ΚΑΡΡ- ΙΣΤΟΡΙΑ ΤΗΣ ΣΟΒΙΕΤΙΚΗΣ ΕΝΩΣΗΣ 1917-1923 (ΤΟΜΟΣ 2)

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

1/501

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

2/501

. X.

' 1917-1923

2

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

3/501

Copyright 1978

' 22, - . 5234790

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

4/501

' 1917-1923

2

:

:

1978

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

5/501

. . Carr

THE BOLSHEVIK REVOLUTION 1917-23, 2

(A History of Soviet Russia)

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

6/501

7

9 IV: 13

15. 1516. 47

(1) 47

(2) 82

(3) 137

(4) 156

(5) 176

17. 195(1) 195

(2) 226

(3) 257

(4) 292

(5) 313

18. 34119. : 355

(1) 355

(2) 375

(3) 400

(4) 417

(5) 432

20. 451

': , 481 ': 495

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

7/501

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

8/501

. , , - . , ., , , 3

.

2 . , . . ,

.. . 1917-23 -, ,

. , , , ,

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

9/501

, , .

. . , , 1923 . 2

. 1922-23. 12 1923 . , 12 ,

. , .

. . , 1952

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

10/501

(VSNK): Vysshii Sovet Narodnogo Khozyaistva

: Vserossiiskii Ispolitelnyi Komitet SoyuzaZheleznodorozhnikov

: Glavnyi Komitet

: Glavnyi Komitet Truda

: Gosudarstvennaya Komissiya poElektrifikatsii Rossii

: Gosudartsvennaya ObshcheplanovayaKommissiya

GUM: Gosudarstvennyi Universalnyi Magazin

: Komitety Bednoty

: Narodnyi Kommissariat Zemledeliya

: Narodnyi Kommisariat Putei Soobshcheniya

: Narodnyi Kommisariat Prodovolstviya

: Narodnyi Kommisariat Truda

: Narodnyi Kommisariat Finansov

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

11/501

( ): Novaya Ekonomicheskaya Politika

A (STO): Sovet Trudai Oborony

: Sovet Narodnykh Komissarov

: Sovet Narodnogo Khozyaistva

: Sovetskoe Khozyaistvo

VTsIK: Vserossiiskii (Vsesoyuznyi) TsentralnyiIspolitelnyi Komitet ( )

1 = 71

1 () = 1

1 = 10.927

1 = 16,36

1 = 9,7

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

12/501

(Edward HallettCarr) 1892 Merchant Taylors School Trinity College . 1916

, 1936 - University College . 1941-46 - Times, 1953-5 Balliol College 1955 Trinity College . , '

" , : The RomanticExiles (1933), The Twenty Years Crisis, 1919-39(1939), Conditions of Peace (1942), The Soviet

Impact on the Western World (1946), The NewSociety (1951) What is History? (1961, ; 70- , 1974).

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

13/501

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

14/501

IV

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

15/501

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

16/501

15

. : . , , -

. - !

. , , ( ) .

, , ,

15

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

17/501

, . , , .

, , , . , , - .

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

18/501

. . , , -

, , : , . ,

. , , . , , .(')

. -

( ) (123), :

. ,

.( )

, .

(1) - , " . XV, 267.

(2) . , .

(3) . , (3 . 1925) . 37.

17

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

19/501

, .

. . , , .(4) , - .(5) . - - - .

, , , . -, , . , , -

, ... ,

(4) ' , ,

( - , " , XIV, 149). - ( 1920) -

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

20/501

.(6) ' , , .(7)

. , .

(8) : , .(9)

' , , ... ,

.

.(1011)

( ) . - .(12)

(6) - , " , XIV, 288-9.

(7) , , . \ . X.

(8) (Verteilung) -

(Austausch). ( )

.

.

( - , " , XII, , 179).

(9) . ., XII , , 185.

(10) . ., XII, , 189. ' -

, -

(11) . ., XV, 276.

(12) , , . ,

19

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

21/501

. , ,

. , . , , ( -

) ,(13) .

, , , - .

, , , .

, .

' ,

-

,

,

1835 ' ,

, , .

(13) - , " , XV, 274. , . ', . XVTII.

20

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

22/501

( )

,

,

.(14)

. - , , , . , , '

; . , , , -

.(1S) , - , .(16) , 1917 .

. , - 2 1903, , ,

(14) . , . \ . XVI.

(15) , , . \ . XXXIX.

(16) - industriels, . travailleurs, (Doctrine de Saint-Simon: Exposition, Premiere Annie [1830|, . 197).

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

23/501

, -- .(1718) ,

, . :

-

, .

. .

.(|8)

.

, , -.(19) - .

, . .

(17) VKP(B) Rezolyutsiyakh (1941), I, 20.

(18) , " , XXI, 482.(19)

. .

22

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

24/501

, , .

, - . ( ) :

. -

, . - . , - , - , .

, , - . , -

23

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

25/501

,

. , , , . .

. 19 , - -

. 1861, - , , .

. , . ,

. , , 90%

24

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

26/501

. , ,

, ^20) , - 1861, , . , , . , , .

, 1892 , -.(21) - - , - .

. , , . -

(20) ': , ,

.

(21) . . , " , 111, 119.

25

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

27/501

- . -

1890 . .

1890, , . 1840 - , :

,

,

.(22)

. .

. - .

,

(22) . , tudes sur la Situation Interieure, la Vie Nationate, etles Institutions Rurales de la Russie, I (1847), 151.

26

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

28/501

, . ( 1/5) ,

, . .(23)

, .

1890 , 1896 . , '

.(24) , 20 , , - , - ,

. , (25)

(23) ,

(estate, sostoyanie). 1861 : ,

(. . , " , III, 410). 1905 - (" , VI, 369-70).(24) , " , XIX, 136.

(25) ,

27

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

29/501

-.(26) ' --,

.(27) . . .

. - ( ) , , .

. . - .

1914 2 . 32,6% , 22,6% ,

19,7% , 14,3% 5,2% ( . . , .. Promyshlennaya Politico SSSR [1926], .44).

(26) ,

, . .

; ; (Vospominaniya [ . 1922], I, 451).

(27) 1913, 24,5% 1000 9,5% - 500 1000 . 1907 8,1% 6,1% ( . . , Promyshlennaya Politika SSSR [1926], .46).

28

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

30/501

, , .

, . 1848 - , .

, , - . 1903, , ,

. 1903 .(28) -,

. : , 16 ( 18 ) - -

(28) 1, . 2.

29

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

31/501

. , -

. , - ... ( ).(29) . .

-

. 1905 , - . (9 1905) , , ,

1905 . 1905 , , , , , 1906,

(29) 1903 VKP(B) > Rezolyuts iyakh (1941), I,19-23.

30

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

32/501

. 1905 : .

, .

1905

. 1905, 3 , , .

, .(30) - . - , - , , , , .

'

(30) . ., I, 46-7.

31

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

33/501

- . ( ,

)

- .

.(31)

. -, 1905, . ,

( ) - ( ). - ( ), -

^32)

1905-6 - (33)

( 4 ), 1906.

(31) , " , VIII, 185-6. 1, . 3.

(32) VKP(B) Rezolyutsiyakh (1941), I, 58-9.

-rijc

1905.(33) " , IX, 458-60. ' (

) 1906 (' , IX, 55-76).

32

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

34/501

, . (

), . , , . . , , . , , -, . ' - . ,

, . . . , , , .

. . , , ( ) ,

(, , ). , -

33

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

35/501

, . , ,

, - . , - , , (34), ' ( ), . , (

) . , , , , - . . , - ,(35)

^- - , . .(36) .

(34) , " , IX, 61.

(35) . ., IX, 149-56, 184-200.

(36) : (" , XI, 187).

34

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

36/501

- .

, , , - -. .(37)

- ( ), - . - 1906,

. , . , ( - ;).

. , - , . ,

,

(37) ( ) Rezolyuts iyakh (1941), 75-6. Chetvertyi (Obedinitelnyi) S ezd RSDRP (1934).

35

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

37/501

1907, :

' -

-

.

- . -

10 ,

7

, (38)

2.300 .

-

, -

...

, , ,

...

,

.(39)

- . ,

(38) :

. , , .

(39) , " , XI, 347.

36

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

38/501

. ,

. , .

1905-6 , . 17 1905, , 3 .

, 9 1906, . . , - , . ,

. - .

, , '- .

37

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

39/501

2 . 1908 1909. ,

. . , , - . .(40) 20 , .

, , - , - ,

- . . . , , . - , , , , -

.(41) ,

(40) . , 1905 (2 . 1922), . 18.

(41) , " , XI, 352.

38

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

40/501

: .

(- ) .(42) ( ) , , ,

. , , .(43)

' . . , 80% - , - - , ( ).

, ,

(42) .7! XI, 348-9, 352.

(43) , " , XI, 378, XII, 123.

39

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

41/501

, . , -,

^44) . . -. ,

. , . , . '

, . , . ,

, . .

, :

(44) . . Rural Russia Under The OldRegime (1932), . 194.

40

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

42/501

,

,

(

)...

'

(

)

(

- ).(45)

, ,

. , - .

1905 80% 50% . . 1900 1913 62% -

(45) , " , XII. 406.

41

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

43/501

35 %.(46)

. . 1900, 1908-13 ' . . , , , - , .(47) ,

, , , ^48) . 1912, , 1905, . ,

500 - . , 1914. 1905 . ,

(46) .. , Istoriya Nanulnogn Khozyaistva SSSR , II (1948), 349,

(47) 1, . 3.

(48) , " , IX, 197,

42

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

44/501

- , .

1914

, . . - , . 1916 -. , , ,

- . , 1916-17 . , , , . , ,

, . 1916 , : - . :

. 3

1917 ,

43

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

45/501

,

. 6, 7 8. 6 ( , , ) . ( 100 300 , , ) - ,(49) 7 ,

8 ( ).(50) , , .

, . , ( , ,

(49) obshchestvennyi,

,

.

.

(50) , " . XX, 88-9.

44

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

46/501

), .(51) , 6

, - . , , . .

1905, , 1917, , . -

, 1917 .

(51) ',.., XX, 19.

45

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

47/501

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

48/501

16

1.

. - . 1917 - .

-

,

...

.

, , ,

.(')

- . - . - . , , 1

(1) , " , XX, 241, 245.

47

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

49/501

-

. .

.

. . 1917 - . (2)

. , .

, , . . . ,

. , (2) (Istoriya Russkoi Revolyulsii, I [ , 1931], 429-45, II [ , 1933], II, 5-39) 1917.

48

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

50/501

.

, , , -

, . , , , , . - , , - , .(3)

-. , , -, .

. . -

(3) , " , XX, 270. 4

1906, , , ( . ., IX, 185).

49

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

51/501

... . ,

:

,

, ,

, -

.

-

,

.(4)

, . - , , , . . -

.(5)

.

(4) ',.., XX, 194.

(5) VKP(B) Rezotyuls iyaUi (1941), 1, 229-30.

50

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

52/501

. , , , .

. - . 1917 , , :

.(6) , , . :

. -

,

-

. -

. -

, .

(6) , " , XX, 350.

51

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

53/501

- - , . -

. , ( 30.000 ) ! . , . , :

.

. ,

, -

. ... -

, -

,

....

.(7)

, . , , - . 3

, , -

(7) . ., XX, 416-17.

52

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

54/501

.

1917 ,

, . , , , . , .

. , , - .(8) ,(9) -

. , , -.(10) ,

, . - , , .

(8) Pervyi Vserossiixkii S"ezd Sovetov (1930), II, 304.

(9) . . , Voprosy Istorii, No 10, 1947, . 17, 1917 52 , 422 .

(10) Pervyi Vserossiiskii S"ezd Sovetov (1930), II, 306-10.

53

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

55/501

.

1917. - ;

, . .(") ' . , , , 242 . . , , , - , , , , -

. ' , , , , - . ,

. . , , , . 242 11

(11) 152 1917, 112 , 387 , 440 , 958 (Razvitie Sovetskoi Ekonomiki, . . . . . [1940|, . 60).

54

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

56/501

, , - .

( ) ' - .

, , -

.^2)

,

, .

,

Rabochii Put , . . , , - ,

2 26 /8 1917 ( - ) . : 12

(12) , " , XXI, 107-13. 1917

. " , ('..,

XXI, 233).

55

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

57/501

, .

( ), .(1314) , -

- , .

. ,

, , . - . ,(,4) :

; , -

,

& .

(13) Sobranie Uzakonenii, 1917-1918, No 1, (2 .), 3. , ,

XXII, 23. :

.

(14)

" (Delo Naroda, 17/30

1917).

56

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

58/501

,

....

. "

.(15)

, ,

2 , . .(16) , - ,

. , ' 25 25

, ^17)

(15) , " , XXII, 23.

:

, ,

( , )

: (.., XXII,641).

( 16) ,... XXII. 83-4.

(17) ,... XXII, 89-90.

57

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

59/501

, , .

.

1917 - .(18) . . , , .(19)

, . , .

, , , .(20) ,

. , , .

(18) . ., XXII, 53.

(19) . ., XXI, 273.

(20) . .

58

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

60/501

, ,

- .

. , . , , , . , -

.(21) , , . , 1917-18

.(22)

(21) Razvitie Sovetskoi Ekonomiki, . . . . . (1940), . 93.

(22) . . , Izvestiya Akademii Nauk SSSR; Seriya Istorii i Filosofii,

V (1948), No 6, . 510-14, ,

,

, , 1918,

. , -

59

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

61/501

, ,

. . . - , , ,(23)

, , .

. . , . , . , -

, .

, (Zemie , I, [1921], 20).

(23) . . , Agrarruiya Politika SSSR (2 ., 1927), . 60.

" '' (. . , TheEconomic Condition o f Sov iet Russia [1924], . 68).

60

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

62/501

. , ,

. - - , . 1917 1918 , , ,

- ,

.

. , 27 /8

1917, , . . , ,

( ;) ( ,

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

63/501

'; ' -

,

. ,

, .

,

.

,

.

,

.

(

, , , '

, -

.

,

,

-

,

(

,

;'

.

.

.

, ,

,

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

64/501

, ,

. (24) , . , , . , , . . - ,

, (25) .

, -

(24)

, 1917

. , ,

.

(" , XXI, 357-61)

. -

- . . , ^/ Programmy Rossiiskikh Politicheskikh

Partii v 1917 . (1929).

(25) , " . XXII, 52. :

Sobnmie I zukoncnii. 9 7- 9 , No 2, 24.

63

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

65/501

, -. , 31 /13 1917 -

, . (26) , , , , , - .(27) ' -. 15 , , . -, , 26 /8 1917. ,

( ), (28) , , ' . 13/26 1917 . . ... -

(26) Volya Naroda, 31 1917. Voprosy Istorii, No 10,

1947, . 19.(27) Protokoly Zasedanii VTsIK Sozyva (1918), o. 29.

(28)

. ( . .

, Agrarnaya Politika SSSR [2 ., 1927], . 60). .

64

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

66/501

- . ' -,

.(29) , , , .(30) , , .

1918 3 . . - . -

, - . . -. 3

, , , . . -

(29) Sobranie Uuikonenii 1917-1918, No 7, 105.

(30) Voprosy Istorii, No 10, 1947, . 38.

65

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

67/501

. 3 . 3/4

, . . .(31) , . 3 18/31 1918. . VTsIK .(32)

: - .

19 1918, 57

' ^3) . 9

(3 11 I ,

, VoprosyIstorii, No 10, 1948, . 29-30 Izvestiya Akadem ii Nauk SSR: Seriya

Istorii i Fihso fii, VI (1949), No 3, . 231.

,

, " , XXII, 252-3.

(32) Tretii Vserossiiskii S ezd Sove tov (1918), . 86.

(33) Sobranie Uzakonenii, 1917-1918, No 25, 346.

, 18/31 1918

66

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

68/501

, , , , , .

. - , , . , - . 11 :

() ,

, , .

() .()

, , , , , .

()

.() ,

, , . (*34)

19 , Voprosv Istorii, No 10, 1948, .32-3.

(34) Sobranie Uzakonenii, 1917-1918, No 25, 346. 1918 . (" , XXIII, 397, 425-6), , , '

67

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

69/501

, , ,

26 /8 1917.

, , . (35) . . , 3. 52 . , 12, ...

. , 25, ... -, . (

1 , 0,8, 16-18 0,75, 0,6 12-16 0,5) . , , , ,

, , (.., XXIII, 399).

(35) . ., XXIII, 398.

68

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

70/501

. . -

, , . - .

, , .

( ) , - ( .)36)

. , , , . , ,

( )

(36) , XXIII, 398.

69

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

71/501

.

. , , , .

1918 , - - .(3738) ' ,

, .

'

( ) .. ..

.

,

.

(

(37) Voprosy Jstorii, No 11, 1947, . 6-8

. - , ' .

(38) Zem le , I (1921), 24-5. Voprosy htorii. No 11, 1947, . 14.

70

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

72/501

' ,

. . , - , - . - . 70 80 .(39) ' , .(40) .

. 86% , 11% , 3% . 1/4 3/4 .(41) , . ,

. .

(39) Zemle , I (1921), 160.

(40) , The BolshevikRevolution, 1917-1918 ( , 1934), . 679-83.

(41) Otchet Narodnogo Komissariata Zemledeliya / Vserossiiskomu S"ezdu Sovetov

(1921), . 6- Zem le,1(1921), 23.

71

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

73/501

. ,

(- ). , , , , .(42) , , - .

- 1918 . , .

. VTsIK(43) ,

(42) RazvitieSovetskoi Ekonomiki (. . . . . , 1940), . 94-5, Izvestiya Akadem ii Nauk SSSR: Seriya Istorii i Filosofii, VI (1949), No 3 .

231-5. .(43)

VTsIK (Protokoly Zase-

danii VTsIK 4guSozyva [ 1920j, . 403-4) - (Pyatyi Vserossiskii S"ezd Sovetov [1918], . 534).

72

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

74/501

,(44) , , . 1918

.(45) , . , , . .

- -

: . 1917 - . 1917 , . , -

, , , . - . . , ,

(44)

3 1918. (Leninskii Sbornik,XXI [1 93 3] , 147). .

(45) Protokoly Zasedami VT.slKdyo Sozyva (1920). . 294.

73

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

75/501

, . 1918 .

- , .(46) - .(47) . - -. - ,

, , .(48) . .

5 , 1918:

, -

, ,

. .. ,

, , .

(46) , " , XXII, 243.

(47) Izvestiya, 18/31 1918.

(48) , " , XXII, 515.

74

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

76/501

,

. ,

,

, - . ,

, : -

. ,

.(49)

. . , , 1905, - ,

.(50) , 1918, . - . , -

. , 14 1918, ,(51) , - , :

(49) Pyatyi Vserossiiskii S ezd Sovetov (1918), . 141-2.(50) 1, . 3.

(51) , " , XXII, 253.

75

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

77/501

, ,

, , , , .... , , ,(5253)

1918 - , , .(s3) ,

-. .

1918. 9 VTsIK

. :

, -

(52) '.,., XXII. 356-7.

(53) ,. .. XXII. 515.

76

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

78/501

1916 1917 . , . ,

, , - .

. , , ( )

. : .(5455)

, .

. (s5)

(54)Sobranie Uzukonenii, 1917-1918,

No 35, 468. " .

(55) , " , XXIII, 524-5. . ..XXIII, 25.

77

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

79/501

, . , ,

- , , , , , . :

, , ,

, , .... . -

- . . . (56)

50 . . - , 27 1918,

. , ,

(56) . ., XXIII, 26-31.

78

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

80/501

- . , -

. (S7) ,

. -. . - , - . 11

1918, ( ), , - - .

, , - - . (58)

(57) Sobranie Uzakonenii. 1917-1918, No 38, 498.

4 . -

(.., No 38, 502).(58)

: ( ) " .

79

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

81/501

, , .

15 , 50% 15 , 20% . (s9)

. . , , . . ,

. :

: , , . . , : . . (*60)

" . . 40 : (British Labour Delegation to Russia, 1920 Report [1920], o. 134).

, ,

6 :

( ) (Shestoi Vserossiiskii Chrezvychainyi S ezd Sovetov [1919], . 87-8).


(60) , " , XXII, 126.

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

82/501

. ,

. . , . . ,

, - . , , , - . 1918, ,

( ) .(61) , . (62)

. , - , .

.

(61) . .. XXIII, 393.

(62) . ., XXIII, 420.

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

83/501

2.

. , : . 1917, , ... . (63) ,

, . (64) . . . , , , , , , , -.

, -, , , .

, ,

(63) VKltH) Hezolyutsiyukh (1941), I, 237.

(64) , " , \ \ , 282.

82

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

84/501

, , , .

1916, , , . . . . . 1917 ,

, . (65) . ,

.

. 22 1917


83

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

85/501

. (66) -. , ,

, . , 1905, - . , . (67) , . - . ,

-. - .

, .

.

(66) . , Slate Control o f Industry in Russia during the War (Yale,

1928), . 173.(67)

1917 Voprosy Istorii, No 10,1947, . 40-64. . , Syndikaty / Tresty Rossii (3 ., 1920), .145,

1917. . . , Isto riva Ekonom icheskogoRazvitiya SSSR (2 ., 1929), . 45, 568

100.000 1917 .

84

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

86/501

1917 , ,(68)

. . . -, - , - - , (69) - . , 1917, :

- . . ,

. (70) - . , -

(68) , " , XX, 211.

(69) . ., XX, 348.

(70) . ., XX, 377.

85

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

87/501

. (71) , , , , , -

, .

. , , , - - . , ,

, , , - , , -

. , , , . , , , -

(71) , , ,

.

, , .

86

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

88/501

.(72) , ,

1917. , , . , . , - .

:

25 , .(73)

400 , 30 1917. , . ,

(72) 1, . 6.(73) . ( ), Stroitelstvo Sotsializma (1918), . 34.

87

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

89/501

, . , , , . ,

, :

. : , - 3/4 , - . , , ,

. - , . ,, ' - .

,

, -

,

,

.

, , . ,

88

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

90/501

. . 290 ,

, 297 , 21 44 . .(74)

' . - , . , , .,

, . , . -

, , - - .(75)

(74) . " XX, 422-4. Oktyabr skaya Revo-

lyutsiya i Fabzavkomy (1927), I, 63-137.

(75) , " , XX, 459. /

.

89

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

91/501

, , : ,

, , .(76) .

. 1905 ,

, -.(77) 1917 , - .

. , . ,

- . . , (Mezhraiontsy), .(78)

(76) . ., XX, 472.(77) .

(78) . 2 1917 . , , , .

90

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

92/501

- . ,

. . , . . , .(79)

. 1917

. , , , 1 .(80)

& . , , , - , ,

(79) Pervyi Vserossiiskii S ezd Professiona l nykh Soyuzov (1918), . 34-6.

1918

(.., . 52).

(80) Oktyabr' skaya

Revoiyuts iya i Fabzavkomy (2 , 1927).

91

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

93/501

, . . .

, , , , , . , , , .(81)

- . - . .

- 1917, , - . , , , , , ,

, , , . , ,

(81) Oktyubr skaya Revolyntsiya i Fabzavkomy (1927), II, 186-8, 193. - , (. ., II, 191-2),

, ,

(Pervyi Vserossiiskii S " ezd Professional' nvkh Sovnzov[1918] . 233-4).

92

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

94/501

, , , , .(82) :

, ( , , , , ) ' , - - , - , . , .

. .(83) , , .

( ;) . - ,

-

(S2) . . ' , XXI. 160.

(83) .,.. XXI. 164-70.

93

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

95/501

,(8485) ( ) -

:

'

,

.

, , , , , - :

"

, .

. ; " ,

- -

.

,

, , -

, -

. (S5)

, , - . (86)

(84) ,. ., XXI. 269-70.

20 .

(85) ,... XXI. 259.

(86) ... XXI. 260.

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

96/501

- . , , -

:

. "

. ,

.

,

-

,

. (8788)

. .

, - .

^8) -(87) .,., XXI. 440. )

,.., XXI, 437.

(88) Narodnoe Khozytdstvo. No 1-2, 1919, . 23.

95

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

97/501

. ,

25 / 7 1917. 2 - .(89) , .(90) , . , .

, , - , , , . - ( ). -

- .(91) - - ; .

(89) , " , XXII, 5-6, 11.

(90) . ., XXII, 575, 7.

(91) . ., XXII, 25-6.

96

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

98/501

.

. . , , . , VTsIK 14/27 1917, , .(92) .

. , , , .

- , , .

(92) . , Rabochii Kontrol (1918), . 20. Vestnik Narodnogo Komissariata Truda, No 2-3 ( -

), 1918, . 385-7, .

97

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

99/501

. VT-

sIK , :

-

-

.... -

-

.

, . ,

, - -. , , , , . .(93) , , VTsIK. - .

,

(93) Protokoly Zasedanii VTsIK 2 Sozyva (1918), . 60.

98

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

100/501

. VT-sIK 24 10 .(94)

. 14/27 1917

.(95)

. , . . - . , ,

.(96) . - -

,

(94) . ., . 60-2 Sobranie Uzakonenii,

1917-1918, No 3, 35.

(95) ,

1918 (Pervyi Vserossii-skii S ezd Profsoyuzov [19 18], . 234), , (Trudy 1 Vserossiiskogo S ezda Sovetov

Narodnogo Khozyaistva [ 19 18 ], . 104).

, (.., . 72).(96) 23 / 6 1917

- .

99

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

101/501

- - .(97)

. , . , , .(9899) , 3 -, 15 . , , , - .(") 1918, - ,

:

-

" ",

, , -

,

....

,

. ,

. . -

(97) Pen-yi Vserossiiskii S"ezd Profsoyuzov (1918), a. 175, 194.

(98) . , Syndikaty i Tresty v Rossii (3 ., 1920), . 157.

(99) A. , Rahoclui Kontrol' (1918), . 33A.

100

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

102/501

,

,

.(">

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

103/501

-

.

,

-

- .

. -

, ,

,

,

.

. ,

,

.

.

1918,

.(104)

,

.

.

. "

.

,

.

(104) The Lansine Paper,. 1914-1920. II ( , 1940), . 369.

102

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

104/501

.(105) ( ) .

- - . - - . . ' , .

. , 14/27 1917, , .

, - 1917 . , , - . '

(105) (

, 17.(2).

103

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

105/501

1918.(106)

( . 17/30 1917, , , , . , , , , , - .(107)

- , -.(108) 1/14 1917 VTsIK .(109110) 5/18 1917.()

(106) .

(107) Sobranie Vzakonenii, 1917-1918, No 3, 38. , " , XXII, 588.

Narodnoe Khozya istvo, No 11, 1918, . 12. ( . ., . 16), : " , , . .(108) , " , XXII, 107.

(109) , " , XXII, 108. VTsIK

. (Narodnoe Khozyaistvo, No 11, 1918, . 17) . (Trudy IVserossiiskogo S ezda Sovetov Narodnogo Khozyaistvo [1918], . 162)

, .


104

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

106/501

-. 5/18 1917 - ( )

. , , . , , . , , . ^111) . : -

- .(112)

. , , ,

. , . 15 . ( )

(111) . " , XXII. 215.

(112) Narodnoe Khozyaistvo, No 11, 1918, . 8.

(TreliiVserossiiskii S "e zd Professwnal'nykh Soyuzov [1920 ], 1 [Plenumy], 7).

105

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

107/501

. , , , ,, .(113)

. , .(114) , . , , , .(115116117) - . -

- .(*) ( ) (1) .(118)

-. , - , 14/27 1917. .

(113) Sobranic Uzakonenii. 1917-1918, No 9, 129 Bol'shaya Sovetskaya

Entsikiopediva, XIII (1929), 561, VSNKh.

(114) Narodnoe Khozyaistvo. No 11. 1918, o. 11-12.

(115) , , XXII. 108.(116) Narodnoe Khozyaistvo, No 11. 1918, o. 12.

(117) Sobranie Uzakonenii. 1917-1918, No 10. 158.

( I 18) o.n.. No 10. 159. 4 ' .

106

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

108/501

VTsIK - .(119)

.(120) . , - . (121) . 20 1917/2 1918 . - .(122) , ,

. .

, .(123) . , , . .

(119) B/i.-rt ' . 5 .

(120) , " , XXII, 139-11.

(121) Nurotlnoe Klwzyais tvo. No II. 1918. . 11-14.


(123) . ;, / Reminiscences o f the Russian Revolu tion (1921), .

213-15.

107

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

109/501

- . -

. , , 23 1917 / 5 1918, . (-) . - . - 14 , , . - ( - ) , .(124)

-, . - .(125) , 1918,(126)

. ,

(124) Sobrunie Uzakonenii, 1917-1918. No 13, 196.(125)

,

( ). (God Proletarskoi Diktatury [ , 1918], . 28-31). Trudy

I Vserossiiskogo S"ezda Sovetov Narodnogo Khozyaistva (1918), . 219.

(126) . ., . 485-8.

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

110/501

(127) -. .

. . .

, . . - - , ' ,

. , , . , . . 23 1917 /5 1918

. , , , , , , .

(127)

,

, ( , XXIII,

36).

109

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

111/501

- ' . ,

, , . . 1918 .(128) ' . .

, - . . .(129)

: . .

.

(128) Trudy 1 Vserossiiskogo S ezda Sovetov N arodnogo Khozyaistvu (1918), . 71.

(129) Bofshuyu Sovetskaya Enstiklopediya, .Kill (1929), 559-60, VSNKh.

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

112/501

, , - 1902. , 1915, .

.(130) 1918, , , 750 .('31)

. , . . .

(132) - , . , , . 16/29 1917 ,

( 1311) Sobranie Uztikonenii. 1917-1918, No 10, 149.

(. ., No 10, 155), - .

(131) Byulleteni Vvsshego Soveta Narodnogo Khozyaistva, No 1, 1918, .42.(132) . . , Istoriya Ekonomicheskogo Razvitiya SSSR

(2 ., 1929), . 112, 5% 1 198 .

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

113/501

.(133) ,

. 1918 , , , .(134) , 1918, , , , . . 30 , 15 ( ) 30 ,

'.(135) ( 1918) , .

1918 . 1915 1916 , , .(136)


(134) Narodnoe Khozyaistvo, No 10, 1918, o. 32 No 11, 1918, o. 43-6.

(135) o .j t ., No 2, 1918, . 43-4.

(136) . State Control o f Industry in Russia during the War

( , 1928), . 129, , , , .

112

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

114/501

1917, , ,

. 1918, , , ( ) (), . () 1918.(137) . , -, 1918.(138) , . - 1918

. , , -, . ,

. " , . , ,

(137) NaroJnoe Khozyaistvo , No 11, 1918, . 18. Trudy 1 V serossiiskogo S 'e zd a

Sovetov Narodnogo Khozyaistva (1918), . 95.

(138) Byulleteni Vysshego Sov eta Narodnogo Khozyaistva, No 1, 1918, o.28. ( ) Sobranie Uzakonenii, 1917-1918, No 29, 377.

( ) Izvestiya Tsen-trochaya, No 1, 25 1918.

13

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

115/501

,

139) -

, , , . - , ( ). , . . ,(140)

, ,(141)

(139) Narodnoe Khozyaistvo , No 3, 1918, . 7-12,

, ,

. . . The Life o f a Chem ist

( , 1946), . 237, , , .

(140) . . , Istoriya Ekonomicheskogo Razvitiya SSSR (2 ., 1929), .

137. , 3

1918 ,

(" , XXII,210).(141) Trudy I Vserossiiskogo Sezda Sovetov Narodnogo Khozyaistva (1918), .

92 Za P yat Let (1922), a. 238. stikhiinyi 1,

1, . 33.

114

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

116/501

. .

, , . .(142) , , , ^143) . .(144) .(14S)

, 3 1918, , . , , - . , .(146)

.

(142) Sobranie Uzakonenii, 1917-1918, No 4,

69, No 6, 95, No 13, 190, 191, 192. . . ,Istoriya Ekonomicheskogo Razvitiya SSSR (2 , 1929), . 115, 70% - .

(143) Sobranie Uzakonenii, 1917-1918, No 9, 140.(141) Sbornik Dekretov po Narodnomu Khozyaistvu (1918), . 270-1.(145) Sobranie Uzakonenii, 1917-1918, No 9, 130.

(146) . ., No 27, 350, 351, 354-60, -

1918.

115

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

117/501

.

, , .(147) . , , , .(148) .(149) 1917-18,

. ,

(147) ,

, (Sobranie Uzakonenii 1917-1918, No 1[2 .), 9). .

(148) Trudy I Vserossiiskogo S ezda Sovetov N arodnogo Khozyaistva (1918), o. 97.

(149) . . IstoriyuEkonomicheskogo Razvitiya SSSR (2 ., 1929), . 113, 521

1 1918, 50%

, 25% 20% . ,

, , - . - .

:

(Trudy I Vserossiiskogo S ezda Sove tov N arodnogo K hozyaistva [1918], .

92).

16

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

118/501

, .(5).

. , 1918,(150151) 1918 ^152) , . , - - . '

- .

(150) Trudy I Vserossiiskogo S"ezda Sovetov Narodnogo Khozyaistva (1918), a. 92.


(152) . ., No 34, 45 7 No 45, 546.

. 7 1918 (. ., No 29, 385).

. -

( , ). . ,

( ) ( ).

, 1918,

: (Trudy 1 Vserossiiskogo S ezda Sove tov Narodnogo Khozyaistva

[1918], a. 93).

117

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

119/501

- .

. . 7 8 1918. , 4 , . :

-

, ,

:

,

,

,

, -

.(153)

- . 40%

(153) S'ezdy Sovetov RSFSR Postanovleniyakh (1939), . 69.

118

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

120/501

, 70% 90% .(154) . ,

. , , , , . . .

. , -, .(155) , - .

, .(156) , . - .(157)

(154) 1918(Trudy I Vserossiiskogo S ezda Sovetov Narodnogo Khozyaistva , a. 15).

Novykh Putyakh(1923), III, 161-3.

(155) 1918

(Narodnoe Khozyaistvo, No

11, 1918, . 14), 1918 (Byulleleni Vysshego Soveta Narodnogo Khozyais tva, No 1,

1918, . 34-41).

(156) Narodnoe Khozyaistvo,

1918, -

, .

( 1918) , .(157) . ,

119

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

121/501

. , & ,

, 1917 ^158) . . .

3 1918 - .

- . ( ) - , . -

, . , . -

, , The

Bolshevik Revolu tion, 1917-1918, . 624.

(158) 1, 5.

120

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

122/501

.

.('59) 19 1918 - , - :

,

, ,

, , .

. ,

.

,

. ,

-

,

, -

, -

.

-*15

(159) Sbornik Dekretov i Postimovlenii po NaroJiwmu Khozyaistvu (1918), . 311-

15.

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

123/501

. .

, : , , .(|60) , , 1918, . . . ,

.

- . ' - , , . - - , -

! Istoriya Ekonomiche-

skogo Razvitiva SSSR (2 ., 1929), . 130-41. Byulleteni Vysshego Soveta Narodnoga Khozyaistva, No 1, 1918, .23-34. . .

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

124/501

. 1918

, , . .(161) , , - , 200 , 200 - 100 . .(162)

, , .

, - , . 4 1918 , 15 .(163) ,

, , . 28 1918, -

(161) Narodnoe Khozyuistvo, No 11, 1918, . 22,

.(162) . , Syndikaty i Tresty Rosii (3 ., 1920), . 161-2.

(163) 1, 8 ,

" , XXII, 561-71.

123

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

125/501

, - .(164) VTsIK -

. 3 , VTsIK 7 - .(165) , - , .

. , , , . .

. , 1917 , . - .

. - . -

(164) . ., XXII, 439-68. ,

,

. ., XXII, 412-25.

, , . ., XXII, 620, 177. , No 1, 20 1918, . 13,

.

(165) Protokoly Zusedanii VTsIK 4go Sozyva (1920), . 206-38. ( ) " , XXII, 471-98, .., XXII, 499-501.

124

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

126/501

-. - ,

,

, . - :

,

-

, ,

.

-

.

^166)

. 1918,

, .(167)

(166) , " , XXII, 523.

(167)

.

, . , ,

125

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

127/501

.

.( 6 ) '

.

.

1917 ,

,

-

,

.

, ,

'

.

,

, ,

,

,

.

.(|69)

,

,

. **

. (Trudy I Vserossii-skof>o 5 czdu Sovetov Narodnono Khozyaistva [1918], o. 72, 112).

( ) . No 2, 27 1918,

. 17, 4 , 200-

250 .

(168) . . Syiulikuty i Trusty Rossii (3 ., 1920), . 165.

(169) , " . XXI, 391, 416.

126

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

128/501

, .(|70) -

, .(170171) . , ,

. -, , - . , , .

.

VTsIK - :

: ,

.

,

, :

; ,

, ; ' -

(170) . , , (Pervyi Vserossiiskii S" ezd Professionalnykh Soyuzov [1918] . 2).

(171) , , ( ) (. . , Ocherk Kliozyaistvennoi Zhizni i Organiza-tziya Nurodnogo Khozyaistvu Sovetskoi Rossii [1920] o. 122).

127

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

129/501

. -

, .

-

, ;

;(172173)

- , . . :

,

, ,

.(73)

, ,

.

, , . . - , :

, !

- .

,

,

, ,

,

.

(172) , " , XXII, 481.

(173) . ., XXII, 514.

128

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

130/501

" .

,(174175)

-

, .

. , . : 1918 , , . , . .

, -, -, - , , - ,(17)

(174) . ., XXII, 378.

- , , -

: . " (Trudy I Vserossiiskogo

S ezda Sovetov Narodnogo Khozyaistva [1918], . 157). , .

(175) . ., XXII, 516-17.

, , ( . .,XXVI, 326).

129

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

131/501

. -. 7

(25 ) 1917 () 1918. . , ( ) . , . , - , - , , .(176177)

, . - . " ' , 1918, , ... , , , , .(,77) :

(176) .,., XXII, 493.

' . ' .

(177) . /. XXII, 489. ,

- , (... XXII. 527-8).

130

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

132/501

. ,

. -

. . -

,

.

,

. ,

,

.(,78)

. : .

, , , .(,79) .

1918 - , . , . .

, 178179

(178) , " , XXII, 487.

(179) . ., XXII, 494.

131

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

133/501

. . -

. - - , . , , , , . - , , , - . . , . -

. ' , , - (), - . (18) -

(180181) .

- 26 1918. .' 100 ,

(180) .., XXIII, 22. . ., XXIII,

538-9, 4 . , Intervention, Civil War and Com munism inRussia ( , 1936), . 379-81.


132

7/25/2019 - 1917-1923 ( 2)

134/501

, . ' 150 .(82) ,

.(182183) - . , , , . .

. , 1890 ( ) , - :

, -

.

,

.(184*)

. , , . ,

(182) Trudy / Vserossjiskogo S ezda Sove tov Narodnogo K hozyuistva (1918), .

VI-X, 82,

.

(183)

.

.(184) Trudy 1 Vserossiiskogo S " ezda Sovetov Narodnogo Khozyaistva, (191

ΚΑΡΡ- ΙΣΤΟΡΙΑ ΤΗΣ ΣΟΒΙΕΤΙΚΗΣ ΕΝΩΣΗΣ 1917-1923 (ΤΟΜΟΣ 2)

Documents

Transcript of ΚΑΡΡ- ΙΣΤΟΡΙΑ ΤΗΣ ΣΟΒΙΕΤΙΚΗΣ ΕΝΩΣΗΣ 1917-1923 (ΤΟΜΟΣ 2)