Κορνήλιος Καστοριάδης - Ανθρωπολογία, πολιτική, φιλοσοφία.pdf
ΤΜΗΜΑ ΦΙΛΟΛΟΓΙΑΣ -...
Transcript of ΤΜΗΜΑ ΦΙΛΟΛΟΓΙΑΣ -...
-
2012-14:
: 2013-14
:
: ,
:
:
.
, .
-
[2]
, 2014
-
[3]
.......................................................................................................................... 4
.......................................................................................... 7
To - ............................................. 7
........................................................... 12
................................................................................. 17
........................................... 20
....................................... 24
.......................................................................................... 32
.......................................................................... 32
............................................................................................. 39
..................................................................................................................... 47
................................................................................................................................... 49
....................................................................................... 51
............................................................................... 52
................................................................................................................................. 69
....................................................... 71
...................................................................... 81
....................................................................................................................... 85
................................................................................................................ 87
-
[4]
, , ,
,
,
,
.
,
,
.1 ,
.2 19
.
.
, , (.. 922-
3, 48, . 163, 186, 189-90)3
, .
,
,
,
,
, .
,
,
.
.
,
1 R. C. Jebb, (1891,
1887): Cambridge. 2 Lesky, (2007): 325. 3 Segal, (2001): 86
-
[5]
,
.
, ,
. ,
,
.4
, ,
.
, .
.
(
)
, ,
.
;5 ;
O T
.
:
,
- -
,
,
(
).6 ,
4 Segal, (1996): 21. 5Bloom, (2007): 26, 27. 6 Scodel, (2011): 147-9.
-
[6]
, . ,
,
.7
,
, :
,
.
,
,
.8 ,
.
;
,
. ;
;
7. Vernant, Page (1978): 479, 481, 489, 494, Goldhill, (1986): 210-21. 8 Carter, (2012): 123.
-
[7]
To -
.9
.
,
.
,
,
. ,
(, , )
,
.10
,
, ,
(. 332-75).11
(, ,
, )
(. 442-506),
, ,
(), ,
12,
.13
9 : , , ,
. , 45. 10 , (1985): 174 -5. 11 , . Staley, (1985): 561, . 1. 12 Karakantza, (2011): 29. 13 , (2001) : 11-36, Oudemans, Lardinois, (1987): 123.
-
[8]
,14
,15
.16 ,
,
.
(. 370)
( , . 252).
,
(. . 280-8).17
,
,
.
: -|
(. 332-3).18
14 Segal,
, Segal, (1999): 165. 15 Lesky, (2007): 342, Staley, (1985): 561-2, . 2, 566, .12, 567 - 70, Crane, (1989): 109, 110. 16 Else : ". . . it is not easy to see how the first stasimon relates to the play. It
has the air of an independent meditation on Man which could have been inserted almost as
well or fill in any other Sophoclean drama", Else, (1976): 43. 17 Griffith, (1999): 180. Whitman
. ,
(. 383, 603) (. 853), Whitman, (1951): 91. 18 :
| (. 585 ..). ,
,
: -| |
| (. . 594-7), Crane, (1989): 105, Staley, (1985): 561.
priamel ,
.
-
[9]
.19
,
( ,
, . 366).
, (. 334-7).
(. 340-1, 350-2),
(. 348-50)
(. 342-6).
,
, , (. 353)
, (. 353-4) (. 354-
5).
, ( | ,
. 360-1) (-|
, . 362-3)
(
| , . 361-2).
:
(, . 347, | , . 353-4),
(, . 355)20
,
( | , . 364-5)
( , . 365).
. , (
19Segal, (1999): 152, Oudemans, Lardinois, (1987): 129, Castoriadis, (2007): 14-5. Jebb
: wonderful, Jebb, (1888): . 332.
Goheen, (1951): 53. Schlesinger
(1144a23
..),
, Staley, (1985): 564. 20 Oudemans, Lardinois, (1987): 125.
-
[10]
21 , . 368)
( ' , . 369),
22 (
+ ) ,
, ,
(. 370-1). ,
,
( - | | , .
373-5). .
.
.
, . ,
, , , ,
, ,
,
. .
- -
- -
.
. ,
, ,
21 Griffith , Reiske
Jebb, .
, (=, ), Oudemans, Lardinois,
(1987): 102, Kirkwood, (1991): 109.
Knox
, Knox, (1964):
185, . 46, Pflugk , Segal, (1999): 445, . 57. 22: , , (= ,
, , holding the
city high), Else, (1976): 46.
, .
http://www.google.gr/search?hl=el&tbo=p&tbm=bks&q=inauthor:%22Gerald+Frank+Else%22
-
[11]
, (
| , . 360-1).
.
.
. ,
,
.23
23 Castoriadis, (2007): 15-9, Crane, (1989): 107.
-
[12]
.24
,
.
,
(. 368-75).
.25
. ,
, ,
.26
.27 , Else,
:
-
.28
.29
( | , . 278-9), ,
(, . 287).30
,
24 Oudemans, Lardinois, (1987): 123. 25 . Castoriadis, (1991): 119. 26 . Karakantza, (2011): 28, Sourvinou Inwood, (1990): 23.
27 . Segal, (1999): 168-9, 189, Knox, (1964): 98-9, Liapis, (2013): 95. 28 Else, (1976): 45. 29 Scodel, (2011): 112, 117. 30 Kirkwood, (1991): 104, 107, Knox, (1964): 102.
-
[13]
(. . 653-4, 658, 777-80).
,
(. 1039-41). ,
-
(. 75, 451, 542, 1070-1) -
(. 454-5, 459-60).
,
( ' , . 369).
,
,
.
Hegel 18 .
, .
, (. . 10, 73, 81 passim)
,
. ,
,
(. 182-3, 187-8, 522)
,
(. 190).31
,
.32
.
.33
31 Knox, (1964): 80, 88, Griffith, (1999): . 187-8, 522, Nussbaum, (2001): 52. 32 . Oudemans, Lardinois , (1987): 131. 33 Goldhill, (1986): 105.
-
[14]
. ,
(. 182-3, 187-90,
. 663-5):
,
(. 182-3)
,
(. 187-90)
.34
,
(. 175-7, 207-10):
,
.
(. 175-7)
,
.
,
.
(. 207-10)
,
:
, ,
( |
34 Jebb, (1888): . 189.
-
[15]
, , . 23-5)
,
,
, ,
(. 198-206). ,
,
35
.36
(. 211-4)
(. 160) (. 161),
.37
,
,
,
.38 ,
,
: -
-
(. 659-76).39
,
(. 7)
( , . 44, .
59), .
, ,
35Sourvinou-Inwood, (1989): 142. 36 Winnington Ingram, (1980): 123. 37. Knox, (1964): 86. ,
(. . 215-9), Griffith, (1999): . 159-60. 38Sourvinou-Inwood, (1990): 28-9, . . . 2.60. 39 Scodel, (2011): 115.
-
[16]
,
:40
,
(. 61-2)
,
.
, ,
,
.
,
,
.
,
.
,
,
(
)
.41
,
,
.
,
.42
40 Whitman, (1951): 89, Scodel, (2011): 109. 41 Scodel, (2011): 107. 42Sourvinou- Inwood, (1990): 25, 30, . 1.138.6, . , 1.7.22, Oudemans,
Lardinois, (1987): 113, Ostwald, (1986): 150, 156-7, 160, Bremmer, (1983): 90-2.
-
[17]
.
, ,
.
,
, ,
, ( .
74-7).
. ,
,
,
. ,
.
,
. ,
:43
,
.
,
, .
(. 450-7)
,
.
,
43 . Griffith, (1999): . 453-5.
-
[18]
(. 672-6),
(. 449-81).44
-
,
,
.
,
:
,
,
(. 466-8)
.
(. 511)
,
,
.45
,
.
,
, .46
, ,
,47
, (.
891-928).
,
(. 909-12).
44 Bowra, (1945): 83, 86. 45 Knox, (1964): 76-9, .24. 46 Castoriadis, (1991): 119. 47, (1995): 125
-
[19]
.
,
( | , . 821-2).
, ,
(. . 79, 907).
(. . 509, 733),
,
.48
, Knox
,
(. 189-91, 209-10)
(. 511), .49
,
.50
48. Liapis, (2013): 83-5, 87-8. 49 . Knox, (1964): 63, Segal, (1999): 184, Oudemans, Lardinois, (1987): 98, Liapis, (2013): 82. 50 Castoriadis, (1991): 119, Segal, (1999): 169, . . 21.
-
[20]
.
,
.
, .
, .
, ,
,
,
.
.
,
.
.
51 (. 481).52
,
, (
53, . 454-5) ,
, 54:
.
(. 1113-4)
;
51
(.. .. 865). 52 Lesky, (2007): 336. 53 Knox (. 455) ,
,
Knox, (1964): 97-9. 54 . Liapis, (2013): 103.
-
[21]
(.
. 60, 632).55 ,
, .
,
(. 1113),
,
.
.56
, ,
.
,
,
, ,
:
'
' ,
.
(. 1368b8-9)
, ,
, .
,
(. 1373b3).
, ,
( , . 1373b6)
, (. 1373b8-9)
,
(.1373b5-6, . 1374a25-6).
, ,
, 55 . Knox, (1964): 113, . 48. 56 . . 2.37.3, . . 793a-d, . 12.169, . . 4.4.19-25, . .
1373b5-18, 1375a15-1375b8.
-
[22]
, , ,
(. 1368b8-9). ,
,
,
, ( , .
1373b8-9), ,
,
(. 1373b6). .
, ,
( ,
1374a20). -
( ).
,
.57
, ,
.58
. ,
, , ,
(. 1373b9-10).
,
.59
57 ' ' ' ,
' , (
, ,
), .
, , (. .
1374a20-8).
58 William, Grimaldi, (1980): 73b1-13, 74a19, 74a26. 59 Knox, (1964): 96-7
-
[23]
(. . 519, 749),60 .
.61
, ,
.
,
. Otto,
.62
60 Burns, (2002): 547. 61 Burns, (2002): 549, Knox, (1964): 96. 62 sanctification of objective being, Otto, (1965): 208.
-
[24]
Collins
, :
.
,
. ,
63
,
, (.. 1180, 1349-52, 1356-7).
,
-
(.. 449-
56).
.
.
(.. 863-71),
64,
.
,
:
,
,
63 Scodel,
, Scodel, (1984): 58. 64 Whitman, Gellie, , Whitman,
(1951): 133, 135, Gellie, (1964): 114.
-
[25]
65 66 ,
,
, -
, .
(.. 863-71)
.
, .
:67
, , -
,
68,
,
(. 604 -10) 65 Enger , 867, .
, Campbell,
, , created in and pervading the
highest heaven Jebb, , Dawe, (1998):
. 867, Jebb, (1883): . 866. Kamerbeek,
thanks to, :
, ,
, Kamerbeek, (1967): . 866-7. ,
(135DK),
| , (. .I 13.1373b6)
,
. 66 , ,
, Kamerbeek, (1967): . 866-7, Dawe , (1998): . 866-
7. 67 Griffith, (1999): . 606-10 68
.
.
, (=,
), Jebb, (1888): . 606, Griffith, (1999): . 606.
-
[26]
:
,
,
.
. ,
, ,
.
.
, ,
,
. ,
,
.
: (.. 863).
, (= ,
) 69,
, (..
864).
,
,
,
.70
,
69 , (.
.. 886, 890, 897). 70Jebb, (1883): . 863. Jebb
. Winnington-Ingram,
, , 'May it
be my abiding moira to possess , (1980): 185.
(. . .111, .74).
Carey, may I possess throughout my life,
Carey, (1986): 175, .2. , ,
. destiny, ,
, Segal,
(2001): 85, Dodds, (1951): 42. Kamerbeek, (1967): .863-5
Dawe, (1998): . 863.
-
[27]
, .
( , .. 830).
.
.
,
, ,
.71 72
(.. 823)
,
.
,
.
73
. ,
,
.
.
. ,
,
(.. 794-
7, 984-6). ,
.
(..1382, 1441).74 ,
,
.
71Winnington - Ingram, (1971): 119, . 3, 133, Carey, (1986): 175, 178, 179. 72 . 73. Kamerbeek, (1967): . 863-5. 74. Carey, (1986): 175, . 7, Winnington - Ingram, (1971): 122-3, 129.
-
[28]
(.. 708-9, 711-2)
, (, .. 852)
(..
919-21).
75, ,
76 (.. 866-7). ,
,
, (.. 868-71).
,
( + ) / ,
, , (.
, .. 868)
- , -
, ( + ).77
,
, ,
(.. 867), , (.. 869), (.. 868),
. ,
,
(.. 871).78
75 (= + , , , ,
). 76 . Winnington - Ingram, (1971): 124. 77.Knox, (1957): 182-4, ,:
(O.T. 130), (O.T. 418), (O.T. 468),
(O.T. 479). 78 . Winnington - Ingram, (1971): 124. Segal, (1996): 29.
-
[29]
(.. 872).79
80
( .. 874) , (. 750 ..)
, 81 (. .
956, 1001), (.. 877):82
' '
,
'
(.. 876-8)
.83
,
: | (.. 883) |
(.. 864) (.. 865)
(.. 885). (.. 863, 887)
,
(.. 874) 84 .
891.85 , (..
887),
79 Blades, . ,
-, ,
,
(.. 128, 380, 408, 514, 535, 541, 588, 592, 799, 925, 939, 1043, 1095),
, Knox, (1957): 53, ,
: ' ' '
| ' , (. 506-7).
(. 60, 1169), .
(. 1056) (.. 872),
, .
. ,
, , . Winnington-Ingram,
(1971): 126. 80 (. 6.3-4,
West, . 153-4, . . 3.2 . . 381-2),
(.. 380). 81 . . 82 Winnington-Ingram, (1971): 124, Jebb, (1883): . 877 83 Winnington-Ingram, (1971): 126, 127.
84 (= ), Jebb, (1883): . 891. 85 Brandenburg, (2005): 36, Winnington - Ingram, (1971): 128, Carey, (1986): 177.
-
[30]
( , .. 892-3)
- -
(
; .. 896) - ,
.
(.. 898-910)
86,
(, .. 900).
,
( |
87, .. 906-7),
88
( , .. 909)
( , .. 910).
,
, ,
(.. 902-5)
( , .. 905).89
, ,
, ( ' , .. 903).
,90
,
, (.. 878).91
,
.
.
, , , 86 Gellie, (1964): 120, Carey, (1986): 178. 87 Jebb, (1883): 171. 88 Carey, (1986): 178. 89Segal, (1996): 23. 90 . Winnington - Ingram, (1971): 119, 128-9, 132, 134. 91 Winnington - Ingram, (1980): 202.
-
[31]
.92
.
. ,
.
,
, .93
92 Carey, (1986): 176, Segal, (1996): 25, Lloyd - Jones, (1971): 111, Winnington - Ingram, (1980):
187. 93 Lloyd - Jones, (1971): 128, Goldhill, (1986): 36-7.
-
[32]
,
, . ,
, .
, .
,
-
,
.94
(.. 791,
854, 994-6)95. (, ,
. .. 151, 157, 463),
.
.96
,
(. H.
46.3-49).97 .
,
, .
, .
,
, , ,
(O.T. 70-7).
(O.T. 114), (O.T. 122-3).
,
94 Winnington Ingram, (1971): 120. 95 Ahl, (1991): 246-8. 96 Segal, (2001): 49, 50, 87. 97 Scodel, (2011): 154.
-
[33]
,
(O.T. 603-4).
,
(O.T.
711-4).
,
-
(O.T. 787-93).
,
,
(O.T. 1438-43, 1518).98
, (.. 96-9)
.
. ,
,99
(.. 711-4). ,
,
.
. ,
(
, .. 709).
,
,
.
:
98Rehm, (2012): 420-1. 99 Kamerbeek,
, Kamerbeek, (1967): . 791-3.
-
[34]
' ' -
' -
' ,
'
(.. 497-503)
( |, .. 498-9).
( ' | , .. 502-3).
(.. 723-4).
, (.. 730)
:
.
(.. 747)
,
.
.
,
. ,
.
,
(..
791-3).
, ,
-
[35]
,
.
,
(. .. 997-9).
,
,
.
,
.
,
.
,
:
;
(.. 828-9)
,
,
. ,
(.. 861-
2). ,
, ,
.
(.. 851-8),
(.. 946-7, 952-3).100
,
:
, ' , ,
,
100 Kamerbeek, (1967): . 953.
-
[36]
101,
, ' '
' ' ' .
'
' ' .
(.. 964-72)
: ;
(.. 973). ,
(),
,
.102 ,
: ' ' ,
| , 103' (.. 977-8)
: 104 , ,
(.. 979). ,
,
.105 : 106
101 | (. .
310). 102 Dawe, (1998): 270. 103 , ,
, , Jebb, (1883): . 978. 104 ,
(. 447-53):
,| , ' |
| , | ,
| ' ' | .
(. 379):
' .
,
, ( , fr. 308 P.). 105 Bowra, (1945): 208. 106 Brunck, Musgrave, .
, Dawe, (1998): 225.
-
[37]
| ,107 , (.. 724-5).
.
,108
,
, . ,
,
.
.
,
:
,
-
.
,
;
(.. 1186 -92)
, , (.. 1186),
. 869,
. (.. 8),
(.. 1193).
, , ,
, .
,
107 Pearson
Kamerbeek. , Pearson
,
,
.
, (1967), 4: . 724-5. 108 Dawe, (1998): 224-5.
-
[38]
.
, .109
-
.
.
.
, .
.
109 Segal, (1996): 30-1.
-
[39]
,
,
. .
,
. ,
, . .110
.
Burkert,
, ,
,
. ,
,
,
.111
,
(.
. . 484-500)112
(. 998).113 ,
, ,
,
,
. ,
, 110 .. Bonnechere, (2007): 145. 111 Burkert, (2005): 31. 112 : ,
, , , , Johnston, (2008): 8. 113 Segal, (1999): 158.
-
[40]
(. .
9.16.1). , ,
( / , . .
. 1.4.12, 5.4.17). Burkert114
.
,
. ,
.
,
,
, ,115
.
, ,
-
(. . .104-30, . 998-1004, . . 840,
. 347).116
.. ,
. ,
, .117
, ( , . 999).
, (
, 9.16.1).118 :
, .
114 Burkert, (2005): 33. 115 Dillery
*men.
E.Rohde U. v.Wilamowitz,
,
, Dillery, (2005): 169, . 2,3,4. Dictionnaire Etymologique de la Langue
Grecque Chantraine, II, 665s.v.
-. 116 Johnston, (2008): 129. 117 Johnston, (2008): 130. 118 Jebb, (1888): . 999.
-
[41]
, ,
,
.
,
,
,
.
,
(. 998-1013)
.
,
(. .
6.111; . 8.134).119
, (),
.
.120
, (. 998-1032)
.
-
(. 1007)
(. . 122-3)121 -
(. 999-1004) (. 1004-11).
( 119 Johnston, (2008): 99. 120 Johnston, (2008): 148. 121 Segal, (1999): 166.
-
[42]
) (),
() (
) .
( , . 1008),
()
()
(),
.
.
122 (. .
410, 1008):
,
(. 409-10)
, '
(. 1007-8)
,
(. 1016-8, . 205-6).
.
:123
,
,
.
(. 1019-22)
122 Segal, (1999): 174. 123 Segal, (1999): 191.
-
[43]
,
,
,
(. 1080-3).
:124
,
,
,
.
(. 1080-3)
, ,
-
(. 196, 247 1081).125
. ,
(.
777-80)
(. 1043-4).
, :
,
,
, .
,
(. 249-54)
124 Jebb, (1888): . 1083. 125 Segal, (1999): 174, Jebb, (1888): . 1081, Griffith, (1999): . 1081.
-
[44]
(. 256)
,
.126 ,
(. 259-60),
,
, (. 262-7).
(127 | , . 278-9). ,
(. 281). ,
,
(.280-8).
(. 415-21).
,
(, . 418)128,
(, . 419).
.129
( , . 421). , (, .
418), ,
( . 8.66-9).130
, , (.
480-3). ,
(. 1347-
53).
126 , ,| .|
| , , . (. 255-8) 127 . (.. 255, 992): , Griffith, (1999): .278-9. 128 Jebb, (1888): . 418. 129 Segal, (1999): 160. 130 Griffith, (1999): . 417-8.
-
[45]
, (. 1033 ..),
(.
653-4, 658, 777-80)
(. 478-9, 667, 738).131
(. 1039-41, . 486-9):132
(. 1039-41)
(, ),
, .133
:
, ,
,
.134
,
,
,
, , .
(. 1067-71)
.
,
, (, ,
. 1197-8).
131 Bowra, (1945): 103. 132 Griffith, (1999): . 1039-41. 133 Segal, (1999): 159. 134 : , , |
(. 255-6),
, | (. 775-6), . Oudemans, Lardinois,
(1987): 137.
-
[46]
:135
.
(. 1113-4)
,136
,
.137
.
,
. ,
,
(. 733).138 -
- ,
(. 1261 ..)
.
.139
135 Lauriola, (2007): 135. 136 . . 1.138.6, ., , 1.7.22. 137 Lesky, (2007): 340. 138 Kirkwood, (1991): 107-9. 139 Lesky, (2007): 338.
-
[47]
,
.
;
(
, . 872).
, ,
.
, ,
.
:
(. 873-4)
,
, (. 908, 921-8)
( ,
. 943, . 904, 924).140
.
, .141
(. 773, 887, 919)
, (. , .
847, , . 876):
-
(. 881-2)
140 Griffith, (1999): . 943, Knapp, (1916): 311.
141 Lesky, (2007): 329.
-
[48]
.
,
(
, . 543), ,
(, . 895,
, . 941).142
, (. 580-1),
,
.
.
: , ,
, (. .
1161-5, 1167, 1320-5).
142 Griffith, (1999): 63, Knox, (1964): 80-2.
-
[49]
,
. 143 ,
, ,
, , .
,
(. 584-5, 593-603, . . . 742-71, . 758-71, .
932-7).
, , ,
, .
,
(, , . 4, 17, 186, 314, 533, 582, 614, 863, 1097, ..
164-5, 1205-6, 1282-5), (. 624, 1259-60),
(. 625).144
, , .
.
Padel,
. -
- .145
,
,
,
(. . 356, 805, 88,126,129, . 687,
143 . : - , (. . 332), Padel,
(1995): 170. 144 Griffith, (1999): . 4, 17 . Cairns, (2013): xiii - xiv, xxviii, Winnington Ingram, (1980):
161. 145 Padel, (1995): 168-9.
-
[50]
. 110, 850, . 597, . 886).146 ,
, ,
.147
;148
146 Cairns, (2013): xxv, Doyle, (1984): 121. 147 Griffith, (1999): . 582 - 625. 148 Doyle, (1984): 96, 117-8.
-
[51]
, .
,
, (
, .. 166) (
, .. 164):
'
(.. 164 - 6)
,
:
'
,
(.. 1204-6)
, ,
:
'
, , , ,
' ', ' .
(.. 1282-5)
, ..
.
.
-
[52]
.
(. 4, 863-5),
(. 379-80, 471-2, 856).
,
, .
:
() ,
(. 49-
57).
,
(. 58-60).
,
,
.
, , ,
:
, ' ,
'
,
(. 184-6)
,
:149
.
(. 313-4)
149 Cairns, (2013): xx, xxi.
-
[53]
,
- -
. , (, . 485),
:150
, ' ,
' .
(. 484 -5)
, ( ' , . 533),
,
(. . 1259-60).
.
. (. 583, 614, 624-5)
.151
,
.152
:
(. 582)
,
:153
(. 613-4)
150 Cairns, (2013): xii, Padel, (1995): 170. 151 Easterling, (1978): 154. 152 . Cairns (2013): xix-xx, xxiii-xxiv, Griffith, (1999): . 615-25, Winnington Ingram, (1980):
168-72. 153 Griffith, (1999): . 582.
-
[54]
,
,
, (
, |
, . 583-5).
- -
( . 594-5).
,
(. 594-603).
,
(, , . 591, 588), (,
, , . 588, 590, 592), (,
, . 592), (,
, . 587, 591).
.154
,
(. 586-92, . . 758-61).
(. 603).
, ( )
155
, ( , . . 383).
, , ,
,
.156 ,
- -
.157
154 Easterling, (1978): .586 .. 155 : , . Winnington Ingram, (1980): 168. 156 Jebb, (1888): . 603. 157 Easterling, (1978): 149.
-
[55]
,
,
(. 605-10). ,
,
(. 605).158
:
'
'
.
(. 611-4)
,
. 614 .159 Heath
, | '
, , Dawe,
.
Griffith
. Mller
nothing proceeds for very long without
disaster,
O.T. (. 1186-96, 1528-30160).
,161
, ,
.
; (. .
158 , . Cairns (2013): liii, . 124, 127. 159 Griffith, (1999): 613-4. 160 | ,
| (.. 1528-30) 161 Easterling, (1978): . 613-4
-
[56]
584, | 596-7, 602, , ,
, 604 .., , 624)162 ;
Lloyd-Jones, | , to
no human creature comes vast abundance without disaster,
,
.
.
(. 1161-71),
,
. ,
, Mller,
.
,
,
.
, ,
.
,
, (. . 857-71).
(. 605-14),
(. 450-60).
,
.
162 Easterling, (1978): . 584-5, Griffith, (1999): . 582- 625.
-
[57]
() (. 449, 455,
481, 519), .163
,
.
(. 615-9),
, ,
, .
,
(. 365-6),
, ( 164 - |
,| , . 615-
7),
( , | , . 618-
9). ,
,
.
, ( , . 617),
( , . 342-3).165
,
, ,
(, . 617)
( , . 624).166
, ,
163 Cairns, (2013): xix, Easterling, (1978): 157, Goheen, (1951): 63. 164
, ]ebb, (1888) : . 615-25.
, much erring, Griffith, (1999): .
615.
165 . Cairns, (2014): 11-4. 166 Griffith, (1999): . 615-25.
-
[58]
(
' | ' , | ,
. 622-4).
.167
, , ,
.168
169 ( . . . 93-
100, . 110, . 385-6). ,
- .
,
,
.
- -
,
.
,
.170
:
'
(. 625)
,
(. . 584, 614), , (.
624), , , .
,
,
167 Jebb, (1888): . 622, Doyle, (1984): 106. 168 Cairns, (2013): xii, . 19, xliii. 169 . . 111-15, . 18 - 22, . 391 -9, . 95-7, Griffith, (1999): . 617. 170 Easterling, (1978): 141.
-
[59]
(. . 742-5).171
(. 284)
, (1.91, 7.137).
856:172
' ' .
(. 856)
,
.173 ,
,
,
.174
(. . 205, . 975). ,
,
,
.
, ( ' , . 472, .
. 713).175
,
(. 929-
30), ,
(. 135-7)
(. 588-93).176 ,
171 Liapis, (2013): 95. 172 Webster, (1936): 31, Bowra, (1945): 87, Griffith, (1999): . 856. 173 Liapis, (2013): 93. 174 Cairns, (2013): xvii. 175 Jebb, (1888): . 472. 176 Segal, (1999): 168. =
( ), . Cairns, (2013): xxvi.
-
[60]
:
177 ,
.
.178
,
,
:
', , '
, ' .
(. 563-4)
(. 2, 857-66),
,
(179, , 867).
.
(. 913-28, 942-3).
, 180 181.
.
, , ,
( 182 , . 1015)
, (
177 Bowra, (1945): 88, Kamerbeek, (1978): . 582-603, . . . 1566. 178 Segal, (1999): 191. 179Segal, (1999): 166.
. (. 582-603, 857-66)
, . Cairns, (2013):
xv. 180 : , , , (= , )
,
() Jebb, (1888): . 857 .. 181 , , , . 182 . . 1051-2.
-
[61]
, 732).183
(. 1023-5)
:
(. 1024)
(.
1025-9).184 ,
:185
,
, , '
(. 705-6)
, (), (.
687). ,
,
(. 718-23, 1023-8).
,
:
'
,
,
' ,
' ,
'
, , .
(. 1064-71)
, (. 49),
.
183 Griffith, (1999): . 1052. 184 , | , |
| , (. 1025-8). 185 Griffith, (1999): . 1023-32.
-
[62]
.
,
, , (. 1028),
:
' '
, ,
(. 853-5)
' ' .
(. 875)
, ,
(, 95),
. , ,
,
. :
(. 220)
,
, |
(. 1242-3),
:
.
, ,
,
, ,
.
(. 1265-9)
( .
561-2, . 99) (
, . 1261).
-
[63]
.186
,
:
,
.
(. 175-7)
,
,
: 187
(. 603)
, ,
:
' .
(. 1089-90)
, ( |
, . 473-4),
:
,
. '
, ,
.
(. 1306-11)
186 (, ) : 176, 207, 374, 459, 510, 557, 993, 1015,
1063, ( ): 49, 169, 353, 648, 682, 683, 707, 727, 754,
755, 792, 904, 1023, 1031, 1051, 1347, 1353, (,
): 473, 479, 603, 768, 1090, 1104, 1261, . Knapp, (1916): 301, 305-6, 309,
311-4. 187 Segal, (1999): 165.
-
[64]
. ,
:188
,
.
(. 1095-7)
, ,
,
,
:
.
(. 1103-4)
(. 1100-1). ,
(. 1108-
10)
(
):
189
,
.
(. 1074-6)
, ,
.
.
, , ,
(. 532-3).
, ,
188 Jebb, (1888): . 1097. 189 , . , . . 58-9, . 382-3.
-
[65]
, ,
( , . . 10, 942)
,
.
:190
' ' ,
.
(. 927-8)
:191
,
' '
(. 1284-5)
: , (. 1325, .
, . 1167).
, ,
, (' | , ,
, . 851-2). ,
: ,
(. 1076).
,
, ,
.
,
.
,
:
190 Jebb, (1888): . 927 .. 191 . Segal, (1999): 187.
-
[66]
,
, ' .192
(. 1259-60)
,
,
, ,
:
193, 194 ,
, 195 .
(. 1272-5)
, 1296
1345-6:
'
.
(. 1345-6)
, ,
:
' .
(. 613-4)
, ,
:
192
( , . 914,
, . 926). 193 . (. 1097), Jebb, (1888): . 1273, Cairns, (2013): xxiii. 194 . . (. 584), Griffith, (1999): . 584. 195 Jebb (
.
, Ellendt
- , Jebb, (1888): . 1275.
-
[67]
'
' ,
' .
(. 622-5)
:
'
196
.
(. 1347-54)
().
(. . 127-8:
| )
, (. . 1270),
. ,
(. . 163, 167, 189-90, 494, 636, 675, 685, 994).
:
'
(. 189-90)
' , ' '
' .
(. 207-8)
,
196 , (. 943), Griffith, (1999): . 1347-53.
-
[68]
(. 165-9). ,
.
(. 734, 736, . . 666-7).
(.
737) ,
:
' .197
(. 739)
:
,
,
.
(. 707-9)
:
,
.
(. 715-7)
. :
, '
.
(. 1344-6)
197 . , |
(.. 54-5).
-
[69]
;
;198
(
, ,
).
.
, , .
.
. ( .
)
.
, ,
.199
, , ,
.200
, , .
, , , ,
, ,
, , ,
.
(. . 218-9, 905-6).
;
.
.201
198 Winnington Ingram, (1980): 152. 199 Cairns, (2013): 141. 200 . Winnington - Ingram, (1980): 151, 187. 201 Winnington - Ingram, (1980): 150.
-
[70]
.
,
.
, ,
.
,
.
-
[71]
,
-
( | ', .. 776-7)
( ' , ..
442). 202
,
, (.. 393-8)
.203
.
.
,
,
, (.. 949), , ,
.204
' ' ,
, '
, .
(.. 977-9)
,
,
(.. 977-9).205
, ,
, , ,
202 , Kamerbeek, (1967): . 442.
203 Jebb, (1883): . 442. 204 Knox, (1957): 177-8. 205 Kamerbeek, (1967): . 977.
-
[72]
,
.
, ,
.206
, ,
;
:
;
Glannon207
,
, . ,
, ;
,
, .
.
.
,
, ,
,
(, , ).208
.
,
,
. , ,
:209
206 Segal, (2001): 85-6, 90. 207 Lawrence, (2013): 149. 208 Kitto, (1939): 146-7, 138-9. 209 Kamerbeek, (1967): . 1302.
-
[73]
, ,
;
;
(.. 1300-2)
.
,
:210
'
, .
' ,
'
(.. 1258 -61)
,
,
,
:
, .
(.. 1311)
,
:
,
'
(.. 1327-8)
,
, , ,
:
, , ,
.
210 Cairns, (2013): 132-3.
-
[74]
' -
, ' .
(.. 1329-32)
.
,
.
,
.211 ,
, ,
:212
' '
' '
(.. 829-30)
,
.213
, ,
,
(, .. 1331),
.
,
.214 ,
211 Scodel, (2011): 147. 212 Cairns
(.. 828-9) , conventional, Cairns, (2013): 127, 132. 213 . Whitman, (1951): 141. : Mikalson, (2012): 432-3. Bowra
,
, Bowra, (1945): 177-85. 214 Lesky, (2007): 379.
-
[75]
. ,
Bernard Williams, , ,
(.. 266).215
, (. .. 419, 454, 790-3)
.
.
, ,
,
.
(.. 1329-31).216
(..
21, 70-1, 77, 80, 86, 95-8, 133-6, 145-6, 149-50, 151-7, 162, 203-5, 242-5, 253,
255, 278-9, 284-5, 305-9, 377, 498, 720, 908, 1329),
(.. 27-8, 189-91, 1329-30).
( ).217
.
, ,
:
,
' .
(.. 376-7)
:
, ;
(.. 738)
215 Cairns, (2013): 136. 216 Cairns, (2013): 140. 217 . Winnington Ingram, (1980): 319.
-
[76]
,
, .218
.
(.. 65-72).
.219
.
,
, , , .220
,
.
.
,221
.
, ( , .. 151),
,
.
,
. Gomme,
.
,
.
, ,
218 Dodds, (1951): 42. 219 Knox (1957): 10. 220 . Winnington Ingram, (1980): 177, , . fr. 119. 221 Knox, (1957): 33.
-
[77]
.222
.. Bowra
.223 ;
;
,
.224
Whitman
,
225
, . Dodds
,
,
. 226
. ,
.227
:
' ' '
(O.T. 1213)
.228 ,
222 Kitto, (1939): 139 223 Bowra, (1945): 175. 224 Kitto, (1939): 139-40. 225 Whitman, (1951): 140-1. 226 Dodds, (1951): 47. 227 Whitman, (1951): 141. 228 Cairns, (2013): 142-3, 150.
-
[78]
, ,
, -
-
, .
,
.
,
, ,
,
:
(.. 713)
.229
,
.
,
- (. ,
.. 738).230
.
231
:
,
-
.
,
'
(.. 1186-92) 229 Segal, (1999): 156. 230 .. Segal, (1996): 20-32. 231 .. Liapis, (2013): 103.
-
[79]
.
,
-
:
'
, .
.
(.. 1080-3)
,
.
, ,
. ,
(. .. 1036).
.232
. , ,
, ,
.
; .
,
. ,
.
.233
.
232 Knox, (1957): 179-80. 233 Segal, (2001): 124-5.
-
[80]
. ,
, . , ,
.
-
- ,
,
, (.. 1436-45,
1517-21).
,
. ,
,
(..
1438-9).
,
(.. 1442-3).
,
,
, , ,
,
.
,
. ,
. 234
234 Segal, (2001): 88, 91.
-
[81]
, priamel,
.235
, ,
, :
,
,
.
(. 951-4)
,
( , . 996):236
'
' ,
' .
(. 622-5)
,
, , (),
, ()237, (. 1158-9),
:238
' ,
(. 1158-9)
(. 1157-9)
.239
, (. 235 . .
, , (fr. 24). 236 Kamerbeek, (1978): . 996. 237 . , (.. 961). 238 Goldhill, (1986): 104. 239 Segal, (1999): 154.
-
[82]
1160).
(. 190, 675),
(. 994)
: 240
,
.
(. 1164-5)
,
.
.
, (. 1091-4) ,
:
,
(. 1100-1)
,
.
.241 ,
, (. 1108 12)
.
.
. (. 1196 ..)
-
-
,
240 Kamerbeek, (1978): . 1158-9. 241 Griffith, (1999): . 1100-1
-
[83]
.
,
,
.
.
.
(. 1192 -43)
.242
, ,
,
:
(. 1337-8)
:
'
,
,
' ,
' ,
'
, , .
, ' .
(. 1064-73)
242 Jebb, (1888): xviii - xx.
-
[84]
(. . )
.
,
,243
.
,
. ,
.
,
:244
'
.
(. 821-2)
,
. ,
,
,
.
. ,
,
.
.
.
;
, .
243 Kitto, (1956): 73. 244 Goldhill, (1986): 103.
-
[85]
: The blindness of man and the desperate
insecurity of the human condition.245
,
. 246
( ).
. , ,
.
, ,
. ,
.247
,
,
. ,
.
.
.
,
.
(584 ..),
.
.
,
, .
,
245 Dodds, (1951): 26. 246 . Cairns, (2013): 147. 247 Cairns, (2013): 127.
-
[86]
,
.
, ,
,
, ().
,
. ,
, .
,
.
,
,
.
;
.
.
.248
, , .
,
.
.
.
248 Liapis, ( 1997): xiii, xiv, xlii-xlvii.
-
[87]
1. Ahl, F. 1991, Sophocles Oedipus: Evidence and Self-Conviction,
(Ithaca).
2. Ahrensdorf, P. J. 2009, Greek tragedy and political philosophy:
Rationalism and religion in Sophocles Theban plays, (Cambridge).
3. Bloom, H. 2007, Blooms Guides: Sophocles Oedipus Rex, (New
York).
4. Bowra, C. M. 1945, Sophoclean Tragedy, (Oxford).
5. Bonnechere P. 2007, Divination, D. Ogden, (ed.), A
companion to greek religion, (Oxford).
6. Brandenburg, Ph. 2005, The Second Stasimon in Sophocles'
Oedipus Tyrannus, L Antiquit Classique 74, 29-40.
7. Bremmer, J. N. 1983, The early greek concept of the soul, (Princeton).
8. Burkert, W. 2005, Signs, commands, and knowledge: Ancient
divination between enigma and epiphany, S. I. Johnston, P.
T. Struck, (eds.), Mantike Studies in Ancient Divination, (Leiden).
9. Burns, T. 2002, Sophocles Antigone and the History of the
concept of Natural Law, Political Studies 50, 545-57.
10. Cairns, D. L. 2013, Introduction: Archaic Thought and Tragic
Interpretation, D. L. Cairns, (ed.), ragedy and archaic Greek
thought, (Swansea), i- liv.
11. Cairns, D. L. 2014, From Solon to Sophocles: Intertextuality and
Interpretation in Sophocles Antigone, JASCA 2, 3-30.
12. Carey, C. 1986, The Second Stasimon of Sophocles' Oedipus
Tyrannus, JHS 106, 175-9.
13. Carter, D. 2012, Antigone, A. Markantonatos (ed.), Brills
Companion to Sophocles, (Leiden), 111-28.
14. Castoriadis, C. 1991, Philosophy, Politics, Autonomy, (New York).
15. Castoriadis, C. 2007, Figures of the Thinkable, . Helen Arnold,
(Stanford).
16. Crane, G. 1989, Creon and the "Ode to Man" in Sophocles'
Antigone, Harvard Studies in Classical Philology 92, 103-16.
17. Dawe, R. D. 1998, , ,
. . , ().
-
[88]
18. Dillery, J. 2005, Chresmologues and manteis: independent
diviners and the problem of authority, S. I. Johnston, P. T.
Struck, (eds.), Mantike Studies in Ancient Divination, (Leiden).
19. Dodds, E. R. 1951, The Greeks and the irrational, (Berkeley).
20. Doyle, R. E. 1984, Ate: its use and meaning, (New York).
21. Easterling, P. E. 1978, The second stasimon of the Antigone,
R. D. Dawe, J. Piggle P. E. Easterling, (eds.), Dionysiaca, Nine
Studies in Greek poetry, (Cambridge).
22. Else, G. F. 1976, The madness of Antigone, (Heidelberg).
23. Gellie, G. H. 1964, Second Stasimon of the Oedipus Tyrannus,
The American Journal of Philology 85.2, 113-23.
24. Goheen, R. F. 1951, The Imagery of Sophocles Antigone: a study of
poetic language and structure, (Princeton).
25. Goldhill, S., 1986, Reading Greek tragedy, (Cambridge).
26. Griffith, M. 1999, Sophocles: Antigone, (Cambridge).
27. Jebb, R. C., 1883, Sophocles: The plays and fragments, 1,
(Cambridge).
28. Jebb, R. C. 1888, Sophocles: The plays and fragments, 3, (Cambridge).
29. Johnston, S. I. 2008, Ancient Greek Divination, (Oxford).
30. Kamerbeek, J.C., 1967, The plays of Sophocles, 4, (Leiden).
31. Kamerbeek, J.C. 1978, The plays of Sophocles, 3, (Leiden).
32. Karakantza, E. D. 2011, Polis anatomy: Reflecting on polis
Structures in Sophoclean Tragedy, Classics Ireland 18, 21-55.
33. , . 1985, , .
, ().
34. , . 1995, , . . ,
().
35. , . 2001,
, ,
. , (), 11-
36.
36. Kirkwood, G. M. 1991, Order and Disorder in Sophocles'
Antigone, Illinois Classical Studies 16.1/2, 101-9.
37. Kitto, H. D. F. 1956, Form and meaning in drama (London).
-
[89]
38. Kitto, H. D. F. 1939, Greek Tragedy, a literary study, (London/ New
York).
39. Knapp, C. 1916, A Point in the Interpretation of the Antigone of
Sophocles, The American Journal of Philology 37.3, 300-16.
40. Knox, B. M. W. 1957, Oedipus at Thebes, (New Haven).
41. Knox, B. M.W. 1964, The Heroic Temper, (Berkeley).
42. Lauriola, R. 2007, Wisdom and Foolishness: A Further Point in
the Interpretation of Sophocles' Antigone, Hermes 135, 389-405.
43. Lawrence, S. E., 2013, Moral awareness in Greek tragedy, (Oxford).
44. Lesky, A. 2007, , ,
. . , ().
45. Liapis, V. 1997, Nothing That is Not Zeus: The Unknowability of
the Gods and the Limits of Human Knowledge In Sophoclean Tragedy,
1, (Ph. D. Glasgow).
46. Liapis, V. 2013, Creon the Labdacid: Political Confrontation and
the doomed oikos in Sophocles Antigone, D. L. Cairns,
(ed.), ragedy and archaic greek thought, (Swansea), 81 - 118.
47. Lloyd - Jones, H. 1971, The justice of Zeus, (Berkeley).
48. Mikalson, J. D. 2012, Gods and heroes in Sophocles, A.
Markantonatos (ed.), Brills Companion to Sophocles, (Leiden), 429-
46.
49. Nussbaum M. C. 2001 ( ), The Fragility of
Goodness: Luck and Ethics in Greek Tragedy and Philosophy,
Cambridge.
50. Ostwald, M. 1986, From Popular Sovereignty to the Sovereignty of
Law, (Berkeley).
51. Otto, W.F. 1965, Dionysus: Myth and cult (. R. B. Palmer),
(Bloomington).
52. Oudemans Th. C. W., Lardinois, A. P. M. H. 1987, Tragic
Ambiguity. Anthropology, Philosophy and Sophocles Antigone,
(Leiden).
53. Padel, R., 1995, Whom Gods Destroy, (Princeton).
54. Rehm, R. 2012, Ritual in Sophocles, A. Markantonatos (ed.),
Brills Companion to Sophocles, (Leiden), 411-27.
-
[90]
55. Scodel, R. 1984, Sophocles, (Boston)
56. Scodel, R. 2011, An introduction to Greek tragedy, (Cambridge).
57. Segal, C.P. 1996, The Chorus and the Gods in Oedipus
Tyrannus, Arion, 4.1, 20-32.
58. Segal, C.P. 1999, Tragedy and Civilization: An Interpretation of
Sophocles, (Norman).
59. Segal, C.P. 2001, ,
, (. .. , . - . .
), ().
60. Sourvinou-Inwood, C. 1989, Assumptions and the Creation of
Meaning: Reading Sophocles Antigone, JHS 109, 134-48.
61. Sourvinou-Inwood, C. 1990, Sophocles Antigone as a bad
woman, F. Dieteren, E. Kloek (eds.), Writing Women into
History, (Amsterdam), 11-38.
62. Staley, G. A. 1985, Ode to Man, The classical world 78.6, 561-70.
63. Webster, T. B. L. 1936, An introduction to Sophocles, (Oxford).
64. Whitman, C. H. 1951, Sophocles: A Study of Heroic Humanism,
(Cambridge).
65. William M. A., Grimaldi, S. J. 1980, Aristotle, Rhetoric I, a
Commentary, (New York).
66. Winnington Ingram, R. P. 1971, The Second Stasimon of the
Oedipus Tyrannus, JHS 91, 119-35.
67. Winnington Ingram, R. P. 1980, Sophocles: An Interpretation,
(Cambridge).
68. Vernant, J. P., Page duBois 1978, Ambiguity and Reversal: On
the Enigmatic Structure of Oedipus Rex, New Literary History,
9.3, 475-501.