - .. ., O

, 12 (1972) 147, . 3.15. 1984, 96. 16. - ., . O

. , 2004, 7.

17. B. : Winter Fr. Studies in HellenisticArchitecture, Toronto 2006, 89: the longest andhighest Macedonian tomb ever found... - (26-7-2009: , . - . , O - . ) : O

. . (. O ,10-1-1999, ).

18. Macridy Th., Un tumulus Macdonien Langaza, JdI 26 (1911) 199. Gossel B., MakedonischeKammergrber, 1980, 143 ( Gossel).


349

, 1954 1966, 8.70, 8.60 8.68 .19. , 1984 , , . , , , -, 1,75 . 2,52 . .

: O 1987 , 10.60-10.70 . , 5.80 . 7.50-7.95 . 20. O , 1987, 10 ., 5 . , 21. O 1993 . , 10.30, 6.10 6.30 .22. O -, 1994 , 10.60 . , 6.60 6.60 .23.

, , , , , , . , , , , , 24 (. 2).

, , , - , - , , , . ,

19. . ., O , 1966, 55. Gossel, 158.

20. . .,. 1987, 1 (1987) 81-84,. 7-11. ., , 1987, 374-79, . 3-4 ., O , Ginouvs R. (.),

, 1993, 156-61, . 1 135-37.21. .,

, 1 (1987) 91. 22. ., O

, 7 (1993) 129.23. .,

1994, 8(1994) 58. ., 1995, 9

(1995) 146-48.24. (.

1984, 32, 96 . 4) , -. O , 8,99 5,31 ., , 1984 , ( 9,50 .) . - ( 9,50 .), . 1984 , 8,60 ., ( 7,83 .) . ( 6,08). , . .., O , 1951, 28. Gossel, 252.

. , , , - , , .

, . , , - . , , 25, - , - , 26 27, . , - , , 28, , 29 .

. O

O , . - 30 , , ,

350

ANAITH AKAPH

25. . - . 26. , .

. , , 1998.27. ..,

, 1955, 151-59. Gossel, 125-31.

28. , , , .

29. , -

, - , - , .

30. 1984, 96-97, 220, 228-29, 233. AAA, 158-59.


351

, - -31.

, . , - , , ) , , , ) - , ) - 32. , - , , - , , 33. -, , - , , , , - 34.

: , ; , , , , ;

, - 35. , , 36, - , , . , - , . , , ,

31. , 160. O Giallombardo Tripodi -, . - - , - -.. Prestianni Giallombardo Tripodi, .. 998 Lehmann, .. , 141-42.

32. 1984, 220.

33. 1984, 96, 220, 228, 233. 34. 1984, 233.35. O - (

1. 24. 11), upsilonlenis - upsilonlenisupsilontilde....

36. . Riginos A.S., The Wounding of Philip IIof Macedon: Fact and Fabrication, JHS 114 (1994)103-119, -.

. , , .

, -, .

O , -37. , , - - -, , .

O (. 3), , () , , . , , , , , ( ). , , - , (. 4, 5). , , , , , , - . , . -, , , , , , . , - , .

, , , ( ) , 38 , (. 3). , -

352

ANAITH AKAPH

37. 1984, 229.38. . 1984, . 31,

, , -.


353

, , , , . O , , , ( ) , - , . , , - , . O , , , 39. -, , - - , .

O - . , - , , , , , . ( ) , (. 5). , , (. 5). , ,

39. . -. , - ,

. , , - , - - (. --, 138).

, 40. , , - , , , . , , ,, , , .

O , , - , - , , , - , , - .

. , , . , , - , . , . , , 41 42. , 43. , , 44

354

ANAITH AKAPH

40. ( ), - , .

41. ., . O - , - -

2 (1932) 13, . 4. Boardman J., ravelling

Rugs, Antiquity 44 (1970) 143-44. Gossel, 119. ., , 33 (1989) 38.Miller, 14, 45.

42. Miller, 45-46, . Vb 14e-f. Gossel, 185.43. .., O

() , 1937, III, 870-71 874.

44. , . 1984, 198-217.


355

45. , .

, , , - , - . - , , , , - , , . - , - 46. , , ( - ), , , 47, 48, 49 . , .

, -, ... 50. , ( ), - , , . ,

45. . , O , M. Ginouvs (.), ( 1993), 160.

46. Miller (Miller, 17), - : ...it is by no means always the same partsof a tomb which are emphasized through architecturalor painted embellishment: elaborate exteriors may becombined with simple interiors and utterly plainfacades may conceal highly ornate burial chambers.

47. , . . 24, 41. - . Rhomiopoulou K., A New MonumentalChamber Tomb with Paintings of the Hellenistic

Period near Lefkadia (West Macedonia), 6(1973) 87-92. ., . , 1997, 30-35. Gossel, 192-200.

48. . ., - . , 1986, 60-98.

49. ., 1994, 8(1994) 53-72 ., 1995, 9 (1995), 143-154.

50. 1984, 220.

. , - , - . , - , , .. , - 51, , - . - .

. , - , , 52 , , (. 4). - , , 0,08 . . , , 53. . , , - , , 54. O - , , .

, , - , , . .. 55 56., , .. 57,

356

ANAITH AKAPH

51. , .. 84. .., : - , 27 (1989-1990) 212-13.

52. ., , 13 (1999) 561.

53. Miller (Miller, 6) - -

, .

54. , .. 562-63. 55. Macridy, .. (. 18) 199, . 3.56. . ., O ,

1966, 25, . 3.57. Makaronas Ch. I. Miller S. G., The Tomb

of Lyson and Kallikles. A Painted Hellenistic Tomb,Archaeology 27 (1974) 249-59. Miller, 27, . 2 4a.


357

58, IV ( )59, Kinch 60, 61, 62 63. O , , , - .

, , .

, , - , - , - . , , ( ), , , - , - . , , - , 64. , , - , 65. ,

58. ., 1981, 57-59. 1984, 35.

59. Andronikos M., Some Reflections on theMacedonian Tombs, BSA 82 (1987) 16.

60. Kinch K.F., Le tombeau de Niaousta.Tombeau macdonien, Mmoires de lAcadmieRoyale des Sciences, 7me Srie, Sect. des Lettres, IV, 3(Copenhague 1920) 283-88, . I-V. .- , O - ( Kinch), (1971) 146-64, . 6 8.

61. - X. - Hoepfner W,.. . , 28 2(1973): ., 455-59, . 5. Gossel, 104-110, .

IIIe.62. . .,

, 20 3 (1965): ., 436. I., , 24 2(1969): ., 327. Gossel, 211-16, . IIId.

63. , .. 36-51. ., O , O , 1985, 11. ., , 33 (1989) 35-38. Gossel, 111-125, . IIIa.

64. 1984, 64 220.65. ., .. VI, 632.

, - .

O , -66, ( ) 67. , - , , , , 3,36 .68. O 69, , , , - . , .

, , - , - , -, . , .

, , : ,

358

ANAITH AKAPH

66. - Tomlinson, . TomlinsonR.A. Vaulting Techniques of the MacedonianTombs, , 1977,476-77.

67. 1984, 220: ...

,

.

. 96 - ,

-

. , - , , .

, , -, , .

68. H Lehmann it is inconcei-vable that the tomb was left facadeless until Olympias,after the assassination of Philip, had later disposed ofKleopatra and her infant son. , Lehmann, ... must have been a matter of structural procedure,whatever the motivation. . Lehmann, .. AAA,140-41.

69. 1984, 228.


359

- -

. , :

70. -, , , - 71. Hammond72.

: 1) , -

-73. . , , , . , , - , , 74.

2) , , 75. , , .. 76, A 77, - 78, -79, 80, . 81 82.

3) O , .

70. 1984, 97.71. , 159-60.72. Hammond N.G.L., Philip of Macedon,

1994, 180.73. Musgrave J.H., Dust and Damnd Oblivion: A

Study of Cremation in Ancient Greece, BSA 85(1990) 276. Prag-Musgrave-Neave, .. 77. - 1984, 170.

74. , . .

75. Miller, 64 . 18-19.76. Miller, 63.

77. -, 30.78. ., , O -

, 1985, 54.79. , ,

1941-1952, 599-601.80. ., O

, 7 (1993) 127-28.81. - . .

1994. , 8 (1994)234.

82. ., O , 1990, 16, 19, 51.

, , , , 83.

, , , .

, 84. , , - 85, . ( ), ., , , , - . - , - 86. , , O, 87 , - , 88. , , , , . - 89.

, , , , , . 90. O

360

ANAITH AKAPH

83. . ., -, 41 (1986): ., 4, 20, 26.

84. 1984, 233.85. 1984, 232. 86. O Hammond (.. Philip of Macedon, 182),

, , , - 1984, 197. , , .

87. 9.7. 8.7.7. , 10.7. . Musgrave, .. BSA, 278

. 32.88. . Lehmann, .. AAA, 140-41.89. Musgrave, .. BSA, 278-79.90. -

, . , - - ( . 1). . ., A , 1960, 69-71. Idem, , 1972, 61, . 39.Gossel, 92-95.


361

, , - . , -

;91 , . - , - - 92.

; ; : ! , ( ) , , , . O , , , - , . , , ( ) ( ) . , . - , 93 (. 6).

, , , , . , - , , . , , , , , , , 94. , -

91. AAA, 162.92. , 160.

. 1984, 97.93. . ..

, 1984, 200 . 161, .

94. , .

Haddad N.,

(. . ), 1995, 213, .108. - . . Haddad, . 15.

, , . O . , , - , .

-: , , 95, 96, . , , , . , , , - , , 97. : , -

, , , 98. , , , . . -, , , - .

, - , , -

362

ANAITH AKAPH

95. O

.... ( 1984, 178).96. Xirotiris N.I. - Langenscheidt F., The Crema-

tions from the Royal Macedonian Tombs of Vergina, 1981, 142, 156. Musgrave, .. AncW 22 (1991) 4.

97. 1984, 143-44, 178. O , ( 1984, 178-79). :

.

,

-

,

(. 1984, 178-79, - ).

98. 1984, 179.


363

, , - . , - , .

O , , - , , . , , , , , .

- , , , , . , -, , , , , -, , . , , , . , , - , .

364

ANAITH AKAPH

E. 2. .

.

10,6 7,5 ; 5,8 10,6 6,6 6,6 5,7 10,3 6,3 6,1 10 5 ; ; 9,5 4,75 7,83 6,35. 9,5 5,56 6,08 5,3 8,7 8,68 8,6 7,7

E. 1. . O

.


365

E. 3. . -

. H .

366

ANAITH AKAPH

E. 4. O . (. . ).

. -

.


367

E. 5. (. . ).

368

ANAITH AKAPH

E. 6. . -

. (. . Haddat).

Παναγιώτης Φάκλαρης Προβλήματα Στον Τάφο ΙΙ Της...

Documents

Transcript of Παναγιώτης Φάκλαρης Προβλήματα Στον Τάφο ΙΙ Της...